Planning Commission September 8, 2016 1:00 PM Edward Ball Building, 1 st Floor Training Room, 214 North Hogan Street, Jacksonville, Florida 32202 Chris Hagan, Chair Jerry Friley Ben Davis Daniel Blanchard, Vice Chair Marshall Adkison Dawn Motes Abel Harding, Secretary Nicole Sanzosti Padgett Matthew E. Schellhorn, Military Representative Tyler Loehnert, School District Representative RESULTS MEETING AGENDA I. Call to Order / Verification of Quorum a) Pledge of Allegiance b) Submittal of Speaker s Cards c) Organization 1. Adopt Previous Meeting Minutes 2. Deferrals 3. Proof of Publications II. III. IV. Exceptions, Variances and Waivers and Administrative Deviations Cellular Antenna Reviews Land Use Amendments, Companion Rezonings, Text Amendments V. Conventional Rezonings VI. VII. VIII. IX. Minor Modifications and Administrative Deviation Appeals Planned Unit Developments Ordinances Old Business X. New Business XI. XII. Appeals Update Information a) 08/18/2016 Minutes XIII. Adjournment NOTE: The next regular meeting of the Planning Commission will be held on Thursday, September 22, 2016 in the Edward Ball Building, 1 st Floor Training Room, 214 North Hogan Street, Jacksonville, Florida 32202. NOTE: The next regular meeting of the Land Use & Zoning Committee will be held on Tuesday, September 20, 2016. Comments from the Public RULE 4.505 DISRUPTION OF MEETING No member of the audience shall applaud nor make any noise or remarks that are audible to the Committee that would indicate approval or disapproval of anything being discussed. Any disregard of this rule may result in removal by the Security. REQUEST TO SPEAK: 1. Fill out a Speaker Card 3. Read the rules on the back of the card. 2. Sign-In on the Sign-In Sheet 4. Place card in tray labeled Speaker Cards. Sections 30.204(d) and 650.105(n) of the Ordinance Code designate the Planning Commission as the City s Local Planning Agency pursuant to Section 163.3174 F.S
September 8, 2016........... Page 2 II. Exceptions, Variances, Waivers and Administrative Deviations None b) Deferred Items To Be Heard 1. E-15-20 (companion WLD-15-05) CD-5 / PD-2 4022 Atlantic Blvd. Request: Retail Sales of alcohol for off-premises consumption Owner: Anjali Food Mart, Inc. Agent: Paul M. Harden, Esq. 2. WLD-15-05 (companion E-15-20) CD-5 / PD-2 4022 Atlantic Blvd. Request: Reduce required minimum distance between liquor license location and Church or School from 500 feet to 175 feet Owner: Anjali Food Mart, Inc. Agent: Paul M. Harden, Esq. 3. E-16-40 (companion WLD-16-10, AD-16-44) CD-5/ PD-3 1407 Atlantic Blvd Request: Retail sale of alcohol for on premises consumption and permanent outside sale and service of alcohol and food Owner: Zambetti Properties, Inc. Agent: Paul M. Harden, Esq. 4. WLD-16-10 (companion E-16-40, AD-16-44) CD-5/ PD-3 1407 Atlantic Blvd Request: Reduce required minimum distance between liquor license location and church or school from 500 feet to 111 feet Owner: Zambetti Properties, Inc. Agent: Paul M. Harden, Esq.
September 8, 2016........... Page 3 5. AD-16-44 (companion WLD-16-10, E-16-40) CD-5/ PD-3 1407 Atlantic Blvd Request: Reduce minimum number of required off-street parking spaces from 43 to 0 Owner: Zambetti Properties, Inc. Agent: Paul M. Harden, Esq. 6. E-16-43 (companion AD-16-45) CD-8/ PD-5 195 Tallulah Ave Request: School Owner: Levi White Agent: Jack Morgan 7. AD-16-45 (companion E-16-43) CD-8/ PD-5 195 Tallulah Ave Request: Reduce Lot Area from 4 acres to 2 acres Owner: Levi White Agent: Jack Morgan c) New 1. E-16-52 CD-9/ PD-5 157 McDuff Ave Request: Manual Car Wash Owner: Edward Mims Agent: Charles Gillum 2. E-16-54 CD-7/ PD-6 6765 Dunn Ave Request: Retail sale of all alcoholic beverages for off-premises consumption Owner: Dunn Village, LLC Agent: Fred Atwill, Jr
September 8, 2016........... Page 4 3. E-16-55 (companion AD-16-57) CD-5/ PD-3 2815 Mercury Road Request: Retail sales of automobiles, light trucks, motorcycles, personal water craft and boats Owner: Premier Land Enterprise, Inc. Agent: Jonathan Horn 4. AD-16-57 (companion E-16-55) CD-5/ PD-3 2815 Mercury Road Request: Reduction of parking and buffer Owner: Premier Land Enterprise, Inc. Agent: Jonathan Horn /C 5. E-16-57 (companion WLD-16-14) CD-14/ PD-5 3210 Roosevelt Blvd Request: Retail sale and service of beer and wine for on premise consumption Owner: William Dye Agent: Penny Castleberry /C /AMD/C 6. WLD-16-14 (companion E-16-57) CD-14/ PD-5 3210 Roosevelt Blvd Request: Reduce minimum distance between the subject property and a church or school from 1,500 square feet to 690 square feet Owner: William Dye Agent: Penny Castleberry 7. E-16-58 CD-4/ PD-3 9726 Touchton Road, #105 Request: Restaurant with sale and service of all alcohol including outside sales and service Owner: Andre Bahri Agent: Mike Herzberg
September 8, 2016........... Page 5 8. E-16-59 CD-9/ PD-4 4354 Blanding Blvd Request: Hand Carwash Owner: Tristar Invesco Inc. Agent: None 9. E-16-60 CD-1/ PD-2 77 Monument Road Request: Auto Storage Owner: City National Bank Agent: Brenda Ezell, Esq. /C Planning Commission: D 10. E-16-61 CD-2/ PD-6 3525 New Berlin Road Request: Daycare Owner: Donald Williams Agent: Alexander Senchuk III. Cellular Antenna Reviews None b) Deferred Item To Be Heard None c) New None
September 8, 2016........... Page 6 IV. Land Use Amendments, Companion Rezonings, and Text Amendments None b) Deferred Item To Be Heard 1. 2015-557 (2015C-017) (companion 2015-558) CD-10 / PD-5 Edgewood Avenue Request: RPI to NC Owner: Janice R. Nelson Agent: Charles Mann Staff Recommendation: D 2. 2015-558 (companion 2015-557) CD-10 / PD-5 Edgewood Avenue Request: CO to CN Owner: Janice R. Nelson Agent: Charles Mann Staff Recommendation: D 3. 2016-68 (2015C-026) (companion 2016-69) CD-8 / PD-6 Calebs Cove Request: CGC to LDR Owner: Patricia L. Odom Agent: Greg Kupperman 4. 2016-69 (companion 2016-68) CD-8 / PD-6 Calebs Cove Request: CCG-2 & RR-Acre to PUD Owner: Patricia L. Odom Agent: Greg Kupperman /C /AMD/C
September 8, 2016........... Page 7 5. 2016-431 (2016C-014) (companion 2016-432) CD-2 / PD-2 Monument Road Request: RPI to CGC Owner: William A. Watson, Jr. & Watson Realty Corp. Agent: Charles L. Mann 6. 2016-432 (companion 2016-431) CD-2 / PD-2 Monument Road (Wawa) Request: PUD to CCG-1 Owner: William A. Watson, Jr. & Watson Realty Corp. Agent: Charles L. Mann 7. 2016-474 (2016C-017) (companion 2016-475) CD-12 / PD-4 4468 Yellow Water Road Request: RR to BP Owner: Chestnut Creek, LLC Agent: Fred Atwill Staff Recommendation: D 8. 2016-475 (companion 2016-474) CD-12 / PD-4 4468 Yellow Water Road Request: AGR to IBP Owner: Chestnut Creek, LLC Agent: Fred Atwill Staff Recommendation: D
September 8, 2016........... Page 8 c) New 1. 2016-532 (2016C-011) (companion 2016-533) CD-12 / PD-4 Shoppes at Normandy Request: LDR &PBF to NC Owner: Audrey Everett, Presbytery of St. Augustine & Gene Lyman Agent: Greg Kupperman 2. 2016-533 (companion 2016-532) CD-12 / PD-4 Shoppes at Normandy Request: RLD-60, PBF-2 & CCG-2 to PUD Owner: Audrey Everett, Presbytery of St. Augustine & Gene Lyman Agent: Greg Kupperman /C V. Conventional Rezonings None b) Deferred Item To Be Heard None c) New 1. 2016-527 CD-8 / PD-5 1850 Jones Road Request: CO to CCG-1 Owners: Joseph Douglas Agent: Charles Davis
September 8, 2016........... Page 9 VI. Minor Modifications and Administrative Deviation Appeals None b) Deferred Item To Be Heard None c) New 1. MM-16-18 CD-3 / PD-3 Hodges Blvd /Glen Kern Request: revised setbacks Owner: Las Vegas Self Storage Inc. Agent: Shalene Estes /AMD/C VII. Planned Unit Developments None b) Deferred to be Heard 1. 2016-476 CD-7 / PD-1 1636 Main Street Request: CGC-Springfield to PUD Owner: St. Augustine Souvenir Company, LLC Agent: Zach Miller, Esq. c) New 1. 2016-525 CD-5 / PD-3 9109 San Jose Blvd Request: PUD to PUD Owner: SSL San Jose, LLC Agent: Steve Diebenow /C
September 8, 2016........... Page 10 2. 2016-526 CD-7 / PD-6 14353 Main Street North Request: PUD to PUD Owner: SAMC REO 2016 01, LLC Agent: Lara Diettrich /C /C 3. 2016-528 CD-12 / PD-4 Pioneer Medical Request: CO to PUD Owner: Pioneer Medical Consultants, Inc. Agent: Lara Hipps /AMD VIII. Ordinances 1. Ordinance 2016-95 Amend Chapter 656 (Zoning Code), Creating New Sec 656.423 (Fencing along Public Streets & Right-of-Ways) to require that Fence Panels be Installed such that the Finished Side Faces Public Streets & R/W. 2. Ordinance 2016-366 Amend Chapter 656 (Zoning Code), Part 1 (Gen Provisions), Subpart C (Procedures for Rezoning & Amends to Zoning Code) & Part 3 (Schedule of Dist. Regs.), Subpart O (Riverside/Avondale Zoning Overlay), to Specify Applicability of the Riverside/Avondale Zoning Overlay to All Zoning Dists, including PUD Dist, to Specify Types of Negative Effects to a Character Area when evaluating an Appl for Rezoning, Identify Addnl Intent & Purpose of Creating the Overlay & Defining the Character Areas, provide Parking Requirements within the Historic Residential Character Areas & Limitations on Nonconforming Site Characteristics, & Require all Rezonings to PUD to Contain a Residential Component & be Situated upon at least 2 Acres of Contiguous Land for All Character Areas.
September 8, 2016........... Page 11 3. Ordinance 2016-368 Amend Chapter 656 (Zoning Code), Part 6 (Off-Street Parking & Loading Regs) Subpart A (Off-Street Parking & Loading for Motor Vehicles), Secs 656.603, 656.604 & 656.607, Ord Code to clarify the use of Parking Credits. IX. Old Business X. New Business a) Chair appointed Dawn Motes, Nicole Padgett and Marshall Adkison to the Nominating Committee. XI. Appeals Update XII. Information a) Planning Commission Minutes for August 18, 2016 - Approved XIII. Adjournment