RURAL ECONOMY AND CONNECTIVITY COMMITTEE AGENDA. 14th Meeting, 2016 (Session 5) Wednesday 14 December 2016

Transcription

1 REC/S5/16/14/A RURAL ECONOMY AND CONNECTIVITY COMMITTEE AGENDA 14th Meeting, 2016 (Session 5) Wednesday 14 December 2016 The Committee will meet at am in the Mary Fairfax Somerville Room (CR2). 1. Forth Replacement Crossing - Project Team Update: The Committee will take evidence from David Climie, Project Director, Forth Replacement Crossing Team, and Lawrence Shackman, Project Manager, Forth Replacement Crossing Team, Transport Scotland. 2. Major transport infrastructure projects update: The Committee will take evidence from Keith Brown, Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Jobs and Fair Work; Michelle Rennie, Director of Major Transport Infrastructure Projects, and Graham Porteous, Head of Special Projects, Transport Scotland, Scottish Government. 3. Public petitions: The Committee will consider the following petitions PE1236 by Jill Fotheringham, on improving safety measures on the A90 by constructing a grade separated junction where the A937 crosses the A90 at Laurencekirk. PE1598 by Guy Linley-Adams, on behalf of Salmon & Trout Conservation Scotland, on protecting wild salmonids from sea lice from Scottish salmon farms. Steve Farrell Clerk to the Rural Economy and Connectivity Committee Room T3.40 The Scottish Parliament Edinburgh Tel: steve.farrell@parliament.scot

2 REC/S5/16/14/A The papers for this meeting are as follows Agenda Item 1 FRC Project Update PRIVATE PAPER Agenda Item 2 Transport Infrastructure Projects Update PRIVATE PAPER Agenda Item 3 Note by the Clerk Note by the Clerk REC/S5/16/14/1 REC/S5/16/14/2 (P) REC/S5/16/14/3 REC/S5/16/14/4 (P) REC/S5/16/14/5 REC/S5/16/14/6

3 REC/S5/16/14/1 Rural Economy and Connectivity Committee 14th Meeting, 2016 (Session 5), Wednesday 14 December 2016 Forth Replacement Crossing Project Update Introduction Today the Committee will hear from the Forth Replacement Crossing (FRC) Project Team who will give a progress report. The team appeared before the REC Committee on 7 September 2016 and regularly provided updates to the previous Infrastructure and Capital investment (ICI) Committee. The FRC scheme includes construction of the Queensferry Crossing, a new threetower, cable-stayed bridge between Fife and Edinburgh. The project has a 13.7 mile (22km) footprint, which includes major improvements to the surrounding road network on the north and south of the Forth. A written update on the project is included in the annex. Claire Murrie Rural Economy and Connectivity Committee December 2016

4 REC/S5/16/14/1

5 REC/S5/16/14/1

6 REC/S5/16/14/1

7 REC/S5/16/14/1

8 REC/S5/16/14/1

9 REC/S5/16/14/1

10 REC/S5/16/14/1

11 Forth Replacement Crossing November 2016 Cause for celebration: the Queensferry Crossing Centre Tower deck span, at 644 metres, has been officially recognised as the longest, free-standing, balanced cantilever structure ever built anywhere in the world. Project Directors Update A round up of the latest progress on the Queensferry Crossing construction project. Page 2 Photo Update Our four page photo spread brings you up to speed with all the latest action on-site. Plus: news of a Guinness World Record! Centre Pages Technical Focus Closing the gaps: with the deck construction nearing completion, we take a look at how the final deck sections are installed. Back Page

12 Welcome A World Record for the Queensferry Crossing Welcome to the latest edition of the Queensferry Crossing s Project Update newsletter. Significant progress has been made in the past three months and the final shape and appearance of the bridge is now very clear for all to see. David Climie & Michael Martin. This may account for the comments we sometimes receive from members of the public suggesting that the bridge must be almost finished. In fact, there remains a lot of detailed work to do between now and the opening of the bridge. But, first, an update on recent progress. In September, we lifted the last of 36 deck segments on to the Centre Tower. This has resulted in the Centre Tower span becoming the longest freestanding, balanced cantilever structure ever built (644 metres), a feat of engineering officially recognised in October by Guinness World Records. We are delighted with this achievement. In total, we have installed 104 deck segments (at the time of writing) out of a total of 110. In July, we achieved the first closure on the Project when we joined the North Tower span to the northern approach viaduct. This was followed, in October, by the closure of the gap between the Centre and South Tower deck spans. These closure operations are always important and technically challenging milestones on any bridge construction project. Two more principal closures remain to be carried out on the Queensferry Crossing. The final and historic closure will be between the South Tower and the southern approach viaduct. When this stage is reached, we will be able to complete the on-going casting of the concrete deck surface on the southern approach viaduct. (Turn to Technical Focus on the back page for details of the technical challenges involved in achieving these large-scale closures.) We are on schedule to complete the casting of the deck surface on the northern approach viaduct by the end of the year. This is what the final road surface will be laid on. Nearby, on land, work is continuing on the new and re-positioned Ferrytoll roundabout which opened to traffic in mid October, handling local traffic travelling to and from the Queensferry Crossing and the North Queensferry, Rosyth and Inverkeithing areas. It has been a tremendously complex operation to create a new roundabout in a slightly different position while keeping the existing junction open to traffic. In September, a new temporary northbound slip road to the Ferrytoll junction opened which, in fact, uses what will become a permanent, dedicated bus lane link from the Forth Road Bridge once the new bridge is open. Our thanks go to motorists here and, indeed, elsewhere across the site on both banks of the Forth for their continuing understanding and patience which has done much to minimise any potential traffic disruption. On the southside network connections, the laying of the final road surface on the new stretch of M90 motorway between the Queensferry Crossing and the existing trunk roads is scheduled to be completed by the end of the year. All ten of the new motorway signage gantries have been successfully installed. Resurfacing works on the B800 between the Tesco roundabout and the existing A90 Queensferry junction are continuing, together with the installation of a new bus lane, and should be complete in November. This autumn will see us complete the removal of most of the remaining temporary steel formwork on the towers. This will include the remaining tower-top formwork on the Centre Tower as well as the tall, triangular trestle structures beneath each of the deck spans. Eagle-eyed passers-by will have noticed that the dismantling has already started of the blue deck-top erection traveller cranes used to lift the individual 750 tonne (on average) deck segments up 60 metres (200ft) from barges into position. Also now gearing up is the mechanical, electrical and plumbing (MEP) works. This involves the installation of the electrical systems needed to power the street lighting, sign gantries and architectural lighting on the outside of the bridge, as well as the complex dehumidification systems for the deck segment tubs and the structural health monitoring and fire detection systems. Also needing power will be the maintenance shuttle monorail system and the tower elevators which will be installed next year. Once all four deck closures are completed, the final road surface will have to be laid across the bridge, along with the wind-shielding structures, expansion joints, sign gantries and navigation lights on the bridge structure itself. Future issues of this Project Update will look in detail at these all-important elements. So, as you can see, great progress is being made and much remains to be done. We are immensely proud of what is being achieved out there often in hostile weather conditions by a first class team of committed and skilled people who are all working hard to complete this magnificent, world-class bridge to the highest possible standards. How the Queensferry Crossing will look when completed. David Climie Transport Scotland Project Director Michael Martin FCBC Project Director 2

13 Community Bang Goes the Borders Science Festival 2016 In September, Andy O Kane, FCBC s Networks Structures Manager, attended the annual Bang Goes the Borders science festival at St Mary s School in Melrose where he spoke to over 600 up-andcoming scientists and engineers about the Queensferry Crossing and explained some of the construction techniques and materials being used on the project. Bang Goes the Borders is aimed at families and is sponsored by Heriot Watt University. It has been run at St Mary s School in Melrose since 2010 and has significantly increased in size year on year. This year, schools and universities from across the UK gathered to give presentations, mount exhibitions and conduct workshops looking at a range of modern technical, biological and scientific challenges ranging from building rocketpropelled model cars, constructing major bridges, designing lightweight kayaks (and putting them to the test on the nearby River Budding civil engineers in Melrose enjoy learning about how the Queensferry Crossing is being constructed Tweed) to mixing bacteria with antibiotics and treating germs with probiotics. Liam Harvey, Headmaster of St Mary s School, commented: We are hugely grateful to Andy O Kane for his contribution to the success of the science festival. The Queensferry Crossing is a fascinating engineering project and it was inspirational for pupils, parents, teachers and other exhibitors to hear all about the construction of this wonderful new bridge. Andy was inundated with visitors to his room, all eager to learn as much as they could. Queensferry High Visits FCBC Laboratory Lab inspected and approved, FCBC s Sharon Johnson delivers a load of newly batched concrete. Also in September, pupils from Queensferry High School visited FCBC s materials testing laboratory in Rosyth dockyard as part of Concrete in the Classroom, an educational programme for secondary school pupils designed to give them a basic understanding of concrete technology and the employment options available within the sector. Concrete Scotland, supported by the Construction Industry Training Board (CITB) Scotland, arranges site visits to concrete plants, manufacturing facilities and construction sites so that pupils can contextualise their learning experiences in the real world of work. For Queensferry High School pupils, where better for a site visit than the Queensferry Crossing right on their doorstep? After all, the bridge will be made up of approximately 80% concrete when complete and is already the holder of the world record for the largest quantity of concrete (16,869m³) ever poured continuously under water. During the visit, the S3 pupils were able to see the various material tests that typically take place on large construction projects. One of the pupils remarked: I hadn t realised the number of different jobs in construction until we visited the Queensferry Crossing. It was quite an eye-opener. Nicola Wilkie, Science teacher at the school, commented: The pupils were engaged with the process and it was an excellent opportunity for them to find out what was happening in their own community. They have had an excellent experience in developing their knowledge of the construction industry. Dale Lyon, Director of Concrete Scotland, added: We are grateful to FCBC for facilitating such a great visit which incorporated an overview of the Queensferry Crossing construction project as well as the fascinating visit to the site s materials testing laboratory. 3

14 Queensferry Crossing Photo Collage TOWERS: DECK: 1 Night-time view of Centre Tower & South Tower deck spans at point of maximum temporary vertical deflection. The deflection (up to about 4 metres) is caused by length of cantilever and weight of deck sections being lifted. 2 Another deck section is lifted into place on the South Tower. 3 After the South Tower/Centre Tower closure deck section has been lifted into place and attached to the South Tower deck, a tiny gap remains before the section is joined to the Centre Tower deck, achieving full closure. 4 The South Tower/Centre Tower closure deck section makes its way towards its destination. 5 Close up view of the end of the Centre Tower Standing proudly on the southernmost deck section of the deck span as the gap between it and the South Tower gets ever smaller. 6 A crew boat arrives at the Centre Tower with the North Tower in the Centre Tower span as Shantha Chinniah, Guinness World background. 7 Not far to go now: the gap narrows between the North Records Senior Adjudicator, presents the certificate to Tower and Centre Tower road decks. Iain Cookson and colleagues. Centre Tower Construction Manager, Iain Cookson (left) with FCBC Project Director, Michael Martin, and Centre Tower Senior Engineer, Calum Henderson. VIADUCTS: 1 A rainbow frames the new bridge and the southern approach viaduct. 2 General view of the northern approach viaduct and the North Abutment. The temporary cladding on top of the structure is to provide weather protection for the on-going concrete deck laying operations. 3 The southern approach viaduct is supported on eight massive, V-shaped, reinforced concrete piers. 4 Preparation work underway for the next concrete deck pour on the southern approach viaduct. Note the criss-cross of steel bars over which the concrete will be poured producing incredibly strong reinforced concrete. 5 A concrete pour underway on the deck of the northern approach viaduct. 6 Aerial view of the 543m long southern approach viaduct. Note separate structures for north and southbound traffic. The Centre Tower construction team celebrates their world record achievement. It s a World Record! 1 Aerial view showing the joining of the South and Centre Tower decks in October. 2 It s not always fair weather out in the middle of the Forth but, when it is, it makes a great picture! 3 A unique site: three iconic bridges spanning three centuries, each representing the highest standards of civil engineering of the time. 4 Passing traffic: the North Tower hoist (on right) heading down to road deck level passes the upward bound basket taking two team members up the side of the tower to continue stay-cable installation operations. 5 Stay cables are the signature feature of the Queensferry Crossing. Here they cascade down to road deck level from the Centre Tower. 6 A spectacular view from the top of the Centre Tower looking towards the North Tower. ROADS: 1 View of new M90 South Queensferry junction The Queensferry Crossing construction project has showing new roundabout, slip roads and final carriageway surface on broken another world record. In October, the Centre northbound carriageway. Next stage finish the southbound carriageway Tower deck span, measuring an incredible 644m in and landscaping. 2 aerial view of new motorway as it approaches the length, became the longest, free-standing, balanced new bridge from the south. 3 The new stretch of A90 where it joins the cantilever structure the world has ever seen. This existing A90 south of the Forth Road Bridge is almost complete. Final road surface, white lines, overhead sign gantries, lamp posts, anti-noise fencing unique feat of engineering was officially recognised by Guinness World and landscaping are all in place. 4 Aerial view of the complex roadworks at Records in a ceremony on the Centre Tower on 7th October. Ferrytoll, north of the Queensferry Crossing, where the construction of a new The achievement has been the cause of celebration by the entire motorway flyover bridge, a re-positioned roundabout, creation of new busproject team. Iain Cookson, FCBC Centre Tower Manager, said: lanes and a re-routed B981 to and from North Queensferry have been achieved Ever since we lifted the first of the 36 deck sections into while keeping all existing roads open to traffic. 5 Installation of the large overhead position in September 2015, this has been a tremendous team sign gantries on the new stretch of M90 south of the new bridge was carried out day effort. We are incredibly proud of what we have built. The and night. 6 Laying the road surface on the newly repositioned Ferrytoll roundabout Queensferry Crossing is an amazing construction project to just north of the Queensferry Crossing. The new roundabout was fully opened to traffic be involved with. We will all be lucky if anything else in October. 7 A technique called echelon paving was used to lay the final road surface comes close to matching it in the rest of our careers! on the new length of dual carriageway outside South Queensferry. This reduces the number Messages of congratulations have come in from of surface joints needed by using three tipper lorries and up to 30 people to lay the black top around the world as well as from people in simultaneously across the whole width of the new road. Fife, Edinburgh and West Lothian, reflecting the pride local people feel in the new, world class bridge being built in their midst

15 Technical Focus Closing the Gaps A significant construction milestone was reached in October with the closure of the gap between the Centre and South Tower deck spans. Here, Martin Romberg, Senior Design Engineer with the Queensferry Crossing s Design Joint Venture, explains the challenges involved in closing the gap successfully. We have now lifted and installed 104 out of a total of 110 deck sections which will eventually form the Queensferry Crossing s motorway road deck which, in less than a year s time, will be carrying tens of thousands of vehicles across the Forth every day. The operations to lift the huge composite steel and concrete deck sections, weighing an average of 750 tonnes, into place 60m (200ft) above the waters of the Forth have been described in previous issues of this Project Update (see, for example, the September 2015 issue available online at address below). Our focus now is on closing the gaps. At 6.1m by 40m by 5m, the deck sections used to close the gaps between the main deck spans are smaller than the main deck sections but, nevertheless, weigh a massive 300 tonnes. It is a technically challenging operation to slot these sections into place because the space to be filled between the main deck spans, constructed over the The South Tower/Centre Tower closure deck section heads towards the gap past 14 months, is incredibly narrow. In fact, as the section completes its journey upwards, we only have 100mm clearance on either side, representing exceptionally tight tolerances. So complete accuracy during the entire lifting operation is absolutely vital. To help with this, we push the entire South Tower deck span back by 300mm using powerful hydraulic jacks attached to the South Tower itself. This creates a gap sufficiently wide to allow the closure deck section to slip into place. The next step is to join the newly arrived section to the South span in much the same way as all the previous deck sections have been installed by welding it into place before pouring a reinforced concrete stitch across the top of the joint to create the final deck surface on which the blacktop will eventually be laid. Unlike other deck sections, the closure sections are not bolted into place, but a series of temporary tension bars pull the two decks tightly together allowing the welding operation to take place. Once the section is fully attached on one side to the South deck span, we are ready to attach the other side to the neighbouring Centre Tower deck. Before we can do this, however, it is vital to check that the horizontal and vertical alignments are an exact match. By altering the tensioning of the stay-cables supporting the already installed deck sections, we can lift the Almost there: the closure deck section slots neatly into position two leading edges to exactly the correct geometry. When everything is ready, we slowly release the compression on the jacks at the South Tower so that the over 600m long South Tower deck span can move back the 300mm, thus closing the gap and allowing the other side of the closure section to be welded and concreted into position. When this is complete, full closure has been achieved. A total of four principal closures will be carried out on this amazing construction project. So far, we have successfully achieved two. As with most things on this job, the principal challenge is the weather. Hundreds of measurements and checks are carried out before and during the closure operation to minimise the risk of anything going wrong 60m up, but the one thing we cannot control is the famous wind out in the Forth. Happily, the operation to close the Centre/South Tower gap went very smoothly and we now turn our attention to preparing for the next closure which will join the Centre and North Tower deck spans. Contacting the FRC team There are a number of ways you can contact us to ask questions, provide comments, make a complaint or find out more about the Forth Replacement Crossing project: Fife A90 Call the dedicated 24 hour Project Hotline the team enquiries@forthreplacementcrossing.info Look for us online: Or go to the Queensferry Crossing YouTube channel Or drop into the Contact & Education Centre Adjacent Forth Road Bridge Administration Office, South Queensferry, Edinburgh EH30 9SF Opening times Mon-Thu: , Fri: , Sat: Firth of Forth B924 A904 We are here B907 South Queensferry B924 A90 Edinburgh A90 B800 A8000 West Lothian

16 REC/S5/16/14/3 Rural Economy and Connectivity Committee 14th Meeting, 2016 (Session 5), Wednesday 14 December 2016 Major Transport Infrastructure Projects Update Introduction Today the Committee will hear from the Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Jobs and Fair Work who will give an update on major transport infrastructure projects, following a letter which was sent to the Committee on 9 December The Cabinet Secretary previously appeared before the committee on 29 June Further information on that meeting can be found in the Official Report. The letter from the Cabinet Secretary for Economy, Jobs and Fair Work is included in the annex. Amy Kerr Rural Economy and Connectivity Committee December 2016

17

18

19 REC/S5/16/14/5 Rural Economy and Connectivity Committee 14 th Meeting 2015 (Session 5), Wednesday 14 December 2016 Introduction Public Petition PE1236 A90/A937 junction at Laurencekirk PE PE1236, lodged on 16 February 2009: Petition by Jill Fotheringham, calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to improve safety measures on the A90 by constructing a grade separated junction where the A937 crosses the A90 at Laurencekirk. Background to PE The A90 is a trunk road connecting central Edinburgh with Fraserburgh, although the route between a point several miles to the north of the Forth Road Bridge and Perth is classified as the M90. The A90 used to run through the centre of Laurencekirk, until a bypass was constructed in the mid-1980s. There are three at-grade junctions connecting Laurencekirk with this stretch of the A90. This petition relates to the southernmost of these, which is a staggered crossroads with the A937, a road which links Laurencekirk with Montrose. Previous Consideration 3. The Public Petitions Committee (PPC) previously considered petition PE778, also submitted by Jill Campbell and took evidence from the petitioner in November The Committee closed the petition in March 2005 after receiving confirmation from the then Scottish Executive that a series of road safety improvements would be made. These were implemented in The current petition, PE1236, was considered extensively by the PPC in both Sessions 3 and 4. The petition was referred to the Infrastructure and Capital Investment Committee (ICI) for further consideration in 2012 and from to 2016 the Committee received written and oral evidence from Transport Scotland, NESTRANS, Aberdeenshire and Angus Councils as well as representatives of the community. 5. All written and oral evidence and updates received during session 4 are available on the previous ICI Committee s web pages: ittees/61721.aspx 6. All background information relating to the petition is available on the petition section of the Scottish Parliament website: 1

20 REC/S5/16/14/5 Rural Economy Committee Consideration 7. At its meeting on 26 October 2016, the Rural Economy and Connectivity Committee questioned the Minister for Transport on the Scottish Government s stated commitment to deliver the grade separated junction at Laurencekirk. The Minister agreed to provide further information on the indicative timescale for the design, development and delivery of the proposed project. At the same meeting, the Committee considered the petition and agreed keep it open and to consider it further once the additional information had been received from the Minister. 8. The Minister responded to the Committee on 24 November, highlighting the Government s intention to identify a preferred junction layout by 2018, and providing that no objections are raised in response to the draft Order, begin construction in The Minister s full response is included in the Annexe. Action 9. Members are invited to consider correspondence received from the Minister for Transport and the Islands and reach a view on whether it wishes to take any further action in relation to the petition. Claire Murrie Rural Economy and Connectivity Committee December

21 REC/S5/16/14/5 Annexe Correspondence from Humza Yousaf MSP, Minister for Transport and the Islands to the Rural Economy and Connectivity Committee, dated 24 November PE1236: A90/A937 JUNCTION AT LAURENCEKIRK- NOTE FOR REC COMMITTEE To provide the committee with further information on the process for major infrastructure projects and an approximate timetable for the start date by which work will begin at the Laurencekirk junction (Col 42-45) Earlier this year we announced 24 million for the design and construction of a new grade-separated junction at Laurencekirk as part of a package of additional investment alongside Aberdeen City Region Deal, and we remain committed to completing this important upgrade for the people of the north east. Following the appointment of consultants in September, Transport Scotland is now taking forward the next stage of design development, which is the options assessment, and thereafter through the relevant statutory procedures. The on-going design and assessment process to identify a preferred junction layout is scheduled to be complete in Development and detailed assessment of the preferred option will follow this culminating in publication of the draft Orders in 2019 for formal comment. Progress thereafter on the delivery of the scheme is dependent on the level and nature of representation received in response to the published draft Orders. However, subject to no objections being received following the publication of draft Orders it is estimated that the earliest construction could commence is While there is still a lot of development work to be carried out we will continue to push forward the preparation stages to deliver this scheme as soon as possible bringing improved road safety and economic benefits to road users and the local community in Laurencekirk and the wider north east. 3

22 REC/S5/16/14/6 Rural Economy and Connectivity Committee 14 th Meeting 2015 (Session 5), Wednesday 14 December 2016 Public Petition PE1598 Protecting wild salmonids from sea lice from Scottish salmon farms Introduction 1. PE1598, lodged on 25 February 2016: Petition by Guy Linley-Adams on behalf of Salmon and Trout Conservation Scotland, calling on the Scottish Parliament to urge the Scottish Government to strengthen Scottish legislative and regulatory control of marine fish farms to protect wild salmonids of domestic and international conservation importance. Background to PE The petition relates to the regulatory control of marine fish farms in order to limit the impact of sea lice on wild salmonids. Salmon farms arguably make a greater contribution than wild fish to the total numbers of salmon lice in the environment. Adult sea lice live on the skin of fish and can cause infection. Public Petitions Committee Consideration 3. At its meeting on 29 September 2016, the Public Petitions Committee (PPC) agreed to refer the petition to the Rural Economy and Connectivity Committee. 4. The PPC had previously considered the petition on 30 June 2016 and agreed to write to the organisations below. The PPC also agreed to seek further information on practices in Norway. Marine Scotland/Scottish Government; Scottish Environment Protection Agency (SEPA); Scottish Salmon Producers Organisation; Atlantic Salmon Trust; and the Association of Salmon Fishery Boards. 5. Responses received are available on the Petitions website. In addition, the REC Committee also received correspondence relating to the petition from Dr Martin Jaffa on 20 October SPICe provided a briefing dated 18 August 2016 in response to the PPC s request for information on sea lice reporting in Norway. The briefing also provides an extract from the Canadian Senate s Committee on Fisheries and Oceans 2015 report on the regulation of aquaculture, which contains details of measures being taken in Norway to reduce the prevalence of sea lice though both regulation and mitigation measures. 1

23 REC/S5/16/14/6 Rural Economy and Connectivity Committee Consideration 7. At its meeting on 26 October 2016, the Committee agreed to write to the Cabinet Secretary for Rural Economy and Connectivity seeking further information on the issues raised in the petition. 8. The Committee received a response from the Cabinet Secretary on 24 November 2016, where he emphasised the valuable contribution of both aquaculture and wild fisheries to the Scottish rural economy and the importance of successful interaction between these sectors. 9. The Cabinet Secretary sought to reassure the committee that a new sea lice policy has been introduced to improve sea lice management and compliance. This includes new reporting levels, increased monitoring and, where necessary, remedial action at site level. He further outlined the details of a major 10-year research project to be undertaken by the Scottish Aquaculture Research Forum (SARF) collecting data on the effectiveness of protective sea lice medicine in relation to wild salmon. 10. The Cabinet Secretary s full response is included in the annexe. Action: 11. The Committee is invited to consider the Cabinet Secretary s letter and reach a view on whether it wishes to take any further action in relation to the petition. Claire Murrie Rural Economy and Connectivity Committee December

24 REC/S5/16/14/6 Annex Letter from Fergus Ewing, Cabinet Secretary for Rural Economy and Connectivity, dated 24 November

25 4 REC/S5/16/14/6

26 5 REC/S5/16/14/6

27 6 REC/S5/16/14/6

28 7 REC/S5/16/14/6