STATE CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION, MUMBAI TO BE HEARD ON DAY OF FEBRUARY, 2016 AT A.M. ( WILL SIT AT )

Transcription

1 STATE CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION, MUMBAI TO BE HEARD ON THE 16 TH DAY OF FEBRUARY, 2016 AT A.M. DB.I ( WILL SIT AT ) OLD SECRETARIAT BUILDING,GROUND FLOOR, KALA GHODA SMT.USHA. S. THAKARE HON BL PRESIDING JUDICIAL MEMBER MR. DHANRAJ KHAMATKAR.. HON BLE MEMBER NOTE :- 1) The Advocate who appears as a proxy Advocate and/or holding for, for Advocate on record shall submit authority letter as per direction dated 20 th July ) Mentioning in the morning session at & 2.00 p. m. only. -1-

2 3) In first session, the admission and order matters will be taken. If the admission board is over in the first session, immediately final hearing matters will be taken otherwise the final hearing matters shown on board will be taken in chronological order in the second session. PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGEMENT SMT.USHA. S. THAKARE HON BL PRESIDING JUDICIAL MEMBER MR. DHANRAJ KHAMATKAR.. HON BLE MEMBER A. COMPLAINT 1 CC/13/453 CONSUMER WELFARE ASSOC. THE ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO.LTD J GAI SAPNA BHUPTANI -2-

3 DUE ADMISSIONS A) ADMISSION OF FIRST APPEAL 1 A/15/271 STATE BANK OF INDIA RAJENDRA SADASHIV PARDESHI MEDHA BEHRES S.V. VISHWA-KARMA -3-

4 2 A/15/322 SUDHARDH CONSTRUCTION MR.SWAMINARAYAN JAYRAMAN M.TRIPATHI & CO. A/15/707 M/S.MAHESHWARI SOFT SOLUTION 3 2+ MILIND PARAB SOU.BEENA D KABRA MATTERS FOR HEARING A. HEARING OF CONSUMER COMPLAINT 4 CC/03/165 SHARAD BHALERAO SHAMRAO DR.SATISH GUJARATHI & ORS PATWAR-DHAN RAHUL GANDHI PRABHA-WALKAR CC/07/109 PRAMOD RADHESHYAM KEJRIWAL & ANR Y.C.NAIDU 5 ARUN KEJRIWAL M/S.S.D.CONSTRUCTIONS & ANR AJAY PAWAR MR SANTOSH R KEJRIWAL & ORS 6 CC/07/110 M/S.S.D.CONSTRUCTION & ORS Y.C.NAIDU ARUN KEJRIWAL AJAY PAWAR -4-

5 7 CC/11/07 MR. RIZWAN G. MERCHANT & ORS. A. V. PATWARDHAN M/S. HARIANI & MR. DHEERAJ WADHAWAN & ORS. CO 8 CC/11/179 RAJPAL ENTERPRISES & ORS CONWARE,CONTAINER FREIGHT STATION S SHENOY DHIRAJ CHAVAN ASHWIN DUGGAL CHAITRA RAO 9 CC/11/180 GLENMARK PHARMACEUTICALS LTD & ORS. CONWARE,CONTAINER FREITH STATION S SHENOY DHIRAJ CHAVAN ASHWIN DUGGAL CHAITRA RAO 10 CC/11/181 CIPLA LTD & ORS. CONWARE, CONTAINER FREITH STATION S SHENOY DHIRAJ CHAVAN ASHWIN DUGGAL CHAITRA RAO 11 CC/11/182 GLOBAL INFLUENCE & ORS. CONWARE, CONTAINER FREITH STATION S SHENOY DHIRAJ CHAVAN ASHWIN DUGGAL CHAITRA RAO M J BIOOHARMA PVT LTD & ORS. S SHENOY CC/11/183 DHIRAJ CHAVAN -5-

6 12 CONWARE, CONTAINER FREITH STATION ASHWIN DUGGAL CHAITRA RAO CC/11/302 MR.MOHAN BABURAO DIVEKAR A G SABNIS 13 M/S TEJASWINI HOMES PVT LTD MEHUL SHAH 14 CC/11/303 MR.SACHIN SUDHIR DIWADKAR M/S TEJASWINI HOMES PVT LTD IN PERSON MEHUL SHAH CC/13/502 MR.YOGESH R WARAD WARUNJIKAR 15 TEIRTH DEVELOPERS & SUYOJIT INFRASTRUCTURE LTD. RAHUL GANDHI CC/13/503 MR.VAIBHAV E FARKANDE WARUNJIKAR 16 TEIRTH DEVELOPERS & SUYOJIT INFRASTRUCTURE LTD. RAHUL GANDHI CC/13/509 MR.RAJESH N SHINDE & ANR WARUNJIKAR 17 TEIRTH DEVELOPERS & SUYOJIT INFRASTRUCTURE LTD. RAHUL GANDHI -6-

7 C) HEARING OF FIRST APPEAL SHRI ASHOK J.BANTHIA & ORS 18 A/01/922 SHRI SHARAD S.PATIL & ORS VISHWAS CHITNIS MR.RANVIR SINGH S/O KEHAR SINGH 19 A/01/950 ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO.LTD S.R.SINGH MR.KEHAR SINGH 20 A/01/951 ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO.LTD S.R.SINGH M/S. JET AIRWAYS 21 A/13/176 MR. RAM MOHAN NAGARKAR VINOD JUWALE H.M. INAMDAR 22 A/13/ SUVARNA KIRTI M. MATHEKAR TATA MOTORS LTD & ORS. MRS.M.U WARUNJIKAR ASHUTOSH MARATHE -7-

8 SHRI S S SANGLE 23 A/13/298 THE DIV.MANAGER, ROYAL SUNDARAM ALLIANCE INSURANCE CO.LTD P.KAYANDE A.S. VIDYARTHI DIWAKAR LAXMAN GONDANE 24 A/15/379 KOTAK MAHINDRA OLD MUTUAL LIFE INS.CO.LTD B.A.TRIPATHI 25 A/15/ S.B.I CARD & PAYMENTS SERVICES PVT.LTD SHRI.YOGESH CHAMPALAL JAIN A.V.PATWAR-DHAN DILIP BODAKE 26 A/15/ COX & KINGS LTD SHRI.YOGNATH BHATTACHARYA HEMANT KENJALKAR V.B.SHARMA Sd/- (A.S.WAIRAGADE) ( REGISTRAR (LEGAL) STATE COMMISSION, -8-

9 -9-

10 STATE CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION, MUMBAI TO BE HEARD ON THE 15 TH DAY OF FEBRUARY, 2016 AT A.M. SB.I ( WILL SIT AT ) OLD SECRETARIAT BUILDING,GROUND FLOOR, KALA GHODA MR. P. B. JOSHI HON BLE PRESIDING JUDICIAL MEMBER NOTE :- 1) The Advocate who appears as a proxy Advocate and/or holding for, for Advocate on record shall submit authority letter as per direction dated 20 th July

11 2) Mentioning in the morning session at & 2.00 p. m. only. 3) In first session, the admission and order matters will be taken. If the admission board is over in the first session, immediately final hearing matters will be taken otherwise the final hearing matters shown on board will be taken in chronological order in the second session. ADDITIONAL FRESH MATTERS A) ADMISSION OF CONSUMER COMPLAINT NAME OF COMPLAINANTS/OPPONENTS, SR. NO CASE NO. NAME OF APPELLANTS/RESPONDENTS, NAME OF REVISION PETITIONERS/NON APPLICANTS, NAME OF ADVOCATE OF BOTH THE PARTIES NEXT DATE NAME OF APPLICANTS/NON APPLICANTS MRS DEVKI DEVI VISHWAKARMA 1 CC/16/77 SHANKUNTALA MATERNITY AND GEN HOSPITAL MATERNITY RAJESH KHOBRAGADE MA/16/59 MR NARESH S TALAVLIKAR 2 IN CC/16/80 2+ M/S EROS ELVATORS AND ESCALATORS PVT LTD G.K.TRIPATHI -11-

12 (B) ADMISSION OF FIRST APPEAL MA/16/64 (DELAY) PRASAD B.BHAVE 3 IN M.NALLURI A/16/144 PANAMHANS CHS LTD 2+ 4 MA/16/84 IN A/16/183 MAHARASHTRA STATE ELECTRICITY DISTRIBUTION CO.LTD S.S.JINSIWALE 2+ AMJAD C PATEL C) ADMISSION OF REVISION PETITION 5 RP/16/49 2S M/S COUNTRY CLUB HOSPITALITY AND HOLIDAY SHRI BHARAT SHEMLANI G.K.TRIPATHI -12-

13 EXECUTION APPLICATIONS i ) EXECUTION APPLICATIONS FILED UNDER SECTION 27 OF CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT, EA/14/08 ANAND S JAISINGH NEW INDIA INSURANCE CO.LTD H.H.TRIVEDI D.R.MAHADIK DUE ADMISSIONS A) ADMISSION OF CONSUMER COMPLIANTS 7 CC/15/722 M/S.AKSHAY APARTMENT CHS.LTD U.P. WARUNJIKAR M/S.ASSOCIATED ENGINEERS DEEPAK BAPAT 8 CC/15/726 AUTOBAHN ENTERPRISES PVT LTD IN PERSON -13-

14 B) ADMISSION OF FIRST APPEAL MA/14/360 IN A/14/842 MR.TUSHAR RAJU 9 2+ ARPANA PEREIRA MR.AMIT SITARAM KAMBLE A/14/996 MA/15/154 IN HITENDRA TAKHTANI 10 A/15/320 RESHMI SINGH 2+ BAJAJ FINANCE LTD MA/14/ IN A/14/ BHARAT LALJI PAWAR DILIP DHONDU SHIRSEKAR SAROJ PAGARE NILESH MOHITE 12 MA/15/163 IN MRS.SHAHIDA A SHAIKH S.P.NALAVDE -14-

15 A/15/341 MR.ABDUL HASAN VODGAMA MA/15/217 IN A/15/498 MAHILA ARTHIK VIKAS MAHAMANDAL AR MRS.ARUNA DONGRE 2+ NATIONAL INSURANCE CO.LTD REGULAR ORDER MATTERS i) REGULAR ORDER MATTERS ARISING FROM CONSUMER COMPLAINTS 14 CC/04/07 KHATAVWADI TENANTS CO-OP HSG.SOC.LTD M/S.VISHAL TEKNIKS ( CIVIL ) PVT.LTD & ORS ASHUTOSH MARATHE CHIMALKAR VICHARE CC/12/12 TORRENT PHARMACEUTICALS LTD. & ORS. MR. SANJIT SHENOY 15 CONWARE CONTAINER FREIGHT STATION ASHWIN DUGGAL & ASS 16 CC/12/13 SHRIMANKAR GAS CAR SERVICES P. LTD & ORS. MR. SANJIT SHENOY -15-

16 CONWARE CONTAINER FREIGHT STATION ASHWIN DUGGAL & ASS 17 CC/12/14 CHANDNEE HI FASHION P. LTD & ORS CONWARE CONTAINER FREIGHT STATION MR. SANJIT SHENOY ASHWIN DUGGAL & ASS 18 CC/12/23 KRAFT SALES AND SERVICES (I) LTD & ANR. CONWARE CONTAINER FREIGHT STATION MR. SANJIT SHENOY ASHWIN DUGGAL & ASSOCIATES MR. BABASAHEB Y. GAWADE 19 CC/13/ M/S. P V CONSTRUCTION P. Y. SHANKAR RAJESHWAR DESHMUKH 20 CC/13/120 SUBHASH N ANBHUYANE & ORS M/S.EVERGREEN DEVELOPERS S.D.INAMDAR CHAITRA RAO CC/13/121 SUBHASH N ANBHUYANE & ORS S.D.INAMDAR

17 M/S.EVERGREEN DEVELOPERS CHAITRA RAO CC/13/497 SHAKILA ABDUL SALAM SIDDIQUI A.MARATHE 22 ROYAL PALMS ( INDIA ) PVT.LTD JITNDRA KESARKA 23 CC/13/498 SALAM ABDUL SIDDIQUI ROYAL PALMS ( INDIA ) PVT.LTD A.MARATHE JITNDRA KESARKA CC/13/434 MR BHARAT ACHARYA 24 V.R.GUPTA BMW SHOWROOM SMT.URMILA CHOUDHARY 25 CC/14/191 LIFE LINE HOSPITAL MEDICAL RESEARCH M.P.SALUNKHE DR.SHENOY 26 CC/14/221 GOVINDRAJU PAPABHATHINI VIJAY G GUPTA SADHANA PATIL NILESH MASURKAR CC/15/136 SHRI.SHRIDHAR D GAIKWAD IN PERSON 27 A.T.M CONSTRUCTIONS SAURABH OKA CC/15/163 SHRI.SHRIDHAR.D.GAIKWAD IN PERSON -17-

18 28 A.T.M CONSTRUCTIONS SAURABH OKA II) REGULAR ORDER MATTERS ARISING FROM FIRST APPEAL 29 A/06/1876 UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO. LTD SUNIL DATTATRAY GURUV S. M. VIDYARTHI UDAY WARUNJIKAR 30 RBT/A/16/34 IN A/14/736 1 S L & T FINANCE LTD BABAN T MORE MOHIT BHANSALI Sd/- (A.S.WAIRAGADE) ( REGISTRAR (LEGAL) STATE COMMISSION, STATE CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION, MUMBAI TO BE HEARD ON THE 16 TH DAY OF FEBRUARY,

19 AT A.M. DB.II ( WILL SIT AT C.S.T OFFICE ) JUSTICE MR.A.P.BHANGALE..HON BLE PRESIDENT MR. NARENDRA KAWDE HON BLE MEMBER NOTE :- 1) The Advocate who appears as a proxy Advocate and/or holding for, for Advocate on record shall submit authority letter as per direction dated 20 th July ) Mentioning in the morning session at & 2.00 p. m. only. 3) In first session, the admission and order matters will be taken. If the admission board is over in the first session, immediately final hearing matters will be taken otherwise the final hearing matters shown on board will be taken in chronological order in the second session PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGEMENT -19-

20 MR. P. B. JOSHI HON BLE PRESIDING JUDICIAL MEMBER MR. NARENDRA KAWDE HON BLE MEMBER A. APPEAL 1 A/98/1128 M/S.AUTOMOTIVE MANUFACTURERS LTD SHRI.SURESHCHANDRA KALE DAS GUPTA 2 A/14/300 SMT. BHAGWATI J VYAS THE CORPORATION BANK, ULHASNAGAR A.V.PATWARDHAN VINAYA CHAVAN -20-

21 REGULAR ADMISSIONS A) ADMISSION OF FIRST APPEAL A/16/35 LATIF GANI & SONS 1 AMIT SHARMA ICICI LOMBARD INSURANCE B) ADMISSION OF REVISION PETITION RUSHABH CHS LTD. 2 RP/16/18-21-

22 B.E.S &T UNDERTAKINGS ANAND GAWANDE DUE ADMISSIONS A) ADMISSION OF CONSUMER COMPLIANTS MA/15/86 HANSH DALEEP JETWANI 3 IN CC/11/147 M/S.GURUKRUPA PROPERTIES PVT.LTD A.V. PATWARDHAN PRAVIN WAGLE 2+ A) ADMISSION OF FIRST APPEAL RBT/A/15/867 M/S.M.K.BUILDERS & ANRS 4 IN A/14/437 MRS.CHAMPATAI PANDIT HIRE & ANR PRAVIN SINGH IN PERSON MATTERS FOR HEARING A. HEARING OF CONSUMER COMPLAINT -22-

23 SHRI.VASANT L BHANUSHALI 5 CC/02/195 THE NEW INDIA ASSURANCE CO.LTD ANITA MARATHE A.S. VIDYARTHI 6 CC/12/24 SHRI. SUBHASH VITTHAL RAKHUNDE. M/S. TULSI GROUP M. M. MAHAJAN ARCHANA PISE 7 CC/12/54 CHETAN N. SUTAR M/S HEMAL BUILDERS & ORS ASHUTOSH MARATHE MR.PATWARDHAN MR SURESH EKNATH SHINDE 8 CC/12/283 M/S SHELTER MAKER ( I ) PVT LTD M/S K ASHAR & CO NALIN MAJETHIA CC/12/290 MRS IRSHAD JAHA IQBAL SHAIKH 9 RUTUJA PATIL PIONEER INDIA DEVELOPERS PVT LTD CC/12/291 MOHAMMAD IQBAL SHAIKH -23-

24 10 RUTUJA PATIL PIONEER INDIA DEVELOPERS PVT LTD 11 CC14/381 ZUBEDA MUBARAK KHIRANI RAVI DEVELOPMENT A. M. MARATHE RAIBAKKAR C) HEARING OF FIRST APPEAL 12 A/00/278 RELIANCE INFRASTRUCTURE LTD SHRI.RAVINDRA SHETTY PRAKASH HEGDE 13 A/00/761 Shri. Ajit Mutha, Partner & TRUSTEE The Divisional Manager (P & G.S.) LIFE INSURANCE CORPORATION ANITA MARATHE A. S. VIDYARTHI 14 A/10/859 DR. J. G. KINI SHRI. JAGANNATH ZAGADE & ANR. S. B.PRABHA- WALKAR A.S. VIDYARTHI A/12/827 THE ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO. LTD. A. S. VIDYARTHI

25 SMT. SAKSHI SUNDEEP SURVE HASAN PATEL ASHUTOSH MARATHE 16 A/12/ THE NATIONAL INSURANCE CO. LTD. MR. BHALCHANDRA B. JOSHI SANJAY MHATRE CHODANKAR ASHWIN HAWELIKAR 17 A/14/104 ASHAPURA HABITATS PVT.LTD SOU.SHALAKA N SHINDE P.N.PATIL A.P.REGE 18 A/14/ MRS.VEENA K SHARMA MR.RITESH KUMAR S.SHIRSAT N.MAJETHIA RBT/A/16/129 M/S.ABIDA BUILDERS & DEVELOPERS 19 MANISHA HIMMATRAO SATPUTE 20 RBT/A/16/ RBT/A/16/

26 22 RBT/A/16/ RBT/A/16/175 Sd/- (A.S.WAIRAGADE) ( REGISTRAR (LEGAL) STATE COMMISSION, -26-