Section 226 Town and Country Planning Act 1990 S.13 Local Government (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1976 Acquisition of Land Act 1981

Transcription

1 Report Section 226 Town and Country Planning Act 1990 S.13 Local Government (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1976 Acquisition of Land Act 1981 The London Borough of Barnet (Brent Cross Cricklewood) Compulsory Purchase Order (No 1) 2015 Proof of Evidence of Mark Davey On behalf of Objector No 2: National Westminster Bank Plc Regarding: Cricklewood Broadway, NW2 3YZ; freehold; Plot 268; Cricklewood Broadway, NW2 3YZ; leasehold; Plot 267; 26 April 2016 Bilfinger GVA 65 Gresham Street, London, EC2V 7NQ (0) gva.co.uk

2 Contents 1. INTRODUCTION INSTRUCTIONS QUALIFICATIONS THE SCHEME THE PROPERTIES TENURE PROPOSED WORKS AND ACQUISITION AFFECTING THE SUBJECT PROPERTIES GROUNDS FOR OBJECTION MATTERS REQUESTED BY NATWEST NEGOTIATIONS DECLARATION... 6 April gva.co.uk

3 1. Introduction 1.1. This document is a proof of evidence on behalf of National Westminster Bank Plc (NatWest) in relation to The London Borough of Barnet (Brent Cross Cricklewood) Compulsory Purchase Order (No 1) National Westminster Bank Plc (Objector No 2) owns property that is affected by the scheme at the following locations: No 160 Cricklewood Broadway, NW2 3YZ; freehold; Plot 268; No 162 Cricklewood Broadway, NW2 3YZ; leasehold; Plot 267; Brent Cross automatic teller machine (ATM); ATM7, East Court; Plot Instructions 2.1. I am instructed by NatWest. 3. Qualifications 3.1. My name is Mark Davey and my qualifications are BSc (Hons), MRICS. I work within the compulsory purchase team at Bilfinger GVA s London office. I have been dealing with compulsory purchase matters for 25 years. During the last 15 years or so, my working life has been spent dealing mostly with compulsory purchase cases. I have acted for both claimants and acquiring authorities. I have dealt with objections to compulsory purchase on behalf of both acquiring authorities and those affected by compulsory purchase. I have also dealt with claims for land taken and disturbance, in relation to many different types of property throughout England. I have been involved with CPO Inquiries, Development Consent Orders and Tribunal cases. I have produced many experts reports and have given evidence at hearings. 4. The scheme 4.1. The scheme for which compulsory purchase powers are sought is the Brent Cross Shopping Centre Extension and associated development. 5. The properties 5.1. The subject properties owned by NatWest and affected by the scheme are as follows No 160 Cricklewood Broadway, NW2 3YZ; freehold; Plot No 162 Cricklewood Broadway, NW2 3YZ; leasehold; Plot 267. April gva.co.uk

4 Brent Cross ATM7, East Court; Plot The ATM is on the first floor of the Brent Cross Shopping Centre There were previously two ATM s. I understand that the ATM5 (West Court) lease was surrendered in December Tenure 6.1. No 160 Cricklewood Broadway is owned freehold by NatWest No 162 Cricklewood Broadway is held leasehold for a term expiring in Brent Cross ATM7 is held on a lease for a term expiring in Proposed works and acquisition affecting the subject properties 7.1. Nos Cricklewood Broadway 7.2. This property is affected by the acquiring authority s proposal to demolish the adjoining buildings on the corner of Cricklewood Lane to re-align Cricklewood Lane and Chichele Road to improve the junction I understand from Paul Astbury at GL Hearn (agent for the acquiring authority) that the rights that will be acquired are as follows: 7.4. To enter the premises for all purposes in connection with the demolition of Cricklewood Broadway and the construction of a new building including but not limited to works of support and the right to swing the jib of a crane in connection with those works 7.5. NatWest ATM, Brent Cross Shopping Centre (ATM7, East Court) 7.6. I understand from the developer, Hammerson, that the intention is that during redevelopment, the ATM will be relocated temporarily in order to refurbish the floor surface. This is expected to be for a matter of weeks When the development is complete the intention is to create new locations for ATM s rather than the current floor-standing models. There will therefore be a temporary relocation and a permanent relocation. April gva.co.uk

5 8. Grounds for objection 8.1. NatWest s letter of objection was dated 13 May The matters set out below form NatWest s primary concerns based on the further information that has become available since the date of the letter of objection and the discussions with the acquiring authority s agent and the developer The proposed works and acquisition of rights will have a detrimental impact on Nos Cricklewood Broadway The proposed works and acquisitions will have a detrimental impact on the operation of the ATM at Brent Cross Shopping Centre. However I understand that the developer proposes to deal with the relocation under the terms in the lease. 9. Matters requested by NatWest 9.1. NatWest requests that the Secretary of State either refuses to confirm the Order, or amends the Order to take account of the concerns set out above If the Secretary of State decides to confirm the Order, NatWest requests that the Secretary of State does not confirm the Order until NatWest has completed an agreement with the acquiring authority and the developer to cover the matters summarised below Nos Cricklewood Broadway 9.4. The developer will consult with NatWest prior to the commencement of works on the adjoining property and will agree a method statement in advance of any works on the adjoining property The developer will give 28 days notice to NatWest prior to the commencement of works on the adjoining property The developer will carry out the works in a manner to ensure that there will be no structural damage to the subject property and that disruption, noise and vibration will be minimised The developer will reinstate, to the reasonable satisfaction of NatWest if there is any damage to the subject property. 10. Negotiations Negotiations have taken place between NatWest (represented by Bilfinger GVA) and the Council and developer (represented by GL Hearn). However there is no agreement at this stage. April gva.co.uk

6 11. Declaration I confirm that the facts stated in this document are true to the best of my belief I confirm that my evidence includes all facts which I regard as being relevant to the opinions which I have expressed and that attention has been drawn to any matter which would affect the validity of those opinions I confirm that the opinions I have expressed represent my true and complete professional opinion I confirm that my duty to the Inquiry as an expert witness overrides any duty to those instructing or paying me; that I have understood this duty and complied with it in giving my evidence impartially and objectively; and that I will continue to comply with that duty as required I confirm that I am not instructed under any conditional fee arrangement I confirm that I have no conflicts of interest I confirm that my evidence complies with the requirements of the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (RICS), as set down in the Surveyors acting as expert witnesses RICS practice statement. Signed:.. MARK DAVEY BSc (Hons) MRICS Dated: 26 April 2016 April gva.co.uk