PLANNING APPLICATIONS COMMENTED ON DURING COUNCIL YEAR

Transcription

1 PLANNING APPLICATIONS COMMENTED ON DURING COUNCIL YEAR Week ending Application number th April 11/01666/HOU Holme Dene 7 Greystones Ben Rhydding LS29 8RJ nd April 11/01696/CLP nd April 11/01699/ADV nd April 06/02519/NMA02 Major Development Address Details Recommendation Area Panel Construction of raised decking and fence 6 Bolton Bridge Road Ilkley West Yorkshire LS29 9AA Mrs Elizabeth Richardson 4 Bolton Bridge Road Ilkley West Yorkshire LS29 9AA Mr Paul Kettlewell Clevedon House Ben Rhydding Drive Ilkley Audley Clevedon Single storey extension to rear External signage to shop front Non-Material Amendment to planning approval 06/02519/FUL (Redevelopment of former school as an assisted living community for Scale: too large, too high. Comment Have neighbours at 4 & 6 Clifton Road, who would be overlooked, been consulted? No comments Conservation Area, too large, unnecessary. Comment Would approve if sign 5 was removed from application. This should be a full application because it is on 1

2 Team nd April 11/01556/FUL th April 11/01552/FUL Richrd Cryer th April 11/01070/FUL District Tea m Amin Ibrar th April 11/01393/LBC Limited 51 Curly Hill Ilkley West Yorkshire LS29 0AY Mrs Vera Adams 66 Bolling Road Ilkley West Yorkshire LS29 8QD Mr Andrew Smallwood Arc Car Wash Riverside Business Park Dansk Way Ilkley LS29 8JZ Backstone Ltd Ilkley Railway Station Station Road Ilkley approximately 150 people, including new residential blocks, communal facilities, parking and landscaping) to carry out minor changes on Block 4 to the roof, elevation and fenestration and add a timber framed balcony structure Renewal of permission 08/01285/FUL dated 30/07/2008: Construction of two new dwellings in the grounds plus replacement garage with en-suite above for the existing house and modifications to the existing house, access improvements and landscaping Demolition of existing property and construction of 2 no new semidetached houses Construction of Class B1 Business Units Installation of stationwide CCTV, new station signage schedule and Green Belt land and because of the special circumstances under which the application was approved. subject to dark colour to roof. Comment - Given orientation of building to neighbouring residential properties, restricting hours of business should be considered. 2

3 Richard Cryer LS29 8HF Mr Alan Tisdell Head Of Estate Management Northern Rail new air handling louvre unit on platform 1 SIGNS are inappropriate (e.g. Ilkley is a terminal so no passing trains) and inaccurate (e.g. station car park is on Station Road not Railway Road). and Panel should make a site visit th April 11/00740/HOU th April 11/01070/FUL District Tea m Amin Ibrar th April 11/01393/LBC Richard Cryer Dalehurst 2 Middleton Avenue Ilkley LS29 0AD Mr R Hearne Arc Car Wash Riverside Business Park Dansk Way Ilkley LS29 8JZ Backstone Ltd Ilkley Railway Station Station Road Ilkley LS29 8HF Mr Alan Tisdell Head Of Estate Management Northern Rail th April 11/01481/HOU 17 Lister Street Ilkley Single storey extension to rear Construction of Class B1 Business Units Installation of stationwide CCTV, new station signage schedule and new air handling louvre unit on platform 1 Rear flat roof dormer to existing Comment guidance needed on CCTV in planning process. DEFER More information required on roofing materials. DEFER Unable to access sufficient information on line (CCTV & signage) in order to comment. There should be a justification for CCTV. 3

4 219 8 th April 11/01536/HOU th April 11/01538/ADV Amin Ibrar th April 11/01560/HOU LS29 9ET Mr Russell Mason 1 Good Wood Ilkley LS29 0BY Mr Andrew Broughton 21 Leeds Road Ilkley LS29 8DP Mr Stuart Goddard 6 Woodroyd Gardens Ilkley LS29 8BU Mr R Tomlinson th April 11/01275/HOU 3 South Parade Ilkley LS29 9AW st April 11/01416/CLP 11/13 Bridge Lane Ilkley LS29 9HL attic bedroom and internal alterations to form en suites Placing of 20 photovoltaic panels on a solar mounting system onto existing upper flat roof Single strip fixed light to existing fascia sign Three storey extension to side of the existing dwelling including extension of existing dormer roofs and alterations to main entrance steps Conversion of garage with extension under the existing roof line Single storey extensions to the rear of both properties Out of keeping with Good Wood. Could set a precedent and panels on lower level would spoil the appearance for those on higher level. Noted that height not on application. Would like clarification on Bradford s policy. Unable to comment because of insufficient information on appearance leave to officers. No comment 4

5 214 1 st April 11/01482/HOU th Mar 11/01276/HOU th Mar 11/01315/VOC Richard Cryer th Mar 11/01317/HOU th Mar 11/01338/CLP th Mar 11/01339/FUL Richard Cryer th Mar 11/01340/LBC Richard Cryer llson (Builders And Contractors) Ltd 1 Margerison Road Ilkley LS29 8QY Mrs Rachel Doherty 9 Princess Road Ilkley LS29 9NP Mr David Farrant 118 Skipton Road Ilkley LS29 9HE Mrs Poonam Cant 3 Chestnut Close Ilkley LS29 8PX Mr John Hein 11 Kings Road Ilkley LS29 9AE Mr IAN McINTOSH The Crescent Hotel Brook Street Ilkley LS29 8DG Mr Graeme Walker The Crescent Hotel Brook Street Ilkley LS29 8DG Mr Graeme Walker Single storey extension to rear Construction of single storey rear extension Variation of condition 2 of planning approval 03/03483/COU (Change of lower ground floor area to childminding facility): to allow for increase of number of children and childminders Garden Decking Roof lights Raising of eaves by 700mm to the three storey adjoining building to accommodate a new apartment dwelling Raising of eaves by 700mm to the three storey adjoining building to accommodate a new apartment dwelling Subject to the variation becoming the maximum number of children. Overbearing. Suggest constructing at a lower level with steps leading down No comments 5

6 th Mar 10/05917/FUL Richard Cryer th Mar 11/01092/HOU th Mar 11/01128/HOU th Mar 11/01214/FUL th Mar 11/01215/OUT Richard Cryer th Mar 11/01221/HOU All Saints' CE Primary School Easby Drive Ilkley LS29 9BE Mrs Helen Pilling 99 Wheatley Lane Ilkley LS29 8PP Mr Edward Preston 2 Chantry Close Ilkley LS29 9JA Mr Mark Freeman Sacred Heart Catholic Primary School Valley Drive Ilkley LS29 8NL Sacred Heart Catholic Primary School 26 Ben Rhydding Road Ilkley LS29 8RL Mr Roger Webb 9 Yew Croft Kings Road Ilkley LS29 9AF Mr Timothy Holmes th Feb 10/06242/FUL 102 Skipton Road Ilkley LS29 9HE Construction of fence (3m high x 36m long) between the school boundary and Westville Road External alterations Single storey extension with pitched tile roof to side and rear of existing property Increase the height of part of the fence to the school playground from 1.8m to 2.4m Construction of detached dwelling in rear garden Single storey rear extension Conversion of basement to form an independent flat including new doors to principal elevation, new sunken patio and reorganisation of car parking to front of the property (revised description-amended plans received) APPROVED Suggest planting on Skipton Rd side to soften appearance. APPROVED Suggest considering moving roof lights to opposite pitch. SUPSENSION of Recommendation Following receipt of additional information, this application was revisited and IPC would like to 6

7 th March 11/01077/HOU 56 King s Road Ilkley LS29 9AT Mrs Linda McNamara th 11/01087/HOU 58 Wheatley Lane Orangery type conservatory Dormer extension. suspend its earlier recommendation of approval pending reassurances and clarification on the following points: The basement would appear to be a void rather than an actual basement. Digging out will significantly alter the character of the front of the building which is in a Conservation Area. The plans do not show the relationship of the proposed development to the garden flat. If the application is approved, could a time limit be applied to the work because of the detrimental effect of the work on the residents in the garden flat. 7

8 March th March 11/01225/HOU Ilkley LS29 8PW Mrs Lesley Johnson 8 Clifford Avenue Ilkley LS29 0AS Mrs LYNNE LAWSON Two storey side and single storey rear extension Subject to meeting the distance requirements for habitable rooms in relation to no th March th March th March 11/00225/FUL Richard Cryer 11/00775/CLP 11/01035/HOU th March 11/00982/HOU th March 11/01014/CLP th March 11/00773/HOU Amin Ibrar th March 11/00967/HOU Unit 5 Ashlands Road Ilkley LS29 8JT Mr Jason Smith 25 Richmond Place Ilkley LS29 8TJ Mr Nick Haywood Solway 83 Curly Hill Ilkley LS29 0BA Mr Scott Addy 4 Strathmore Road Ilkley LS29 8PQ Mr Warren Lloyd 10 Woodlands Ilkley LS29 8LE Mr Darren Bruce Piccolino s Brook Street Ilkley 3 Lodge Cottages Langbar Road Ilkley Additional use of premises for private hire operator/business. Extensions and alterations to lower ground floor. Retrospective application for roof conservatory. Two storey side and single storey rear extension Construction of single storey rear extension Installation of concertino windows to the front elevation Proposal to build a detached stone built outbuilding with pitched slate No comment Subject to ensuring free movement of traffic during construction. No comment No comment 8

9 LS29 0ED Mrs Joanne Sugden roof, for owners cars and garden furniture th Feb paper 11/00760/FUL Amin Ibrar 56 Ben Rhydding Road Ilkley LS29 8RN Mr Gary Myers Demolish detached garage and construct a new double garage with home office above in new position to serve the existing property and construct new 5 bedroom detached house within grounds of existing property Acknowledged that some of the issues had been resolved but still overdevelopment of the site, out of character with the area, incongruous in street scene, tandem driveways best avoided, existing property has already been extended considerably th Feb paper 11/00797/HOU 9 Lister Street Ilkley LS29 9ET Miss Sharon McAuley Rear door to lower ground elevation with access walkway and stairs to ground floor rear elevation and solar panels to front and rear roof Overall design is still inappropriate, relates poorly to the rest of the property, inappropriate scale, overlooking neighbour s garden. Noted no information on solar panels. 9

10 th Feb 11/00837/HOU Heather Flack 6 Parish Ghyll Drive Ilkley LS29 9ND Mr Duncan Halloways Construction of balcony and replacement and alteration of existing steps th Feb 11/00850/CLP Heather Flack th Feb 11/00874/HOU Mr Steve Horne th Feb 10/06242/FUL Gary Rushworth th Feb 11/00574/HOU th Feb 11/00646/REM th Feb 10/00139/NMA01 66 Skipton Road Ilkley LS29 9HA Mr & Mrs Gordon Mee 60 Leeds Road Ilkley LS29 8EQ 102 Skipton Road Ilkley LS29 9HE 17 Queen s Drive Ilkley LS29 9QW Mr Chris Hunt 248 Leeds Road Ilkley LS29 8LW Mr Melvin Lilley The Crescent Hotel Brook Street Ilkley LS29 8DG Mr Graeme Walker Rear dormer Dropped kerb and crossing of grass verge to an existing driveway Conversion of basement to form an independent flat including new doors to principal elevation, new sunken patio and reorganisation of car parking to front of the property (revised description-amended plans received) Construction of single storey garden room extension to rear of dwelling house Submission of additional information to approved application 10/02908/OUT Reserved matters for outline permission 10/02908/OUT including details of access and parking, details of scale, appearance & layout of a 2 storey semi-detached dwelling. Provision of landscaping including boundary treatment. Non Material amendment to approval 10/00139/FUL dated 21/04/2010: Conversion of second and third floors to 10 residential apartments, change of use of No comments Comments as previous the wall and the entrance have already been changed and without permission. This is a material amendment and should therefore have had a 10

11 th Feb 11/00700/HOU 2 St James Road Ilkley LS29 9PY Mr David Bullock ground floor function room to retail unit and internal alterations to include 'The following internal changes to the retail unit and apartment above; new access door positions to retail unit, new windows to main entrance of retail unit, existing window openings enlarged in retail unit (north elevation), eaves and roof heights raised on north elevation, new access door position to roof garden. See plans 537 PL 007B and B Proposed flat roof rear dormer and replacement porch to rear separate application. This is a significant change to what is a Listed building in the town centre and in the Conservation Area. IPC would like to know if the Conservation team has had the opportunity to comment. Should be a pitched roof because it is visible from The Grove TH Feb 10/05169/NMA01 12 Bolton Bridge Road Ilkley LS29 9AA Candelisa Thorpe Park LLP Non material amendment to upgrade the existing corrugated asbestos sheet covering to the retail section of the building to meet current building regulation thermal requirements. This is a material amendment and should therefore have had a separate application. Lack of information on roofing material so unable to comment TH Feb 11/00135/HOU 17 Victoria Avenue Ilkley LS29 9BW Mr Gill Robinson Conversion of triple garage to granny flat It was noted that Conservation Officer s report had been scanned erroneously under 11

12 178 11/00165/HOU TH Feb 11/00320/HOU TH Feb 11/00471/FUL TH Feb 11/00472/HOU 2 Beechwood Grove Ilkley LS29 9AX Mr Richard Siddons 34 Nelson Road Ilkley LS29 8HN Mr Neil Spencer 1 Hawksworth Street Ilkley Mrs Alexa Makaafi 30 Beverley Rise Ilkley LS29 9DB Mrs Marilyn Peckett Environmental Health. Construction of timber conservatory Single storey rear extension with dormer to replace existing and front porch Change of use from offices (B1) to combined designer dress retail agency with beauty therapy service Two storey porch extension, two storey rear extension and raising of existing roof in order to create loft conversion, and front boundary wall and gates Out of character. Noted that the development appears to encroach onto shared access unsure of legality. Overdevelopment of the site; the front wall, railings and gates are obtrusive and out of character in the street scene; the rear chimney is overbearing; the rear extension is overbearing; low velox windows would lead to loss of privacy for neighbouring properties. It was noted that the site plan is 12

13 inaccurate in relation to neighbouring properties TH Feb 11/00500/OUT Richard Cryer Dove Corner And Gateacre Mews Hollingwood Gate Ilkley LS29 9PP Mr Peter Heaton And Mr A R Hey Demolition of 2no existing houses and construction of 3 new houses and garages Overdevelopment of site; scale overbearing; houses one and two are too close together; all three houses proposed are too close to neighbouring properties th Feb 11/00529/FUL th Feb 11/00536/HOU th Feb 11/00566/HOU 66 Bolling Road Ilkley LS29 8QD Mr A Smallwood 57 Ben Rhydding Road Ilkley LS29 8RN Mr And Mrs Houghton Owlwood Owler Park Road Ilkley LS29 0BG Mr D Mitchell Demolition of existing property and construction of 2 No new semidetached dwellings Single storey extension To resurface and slightly increase the width of the drive leading up to Owlwood Overdevelopment of site; out of place in street scene. IPC would like to know why planning application was felt to be necessary in this case. Could it not have been dealt with by the Enforcement team? th Feb 11/00275/LBC Ilkley Railway Station Station Road Ilkley LS29 8HF Construction of a new ticket office, staff room, staff wc, waiting room and shelter facility on platform 1 of Ilkley station. Enhancement of the Subject to: Public toilet on 13

14 existing projecting entrance canopy platform 1 (more important than open waiting area); retention of quarter mile sign; entrance through the arcade should not be closed. Note inaccurate location of current ticket office on site plan th Feb 11/0368/HOU 15 Rombald Grange Crossbeck Road Ilkley LS29 9JL th Feb 11/00134/HOU th Feb 11/00372/ADV Paul Verity th Feb 11/00520/HOU 25 Ben Rhydding Drive Ilkley LS29 8AY Mr A King Ilkley Middle School Valley Drive Ilkley LS29 8PA Ms Linda Howes 6 Kingsway Drive Ilkley LS29 9AG Mrs Claire Simms Construction of conservatory to rear Demolition of existing garage and construction of new garage with matching materials to existing dwelling Two freestanding temporary signs and two flagpoles.construction of single storey side extension Scale is much too large; would distract drivers at what is a Bad junction; could be misleading lead people to think land is to be built on. Overdevelopment ; over dominant. 14

15 th Jan 11/00114/FUL The Old Lodge Ashlands Road Ilkley LS29 8JT th Jan 11/00238/HOU th Jan 11/00310/HOU th Jan 11/00364/HOU th Jan 11/00374/ADV Amin Ibrar Hebden Queens Drive Ilkley LS29 9QW Mr H Kordowicz 17 Beverley Rise Ilkley LS29 9DB Mike Henderson 115 Bolling Road Ilkley LS29 8PN Mr Damian Kearns Land Former Site Of Ilkley Middle School Valley Drive Ilkley Ms Linda Howes th Jan 11/00130/ADV King s Hall and Winter Gardens Station Road Ilkley LS29 8HA th Jan 11/00221/HOU 3 Victoria Close Ilkley LS29 9BD Mr Andrew Lambert Change of use from highway land to garden land Construction of single storey orangery to the south elevation First floor side extension above garage to form new bedroom Internal alterations /room reconfiguration to basement to provide TV room, utility and garage. Removal of existing glass conservatory and re-plan of kitchen to ground floor with new fenestration in a style more consistent with the vernacular of the property/area 1 x freestanding temporary sales sign Installation of two additional show cases to match existing and the replacement of one existing wooden show case Neighbours should be consulted. Single storey rear extension th Jan 10/06158/CAC 6 Parish Ghyll Walk Demolition of existing bungalow 15

16 Ilkley LS29 9PZ and replacement with new dwelling th Jan 10/06242/HOU 102 Skipton Road Ilkley LS29 9HE Basement conversion including new doors to principle elevation with landscaping and reorganisation of car parking to front of property INSUFFICIENT INFORMATION no PO / TO comments, no documents on planning portal It would appear that work has already begun. Could planning officers check if front boundary wall has been moved? th Jan 11/00077/HOU 4 Undercliffe Rise Ilkley LS29 8RF Single storey extension to lower ground floor and ground floor th Jan 10/06073/HOU 3 Woodroyd Gardens Ilkley LS29 8BU Construction of single storey rear extension and new raised terrace and steps to rear garden Difficult to see the detail on the document with the grey background th Jan 10/06251/HOU 12 Mount Pleasant Ilkley LS29 8TW Ms Bev Maxwell Conversion of existing garage into habitable annexe and car port This is a separate dwelling; overdevelopment of the site, loss of parking; previous history; capacity of road; access issues (see letters of objection) th Jan 10/06062/HOU 66 Skipton Road Ilkley LS29 9HA Addition of two dormer windows, one to the side and one to the rear 16

17 of the property Harmful to character of the building; would unbalance the building; flat roof visible from the road because of the angle of the building in the plot TH Jan 10/06211/HOU 2 Ashburn Place Ilkley LS29 9NW Mr Mark Wogden Single storey extensions Reasons for refusal of previous application apply; agree with letter of objection st Dec 09/03175/NMA01 Major Development Team Fiona Tiplady Land Former Site Of Ilkley Middle School Valley Drive Ilkley Mr Steven Rigby Non material amendment to permission 09/03175/FUL dated : Construction of 56 specialised housing apartments for persons aged 60 and over (class C2) to provide care to people in need of care to include additional windows added to the kitchen and bathroom of flats 7,17 and 31, as shown on the west rear elevation drawing 2834(3)01 rev E - Block Elevations. Additional window added to the kitchen of flats 25,39 and 51, as shown on the north elevation courtyard of drawing 2834(3)01 rev E - Block Elevations. Sunpipes shown. Site layout amended to suit building setting NO COMMENT st Dec 10/06227/HOU 2 Ash Street Ilkley LS29 8ES Construction of fence on an existing stone wall to front and side 17

18 Mr Michael Dean st Dec 10/06043/LBC 4 Church Street Ilkley LS29 9DS th Dec paper 10/05764/HOU Flat 18 Deaconess Court Queen s Road Ilkley LS29 9QJ Mrs Susan Parker boundaries with replacement access gate Interior alteration to remove existing meeting rooms tea kitchen and replace with 3 toilets for ambulant disabled and wheelchair disability. To comply with regulations re public requirements for public meeting place. Problem of sight line suggest reduction in height to 1 metre back to gates in order to enable good sight lines for traffic. Disabled person s access th Dec 10/00604/ NMA01 15 Wheatley Avenue Ilkley LS29 8PT Mr&Mrs RL Meredith Non-material amendment to planning application 10/00604/HOU (Replacement double garage): new roof-light and changes to roof tiles But concerned about the way the applicant has been dealt with by BMDC. Would like to see copies of correspondence between planning officers and applicants posted onto the planning portal this 18

19 information would help IPC when it makes its recommendations to BMDC th Dec paper 10/05867/FUL District team th Dec 10/05864/HOU Land north of Westwood Lodge Wells Road Ilkley LS29 9JF Mrs Paula Hunt & Mr T John Edwards 1 Langbar Road Ilkley LS29 0AR Mr & Mrs Melvin th Dec 10/05849/FUL Land west of Heathmount Hall Crossbeck Road Ilkley Mr Peter Boreham th Dec 10/05969/CLP Brookfield Court 67A Bolling Road Ilkley Construction of a 4 bed detached dwelling house on plot 46 of the original master plan for the area Single storey side extension Construction of single 3 bedroom dwelling Construction of entrance walls with no further tree removal. Have trees already been removed? Access on to Crossbeck Road totally unacceptable/ gradient of road/tpos throughout site/effect on residents of Hall/agree with resident objector s comments. Need Tree Officer report. Hope walls reduced in height if proposed by BMDC 19

20 LS29 8QA Mr Mark O'Brien from previous app th Dec 10/05974/HOU 57 Ben Rhydding Road LS29 8RN Mr And Mrs Houghton Single storey extension Leave to PO s discretion rd Dec 07/03441/NMA01 Coach House Cottage 33 Parish Ghyll Road Ilkley LS29 9NG Mr Graham Non-Material Amendment to approval 07/03441/FUL (Reconstruction and extension of existing coach house to form detached dwelling) to: change the type of sash windows and panes Decision already agreed rd Dec 10/05721/ADV Alba Tyres Limited Little Lane Ilkley West Yorkshire LS29 8HZ Mrs Helen Moxon Display of two non-illuminated fascia signs and non-illuminated menu board displayed to the front of the car park Menu board too large for a residential area rd Dec 10/05769/FUL Westwood Lodge Wells Road Ilkley LS29 9JF Westwood Lodge Renewal of components of the existing structure, including replacement windows, rooflights and dormer windows rd Dec 10/05931/HOU Whinfell Hangingstone Road Ilkley LS29 8RS Mr Robin Litten Construction of side extension to form new attached double garage with garden store and various external alterations th Nov 10/05436/HOU 18 Mayfield Avenue Ilkley West Yorkshire LS29 8LF Mrs E Haestier Extension to form additional living space, utility and ground floor shower room with alterations to form off street parking th Nov 10/05673/CLP Heather Flack 3 Grove Avenue Ilkley West Yorkshire LS29 9PL Mr & Mrs Jones Velux window to rear presume Conservation Area light to be 20

21 used th Nov 10/05757/HOU th Nov 10/05322/FUL th Nov 10/05224/HOU th Nov 10/05687/HOU th Nov 10/05324/FUL 15 Kings Road Ilkley West Yorkshire LS29 9AE Mr Jonathan Barber The Corn Mill Railway Road Ilkley LS29 8JB 31 Wesville Road Ilkley LS29 9AQ 15 Owler Oark Road Ilkley LS29 0BG Ashlands Primary School Leeds Road Ilkley LS29 8JY Construction of first floor side extension Change of use of the first floor of the five storey building from B1 to D2 ( one to one Personal Training Studio) Dormer window extension to second floor and new entrance porch Replacement of veranda with glazed room Increase the extent of the external hard play surface area to the Foundation Stage of the school with some internal fencing and realigned footpath th Nov 10/04863/HOU 16 Strathmore Road Ilkley LS29 8PQ Mr Alec Grimshaw Demolition of existing garage, replace with new garage and base, drain roof in to existing drainage gulley and new gulley to existing house land drainage system, introduce electrics th Nov 10/05167/FUL Red Gables Nursing Home 59 Parish Ghyll Drive Ilkley LS29 9PR Queensland Care Limited Alterations to open up and extend the use of the basement Query loss of 17 parking spaces re application form th Nov 10/05375/FUL Land South Of 28 Queens Drive Lane Ilkley Construction of dwelling house with attached double garage including related external works Lane is unsuitable for 21

22 th Nov 10/05571/CLP Ross Hallam Mr Robert Bennett Stubham Lodge Clifford Road Ilkley LS29 0AX Mr Stephen Pearce th Nov 09/06173/SUB01 32 Clifton Road Ilkley LS29 8TU Yorparks Ltd th Nov 10/05550/HOU 9 Lister Street Ilkley LS29 9ET th Nov 10/05230/HOU The Barns Ben Rhydding Road Ilkley LS29 8BG Brian Kaufe th Nov Ben Rhydding Sports Construction of a dwelling within gardens of main house (Confirmation of commencement of works) Discharge of conditions 8,9 and 11 of planning approval 09/06173/FUL (Demolition of existing dwelling and garage and construction of 5 new dwellings with associated access, car parking, turning area and landscaping) Construction of rear balcony with stairs Erection of stone built barbecue / oven within adjoining stone walls and pergola and posts and stone seating within ornate garden New triple lane cricket practice area any additional traffic or construction traffic; designated as key open area in Conservation Area appraisal document; would set a precedent Would like Planning Officers to check that all work is being carried out according to permission granted Agree Tree Officer s recommendations Loss of privacy and security to neighbouring property 22

23 122 5 th Nov 10/04024/NMA01 Club Coutances Way Ilkley LS29 8AW BRSC Cricket Club Ben Rhydding Primary School Bolling Road Ilkley LS29 8QH Mr Rod Dick with synthetic surface, perimeter fence and internal nets to replace the existing one lane mobile metal framed net system structure in a new location adjacent to the pitch at the existing sports ground Alterations to planning approval 10/04024/REG dated 15/10/10 (Demolition of existing nursery and construction of a new nursery, external play areas and changing rooms to serve adjacent playing fields) : Re-site the building further to the west No comments th Nov 10/04983/HOU Ghyllstone Princess Road Ilkley LS29 9NP Mr J Craddock Extension to side to form garden room and incorporation of existing undercroft at rear to form playroom th Nov 10/05244/CLP 11 Hollingwood Rise Ilkley LS29 9PW Mr P Mawson Construction of rear dormer extension to enlarge bedroom No comments Server down - no plans to view th Nov 10/05370/HOU th Oct 10/03627/HOU th Oct 10/04434/HOU 22 Crossbeck Road Ilkley LS29 9JN Mr Lincoln Jowitt 5 North Parade Ilkley LS29 8JN Mr Adam Balderstone 6 Rupert Road Ilkley LS29 0AQ Mr David Seymour th Oct 10/04527/FUL 4 The Grove Ilkley Removal of existing entrance vestibule and wc and replacement with new open porch and vestibule Single storey porch extension to front with demolition of existing single storey dining area to rear and construction of single storey kitchen Replacement of garage and associated alterations Change of use from A1 retail to A2 financial and professional services The Parish 23

24 115 8 th Oct 10/04539/HOU th Oct 10/04599/HOU th Oct 10/04586/HOU th Oct 10/04621/CLP th Oct 10/04680/HOU th Oct 10/04937/HOU st Oct 10/04746/LBC LS29 9EG Leeds Developments Limited 1 Belmont Road Ilkley LS29 8PE Jonathan Fleetwood 10 Heath Park Ilkley LS29 9PX Mr + Mrs Hooper 17 Eaton Road Ilkley LS29 9PU Mr Alistair Barlow 2 East Parade Ilkley LS29 8JP Mr Rob Gammon Angles Maxwell Road Ilkley LS29 8RP Mrs Julie Brett 21A Wheatley Lane Ilkley LS29 8BW Mr Philip Cooper- Smith Westwood Lodge Wells Road Ilkley LS29 9JF Westwood Lodge Construction of extension and internal alterations Construction of extension and internal works New pitched roof to existing flat roof dormer to rear elevation Construction of dormer and single storey extension to rear Extension to front elevation and internal alterations creating entrance lobby/hallway plus associated works Renewal of permission 07/06913/FUL for three-storey extension to house Renewal of components of the existing structure, including replacement windows, roof-lights & dormer windows Council would like to be kept informed of any amendments. No documents available - defer recommendation Noted that there are no documents on the Planning Portal Noted that there are no documents on the Planning Portal Queried Is this permitted development? Recommended for 11 th October st Oct 10/04372/HOU 10 High Wood Ilkley Single storey extension to side and 24

25 LS29 8SB external decking st Oct 10/04746/LCB Westwood Lodge Wells Road Ilkley LS29 9JF Renewal of components of the existing structure, including replacement windows, roof-lights & dormer windows th Sept 09/05839/NMA01 Lingstead Panorama Drive Ilkley LS29 9RA John Walker Non material amendment to planning approval 09/05839/HOU to amend rear elevation window detail showing French doors and a glazed/stainless steel frame balustrade and the repositioning of the side elevation windows and door Already granted th Sept 10/04304/HOU 34 Nelson Road Ilkley LS29 8HN Mr Neil Spencer Construction of 2 storey extension to rear of house, new pitched roof dormer to front and porch to front Subject to not taking light from neighbouring properties th Sept 10/04316/HOU Dale Cottage Denton Road Ilkley LS29 0AA Mr Adam Peniket Construction of replacement garage above flood plain and decking to side Could approve the garage but could not approve the decking inappropriate design in Conservation Area and Green Belt th Sept 10/04498/HOU 21 Parish Ghyll Drive Ilkley LS29 9PT Mr John Wharton Demolition of rear + western extensions, construction of replacement western extension + new garage and alterations to site 25

26 th Sept 10/03611/FUL Bradford Team th Sept 10/03740/FUL th Sept 10/03789/HOU Lesley Smith th Sept 10/04108/HOU th Sept 10/04109/LBC 21A Wheatley Lane Ilkley LS29 8BW Mr Philip Cooper- Smith West Holme Fields South Of Denton Road Ilkley Mr Philip Hall 19 The Crescent Ilkley LS29 8LX Mrs Jennifer Parkinson The Barn Grange Farm Carters Lane Ilkley LS29 0DQ Tim Croft The Barn Grange Farm Carters Lane Ilkley LS29 0DQ Tim Croft access Renewal of application 07/06914/FUL for the construction of three storey terrace house Refurbishment of Changing Rooms Porch extension to front of dwelling including study and closet with new cloakroom Single storey extension with pitched roof to the rear elevation extending the existing kitchen and forming a utility/boot room/lobby plus associated works Single storey extension with pitched roof to the rear elevation extending the existing kitchen and forming a utility/boot room/lobby plus associated works But would not like to see any permanent advertisement boards on external walls th Sept 10/04179/HOU 20 Colbert Avenue Ilkley LS29 8LU Mr Sam Naylor Construction of two storey side extension and single storey rear extension th Sept 10/04186/HOU Thornfield Slates Lane Ilkley LS29 0DU Mr John Pike Extension and alteration of loft space with minor internal amendments to the existing property 26

27 95 17 th Sept 10/04206/HOU 1 Wheatley Lane Ilkley LS29 8BW Ms C Cundale Retrospective application for construction of boundary fence, gates and gateposts th Sept 10/04285/HOU 14 Beverley Rise Ilkley LS29 9DB Mr Mike Martin Construction of two storey side and rear extension 93 3 rd Sept 08/04001/NMA rd Sept 10/03531/FUL 91 3 rd Sept 10/03682/FUL Bradford Team 90 3 rd Sept 10/03801/FUL 89 3 rd Sept 10/03849/HOU 88 3 rd Sept 10/03944/HOU 44 Clifton Road Ilkley LS29 8RU Mr Craig Meeson Little Acre Langbar Road Ilkley LS29 0AR Mr Peter Egglestone Land West Of Heathmount Hall Crossbeck Road Ilkley Mr Peter Boreham Ilkley Grammar School Cowpasture Road Ilkley LS29 8TR Ilkley Grammar School 18 Southway Ilkley LS29 8QG Mrs Diane Hopton 19 Cardan Drive Ilkley LS29 8PH Mrs Lola Green Alterations to planning approval 08/04001/FUL dated 11/11/08 :Construction of 4 bedroom dwelling with integral garage on land adjacent Renewal of planning permission 05/02242/FUL dated 20/07/2005 for the construction of single storey dwelling Already granted Construction of 3 dwellings. Withdrawn Change of Use from dwelling to educational 'applied learning centre' south elevation extension to building and internal refurb Construction of a first floor extension over existing flat roof of garage Demolition of existing extension and construction of 2 storey side extension and single storey rear extension 87 3 rd Sept 10/03956/OUT Land East Of 20 Construction of residential - 27

28 Cheltenham Avenue Ilkley The Wright Family development of six dwellings No information on outline location of dwellings. Concerns re impact on drainage to railway. Dangerous egress onto Wheatley Lane. unless more detail supplie d 86 3 rd Sept 10/03969/LBC The Crescent Hotel Brook Street Ilkley LS29 8DG Mr Robert Beacham Installation of 3 Condenser Units and external seating area Proposed seating area - Would spoil the setting of the listed building. Servicing area would require using public footpath. Proximity of traffic lights. Use of umbrellas would obscure view for traffic rd Sept 10/04193/FUL Sacred Heart Catholic Primary School Valley Drive Ilkley LS29 8NL Mr Kevin Anderson Provision of new 2.4m high "Nylofur" weld mesh fencing and gate system front boundary of the school and Valley Drive Imposing impact on street scene. Purpose not clear. Would not wish to see this fencing extended around the site st Aug 10/03777/FUL 34 Ben Rhydding Road Ilkley LS29 8KL Mr JB Frost Creation of a new build detached dwelling. 28

29 83 20 th August th August th August th 79 6 th August August th August 10/02246/ADV 10/03717/HOU 10/03776/HOU 10/03866/HOU 10/03918/HOU 10/04024/REG th Aug 10/3274//HOU The Wendy House 335 Leeds Road Ilkley LS29 8NF Mrs Michelle Firth 12 Denton Road Ilkley LS29 0AA Mr Trouille Springwood Owler Park Road Ilkley LS29 0BG Ms Sally Shelton 16 Regent Road Ilkley LS29 9EA Dr Philip Haworth North Hill Clifford Avenue Ilkley LS29OAS Mr Michael Braithwaite Land adjacent to Ben Rhydding Primary School LS29 8QS 8 Lister Street Ilkley LS29 9ET Miss Joanne Slinger Display of two fascia signs Demolish existing single storey rear entrance porch. Construct new two storey rear extension to accommodate entrance porch. (Resubmission 09/05663/HOU) Retrospective application for new boundary fence and electrical operating access gate Construction of two pitched roof dormers to rear Works located at the rear of the property and on extensions that was approved and built in May Removal of existing mono pitched hardrow slate roof and replacing with a hipped lean to roof at 35-40% pitch covered with red rosemary clay tile to match and to be compatible with those on existing house roof. Demolition of existing nursery and rebuilding a nursery to current standards. Construction of a single storey extension to rear of dwelling and renewal of previous permission to form a garden room Already granted Already granted subject to Conservation Officer s comments and 29

30 76 13 th Aug 10/03229/HOU th Aug 10/03563/CLP th Aug 10/03697/HOU 73 6 th 72 6 th August paper August paper 10/03158/HOU 10/03475/FUL Gordon Street Ilkley LS29 8JW Mr Lee Alderson 16 Strathmore Road Ilkley LS29 8PQ Alec Grimshaw 18 Oakburn Road Ilkley LS29 9NN Mr And Mrs R Templar 14 Wheatlands Ilkley LS29 8JH Mr Damien Smithson Agent Mr Andrew Walbank Piccolino Brook Street Ilkley The Individual Restaurant Company Alterations to front window to form new entrance to ground floor flat Demolition of existing garage, replace with new garage and base and drain roof into an existing gulley and introduce second new gulley Enlargement of existing rear conservatory Demolition of conservatory and construction of bedroom and bathroom Outdoor dining area noted that this is a new application - not a renewal. No comment Inappropriate use of this area: the grassed area should be maintained; there would be pressure to cut back the trees;; established right of way extant - also accuracy of the application in question re ownership of land th 10/03525/HOU Rowangarth Rowley Demotion of existing garage and 30

31 August Drive Ilkley LS29 8BB Mr Christopher Dawson store, removal of existing balcony and the construction of a single storey lounge to the side of the house linked to a new dining area above an extended basement to create a double garage at basement level 70 6 th August 10/03557/HOU Middleton Croft 11 Clifford Avenue Ilkley LS29 0AS Mr David Cowell Construction of single storey rear extension and balcony 69 6 th August 10/03562/ADV Sunwin House Railway Road Ilkley LS29 8HQ W Boyce And Co Ltd 3 signs comprising: Internally illuminated box sign, non illuminated sign and fascia sign adhered to window of amended application external illumination and removal of window decals th August paper 10/03604/HOU 49 Ben Rhydding Road Ilkley LS29 8RN Mrs Judy Banks Construction of timber orangery (conservatory) on front elevation st July 10/03889/FUL Land adjacent to Ben Rhydding Road Ilkley Mr Nicholas White Construction of two storey detached dwelling with associated external works and woodland management. Access and egress on dangerous bend. Concerns re loss of trees in woodland area and future loss of trees. Would like to see BMDC arboreal report and drainage report. 31

32 66 30 th July 10/03377/FUL th July 10/03487/HOU th July paper 10/03505/HOU th July 10/03507/ADV Mark Hutchinson Hawthorne Owler Park Road Ilkley LS29 0BG Mr Robert Lilley 10 Mayfield Road Ilkley LS29 8JG Mr Fisher 2 Woodlands Grove Ilkley LS29 9BX Mr And Mrs J Brash 20 Brook Street Ilkley LS29 8DE Miss Rebecca Spedding rd July 10/03752/FUL Ilkley RUFC Denton Road Ilkley LS29 0BZ rd July 10/02919/VOC 118 Skipton Road Ilkley LS29 9HE Mrs Poonam Cant Alteration to planning approval 09/05398/FUL (alterations to existing house and construction of new house forward of existing house (amended version of dwelling on plot2 in previous 2008 approval)) with increase to the floor area with the front wall pulled forward by 900mm. Construction of two storey extension to side and single storey to rear ALREADY GRANTED It should be noted that there were no plans available for the public to view. Letter of objection noted. Dormer roof extension ALREADY GRANTED Fascia sign Installation of 15m slim line column accommodating 1 no tri sector antenna and 1 no 600mm transmission dish with an equipment cabinet and ancillary meter pillar located adjacent at ground level. To vary condition 2 attached to planning approval 03/03483/COU relating to number of children and childminders of externally illuminated sign only. follow up Highways Officer for enforcement 32

33 60 23 rd July 10/02926/VOC rd July 10/03423/HOU rd July 10/03437/HOU rd July 10/03511/HOU th July paper th July paper th July paper 10/03123/FUL 10/03266/HOU 10/03308/HOU th July 10/03634/CLP 118 Skipton Road Ilkley LS29 9HE Mrs Poonam Cant 31 Beverley Rise Ilkley LS29 9DB Mr Chris Hendy 99 Wheatley Lane Ilkley LS29 8PP Mr E Preston 15 Kings Road Ilkley LS29 9AE Mr Jonathan Barber 4 The Grove Promenade Ilkley LS29 8AF Mr Roger Quarmby 9 Parish Ghyll Lane Ilkley LS29 9QP Mr S A Shah Kirkwood Rombalds Lane Ilkley LS29 8RT Mr Richard Kelt 24 Bridge Lane Ilkley LS29 9HN Mr Robin Culver To vary Condition 2 to increase the number of children and carers on site at any one time attached to planning approval 10/00976/FUL Construction of two storey side extension and single storey rear extension Construction of side extension with porch, ground floor extension to front and dormer to front of property Construction of first floor side extension Enlargement of services yard/bin store to accommodate bins Removal of roof over garage and utility room construction of new first floor to form 2 bedrooms, bathroom, hall, landing, sunroom and store follow up Highways officer for enforcement subject to Tree Officer agreement Construction of replacement garage Pathway, house access and car parking NO NO PLANS PROVIDED Not happy with car parking on unmade up road 52 9 th July 10/02832/VOC Brookfield Croft 67A Demolition of existing bungalow 33

34 Major Development Team Amin Ibrar 51 9 th July 10/03106/HOU 50 9 th July 10/03217/HOU th July 10/02694/HOU Ian Wilson th July 10/03222/HOU 47 2 nd July 10/03080/HOU 46 2 nd July 10/03068/HOU 45 2 nd July 10/03061/CLP 44 2 nd July 10/02908/OUT Bolling Road Ilkley LS29 8QA Mark O'Brien 8 Denton Road Ilkley LS29 0AA Mrs E Wilson 1 Cranford Gardens Ilkley LS29 9SY Mr David Lishman 15 Hollingwood Rise Ilkley LS29 9PW Mr Michael Oxley 1 Woodlands Close Ilkley LS29 9BY Mr & Mrs Chris Eagle 7 High Wheatley Ilkley LS29 8RX Mr And Mrs Ezard 86 Kings Road Ilkley LS29 9BZ Mrs Felicity Tomblin 16 Middleton Road Ilkley LS29 9EX Mr Ian Layfield 248 Leeds Road Ilkley LS29 8LW and construction of 19 Apartments: Removal of Traffic Island from Highways Scheme Construction of dormer window to rear of property Replacement of existing conservatory with new - to rear of house Timber decking to rear and west side of detached house Road safety concerns should be resolved before building commences. Some traffic calming is essential. Construction of a new dormer to existing bedroom to enable the creation of a en-suite suite. Cladding and re roofing of existing garage including insertion of roof light windows. Replacement windows and doors including new windows and folding doors to main dwelling Construction of Porch Change of use of garage to a summer house Construction of dwelling Already granted 34

35 43 2 nd July 10/02656/FUL th June 10/02907/HOU Mr Peter Eggleton 4 Hawksworth Street Ilkley LS29 9DU Dr Jason O'Connor 6 Rupert Road Ilkley LS29 0AQ Mr David Seymour Change of use from current buisness of beauty clinic to chiropractic clinic (A1 use to D1) Replacement of garage and associated alterations subject to Conservation Officer s comments th June 10/02813/HOU 8 Alexandra Place Alexandra Crescent Ilkley LS29 9ES Mrs Margaret Kleppen Construction of a ground floor terrace at the rear of the property. Existing window altered to create access door onto terrace th June 10/02772/HOU 10 Whitton Croft Road Ilkley LS29 9HR Mrs B Sykes Construction of single storey rear extension th June 10/02650/REG Ilkley Grammar School Cowpasture Road Ilkley LS29 8TR Mr Andy MacDonald Temporary double classroom unit but concerns about poor quality of application several inaccuracies and information lacking th June 10/02306/HOU 7 Curlew Close Ilkley LS29 9DG Mr H Lloyd Construction of two storey side extension and replacement of existing utility room with a garage th June 06/02519/NMA01 Major Development Team Former Site Of Clevedon House Victuallers School Ben Rhydding Drive Ilkley Audley Clevedon Limited Non-Material Amendment to planning approval 06/02519/FUL (Redevelopment of former school as an assisted living community, including residential blocks, facilities, parking and landscaping): Amendments to block 4 No comments 35

36 36 18 th June 10/02580/PN 1-30 Dalecourt Fieldway Ilkley LS29 8NB Mr Allan Thomas Demolition of 3 rectangular blocks containing 10 flats each, plus link corridors, communal lounge and wardens bungalow with restoration of site by top soiling and seeding as confirmed by supplementary dated 18 June Would like to see community involvement in plans for future use of land th June 10/02466/FUL 6 Brook Street Ilkley LS29 8DA Nero Holdings Ltd Change of use from retail (A1) to mixed A1/A3 (cafe) use th June 10/02399/ADV Audley Clevedon Ben Rhydding Drive Ilkley Mr Rupert Price Installation of temporary directional signage for six month s duration th June 10/02270/HOU th June 10/01859/FUL th June 09/05398/NMA Curly Hill Ilkley LS29 0DS Mr & Mrs Andrew Hatfield 52 The Grove Ilkley Mr Chris Mallows Hawthorne Owler Park Road Ilkley LS29 0BG Mr Robert Lilley Proposed tandem garage attached to South West elevation of house. Change of use from A3 restaurant and take away to A4 pub and bar. Non material amendment to permission 09/05398/FUL dated 04/01/10 (Alterations to existing house and construction of new house forward of existing house (amended version of dwelling on "plot 2" in previous 2008 approval)) to include: Alterations to the existing approved plans to increase Subject to its being acceptable to the Planning Officer - question why this was not included in the original application. No comment 36

37 30 4 th June 10/02427/HOU 29 4 th June 10/02420/REG 28 4 th June 10/02372/HOU Paul Verity 27 4 th June 10/02370/ADV 26 4 th June 10/02331/CLP Mr 25 4 th June 10/02329/HOU Paul Verity 24 4 th June 10/02293/FUL 5 Clifford Avenue Ilkley LS29 0AS Mr Cyril Clarke Land Adj To Ben Rhydding Primary School Bolling Road Ilkley LS29 8QH Mr Rod Dick Marlbeck 59 Grove Road Ilkley LS29 9PQ Mrs S L Phillips 39 Leeds Road Ilkley LS29 8DP Mr Owen Higgs Stonecroft Owler Park Road Ilkley LS29 0BG Barrie Goldsborough 69 Grove Road Ilkley LS29 9PQ Sacred Heart Catholic Primary School Valley Drive Ilkley LS29 8NL The School Governors the depth of the dwelling by bringing the front wall forward by 900mm giving increased internal areas. No alterations to side or rear window position or materials already approved: Construction of two storey rear and single storey side extension and replacement of garage Demolition of existing nursery and construction of a nursery to current standards Demolition of side garage to be replaced with two storey extension and replace conservatory with rear extension Free standing advertisement board to front of property Construction to side of house using existing drains New hipped roof replacing an existing flat roof Installation of new 2.4m high "Nylofur" weld mesh fencing system to the perimeter of the school No plan on which to comment Already granted DEFER Suggest school speak to neighbours raising objections. Panel n 23 4 th June 10/02192/CLP Oak Tree Cottage Construction of two storey and No comment 37

38 Langbar Road Ilkley LS29 0ED Mr And Mrs Ramage single storey extension with basement 22 4 th June 10/02152/FUL Mornington House Railway Road Ilkley LS29 8HT Dr Martin Nieland Change of use of premises to a mixed use comprising consulting rooms for psychology, lifestyle and ancillary services on ground and 1st floors; with 3 guest en suite bedrooms on 2nd floor, and retaining owners residential accommodation in principle But concerned about additional parking required for residential clients th June 10/02072/FUL 5-7 Brook Street Ilkley LS29 8AA Mrs Karen Horsfall Re-grading the existing footpath local to the right entrance of the building to achieve level access into the building providing means of access for disabled users compliant with DDA requirements But concerned about the level of the pavement coming straight out from the entrance to the building th May 10/02149/ADV 34 Leeds Road Ilkley Mrs Alison Wray New signage for proposed tax advisors at 34 Leeds Road th May 10/02137/HOU Hollin Close 17 Victoria Avenue Ilkley LS29 9BW Mr Gill Robinson Construction of extension to the rear of the existing property th May 10/02110/CAC Heather Flack 1 South Parade Ilkley LS29 9AW Mr Jo Cape Demolition of existing garage and construction of new extension with enlarged external doors and windows to existing south elevation th May 10/02109/HOU 1 South Parade Ilkley LS29 9AW Mr Jo Cape Demolition of existing garage and construction of new extension with enlarged external doors and windows to existing south elevation Panel n 38

39 16 28 th May 10/01984/FUL 34 Leeds Road Ilkley Mr David Forrester Change of use of ground floor to include A2 class use th May 10/01588/FUL st May 10/01678/HOU Heather Flack Langfield Langbar Road Ilkley LS29 0AR Mrs T Robertshaw 16 Westwood Rise Ilkley LS29 9SW Renewal of Planning Permission 05/02319/FUL dated : Construction of first floor extension and external alterations to property Formation of raised patio area - amended plan. Agree with Conservation Officer landscaping would be too steep and would not soften the line of the wall. Also, reiterate previous comments as below Whilst it is recognised that the proposed screening on the East side is an attempt to address concerns of neighbours at no 14, this screening would need to be extremely high and would be overbearing. Whilst it is recognised that the lowering of the decking on the North side is an attempt to address concerns of 39