APPENDIX J: STAGE 1 ARCHAEOLOGICAL ASSESSMENT

APPENDIX J: STAGE 1 ARCHAEOLOGICAL ASSESSMENT

A.1 Registered Archaeological Sites Within Three Kilometres of the Study Area A total of 112 sites have been registered within three kilometres of the study area boundaries. These sites span the Late Paleo-Indian period, circa 10,000 BP, to the Euro-Canadian period. The registered sites located within a one kilometre radius of the study boundaries are described briefly below. Particulars concerning all sites within three kilometres of the study area are summarized in Table 1. The Waltham site (AlGs-9) is located approximately one kilometre from the northwest corner of the study area. It is a Middle Iroquoian village site of undetermined size located on the westerly branch of Lynde creek. The West Whitby Townline 28 site (AlGr-15) is a precontact camp consisting of eight lithic artifacts. The Henry Hood site (AlGr-71) is located within 100 metres of the study area boundary close to the intersection of Coronation Street and Taunton Road. It is a Euro-Canadian homestead of undetermined size. AlGr-105 is located north of Kingston Road (Highway 2) and west of Audley Road. It is a precontact isolated find consisting of a single chert scraper. The Lynde site (AlGr-110) is located less than one kilometre from the eastern boundary of the study area, on the south side of Taunton Road, east of Coronation Road. It is a Euro-Canadian homestead that dates circa A.D.1810-1840. Site AlGr-160 is located approximately 200 metres from the eastern boundary of the study area and it is a precontact isolated find consisting of a Levanna-type projectile point that dates to the Late Woodland circa A.D. 800. The Bowerman site (AlGr-161) is located in Lynde Creek less than 200 metres from the eastern boundary of the study area and it is a Euro-Canadian homestead of undetermined size. The McGowan Farm site (AlGr-162) is located just to the south of the Bowerman site in the NW corner of the City of Whitby and is less than 200 metres from the eastern boundary of the study area. It is a Euro-Canadian homestead of undetermined size dating to the early to mid 19 th century. The Lynde House site (AlGr-42) is located less than 200 metres from the boundary towards the south eastern edge of the study area. It is a Euro-Canadian homestead. Site AlGr-46 is located less than 100 metres from the study boundary at the south-western edge of the study area. It is a pre-contact isolated find. September 2009 planningalliance 2

TABLE 1: Previously Registered Archaeological Sites Located within 3km of the West Whitby Study Area Borden Name Site Type Culture Researcher* AlGr-2 Rodd Undetermined Pre-Contact A. Roberts 1978 AlGr-9 Hogarth Undetermined Undetermined A. Roberts 1978 AlGr-14 West Whitby Townline Undetermined Early Archaic A. Roberts 1978 26 AlGr-15 West Whitby Townline Camp Pre-Contact A. Roberts 1978 28 AlGr-16 W Whitby Townline 29 Undetermined Late Archaic A. Roberts 1978 AlGr-17 West Whitby Townline Undetermined Late Archaic A. Roberts 1978 20 AlGr-18 West Whitby Townline Isolated Find Pre-Contact A. Roberts 1978 19 AlGr-19 Whitby Townline 31 Isolated Find Pre-Contact A. Roberts 1978 AlGr-20 Whitby Townline 32 Isolated Find Pre-Contact A. Roberts 1978 AlGr-21 Whitby Townline 25 Isolated Find Pre-Contact A. Roberts 1978 AlGr-23 Whitby Townline 21 Isolated Find Archaic A. Roberts 1978 AlGr-24 Whitby Townline 23 Isolated Find Late Archaic A. Roberts 1978 AlGr-25 W Whitby Townline 27 Undetermined Woodland A. Roberts 1978 AlGr-26 W. Whitby Townline 33 Camp Paleo-Indian /Early Archaic A. Roberts 1978 AlGr-28 n/a Undetermined Late Archaic/Early Woodland A. Roberts 1978 AlGr-29 Isolated Find Pre-Contact A. Roberts 1978 AlGr-30 Undetermined undetermined A. Roberts 1978 AlGr-31 Undetermined Late Archaic A. Roberts 1978 AlGr-32 Undetermined Late Archaic A. Roberts 1978 AlGr-33 Undetermined Archaic, Early Paleo-Indian A. Roberts 1978 AlGr-34 Undetermined Pre-Contact A. Roberts 1978 AlGr-35 Undetermined Pre-Contact A. Roberts 1978 AlGr-36 Undetermined Pre-Contact A. Roberts 1978 AlGr-37 Isolated Find Pre-Contact A. Roberts 1978 AlGr-38 Camp Pre-Contact A. Roberts 1978 AlGr-39 Undetermined Late Archaic A. Roberts 1978 AlGr-40 Lagoon Undetermined Pre-Contact A. Roberts 1978 AlGr-42 Lynde House Homestead Euro-Canadian D.A. Brown 1986 AlGr-45 Isolated Find Euro-Canadian O.M.A. 1988 AlGr-46 Isolated Find Pre-Contact O.M.A. 1988 AlGr-47 Lynde Shores East 1 Camp Archaic R. Nisbet 1989 AlGr-48 Lynde Shores East 2 Camp Archaic R. Nisbet 1989 AlGr-49 Lynde Shores East 3 Camp Archaic R. Nisbet 1989 AlGr-50 Lynde Shores East 4 Camp Archaic-Woodland R. Nisbet 1989 AlGr-51 Lynde Shores East 5 Camp Archaic R. Nisbet 1989 AlGr-52 Lynde Shores East 6 Camp Archaic R. Nisbet 1989 AlGr-53 Trumpeter Swan Isolated Find Late Middle Archaic A.S.I. 1990 AlGr-54 Harrier Isolated Find Iroquoian; Late Woodland A.S.I. 1990 AlGr-55 Harlequin Isolated Find prehistoric A.S.I. 1990 AlGr-56 Dunlin Isolated Find Middle Archaic A.S.I. 1990 AlGr-57 Kingfisher Isolated Find Early Woodland A.S.I. 1990 AlGr-58 Robin Homestead Euro-Canadian A.S.I. 1991 AlGr-69 Homestead Euro-Canadian A.S.I. 1993 AlGr-71 Henry Hood Homestead Euro-Canadian A.S.I. 1994 September 2009 planningalliance 3

Borden Name Site Type Culture Researcher* AlGr-90 Isolated Find Early Archaic A.S.I. 1996 AlGr-91 Isolated Find Middle Archaic A.S.I. 1996 AlGr-93 Homestead Euro-Canadian A.S.I. 1996 AlGr-94 Homestead Euro-Canadian A.S.I. 1996 AlGr-105 Isolated Find Pre-Contact A.S.I. 1997 AlGr-110 Lynde Homestead Euro-Canadian A.S.I. 1998 AlGr-160 Isolated Find Late Woodland A.S.I. 2004 AlGr-161 Bowerman Homestead Euro-Canadian A.S.I. 2004 AlGr-173 AlGr-173 Isolated Find Pre-Contact AlGs-9 Waltham Village Middle Iroquoian V. Konrad AlGs-90 Milt Parkin Undetermined Late Archaic AlGs-149 O'Shanter 2 Isolated Find Pre-Contact Y.N.A S. 1994 AlGs-150 O'Shanter 1 Lithic scatter Pre-Contact Y.N.A S. 1994 AlGs-151 O'Shanter 3 Homestead Euro-Canadian Y.N.A S. 1994 AlGs-160 Isolated Find Pre-Contact A.S.I. 1997 AlGs-161 Isolated Find Pre-Contact A.S.I. 1997 AlGs-162 Isolated Find Pre-Contact A.S.I. 1997 AlGs-163 Isolated Find Early Archaic A.S.I. 1997 AlGs-164 Isolated Find Middle Archaic A.S.I. 1997 AlGs-165 Isolated Find Pre-Contact A.S.I. 1997 AlGs-166 Isolated Find Middle Woodland A.S.I. 1997 AlGs-167 Isolated Find Early Woodland A.S.I. 1997 AlGs-168 Isolated Find Early Archaic A.S.I. 1997 AlGs-169 Homestead Euro-Canadian A.S.I. 1997 AlGs-170 Homestead Euro-Canadian A.S.I. 1997 AlGs-171 Transformer Homestead Euro-Canadian A.S.I. 1997 AlGs-172 Carpenter Homestead Euro-Canadian A.S.I. 1997 AlGs-173 Homestead Euro-Canadian A.S.I. 1997 AlGs-174 Madhill Homestead Euro-Canadian A.S.I. 1997 AlGs-216 Steele Valley Camp Early Archaic L. Jackson 1998 AlGs-221 - Camp Middle - Late Archaic AlGs-222 - Camp Archaic AlGs-223 - Isolated Find Middle - Late Archaic AlGs-224 - Isolated Find Archaic AlGs-236 Guthrie Cabin Euro- Canadian AlGs-237 Miller's House Homestead Euro-Canadian AlGs-238 Grist Mill Grist Mill Euro-Canadian AlGs-239 Guthrie Isolated Isolated Find Pre-Contact AlGs-240 N.W. Brown Farmstead Euro-Canadian Y.N.A S. 2002 AlGs-241 - Isolated Find Pre-Contact Y.N.A S. 2002 AlGs-242 - Isolated Find Pre-Contact Y.N.A S. 2002 AlGs-243 - Isolated Find Pre-Contact Y.N.A S. 2002 AlGs-244 McKay Isolated Find Late Archaic AlGs-245 Carruther's Creek 2 Isolated Find Pre-Contact AlGs-246 Carruther's Creek I Lithic Scatter Late Archaic AlGs-247 - Isolated Find Middle Archaic AlGs-248 - Isolated Find Pre-Contact AlGs-249 - Isolated Find Contact period Mississauga AlGs-250 - Isolated Find Pre-Contact September 2009 planningalliance 4

Borden Name Site Type Culture Researcher* AlGs-255 Ira B. Carpenter farmstead Euro-Canadian AlGs-257 - Isolated Find Early Woodland AlGs-258 - Homestead Euro-Canadian AlGs-259 McQuay I Homestead Euro-Canadian AlGs-318 Old Post Inn Tavern Euro-Canadian *A.S.I. Archaeological Services Inc. O.M.A. Ontario Museum of Archaeology Y.N.A S.: York North Archaeological Services A.2 Historic Property Occupants and Features Table 2 summarizes the property owners and historic features identified in the 1877 atlas and includes images of two of the settlement complexes included in the atlas. It should be noted, however, that not all features of interest were mapped systematically in the Ontario series of historical atlases, given that they were financed by subscription, and subscribers were given preference with regard to the level of detail provided on the maps. Moreover, not every feature of interest would have been within the scope of the atlas at the time of its compilation. Nevertheless, the atlas identifies the general locations of over 50 19 th -century farmstead complexes, as well as several saw and grist mills, and a church. TABLE 2: Property Owners/Occupants and Historic Features Illustrated within the Study Area on the 1877 Historic Atlas Con. Lot Owner/Occupant(s) Feature(s) 1 2 3 35 J. Almonu (90 acres in north. ½) --- lots with frontage on Kingston Rd 34 J. Almonu (50 acres, north ½, west ¼) 2 residences 34 E. Hart (50 acres north ½, east ¼) 1 residence 33 E. Hart (50 acres north ½, west ¼) 33 D. Brown (50 acres north ½, east ¼) 32 D. Brown (100 acres north ½) 1 residence 35 W. Hall (72 ½ acres south 1/3) 3 residences 35 J. Hall (72 ½ acres middle 1/3) 1 residence 35 Mrs. Watson (50 acres north 1/3) 1 residence 34 F.A. McKinnie (140 acres) -- 34 J. Wilson (50 acres, north-west ¼) 33 W. McGregor (50 acres southwest ¼) 1 house 33 J. McGregor (50 acres southeast ¼) 1 house 33 S. Mackie (100 acres north ½) 1 house 32 S. Mackie (100 acres, west ½) 1 residence church in NE corner, 4 residences 4 houses fronting on Dundas/Kingston Rd. Lynde Creek 32 D.L. Reed (100 acres east ½) 1 house (Dundas/Kingston Rd) 35 W. Duncan (100 acres south ½) 2 houses, 2 branches of Lynde Creek 35 R. Gutherie (10 acres north ½) 1 house at Taunton 34 W. Duncan (75 acres south part ) 34 Mrs. Watson (25 acres east ¼ of south ½) 34 W. Bailey (100 acres north part) 1 house west of Lynde Creek 33 T. Marquis (100 acres south part) 33 G. McGillivray (100 acres north part) 32 T. Marquis (52.5 acres south part) 32 Q. MGowan (75 acres ) Grist Mill, Saw Mill, 4 houses, mill pond, Lynde Creek September 2009 planningalliance 5

Con. Lot Owner/Occupant(s) Feature(s) 32 Robb Brothers ( 10 acres north part) 1 house 32 G. McGillivray (50 acres north part) 2 houses 31 G. Phipps (82 acres south part) 1 house, Lynde Creek 31 Q. McGowan (18 acres ) 4 35 G. McGillivray (25 acres southwest part) 35 W. Lawrence (95 acres north part) 1 house 35 J. Madhill (50 acres southeast part) 34 J. Madhill (90 acres southeast part) 1 farmstead (Bonny Bank) on Taunton Rd 34 J. Rankin (10 acres southwest part) 1 house on concession road 34 G. McGillivray (100 acres north part) 1 house facing concession road 33 G. Ogston (100 acres south part) 1 house facing concession road 33 Alex Ogston (100 acres north part) 1 house in centre of lot 32 G. Ogston (50 acres southwest part) Lynde Creek 32 Robb Brothers ( 50 acres southeast part 32 C. Lynde (100 acres north part) 1 house facing concession road 31 R. Pardon (100 acres south part) 1 house 31 Mrs. Robb (100 acres north part) 1 house 30 James Gordon (50 acres south west 1 house facing concession road, settled in 1831 part) 30 W. Hudson (50 acres southeast part) 1 house 30 I. Newport (25 acres northwest part) 30 J. Baze (25 acres northwest part) 1 house 30 J. Coffee (50 acres northeast part)) 1 house 29 Tweedie Bothers (200 acres) 28 J. Jones (75 acres south part) 1 house, Lynde Creek 28 J. Cooper, merchant miller (23 acres Grist Mill, 2 houses southeast part) 28 G. Sonley (100 acres north part 27 J.R. Hill (100 acres north part) 3 buildings, Saw and Lumber Mill September 2009 planningalliance 6

A.3 Stage 1 Field Review Photography September 2009 planningalliance 7

Plate 1: Country Lane Golf Course on Country Lane north of Taunton Road. Plate 2: Sheridan Nurseries parking lot and store front on Taunton Road Plate 3: Topsoil and Landscaping material operation on Halls Road, north of Taunton Road. Plate 4: Farmers Market on south side of Dundas Street, east of Halls Road Plate 5: Historic house on Coronation Road north of Taunton Road, corresponding with location of farmstead belonging to C. Lynde in 1877 Illustrated Historical Atlas. Plate 6: Historic house on Coronation Rd south of Taunton Rd. corresponding with the location of a farmstead listed under the Ross Brothers in the 1877 Illustrated Historical Atlas. September 2009 planningalliance 8

Plate 7: House located on the northeast corner of Dundas and Halls Road corresponding to the location of a house in the 1877 Illustrated Historical Atlas. Plate 8: Historic house located on Dundas Street corresponding to location of the house in the 1877 Illustrated Historical Atlas belonging to F.A. McKinnie. Plate 9: A typical agricultural field with archaeological potential. This property is on Halls Road south of Rossland Road. Plate 10: Lynde Creek at north end of study area where it passes under Lyndebrook Road. Plate 11: A typical agricultural field with archaeological potential. This property is on west side of Coronation Road north of Taunton. Plate 12: Orchard with archaeological potential. Stroud s Farms at corner of Taunton Road and Lakeridge Road. September 2009 planningalliance 9