Proposed Auckland Unitary Plan Summary of Decisions Requested Sub#/ Point Name Theme Topic Subtopic Summary

Transcription

1 Precincts North Devonport Peninsula Proposed Auckland Unitary Plan Summary of Decisions Requested Emily Morrow Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Emily Morrow Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Emily Morrow Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Emily Morrow Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Emily Morrow Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Emily Morrow Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Emily Morrow Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Emily Morrow Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Sharyn M Carew Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Add a new Sub-precinct G - Beresford, being 1 and 3 Sandy Bay Road, 83, 85, and Beresford Street; and 80, 82, 84, and 90 Beresford Street, to provide for comprehensive redevelopment of relatively contiguous landholdings. Refer map page 50/67 vol.2. Amend the Description, first sentence, as follows: 'The of the underlying zone apply in the Devonport Peninsula Precinct unless otherwise where specified. Refer to planning maps for the location and extent of the precinct.'. Refer submission page 52/67 vol. 2. Amend the Description, third paragraph under the sub heading 'Precinct description', to provide for an additional sub precinct identified as, 'Sub-Precinct G - Beresford Street' amend the text to change from six to seven sub precincts, change the land area from 24.9 to 25.9 hectares and change the description of the range of sub precinct areas to include a 1 hectare sub precinct as the smallest area. Refer submission page 52/67 vol. 2. Amend the Description, sixth paragraph under the sub heading Precinct description, to change the height areas by adding an additional area at the beginning of the list identified as 'Area 1' being 18 metres and 5 storeys, and consequentially renaming the other areas as follows: Area 1 becomes Area 2 with height of 14.5 metres and 4 storeys; Area 2 become Area 3 with a height of 11 metres and 3 storeys; and, Area 3 becomes Area 4 with a height of 8 metres and 2 storeys. Refer submission page 52/67 vol. 2. Amend the Description, all twelve paragraphs under the sub heading 'Sub-Precincts' to make various changes to the description of height areas and their relationships to other height areas and sub precincts. Refer submission page 53/69 vol. 2. [refer also to point number 53]. Amend the Description, under the sub heading 'Sub-Precincts' to add the description for sub precinct 'Sub-Precinct G - Beresford Street', including size, location and height areas. Refer submission page 53/67 vol. 2. Delete the introductory clause to the objectives as follows: 'The objectives as listed in the Mixed Housing Suburban Zone apply in addition to the objectives specified below: '. [p 54/67 vol 2] Add a new objective as follows: '3. Enable the development of retirement villages.' [p 54/67 vol 2] Add a new objective as follows: '4. Facilitate public access along the coastal edge where no public access is provided without requiring an esplanade reserve.'. [p 54/67 vol 2] Add a new objective as follows: '5. Mixed Housing Suburban Zone D.1.5 Objective 1.'. [p 54/67 vol 2] Add a new objective as follows: '6. Mixed Housing Suburban Zone D.1.5 Objective 3.'. [p 54/67 vol 2] Add a new objective as follows: '7. Mixed Housing Suburban Zone D.1.5 Objective 4.'. [p 54/67 vol 2] Delete the introductory clause to the policies as follows: 'The policies as listed in the Mixed Housing Suburban Zone apply in addition to the policies specified below: '. [p 54/67 vol 2] Add a new policy as follows: '7. Mixed Housing Suburban Zone D.1.5 Policy 1.' [p 54/67 vol 2] Add a new policy as follows: '8. Mixed Housing Suburban Zone D.1.5 Policy 3.' [p 54/67 vol 2] Add a new policy as follows: '9. Mixed Housing Suburban Zone D.1.5 Policy 5.' [p 54/67 vol 2] Add a new policy as follows: '10. Mixed Housing Suburban Zone D.1.5 Policy 8.' [p 54/67 vol 2] Retain the general approach of the precinct. [p 39/60 vol 1] Ensure a high level of urban design for changes to housing density within the Devonport precinct. Ensure intensive development in Devonport precinct results in increased amounts of public recreational open space. Changes permitted by the Devonport precinct are to be consistent with the existing character, type of development, aesthetic and overall feel of the neighbourhood. Consider Ngataringa Road and/or Fort Takapuna, Devonport for Retirement village activities or smaller units to provide housing options for seniors. Improvements to infrastructure to be designed and implemented either prior to or concurrently with any housing intensification in the Devonport precinct. Explore other road options to serve increased congestion on Lake Road, including all secondary and suburban roads in Devonport. Maintain the 2 story existing building level height in the Ngataringa Road area of Devonport. Minimise the impact on coastal environmental areas and trees in the Devonport precinct. Apply due process review rather than special housing area fast track to any intensification in the Devonport precinct. 1/11

2 Precincts North Devonport Peninsula Sharyn M Carew Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Apply a high level of urban design to the Devonport precinct when considering any changes to housing density Sharyn M Carew Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Increase and enhance open / recreational areas if more intense development is permitted in the Devonport precinct Sharyn M Carew Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Ensure any changes permitted in the Devonport precinct are consistent with the underlying neighbourhood character Sharyn M Carew Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Provide for a full service retirement community (independent housing, assisted living and hospital care) in the Devonport precinct eg Ngataringa Rd and / or Fort Takapuna Sharyn M Carew Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Design and implement improvements to infrastructure prior to or concurrent with any housing intensification in the Devonport precinct eg Lake Rd improvements. Explore other road options as an alternative to Lake Rd Sharyn M Carew Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Keep the height of all new buildings in the Ngataringa Rd area to two-storey Sharyn M Carew Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Minimise the impact on coastal environmental areas and trees within the Devonport precinct Sarah Ley-Bucherer Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Apply sustainable building/living design principles to the Devonport precinct Sarah Ley-Bucherer Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Provide emergency facilities for water storage, electricity generation and waste disposal in any new housing areas in Devonport Sarah Ley-Bucherer Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend the Devonport Precinct to ensure any permitted changes are consistent with the existing neighbourhood character Sarah Ley-Bucherer Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Align improvments to infrastructure with housing intensification in the Devonport precinct Sarah Ley-Bucherer Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Address road congestion in Devonport, particulary on Lake Road Sarah Ley-Bucherer Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Retain a two storey building height on Ngataringa Road Devonport David Newbold Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Retain current density across Devonport Peninsula of single dwellings sections in sub-precinct F David Newbold Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Ensure quality design in sub-precinct F David Newbold Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Ensure wastewater system is able to cope with significant increase in population of Devonport Peninsula David Newbold Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Acknowledge that additional traddic from sub-precinct A will aggrevate an already overloaded arterial David Newbold Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Ensure land at Wakakura Crescent is cleared of asbestos cladding before new buildings are developed Paul L Morrow Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Ensure a high level of urban design for changes to housing density within the Devonport precinct Paul L Morrow Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Ensure intensive development in Devonport precinct results in increased amounts of public recreational open space Paul L Morrow Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Ensure changes permitted in the Devonport precinct are to be consistent with the existing character, type of development, aesthetic and overall feel of the neighbourhood Paul L Morrow Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Consider Ngataringa Road and/or Fort Takapuna, Devonport for retirement village activities or smaller units to provide housing options for seniors Paul L Morrow Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Design and implement improvements to infrastructure either prior to or concurrently with any housing intensification in the Devonport precinct Paul L Morrow Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Explore other road options to serve increased congestion on Lake Road, including addressing congestion on all secondary and suburban roads in Devonport Paul L Morrow Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Maintain the 2 story existing building level height in the Ngataringa Road area of Devonport Paul L Morrow Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Minimise the impact on coastal environmental areas and trees in the Devonport precinct Chris Thomas Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Reject infill housing in the Devonport peninsula Vicky A H Stewart Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Reject the Devonport Peninsula Sub Precinct F, with particular regard to Wakakura Crescent Lawrence Proffit Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Reject proposed extension of David St, Bayswater, that is proposed as part of the Devonport Peninsula sub-precinct C Christine L Jackson Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Reject the proposed intensification of development in the precinct Christine L Jackson Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Review and upgrade infrastructure services before initiating development in Wakakura Crescent Sandra Waine Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Reject high density housing proposed in the Devonport Peninsula precinct as the local area will not be able to sustain the population growth. 2/11

3 Precincts North Devonport Peninsula Christopher B M Jackson Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Request resolution of Lake Road traffic issues before addition of traffic from Wakakura crescent development Christopher B M Jackson Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Request thorough impact report on condition and capacity of existing infrastructure in relation to requirements to development Wakakura Crescent Christopher B M Jackson Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Request upgrading of infrastructure required to develop Wakakura Crescent is funded by developer Christopher B M Jackson Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Request local community be consulted on development of Wakakura Crescent including reviewing proposal before development commences Tarn Cameron Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Add to Devonport Peninsula sub-precinct F restricting height to two storeys Michael A Hawkins Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Reduce four storey height limit for Sub-Precinct E - Vauxhall Road, Devonport Michael A Hawkins Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Add D.1.4 Single house to Sub-Precinct E - Vauxhall Road Nicky Proffit Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend precinct to retain end of David street as pedestrian access only Kathleen M Helyer Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Should apply consistent high level of urban design Kathleen M Helyer Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Intensification in Devonport precinct area should result in increased amounts of public, open recreational space Kathleen M Helyer Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Development in the Devonport precinct area should be consistent with existing, underlying neighbourhood character Kathleen M Helyer Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Devonport sub-precinct F should allow a retirement village type development Kathleen M Helyer Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Other road options should be explored to serve development in the Devonport precinct area Holly Sanford Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Investigation by Council of other options to serve increased congestion on Lake Road and on all secondary and suburban roads on the Devonport peninsula Inge E B Rudolph Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend PAUP so that any further development on the Devonport peninsula is conditional on providing alternative access to the the city Ron and Michele Copeland Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Seeks that city planners advise on how any application involving the Bayswater Marina fits with plans and by-laws Ron and Michele Copeland Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Planning reports on applications are to provide no recommendations on outcomes as this is the job of the independent commissioners Ron and Michele Copeland Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Reject further intensification within the Precinct until Lake Road traffic problems are solved Adrienne Wigmore Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Retain coastal vegetation protection Adrienne Wigmore Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Retain protection for views of the volcanic cones and the city Adrienne Wigmore Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Retain pedestrian access to the whole of the precinct's foreshore Adrienne Wigmore Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend precinct to provide for improved infrastructure e.g. roading and sewage systems, either prior or concurrently with any housing intensification Adrienne Wigmore Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend precinct to provide for development of a Retirement Villiage along Ngataringa Road or Ft Takapuna Adrienne Wigmore Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Retain recreational spaces, beaches and parks Adrienne Wigmore Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend precinct to recognise the possible wind tunnel effect of groupings of higher buildings, and its effects should not negatively impact on existing or future inhabitants Cameron Smith and Amelia Linzey Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend precinct to apply to the whole Devonport peninsula if this type of development is considered to be appropriate for parts of the peninsula [refer to Page 2/4 for details] Cameron Smith and Amelia Linzey Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Retain Objective 2 if this Precinct is retained Cameron Smith and Amelia Linzey Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Cameron Smith and Amelia Linzey Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Kirsty Donnan Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Kirsty Donnan Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend Objective 1, if this Precinct is retained, to read: 'Integrated high quality housing development on large contiguous sites, which incorporates provides for additional building height where this can be managed so as to avoid unreasonable adverse effects on the amenity of surrounding sites and while complimenting building heights in adjacent residential areas'. Delete the Devonport Peninsula precinct. Apply the objectives, policies and guidelines of the Single House zone to sub-precinct E Vauxhall Rd, Devonport Peninsula precinct Rezone sub-precinct F Wakakura Cres, Devonport Peninsula precinct, from Mixed Housing Suburban to Single House 3/11

4 Precincts North Devonport Peninsula Kirsty Donnan Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Retain the Kirsty Donnan Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Protect the built and cultural heritage associated with sub-precinct E Karren Beanland Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Retain proposed intensification at Fort Takapuna and Wakakura Crescent to a height that is agreed after consultation with local communities Leigh A Jewell Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Resolve traffic and access issues to Devonport before implementing precinct Trish and Joe Deans Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend the Fort Takapuna sub-precinct E objectives and polices to require that the guidelines that apply to Devonport Residential Single House Zone apply to Fort Takapuna sub-precinct E Trish and Joe Deans Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Reject provisions that provide for further intensification on the Devonport isthmus without corresponding development of infrastructure such as roads Trish and Joe Deans Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Require assessment of the effects on Lake Road traffic when considering resource consent applications for new development Devonport Heritage Incorporated Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Delete Ngataringa Bay and Wakakura Crescent (Devonport) from the precinct and include them in the Single House zone William K Smedley Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Delete all provisions relating to Sub-Precinct C Peter J S Buckland Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Remove provisions for further intensification south of Hauraki Sylvia M Emm Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Sylvia M Emm Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Michele R Brooke Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Michele R Brooke Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Michele R Brooke Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Michele R Brooke Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Adam Moy Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Adam Moy Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Christian R Wehrle Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Christian R Wehrle Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Christian R Wehrle Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Christian R Wehrle Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Christian R Wehrle Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Christian R Wehrle Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Christian R Wehrle Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Christian R Wehrle Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Elizabeth M Boyd Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Elizabeth M Boyd Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Elizabeth M Boyd Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Elizabeth M Boyd Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Elizabeth M Boyd Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Delete height limits of four storeys for sub-precincts A Marden St, B Birchfield Rd and C Hillary Crescent and replace with a height restriction of two storeys with no provision to build higher [sub-precinct C is Plymouth Crescent in PAUP]. Apply the pre-1944 demolition rule to all historic and socially significant areas of Devonport Peninsula sub-precinct E. Recognise the need for high-level urban design to ensure any development remains within the special character of its surrounding environment. Recognise that the intensification of housing and the relaxation of density and height restrictions will significantly change the character of the area. Retain Polly's Park (running south of Wakakura Crescent). Any application for dwellings that may be allowed under Mixed Housing Suburban should follow normal resource consent process and allow for consultation. Reject the Devonport Peninsula Sub Precinct C - Plymouth Crescent. Reject intensification for the whole of Devonport Peninsular Precinct. Amend objective 1 to provide a more holistic approach to the development of the precinct. Refer to the full submission for suggested wording [page 9/15]. Amend objective 2: 'Development that mitigates general visual and dominance effects and enhances public pedestrian use and accessibility of the precinct and surrounding public open space.' Amend policy 1 to address the effects of development on the wider receiving environment. Refer to submission for wording [page 10/15]. Amend policy 2 to avoid the adverse effects of new pedestrian or road connections on the surrounding local road network. Refer to submission for wording [page 10/15]. Amend policy 3(a) to address the wider effects of additional building height (not just dominance and visual effects). Refer to submission for wording [page 11/15]. Amend policy 4 to encourage consultation with the wider community when preparing a framework plan. Refer to submission for wording [page 11/15]. Amend policy 5(b) to change the focus to integrating development with the surrounding residential environment rather than any neighbouring precinct. Refer to submission for wording [page 12/15]. Delete policy 6: 'Provide for integrated residential development on moderately large sites. ' Seeks a high level of urban design is applied to the "Devonport Precinct" area. Seeks increased provision of public open space if more intensive development is to occur. Seeks development in Devonport is consistent with the existing, underlying neighbourhood character. Seeks development of a retirement facility in Devonport. Seeks development of a daycare facility in close proximity to a retirement facility in Devonport. 4/11

5 Precincts North Devonport Peninsula Elizabeth M Boyd Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Seeks that infrastructure improvements are implement prior or concurrently with intensification of Devonport Elizabeth M Boyd Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Seeks that other roading options are investigated to relieve congestion on Lake Road, Devonport Diane Humphreys Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Provide infrastructure for transportation, roading, shops, education, sewage and drainage Diane Humphreys Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Protect Polly's Park Keith S Humphreys Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Require improvements to infrastructure including road and sewerage before any real increase in housing even if the zoning is approved Julie Irving Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Provide increased amounts of public open recreational space Julie Irving Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend precinct to be consistent with the existing underlying neighbourhood character Julie Irving Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Ensure improvements to infrastructure are designed and implemented either prior to or concurrently with any housing intensification Julie Irving Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Explore roading options to address congestion on Lake Road, Devonport Stephen D Shaw Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Add to restrict height to two storeys or 8m in sub-precinct C Theresa Wells Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend Objective 1 to to give consideration to the overall bulk, scale and density of development that will occur and the potential effects on the environment. Refer to page 11/17 of the submission for details Theresa Wells Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Delete Objective Theresa Wells Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Apply the policies and objectives for a limitation for a two storey development as reflected in the Single House zone to the precinct, particularly to Plymouth Crescent Miranda Powrie Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend Objective 1 to read: 'Integrated high quality housing development on large contiguous sites, which incorporate additional building bulk, height and density while complementing building heights in adjacent residential areas avoiding, remedying or mitigating effects on the environment.' Miranda Powrie Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend Objective 2 to read: 'Development that mitigates general visual and dominance effects and enhances public pedestrian use and accessibility of the precinct and surrounding open space.' Miranda Powrie Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend Policy 1 to read: 'Encourage the location, bulk, outlook, access to, and servicing of buildings to be planned and avoided, remedied or mitigated.' Miranda Powrie Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend Policy 2 to read: 'Encourage the establishment of an integrated, well-connected, safe and accessible pedestrian and public open space network through a framework plan that creates a public neighbourhood environment and which networks.' Boyd and Theresa Thwaites Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Delete Special Housing Areas due to infrastructure constraints Boyd and Theresa Thwaites Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Undertake extensive consultation and public notification of all development plans within the Devonport Peninsula precinct Boyd and Theresa Thwaites Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Ensure no development occurs within the precinct before adequate infrastructure has been put in place Boyd and Theresa Thwaites Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Ensure no intensive development occurs within the precinct due health and safety and civil defence concerns Tim and Hannah Mortlock Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend objective 1 to read: 'Integrate high quality housing development on large contiguous sites, which incorporate additional bulk, height, and density while complementing building heights in adjacent residential areas avoiding, remedying or mitigating effects on the environment' Tim and Hannah Mortlock Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend objective 2 to read: 'Development that mitigates general visual and dominance effects and enhances public pedestrian use and accessibility of the precinct and surrounding public open space' Tim and Hannah Mortlock Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Tim and Hannah Mortlock Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Tim and Hannah Mortlock Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Tim and Hannah Mortlock Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Tim and Hannah Mortlock Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend policy 1 to read: 'Encourage the location,bulk, outlook, access to, and servicing of buildings to be planned and designed in a a comprehensive and integrated manner though a framework plan such that the effects on the environment are avoided, remedied or mitigated'. Amend policy 2 to read: 'Encourage the establishment of an integrated, well-connected, safe and accessible pedestrian and public open space network through a framework plan that creates a a public neighbourhood environment and which networks'. Amend policy 3 (a) to read: 'Avoiding wider dominance or visual effects on the environment'. Amend policy 4 to read: 'Encourage consultation with the community and any other owners of land within a sub-precinct when preparing a framework plan'. Amend policy 5 (b) to read: 'any neighbouring precinct the surrounding residential environment'. 5/11

6 Precincts North Devonport Peninsula Tim and Hannah Mortlock Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Remove policy Garry C Venus Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Garry C Venus Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Garry C Venus Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Garry C Venus Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Garry C Venus Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Garry C Venus Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Garry C Venus Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Garry C Venus Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend objective 1 to read: 'Integrated high quality...additional building bulk, height, and density while complementing building heights in adjacent residential areas avoiding, remedying or mitigating the effects on the environment.' Amend objective 2 to read: 'Development that mitigates general visual and dominance effects and enhances public pedestrian use and... ' Amend policy 1 to read: 'Encourage the location... through a framework plan such that the effects on the environment are avoided remedied or mitigated.' Amend policy 2 to read: 'Encourage the establishment... and which complements and improves accessibility to avoids any adverse effects on surrounding public open space and local road networks. Amend policy 3(a) to read: 'avoiding wider dominance or visual effects on the environment;' Amend policy 4 to read: 'Encourage consultation with the community and any other... ' Amend policy 5(b) to read: 'any neighbouring precinct the surrounding residential environment.' Delete policy 6: 'Provide for integrated residential development on moderately large sites. ' Clive W Rhodes Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Clive W Rhodes Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Clive W Rhodes Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Clive W Rhodes Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Clive W Rhodes Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Clive W Rhodes Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Clive W Rhodes Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Clive W Rhodes Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Nicola Gibson Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Nicola Gibson Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Nicola Gibson Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Nicola Gibson Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Wendy Bailey Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Kriston Cox Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Robert B Boyd Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Robert B Boyd Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Robert B Boyd Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Robert B Boyd Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Robert B Boyd Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Robert B Boyd Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend objective 1 to read: 'Integrated high quality... additional building bulk, height, and density while complementing building heights in adjacent residential area s avoiding, remedying or mitigating the effects on the environment.' Amend objective 2 to read: 'Development that mitigates general visual and dominance effects and enhances public pedestrian use... ' Amend policy 1 to read: 'Encourage the location,... framework plan such that the effects on the environment are avoided, remedied or mitigated.' Amend policy 2 to read: 'Encourage the establishment... and which complements and improves accessibility to avoids and adverse effects on surrounding public open space and local road networks.' Amend policy 3(a) to read: 'avoiding wider dominance or visual effects on the environment;' Amend policy 4 to read: 'Encourage consultation with the community and any other owners... ' Amend policy 5(b) to read: 'any neighbouring precinct the surrounding residential environment.' Delete policy 6: 'Provide for integrated residential development on moderately large sites. ' Delete Special Housing Areas due to infrastructure constraints. Require extensive consultation and public notification of all development plans within the Devonport Peninsula precinct. Ensure no development occurs within the precinct before adequate infrastructure has been put in place Ensure no intensive development occurs within the precinct due health and safety and civil defence concerns. Accept the concept of a retirement village on the land holding at Wakakura Crescent, Devonport. Delete Sub-precinct C. Amend Objective 1 as follows: Integrated high quality housing development on large contiguous sites, which incorporate additional building bulk, height and density while complementing building heights in adjacent residential areas avoiding, remedying or mitigating the effects on the environment. Amend Objective 2 as follows: Development that mitigates general visual and dominance effects and enhances public pedestrian use and accessibility of the precinct and surrounding public open space. Amend Policy 1 as follows: Encourage the location, bulk, outlook, access to, and servicing of buildings to be planned and avoided, remedied or mitigated. Amend Policy 2 as follows: Encourage the establishment of an integrated, well-connected, safe and accessible pedestrian and public open space network through a framework plan that creates a public neighbourhood environment and which complements and improves accessibility to avoid any adverse effects on surrounding public open space and local road networks. Amend Policy 3 as follows: Enable greater building height in appropriate locations through a framework plan consent while: a. avoiding wider dominance or visual effects on the environment;... Amend Policy 4 as follows: Encourage consultation with the community and any other owners of land within a sub-precinct when preparing a framework plan. 6/11

7 Precincts North Devonport Peninsula Robert B Boyd Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend Policy 5 as follows: Require the framework plan to demonstrate the interrelationship and future integration with:... b.any neighbouring precinct the surrounding residential environment Robert B Boyd Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Delete Policy Lucy Bucknall Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Allow Pollys Park, Devonport and waters edge of Ngataringa Road (from Weseley St onwards) to be accessed by the public Lucy Bucknall Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Include provision for a public park within the new development Murray Thompson and Domenico de Vincentis Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Ensure development is consistent with the existing underlying character, type of development, aesthetic and overall 'feel' of the neighbourhood Murray Thompson and Domenico de Vincentis Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Consider a 'retirement community' or similar facility in the Devonport Precinct and in particular areas such as Ngataringa Road and/or Fort Takapuna areas Murray Thompson and Domenico de Vincentis Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Minimise the impact on coastal environmental areas and trees Nathan and Rebecca Hale Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend the Policies and Objectives to restrict heights to 2 storeys within Sub-Precinct C Nathan and Rebecca Hale Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Reject any development before infrastructure has been put in place to cope with an increased population on the Devonport Peninsula Cecelia M Williams Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Delete provisions for development in the Precinct Bayswater Community Committee Incorporated Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend to require sites with coastal boundaries to protect the marine environment and be consistent with the requirements for coastal properties in the adjacent neighbourhoods Bayswater Community Committee Incorporated Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend precinct description to remove the words 'residential activities' Bayswater Community Committee Incorporated Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend precinct description for sub precinct B to delete the words 'and residential development' Bayswater Community Committee Incorporated Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Delete Policy Bayswater Community Committee Incorporated Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Delete Policy Jo-anne Twiggins Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend description to state total area is 29.5 ha not 24.9 ha Robert C Shearer Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Undertake infrastructure upgrades prior to development Robert C Shearer Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Reject development plans for sub districts Navin Weeraratne Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend to require community engagement and management of adverse effects in the consenting process Navin Weeraratne Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Ensure mechanisms to fund mitigation measures including infrastructure are identified and implemented Hector R Weeraratne Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Provide necessary infrastructure to cope with proposed development in the precinct prior to or alongside that development Gay Richards Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Reject the precinct Marinka D Teague Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Delete Precinct David and Cassino Street and Birkley Avenue and Lake Road Residents Group Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula DeletePrecinct Objectives and Policies and replace with of the Single House Zone Dan O'Leary Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Apply a consistently high level of urban design to the development precinct areas when considering any changes in housing density Hugh Smith Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Reject the Devonport Peninsula Precinct Hugh Smith Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend provisions around Hauraki Primary School in Waitemata Rd, Fentham Rd and Marsden St, Devonport to reduce proposed building height. [Refer to map on p[age 3/3 of the submission] Terry E King Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Delete the provisions for Devonport Peninsula Margaret Taylor Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Retain the provisions that recognise Devonport's special character and give special protection to such taonga as Mount Victoria, and protect sightlines to it and other volcanoes Margaret Taylor Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Retain the provisions that recognise the contribution the recreational playgrounds give to the Devonport lifestyle Yong Phing Olan and Rui Bang Dai Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend the to give certainty to the wider local community that the effects of the intensification can be appropriately avoided, remedied or mitigated. 7/11

8 Precincts North Devonport Peninsula Yong Phing Olan and Rui Bang Dai Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Remove the non notification rule so that normal notification tests apply for framework plans Yong Phing Olan and Rui Bang Dai Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend 5.11 Objective 1 to read: 'Integrated high quality housing development on large contiguous sites, which incorporate additional building bulk, height and density while complementing building heights in adjacent residential areas avoiding, remedying or mitigating the effects on the environment.' Yong Phing Olan and Rui Bang Dai Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend Objective 2 to read 'Development that mitigates general visual and dominance effects and enhances public pedestrian use and accessibility of the precinct and surrounding public open space.' Yong Phing Olan and Rui Bang Dai Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend Policy 1 to read 'Encourage the location, bulk, outlook, access to, and servicing of buildings to be planned and avoided, remedied or mitigated.' Yong Phing Olan and Rui Bang Dai Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend Policy 2 to read 'Encourage the establishment of an integrated, well connected, safe and accessible pedestrian and public open space network through a framework plan that creates a public neighbourhood environment and which networks.' Yong Phing Olan and Rui Bang Dai Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend Policy 3 to read 'Enable greater building height in appropriate locations through a framework plan consent while (a) avoiding wider dominance or visual effects on the environment, (b)...' Yong Phing Olan and Rui Bang Dai Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend Policy 4 to read 'Encourage consultation with the community and any other owners of land within a sub-precinct when preparing a framework plan.' Takako Kambayashi Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Retain Wakakura Block as an open space area with native bush Stuart Thom Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Remove sub-precinct D Derrick S Powrie Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend Objective 1 to read "Integrated high quality housing development on large contiguous sites, which incorporate additional building bulk, height and density while complementing building heights in adjacent residential areas avoiding remedying or mitigating the effects on the environment." Derrick S Powrie Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend Objective 2 to read "Development that mitigates, visual and dominance effects and enhances public pedestrian use and accessibility of the precinct and surrounding public open space." Derrick S Powrie Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Derrick S Powrie Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Derrick S Powrie Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Derrick S Powrie Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Derrick S Powrie Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Derrick S Powrie Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Scott and Felicity Wilson Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Linda Otter Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Linda Otter Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Powrie Family Trust Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Powrie Family Trust Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Powrie Family Trust Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Powrie Family Trust Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Powrie Family Trust Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Powrie Family Trust Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Powrie Family Trust Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend Policy 1 to read "Encourage the location, bulk, outlook, access to, and servicing of buildings to be planned and avoided remedied or mitigated." Amend Policy 2 to read "Encourage the establishment of an integrated, well-connected, safe and accessible pedestrian and public open space network through a framework plan that creates a public neighbourhood environment and which networks." Amend Policy 3 to read "...(a) avoiding wider dominance or visual effects on the environment." Amend Policy 4 to read " Encourage consultation with the community and any other owners of land within a sub-precinct when preparing a framework plan." Amend Policy 5 to read "...(b) any neighbouring precinct the surrounding residential environment." Delete Policy 6 [regarding integrated residential development]. Protect viewshafts on Wakakura Crescent, Devonport. Seeks infrastructure is put in place before any development occurs on the Devonport peninsula.refer to submission [page 4] for plan showing alterative road layout. Remove development plans for sub-districts dues to health and safety and Civil Defence concerns. Amend Objective 1 to read "1. Integrated high quality housing development on large contiguous sites, which incorporate additional building bulk, height, and density while complementing building heights in adjacent residential areas avoiding, remedying or mitigating the effects on the environment." Amend Objective 2 to read "2. Development that mitigates general visual and dominance effects and enhances public pedestrian use and accessibility of the precinct and surrounding public open space." Amend Policy 1 to read "1. Encourage the location...through a framework plan such that the effects on the environment are avoided, remedied or mitigated." Amend Policy 2 to read "2. Encourage...environment and which complements and improves the accessibility to avoids any adverse effects on surrounding public open space and local road networks." Amend Policy 3(a) to read "a. avoiding wider dominance or visual effects on the environment." Amend Policy 4 to read "4. Encourage consultation with the community and any other owners..." Amend Policy 5(b) to read "b. any neighbouring precincts the surrounding residential environment." 8/11

9 Precincts North Devonport Peninsula Powrie Family Trust Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Delete Policy 6 [requiring integrated residential development] Simeon Wright Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend the Objectives and Policies to state that height will be restricted to 2 storey dwellings in Wakakura Crescent (Subprecinct F) Petra Heemskerk Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Delete the special Precinct [Devonport Peninsula sub-precinct F] on Wakakura Crescent, Devonport Sarah Powrie Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend Objective 1 as follows: Integrated high quality housing development on large contiguous sites, which incorporate additional building bulk, height and density while complementing building heights in adjacent residential areas avoiding, remedying or mitigating the effects on the environment Sarah Powrie Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend Objective 2 as follows: Development that mitigates general visual and dominance effects and enhances public pedestrian use and accessibility of the precinct and surrounding public open space Sarah Powrie Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend Policy 1 as follows: Encourage the location, bulk, outlook, access to, and servicing of buildings to be planned and avoided remedies or mitigated Sarah Powrie Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend Policy 2 as follows: Encourage the establishment of an integrated, well-connected, safe and accessible pedestrian and public open space network through a framework plan that creates a public neighbourhood environment and which networks Sarah Powrie Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend Policy 3 as follows: Enable greater building height in appropriate locations through a framework plan consent while: a. avoiding wider dominance or visual effects on the environment; Sarah Powrie Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend Policy 4 as follows: Encourage consultation with the community and any other owners of land within a sub-precinct when preparing a framework plan Sarah Powrie Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend Policy 5(b) as follows: Require the framework plan to demonstrate the interrelationship and future integration with:... b. any neighbouring precinct the surrounding residential environment Sarah Powrie Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Delete Policy 6 as follows: Provide for integrated residential development on moderately large sites Gordon Sims Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend the Precinct to recognise the inadequacy of local road (particularity Lake Rd, Jutland Rd, Northboro Rd) to cope with additional traffic pressure from new development Gordon Sims Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend the Precinct to recognise the inadequacy of current water and sewer infrastructure to cope with increased density Deane Gates Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Delete extension of David Street in sub-precinct C Deane Gates Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend to remove opportunities for medium-high density housing and relaxation of density controls Deane Gates Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Delete development plans for sub-precincts Yvonne Groit Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend the provisions to reduce the level of intensification proposed in Sub-precinct B Lesley Newland Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend Precinct plan 3: Devonport Peninsula Sub-Precinct C, to remove the street connection from the end of David Street through to Plymouth Crescent Kevin and Catherine Mendousse Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Reject "development plans for sub-districts [inferred to mean sub-precincts] due to health and safety and Civil Defence Concerns] Kevin and Catherine Mendousse Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Retain biodiversity values, open space, native trees and the condition of natural resources within the Bayswaster Peninsula Janice M Venus Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend Objective 1 as follows: Integrated high quality housing development on large contiguous sites, which incorporate additional building bulk, height, and density while complementing building heights in adjacent residential areas avoiding, remedying or mitigating the effects on the environment Janice M Venus Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend Objective 2 as follows: Development that mitigates general visual and dominance effects and enhances public pedestrian use and accessibility of the precinct and surrounding public open space Janice M Venus Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Janice M Venus Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Janice M Venus Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Janice M Venus Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Janice M Venus Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Janice M Venus Precincts - North Devonport Peninsula Amend Policy 1 as follows: Encourage the location, bulk, outlook, access to, and servicing of buildings to be planned and avoided remedied or mitigated. Amend Policy 2 as follows: Encourage the establishment of an integrated, well-connected, safe and accessible pedestrian and public open space network through a framework plan that creates a public neighbourhood environment and which networks. Amend Policy 3(a) as follows: Enable greater building height in appropriate locations through a framework plan consent while: a. avoiding wider dominance or visual effects on the environment;... Amend Policy 4 as follows: 4. Encourage consultation with the community and any other owners of land within a subprecinct when preparing a framework plan. Amend Policy 5 (b) as follows: Require the framework plan to demonstrate the interrelationship and future integration with:... b. any neighbouring precinct the surrounding residential environment. Delete Policy 6 [integrated residential development]. 9/11