SCOTTISH ADVISORY COMMITTEE ON DISTINCTION AWARDS ANNUAL REPORT

Transcription

1 SCOTTISH ADVISORY COMMITTEE ON DISTINCTION AWARDS ANNUAL REPORT April 2010

2 CONTENTS Foreword 1 PART ONE Report on the 2009 Awards Round 2 Appendices Consultants approved for awards A. List of awards granted in B. List of award holders as at 30 September Analysis in relation to 2009 awards round C. Age group 17 D. Nominated consultants by gender and ethnic grouping 18 E. Age group and category of consultants who retired 19 Analysis of award holders as at 30 September 2009 F. Age group 20 G. Nature of contract 21 H. NHS Board Area 22 I. Speciality 23 J. Gender 24 K. Ethnic origin 25 Membership of SACDA L. For the 2010 awards round. 26 PART TWO Review of Awards Granted under Scoring System. 29 Appendices M. Nominations and awards granted by general category of nominee 32 N. Nominations and awards granted by specialty 33 O. Nominations and awards granted by NHS Employer 34 Page

3 FOREWORD This is the eleventh Annual Report of the Scottish Advisory Committee on Distinction Awards ( SACDA ). The Annual Report incorporates lists of Distinction Awards approved by SACDA during the 2009 awards round and of all award holders as at 30 September 2009, together with supporting statistical analysis. As presented in previous years, the statistical analysis is in two parts. The first part presents the data for the 2009 round. The second part contains a more extensive analysis of the data for the seven rounds, , in which the scoring system has been fully in use. This report is freely available to consultants in the NHS, NHS Boards, and all others who have an interest in the awards scheme. As explained in the following pages, the operation of SACDA has continued the pattern established in previous years. The Review Group set up to consider the future of the scheme administered by SACDA has completed its work and reported. The Cabinet Secretary has accepted the Report, which is available on the SACDA website, and an Implementation Group is being formed to take forward the changes required. Many of the changes proposed by the Review Group have already been implemented by SACDA as the scheme has evolved over the past few years. Nevertheless, future reports will describe substantial changes to the awards scheme, especially at the level of the B awards. In 2009, the number of awards was similar to that in The number of available awards was determined by retirals, resignations, deaths and the recommendations of the DDRB. Competition for all levels of award remains very high. Professor Colin J Suckling Chairman 1

4 SCOTTISH ADVISORY COMMITTEE ON DISTINCTION AWARDS PART ONE REPORT ON THE 2009 AWARDS ROUND (1 October September 2009) Introduction The Scottish Advisory Committee on Distinction Awards ( SACDA ) was set up in November 1998 to replace the Scottish Sub-Committee of the Advisory Committee on Distinction Awards ( ACDA ). SACDA, a non-departmental public body, acts on behalf of the First Minister and the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing in deciding which nominated medical and dental consultants in the NHS in Scotland should receive distinction awards for outstanding professional work. SACDA is responsible for the operation of the distinction awards scheme in Scotland, and ACCEA for its operation in England and Wales. Although the two committees are completely independent, close contact between the Chairmen and Medical Directors of SACDA and ACCEA has been maintained. We attach weight to ensuring general consistency of approach. Membership of SACDA during the year ended 31 October 2009 Professor C J Suckling OBE Chairman Professor J L Reid OBE Medical Director Dr H J G Burns (Chief Medical Officer) ex-officio SGHD Professor H Capell Mrs S Douglas Professor M D M Hadley Mr R R Jeffrey Professor J McDonald Dr K Paterson Mr PAM Raine Dr C Winstanley Dr K Woods (Chief Executive of NHS Scotland) ex-officio SGHD Details of Committee members appointed for the 2010 awards round are set out in Appendix L. Awards Granted The 2009 awards round was operated in accordance with the detailed arrangements set out in the Guide to the NHS Consultants Distinction Awards Scheme (Scotland) which was published in November There were 103 Distinction Awards available for consultants in consequence of the retirement of existing award holders and other vacancies - transfers to England, deaths, consequential awards (76) - and the implementation of the Review Body on Doctors and Dentists Remuneration ( DDRB ) recommendation on additional awards (27). SACDA, on 24 September 2009 approved 9 A+ Awards, 29 A Awards and 65 B Awards. A list of consultants in Scotland granted awards with effect from 1 April 2009 is at Appendix A. 2

5 As at 30 September 2009 there were 578 holders of awards in Scotland as set out in the following table:- Award Award Holders % of all Consultants A % A % B % Total % It should be noted that although only 12% of all consultants hold awards, the chance of holding an award at the time of retirement is almost 1 in 3. Last year, 38% (50% in 2008) of retiring consultants held an award (see Appendix E). A list of all award holders in Scotland as at 30 September 2009 is at Appendix B and related statistical analysis is set out in appendices C to K. Self Nominations The 2009 approved awards included 12 (9 A+ 1, 1 A, 2 B) awards for consultants who had selfnominated. Over the last eleven years, in aggregate, 45 consultants not otherwise nominated by any other party have been granted distinction awards following self-nomination or a 10-year review 2. These mechanisms provided an accessible nomination route for consultants who may be award worthy but whose names would not otherwise come to the committee s attention. From the 2010 awards round, in line with the recommendations of the Review Group, selfnomination will be the only route of application available for all levels of award. Five-Yearly Review of Awards During the year, 77 awards (53 B, 19 A and 5 A+) were reviewed by SACDA and the committee recommended continuation of 77 awards. Supplementary Review of Award One Supplementary Review was undertaken in 2009 following the unsatisfactory conclusion of a five-yearly review in the 2008 awards round. SACDA considered the information submitted and agreed to renew the award and return the consultant to the normal five-yearly review cycle. Special Review One Special Review was undertaken in After full consideration of the application, SACDA chose not to make an award. Scoring System The Scoring System was used to assist in the assessment of all nominations for all levels of award. It formed the basis for the Committee s evaluation of nominations but was only part of the 1 In 2009, self-nomination was the only route available for all A+ applicants 2 10-year reviews have been discontinued since

6 information used by the Committee. The final decisions reflected SACDA s judgement in what was a highly competitive round. A more detailed analysis of the pattern of awards under the current scoring system is given in Part 2 of this Report. Forward Planning We have submitted evidence to the DDRB but at the time of writing no decisions were available. An operational plan to implement the recommendations of the Review Group is about to be developed by an Implementation Group. The report of the Review Group is available on the SACDA website ( Publication of Information The Guide to the NHS Consultants Distinction Awards Scheme (Scotland) for 2010 was published in October 2009 on the SACDA website. For the first time, the Guide was split into four separate documents one each for Applicants, Award Holders, Employers and Supporting Bodies. There were no changes made to the Scoring System used in assessing applications since November SACDA Online Taking into account feedback from users who had trialled the system in 2008, the SACDA Online system was used in the 2009 round for the submission of all documentation. The Secretariat gathered further feedback from users and improvements were made to the system prior to the opening of the 2010 awards round. Acknowledgements We continue to maintain close links with our colleagues in ACCEA and warmly appreciate their collaboration. We are particularly grateful to our network of SACDA Advisors who work hard to support the scheme and without whose help SACDA would be the poorer. Professor Colin J Suckling Chairman Professor John L Reid Medical Director 4

7 Appendix A 2009 Distinction Awards The following consultants employed by the NHS in Scotland were granted distinction awards with effect from 1 April A+ Awards Name Specialty Award Date of NHS Employer held Award Critchley, HOD Obstetrics & Gynaecology A 01/04/2003 NHS Lothian Finlay, IG General Surgery A 01/04/2002 NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde Gibson, BES Haematology A 01/04/2000 NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde Harrison, DJ Histopathology A 01/04/2002 NHS Lothian MacDonald, TM General Medicine A 01/04/2004 NHS Tayside Ralston, SH General Medicine A 01/04/2001 NHS Lothian Reid, DM General Medicine A 01/04/2004 NHS Grampian Sandercock, PAG Neurology A 01/04/2001 NHS Lothian Seckl, JR General Medicine A 01/04/2004 NHS Lothian A Awards Specialty Award Date of NHS Employer Name held Award Andrews, PJD Anaesthetics B 01/04/2005 NHS Lothian Banham, S Respiratory Medicine B 01/04/2002 NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde Beard, K Geriatric Medicine B 01/04/2003 NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde Brown, KW General Psychiatry B 01/04/2004 NHS Forth Valley Carman, WF Medical Microbiology B 01/04/2003 NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde Cooper, SA Psychiatry of Learning Disability B 01/04/2004 NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde Davey, PG Communicable Diseases B 01/04/2001 NHS Tayside Felix, DH Dentistry B 01/04/2002 NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde Fleming, S Histopathology B 01/04/2004 NHS Tayside Galloway, DJ General Surgery B 01/04/2004 NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde Gilbert, FJ Diagnostic Radiology B 01/04/2003 NHS Grampian Godden, DJ Respiratory Medicine B 01/04/2005 NHS Highland Herriot, R Haematology B 01/04/2004 NHS Grampian Irvine, DS Obstetrics & Gynaecology B 01/04/2002 NHS Education for Scotland Kunkler, IH Radiotherapy B 01/04/2003 NHS Lothian MacArthur, KJD Cardiothoracic Surgery B 01/04/2003 NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde MacEwen, CJ Ophthalmology B 01/04/2003 NHS Tayside McGregor, JR General Surgery B 01/04/2001 NHS Ayrshire & Arran McInnes, IB General Medicine B 01/04/2004 NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde McLellan, AR General Medicine B 01/04/2004 NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde Nathwani, D Communicable Diseases B 01/04/2002 NHS Tayside Paterson-Brown, S General Surgery B 01/04/2004 NHS Lothian Porteous, MEM Clinical Genetics B 01/04/2004 NHS Lothian Reid, JH Diagnostic Radiology B 01/04/2003 NHS Borders Rodger, RSC General Medicine B 01/04/2004 NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde Simpson, AHR Orthopaedic Surgery B 01/04/2003 NHS Lothian Urbaniak, SJ Blood Transfusion B 01/04/2001 NHS National Services Scotland Vallance, B General Medicine B 01/04/2001 NHS Lanarkshire Watt, LJ General Psychiatry B 01/04/2001 NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B Awards Name Specialty NHS Employer Ahmed, SF Paediatrics NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde Anderson, JH General Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde Bain, MRS Public Health Medicine NHS National Services Scotland Baldacchino, AM General Psychiatry NHS Fife Ball, GE Dentistry NHS Fife Bhattacharya, JJ Diagnostic Radiology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde Bilsland, DJ Dermatology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde 5

8 Binning, AR Anaesthetics NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde Brady, AJ General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde Brittenden, J General Surgery NHS Grampian Burns, SM Medical Microbiology NHS Lothian Carton, ATM Dentistry NHS Lanarkshire Clarkson, JE Dentistry NHS Education for Scotland Clift, BA Orthopaedic Surgery NHS Tayside Coghill, D Child & Adolescent Psychiatry NHS Tayside Connolly, M General Psychiatry NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde Cruickshank, M Obstetrics & Gynaecology NHS Grampian Culligan, DJ Haematology NHS Grampian Davies, JM Haematology NHS Lothian Dempster, JH ENT Surgery NHS Ayrshire & Arran Diament, RH General Surgery NHS Ayrshire & Arran Doyle, E Anaesthetics NHS Lothian Dunn, LT Neurosurgery NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde El-Omar, EM General Medicine NHS Grampian El-Shafei, H Cardiothoracic Surgery NHS Grampian Evans, A Histopathology NHS Tayside Hunter, JA General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde Jackson, GA Old Age Psychiatry NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde Johnston, PW Histopathology NHS Grampian Jones, BL Medical Microbiology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde Kennedy, N General Medicine NHS Lanarkshire Kirk, AJB Cardiothoracic Surgery National Waiting Times Centre Kirkpatrick, M Paediatrics NHS Tayside Large, DF Orthopaedic Surgery NHS Ayrshire & Arran Leung, HHY Urology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde Lush, CJ Haematology NHS Highland Lyons, D General Psychiatry Mental Welfare Commission for Scotland McKay, PJ Haematology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde McKillop, G Diagnostic Radiology NHS Lothian McRitchie, HA Diagnostic Radiology NHS Borders Morrison, RA Forensic Psychiatry NHS Forth Valley Mumford, CJ Neurology NHS Lothian N Dow, J Urology NHS Grampian Neilly, J General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde Palin, AN General Psychiatry NHS Grampian Patey, RE Anaesthetics NHS Grampian Petrie, J General Medicine NHS Tayside Ray, DC Anaesthetics NHS Lothian Roditi, GH Diagnostic Radiology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde Salter, DM Histopathology NHS Lothian Seaton, RA Communicable Diseases NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde Shearer, AC Dentistry NHS Tayside Sheikh, A General Practice NHS Lothian Stenson, BJ Paediatrics NHS Lothian Tannahill, AJ Public Health Medicine NHS Health Scotland Taylor, J Geriatric Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde Thomas, JSTJ Histopathology NHS Lothian Uren, NG General Medicine NHS Lothian Walker, ADW Public Health Medicine NHS Tayside Walters, MR General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde Ward, HJT Public Health Medicine NHS National Services Scotland Waterhouse, J General Psychiatry NHS Dumfries & Galloway Watson, SB Plastic Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde Wigmore, S General Surgery NHS Lothian Wright, SC General Medicine NHS Forth Valley 6

9 Distinction Award holders in Scotland as at 30 September 2009 Appendix B Surname/Initials Specialty Employer Award Year Abu Arafeh IAI Paediatrics NHS Forth Valley B 08 Ahmed S Public Health Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 08 Ahmed SF Paediatrics NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 09 Aitchison M Urology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 06 Akyol AM General Surgery NHS Lothian B 05 Allan DB Orthopaedic Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 08 Allan PLP Diagnostic Radiology NHS Lothian A+ 06 Alston RP Anaesthetics NHS Lothian B 08 Anderson IWR Accident & Emergency NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 03 Anderson JH General Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 09 Anderson RA Obstetrics & Gynaecology NHS Lothian B 07 Andrews PJD Anaesthetics NHS Lothian A 09 Auld CD General Surgery NHS Dumfries & Galloway B 02 Ayoub A Dentistry NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 07 Bagg J Dentistry NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 06 Bain MRS Public Health Medicine NHS National Services Scotland B 09 Baldacchino AM General Psychiatry NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 09 Ball GE Dentistry NHS Fife B 09 Banham SW Respiratory Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 09 Barlow DH Obstetrics & Gynaecology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A+ 03 Bartolo DCC General Surgery NHS Lothian B 98 Bateman DN General Medicine NHS Lothian A 04 Baxter GM Diagnostic Radiology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 05 Beard K Geriatrics NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 09 Beattie TF Accident & Emergency NHS Lothian B 04 Medicine Beattie TJ Paediatrics NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 07 Beggs IG Diagnostic Radiology NHS Lothian B 05 Belch JJF General Medicine NHS Tayside A+ 08 Berg GA Cardiothoracic Surgery National Waiting Times Centre B 07 Bevan JS General Medicine NHS Grampian A 07 Bhattacharya S Obstetrics & Gynaecology NHS Grampian B 08 Bhattacharya JJ Diagnostic Radiology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 09 Bhopal RS Public Health Medicine NHS Lothian A 04 Bigrigg MA Obstetrics & Gynaecology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 05 Bilsland DJ Dermatology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 09 Binning AR Anaesthetics NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 09 Birnie GG General Medicine NHS Fife B 08 Blackwood DHR General Psychiatry NHS Lothian A 00 Blair RL ENT Surgery NHS Tayside A 00 Bonnar SE Child & Adolescent NHS Tayside B 06 Psychiatry Boon NA General Medicine NHS Lothian A 04 Booth MG Anaesthetics NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 07 Booth P Paediatrics NHS Grampian B 07 Bouch CJK General Psychiatry NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 05 Brady AJ General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 09 Brenkel IJ Orthopaedic Surgery NHS Fife B 07 Brewster DH Public Health Medicine NHS National Services Scotland B 08 Bridges AB General Medicine NHS Forth Valley B 06 Brittenden J General Surgery NHS Grampian B 09 Brodie MJ General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 02 Brown KW General Psychiatry NHS Forth Valley A 09 Brown TM General Psychiatry NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 08 Buist LJ General Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 08 Burden AD Dermatology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 08 Burns HJG Public Health Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde / SGHD A+ 06 Burns SM Medical Microbiology NHS Lothian B 09 Cachia PG Haematology NHS Tayside A 08 Callender JS General Psychiatry NHS Grampian B 06 7

10 Cameron AD Obstetrics & Gynaecology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 08 Campbell H Public Health Medicine NHS Lothian A 06 Canney PA Radiotherapy NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 08 Cantwell R General Psychiatry NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 08 Caplan RP General Psychiatry NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 01 Carachi R Paediatric Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 04 Carey FA Histopathology NHS Tayside B 07 Carman WF Medical Microbiology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 09 Carter CR General Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 05 Carton ATM Dentistry NHS Lanarkshire B 09 Cassidy J General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 07 Chambers WA Anaesthetics NHS Grampian A 01 Chick JD General Psychiatry NHS Lothian B 03 Clarkson JE Dentistry NHS Tayside B 09 Clift BA Orthopaedic Surgery NHS Tayside B 09 Cobbe SM General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A+ 04 Coghill D Child & Adolescent NHS Tayside B 09 Psychiatry Coia DA General Psychiatry NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 06 Coia JE Medical Microbiology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 08 Colledge NR Geriatrics NHS Lothian B 06 Colvin JR Anaesthetics NHS Tayside B 08 Conn IG Urology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 04 Connacher AA General Medicine NHS Tayside B 08 Connell JMC General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A+ 05 Connelly PJ Old Age Psychiatry NHS Tayside A 06 Connolly M General Psychiatry NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 09 Connor JM Clinical Genetics NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 95 Cooper S Psychiatry of Learning NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 09 Disability Corrigan FM General Psychiatry NHS Highland B 00 Court-Brown CM Orthopaedic Surgery NHS Lothian B 98 Coyle EF Public Health Medicine NHS Fife B 03 Crawford DH Medical Microbiology NHS Lothian B 05 Critchley HOD Obstetrics & Gynaecology NHS Lothian A+ 09 Crowther JA ENT Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 06 Cruickshank M Obstetrics & Gynaecology NHS Grampian B 09 Culligan DJ Haematology NHS Grampian B 09 Cumming AD General Medicine NHS Lothian A 08 Currie CT Geriatrics NHS Lothian B 99 Currie JM Anaesthetics NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 01 Dargie HJ General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A+ 03 Davey PG Communicable Diseases NHS Tayside A 09 Davies JM Haematology NHS Lothian B 09 Davis CF Paediatric Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 07 De Caestecker LC Public Health Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 04 Dean JCS Clinical Genetics NHS Grampian B 06 Dempster JH ENT Surgery NHS Ayrshire & Arran B 09 Dennis MS General Medicine NHS Lothian A 07 Dewar JA Radiotherapy NHS Tayside B 02 Dewhurst NG General Medicine NHS Tayside B 04 Dhillon BJ Ophthalmology NHS Lothian B 05 Diament RH General Surgery NHS Ayrshire & Arran B 09 Dixon JMJ General Surgery NHS Lothian B 02 Dobson HM Diagnostic Radiology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 02 Dominiczak AF General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A+ 07 Dominiczak MH Chemical Pathology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 00 Donaghy MG Public Health Medicine NHS National Services Scotland B 07 Donaldson MDC Paediatrics NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 04 Donnelly PD Public Health Medicine NHS Fife B 02 Dorward AJ General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 99 Dougall JRI Anaesthetics NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 03 Douglas JG Respiratory Medicine NHS Grampian A 05 Douglas NJ Respiratory Medicine NHS Lothian A+ 03 Dow E Chemical Pathology NHS Tayside B 06 8

11 Doyle E Anaesthetics NHS Lothian B 09 Drummond GB Anaesthetics NHS Lothian A 95 Duncan JL General Surgery NHS Highland A 08 Duncan R Neurology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 04 Dunlop DJ General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 07 Dunlop MG General Surgery NHS Lothian A 03 Dunn FG General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 04 Dunn LT Neurosurgery NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 09 Dutton GN Ophthalmology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 01 Eagles JM General Psychiatry NHS Grampian B 02 Edwards RD Diagnostic Radiology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 04 El-Omar EM General Medicine NHS Grampian B 09 El-Shafei H Cardiothoracic Surgery NHS Grampian B 09 Eljamel MS Neurosurgery NHS Tayside B 06 Eteiba MHM General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 08 Evans A Histopathology NHS Tayside B 09 Evans TRJ General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 08 Farquharson DIM Obstetrics & Gynaecology NHS Lothian A 08 Fearon KCH General Surgery NHS Lothian B 06 Felix DH Dentistry NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 09 Ferguson J Dermatology NHS Tayside A 02 Ferguson J Accident & Emergency NHS Grampian B 05 Medicine Ferguson JC General Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 01 Fergusson RJ Respiratory Medicine NHS Lothian B 08 Findlay DJ Old Age Psychiatry NHS Tayside B 01 Findlay IN General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 06 Finlay IG General Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A+ 09 Finlayson DF Orthopaedic Surgery NHS Highland B 04 Fisher BM General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 03 Fitzsimons EJ Haematology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 02 Flapan AD General Medicine NHS Lothian B 08 Fleck BW Ophthalmology NHS Lothian B 04 Fleming S Histopathology NHS Tayside A 09 Forrester JV Ophthalmology NHS Grampian A+ 00 Forsythe JLR General Surgery NHS Lothian A 05 Fothergill NJ Accident & Emergency NHS Lothian B 01 Medicine Foulds I Dermatology NHS Ayrshire & Arran B 97 Foulis AK Histopathology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 92 Fowkes FGR Public Health Medicine NHS Lothian A+ 03 Fox JG General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 07 Fox KAA General Medicine NHS Lothian A+ 04 Fox R Communicable Diseases NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 08 Franklin IM Blood Transfusion NHS National Services Scotland A 99 Fraser AK Public Health Medicine NHS Highland (Seconded to Scottish Prison B 06 Service) Frenneaux MP General Medicine NHS Grampian B 03 Frier BM General Medicine NHS Lothian A 02 Gallacher SJ General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 07 Galloway DJ General Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 09 Garden OJ General Surgery NHS Lothian A+ 04 George WD General Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A+ 99 Gibson BES Haematology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A+ 09 Gilbert FJ Diagnostic Radiology NHS Grampian A 09 Gillespie IN Diagnostic Radiology NHS Lothian B 01 Glasier AF Obstetrics & Gynaecology NHS Lothian A+ 06 Glavin RJ Anaesthetics NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 05 Godden DJ Respiratory Medicine NHS Highland A 09 Going JJ Histopathology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 01 Goldberg DJ Public Health Medicine NHS National Services Scotland A 05 Gould IM Medical Microbiology NHS Grampian A 04 Grant AM Public Health Medicine NHS Grampian A 01 Grant IS Anaesthetics NHS Lothian B 97 Grant R Neurology NHS Lothian B 06 9

12 Gray A Accident & Emergency NHS Lothian B 08 Medicine Greaves M Haematology NHS Grampian A+ 04 Greene SA Paediatrics NHS Tayside A 07 Greening AP Respiratory Medicine NHS Lothian A 08 Grieve JHK Histopathology NHS Grampian B 07 Grosset DG Neurology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 05 Gruer LD Public Health Medicine NHS Health Scotland A 08 Gupta SR Ophthalmology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 98 Gusterson BA Histopathology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A+ 03 Hadley MDM Diagnostic Radiology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A+ 03 Haddock G Paediatric Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 06 Haites NE Clinical Genetics NHS Grampian A+ 02 Hall DJ General Psychiatry NHS Dumfries & Galloway B 05 Hallworth D Anaesthetics NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 00 Hamilton MPR Obstetrics & Gynaecology NHS Grampian A 08 Hanlon PW Public Health Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 03 Hannaford PC Public Health Medicine NHS Grampian B 06 Harley KE Dentistry NHS Lothian B 08 Harrison DJ Histopathology NHS Lothian A+ 09 Haslett C Respiratory Medicine NHS Lothian A+ 01 Hay AG Forensic Psychiatry NHS Highland B 08 Hayes PC General Medicine NHS Lothian B 03 Helms PJB Paediatrics NHS Grampian A 08 Hendry AJ Geriatrics NHS Lanarkshire B 05 Hendry WS General Surgery NHS Forth Valley A 08 Hepburn M Obstetrics & Gynaecology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 04 Herrington CS Histopathology NHS Tayside B 05 Herriot R Histopathology NHS Grampian A 09 Heys SD General Surgery NHS Grampian A 08 Hillis WS General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 01 Hislop WS Dentistry NHS Ayrshire & Arran B 05 Hogg K General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 07 Holland BM Paediatrics NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 01 Holyoake TL Haematology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 06 Hood J Medical Microbiology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 05 Horgan PG General Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 07 Houston AB General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 01 Howard GCW Radiotherapy NHS Lothian B 01 Howatson AG Histopathology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 02 Howie CR Orthopaedic Surgery NHS Lothian B 06 Howie JC Anaesthetics NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 01 Ho-Yen DO Medical Microbiology NHS Highland B 04 Hughes RG Obstetrics & Gynaecology NHS Lothian B 07 Hunter JA General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 09 Hunter R General Psychiatry NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 02 Hume R Paediatrics NHS Tayside A 99 Hussein SSM ENT Surgery NHS Lothian B 08 Hussey JK Diagnostic Radiology NHS Grampian B 00 Hutchison JD Orthopaedic Surgery NHS Grampian A 02 Ibbetson RJ Dentistry NHS Lothian A 08 Innes JA Respiratory Medicine NHS Lothian B 07 Iredale J General Medicine NHS Lothian A 08 Ironside JW Histopathology NHS Lothian A+ 08 Irvine DS Obstetrics & Gynaecology NHS Lothian A 09 Isles CG General Medicine NHS Dumfries & Galloway A 02 Jackson GA Old Age Psychiatry NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 09 Jackson PD Paediatrics NHS Lothian B 07 Jardine AG General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 06 Jeffrey RR Cardiothoracic Surgery NHS Grampian A 06 Jennings KP General Medicine NHS Grampian B 02 Johnston IG Anaesthetics NHS Highland B 07 Johnston PW Histopathology NHS Grampian B 09 Johnstone EC General Psychiatry NHS Lothian A+ 97 Jones BL Medical Microbiology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 09 10

13 Jones MC General Medicine NHS Lothian B 04 Junor BJR General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 98 Keating JF Orthopaedic Surgery NHS Lothian B 08 Keel A Haematology NHS Lothian / SGHD B 07 Kelnar CJH Paediatrics NHS Lothian A+ 08 Kennedy N General Medicine NHS Lanarkshire B 09 Kennedy PGE Neurology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A+ 08 Ker JS General Practice NHS Tayside B 08 Kerr KM Histopathology NHS Grampian A 05 Kidd BA General Psychiatry NHS Forth Valley B 02 King DJ Haematology NHS Grampian A 08 King PM General Surgery NHS Grampian B 08 Kinsella J Anaesthetics NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 08 Kirk AJB Cardiothoracic Surgery National Waiting Times Centre B 09 Kirkpatrick M Paediatrics NHS Tayside B 09 Knight PV Geriatrics NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 04 Knight RSG Neurology NHS Lothian B 04 Knox FM Anaesthetics NHS Grampian B 01 Krukowski ZH General Surgery NHS Grampian A+ 08 Kunkler IH Radiotherapy NHS Lothian A 09 Kyle PM Ophthalmology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 99 Laing IA Paediatrics NHS Lothian A 05 Laing MR ENT Surgery NHS Highland B 02 Lang C General Medicine NHS Tayside B 07 Langhorne P Geriatrics NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 06 Large DF Orthopaedic Surgery NHS Ayrshire & Arran B 09 Lavelle-Jones M General Surgery NHS Tayside B 03 Lawrie SM General Psychiatry NHS Lothian B 08 Lean MEJ General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 02 Leen CLS Communicable Diseases NHS Lothian B 08 Leigh IM Dermatology NHS Tayside A+ 00 Lees DAR Obstetrics & Gynaecology NHS Highland B 00 Lees KR General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 05 Leese GP General Medicine NHS Tayside B 05 Leiper JM Palliative Medicine NHS Tayside B 04 Leslie PJA General Medicine NHS Borders B 08 Leung HHY Urology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 09 Levack ID Anaesthetics NHS Tayside B 06 Lewis-Jones MS Dermatology NHS Tayside A 07 Lipworth BJ General Medicine NHS Tayside A 08 Livingston MG General Psychiatry NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 96 Logie JRC General Surgery NHS Highland A 98 Lowe GDO General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A+ 08 Ludlam CA Haematology NHS Lothian A+ 04 Lumsden MA Obstetrics & Gynaecology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 07 Lush CJ Haematology NHS Highland B 09 Lyall RM Psychiatry of Learning Mental Welfare Commission for Scotland B 06 Disability Lyon AJ Paediatrics NHS Lothian B 05 Lyons D General Psychiatry Mental Welfare Commission for Scotland B 09 MacArthur KJD Cardiothoracic Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 09 MacDonald EB Occupational Health NHS Lanarkshire A 02 MacDonald TM General Medicine NHS Tayside A+ 09 MacDougall RH Radiotherapy NHS Lothian B 07 MacEwen CJ Ophthalmology NHS Tayside A 09 MacFadyen U Paediatrics NHS Forth Valley A 01 MacFie AG Anaesthetics National Waiting Times Centre B 08 MacIntyre PD General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 06 MacKay TW Respiratory Medicine NHS Lothian B 05 MacKenzie K ENT Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 07 MacKenzie N Anaesthetics NHS Tayside B 04 MacKenzie SJ Anaesthetics NHS Lothian B 06 MacKinlay GA Paediatric Surgery NHS Lothian B 04 MacLeod AM General Medicine NHS Grampian A 02 MacNee W Respiratory Medicine NHS Lothian A

14 MacPherson LMD Dentistry NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 08 MacPherson SG General Surgery NHS Education for Scotland A+ 05 MacRury SM General Medicine NHS Highland B 06 MacTier RA General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 06 Madhok R General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 03 Mahmood TA Obstetrics & Gynaecology NHS Fife A 06 Mallon EA Histopathology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 06 Mankad PS Cardiothoracic Surgery NHS Lothian B 02 Marshall SE Chemical Pathology NHS Tayside B 08 Martin BJ Geriatrics NHS Lanarkshire B 04 Masterton RG Medical Microbiology NHS Ayrshire & Arran A 07 Mathers AM Obstetrics & Gynaecology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 08 Matthews K General Psychiatry NHS Tayside B 05 Maxwell SRJ General Medicine NHS Lothian B 08 McAlpine CH Geriatrics NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 08 McAlpine LG General Medicine NHS Lanarkshire B 04 McClinton S Urology NHS Grampian B 06 McColl KEL General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A+ 08 McCord JF Dentistry NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 08 McCubbin TD Anaesthetics NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 98 McDonald JP Dentistry NHS Fife A+ 06 McGarry GW ENT Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 05 McGowan A Accident & Emergency NHS Education for Scotland A+ 08 Medicine McGrady EM Anaesthetics NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 08 McGregor JR General Surgery NHS Ayrshire & Arran A 09 McHardy KC General Medicine NHS Grampian B 07 McInnes IB General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 09 McInnes GT General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 07 McKay AJ General Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 03 McKay CJ General Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 08 McKay PJ Haematology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 09 McKee RF General Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 05 McKenzie H Medical Microbiology NHS Grampian B 06 McKeown DW Anaesthetics NHS Lothian A 05 McKerrow WS ENT Surgery NHS Highland A 01 McKillop G Diagnostic Radiology NHS Lothian B 09 McKillop JH General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 96 McKnight JA General Medicine NHS Lothian B 08 McLellan AR General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 09 McManners J Dentistry NHS Forth Valley B 04 McMurdo MET Geriatrics NHS Tayside A 05 McMurray JJV General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 06 McQueen MM Orthopaedic Surgery NHS Lothian B 02 McRitchie HA Diagnostic Radiology NHS Borders B 09 McWhirter MF Public Health Medicine NHS Forth Valley / SGHD B 05 Meddings RN Urology NHS Ayrshire & Arran B 08 Mehta A Paediatrics NHS Tayside B 08 Miller SM Psychiatry of Learning NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 05 Disability Mills PR General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 07 Mills RP ENT Surgery NHS Lothian B 07 Milroy R Respiratory Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 06 Mires G Obstetrics & Gynaecology NHS Tayside B 04 Moffat LEF Urology NHS Grampian B 04 Mok JYQ Paediatrics NHS Lothian B 00 Molloy RG General Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 08 Morran CG General Surgery NHS Ayrshire & Arran B 03 Morris AD General Medicine NHS Tayside A 07 Morris AJ General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 08 Morrison CE Public Health Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 05 Morrison JM General Practice NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 07 Morrison RA Forensic Psyhciatry NHS Forth Valley B 09 Morrison WG Accident & Emergency Medicine NHS Tayside A 08 12

15 Morton NS Anaesthetics NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 02 Moss JG Diagnostic Radiology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 08 Mossey PA Dentistry NHS Tayside B 07 Mountain RE ENT Surgery NHS Tayside B 05 Muir WJ Psychiatry of Learning NHS Lothian A 08 Disability Mumford CJ Neurology NHS Lothian B 09 Munro CS Dermatology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 05 Murchison JT Diagnostic Radiology NHS Lothian B 08 Murdoch PS Geriatrics NHS Forth Valley B 00 Murie JA General Surgery NHS Lothian B 00 Murray AD Diagnostic Radiology NHS Grampian B 07 Murray GI Histopathology NHS Grampian B 05 Murray SA General Practice NHS Lothian B 08 N Dow J Urology NHS Grampian B 09 Nandwani R Genito Urinary Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 05 Nathwani D Communicable Diseases NHS Tayside A 09 Needham G Diagnostic Radiology NHS Grampian B 04 Neilly J General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 09 Newby DE General Medicine NHS Lothian B 07 Nichols DM Diagnostic Radiology NHS Highland A 02 Nicolson MC General Medicine NHS Grampian B 05 Nixon SJ General Surgery NHS Lothian A 01 Noble DW Anaesthetics NHS Grampian B 05 Norman JE Obstetrics & Gynaecology NHS Lothian B 04 Norris JFB Dermatology NHS Dumfries & Galloway B 04 O Dwyer PJ General Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 02 Ogden GR Dentistry NHS Tayside A 08 O Hare AE Paediatrics NHS Lothian B 04 O Kelly TJ General Surgery NHS Grampian B 05 Oldroyd KG General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 06 O Regan MB Dentistry NHS Fife B 04 O Reilly BF ENT Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 06 Ormerod AD Dermatology NHS Grampian B 03 Orr JD Paediatric Surgery NHS Lothian A+ 08 Owen P Obstetrics & Gynaecology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 08 Owens DGC General Psychiatry NHS Lothian A 02 Pace N Anaesthetics NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 06 Padfield PL General Medicine NHS Lothian A 07 Palin AN General Psychiatry NHS Grampian B 09 Palmer KR General Medicine NHS Lothian A 06 Parkin DE Obstetrics & Gynaecology NHS Grampian A 03 Parks RW General Surgery NHS Lothian B 06 Paterson-Brown S General Surgery NHS Lothian A 09 Paterson KR General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 05 Patey RE Anaesthetics NHS Grampian B 09 Paton JY Paediatrics NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 08 Peacock AJ Respiratory Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 08 Pearson DWM General Medicine NHS Grampian A 08 Pell JP Public Health Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 05 Pelosi AJ General Psychiatry NHS Lanarkshire A 05 Penman ID General Medicine NHS Lothian B 08 Petrie J General Medicine NHS Tayside B 09 Peutrell J Anaesthetics NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 08 Phillips MGA Medical Microbiology NHS Tayside B 08 Pitts NJ Dentistry NHS Tayside A 01 Pollock JCS Cardiothoracic Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 04 Porteous MEM Clinical Genetics NHS Lothian A 09 Power I Anaesthetics NHS Lothian B 04 Primrose WR Geriatrics NHS Grampian B 08 Pringle SD General Medicine NHS Tayside B 06 Raby N Diagnostic Radiology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 08 Ralston SH General Medicine NHS Lothian A+ 09 Rampling RP Radiotherapy NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 03 Rankin AC General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 03 13

16 Ray AK Plastic Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 03 Ray DC Anaesthetics NHS Lothian B 09 Reed NSE Radiotherapy NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 05 Rees J Dermatology NHS Lothian A 05 Reid DM General Medicine NHS Grampian A+ 09 Reid IC General Psychiatry NHS Grampian B 08 Reid JH Diagnostic Radiology NHS Borders A 09 Reid RP Histopathology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 04 Reid W Geriatrics NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 08 Reilly DPT General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 00 Rennie JS Dentistry NHS Education for Scotland A 01 Rice PM General Psychiatry NHS Tayside B 07 Ritchie IK Orthopaedic Surgery NHS Forth Valley B 05 Ritchie LD General Practice NHS Grampian A 07 Robb JE Orthopaedic Surgery NHS Lothian B 01 Roberts MA Geriatrics NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 01 Roberts RC Neurology NHS Tayside B 03 Robertson AG Radiotherapy NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 07 Robertson CE Accident & Emergency NHS Lothian A 03 Robertson I Diagnostic Radiology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 07 Rodger RSC General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 09 Roditi GH Diagnostic Radiology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 09 Rowley DI Orthopaedic Surgery NHS Tayside A 00 Roxburgh STD Ophthalmology NHS Tayside A 06 Rymaszewski LA Orthopaedic Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 01 Salter DM Histopathology NHS Lothian B 09 Sandercock PAG Neurology NHS Lothian A+ 09 Satsangi J General Medicine NHS Lothian B 06 Sattar N Chemical Pathology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 08 Saunders WP Dentistry NHS Tayside A 03 Savill JS General Medicine NHS Lothian A+ 05 Scott HRW Respiratory Medicine NHS Lanarkshire B 08 Seaton RA Communicable Diseases NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 09 Seckl JR General Medicine NHS Lothian A+ 09 Sellar RJ Diagnostic Radiology NHS Lothian A 06 Semple CG General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 06 Serpell MG Anaesthetics NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 04 Sethi T Respiratory Medicine NHS Lothian B 05 Sharpe M General Psychiatry NHS Lothian A 07 Shearer AC Dentistry NHS Tayside B 09 Sheikh A General Practice NHS Lothian B 09 Shimi SM General Surgery NHS Tayside B 05 Siddiqui NA Obstetrics & Gynaecology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 06 Simmonds PN Medical Microbiology NHS Lothian B 08 Simpson AHR Orthopaedic Surgery NHS Lothian A 09 Simpson DL Anaesthetics NHS Lothian B 08 Simpson HKL General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 00 Simpson NJ Psychiatry of Learning NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 08 Disability Simpson RM Paediatrics NHS Dumfries & Galloway B 07 Singh J Ophthalmology NHS Lothian B 08 Skeoch CH Paediatrics NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 06 Small M General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 03 Smith DM General Surgery NHS Tayside B 08 Smith FW Diagnostic Radiology NHS Grampian A 06 Smith ID General Psychiatry NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 03 Smith NC Obstetrics & Gynaecology NHS Grampian B 01 Smith RC General Surgery NHS Forth Valley B 97 Smith WCS Public Health Medicine NHS Grampian A 04 St Clair DM General Psychiatry NHS Grampian B 08 Starr JM Geriatrics NHS Lothian B 06 Steedman DJ Accident & Emergency NHS Lothian B 07 Medicine Steele RJC General Surgery NHS Tayside A+ 08 Steers AJW Neurosurgery NHS Lothian A 99 14

17 Stenson BJ Paediatrics NHS Lothian B 09 Steven MM General Medicine NHS Highland A 07 Stevenson JH Plastic Surgery NHS Tayside B 00 Stone DH Paediatrics NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 01 Stonebridge PA General Surgery NHS Tayside B 06 Stott DJ Geriatrics NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 07 Strachan JG General Psychiatry NHS Lothian B 01 Struthers AD General Medicine NHS Tayside A+ 07 Sturrock RD General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 98 Sullivan F General Practice NHS Tayside B 07 Sunderland GT General Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 05 Swainson CP General Medicine NHS Lothian A+ 07 Swan IRC ENT Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 07 Taha ASA General Medicine NHS Ayrshire & Arran B 07 Tait RC Haematology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 06 Tannahill AJ Public Health Medicine NHS Health Scotland B 09 Taylor J Geriatric Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 09 Teasdale EM Diagnostic Radiology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 01 Templeton AA Obstetrics & Gynaecology NHS Grampian A+ 01 Terry PB Obstetrics & Gynaecology NHS Grampian B 05 Thomas AE Haematology NHS Lothian A 08 Thomas JSTJ Histopathology NHS Lothian B 09 Thompson AM General Surgery NHS Tayside B 05 Thomson LDG Forensic Psychiatry State Hospitals Board for Scotland B 08 Thomson NC Respiratory Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A+ 08 Todd WTA Communicable Diseases NHS Lanarkshire B 02 Toft AD General Medicine NHS Lothian A+ 01 Tolley DA Urology NHS Lothian A 06 Townell NH Urology NHS Tayside B 99 Treliving LR Psychotherapy NHS Grampian B 08 Turnbull CM Diagnostic Radiology NHS Lothian B 99 Turner AN General Medicine NHS Lothian B 08 Turner ML Blood Transfusion NHS National Services Scotland B 06 Urbaniak SJ Blood Transfusion NHS National Services Scotland A 09 Uren NG General Medicine NHS Lothian B 09 Vallance BD General Medicine NHS Lanarkshire A 09 Walker ADW Public Health Medicine NHS Tayside B 09 Walker BR General Medicine NHS Lothian B 04 Walker ID Haematology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A+ 04 Walker WS Cardiothoracic Surgery NHS Lothian B 08 Wallace WHB Paediatrics NHS Lothian A 08 Walsh TS Anaesthetics NHS Lothian B 07 Walters MR General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 09 Ward HJT Public Health Medicine NHS National Services Scotland B 09 Wardlaw D Orthopaedic Surgery NHS Grampian B 97 Wardlaw JM Diagnostic Radiology NHS Lothian A 08 Waterhouse J General Psychiatry NHS Dumfries & Galloway B 09 Watson HG Haematology NHS Grampian B 08 Watson JD Plastic Surgery NHS Lothian B 07 Watson ML General Medicine NHS Lothian A 07 Watson SB Plastic Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 09 Watt GCM General Practice NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 07 Watt LJ General Psychiatry NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 09 Waugh NR Public Health Medicine NHS Grampian B 07 Weaver LT Paediatrics NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 04 Webb DJ General Medicine NHS Lothian A+ 08 Webster J General Medicine NHS Grampian A 01 Webster NR Anaesthetics NHS Grampian A 03 Weiler-Mithoff EM Plastic Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 08 Welbury RR Dentistry NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 06 Weller DP General Practice NHS Lothian B 07 Welsh J Palliative Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 03 West CP Obstetrics & Gynaecology NHS Lothian B 96 White PS ENT Surgery NHS Tayside B 07 Whittle IR Neurosurgery NHS Lothian A 02 15

18 Wigmore S General Surgery NHS Lothian B 09 Will RG Neurology NHS Lothian A 02 Williams C General Psychiatry NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde B 06 Willison HJ Neurology NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 08 Wilson JA General Medicine NHS Fife B 01 Wilson PA Anaesthetics NHS Ayrshire & Arran A 08 Winter JH Communicable Diseases NHS Tayside B 08 Wray DM Dentistry NHS Greater Glasgow & Clyde A 07 Wright AF Clinical Genetics NHS Lothian B 05 Wright SC General Medicine NHS Forth Valley B 09 Youngson GG Paediatric Surgery NHS Grampian A+ 07 Zoma AA General Medicine NHS Lanarkshire B 01 16

19 Appendix C ANALYSIS OF NEW AWARD HOLDERS BY AGE Scotland Awards Round NEW AWARD HOLDERS AGE GROUP A+ A B Total Total Average Age

20 Appendix D ANALYSIS OF NOMINATED CONSULTANTS BY GENDER AND ETHNIC GROUPING Scotland Awards Round GENDER FEMALE MALE Nominations Awards Granted Nominations Awards Granted No. % No. % No. % No. % A A B Total ETHNIC GROUPING ETHNIC MINORITIES OTHER Nominations Awards Granted Nominations Awards Granted No. % No. % No. % No. % A A B Total NB: Not all consultants declare their ethnicity. 18

21 Appendix E ANALYSIS BY AGE GROUP AND CATEGORY OF CONSULTANTS WHO RETIRED Scotland Awards Round CONSULTANTS RETIRING AGE GROUP Award Without Total Holders Awards Under Number % and Number over % Total Number %

22 Appendix F ANALYSIS BY AGE GROUP (All Consultants Award Holders/Non-Award Holders) Scotland Awards Round Award Holders AGE GROUP A+ A B Total Non-Award Holders All Consultants Under and over Total

23 Appendix G ANALYSIS BY NATURE OF CONTRACT Scotland Awards Round ALL CONSULTANTS NATURE OF CONTRACT Non-Award A+ A B Holders Permanent Fixed Term Fixed Term Job Share Honorary Total

24 Appendix H ANALYSIS BY HEALTH BOARD AREA Scotland as at 30 September 2009 Award Holders A+ A B Total Non-Award Holders All Consultants Health Board Area % Per % Per % Per % Per % Per No. Area No. Area No. Area No. Area No. Area Ayrshire and Arran Borders Dumfries and Galloway Fife Forth Valley Grampian Greater Glasgow & Clyde Highland Lanarkshire Lothian National Orkney Shetland Tayside Western Isles Total Includes consultants working in National Organisations e.g. NHS National Services Scotland (operating name for the Common Services Agency), NHS Education for Scotland, NHS Quality Improvement Scotland, NHS Health Scotland, The State Hospitals Board for Scotland and Golden Jubilee National Hospital. 22

25 Appendix I ANALYSIS BY SPECIALTY Scotland as at 30 September 2009 Total No. of Award Holders Non-Award Consultants % of All A+ A B TOTAL Holders Specialty In Specialty Consultants No. % of No. % of No. % of No. % of No. % of Specialty Specialty Specialty Specialty Specialty Anaesthetics Public Health Medicine General Practice Occupational Medicine Dentistry (1) Blood Transfusion Chemical Pathology (2) Haematology Clinical Genetics Medical Microbiology Histopathology Communicable Diseases Dermatology General Medicine (3) Geriatrics Paediatrics (4) Palliative Medicine Neurology Rehabilitation Medicine Respiratory Medicine Genito Urinary Medicine Obstetrics & Gynaecology (5) General Psychiatry (6) Psychotherapy Child & Adolescent Psychiatry Forensic Psychiatry Psychiatry of Learning Disability Old Age Psychiatry Diagnostic Radiology (7) Radiotherapy Accident & Emergency Medicine ENT Surgery General Surgery Neurosurgery Ophthalmology Trauma & Orthopaedic Surgery Plastic Surgery Paediatric Surgery Cardiothoracic Surgery Urology Total of all consultants NOTES: (1) Includes: oral medicine, oral surgery, orthodontics, paediatric dentistry, restorative dentistry, community dentistry and community dental health (2) Includes: immunology and virology (3) Includes: cardiology, clinical pharmacology and therapeutics, endocrinology and diabetes, gastroenterology, general medicine, homeopathy, medical oncology, nephrology and rheumatology (4) Includes: community child health (5) Includes family planning service and well woman service (6) Includes: community psychiatry (7) Includes; breast screening service and nuclear medicine 23