FORTH CROSSING BILL CALL FOR EVIDENCE RESPONSE FCB8 SCOTTISH ASSOCIATION FOR PUBLIC TRANSPORT (SAPT)
|
|
- Randell Scott
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 FORTH CROSSING BILL CALL FOR EVIDENCE RESPONSE FCB8 SCOTTISH ASSOCIATION FOR PUBLIC TRANSPORT (SAPT) Assessment of Principles and Fit with Future Budgets Submission to Forth Crossing Bill and Finance Committees of Scottish Parliament by Tom Hart, Vice President, Scottish Association for Public Transport - March 2010 Tom Hart is a former lecturer in the Dept of Economic and Social History at Glasgow University with special interests in modern Scottish and British Economic History and in the role of transport in economies since 1870 He is also a Board Member of Transform Scotland, an appointed member of SPT and a member of the Scottish Government Advisory Committee on Transport and Tourism Statistics. He has published widely on transport, economic and environmental issues including:- Transport Options for a Sustainable Scotland (jointly edited with Nigel Doar, 1999) Transport Chapter in Energy and the Natural Heritage, SNH, 2008 The STPR, the Forth Crossing and Scottish Transport Finance (with John Howison, Project Director, Forth Crossing) in the March 2009 issue of the quarterly Scottish Transport Review 20 th century surface transport chapters in Transport and Communications (in Scotland), Scottish Life and Society series, edited by Kenneth Veitch, December 2009, John Donald/Birlinn Changing Trends in Passenger Movement : Scotland seminar presentation by Tom Hart to Scottish Transport Studies Group, Glasgow University, 20 January 2010 This statement complements the submission already made to the Transport Infrastructure and Climate Change Committee on the Public Transport Corridor proposals in the Forth Crossing Bill. This concluded that, on the evidence of reduced growth in passenger movement and the ability of the existing rail and road bridges to handle higher shares of passenger movement by public transport and in multi-occupant cars, the most cost-effective policy for the next decade would be to improve utilisation of the existing road and rail bridges both to cut levels of congestion and unreliability and to accelerate absolute cuts in carbon emissions and shifts to alternative energy sources. The rest of this submission deals with the overall principles of the Forth Crossing Bill and their fit with tightened budgets more highly geared towards delivery of prime economic, energy and climate change objectives for 2020 and beyond. Principles of Forth Crossing Bill The underlying principle behind the decision to introduce the Bill and have an additional crossing and approach road works open by 2016 is that this is an essential step to improve the overall performance of the Scottish economy and encourage 1
2 further development along the east coast corridor (as identified in the National Planning Framework) from Aberdeen to Edinburgh with extensions west to Glasgow and south to Newcastle. An extra bridge by 2016 is seen as vital to avoid unreliability, uncertainty and congestion relating to the present road bridge, though with the existing road bridge retained for public transport, pedestrians and cyclists. The additional bridge will involve significant carbon costs in construction (and further such costs in maintenance of the new and existing road bridges) and will also involve increased carbon emissions due to the 11% rise in car, lorry and van use expected by Transport Scotland as a result of shorter trip times. The Policy Memorandum (Paras 104/105) accepts that work on emissions is incomplete. In the longer term, improved fuel efficiency and the shift away from carbon-fuelled road transport are expected to bring absolute carbon cuts in line with the Scottish Government s climate change objectives. The Sustainable Appraisal and Carbon Management Report (Transport Scotland, 9 Dec., states (para 4.15) that the increased carbon emissions in the initial years of operation of the new crossing will require to be balanced by carbon cuts elsewhere if the overall carbon cuts sought by the Scottish Government by 2020 are to be delivered. The Policy Memorandum (Paras. 153/156) states that the base Benefit to Cost ratio (compared to continued general purpose use of the existing road bridge) would be low at 1.34 but then argues that taking account of other gains in transport efficiency and Wider Economic Benefits- e.g of agglomeration, better access to markets, competition - the benefit to cost ratio rises to 2.03, still low compared to other schemes. In relation to Opportunity Costs, the Policy Memorandum (Paras. 143/146) states that the Bridge Project will inevitably hit other Scottish capital projects given a total Scottish Capital Budget expected to fall to 2.6bn a year (or less). This can be eased if borrowing is permitted or other ways found to gain extra EU or Treasury funding but the Memorandum goes on to say that there are no present prospects of such funding. It reports the Treasury as in broad agreement with the principle of an additional crossing but with funding being a matter for the Scottish Government. Defects of Economic and Carbon Assessments SAPT considers that the above assessments have very serious defects which, in total, warrant a decision not to endorse the principles of the Bill. Four substantial defects of which the last in respect of opportunity costs is seen as the most serious are drawn to the attention of both the Bill and Finance Committees. 1) An additional bridge by 2016 is vital for the Scottish economy and especially for the east coast. There is no evidence in support of this statement and considerable contrary evidence, including:- traffic levels of motorway and A roads in Scotland (see APPENDIX) are already almost stable whereas growth in rail and bus use continues an expected 50% rise in the real price of oil to $150 a barrel by, or before, 2016 despite a highly suspect Transport Scotland forecast of 44% growth in road vehicular traffic across the Forth between 2005 and 2017, Transport Scotland s forecast of further growth to 2027 falls to 6% (Engineering, Traffic and Economic Assessment 4 Dec., 2009 Para 5.9.3) 2
3 the February 2010 Report by Denvil Coombe, commissioned by DfT, on the Appraisal of Multi-modal Modelling has been very critical of defects in models leading to over-estimation of road traffic growth, under-estimation of public transport growth and inadequate treatment of impacts on carbon reduction targets and of pricing changes and demand management on congestion the vast majority of freight movement to and from the north, and into and out of Scotland, will continue to be on the road and rail corridors south to the Eurocentral distribution zone and to England and English ports via Carlisle (including the A66 link from Penrith to the east coast) and to the ports at Grangemouth and Rosyth (listed for growth in the National Planning Framework) with priority management measures to encourage shifts to public transport and car-sharing and to encourage HGVs to use other routes, the present Forth Road Bridge can have reduced traffic levels and improved reliability at peak periods for around 20% of the capital cost of an additional crossing plus a retained, but lightly used, existing bridge the Forth Crossing proposals have no bearing on the recent decision by Diageo to relocate 400 jobs to Fife (see also opportunity costs at (4) nor on job prospects for Tayside and points north 2) Carbon Costs The present Forth Crossing proposals fail to recognise that better management of the existing Forth road and rail crossings can yield earlier and larger carbon savings, unlike the increases arising from the current proposals. Assessments must give a higher weighting to this advantage, including reduced road vehicle volumes in West Edinburgh, West Lothian and South Fife assisted by shifts to public transport and car-sharing and also offering further carbon savings from reduced congestion. 3) Benefit to Cost Ratios Present ratios are heavily influenced by:- a failure to measure the benefits of an additional managed crossing from a base including better management and utilisation of the existing road and rail crossings and diversionary routes e.g a more direct and free-flow road from Halbeath to Kincardine; fast passenger ferries a high weighting for monetised gains from absolute time-saving compared to a low weighting for carbon savings and for shifts from car use to public transport. Benefits from increased working and residence in the areas north and south of Queensferry (including working from home) need to be assessed as well as gains from agglomeration and longer-distance commuting. There should be evaluation of these factors as key elements in Committee scrutiny of Forth Crossing principles. It is likely that intelligent management of the existing road and rail crossings will give an improved benefit to cost ratio, aided by the substantial savings in capital and carbon costs, less congestion and minimal adverse impacts. Though an extra crossing would have require less maintenance than the present road bridge, the plan to have both bridges remain will raise total maintenance costs. While the new bridge would avoid some delays due to wind conditions, shielding around the existing bridge towers could cut delays and the rail bridge is largely unaffected by wind. 3
4 If cable renewal is essential in the next six years, adverse impacts would be higher due to some periods of lane closure but the total adverse impact would be small relative to capital savings. Impacts can be mitigated by acceleration of the rail and bus improvements and car- sharing which, in any case, require action in the coming six years. If the HGV load on the present bridge is eased, cable renewal could be deferred ten years and potentially, for several decades. 4) Opportunity Cost The most serious defect in the Bridge Crossing Policy Memorandum is the inadequate treatment of opportunity costs. Early action on an additional bridge can only be justified if, in relation to policy aims, such action gives better outcomes for employment and the economy than alternative public spending options. The key aims of the Scottish Government in the present decade are to promote sustainable growth and cyclical revival though faster action on measures to promote energy efficiency and conservation and shifts to non-fossil fuels (plus carbon capture and storage) which also offer significant employment opportunities. Priority action must focus on budget restructure and regulatory/fiscal efforts to increase necessary investment and employment. This embraces measures giving quick wins for carbon cuts, reduced congestion and accelerated traffic management, modal shift and electrification in the transport sector. It is significant that both the Auditor-General for Scotland and the Council of Economic Advisers have expressed reservations about the fit with overall economic and policy strategy of the Forth Crossing proposals as presently financed. On the available evidence, an extra Forth Crossing needing a further 2bn of spending by 2016 within reduced overall funding comes nowhere near meeting key criteria. Priority for this project will lead to steeper cuts in projects and programmes better aligned to economic, energy and climate change objectives plus added benefits for jobs and social priorities. In February 2009, John Swinney as Cabinet Secretary for Finance and Sustainable Growth, indicated that the Forth Crossing would absorb between 330m and 465m in each year to 2016 from a falling total of capital funding. Under the Public Spending Review after the General Election, the overall annual capital budget of the Scottish Government could fall as low as 2bn per year (exclusive of gains from new sources of income and/or cuts in revenue spend). This indicates the scale of the opportunity costs involved and requires explicit assessment in relation to the principles of the Bill and optimum strategies for public finance to Conclusions and Recommendations The economic and carbon assessments in the Policy Memorandum and related Transport Scotland website information are fundamentally flawed. They fail to establish the case for an additional Forth Crossing as the largest single project in Scotland in a period of tighter limits on public spending and increasing pressure for cuts in carbon emissions and faster progress on employment-boosting energy efficiency and shifts to alternative fuel s, public transport and car-sharing. The principle of an additional Forth Crossing by 2016 should be rejected in favour of specific measures to ensure carbon cuts and better use of the existing rail and road bridges. Observation of the results of such measures by 2017 should be used to re-examine longer-term plans for the Forth Crossing, including options for borrowing and reforms in fares and road pricing policies. SAPT accepts that, at some future date, it may be 4
5 possible to establish a sound case for an additional crossing possibly to the immediate west of an expanding port at Rosyth but no such case has been established in the evidence on the current Bill. 2 March
6 APPENDIX Road and Car Traffic Statistics (million vehicle Kms) Rail Comparisons Scottish M way & A Roads All traffic 28,209 28,055 28,898 28,986 28,810 Cars 22,308 22,060 22,610 22,392 22,221 STS No 28 p 124 M90 at Kelty (average daily flows for all traffic thousand vehicles) 29,565 30,703 26,511 30,787 STS No 28 p 130 Transport Scotland data on actual and expected road vehicle crossings on Queensferry Road Bridges in 2005 and 2017 (thousand vehicles per day) (no extra bridge) (on new bridge) (on present bridge) 66 no data SAPT Vehicle estimates Total passengers (see SAPT evidence to Transport Committee) (including by rail and ferry) Rail Passenger kms in Scotland outwith SPT area (millions) , % STS No p 152 Total pass kms in Scotland continued upwards from 2,224m in to 2,601m in i.e. +18% with rate of growth being higher in the east of Scotland STS No 28 p 158 Examples of yearly passenger usage of Forth area rail stations (thousands) Dundee 1,438 1,515 1,490 1,600 Kirkcaldy ,072 1,126 1,152 Inverkeithing ,032 Dunfermline Town South Gyle Leuchars Dalmeny Dunfermline Queen Margaret Dalgety Bay Annual data in STS on 100 top stations and usage of new stations more detail available from ORR Estimated usage of Gogar Rail/Tram/Bus Interchange in first full year is 750 thousand Peak Daily Rail Passenger Volumes south of Inverkeithing (7 to 9 am working days) March 2006 April 2009 March ,247 3,592 forecast requested but not yet available Peak Daily Bus Passenger Volumes south of Ferrytoll Park and Ride ( am working days) April 2006 April 2009 April ,285 Data and forecasts requested but not yet available Source: Fife Council Local Plan p plus updated rail data for
WRITTEN EVIDENCE FROM SCOTTISH ASSOCIATION FOR PASSENGER TRANSPORT
WRITTEN EVIDENCE FROM SCOTTISH ASSOCIATION FOR PASSENGER TRANSPORT Forth Crossing Public Transport Corridor: Introductory Notes The Scottish Association for Public Transport (SAPT) is concerned that the
More informationTourism Development Plan for Scotland Questionnaire
Draft National Tourism Development Plan Public Consultation 2013 Tourism Development Plan for Scotland Questionnaire We would like your views on this Plan and, in particular, your comments on opportunities
More informationConsultation on Draft Airports National Policy Statement: new runway capacity and infrastructure at airports in the South East of England
Tony Kershaw Honorary Secretary County Hall Chichester West Sussex PO19 1RQ Telephone 033022 22543 Website: www.gatcom.org.uk If calling ask for Mrs. Paula Street e-mail: secretary@gatcom.org.uk 22 May
More informationWRITTEN SUBMISSION FROM RMT 17 OCTOBER 2008
WRITTEN SUBMISSION FROM RMT 17 OCTOBER 2008 The National Union of Rail, Maritime and Transport Workers (RMT) welcomes the opportunity to respond to the Scottish Parliament, Transport Infrastructure and
More informationAugust Briefing. Why airport expansion is bad for regional economies
August 2005 Briefing Why airport expansion is bad for regional economies 1 Summary The UK runs a massive economic deficit from air travel. Foreign visitors arriving by air spent nearly 11 billion in the
More informationGo First Go Far Go Forth Queensferry One
Go First Go Far Go Forth Queensferry One queensferryone.com A new, international waterside destination. queensferryone.com Edinburgh Forth Rail Bridge Forth Bridge Queensferry Crossing South Queensferry
More informationRail Update Station Usage Statistics and Network Rail Performance
Rail Update Station Usage Statistics and Network Rail Performance Committee Operations Date of meeting 26 January 2018 Date of report 21 December 2017 Report by Senior Director 1. Object of report To update
More informationEAST WEST RAIL EASTERN SECTION. prospectus for growth
EAST WEST RAIL EASTERN SECTION prospectus for growth September 2018 executive summary The East West Rail Consortium, a partnership of local authorities, rail operators and Network Rail, continues to promote
More informationPOLICY SUBMISSION NETWORK RAIL SCOTLAND RAIL ROUTE UTILISATION STRATEGY. January
POLICY SUBMISSION NETWORK RAIL SCOTLAND RAIL ROUTE UTILISATION STRATEGY January 2011 www.scdi.org.uk SCDI is an independent and inclusive economic development network which seeks to influence and inspire
More informationPerformance Criteria for Assessing Airport Expansion Alternatives for the London Region
Performance Criteria for Assessing Airport Expansion Alternatives for the London Region Jagoda Egeland International Transport Forum at the OECD TRB Annual Meeting 836 - Measuring Aviation System Performance:
More informationHSR the creation of a mega-project
HSR the creation of a mega-project Jim Steer Director Greengauge 21 Omega Centre May 2009 2oth May 2009 omega centre: transport mega-projects 1 Outline Motivations The formative history on HSR: how a mega-project
More informationWELLINGTON $422 MILLION $614 MILLION $83 MILLION 22% SPEND $1.9 BILLION
WELLINGTON WELLINGTON $1.9 BILLION FORECAST TOTAL WELLINGTON INVESTMENT The Wellington region s transport challenges are dominated by the region s concentration of population in the metropolitan cities,
More informationAgenda Item 5: Rail East Midlands Rail Franchise Consultation
Strategic Transport Forum 15 th September 2017 Agenda Item 5: Rail East Midlands Rail Franchise Consultation Recommendation: It is recommended that the Forum agree (subject to any amendments agreed by
More informationThe Government s Aviation Strategy Transport for the North (TfN) response
The Government s Aviation Strategy Transport for the North (TfN) response Transport for the North Background Good transport links are a crucial part of a strong economy supporting labour markets and delivering
More informationWales. Andy Thomas. Route Managing Director Wales. Ken Skates, Cabinet Secretary for Economy and Infrastructure, Welsh Government
Wales The railway in Wales and Borders plays a critical role in connecting people, businesses and communities to support both regional and national economic growth. We run the safest railway in Europe,
More informationSubmission by Heathrow Southern Railway Ltd.
Response to Consultation on core elements of the regulatory framework to support capacity expansion at Heathrow Submission by Heathrow Southern Railway Ltd. 22 nd September 2017 Contact; Steven Costello,
More informationCBD Rail Link Business Case
CBD Rail Link Business Case Executive Summary: CBD Link Business Case (Nov 2010) Background The CBD Rail Link will be the most significant improvement to Auckland s transport network since the opening
More informationScotland to England Journeys (million)
Introduction WRITTEN SUBMISSION FROM THE SCOTTISH CHAMBERS OF COMMERCE 17 OCTOBER 2008 SCC welcomes the chance to respond to the committee s inquiry into this important matter. There is high and growing
More informationThe Edinburgh Glasgow Improvement Programme. Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA) Consultation Document. October 2013
The Edinburgh Glasgow Improvement Programme Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA) Consultation Document October 2013 Transport Scotland Rail Directorate Table of Contents 1.0 Introduction 2.0 The Edinburgh
More informationREAUTHORISATION OF THE ALLIANCE BETWEEN AIR NEW ZEALAND AND CATHAY PACIFIC
Chair Cabinet Economic Growth and Infrastructure Committee Office of the Minister of Transport REAUTHORISATION OF THE ALLIANCE BETWEEN AIR NEW ZEALAND AND CATHAY PACIFIC Proposal 1. I propose that the
More informationWokingham Borough Council Response to the Consultation on the Draft Airports National Policy Statement
Wokingham Borough Council Response to the Consultation on the Draft Airports National Policy Statement The consultation Draft Airports National Policy Statement (Draft NPS) sets out Government s policy
More informationEast West Rail Consortium
East West Rail Consortium EWR Wider Economic Case: Refresh 18 th November 2015 Rupert Dyer Rail Expertise Ltd Rail Expertise Ltd. Tel: 01543 493533 Email: info@railexpertise.co.uk 1 Introduction 1.1 The
More informationViews of London Forum of Amenity and Civic Societies to the House of Commons Environmental Audit Committee on the Airports Commission report
Views of London Forum of Amenity and Civic Societies to the House of Commons Environmental Audit Committee on the Airports Commission report Summary i) We strongly recommend that the Government reject
More informationEast Lancashire Highways and Transport Masterplan East Lancashire Rail Connectivity Study Conditional Output Statement (Appendix 'A' refers)
Report to the Cabinet Member for Highways and Transport Report submitted by: Director of Corporate Commissioning Date: 1 June 2015 Part I Electoral Divisions affected: All East Lancashire Highways and
More informationAppendix 12. HS2/HS1 Connection. Prepared by Christopher Stokes
Appendix 12 HS2/HS1 Connection Prepared by Christopher Stokes 12 HS2/HS1 CONNECTION Prepared by Christopher Stokes Introduction 12.1 This appendix examines the business case for through services to HS1,
More informationAgenda 11. Strathclyde Bus Alliance progress update. Date of meeting 9 December 2016 Date of report 15 November 2016
Agenda 11 Strathclyde Bus Alliance progress update Date of meeting 9 December 2016 Date of report 15 November 2016 Report by Assistant Chief Executive (Operations) 1. Object of report The object of this
More informationAirdrie - Bathgate Railway and Linked Improvements Bill. Environmental Statement Page 1
Environmental Statement Page 1 1.0 INTRODUCTION 1.1 The Scheme Proposal The scheme proposals are to re-open the Airdrie to Bathgate section of the former Bathgate and Coatbridge Railway (Monklands Railway)
More informationALL ABOARD LABOR S LONG TERM PASSENGER TRANSPORT STRATEGY
ALL ABOARD LABOR S LONG TERM PASSENGER TRANSPORT STRATEGY Revitalising Passenger Transport Increasing traffic congestion in our cities and a lack of transport services in our regional towns is frustrating
More information.org.uk. Regional. Transport. Strategy. Revised June Serving Dumfries and Galloway. South West of Scotland Transport Partnership
South West of Scotland Transport Partnership.org.uk Regional Transport Strategy Revised June 2008 Serving Dumfries and Galloway South West of Scotland Transport Partnership.org.uk SOUTH WEST OF SCOTLAND
More informationChapter 12. HS2/HS1 Connection. Prepared by Christopher Stokes
Chapter 12 HS2/HS1 Connection Prepared by Christopher Stokes 12 HS2/HS1 CONNECTION Prepared by Christopher Stokes 12.1 This chapter relates to the following questions listed by the Committee: 3.1 Business
More informationTAYplan SDPA. Main Issues Report. Options for Scotland s s SusTAYnable Region (Strategic Development Planning Authority)
TAYplan SDPA (Strategic Development Planning Authority) Main Issues Report Options for Scotland s s SusTAYnable Region 2012-2032 2032 Content 1. The Development Plan System in Scotland 2. TAYplan in Context
More information3 The growth of Western Sydney
3 The growth of Western Sydney About this chapter This chapter provides an overview of Western Sydney s growing population and economy, and the benefit of the proposed Western Sydney Airport. Population
More informationTHE CARICOM REGIONAL IMPLEMENTATION PLAN
THE CARICOM REGIONAL IMPLEMENTATION PLAN Presented at the First Regional Workshop on Ensemble Climate Modeling August 20-29, 2012 University of the West Indies, Mona, Jamaica By Joseph McGann, Programme
More informationM6 CORRIDOR. Strategic Infrastructure Prospectus
CORRIDOR Strategic Infrastructure Prospectus May 2017 IntRODuCtIOn cumbria has real potential. We have a strong economy with major capability in energy, advanced manufacturing, logistics, agri-food and
More informationTfL Planning. 1. Question 1
TfL Planning TfL response to questions from Zac Goldsmith MP, Chair of the All Party Parliamentary Group on Heathrow and the Wider Economy Heathrow airport expansion proposal - surface access February
More informationScottish Parliament Devolution (Further Powers) Committee
Scottish Parliament Devolution (Further Powers) Committee 6 th March 2015 Our Vision is that by 2020, Scotland is a destination of 1 st choice for a high quality, value for money and memorable customer
More informationChapter 11. Links to Heathrow. Prepared by Christopher Stokes
Chapter 11 Links to Heathrow Prepared by Christopher Stokes 11 LINKS TO HEATHROW Prepared by Christopher Stokes 11.1 This submission relates to the following questions listed by the Committee: 2.3 Implications
More informationAn Introduction to HS2
July 16 1 Overview HS2 is a vital part of the Government s long term economic plan, strongly supported by midland, northern English and Scottish cities. HS2 will not be a separate, standalone railway.
More informationGold Coast. Rapid Transit. Chapter twelve Social impact. Chapter content
Gold Coast Rapid Transit Chapter twelve Social impact Chapter content Social impact assessment process...235 Existing community profile...237 Consultation...238 Social impacts and mitigation strategies...239
More informationSummary Delivery Plan Control Period 4 Delivery Plan More trains, more seats. Better journeys
Summary Delivery Plan Control Period 4 Delivery Plan 2009 More trains, more seats Better journeys Network Rail aims to deliver a railway fit for the 21st century. Over the next five years (Control Period
More informationStrategic Transport Forum 21 st September 2018
Strategic Transport Forum 21 st September 2018 Agenda Item 4: Heathrow Airport Expansion: Surface Access Strategy Update Recommendation: It is recommended that the Forum consider the update provided by
More informationCOMMISSION OF THE EUROPEAN COMMUNITIES COMMUNICATION FROM THE COMMISSION. Developing an EU civil aviation policy towards Brazil
COMMISSION OF THE EUROPEAN COMMUNITIES Brussels, 5.5.2010 COM(2010)210 final COMMUNICATION FROM THE COMMISSION Developing an EU civil aviation policy towards Brazil COMMUNICATION FROM THE COMMISSION Developing
More informationScotland s railways - today
Cynulliad Cenedlaethol Cymru National Assembly for Wales Y Pwyllgor Menter a Busnes Enterprise and Business Committee Ymchwiliad i r Blaenoriaethau ar gyfer Inquiry into the Priorities for the future dyfodol
More informationCAA consultation on its Environmental Programme
CAA consultation on its Environmental Programme Response from the Aviation Environment Federation 15.4.14 The Aviation Environment Federation (AEF) is the principal UK NGO concerned exclusively with the
More informationCHRISTCHURCH MOTORWAYS. Project Summary Statement February 2010
CHRISTCHURCH MOTORWAYS Project Summary Statement February 2010 Table of Contents 1. Purpose of Document 2. Strategic Context 3. Benefits 4. Project Scope and Economics 5. Implementation Plan 1 ROADS OF
More informationUpdate on the Thameslink programme
A picture of the National Audit Office logo Report by the Comptroller and Auditor General Department for Transport Update on the Thameslink programme HC 413 SESSION 2017 2019 23 NOVEMBER 2017 4 Key facts
More informationFEDERAL BUDGET PRIORITIES FOR THE SOUTH WEST METROPOLITAN REGION 2018 TO 2022
A Co-operative venture of the municipalities of: Cockburn, East Fremantle, Fremantle, Kwinana, Melville & Rockingham Tuesday, 5 December 2017 Enquiries: Mick McCarthy 9364 0631 Our Ref: Federal Budget
More informationPERTH AND KINROSS COUNCIL. Enterprise and Infrastructure Committee 4 November 2009
PERTH AND KINROSS COUNCIL 4 09/494 Enterprise and Infrastructure Committee 4 November 2009 STRATEGIC PRIORITIES FOR TOURISM AND AREA TOURISM PARTNERSHIP ARRANGEMENTS Report by Depute Director (Environment)
More informationAbout ABTA. Executive summary
ABTA response to the Department for Transport Draft Airports National Policy Statement new runway capacity and infrastructure at airports in the South East of England About ABTA ABTA The Travel Association
More informationScottish Fire and Rescue Service a journey of change From an Asset Management Perspective
Scottish Fire and Rescue Service a journey of change From an Asset Management Perspective Iain Morris: Head of Asset Management Scott Roberts: Scottish Fleet Manager APSE, Seminar Aviemore 8 May 2014 The
More informationMajor Scheme Business Case Summary Report for Programme Entry
Paper A Heart of South West Local Transport Board Major Scheme Business Case Summary Report for Programme Entry M5 Junction 25, Taunton July 2016 1 SCHEME SUMMARY Scheme Name M5 Junction 25, Taunton Date
More informationNewcastle Transport Program Newcastle Light Rail Determination Report
Newcastle Transport Program Newcastle Light Rail Determination Report Date Author 25 July 2016 TfNSW Ref 5276649 Status Final TfNSW 2014 UNCONTROLLED WHEN PRINTED Page 1 of 19 Table of contents 1 Introduction
More informationItem 1. Leadership Board. On: 1 April Report by: Director of Development and Housing Services. Heading: Update on City Deal. 1.
Item 1 To: Leadership Board On: 1 April 2015 Report by: Director of Development and Housing Services Heading: Update on City Deal 1. Summary 1.1 This report seeks to update the Board on the work that has
More informationReport of the Strategic Director of Place to the meeting of Executive to be held on 11 September 2018
Report of the Strategic Director of Place to the meeting of Executive to be held on 11 September 2018 Subject: M Arrangements for the establishment of a West Yorkshire Urban Traffic Management Control
More informationSUMMARY PROOF OF EVIDENCE. Gerald Kells Transport Policy and Campaigns Advisor
Highways Inquiry Procedure Rules 1994 Doc Ref: OBJ/0125 2 For a local inquiry into: SUMMARY PROOF OF EVIDENCE Gerald Kells Transport Policy and Campaigns Advisor For Friends of the Earth Cymru / Cyfeillion
More informationCalderdale MBC. Wards Affected: Town. Economy and Investment Panel: 20 October Halifax Station Gateway Masterplan
Calderdale MBC Wards Affected: Town Economy and Investment Panel: 20 October 2016 Halifax Station Gateway Masterplan Report of the Acting Director, Economy and Environment 1. Purpose of the Report 1.1
More informationSUBMISSION FROM RENFREWSHIRE COUNCIL
SUBMISSION FROM RENFREWSHIRE COUNCIL What does regeneration mean in your area? 1. Renfrewshire takes a broad view of regeneration activity. It firmly embedded in our strategic documents, such as the Single
More informationLocate in Falkirk. A guide for retail businesses
Locate in Falkirk A guide for retail businesses Contents Introduction to Falkirk and the surrounding area Introduction to Falkirk and the surrounding area...3 Key Economic Growth Priorities...4 Transport
More informationCITY OF MELBOURNE 10 Year Financial Plan People s Panel Report. 8 November 2014
CITY OF MELBOURNE 10 Year Financial Plan People s Panel Report 8 November 2014 The Panel s Decision Making Principles 1. SMART (Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Realistic, Timely) 2. Sustainable 3. Forward
More informationTHAMES GATEWAY BRIDGE INQUIRY ENDS
Media Briefing May 2006 THAMES GATEWAY BRIDGE INQUIRY ENDS The public inquiry into controversial plans by Transport for London (TfL), to build a 6-lane road bridge across the Thames between east and south
More informationThe Challenges for the European Tourism Sustainable
The Challenges for the European Tourism Sustainable Denada Olli Lecturer at Fan S. Noli University, Faculty of Economy, Department of Marketing, Branch Korça, Albania. Doi:10.5901/mjss.2013.v4n9p464 Abstract
More informationWest Midlands Sustainable Urban
West Midlands Sustainable Urban Transport Strategy and its Delivery: Movement for Growth Liveable City Conference Transport and Connectivity Seminar - 30/11/2017 Adam Harrison, Strategy & Intelligence
More informationOur ref: FRC/REC/Nov Steve Farrell Clerk to the Rural Economy and Connectivity Committee The Scottish Parliament.
Major Transport Infrastructure Projects Forth Replacement Crossing Principal Contract Project Office King Malcolm Drive, Rosyth KY11 2DY Steve Farrell Clerk to the Rural Economy and Connectivity Committee
More informationHigh-Speed Rail Inquiry
High-Speed Rail Inquiry Evidence from HACAN HACAN is the well-established organisation which represents residents under the Heathrow flight paths. www.hacan.org.uk There is evidence that high-speed rail
More informationMay 2011 to April 2012.
Annual Performance 2011-2012 KEY FACTS 2011/12 38 million passenger journeys were made on Stagecoach in Fife, Stagecoach in Perth and Stagecoach Strathtay services 27.1 million miles operated across Fife,
More informationFirstGroup plc TransPennine Express
FirstGroup plc TransPennine Express Rail franchise award Wednesday 9 December 2015 TransPennine Express awarded to FirstGroup FirstGroup is delighted to be selected by the Department for Transport (DfT)
More informationSOUTH CAMBRIDGESHIRE DISTRICT COUNCIL. Executive Director / Senior Planning Policy Officer
SOUTH CAMBRIDGESHIRE DISTRICT COUNCIL REPORT TO: Leader and Cabinet 8 May 2008 AUTHOR/S: Executive Director / Senior Planning Policy Officer SOUTH CAMBRIDGESHIRE DISTRICT COUNCIL S RESPONSE TO UTTLESFORD
More informationStrategic Transport Forum
Strategic Transport Forum Friday 16 th March 2018 www.englandseconomicheartland.com Item 3: Innovation www.englandseconomicheartland.com Innovation work stream - EEH 1. Policy modelling 2. MaaS 3. EEH
More informationPERTH AND KINROSS COUNCIL. Housing and Health Committee. 25 May Perth and Kinross Local Housing Strategy
PERTH AND KINROSS COUNCIL 7 16/234 Housing and Health Committee 25 May 2016 Perth and Kinross Local Housing Strategy 2016-2021 Report by Director (Housing and Social Work) PURPOSE OF REPORT This report
More informationPark and Ride Update. Committee. Strategy and Programmes. Date of meeting 29 November 2013 Date of report 6 November 2013
Park and Ride Update Committee Strategy and Programmes Date of meeting 29 November 2013 Date of report 6 November 2013 Report by Assistant Chief Executive (Operations) 1. Object of report To update the
More informationPERTH-ADELAIDE CORRIDOR STRATEGY
INTRODUCTION The Royal Automobile Association of SA Inc (RAA), the State s principal advocate for motorists on a broad range of motoring-related issues, represents the views of more than 560,000 South
More informationNSW PRE-BUDGET STATEMENT FUTURE ECONOMY FUTURE JOBS
2017-18 NSW PRE-BUDGET STATEMENT FUTURE ECONOMY FUTURE JOBS Executive Summary The 2017-18 NSW State Budget presents an opportunity for the NSW Government to future-proof the tourism and transport sectors.
More informationThe case for rail devolution in London. Submission to the London Assembly Transport Committee. June Response.
Response The case for rail devolution in London Submission to the London Assembly Transport Committee Pedro Abrantes Senior Economist pteg Support Unit Wellington House 40-50 Wellington Street Leeds LS1
More informationPolicy Transport. Policy highlights. Our plan
Policy 2017 Our plan Policy highlights National is committed to building the world-class infrastructure to ensure New Zealand continues to grow. Record investment in transport Delivering the Roads of National
More informationReport to: Greater Cambridge Partnership Joint Assembly 18 January A10 Foxton level crossing bypass and travel hub
Report to: Greater Cambridge Partnership Joint Assembly 18 January 2018 Lead officer: Chris Tunstall GCP Director of Transport A10 Foxton level crossing bypass and travel hub 1. Purpose 1.1 The list of
More informationGuildford Borough Transport Strategy 2017, Topic Paper: Transport, June 2017 (accompanying Local Plan 2017) Local Plan Transport Strategy 2017
Guildford Society Transport Group Position Paper August 2017 Based on submissions in response to the June/July 2017 Local Plan consultation including material presented to Drop-in Session 15 July 2017.
More informationProspect ATCOs Branch & ATSS Branch response to CAP Terminal Air Navigation Services (TANS) contestability in the UK: Call for evidence
Prospect ATCOs Branch & ATSS Branch response to CAP 1605 Terminal Air Navigation Services (TANS) contestability in the UK: Call for evidence Introduction This document sets out the views of Prospect s
More informationCHALLENGES IN DELIVERING SAFER ROADS IN ENGLISH LOCAL AUTHORITIES
CHALLENGES IN DELIVERING SAFER ROADS IN ENGLISH LOCAL AUTHORITIES Tony Ciaburro Corporate Director for Place Commissioning Northamptonshire County Council CHANGING LOCAL GOVERNMENT LANDSCAPE COMBINED AUTHORITIES
More informationCAUTHE 2008 Conference Where the Bloody Hell are we?
CLIMATE CHANGE POLICIES AND AUSTRALIAN TOURISM: A SCOPING STUDY OF THE ECONOMIC ASPECTS ABSTRACT Ray Spurr STCRC Senior Research Fellow School of Marketing University of New South Wales Sydney NSW 2052
More informationA TRANSPORT SYSTEM CONNECTING PEOPLE TO PLACES
THE MAYOR'S VISION FOR TRANSPORT A TRANSPORT SYSTEM CONNECTING PEOPLE TO PLACES VISION We will build a transport system that works for everyone, connecting people to the places they want to go within the
More informationNational Infrastructure Assessment Technical Annex. Technical annex: Tidal power
Technical annex: Tidal power July 2018 1 Tidal Power The Commission has considered the case for tidal lagoons alongside the full range of other options for meeting the UK s energy needs. Recent history
More informationSarah Olney s submission to the Heathrow Expansion Draft Airports National Policy Statement
Sarah Olney s submission to the Heathrow Expansion Draft Airports National Policy Statement https://www.gov.uk/government/consultations/heathrow-expansion-draftairports-national-policy-statement Question
More informationAlternative Funding Models for Affordable Housing: Lessons from Scotland. Kenneth Gibb
Alternative Funding Models for Affordable Housing: Lessons from Scotland Kenneth Gibb Overview Background and Context-setting The Baseline Models New Approaches for 2011 The Longer Term Agenda A Critical
More informationREPORT ON CHARGING FOR CAR PARKING AND THE IMPLEMENTATION OF CEL1 (2008) WITHIN NHS LOTHIAN
NHS Lothian John Jack Director of Facilities 5th June 2008 REPORT ON CHARGING FOR CAR PARKING AND THE IMPLEMENTATION OF CEL1 (2008) WITHIN NHS LOTHIAN 1 Purpose of the Report 1.1 The purpose of this report
More informationAgenda item no 7. Strathclyde Bus Alliance - Proposal. Committee. Strategy and Programmes. Date of meeting 20 May 2016 Date of report 25 April 2016
Agenda item no 7 Strathclyde Bus Alliance - Proposal Committee Strategy and Programmes Date of meeting 20 May 2016 Date of report 25 April 2016 Report by Assistant Chief Executive (Operations) 1. Object
More information5 Rail demand in Western Sydney
5 Rail demand in Western Sydney About this chapter To better understand where new or enhanced rail services are needed, this chapter presents an overview of the existing and future demand on the rail network
More informationStrategic Cross Border Planning in the West Midlands
Strategic Cross Border Planning in the West Midlands RTPI Planners, Birmingham 21/02/2018 Adam Harrison, TfWM Transport Governance and WMCA Renaissance: Why the West Midlands? Transforming our place? Challenges
More informationThe Strategic Commercial and Procurement Manager
Item 3 To: Procurement Sub Committee On: 8 June 2016 Report by: The Strategic Commercial and Procurement Manager Heading: Renfrewshire Council s Community Benefit Strategy 2016 1. Summary 1.1. The purpose
More informationSTAG - Part 1 Appraisal Summary Table
Proposal Details Proposal Name: Option 1 - Do-minimum Proposal Description: This assumes that the Council only carry out the statutory requirements under the Roads (Scotland) Act 1984. This would include
More informationFUTURE AIRSPACE CHANGE
HEATHROW EXPANSION FUTURE AIRSPACE CHANGE UPDATE SEPTEMBER 2018 On 25 June 2018, Parliament formally backed Heathrow expansion, with MPs voting in support of the Government s Airports National Policy Statement
More informationSouth of England north-south connectivity
South of England north-south connectivity An outline economic case for the inclusion of north-south connectivity improvements to form part of the government s road investment strategy (RIS2) Weston-super-Mare
More informationThere was consensus among the participants that a strong European aviation industry is critical to ensure the right to
Bruges Declaration Introduction The European aviation industry stands at a crossroads. It is restructuring to face the economic crisis and the growing global competition. The aviation industry is also
More informationProduced by: Destination Research Sergi Jarques, Director
Produced by: Destination Research Sergi Jarques, Director Economic Impact of Tourism Epping Forest - 2014 Economic Impact of Tourism Headline Figures Epping Forest - 2014 Total number of trips (day & staying)
More informationeasyjet response to CAA Q6 Gatwick final proposals
easyjet response to CAA Q6 Gatwick final proposals Summary easyjet does not support the proposals set out by the CAA, as they are not in the interests of our passengers. The proposals will unreasonably
More informationTourism Development Framework for Scotland. Executive Summary- Development Framework to 2020 for the Visitor Economy (Refresh 2016)
Tourism Development Framework for Scotland Executive Summary- Development Framework to 2020 for the Visitor Economy (Refresh 2016) Introduction The Tourism Development Framework for Scotland refresh 2016:
More information2. Our response follows the structure of the consultation document and covers the following issues in turn:
Virgin Atlantic Airways response to the CAA s consultation on Economic regulation of capacity expansion at Heathrow: policy update and consultation (CAP 1658) Introduction 1. Virgin Atlantic Airways (VAA)
More informationEconomic Development Sub- Committee
Report title: Economic Development Sub- Committee Item No. Date of meeting: 24 November 2016 A47 Road Investment Strategy - update Responsible Chief Tom McCabe Executive Director, Community Officer: and
More informationPERTH AND KINROSS COUNCIL. 22 June 2016 DEVELOPING THE CULTURAL OFFER IN PERTH AND KINROSS UPDATE AND NEXT STEPS
PERTH AND KINROSS COUNCIL 8 16/278 22 June 2016 DEVELOPING THE CULTURAL OFFER IN PERTH AND KINROSS UPDATE AND NEXT STEPS Report by Senior Depute Chief Executive (Equality, Community Planning & Public Service
More informationWaverley Railway (Scotland) Bill. Scottish Borders Council ( Promoter ) WAVERLEY RAILWAY
Waverley Railway (Scotland) Bill Scottish Borders Council ( Promoter ) WAVERLEY RAILWAY Non -Technical Summary of the Outline Business Case submitted to the Waverley Railway (Scotland) Bill Committee Turner
More informationRegulatory Committee
Page 1 - Proposed Turning Movement Bans at South Gate Junction, Dorchester Regulatory Committee Date of Meeting 16 March 2017 Officer Subject of Report Executive Summary Andrew Martin Service Director
More information