Benchmark City Survey Data

Transcription

1 Section E: Traffic Safety Please refer survey questions or comments to Chris Kostelac, Watch Commander Overland Park Police Department, or Background The Benchmark City Survey was originally designed in 1997 by a core group of Police Chiefs from around the country. These Chiefs sought to establish a measurement tool to help ensure their Departments were providing the best service possible within their respective community. The survey provides a wide range of information about each Department. With that information, the participating agencies can set better goals and objectives, and then compare their performance in the various areas. The Overland Park, Kansas Police Department has taken the lead in compiling the survey results, and makes the final Benchmark City Survey Report available to all participants at an annual Chief's Summit hosted by participating agencies on a rotating basis. This year the conference is being held in Henderson, NV. Bellevue, WA Steve Mylett Boca Raton, FL - Daniel C. Alexander Boise, ID William Bones Boulder, CO Greg Testa Broken Arrow, OK David Boggs Carlsbad, CA Neil Gallucci Cedar Rapids, IA Wayne Jerman Chesapeake, VA - Kevin L. Wright Chula Vista, CA - David Bejarano Columbia, MO Kenneth M. Burton 2015 Participating Agencies Coral Springs, FL Tony J. Pustizzi Edmond, OK - Bob A. Ricks Fort Collins, CO John Hutto Fremont, CA Richard Lucerno Garland, TX - Mitch Bates Grand Prairie, TX Steve Dye Henderson, NV Patrick Moers Irving, TX - Larry Boyd Lakewood, CO - Kevin Paletta Lawrence, KS - Tarik Khatib Lincoln, NE Jim Peschong Naperville, IL Robert W. Marshall Norman, OK Keith Humphrey Olathe, KS Steve Menke Overland Park, KS Frank Donchez Peoria, AZ Roy W. Minter Jr. Plano, TX - Gregory W. Rushin Richardson, TX Jim Spivey San Angelo, TX - Tim R. Vasquez Springfield, MO - Paul Williams Section E Traffic Safety 1

2 Benchmark Cities Bellevue, WA Fremont, CA Boise, ID Boulder, CO FT Collins, CO Lincoln, NE Cedar Rapids, IA Overland Park, KS Naperville, IL Chesapeake, VA Lakewood, CO Carlsbad, CA Henderson, NV Edmond, OK Lawrence, KS Olathe, KS Columbia, MO Springfield, MO Norman, OK Broken Arrow, OK Peoria, AZ Irving, TX Plano, TX Chula Vista, CA Grand Prairie, TX Garland, TX Boca Raton, FL San Angelo, TX Richardson, TX Coral Springs, FL Section E Traffic Safety 2

3 Traffic Crashes (Total) per 1,000 Citizens, 2-Year Comparison 2015 Average Traffic Crashes per 1,000 Citizens is 23.1 Section E - Traffic Safety 3

4 Traffic Crashes (Total) per 1,000 Citizens, 5-Year Comparison 2015 Average Traffic Crashes per 1,000 Citizens is 23.1 City Name Population Traffic Crashes Bellevue, WA 135,000 1, Boca Raton, FL 87,552 3, Boise, ID 223,670 3, Boulder, CO 104,810 3, Broken Arrow, OK 107,000 1, Carlsbad, CA 112,299 2, Cedar Rapids, IA 129,195 4, Chesapeake, VA 233,908 2, Chula Vista, CA 257,989 1, Columbia, MO 118,519 5, Coral Springs, FL 124,282 2, Edmond, OK 89,926 1, Fort Collins, CO 158,600 4, Fremont, CA 226,551 1, Garland, TX 234,533 3, Grand Prairie, TX 185,453 3, Henderson, NV 286,273 3, Irving, TX 228,610 3, Lakewood, CO 147,220 4, Lawrence, KS 97,193 2, Lincoln, NE 272,996 8, Naperville, IL 144,108 3, Norman, OK 119,362 2, Olathe, KS 134,308 3, Overland Park, KS 187,730 4, Peoria, AZ 163,839 2, Plano, TX 271,140 5, Richardson, TX 102,430 1, San Angelo, TX 98,975 2, Springfield, MO 165,378 7, Average 164,962 3, Section E - Traffic Safety 4

5 Traffic Crashes (Fatality), 2-Year Comparison 2015 Average Fatality Traffic Crashes per 1,000 Citizens is.047 Section E - Traffic Safety 5

6 Traffic Crashes (Fatality), 5-Year Comparison 2015 Average Fatality Traffic Crashes per 1,000 Citizens is.047 City Name Population Fatality Traffic Crashes Bellevue, WA 135, Boca Raton, FL 87, Boise, ID 223, Boulder, CO 104, Broken Arrow, OK 107, Carlsbad, CA 112, Cedar Rapids, IA 129, Chesapeake, VA 233, Chula Vista, CA 257, Columbia, MO 118, Coral Springs, FL 124, Edmond, OK 89, Fort Collins, CO 158, Fremont, CA 226, Garland, TX 234, Grand Prairie, TX 185, Henderson, NV 286, Irving, TX 228, Lakewood, CO 147, Lawrence, KS 97, Lincoln, NE 272, Naperville, IL 144, Norman, OK 119, Olathe, KS 134, Overland Park, KS 187, Peoria, AZ 163, Plano, TX 271, Richardson, TX 102, San Angelo, TX 98, Springfield, MO 165, Average 164, Section E - Traffic Safety 6

7 Traffic Crashes (Injury) per 1,000 Citizens, 2-Year Comparison 2015 Average Injury Crashes per 1,000 Citizens is 4.8 Section E - Traffic Safety 7

8 City Name A Coalition for Mutual Support Traffic Crashes (Injury) per 1,000 Citizens, 5-Year Comparison 2015 Average Injury Crashes per 1,000 Citizens is 4.8 Population Injury Traffic Crashes Bellevue, WA 135, Boca Raton, FL 87, Boise, ID 223,670 1, Boulder, CO 104, Broken Arrow, OK 107, Carlsbad, CA 112, Cedar Rapids, IA 129, Chesapeake, VA 233,908 1, Chula Vista, CA 257, Columbia, MO 118, Coral Springs, FL 124, Edmond, OK 89, Fort Collins, CO 158, Fremont, CA 226, Garland, TX 234,533 1, Grand Prairie, TX 185, Henderson, NV 286, Irving, TX 228,610 1, Lakewood, CO 147, Lawrence, KS 97, Lincoln, NE 272,996 1, Naperville, IL 144, Norman, OK 119, Olathe, KS 134, Overland Park, KS 187, Peoria, AZ 163, Plano, TX 271,140 1, Richardson, TX 102,430 1, San Angelo, TX 98, Springfield, MO 165,378 1, Average 164, Section E - Traffic Safety 8

9 Traffic Crashes (Non-Injury) per 1,000 Citizens, 2-Year Comparison 2015 Average Non-Injury Crashes per 1,000 Citizens is 18.3 Section E - Traffic Safety 9

10 City Name A Coalition for Mutual Support Traffic Crashes (Non-Injury) per 1,000 Citizens, 5-Year Comparison 2015 Average Non-Injury Crashes per 1,000 Citizens is 18.3 Population Non-Injury Traffic Crashes Bellevue, WA 135,000 1, Boca Raton, FL 87,552 3, Boise, ID 223,670 1, Boulder, CO 104,810 3, Broken Arrow, OK 107,000 1, Carlsbad, CA 112,299 1, Cedar Rapids, IA 129,195 4, Chesapeake, VA 233,908 1, Chula Vista, CA 257, Columbia, MO 118,519 5, Coral Springs, FL 124,282 1, Edmond, OK 89,926 1, Fort Collins, CO 158,600 4, Fremont, CA 226,551 1, Garland, TX 234,533 2, Grand Prairie, TX 185,453 2, Henderson, NV 286,273 2, Irving, TX 228,610 2, Lakewood, CO 147,220 4, Lawrence, KS 97,193 2, Lincoln, NE 272,996 6, Naperville, IL 144,108 2, Norman, OK 119,362 1, Olathe, KS 134,308 2, Overland Park, KS 187,730 3, Peoria, AZ 163,839 1, Plano, TX 271,140 4, Richardson, TX 102, San Angelo, TX 98,975 2, Springfield, MO 165,378 5, Average 164,962 2, Section E - Traffic Safety 10

11 Alcohol Related Fatality Crashes per 1,000 Citizens, 2-Year Comparison 2015 Average Alcohol Related Fatality Crashes per 1,000 Citizens is Section E - Traffic Safety 11

12 Alcohol Related Fatality Crashes per 1,000 Citizens, 5-Year Comparison 2015 Average Alcohol Related Fatality Crashes per 1,000 Citizens is City Name Population Fatality (Alcohol Related) Bellevue, WA 135, Boca Raton, FL 87, Boise, ID 223, Boulder, CO 104, Broken Arrow, OK 107, Carlsbad, CA 112, Cedar Rapids, IA 129, Chesapeake, VA 233, Chula Vista, CA 257, Columbia, MO 118, Coral Springs, FL 124, Edmond, OK 89, Fort Collins, CO 158, Fremont, CA 226, Garland, TX 234, Grand Prairie, TX 185, Henderson, NV 286, Irving, TX 228, Lakewood, CO 147, Lawrence, KS 97, Lincoln, NE 272, Naperville, IL 144, Norman, OK 119, Olathe, KS 134, Overland Park, KS 187, Peoria, AZ 163, Plano, TX 271, Richardson, TX 102, San Angelo, TX 98, Springfield, MO 165, Average 164, Section E - Traffic Safety 12

13 Top Three Causes of Traffic Crashes Top Three Fail to Yield ROW Follow too close Inattention City Name #1 #2 #3 Bellevue, WA Inattention Fail to Yield ROW Speed Boca Raton, FL Careless Driving Fail to Yield ROW Follow too Close Boise, ID Follow too Close Fail to Yield ROW Inattention Boulder, CO Careless Driving Other Contributing Causes Follow too Close Broken Arrow, OK Follow Too Close Inattention Improper Backing Carlsbad, CA Speed Other Contributing Causes DUI Cedar Rapids, IA Inattention Disobey Traffic Control Device Speed Chesapeake, VA Follow too Close Inattention Speed Chula Vista, CA Speed Improper Turn Alcohol Columbia, MO Fail to Yield ROW Inattention Follow too Close Coral Springs, FL Other Contributing Causes Fail to Yield ROW Careless Driving Edmond, OK Inattention Fail to Yield ROW Follow too Close Fort Collins, CO Follow too Close Fail to Yield ROW Careless Driving Fremont, CA Disobey Traffic Control Device Speed Fail to Yield ROW Garland, TX Inattention Speed Fail to Yield ROW Grand Prairie, TX Careless Driving Improper Turn Speed Henderson, NV Fail to yield ROW Follow too close Fail to Maintain Lane Irving, TX Inattention Speed Follow too Close Lakewood, CO Other Contributing Causes Inattention Driver Inexperience Lawrence, KS Inattention Fail to Yield ROW Follow too Close Lincoln, NE Negligent Driving Fail to Yield ROW Follow too Close Naperville, IL Speed Fail to Yield ROW Improper Backing Norman, OK Inattention Fail to Yield ROW Follow too Close Olathe, KS Inattention Fail to Yield ROW Follow too Close Overland Park, KS Follow too Close Inattention Fail to Yield ROW Peoria, AZ Speed Fail to Yield ROW Other Contributing Causes Plano, TX Speed Fail to Yield ROW Improper Lane Change Richardson, TX Speed Fail to Yield ROW Fail to Maintain a Single Lane San Angelo, TX Speed Careless Driving Fail to Yield ROW Springfield, MO Not Tracked Not Tracked Not Tracked Section E - Traffic Safety 13

14 % of Traffic Crashes Resulting in a Citation, 2-Year Comparison 2015 Average % of Traffic Crashes Resulting in a Citation is 56.7% Section E - Traffic Safety 14

15 % of Traffic Crashes Resulting in a Citation, 5-Year Comparison 2015 Average % of Traffic Crashes Resulting in a Citation is 56.7% City Name Traffic Crashes Bellevue, WA 1, % 78.0% 70.0% 70.0% 0.70 Boca Raton, FL 3, % 29.0% 30.7% 23.7% 0.20 Boise, ID 3, % 80.0% 90.0% 88.0% 0.86 Boulder, CO 3, % 89.0% 89.0% 88.0% 0.87 Broken Arrow, OK 1, % 87.5% 85.7% 88.0% 0.73 Carlsbad, CA 2, % Cedar Rapids, IA 4,463 Not Tracked Not Tracked Chesapeake, VA 2, % 17.3% 20.0% 21.2% 0.20 Chula Vista, CA 1,330 Not Tracked Not Tracked Columbia, MO 5,750 Not Tracked Not Tracked 24.0% 19.7% Coral Springs, FL 2, % 25.6% 30.0% 30.5% 0.22 Edmond, OK 1,516 Not Tracked Not Tracked Fort Collins, CO 4, % 74.0% 75.0% 78.0% 0.72 Fremont, CA 1,853 Not Tracked Not Tracked Garland, TX 3, % 16.2% 18.3% 19.9% 0.39 Grand Prairie, TX 3, % 47.3% 44.0% 45.0% 0.45 Henderson, NV 3, % 63.3% 48.1% 48.0% 0.51 Irving, TX 3,553 Not Tracked Not Tracked Lakewood, CO 4, % 74.9% 76.7% 65.7% 0.76 Lawrence, KS 2,873 Not Tracked Not Tracked Lincoln, NE 8, % 85.2% 83.1% 85.6% 0.84 Naperville, IL 3, % 77.0% 76.4% 89.4% 0.89 Norman, OK 2,431 Not Tracked 81.6% 61.0% 59.9% 0.64 Olathe, KS 3, % 65.9% 64.2% 68.8% 0.67 Overland Park, KS 4, % 69.3% 64.8% 67.9% 0.68 Peoria, AZ 2,020 Not Tracked Not Tracked Plano, TX 5, % 27.7% 26.8% 25.1% 0.24 Richardson, TX 1, % 65.8% 52.0% 49.0% 0.51 San Angelo, TX 2, % 15.0% 13.9% 12.4% 0.30 Springfield, MO 7,315 Not Tracked Not Tracked Average 3, % 58.5% 56.0% 54.7% 55.1% Section E - Traffic Safety 15

16 DUI Arrests per 1,000 Citizens, 2-Year Comparison 2015 DUI Arrests/Citations per 1,000 Citizens is 2.8 Section E - Traffic Safety 16

17 City Name Population A Coalition for Mutual Support DUI Arrests per 1,000 Citizens, 5-Year Comparison 2015 DUI Arrests/Citations per 1,000 Citizens is 2.8 DUI Arrests Bellevue, WA 135, Boca Raton, FL 87, Boise, ID 223,670 1, Boulder, CO 104, Broken Arrow, OK 107, Carlsbad, CA 112, Cedar Rapids, IA 129, Chesapeake, VA 233, Chula Vista, CA 257, Columbia, MO 118, Coral Springs, FL 124, Edmond, OK 89, Fort Collins, CO 158, Fremont, CA 226, Garland, TX 234, Grand Prairie, TX 185, Henderson, NV 286, Irving, TX 228, Lakewood, CO 147, Lawrence, KS 97, Lincoln, NE 272,996 1, Naperville, IL 144, Norman, OK 119, Olathe, KS 134, Overland Park, KS 187, Peoria, AZ 163, Plano, TX 271, Richardson, TX 102, San Angelo, TX 98, Springfield, MO 165, Average 164, Section E - Traffic Safety 17

18 Alcohol Arrests per 1,000 Citizens, 2-Year Comparison 2015 Alcohol Arrests/Citations per 1,000 Citizens is 3.6 Section E - Traffic Safety 18

19 City Name A Coalition for Mutual Support Alcohol Arrests per 1,000 Citizens, 5-Year Comparison 2015 Alcohol Arrests/Citations per 1,000 Citizens is 3.6 Population Alcohol Arr Bellevue, WA 135, Boca Raton, FL 87, Boise, ID 223,670 1, Boulder, CO 104,810 1, Broken Arrow, OK 107, Carlsbad, CA 112, Cedar Rapids, IA 129,195 1, Chesapeake, VA 233,908 Not Tracked Not Tracked Chula Vista, CA 257, Columbia, MO 118, Coral Springs, FL 124, Edmond, OK 89, Fort Collins, CO 158, Fremont, CA 226, Garland, TX 234, Grand Prairie, TX 185, Henderson, NV 286, Irving, TX 228, Lakewood, CO 147, Lawrence, KS 97, Lincoln, NE 272,996 1, Naperville, IL 144, Norman, OK 119, Olathe, KS 134, Overland Park, KS 187, Peoria, AZ 163, Plano, TX 271,140 1, Richardson, TX 102, San Angelo, TX 98, Springfield, MO 165, Average 164, Section E - Traffic Safety 19

20 Number of On-Duty Officer-Involved Traffic Crashes, 2-Year Comparison 2015 Average On-Duty Officer-Involved Traffic Crashes is 40 Section E - Traffic Safety 20

21 Number of On-Duty Officer-Involved Traffic Crashes, 5-Year Comparison 2015 Average On-Duty Officer-Involved Traffic Crashes is 40 Assigned Miles City Name Officers Driven Bellevue, WA , Boca Raton, FL 203 2,365, Boise, ID 294 1,679, Boulder, CO , Broken Arrow, OK 135 1,802, Carlsbad, CA 115 1,155,821 5 Cedar Rapids, IA 213 1,599, Chesapeake, VA 391 4,557, Chula Vista, CA , Columbia, MO , Coral Springs, FL 208 1,648, Edmond, OK 123 1,283, Fort Collins, CO 203 1,536, Fremont, CA , Garland, TX 334 2,285, Grand Prairie, TX 259 2,475, Henderson, NV 389 1,462, Irving, TX 346 1,806, Lakewood, CO 261 1,800, Lawrence, KS , Lincoln, NE 323 2,278, Naperville, IL 168 1,183, Norman, OK 179 1,051, Olathe, KS 173 1,458, Overland Park, KS 250 1,550, Peoria, AZ 195 1,449, Plano, TX 364 1,929, Richardson, TX 156 1,347, San Angelo, TX 165 1,123, Springfield, MO 352 1,491, Average 230 1,568, Section E - Traffic Safety 21

22 Average Traffic Crashes per Officer, 2-Year Comparison 2015 Average Traffic Crashes per Officer is 0.17 Section E - Traffic Safety 22

23 City Name A Coalition for Mutual Support Average Traffic Crashes per Officer, 5-Year Comparison 2015 Average Traffic Crashes per Officer is 0.17 Assigned Officers On-Duty Officer Involved Traffic Crashes Bellevue, WA Boca Raton, FL Boise, ID Boulder, CO Broken Arrow, OK Carlsbad, CA Cedar Rapids, IA Chesapeake, VA Chula Vista, CA Columbia, MO Coral Springs, FL Edmond, OK Fort Collins, CO Fremont, CA Garland, TX Grand Prairie, TX Henderson, NV Irving, TX Lakewood, CO Lawrence, KS Lincoln, NE Naperville, IL Norman, OK Olathe, KS Overland Park, KS Peoria, AZ Plano, TX Richardson, TX San Angelo, TX Springfield, MO Average Section E - Traffic Safety 23

24 Percent of Officer At-Fault Traffic Crashes, 2-Year Comparison 2015 Average Officer At-Fault Traffic Crashes is 53.7% Section E - Traffic Safety 24

25 City Name A Coalition for Mutual Support Percent of Officer At-Fault Traffic Crashes, 5-Year Comparison 2015 Average Officer At-Fault Traffic Crashes is 53.7% Officer Involved Traffic Crashes Officer At Fault Traffic Crashes Bellevue, WA % 66.7% 83.3% 76.0% 77.8% Boca Raton, FL % 26.5% 26.0% 26.9% 16.7% Boise, ID % 53.5% 54.2% 63.3% 58.6% Boulder, CO % 54.2% 53.8% 36.4% 84.2% Broken Arrow, OK % 55.9% 30.8% 35.3% 25.0% Carlsbad, CA % Cedar Rapids, IA % 38.5% 52.2% 71.4% 82.4% Chesapeake, VA % 42.5% 46.3% 50.8% 63.0% Chula Vista, CA % 60.9% 28.6% 45.0% 35.7% Columbia, MO % 60.9% 74.1% 75.0% 50.0% Coral Springs, FL % 36.6% 42.1% 47.6% 40.5% Edmond, OK % 41.7% 23.5% 22.2% 57.1% Fort Collins, CO % 42.9% 46.4% 61.1% 4.0% Fremont, CA % 53.8% 75.0% 75.0% 63.3% Garland, TX % 38.7% 39.1% 50.9% 52.1% Grand Prairie, TX % 58.1% 61.7% 56.6% 53.4% Henderson, NV % 62.2% 69.2% 71.4% 65.9% Irving, TX % 60.9% 49.2% 58.7% 56.3% Lakewood, CO % 61.4% 71.4% 58.3% 59.1% Lawrence, KS % 29.2% 90.5% 40.0% 70.6% Lincoln, NE % 63.3% 52.2% 61.8% 51.9% Naperville, IL % 32.0% 43.6% 54.2% 44.0% Norman, OK % 50.0% 56.8% 42.6% 34.7% Olathe, KS % 57.1% 62.5% 56.0% 60.7% Overland Park, KS % 44.2% 40.0% 51.3% 46.5% Peoria, AZ % 63.6% 40.9% 62.5% Plano, TX % 36.1% 52.6% 49.3% 54.1% Richardson, TX % 52.4% 43.3% 58.1% 31.0% San Angelo, TX % 46.0% 32.1% 60.4% 65.9% Springfield, MO % 66.0% 53.7% 56.7% 37.7% Average % 50.2% 51.6% 54.3% 51.5% Section E - Traffic Safety 25

26 Number of Officer At fault Traffic Crashes Per 100,000 Miles Driven, 2-Year Comparison 2015 Average Officer At Fault Traffic Crashes Per 100,000 Miles Driven is 1.3 Section E - Traffic Safety 26

27 Number of Officer At fault Traffic Crashes Per 100,000 Miles Driven, 5-Year Comparison City Name 2015 Average Officer At Fault Traffic Crashes Per 100,000 Miles Driven is 1.3 Miles Driven Officer At Fault Traffic Crashes Bellevue, WA 624, Boca Raton, FL 2,365, Boise, ID 1,679, Boulder, CO 821, Broken Arrow, OK 1,802, Carlsbad, CA 1,155, Cedar Rapids, IA 1,599, Chesapeake, VA 4,557, Chula Vista, CA 881, Columbia, MO 843, Coral Springs, FL 1,648, Edmond, OK 1,283, Fort Collins, CO 1,536, Fremont, CA 750, Garland, TX 2,285, Grand Prairie, TX 2,475, Henderson, NV 1,462, Irving, TX 1,806, Lakewood, CO 1,800, Lawrence, KS 823, Lincoln, NE 2,278, Naperville, IL 1,183, Norman, OK 1,051, Olathe, KS 1,458, Overland Park, KS 1,550, Peoria, AZ 1,449, Plano, TX 1,929, Richardson, TX 1,347, San Angelo, TX 1,123, Springfield, MO 1,491, Average 1,568, Section E - Traffic Safety 27

28 Number of Miles Driven (Patrol Vehicles), 2-Year Comparison 2015 Average Miles on Patrol Vehicles is 1,568,922 Section E - Traffic Safety 28

29 Number of Miles Driven (Patrol Vehicles), 5-Year Comparison 2015 Average Miles on Patrol Vehicles is 1,568,922 City Name Bellevue, WA 624, , , , ,489 Boca Raton, FL 2,365,878 2,494,160 2,430,457 2,619,114 1,530,458 Boise, ID 1,679,277 1,665,132 1,695,998 1,791,048 1,949,734 Boulder, CO 821, , , , ,440 Broken Arrow, OK 1,802,116 1,753,248 1,713,248 1,579,417 1,729,248 Carlsbad, CA 1,155,821 Cedar Rapids, IA 1,599,551 1,070,408 1,231,641 1,651,442 1,473,916 Chesapeake, VA 4,557,647 4,582,271 5,296,063 4,870,504 4,608,753 Chula Vista, CA 881, , , , ,983 Columbia, MO 843, , , , ,261 Coral Springs, FL 1,648,094 1,728,575 1,926,048 2,136,235 2,814,864 Edmond, OK 1,283,369 1,273,783 1,368,448 1,345,408 1,259,913 Fort Collins, CO 1,536,442 1,385,213 1,325,236 1,474,450 1,492,165 Fremont, CA 750, , , , ,138 Garland, TX 2,285,778 2,163,547 2,254,465 2,203,904 2,370,325 Grand Prairie, TX 2,475,623 2,323,893 2,189,632 1,855,161 1,992,856 Henderson, NV 1,462,388 1,402,976 1,513,087 1,832,803 1,969,985 Irving, TX 1,806,654 1,858,263 1,868,243 1,852,000 Lakewood, CO 1,800,000 1,800,000 1,800,000 1,942,983 1,670,000 Lawrence, KS 823, , , , ,709 Lincoln, NE 2,278,661 2,481,230 2,327,964 2,455,302 2,478,197 Naperville, IL 1,183,980 1,073, ,472 1,248,954 1,278,974 Norman, OK 1,051,471 1,347,135 1,428,197 1,474,515 1,395,326 Olathe, KS 1,458,421 1,080,864 1,128,999 1,117,056 1,120,026 Overland Park, KS 1,550,771 1,356,535 1,265,648 1,074,994 1,914,285 Peoria, AZ 1,449,946 1,404,322 1,353,000 1,422,000 Plano, TX 1,929,237 1,933,224 2,141,046 2,012,168 2,001,861 Richardson, TX 1,347,662 1,336,978 1,420,105 1,372,242 1,284,211 San Angelo, TX 1,123,381 1,117,009 1,376,305 1,006,763 1,079,130 Springfield, MO 1,491,317 1,418,677 1,855,814 1,491,906 1,468,900 Average 1,568,922 1,548,978 1,604,211 1,607,317 1,621,413 Section E - Traffic Safety 29

30 Vehicle Replacement Criteria City Name Annual miles driven by Patrol Vehicles Patrol Vehicle Replacement Criteria Bellevue, WA 624, years or 120,000 Boca Raton, FL 2,365,878 Combination of year, mileage and repair cost Boise, ID 1,679,277 5yrs and/or 100,000 miles or if the vehicle cost more than it is worth to maintain. Boulder, CO 821,278 6 years or 100,000 Broken Arrow, OK 1,802,116 0 Carlsbad, CA 1,155, ,000 miles Cedar Rapids, IA 1,599,551 Based on life cycle cost Chesapeake, VA 4,557,647 Combination of mileage, age & repair cost, determined by Fleet Mgmt Chula Vista, CA 881, miles Columbia, MO 843,196 4 years or miles Coral Springs, FL 1,648,094 Vehicle Age 7 years, Maintenance Cost, Mileage Edmond, OK 1,283,369 9 Years or 135,000 miles Fort Collins, CO 1,536, ,000 Fremont, CA 750,000 5 years or 100,000 miles Garland, TX 2,285,778 Currently, Crown Vics are replaced about every three years or 75,000 miles; Caprices and Tahoes are replaced about every four years or 100,000 miles. Grand Prairie, TX 2,475, ,000 miles Henderson, NV 1,462,388 Age, accumulated mileage and hours, and maintenance history determine the optimum disposal point. Irving, TX 1,806, miles Lakewood, CO 1,800, ,000 Lawrence, KS 823,864 Rating Scale (depends on age/ miles/ type of service reliability/ costs for up keep/ condition) Lincoln, NE 2,278,661 80,000/5 years service Naperville, IL 1,183, ,000 Norman, OK 1,051,471 Computer program that considers mileage, age, repair costs Olathe, KS 1,458,421 90,000 miles, 4 years, maintenance records reviewed Overland Park, KS 1,550, ,000 miles Peoria, AZ 1,449,946 Point System = Age+Mileage+Total Repair Costs Over Life of Vehicle Plano, TX 1,929,237 Vehicle replacement is determined by age, mileage, and maintenance issues. Goal is to replace Crown Vics at 90,000 miles and Tahoes at 110,000 miles Richardson, TX 1,347,662 1/3 of fleet replaced annually resulting in a 83,000 mile average. San Angelo, TX 1,123,381 90,000/7 yrs. Springfield, MO 1,491,317 The department currently relies on our City Service Center to evaluate the fleet via a 15 point system based on age/mileage/repair costs, etc. At 15 points the vehicle should be replaced. This typically doesn't happen and is dependent on funding. Section E - Traffic Safety 30

31 Does your agency policy allow issuance of take home cars? City Name Bellevue, WA Boca Raton, FL Boise, ID Boulder, CO Broken Arrow, OK Carlsbad, CA Cedar Rapids, IA Chesapeake, VA Chula Vista, CA Columbia, MO Coral Springs, FL Edmond, OK Fort Collins, CO Fremont, CA Garland, TX Grand Prairie, TX Henderson, NV Irving, TX Lakewood, CO Lawrence, KS Lincoln, NE Naperville, IL Norman, OK Olathe, KS Overland Park, KS Peoria, AZ Plano, TX Richardson, TX San Angelo, TX Springfield, MO Does your agency policy allow issuance of take home cars? No No No Section E - Traffic Safety 31

32 Number of Traffic Citations per 1,000 Citizens, 2-Year Comparison 2015 Average Traffic Citations per 1,000 Citizens is 146 Section E - Traffic Safety 32

33 Number of Traffic Citations per 1,000 Citizens, 5-Year Comparison 2015 Average Traffic Citations per 1,000 Citizens is 146 City Name Population Traffic Citations Bellevue, WA 135,000 11, Boca Raton, FL 87,552 37, Boise, ID 223,670 25, Boulder, CO 104,810 13, Broken Arrow, OK 107,000 16, Carlsbad, CA 112,299 7, Cedar Rapids, IA 129,195 8, Chesapeake, VA 233,908 38, Chula Vista, CA 257,989 13, Columbia, MO 118,519 3, Coral Springs, FL 124,282 23, Edmond, OK 89,926 10, Fort Collins, CO 158,600 17, Fremont, CA 226,551 9, Garland, TX 234,533 43, Grand Prairie, TX 185,453 58, Henderson, NV 286,273 24, Irving, TX 228,610 30, Lakewood, CO 147,220 18, Lawrence, KS 97,193 14, Lincoln, NE 272,996 22, Naperville, IL 144,108 12, Norman, OK 119,362 21, Olathe, KS 134,308 29, Overland Park, KS 187,730 39, Peoria, AZ 163,839 10, Plano, TX 271,140 53, Richardson, TX 102,430 36, San Angelo, TX 98,975 18, Springfield, MO 165,378 22, Average 164,962 23, Section E - Traffic Safety 33

34 Number of Traffic Citations by Type City Name Traffic Citations Non-Moving Violations Note: Alcohol numbers reflect a combination of Citations and/or Arrests. Moving Violations DUI Alcohol Speed Red Light Violations Other Moving Violations Bellevue, WA 11,428 Not Tracked 11, , ,518 Boca Raton, FL 37,127 13,856 23, ,812 3,202 8,912 Boise, ID 25,180 12,136 13,044 1,177 1,534 6, ,850 Boulder, CO 13,106 3,722 9, ,484 2, ,668 Broken Arrow, OK 16,124 8,257 7, , ,937 Carlsbad, CA 7,808 4,330 3, , ,153 Cedar Rapids, IA 8,094 Not Tracked 8, ,068 1, ,321 Chesapeake, VA 38,227 14,025 24, Not Tracked 17, ,005 Chula Vista, CA 13,290 4,848 8, ,162 1,728 2,849 Columbia, MO 3,973 1,604 2, Coral Springs, FL 23,360 12,196 11, ,006 1,773 3,204 Edmond, OK 10,498 2,433 8, , ,986 Fort Collins, CO 17,418 2,383 15, , ,566 Fremont, CA 9,209 3,473 5, ,231 1,397 2,660 Garland, TX 43,488 17,045 26, ,449 3,975 5,711 Grand Prairie, TX 58,246 28,852 29, ,070 8,304 6,293 Henderson, NV 24,399 7,767 16, ,661 1,748 6,475 Irving, TX 30,355 10,148 20, , ,276 Lakewood, CO 18,197 5,336 12, , ,600 Lawrence, KS 14,007 6,191 7, , ,753 Lincoln, NE 22,780 Not Tracked 22,780 1,131 1,291 11,002 1,429 7,927 Naperville, IL 12,534 3,900 8, , ,170 Norman, OK 21,547 8,533 13, , ,206 Olathe, KS 29,218 15,269 13, , ,806 Overland Park, KS 39,922 18,133 21, ,684 1,436 12,778 Peoria, AZ 10,897 Not Tracked 10, , ,976 Plano, TX 53,850 8,543 45, ,017 28,509 1,773 13,173 Richardson, TX 36,310 1,917 34, , ,886 San Angelo, TX 18,288 1,505 16, , ,178 Springfield, MO 22,687 13,783 8, , ,027 Average 23,052 8,853 15, ,305 1,254 5,857 Section E - Traffic Safety 34