Benchmark City Survey Data

Transcription

1 Section E: Traffic Safety Please refer survey questions or comments to Darcy Boorem, Senior Crime Analyst Overland Park Police Department, or Background The Benchmark City Survey was originally designed in 1997 by a core group of Police Chiefs from around the country. These Chiefs sought to establish a measurement tool to help ensure their Departments were providing the best service possible within their respective community. The survey provides a wide range of information about each Department. With that information, the participating agencies can set better goals and objectives, and then compare their performance in the various areas. The Overland Park, Kansas Police Department has taken the lead in compiling the survey results, and makes the final Benchmark City Survey Report available to all participants at an annual Chief's Summit hosted by participating agencies on a rotating basis. This year the conference is being held in Springfield, MO. Bellevue, WA Steve Mylett Boca Raton, FL - Daniel C. Alexander Boise, ID William Bones Boulder, CO Greg Testa Broken Arrow, OK Brandon Berryhill Carlsbad, CA Neil Gallucci Cary, NC Tony Godwin Cedar Rapids, IA Wayne Jerman Chesapeake, VA - Kelvin L. Wright Chula Vista, CA Roxana Kennedy 2017 Participating Agencies Columbia, MO Kenneth M. Burton Coral Springs, FL Clyde Parry Edmond, OK J.D. Younger Fort Collins, CO Terry Jones (Interim) Fremont, CA Richard Lucero Garland, TX - Mitch Bates Grand Prairie, TX Steve Dye Henderson, NV LaTesha Watson Irving, TX Jeff Spivey Section E Traffic Safety Lawrence, KS Gregory Burns Jr. Lincoln, NE Jeffrey Bliemeister Naperville, IL Robert W. Marshall Norman, OK Keith Humphrey Olathe, KS Steve Menke Overland Park, KS Frank Donchez Peoria, AZ Roy W. Minter Jr. Plano, TX - Gregory W. Rushin Richardson, TX Jim Spivey Springfield, MO - Paul Williams 1

2 Benchmark Cities Bellevue, WA Fremont, CA Boise, ID Boulder, CO FT Collins, CO Lincoln, NE Cedar Rapids, IA Overland Park, KS Naperville, IL Chesapeake, VA Carlsbad, CA Henderson, NV Edmond, OK Lawrence, KS Olathe, KS Columbia, MO Springfield, MO Cary, NC Norman, OK Broken Arrow, OK Peoria, AZ Irving, TX Plano, TX Chula Vista, CA Grand Prairie, TX Garland, TX Boca Raton, FL Richardson, TX Coral Springs, FL Section E Traffic Safety 2

3 Traffic Crashes (Total) per 1,000 Citizens, 2-Year Comparison 2017 Average Traffic Crashes per 1,000 Citizens is 21.8 Section E - Traffic Safety 3

4 Traffic Crashes (Total) per 1,000 Citizens, 5-Year Comparison 2017 Average Traffic Crashes per 1,000 Citizens is 21.8 City Name Population Traffic Crashes Bellevue, WA 140,700 1, Boca Raton, FL 96,114 3, Boise, ID 228,930 3, Boulder, CO 108,090 3, Broken Arrow, OK 108,854 2, Carlsbad, CA 113, Cary, NC 159,170 4, Cedar Rapids, IA 131,127 5, Chesapeake, VA 242,336 2, Chula Vista, CA 267,172 1, Columbia, MO 122,443 4, Coral Springs, FL 127,673 2, Edmond, OK 93,105 1, Fort Collins, CO 167,492 4, Fremont, CA 227,934 1, Garland, TX 236,786 2, Grand Prairie, TX 187,050 3, Henderson, NV 307,928 3, Irving, TX 238,289 4, Lawrence, KS 99,496 2, Lincoln, NE 280,364 8, Naperville, IL 147,122 3, Norman, OK 122,738 3, Olathe, KS 138,944 2, Overland Park, KS 191,780 4, Peoria, AZ 167,073 2, Plano, TX 277,720 5, Richardson, TX 113,347 1, Springfield, MO 167,319 7, Average 172,795 3, Section E - Traffic Safety 4

5 Traffic Crashes (Fatality), 2-Year Comparison 2017 Average Fatality Traffic Crashes per 1,000 Citizens is.044 Section E - Traffic Safety 5

6 Traffic Crashes (Fatality), 5-Year Comparison 2017 Average Fatality Traffic Crashes per 1,000 Citizens is.044 City Name Population Fatality Traffic Crashes Bellevue, WA 140, Boca Raton, FL 96, Boise, ID 228, Boulder, CO 108, Broken Arrow, OK 108, Carlsbad, CA 113, Cary, NC 159, Cedar Rapids, IA 131, Chesapeake, VA 242, Chula Vista, CA 267, Columbia, MO 122, Coral Springs, FL 127, Edmond, OK 93, Fort Collins, CO 167, Fremont, CA 227, Garland, TX 236, Grand Prairie, TX 187, Henderson, NV 307, Irving, TX 238, Lawrence, KS 99, Lincoln, NE 280, Naperville, IL 147, Norman, OK 122, Olathe, KS 138, Overland Park, KS 191, Peoria, AZ 167, Plano, TX 277, Richardson, TX 113, Springfield, MO 167, Average 172, Section E - Traffic Safety 6

7 Traffic Crashes (Injury) per 1,000 Citizens, 2-Year Comparison 2017 Average Injury Crashes per 1,000 Citizens is 5.1 Section E - Traffic Safety 7

8 Traffic Crashes (Injury) per 1,000 Citizens, 5-Year Comparison 2017 Average Injury Crashes per 1,000 Citizens is 5.1 City Name Population Injury Traffic Crashes Bellevue, WA 140, Boca Raton, FL 96, Boise, ID 228,930 1, Boulder, CO 108, Broken Arrow, OK 108, Carlsbad, CA 113, Cary, NC 159,170 1, Cedar Rapids, IA 131, Chesapeake, VA 242,336 1, Chula Vista, CA 267, Columbia, MO 122, Coral Springs, FL 127, Edmond, OK 93, Fort Collins, CO 167, Fremont, CA 227, Garland, TX 236,786 1, Grand Prairie, TX 187,050 1, Henderson, NV 307, Irving, TX 238,289 1, Lawrence, KS 99, Lincoln, NE 280,364 1, Naperville, IL 147, Norman, OK 122, Olathe, KS 138, Overland Park, KS 191, Peoria, AZ 167, Plano, TX 277,720 1, Richardson, TX 113, Springfield, MO 167,319 2, Average 172, Section E - Traffic Safety 8

9 Traffic Crashes (Non-Injury) per 1,000 Citizens, 2-Year Comparison 2017 Average Non-Injury Crashes per 1,000 Citizens is 17.3 Section E - Traffic Safety 9

10 Traffic Crashes (Non-Injury) per 1,000 Citizens, 5-Year Comparison 2017 Average Non-Injury Crashes per 1,000 Citizens is 17.3 City Name Population Non-Injury Traffic Crashes Bellevue, WA 140,700 1, Boca Raton, FL 96,114 3, Boise, ID 228,930 2, Boulder, CO 108,090 2, Broken Arrow, OK 108,854 1, Carlsbad, CA 113, Cary, NC 159,170 3, Cedar Rapids, IA 131,127 5, Chesapeake, VA 242,336 1, Chula Vista, CA 267, Columbia, MO 122,443 3, Coral Springs, FL 127,673 2, Edmond, OK 93, Fort Collins, CO 167,492 3, Fremont, CA 227,934 Not Tracked Not Tracked Garland, TX 236,786 1, Grand Prairie, TX 187,050 2, Henderson, NV 307,928 2, Irving, TX 238,289 2, Lawrence, KS 99,496 2, Lincoln, NE 280,364 7, Naperville, IL 147,122 3, Norman, OK 122,738 2, Olathe, KS 138,944 2, Overland Park, KS 191,780 3, Peoria, AZ 167,073 1, Plano, TX 277,720 3, Richardson, TX 113, Springfield, MO 167,319 5, Average 172,795 2, Section E - Traffic Safety 10

11 Alcohol Related Fatality Crashes per 1,000 Citizens, 2-Year Comparison 2017 Average Alcohol Related Fatality Crashes per 1,000 Citizens is Section E - Traffic Safety 11

12 Alcohol Related Fatality Crashes per 1,000 Citizens, 5-Year Comparison 2017 Average Alcohol Related Fatality Crashes per 1,000 Citizens is City Name Population Fatality (Alcohol Related) Bellevue, WA 140, Boca Raton, FL 96, Boise, ID 228, Boulder, CO 108, Broken Arrow, OK 108, Carlsbad, CA 113, Cary, NC 159, Cedar Rapids, IA 131, Chesapeake, VA 242, Chula Vista, CA 267, Columbia, MO 122, Coral Springs, FL 127, Edmond, OK 93, Fort Collins, CO 167, Fremont, CA 227, Garland, TX 236, Grand Prairie, TX 187, Henderson, NV 307, Irving, TX 238, Lawrence, KS 99, Lincoln, NE 280, Naperville, IL 147, Norman, OK 122, Olathe, KS 138, Overland Park, KS 191, Peoria, AZ 167, Plano, TX 277, Richardson, TX 113, Springfield, MO 167, Average 172, Section E - Traffic Safety 12

13 Top Three Causes of Traffic Crashes Top Three Fail to Yield ROW Inattention Speed City Name #1 #2 #3 Bellevue, WA Inattention Fail to Yield ROW Speed Boca Raton, FL Careless Driving Other Contributing Causes Fail to Yield ROW Boise, ID Follow too Close Fail to Yield ROW Inattention Boulder, CO Other Contributing Causes Careless Driving Inattention Broken Arrow, OK Fail to Yield ROW Inattention Speed Carlsbad, CA Other Contributing Causes Speed Unsafe Turn Cary, NC Speed Fail to Yield ROW Improper Backing Cedar Rapids, IA Disobey Traffic Control Device Fail to Yield ROW Inattention Chesapeake, VA Follow too Close Inattention Speed Chula Vista, CA Speed Improper Turn Alcohol Columbia, MO Fail to Yield ROW Inattention Follow too Close Coral Springs, FL Other Contributing Causes Fail to Yield ROW Careless Driving Edmond, OK Inattention Disobey Traffic Control Device Speed Fort Collins, CO Follow too Close Careless Driving Fail to Yield ROW Fremont, CA Speed Unsafe Turn Fail to Yield ROW Garland, TX Inattention Speed Fail to Yield ROW Grand Prairie, TX Careless Driving Improper Turn Speed Henderson, NV Fail to Yield ROW Follow too Close Fail to Maintain a Single Lane Irving, TX Speed Inattention Follow too Close Lawrence, KS Inattention Fail to Yield ROW Follow too Close Lincoln, NE Negligent Driving Fail to Yield ROW Other Contributing Causes Naperville, IL Speed Fail to Yield ROW Improper Lane Change Norman, OK Inattention Fail to Yield ROW Follow too Close Olathe, KS Inattention Careless Driving Alcohol Overland Park, KS Follow too Close Inattention Fail to Yield ROW Peoria, AZ Speed Fail to Yield ROW Other Contributing Causes Plano, TX Speed Improper Lane Change Follow too Close Richardson, TX Speed Fail to Yield ROW Fail to Maintain a Single Lane Springfield, MO Fail to Yield ROW Inattention Follow too Close Section E - Traffic Safety 13

14 % of Traffic Crashes Resulting in a Citation, 2-Year Comparison 2017 Average % of Traffic Crashes Resulting in a Citation is 52.0% Section E - Traffic Safety 14

15 % of Traffic Crashes Resulting in a Citation, 5-Year Comparison 2017 Average % of Traffic Crashes Resulting in a Citation is 52.0% City Name Traffic Crashes Bellevue, WA 1, % 77.0% 75.0% 78.0% 70.0% Boca Raton, FL 3, % 39.0% 32.0% 29.0% 30.7% Boise, ID 3, % Not Tracked 88.0% 80.0% 90.0% Boulder, CO 3, % 90.0% 89.0% 89.0% 89.0% Broken Arrow, OK 1, % 46.0% 74.0% 87.5% 85.7% Carlsbad, CA 2, % 0.0% 0.002% Cary, NC 4, % 20.0% Cedar Rapids, IA 5, % Not Tracked Not Tracked Chesapeake, VA 2, % 56.0% 17.3% 17.3% 20.0% Chula Vista, CA 1,845 Not Tracked Not Tracked Not Tracked Columbia, MO 5,843 Not Tracked Not Tracked Not Tracked Coral Springs, FL 2, % 21.4% 24.0% 25.6% 30.0% Edmond, OK 1, % Not Tracked Not Tracked Fort Collins, CO 4, % 71.0% 72.0% 74.0% 75.0% Fremont, CA 1,662 Not Tracked Not Tracked Not Tracked Garland, TX 3, % 9.0% 12.7% 16.2% 18.3% Grand Prairie, TX 3, % 53.7% 51.9% 47.3% 44.0% Henderson, NV 4, % 69.8% 59.9% 63.3% 48.1% Irving, TX 4,370 Not Tracked Not Tracked Not Tracked Lawrence, KS 2,830 Not Tracked Not Tracked Not Tracked Lincoln, NE 8, % 83.0% 84.0% 83.1% Naperville, IL 3, % 80.0% 50.0% 77.0% 76.4% Norman, OK 2, % Not Tracked Not Tracked 81.6% 61.0% Olathe, KS 3, % 74.4% 67.0% 65.9% 64.2% Overland Park, KS 4, % 68.8% 72.6% 69.3% 64.8% Peoria, AZ 2,441 Not tracked Not tracked Not Tracked Plano, TX 6, % 43.9% 34.6% 27.7% 26.8% Richardson, TX 2, % 70.0% 69.5% 65.8% 52.0% Springfield, MO 6,480 Not Tracked Not Tracked Not Tracked Average 3, % 54.1% 57.3% 58.5% 57.2% Section E - Traffic Safety 15

16 DUI Arrests per 1,000 Citizens, 2-Year Comparison 2017 DUI Arrests/Citations per 1,000 Citizens is 2.5 Section E - Traffic Safety 16

17 City Name A Coalition for Mutual Support DUI Arrests per 1,000 Citizens, 5-Year Comparison 2017 DUI Arrests/Citations per 1,000 Citizens is 2.5 Population DUI Arrests Bellevue, WA 140, Boca Raton, FL 96, Boise, ID 228, Boulder, CO 108, Broken Arrow, OK 108, Carlsbad, CA 113, Cary, NC 159, Cedar Rapids, IA 131, Chesapeake, VA 242, Chula Vista, CA 267, Columbia, MO 122, Coral Springs, FL 127, Edmond, OK 93, Fort Collins, CO 167, Fremont, CA 227, Garland, TX 236, Grand Prairie, TX 187, Henderson, NV 307, Irving, TX 238, Lawrence, KS 99, Lincoln, NE 280, Naperville, IL 147, Norman, OK 122, Olathe, KS 138, Overland Park, KS 191, Peoria, AZ 167, Plano, TX 277, Richardson, TX 113, Springfield, MO 167, Average 172, Section E - Traffic Safety 17

18 Alcohol Arrests per 1,000 Citizens, 2-Year Comparison 2017 Alcohol Arrests/Citations per 1,000 Citizens is 2.7 Section E - Traffic Safety 18

19 City Name A Coalition for Mutual Support Alcohol Arrests per 1,000 Citizens, 5-Year Comparison 2017 Alcohol Arrests/Citations per 1,000 Citizens is 2.7 Population Alcohol Arr Bellevue, WA 140, Boca Raton, FL 96, Boise, ID 228,930 1, Boulder, CO 108, Broken Arrow, OK 108, Carlsbad, CA 113, Cary, NC 159, Cedar Rapids, IA 131, Chesapeake, VA 242,336 Not Tracked Not Tracked Not Tracked Not Tracked Chula Vista, CA 267, Not Tracked Columbia, MO 122, Coral Springs, FL 127, Edmond, OK 93, Fort Collins, CO 167, Fremont, CA 227, Garland, TX 236, Grand Prairie, TX 187, Henderson, NV 307, Irving, TX 238, Lawrence, KS 99, Lincoln, NE 280,364 1, Naperville, IL 147, Norman, OK 122, Olathe, KS 138, Overland Park, KS 191, Peoria, AZ 167, Plano, TX 277,720 1, Richardson, TX 113, Springfield, MO 167, Average 172, Section E - Traffic Safety 19

20 Number of On-Duty Officer-Involved Traffic Crashes, 2-Year Comparison 2017 Average On-Duty Officer-Involved Traffic Crashes is 36 Section E - Traffic Safety 20

21 Number of On-Duty Officer-Involved Traffic Crashes, 5-Year Comparison 2017 Average On-Duty Officer-Involved Traffic Crashes is 36 City Name Assigned Officers Miles Driven Bellevue, WA , Boca Raton, FL 216 2,413, Boise, ID 296 2,637, Boulder, CO , Broken Arrow, OK 146 1,624, Carlsbad, CA 115 1,075, Cary, NC 198 1,447, Cedar Rapids, IA 213 1,176, Chesapeake, VA 397 4,315, Chula Vista, CA , Columbia, MO , Coral Springs, FL 216 1,072, Edmond, OK 120 1,218, Fort Collins, CO 214 1,574, Fremont, CA , Garland, TX 348 2,332, Grand Prairie, TX 276 2,698, Henderson, NV 378 3,095, Irving, TX 359 1,807, Lawrence, KS 154 1,046, Lincoln, NE 335 2,333, Naperville, IL 169 1,144, Norman, OK 180 1,327, Olathe, KS 181 1,477, Overland Park, KS 255 1,511, Peoria, AZ 199 1,460, Plano, TX 394 1,931, Richardson, TX 165 1,396, Springfield, MO 352 2,121, Average 236 1,665, Section E - Traffic Safety 21

22 Average Traffic Crashes per Officer, 2-Year Comparison 2017 Average Traffic Crashes per Officer is 0.15 Section E - Traffic Safety 22

23 City Name A Coalition for Mutual Support Average Traffic Crashes per Officer, 5-Year Comparison 2017 Average Traffic Crashes per Officer is 0.15 Assigned Officers On-Duty Officer Involved Traffic Crashes Bellevue, WA Boca Raton, FL Boise, ID Boulder, CO Broken Arrow, OK Carlsbad, CA Cary, NC Cedar Rapids, IA Chesapeake, VA Chula Vista, CA Columbia, MO Coral Springs, FL Edmond, OK Fort Collins, CO Fremont, CA Garland, TX Grand Prairie, TX Henderson, NV Irving, TX Lawrence, KS Lincoln, NE Naperville, IL Norman, OK Olathe, KS Overland Park, KS Peoria, AZ Plano, TX Richardson, TX Springfield, MO Average Section E - Traffic Safety 23

24 Percent of Officer At-Fault Traffic Crashes, 2-Year Comparison 2017 Average Officer At-Fault Traffic Crashes is 59.8% Section E - Traffic Safety 24

25 Percent of Officer At-Fault Traffic Crashes, 5-Year Comparison City Name 2017 Average Officer At-Fault Traffic Crashes is 59.8% Officer Involved Traffic Crashes Officer At Fault Traffic Crashes Bellevue, WA % 0.0% 33.3% 66.7% 83.3% Boca Raton, FL % Not Tracked 14.7% 26.5% 26.0% Boise, ID % 73.5% 59.6% 53.5% 54.2% Boulder, CO % 57.1% 73.7% 54.2% 53.8% Broken Arrow, OK % 51.9% 82.8% 55.9% 30.8% Carlsbad, CA % 48.6% 100.0% Cary, NC % 34.0% Cedar Rapids, IA % 47.4% 47.6% 38.5% 52.2% Chesapeake, VA % 39.6% 45.0% 42.5% 46.3% Chula Vista, CA % 60.9% 63.2% 60.9% 28.6% Columbia, MO 0 Not Tracked Not Tracked 60.9% 59.3% 60.9% 74.1% Coral Springs, FL % 42.9% 46.6% 36.6% 42.1% Edmond, OK % 56.0% 55.0% 41.7% 23.5% Fort Collins, CO % 54.5% 38.5% 42.9% 46.4% Fremont, CA % 64.3% 57.1% 53.8% 75.0% Garland, TX % 50.6% 27.8% 38.7% 39.1% Grand Prairie, TX % 55.2% 51.4% 58.1% 61.7% Henderson, NV % 52.9% 69.6% 62.2% 69.2% Irving, TX % 57.7% 56.4% 60.9% 49.2% Lawrence, KS % 83.3% 23.1% 29.2% 90.5% Lincoln, NE % 58.1% 52.9% 63.3% 52.2% Naperville, IL % 40.7% 60.0% 32.0% 43.6% Norman, OK % 65.2% 56.1% 50.0% 56.8% Olathe, KS % 56.0% 63.2% 57.1% 62.5% Overland Park, KS % 50.0% 50.0% 44.2% 40.0% Peoria, AZ % 48.0% 37.5% 63.6% 40.9% Plano, TX % 43.1% 58.3% 36.1% 52.6% Richardson, TX % 38.9% 53.3% 52.4% 43.3% Springfield, MO % 60.5% 58.7% 66.0% 53.7% Average % 51.8% 53.4% 49.9% 51.5% Section E - Traffic Safety 25

26 Number of Officer At fault Traffic Crashes Per 100,000 Miles Driven, 2-Year Comparison 2017 Average Officer At Fault Traffic Crashes Per 100,000 Miles Driven is 1.4 Section E - Traffic Safety 26

27 Number of Officer At fault Traffic Crashes Per 100,000 Miles Driven, 5-Year Comparison 2017 Average Officer At Fault Traffic Crashes Per 100,000 Miles Driven is 1.4 City Name Miles Driven Officer At Fault Traffic Crashes Bellevue, WA 627, Boca Raton, FL 2,413, Not Tracked Boise, ID 2,637, Boulder, CO 826, Broken Arrow, OK 1,624, Carlsbad, CA 1,075, Cary, NC 1,447, Cedar Rapids, IA 1,176, Chesapeake, VA 4,315, Chula Vista, CA 972, Columbia, MO 882,791 Not Tracked Not Tracked Coral Springs, FL 1,072, Edmond, OK 1,218, Fort Collins, CO 1,574, Fremont, CA 750, Garland, TX 2,332, Grand Prairie, TX 2,698, Henderson, NV 3,095, Irving, TX 1,807, Lawrence, KS 1,046, Lincoln, NE 2,333, Naperville, IL 1,144, Norman, OK 1,327, Olathe, KS 1,477, Overland Park, KS 1,511, Peoria, AZ 1,460, Plano, TX 1,931, Richardson, TX 1,396, Springfield, MO 2,121, Average 1,665, Section E - Traffic Safety 27

28 Number of Miles Driven (Patrol Vehicles), 2-Year Comparison 2017 Average Miles on Patrol Vehicles is 1,665,489 Section E - Traffic Safety 28

29 Number of Miles Driven (Patrol Vehicles), 5-Year Comparison 2017 Average Miles on Patrol Vehicles is 1,665,489 City Name Bellevue, WA 627, , , , ,138 Boca Raton, FL 2,413,722 2,412,175 2,365,878 2,494,160 2,430,457 Boise, ID 2,637,374 2,320,571 1,679,277 1,665,132 1,695,998 Boulder, CO 826, , , , ,976 Broken Arrow, OK 1,624, ,341 1,802,116 1,753,248 1,713,248 Carlsbad, CA 1,075,796 1,091,100 1,155,821 Cary, NC 1,447,682 1,335,356 Cedar Rapids, IA 1,176,114 1,159,061 1,599,551 1,070,408 1,231,641 Chesapeake, VA 4,315,963 4,319,854 4,557,647 4,582,271 5,296,063 Chula Vista, CA 972, , , , ,560 Columbia, MO 882, , , , ,896 Coral Springs, FL 1,072,746 1,273,191 1,648,094 1,728,575 1,926,048 Edmond, OK 1,218,282 1,359,238 1,283,369 1,273,783 1,368,448 Fort Collins, CO 1,574,103 1,554,893 1,536,442 1,385,213 1,325,236 Fremont, CA 750, , , , ,338 Garland, TX 2,332,205 2,360,011 2,285,778 2,163,547 2,254,465 Grand Prairie, TX 2,698,125 2,587,723 2,475,623 2,323,893 2,189,632 Henderson, NV 3,095,958 3,178,457 1,462,388 1,402,976 1,513,087 Irving, TX 1,807,643 1,763,972 1,806,654 1,858,263 1,868,243 Lawrence, KS 1,046, , , , ,096 Lincoln, NE 2,333,634 2,350,110 2,278,661 2,481,230 2,327,964 Naperville, IL 1,144,327 1,150,000 1,183,980 1,073, ,472 Norman, OK 1,327,236 1,731,272 1,051,471 1,347,135 1,428,197 Olathe, KS 1,477,320 1,629,931 1,458,421 1,080,864 1,128,999 Overland Park, KS 1,511,752 1,341,873 1,550,771 1,356,535 1,265,648 Peoria, AZ 1,460,103 1,440,071 1,449,946 1,404,322 1,353,000 Plano, TX 1,931,672 1,774,951 1,929,237 1,933,224 2,141,046 Richardson, TX 1,396,028 1,326,227 1,347,662 1,336,978 1,420,105 Springfield, MO 2,121,308 1,405,852 1,491,317 1,418,677 1,855,814 Average 1,665,489 1,603,129 1,576,581 1,555,679 1,605,401 Section E - Traffic Safety 29

30 Vehicle Replacement Criteria City Name Annual miles driven by Patrol Vehicles Patrol Vehicle Replacement Criteria Bellevue, WA 627, Years or 120,000 Boca Raton, FL 2,413,722 Combination of year, mileage and repair cost Boise, ID 2,637,374 5yrs and/or 100,000 miles, or if the vehicle cost is more than it is worth to maintain. Boulder, CO 826,757 6 years or 100,000 Broken Arrow, OK 1,624, ,000 miles and ten years or 110,000 miles Carlsbad, CA 1,075, ,000 or 4 years Cary, NC 1,447,682 point value system based on set criteria Cedar Rapids, IA 1,176,114 Based on life cycle cost Chesapeake, VA 4,315,963 Combination of mileage, age & repair cost, determined by Fleet Mgmt Chula Vista, CA 972, ,000 miles Columbia, MO 882,791 4 years or miles Coral Springs, FL 1,072,746 Vehicle Age 7 years, Maintenance Cost, Mileage Edmond, OK 1,218,282 9 Years or 135,000 miles Fort Collins, CO 1,574,103 Point System Formula:Mileage, Age, Service Fremont, CA 750,000 5 years or 100,000 miles Garland, TX 2,332,205 Replacement is based on vehicle mileage warranties. Crown Vics are replaced after 70,000 miles. Caprices and Tahoes are replaced after 100,000 miles. Other nonpursuit vehicles utilized in the department are also based on mileage warranties and varies with the type of vehicle it is. Vehicles can also be replaced for continuous mechanical issues. Grand Prairie, TX 2,698, miles Henderson, NV 3,095,958 Age, accumulated mileage and hours, and maintenance history determine the optimum disposal point. Irving, TX 1,807,643 85,000 miles Lawrence, KS 1,046,695 Rating Scale (depends on age/ miles/ type of service reliability/ costs for up keep/ condition) Lincoln, NE 2,333, ,000/6 years service Naperville, IL 1,144, ,000 Norman, OK 1,327,236 Computer program that considers mileage, age, repair costs Olathe, KS 1,477,320 90,000 miles, 4 years, maintenance records reviewed Overland Park, KS 1,511, ,000 miles Peoria, AZ 1,460,103 Point System = Age+Mileage+Total Repair Costs Over Life of Vehicle Plano, TX 1,931,672 Vehicle replacement is determined by age, mileage, and maintenance issues. Goal is to replace Crown Vics at 90,000 miles and Tahoes at 110,000 miles Richardson, TX 1,396,028 Sedans replaced in 3 yrs or 80K miles SUVs replaced in 3 yrs or 120k miles Springfield, MO 2,121,308 The department currently relies on our City Service Center to evaluate the fleet via a 15 point system based on age/mileage/repair costs, etc. At 15 points the vehicle should be replaced. This typically doesn't happen and is dependent on funding. Section E - Traffic Safety 30

31 Does your agency policy allow issuance of take home cars? City Name Does your agency policy allow issuance of take home cars? Criteria Bellevue, WA Yes Command Staff, Detectives, SROs, PIO Boca Raton, FL Yes All Law Enforcement Officers if they live in an adjoining county Civilian employees holding the position of CSO, THI and Forensics Manager Boise, ID Yes CS, LT, CID on rotation, specialty assignments on case by case basis. Boulder, CO Yes Chief, (2) Deputy Chiefs, Detective Commander, SWAT Commander, Major Crimes Detective Sergeant, On-Call Personnel Broken Arrow, OK Yes All Sworn plus 3 civilians 144 Carlsbad, CA Yes Command Staff, Professional Standards, Investigations, Traffic, K9, Crime Suppression Cary, NC No N/A Cedar Rapids, IA Yes SROs, K9s, SWAT commanders Chesapeake, VA Unknown Unknown Chula Vista, CA Yes Command, COV, Lts (Non-Patrol), Traffic, K-9 Columbia, MO Yes K9, SWAT/VNOC LT, Street Crimes Sgt, COU Sgt, On-call personnel Coral Springs, FL Yes All Sworn, Civilian - CSI & Victim Advocates on call,community Involvement Coordinator Edmond, OK Yes All Commissioned personnel Fort Collins, CO Yes All Sworn Fremont, CA Yes Investigations, Command Staff Garland, TX Yes Command staff, CID, NPOs, SROs, Traffic Unit, and selected Bomb Unit personnel. Grand Prairie, TX Yes All who live within the City of Grand Prairie Henderson, NV Yes Command Staff (Capt to Chief), Lieutenants in Special Assignments, PIO, SWAT Irving, TX Yes Command Staff, Tactical, Narcotics Lawrence, KS Yes Command Staff, K9 Unit Lincoln, NE Yes Chiefs and K-9 Officers Naperville, IL Yes Chief, DCs, and 3 K-9 Norman, OK Yes All Commissioned, PIO, Communications Manager, Communications Technician, Forensic Technicians, Animal Welfare, Shelter Manager Olathe, KS Yes Command Staff, traffic, SRO, Investigations, K9 Overland Park, KS Yes Division Commanders, Deputy Chiefs & Chief. Plus the ESS Captain. Peoria, AZ Yes Command Staff, Public Information Officer, Professional Standards Unit, Criminal Investigations, TLO Detectives, K9, Street Crimes (Rotation when on-call), Traffic, SWAT Plano, TX Yes Chief, Asst Chiefs, PSU Sgt & on call Inv., CISD On-Call Sgt, Dets, and Back-up, PIO, Canine, and SWAT & Bomb Techs. Richardson, TX Yes Chief, PIO, SWAT, K9 On-call Investigators, Traffic & Negotiator Springfield, MO Yes Command Staff, SRT, IIAU, Special Investigations, Narcotics Section E - Traffic Safety 31

32 Number of Traffic Citations per 1,000 Citizens, 2-Year Comparison 2017 Average Traffic Citations per 1,000 Citizens is 140 Section E - Traffic Safety 32

33 Number of Traffic Citations per 1,000 Citizens, 5-Year Comparison 2017 Average Traffic Citations per 1,000 Citizens is 140 City Name Population Traffic Citations Bellevue, WA 140,700 11, Boca Raton, FL 96,114 9, Boise, ID 228,930 20, Boulder, CO 108,090 8, Broken Arrow, OK 108,854 12, Carlsbad, CA 113,952 3, Cary, NC 159,170 7, Cedar Rapids, IA 131,127 11, Chesapeake, VA 242,336 34, Chula Vista, CA 267,172 17, Columbia, MO 122,443 3, Coral Springs, FL 127,673 16, Edmond, OK 93,105 10, Fort Collins, CO 167,492 13, Fremont, CA 227,934 14, Garland, TX 236,786 55, Grand Prairie, TX 187,050 63, Henderson, NV 307,928 23, Irving, TX 238,289 31, Lawrence, KS 99,496 11, Lincoln, NE 280,364 43, Naperville, IL 147,122 15, Norman, OK 122,738 86, Olathe, KS 138,944 23, Overland Park, KS 191,780 31, Peoria, AZ 167,073 10, Plano, TX 277,720 45, Richardson, TX 113,347 31, Springfield, MO 167,319 20, Average 172,795 23, Section E - Traffic Safety 33

34 Number of Traffic Citations by Type City Name Traffic Citations Non-Moving Violations Moving Violations DUI Alcohol Speed Red Light Violations Other Moving Violations Bellevue, WA 11,872 Not Tracked 11, , ,892 Boca Raton, FL 9,596 2,919 6, , ,587 Boise, ID 20,392 7,038 13, ,116 7, ,434 Boulder, CO 8,229 1,332 6, , ,048 Broken Arrow, OK 12,147 6,462 5, , ,885 Carlsbad, CA 3,132 1,383 1, , Cary, NC 7, , , ,012 Cedar Rapids, IA 11,197 Not Tracked 11, , ,930 Chesapeake, VA 34,048 14,432 19, Not Tracked 14, ,236 Chula Vista, CA 17,063 7,420 9, ,552 2,141 4,509 Columbia, MO 3,782 1,574 2, ,082 Coral Springs, FL 16,103 3,885 12, , ,303 Edmond, OK 10,809 1,358 9, , ,115 Fort Collins, CO 13,756 1,692 12, , ,069 Fremont, CA 14,116 2,884 11, ,834 3,851 4,021 Garland, TX 55,560 22,914 32, ,831 2,235 8,661 Grand Prairie, TX 63,462 32,721 30, ,821 8,821 6,216 Henderson, NV 23,861 6,031 17, ,032 1,305 5,804 Irving, TX 31,007 10,024 20, , ,395 Lawrence, KS 11,614 5,757 5, , ,311 Lincoln, NE 43,393 20,071 23, ,255 11,630 1,167 8,346 Naperville, IL 15,743 5,399 10, , ,458 Norman, OK 86,464 25,770 60, ,185 1,794 48,598 Olathe, KS 23,803 15,092 8, , ,040 Overland Park, KS 31,676 13,708 17, ,334 1,297 6,288 Peoria, AZ 10,961 Not tracked 10, , ,490 Plano, TX 45,818 8,884 36, ,796 1,434 11,842 Richardson, TX 31,194 1,977 29, , ,410 Springfield, MO 20,288 5,003 15, , ,913 Average 23,745 8,684 15, ,204 1,162 6,876 Note: Alcohol numbers reflect a combination of Citations and/or Arrests. Section E - Traffic Safety 34