North York Moors National Park Authority Planning Committee

Transcription

1 North York Moors National Park Authority Planning Committee Item 4 26 April 2012 Miscellaneous Items (a) Appeals (i) Appeals received: Ref Number ENF 253/2008 NYM/2011/0642/FL Appellants Name and Location Mr Simon McCabe Red House, High Street, Staithes Mr P A Hare Flockton House, Egton Description Without planning permission, operational development comprising the installation of a top-opening mock Victorian sash window to the left of the front door on the ground floor. Replacement of timber windows with replacement white upvc windows. (b) Planning Applications Determined by the Director of Planning A list of planning applications determined by the Director of Planning in accordance with the Scheme of Delegation is attached at Appendix 1. [NB: Members wishing to enquire further into particular applications referred to in the Appendix are asked to raise the matter with the Director of Planning in advance of the meeting to enable a detailed response to be given]. (c) List of Enforcement Matters Determined by the Director of Planning A list of enforcement matters determined by the Director of Planning in accordance with the Scheme of Delegation is attached at Appendix 2. (d) Numbers of Planning Applications Determined A graph is attached at Appendix 3 which indicates the number of applications determined within 8 weeks for the last 12 months [The individual files will be available for Members to inspect at the meeting]. Andy Wilson Chief Executive (National Park Officer) Chris France Director of Planning Miscellaneous Items/1

2 List of Planning Applications Determined by the Director of Planning for the Period from 08/03/2012 to 12/04/2012 in the Following Order and then by District: Delegated Planning Applications; Post Committee Applications; on Expiration of Advertisement; on Receipt of Amended Plans and Further Observations; Approval of Conditions; Applications Adjacent to the Park (3024); Notifications Under Schedule 2, Part 6/7, of The Town & Country Planning (General Permitted Development) Order 1995 NYM/2011/0285/FL Issued 30/03/12 change of use and alterations to domestic workshop to form bed and breakfast letting accommodation at 17 Oswaldene, Osmotherley for Mrs Anne Abbott NYM/2011/0504/CLE Approved 02/04/12 certificate of lawfulness for use of the building for purposes defined under B2 of the Use Class Order in excess of ten years at The Black Barn, Wild Goose Nest, High Paradise Farm, Boltby for Mrs Judith Skilbeck NYM/2012/0020/FL Approved 19/03/12 change of use of dwelling to guest house, construction of single storey and first floor extensions to rear following demolition of conservatory, covered access and installation of replacement timber windows to rear at 11 South End, Osmotherley for Mr M Cameron NYM/2012/0021/LB Approved 19/03/12 Listed Building consent for construction of single storey and first floor extensions to rear following demolition of conservatory, covered access, installation of replacement timber windows to rear and internal alterations at 11 South End, Osmotherley for Mr M Cameron NYM/2012/0029/FL Approved 14/03/12 construction of single storey extension, installation of replacement timber windows, part rendering of property and creation of parking area at School View, Carlton In Cleveland for Mrs Paula Ferguson NYM/2012/0054/FL Refused 20/03/12 erection of implement shed (submission following withdrawal of NYM/2011/0438/FL) at The Park, Battersby, Great Ayton for Mr Ian Jones NYM/2012/0060/FL Approved 28/03/12 proposed 16 no. ground mounted solar panels at Fairville, Heathwaite, Swainby for Mr R G Swainson

3 NYM/2012/0062/FL Approved 22/03/12 installation of replacement timber windows and doors together with replacement roof tiles at 46 North End, Osmotherley for Mr David Woodhead NYM/2012/0063/LB Approved 23/03/12 Listed Building consent for installation of replacement timber windows and doors together with replacement roof tiles at 46 North End, Osmotherley for Mr David Woodhead NYM/2012/0075/FL Approved 10/04/12 erection of an agricultural livestock building at Hill Top Farm, Thimbleby for Mr K Pearson NYM/2012/0141/NM Approved 12/04/12 non material minor amendment to planning approval NYM/2011/0559/FL to allow alterations to the layout of the first floor and alterations to rooflights at The Coachmans Cottage, Busby Hall, Carlton in Cleveland for Mr David Marwood NYM/2011/0631/ETL Approved 27/03/12 extension to time limit of extant planning permission NYM/2008/0617/FL for conversion of agricultural buildings to form 2 no. dwellings and residential annexe together with demolition of 2 no. farm buildings at Hallgarth Farm, Westgate, Thornton le Dale for Mr M & Miss M Potter NYM/2011/0657/FL Refused 20/03/12 installation of upvc replacement windows, installation of 5 no. rooflights, erection of stable, rebuilding of pavilion, erection of building to house sauna/steam room including solar panels, installation of stone pillars and entrance gates, creation of a track to south side of site, erection of a portacabin, use of land for camping and caravanning and siting of a marquee at Sutherland Lodge, Cropton for Mr Stephen Vella NYM/2011/0666/LB Approved 02/04/12 Listed Building consent for internal alterations to farmhouse and internal and external alterations to outbuildings to enable the conversion to 2 no. holiday letting cottages/local needs letting accommodation at Mill Farm, Low Mill, Farndale for The Farndale Estate NYM/2011/0773/FL Approved 03/04/12 change of use of agricultural land to form extension to domestic curtilage together with construction of replacement domestic games room building at St Mary's, Anserdale Lane, Lastingham for Mr & Mrs C Heinrich

4 NYM/2011/0857/FL Approved 14/03/12 conversion of and extension to existing buildings to create 1 no. open market dwelling following demolition of modern agricultural buildings (revised scheme to NYM/2010/0597/FL) at Scawling Farm, Main Street, Oldstead for Mr Richard Menage NYM/2011/0866/FL Approved 20/03/12 construction of single storey link between dwelling and outbuildings, link corridor to rear of dwelling and glazed entrance porch at Pennyholme, Fadmoor for Mr Peter Wilkinson NYM/2012/0031/FL Approved 12/03/12 construction of replacement single storey garden room extension above kitchen (revised scheme to NYM/2011/0528/FL) at Corner Cottage, Maltongate, Thornton Dale for Mr & Mrs Ward NYM/2012/0035/LB Approved 15/03/12 Listed Building consent for the restoration of section of village well to include coping stone replacement and repairs to railings at site between Ivy Cottage and The Forge, Lockton for Lockton Parish Council NYM/2012/0037/FL Approved 14/03/12 construction of single storey side extension at 19 Castle Garth, Thornton le Dale for Mrs Sarah Hill NYM/2012/0038/FL Refused 09/03/12 formation of vehicular access and parking area (revised scheme to NYM/2011/0157/FL) at Amadys, Church Lane, Thornton le Dale for Mrs M Bee-Williams NYM/2012/0042/FL Approved 14/03/12 replacement pitched roof to garage at Mayfield, Appleton le Moors, for Mr Peter Smith NYM/2012/0045/FL Approved 28/03/12 construction of a conservatory and porch to rear at Sheraton Cottage, Cold Kirby for Mr & Mrs Taylor NYM/2012/0057/LB Approved 11/04/12 Listed Building consent to retain the existing windows and fireplace, ground floor coverings and first floor internal subdivisions at Woodmans Cottage, Spaunton, Appleton le Moors for Mr George Winn-Darley NYM/2012/0066/NM Approved 26/03/12 non material minor amendment to planning approval NYM/2010/0251/FL to allow the re-positioning of approved dwelling at Dalby Beck, Low Dalby for Mr Jon Gascoyne

5 NYM/2012/0069/FL Approved 20/03/12 erection of extension to existing conservatory at 4 Hill Houses, Rosedale for Mr Brian Dowding NYM/2012/0078/AD Approved 20/03/12 advertisement consent for the display of 1 no. replacement wall mounted sign on side elevation at Rosedale Field Centre, Daleside Road, Rosedale Abbey for Mrs S Readhead NYM/2012/0079/FL Approved 29/03/12 construction of single storey garden room extension following removal of existing lean-to at Mill House, Farndale for Reverend P Francis NYM/2012/0089/FL Approved 28/03/12 variation of condition 2 of planning approval NYM/2010/0895/FL to allow the roof to the tractor shed to be corrugated sheeting instead of pantile at Manor Farmhouse, Appleton le Moors for Mr Malcolm Greener NYM/2012/0090/LB Approved 27/03/12 variation of condition 2 of Listed Building consent NYM/2010/0896/LB to allow the roof to the tractor shed to be corrugated sheeting instead of pantile at Manor Farmhouse, Appleton le Moors for Mr Malcolm Greener NYM/2012/0093/CU Approved 10/04/12 change of use with external alterations to holiday cottages to form ancillary domestic accommodation together with construction of first floor link to main dwelling at Sleightholmedale Lodge, Sleightholme for Mr Patrick James NYM/2011/0136/AD Approved 08/03/12 advertisement consent for the display of 3 no. blackboards and 1 no. menu board at The Royal George Pub, High Street, Staithes for Chelwood Business Finance Ltd NYM/2011/0266/CU Approved 02/04/12 change of use of part of premises to form micro brewery at The Captain Cook Inn, 60 Staithes Lane, Staithes for Mr Neil Readman NYM/2011/0367/LB Refused 30/03/12 Listed Building consent for painting of exterior walls light blue (Sandtex L7341K) at The Mariners, High Street, Staithes for Ms Miranda Winram NYM/2011/0629/LB Approved 05/04/12 Listed Building consent for extension to porch and internal/external alterations to house to form additional holiday letting unit at 51 Rosedale Lane, Port Mulgrave for Mr Gary Chadfield

6 NYM/2011/0665/FL Approved 05/04/12 subdivision of dwelling to form separate holiday letting unit together with extension to porch (increase in roof height) at 51 Rosedale Lane, Port Mulgrave for Mr Gary Chadfield NYM/2011/0670/FL Approved 12/04/12 conversion of hay barn to holiday cottage (revised scheme to NYM/2007/0893/FL) to include greater levels of rebuilding and raising height of building at Fern Farm, Dalehouse, Staithes for Mr & Mrs C Welford NYM/2011/0798/FL Approved 09/03/12 use of land for the siting of a static caravan for use by an agricultural worker at Dunboggs Farm, Guisborough Road, Whitby for Mr Philip Gaines NYM/2011/0838/FL Approved with Conditions 13/03/12 conversion of domestic storage area together with increase in roof height and external alterations to form additional living accommodation at 19A The Lane, Mickleby for Mr William G Trotter NYM/2012/0003/FL Approved 09/03/12 construction of replacement garage and car port at West Lea, 2 Echo Hill, Sleights for Mr Lee Atkinson NYM/2012/0009/FL Approved 09/03/12 construction of single storey extension, alterations to and installation of replacement windows and doors, insertion of 3 no, Conservation rooflights, re-roofing, re-pointing and re-building of chimney stack at 34/36 Castlegate, East Ayton for Mr Paul Chadwick NYM/2012/0010/LB Approved 09/03/12 Listed Building consent for internal and external alterations including construction of single storey extension, alterations to and installation of replacement windows and doors, insertion of 3 no, Conservation rooflights, re-roofing, re-pointing and re-building of chimney stack at 34/36 Castlegate, East Ayton for Mr Paul Chadwick NYM/2012/0015/FL Approved 20/03/12 erection of a summerhouse/domestic storage building at Orchard Cottage, Egton Bridge for Mrs Suzanne Ellison/Jones NYM/2012/0026/LB Approved 27/03/12 Listed Building consent for removal of wooden shutters and all brackets and fixings together with re-pointing of external walls at Woodleigh House, 21 Main Road, Aislaby for AJ and RI Little NYM/2012/0027/LB Approved 28/03/12 Listed Building consent for the display of 3 no. blackboards and 1 no. menu board at The Royal George, High Street, Staithes for Chelwood Business Finance Ltd

7 NYM/2012/0039/FL Approved 09/03/12 variation of condition 1 of planning approval NYM/2011/0443/FL to extend the permitted time limit by three months at land adjacent to Jugger Howe Moor, near Harwood Dale for Mr Richard Hunt, York Potash Ltd NYM/2012/0040/FL Approved 13/03/12 variation of condition 1 of planning approval NYM/2011/0339/FL to extend the permitted time limit by three months at land adjacent Raikes Lane, Sneaton Thorpe for Mr Richard Hunt, York Potash Ltd NYM/2012/0046/FL Approved 28/03/12 construction of two storey extension including basement level together with construction of subterranean garage and associated landscaping works following the demolition of existing garage and extensions at Keepers Cottage, Moor Road, Aislaby for Mr Paul Hogarth NYM/2012/0050/FL Approved 19/03/12 variation of condition 2 (material minor amendment) to planning approval NYM/2010/0906/CU to allow alterations to profile of south side of shed roof at Low Farm, 17 Low Farm, Mickleby for Mr Stephen Hunneysett NYM/2012/0059/FL Approved 22/03/12 construction of a double garage attached to dwelling and creation of vehicular access at 5 Mill View, Hawsker for Mr & Mrs Wain NYM/2012/0065/FL Approved 27/03/12 siting of a gas tank at Overdale, Egton for Mr Raymond Ward NYM/2012/0067/FL Approved 27/03/12 construction of first floor extension at Fyling Garth, Fylingdales for Mr James Hallett NYM/2012/0070/FL Approved 14/03/12 variation of condition 2 (material minor amendment) of planning approval NYM/2011/0558/FL to allow the replacement of rooflight with dormer window to rear elevation at Lowcroft, 2 Church Lane, Fylingthorpe for Mr William Taylor & Mrs Julie Galliard NYM/2012/0071/FL Approved 27/03/12 installation of solar panels to south facing roofslope at New Botton Farmhouse, Botton Village for The Camphill Village Trust NYM/2012/0072/FL Approved 20/03/12 construction of single storey rear extension following removal of porch to allow for a wet room to be created for disabled person(s) at West Winds, Keasbeck, Harwood Dale for Mrs J Myhill

8 NYM/2012/0073/FL Approved 30/03/12 construction of replacement bay window classroom extension at Lealholm Primary School, Lealholm for Mrs H Ward NYM/2012/0074/FL Approved 23/03/12 insertion of 2 no. rooflights to farm office and 2 no. windows to the rear elevation together with construction of porch to front elevation at Ellers Farm, Great Fryup Dale for R J & Mrs S E Welford NYM/2012/0080/FL Approved 11/04/12 erection of a general purpose agricultural building at Brown Hill Farm, Westerdale for Mr Jonathan Murray NYM/2012/0092/FL Approved 12/04/12 construction of pitched roof to existing extension at 11 Kingston Garth, Fylingthorpe for Mr Mark Winspear NYM/2012/0098/NM Approved 14/03/12 non material minor amendment to planning approval NYM/2009/0025/FL to allow external alterations to approved garage at 3 Galley Hill Slack, Aislaby for Mr Paul Sedman NYM/2012/0103/FL Approved 30/03/12 insertion of 3 no. rooflights at Egton C of E Primary School, Egton for Egton C of E Primary School NYM/2012/0104/FL Approved 11/04/12 construction of dormer window and pitched roof over front entrance area, insertion of rooflights and solar panels together with construction of a garden store at Field House, Dunsley for Mr G Sargeant NYM/2012/0107/FL Refused 19/03/12 erection of 4 no. feed bins at Grange Farm, Staintondale for JE & MP Else NYM/2012/0110/NM Approved 16/03/12 non material minor amendment to planning approval NYM/2008/0193/FL to allow a reduction in the number of rooflights, alteration to window position to gable end and retention of 5 no. existing window positions at Darnholme Farm, Darnholme, Goathland for J W & H M Graham NYM/2012/0111/FL Refused 19/03/12 erection of a covered area for livestock at Grange Farm, Staintondale for J E & M P Else NYM/2012/0115/NM Approved 19/03/12 non material minor amendment to planning approval NYM/2011/0809/FL to allow a reduction in size of the approved garage and cart barn at Key Green Farmhouse, Egton Grange for Mr & Mrs Timothy Boskett

9 Notifications NYM/2012/0036/AGRP Approved 13/03/12 erection of extension to agricultural livestock building at Woodhall Farm, Ugthorpe for D J & D Schofield & Son NYM/2012/0061/AGRP Approved 20/03/12 proposed upgrading of forest track at Moor Lane, Cropton for Forestry Commission NYM/2012/0087/AGRP Approved 02/04/12 erection of replacement hay/implement shed at Hollin House Farm, Goathland for Mr John Summerson Applications Determined by the Director of Planning on Expiry of Advertisement, Receipt of Further Amended Plans and Observations NYM/2011/0815/FL Change of use of and extension to workshop to form a local occupancy dwelling at Paddock Workshop, Hawsker Lane, Low Laithes, Whitby Amended plans have been received and the application approved with an amendment to condition 2 as follows: 2. AP01 Original plans amended by plans received on 30 March 2012 NYM/2012/0083/FL Construction of single and two storey extensions, creation of a side balcony, remodelling of garden and construction of new retaining walls together with replacement of bow window to east gable with folding doors (resubmission following withdrawal of NYM/2011/0774/FL) at House On The Wall, Runswick Bay The application has been refused by Members, contrary to Officer recommendation, for the following reason: The proposed extensions are considered to detract from the character of Runswick Bay Conservation Area owing to the use of unpainted timber and zinc which is considered to have a detrimental impact on the character of this coastal village location and therefore the proposal is contrary to the requirements of NYM Development Policy 4.

10 Applications Adjacent to the National Park (3024) 11/01128/FUL Erection of a 39m high (overall tip height of 54.5m) 225Kw wind turbine for commercial electricity generation to the National Grid at Pheasant Hill Farm, Hagg Side Lane, Ebberston, Scarborough The Authority has considered the details of the proposed application and objected for the following reason: The National Park s Ecologist has assessed the revised information has advised that the report does not allay concerns that important bird species nesting in the National Park notably Nightjar but also Turtle Dove, might be detrimentally affected by the proposed turbine. R/2012/0005/FF Installation of 1 wind turbine (max.height 67m) with access track at Ridge Farm, Stranghow Ridge, Stranghow The Authority has considered the details of the proposed application and raised strong objections for the following reason: The proposal would cause significant harm to the landscape setting of the National Park and seriously erode the public enjoyment of the special qualities of the North York Moors. Background Documents to this report File Ref: 1. Signed reports dates as given 3022/1 2. Signed letter dates as given 3024/1 Location North York Moors National Park The Old Vicarage, Bondgate, Helmsley, York, Y062 5BP

11 List of Enforcement Matters Determined by the Director of Planning For The Period March 2012 File No. Development & Address Decision Taken 119/2007 Royal George, High Street, Staithes Unauthorised lighting to entrance. Not expedient to pursue

12