Puerto Rico & the US Virgin Islands in the Aftermath of Hurricanes Irma and Maria Jason Bram, Officer Research Economist Presentation to Community Advisory Group June 21, 2018 The views expressed here are those of the presenter and do not necessarily represent those of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York or the Federal Reserve System.
Overview Economic & fiscal conditions in Puerto Rico and US Virgin Islands (USVI) were poor even before hurricanes Irma & Maria. Puerto Rico s economic downturn began in 2006; the USVI began a few years later. We look at a variety of indicators to help gauge the hurricanes effects on these areas economy and outlook. Despite widespread devastation, the Puerto Rico economy has shown some signs of resilience; the USVI less so. While the main focus here is on economic effects, it s important to note that the storms took a great toll in terms of loss of life, physical destruction, health issues, and widespread suffering. FEDERAL RESERVE BANK OF NEW YORK 1
Puerto Rico Economic & Fiscal Conditions Indexes of Economic Activity, Employment, and Population Index (2006=100) 105 100 95 Population Employment 90 Since 2006: Population down 12% 85 Employment down 16% Real GNP Real GNP down 15% 80 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014 2016 2018 Sources: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, U.S. Census Bureau, Planning Board of Puerto Rico, and Moody s Economy.com. The economy had already been in decline for over a decade. Public debt in 2016 was roughly 100% of GNP. The Island had defaulted on debt payments and could no longer borrow. U.S. Congress implemented PROMESA in 2016 to restore long-term economic growth and fiscal balance, creating a fiscal oversight board and a bankruptcy-like process. FEDERAL RESERVE BANK OF NEW YORK 2
Puerto Rico Economic & Fiscal Conditions Payroll Employment, Thousands of Jobs, Seasonally Adjusted 760 Thousands (Private-Sector) Thousands (Government) Post Maria 340 740 320 720 300 700 680 Section 936 Phased out Private-Sector (left scale) 280 260 660 Government (right scale) May 240 640 220 620 600 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 Post Maria 200 180 Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Moody s Economy.com, and FRBNY staff calculations (early benchmark). 3
Puerto Rico Economic & Fiscal Conditions Medical Cluster Employment, 12-Month Moving Average 45 Thousands 40 35 30 25 20 Section 936 Phased out Pharmaceuticals 15 Diagnostic Labs 10 5 Medical Equipment and Supplies 0 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 Sources: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (QCEW) and Moody s Economy.com 4
USVI Also Weak Well Before Irma & Maria Indexes of Economic Activity, Employment, and Population 105 Index (2006 = 100) 100 Population 95 90 85 Employment 80 75 Since 2006: Population down 4% Employment down 15% Real GDP down 27% Real GDP 70 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014 2016 2018 Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, USVI Bureau of Economic Research, World Bank, and Moody s Economy.com. 5
Initial Impacts of the Storms 6
Fallout on Puerto Rico Physical damage and loss of life - More than 1,000 deaths have been attributed to the hurricane in Puerto Rico, with estimates ranging from roughly 1,050 to 4,600. 1 - Many homes and businesses were severely damaged. - Major damage to water, telecom, transportation, and power infrastructure. - Widespread agricultural devastation 80% of crops destroyed in Puerto Rico. 2 Population loss - Air passenger data through March suggest that 175K residents left Puerto Rico after Maria and had not returned, exacerbating the islands ongoing population decline. - It remains to be seen how many of these migrants will return in the months ahead. Economic disruption - In the first few weeks, there were widespread power and telecommunications outages, fuel shortages, and transportation blockages. - Many areas went without electricity and running water for months. - Economic activity fell sharply in September and October but subsequently rebounded. 1) Estimates of excess deaths in Puerto Rico following Hurricane Maria Alexis Santos & Jeffrey T. Howard (Dec. 2017) https://osf.io/preprints/socarxiv/s7dmu Mortality in Puerto Rico after Hurricane Maria (New England Journal of Medicine, May 2018) https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/nejmsa1803972 2) Attributed to Carlos Flores Ortega, Secretary of Agriculture for Puerto Rico FEDERAL RESERVE BANK OF NEW YORK 7
Population Loss After the Storms Net Domestic Passengers to Puerto Rico, 12-Month Rolling Sum 50 0 Thousands U.S. Census Net PR Migration 2011-2016 Annual -50-100 Puerto Rico Net Airline Passengers Sep -150-200 -250 In the 12 months ending March, a net of 180,000 domestic air passengers left the island (roughly 125,000 above existing trend) Mar -300 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 Dec Note: Airports are Luis Munoz Marin Intl Airport in San Juan, Mercedita Intl Airport in Ponce, and Rafael Hernandez Intl Airport in Aguadilla. Source: U.S. Bureau of Transportation Statistics and FRBNY staff calculations. 8
Assessing Damage and Recovery: Nighttime Lights Research 1 shows that nighttime lights can serve as a proxy for economic activity, though the relationship is not one-to-one particularly during a power outage. In Puerto Rico, nighttime light images can be used to gauge the loss and subsequent restoration of power after the storms which localities were most affected, and how quickly they recovered. In the US Virgin Islands, where power was restored more quickly, nighttime lights can provide some indication of the reduction in economic activity. 1) Newer Need Not be Better: Evaluating the Penn World Tables and the World Development Indicators Using Nighttime Lights (Maxim Pinkovskiy and Xavier Sala-i-Martin, 2016) http://www.nber.org/papers/w22216 FEDERAL RESERVE BANK OF NEW YORK 9
Nighttime Lights in Puerto Rico and USVI August October San Juan St. John St. Thomas San Juan St. John St. Thomas Arecibo Caguas Arecibo Caguas Mayaguez St. Croix Mayaguez St. Croix Ponce Ponce December April San Juan St. John St. Thomas San Juan St. John St. Thomas Arecibo Caguas Arecibo Caguas Mayaguez St. Croix Mayaguez St. Croix Ponce Ponce Source: Earth Observation Group; NOAA National Geophysical Data Center. 10
April Nighttime Lights Brightness as a Percentage of August Baseline As of April 2018, Puerto Rico on the whole is 91% as bright as the August baseline. And the U.S. Virgin Islands are 82% as bright. BRITISH VIRGIN ISLANDS (not calculated) St. John Culebra St. Thomas PUERTO RICO San Juan Vieques U.S. VIRGIN ISLANDS Arecibo Aguadilla Caguas Humacao St. Croix Mayaguez Ponce Less than 50% 50% - 60% 60% - 70% 70% - 80% 80% - 90% More than 90% Source: Authors Calculations; Earth Observation Group; NOAA National Geophysical Data Center. 11
Economic Outlook After the Storms 12
How Does This Compare to Other Disasters? Economic effects of natural disasters share some common elements: - Economic disruptions tend to be severe for 1-2 months but then dissipate. - Typically tourism-related industries are the most adversely affected. - Subsequently, economic activity is boosted by clean-up, restoration, and reconstruction efforts. - Insurance payouts and federal aid further buoy spending and investment. - In considering how Puerto Rico s economy might be affected in the longer run, this history can be a useful guide. Still, this disaster has unique features that complicate comparisons with other natural disasters. - The power outage has lasted much longer than after past disasters. - Puerto Rico s dire fiscal situation before the storm is unprecedented. - These and other issues make it harder to predict Puerto Rico s prospects. - The US Virgin Islands dependence on tourism likely prolonged the slump. FEDERAL RESERVE BANK OF NEW YORK 13
How Does This Compare to Other Disasters? Local Job Loss Following Natural Disasters, from Onset to Trough -29.7% Katrina-Metro New Orleans (Aug2005) -11.7% -9.4% Maria & Irma-US Virgin Islands (Sep2017) Hugo-US Virgin Islands (Sep1989) For context, during the Great Recession, NYC saw a 3.3 percent job loss over the course of 10 months -6.2% -5.8% -2.3% -1.3% -1.3% -0.9% -0.5% -0.3% -0.1% +0.0% Marilyn-US Virgin Islands (Sep1995) Maria-Puerto Rico (Sep2017) Ivan-Pensacola (Sep2004) Irma-Florida (Sep2017) Sandy - NY/NJ Coastal Counties (Oct2012) Harvey-Metro Houston (Aug2017) Georges-Puerto Rico (Sep1998) Hugo-Puerto Rico (Sep1989) Blizzard-Philadelphia Metro (Jan1996) Andrew-Metro Miami (Aug1992) Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Haver Analytics, and Moody s Economy.com. 14
Employment Paths Post Hurricanes Index (Month Before Hurricane = 100) 110 Index (Month Before Hurricane = 100) 100 90 U.S. Virgin Islands (Marilyn Sep 1995) Puerto Rico (Maria Sep 2017) U.S. Virgin Islands (Hugo Sep 1989) U.S. Virgin Islands (Irma/Maria Sep 2017) New Orleans (Katrina Aug 2005) 80 Months Before Hurricane Months After Hurricane 70-12 -10-8 -6-4 -2 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26 28 30 Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Moody s Economy.com, and FRBNY staff calculations. 15
Components of Job Loss by Sector: PR Thousands of Jobs Lost Since Aug. 2018 (Before Maria) 0-10 Thousands Accommodation Restaurants & Bars Retail 2.2% Drop -20 Government -30-40 -50-60 Aug17 Sep17 Oct17 Nov17 Dec17 Jan18 Feb18 Mar18 Apr18 May18 Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Moody s Economy.com, and FRBNY staff calculations. 16
Components of Job Loss by Sector: USVI Thousands of Jobs Lost Since Aug. 2018 (Before Irma & Maria) 0 Thousands -1-2 Accommodation Restaurants & Bars 9.8% Drop -3-4 Retail Other Private Government -5 Aug17 Sep17 Oct17 Nov17 Dec17 Jan18 Feb18 Mar18 Apr18 May18 Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Moody s Economy.com, and FRBNY staff calculations. 17
Assessing the Economic Fallout Initial job losses in Puerto Rico (6%) and especially in the USVI (11%), though far less severe than after Katrina, were still substantial. The USVI s economy has been much slower to recover than Puerto Rico s, largely due to its dependence on tourism. Some businesses and homes had backup power, which may have helped mitigate the economic effect somewhat. The job loss may understate the true economic cost because: - At least some of those still employed likely suffered a drop-off in income. - There may be additional unmeasured effects on the informal economy. - We do not account for the value people place on quality-of-life issues. FEDERAL RESERVE BANK OF NEW YORK 18
Conclusions Hurricanes Maria and Irma were overlaid onto already weak economies, raising concerns about longer-term prospects for both territories. Despite widespread devastation and the dire situation before the storms, Puerto Rico s economy has shown signs of resilience. The Virgin Islands economy has been more adversely affected. Looking ahead, Puerto Rico s recovery will likely be affected by the degree of out-migration, external aid, fiscal & other reforms. Some redesign & investment in the electricity and water infrastructure grid also has sizable potential benefits. USVI s recovery will likely be affected by how well the tourism infrastructure is restored and how quickly visitors return. FEDERAL RESERVE BANK OF NEW YORK 19