AF 447 Rio-Paris, 2009 Air Asia QZ 8501 Surabaya-Singapore, A Common thread for training? Capt. Nathalie de Ziegler WATS 2016
|
|
- Allison Griffith
- 6 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 AF 447 Rio-Paris, 2009 Air Asia QZ 8501 Surabaya-Singapore, 2014 A Common thread for training? Capt. Nathalie de Ziegler WATS 2016
2 REMINDER The sole objective of the safety investigation shall be the prevention of accidents and incidents. It is not the purpose of this activity to apportion blame or liability (ICAO Annex 13). 2
3 REMINDER The choice of events was driven by their availability to the BEA through investigations as investigation leader (AF 447) or an accredited representative (Air Asia QZ 8501) This presentation is not a formal study, it has no statistical value The aim is to suggest ideas for loss of control recovery training Snapshots are not the replica of the airplane cockpit during the event (drawn from FDR data, some missing elements recalculated) 3
4 Summary of event Air France 447 A330, Rio to Paris, June 2009 Augmented crew : 1 Captain, 2 F/Os In cruise at FL350, Captain not in cockpit Aircraft enters ice crystals, 3 pitot probes freeze 4
5 Air Asia QZ 8501 Summary of event A320, Surabaya - Singapore, Dec 2014 Crew of 2 pilots In cruise at FL320, crew mismanages an ECAM procedure, and disables both FACs 5
6 For both events, a common final scenario All Automation suddenly disengages Flight controls revert from normal to alternate law Some FE protections are lost, incl. the AOA protection Crews make inappropriate inputs on the flight controls Crews are unable to recognize the stall situation Airplanes enters a developed stall from which crews fail to recover Airplanes impact water less than 5 mn after AP disengagement 6
7 Is there a common thread for training? 7
8 Specific flight context? Particular crews? Event triggers? Airplane technical status? Startle effect? Crew performance? Aircraft energy awareness Crew dynamics Topics 8
9 References to other accidents Colgan Air, Dash 8 Q400, Newark to Buffalo, during approach, 2009 NTSB report concluded that the leading cause of the crash was the pilots inappropriate response to the SW West caribbean, MD82, Tocumen (Panama) to Fort de France, Martinique, FL 310 in 2005 JIAAC report concluded : «Circumstances... of the flight resulted in a stall. CRM and decision making of the crew were not appropriate» 9
10 Flight Context IMC, crews pre-occupied with weather issues In cruise at high altitude Normal SOPs prior to event are conducted uneventfully (from CVR) Note 1: West Caribbean Airways MD82 in 2005 (IMC, high altitude) Note 2: Colgan air is IMC in approach 10
11 Low experienced PF Air Asia, 2500 h AF 447, 2900 h Non standard cockpit gradient AF 447, two F/Os under-trained to leadership & decision making Flight crew Air Asia, the Captain was very experienced and a high authority gradient is perceptible in the CVR Note 1 : Colgan air Dash-8 Q400 : PF h (PM 2250 h) Note 2 : West caribean : PF 5 900h, as Captain, (PM 800 h), High cockpit gradient is found causal in event 11
12 Flight crew In both cases, at the initiation of the event, the usual decision-maker (captain) is not in his seat therefore «out of the loop» Note: Rejoining Flight in Progress for an «out of the loop» pilot in complex situations on complex airplanes could be investigated further 12
13 Event triggers Event triggers AF 447, event (pitot icing) is un-related to prior crew action Pitot icing is due to ice-crystals (St Elmo s fire, rise in SAT and cockipt temperature, smell of ozone are commented by the crew) The crew makes no connexion between symptoms of ice crystals, pitot icing and possible loss of airspeeds 13
14 In Air Asia Event triggers The trigger is the result of an inadequate crew action Captain pulls both FAC CBs (not permitted by QRH reset table) Captain is not aware of the consequence of his actions in flight F/O not aware that the Captain is going to pull the CBs F/O not aware of the impact of such action on the handling of the airplane (alternate law and rudder deflection) 14
15 Flight controls Flight controls revert to «Alternate law» Pitch control is normal, THS is operative Roll control becomes direct (somewhat sharper than normal) Some protections are lost: High pitch, high bank angle, High AOA Stall warning system is operative 15
16 Additionally, in Air Asia Flight controls The PF has to make a permanent right input on the sidestick to keep the wings level Because both FAC CBs were pulled The initial position of the rudder is approx 2 L 16
17 Startle «Normal» situation then suddenly: AP and A/THR disengage, ECAM warnings and Cautions Initial Startle Immediate and abrupt pilot actions on side-stick (PF) Impairment of situational awareness and problem solving ability Pilots have limited understanding of the situation Prolonged Startle (fear) «Startle Cycle» 17
18 Aircraft Energy In normal situation on a majority of modern aircraft PFD speed tape displays current speed (raw number) Current speed is assessed in relation to «known» limits (MMO, Green dot, VLS or equivalent ) which represent visual thresholds or boundaries Current speed is «projected» via SPEED TRENDS 18
19 Aircraft Energy Crews awareness of the aircraft energy seems fragile For both crews : 1. Energy awareness appears to be more dependent on speed tape indications, than on pitch / thrust 2. The initial focus is to keep the wings level, not to control the aircraft energy 3. «Stall» is not verbalized, the Stall recovery procedure not applied 19
20 Aircraft Energy 1 The crews energy awareness appears to be more dependent on speed tape indications, than on basic parameters : pitch, thrust 20
21 AF 447 Speed values are grossly erroneous at the initiation of event «SPD LIM» Flag is apparent Speed trends disappears Aircraft Energy 21
22 Air Asia Speed values are correct Characteristic speeds (boundaries) disappear (CBs pulled) «SPD LIM» flag is apparent Speed trends disappear Aircraft Energy 22
23 Aircraft Energy When some «familiar» elements of the speed tape are suddenly missing, flagged, or inconsistent The crew does not revert to pitch and thrust («FLY») 23
24 The main focus is to keep the wings level, not to control the aircraft energy AF 447: Essaie de ne pas toucher les commandes en latéral (try not to touch to the controls laterally) 2 Air Asia : level, level, level Aircraft Energy 24
25 Aircraft Energy «Stall» is not verbalized* / Procedure not applied 3 Crews do not make reference to Stall warning, do not identify / understand deterrent buffet (CVR) Stall warning does not trigger the expected action *Except West Caribbean («Es el Stall Capi») 25
26 Crew Dynamics Crew dynamics and mutual support ability are affected PF is not aware, almost incapacitated : Over-correcting, not correcting, tunnelling, frozen PM shows some awareness of the pitch /energy PM does not support PF efficiently (indicate deviations, take over when necessary) *Note : West Caribbean Airways, the Captain is tunneling on engine parameters 26
27 Crew Dynamics PF likely unaware of high pitch PF does not correct wide pitch excursions 27
28 Crew Dynamics PM seems to have some awareness of high pitch and low energy (CVR) AF 447 redescends ( go down ) Air Asia: pull down 28
29 Crew Dynamics PM does not support PF efficiently PM does not announce deviations with standard calls, orders provide un-clear or inconsistent targets : ie «pull down», «go down» PM unable to take over controls in due time When PM takes over, priority take over procedure is not carried out correctly 29
30 Crew Dynamics During the event, the normally expected crew dynamics is lost : Pilots do not share the same picture (energy awareness) Crew appears «dissociated» 30
31 Crew Dynamics Finally, when the stall is fully developped, both crews express they are completely lost AF 447: Tu comprends ou pas ce qui se passe? (do you understand what is going on or not?) Air Asia : Qu est ce qu il fout, là? (what is it doing here?) 31
32 Specific flight context Yes : IMC, avoiding adverse weather Specific crew Yes : Latent leadership issues (problematic authority gradient)? : Low experience Event triggers Topics Review Different but almost same operational consequences 32
33 Crew performance Before the event, SOPs are applied uneventfully During the event, main issues appear to be: Prolonged Startle Topics Review Loss of pilot know-how in basic handling Loss of energy awareness, especially for PF Dissociation of the crew, loss of dynamics 33
34 TRAINING STATUS Crews had not been trained extensively to manual flying at high altitude in the simulator and never practice on the line Crews had been trained to «approach to stall» in the simulator, but always in a known and predictable environment Simulator training scenarios do not always provide realistic startling situations possibly encountered in flight 34
35 Areas of Improvement in training: Improve understanding of aircraft energy : ie relation between pitch, thrust, speed Increase the ability to revert to basic flying without delay, if any doubt about speed display Improve recognition of Stall Key training issues Rehearse systematic immediate reaction to Stall warning 35
36 Key Training issues Explain to crews how and why the crew dynamics may be lost during stall Consider stall as a possibly startling, incapacitating, situation, for some crews, especially for the PF Train the PM to recover in case of inappropriate PF s actions, in case he/she is startled 36
37 AF 447 and Air Asia reports Links to the reports : AF Air Asia (QZ8501) Final report issued 1 december
38 Thank you for your attention 38
Indonesia AirAsia Flight Accident. Investigation
Indonesia AirAsia Flight Accident. On 28 December 2014, ATC lost contact with an Airbus A320 (PK-AXC) being operated by Indonesia AirAsia on a scheduled passenger flight from Surabaya to Singapore which
More informationHuman Factors Approach in KNKT Aviation Investigation Analysis
Human Factors Approach in KNKT Aviation Investigation Analysis Presented by Capt. Nurcahyo Ray Utomo Dip. TSI Head of Aviation Investigation Sub Committee Komite Nasional Keselamatan Transportasi (KNKT),
More informationStall. Review of the Fundamentals, the Procedure and the Training. Presented by Capt. Christian Norden/ Flight Crew Development
May 2011 Stall Review of the Fundamentals, the Procedure and the Training Presented by Capt. Christian Norden/ Flight Crew Development Content Introduction Stall phenomenon Angle of Attack Control and
More information- Ashok Poduval. School of Aviation
- Ashok Poduval 2009 RAeS FSG meeting International Committee for Aviation Training in Extended Envelopes (ICATEE) 2011 FAA ARC 2012 ICAO, EASA & FAA Loss of Control Avoidance and Recovery Training LOCART
More informationSerious Incident which occurred on 20 December 2009 In the cruise, FIR de Reims to Mc Donnell Douglas MD83
REPORT Serious Incident which occurred on 20 December 2009 In the cruise, FIR de Reims to Mc Donnell Douglas MD83 registration F-GMLU operated by Blue Line BEA Bureau d Enquêtes et d Analyses pour la Sécurité
More informationFINAL REPORT BOEING B777, REGISTRATION 9V-SWH LOSS OF SEPARATION EVENT 3 JULY 2014
FINAL REPORT BOEING B777, REGISTRATION 9V-SWH LOSS OF SEPARATION EVENT 3 JULY 2014 AIB/AAI/CAS.109 Air Accident Investigation Bureau of Singapore Ministry of Transport Singapore 11 November 2015 The Air
More informationFlight Operations Briefing Notes
Flight Operations Briefing Notes I Introduction Strict adherence to suitable standard operating procedures (SOPs) and associated normal checklists is a major contribution to preventing and reducing incidents
More informationAeroplane State Awareness during Go-around (ASAGA)
Aeroplane State Awareness during Go-around (ASAGA) INTRODUCTION Towards the end of the 2000 s, the BEA observed that a number of public air transport accidents or serious incidents were caused by a problem
More informationWhy Are We Here? (The Accident Loss of Control Record)
Why Are We Here? (The Accident Loss of Control Record) ICAO Loss of Control Symposium May 20-22, 2014 Dennis A. Crider Chief Technical Advisor, Vehicle Simulation National Transportation Safety Board 1
More informationDealing with Unexpected Events. ICAO LOC-I Symposium June 2015, Nairobi Sunjoo Advani - President, IDT
Dealing with Unexpected Events ICAO LOC-I Symposium 22-24 June 2015, Nairobi Sunjoo Advani - President, IDT 1 2 What is the most common human factor in LOC-I incidents? 3 Startle 1 What is Surprise in
More informationApproach-and-Landing Briefing Note Response to GPWS Pull-Up Maneuver Training
Approach-and-Landing Briefing Note 6.3 - Response to GPWS Pull-Up Maneuver Training Introduction A typical awareness and training program for the reduction of approach-and-landing accidents involving controlled-flight-into-terrain
More informationUpset Recovery Training (UPRT) for Type Rating Course
Upset Recovery Training (UPRT) for Type Rating Course 2016 Vadims Prudnikovs Ethiopian Airlines Capt. B767 15 years of TRI/TRE B767, B737, F50 Agenda Less than an hour brief summary of: UPRT legislation
More informationREPUBLIC OF KENYA MINISTRY OF TRANSPORT AND INFRASTRUCTURE DEPARTMENT OF AIR ACCIDENT INVESTIGATION
REPUBLIC OF KENYA MINISTRY OF TRANSPORT AND INFRASTRUCTURE DEPARTMENT OF AIR ACCIDENT INVESTIGATION PRESENTER Colonel Enos Ndoli CEng MRAeS MIEK Air Accident Investigator and Lecturer in Aeronautical Engineering
More informationdel Airbus en el mundo de la
Ing Ivan Ramirez Centro de ensayos de Airbus en Toulouse-Francia Automatización del Airbus en el mundo de la aviación Fly by wire aircraft Page 2 Contents Fly by wire principles Flight Handling Page 3
More informationFrom London to Athens : how a fuel imbalance lead to control difficulty!
Original idea from NTSB A CRITICAL FUEL IMBALANCE! From London to Athens : how a fuel imbalance lead to control difficulty! HISTORY OF THE FLIGHT The B737-400 departed from London Gatwick for a scheduled
More informationAirbus A , G-EZTE. None. 39 years
INCIDENT Aircraft Type and Registration: No & Type of Engines: Airbus A320-214, G-EZTE 2 CFM CFM56-5B4/3 turbofan engines Year of Manufacture: 2009 (Serial no: 3913) Date & Time (UTC): Location: Type of
More informationGo-Around Procedure. Flight Instructor Seminar / Miami, May 24 th and 25 th, 2011
Flight Instructor Seminar / Miami, May 24 th and 25 th, 2011 Go-Around Procedure Presented by Capt. David Owens / Senior Director Flight Crew Training Policy Content Introduction Go-Around Preparation
More informationFlight control checks Flight Control Events
Operational Liaison Meeting Fly-By-Wire Aircraft 2004 Flight control checks Flight Control Events Customer Services Contents Introduction Typical Flight Control Events Enhanced SOP F/CTL CHECKS Conclusion
More informationLoss Of Control Inflight. An Approach to Enhance Safety
Loss Of Control Inflight An Approach to Enhance Safety Loss Of Control Inflight TOP 3 HIGH-RISK OCCURRENCE CATEGORIES(TOT7) R/W SAFETY RELATED CONTROLLED FLIGHT INTO TERRAIN LOSS OF CONTROL IN-FLIGHT Loss
More informationforeword The Training and Flight Operations support team.
foreword This Flight Crew Training Manual is an essential tool to learn the ATR standard operating procedures. It has been conceived as the standard baseline for all ATR flight crew training. To facilitate
More informationDestabilized Approaches, The operational perspective Capt. Bertrand de Courville IATA - ECAST
Destabilized Approaches, The operational perspective Capt. Bertrand de Courville IATA - ECAST ICAO GRSS 2011 - Montreal Aircraft landing performance perspective Minimum stabilization height Activation
More informationApplication for the inclusion of the A330 Aeroplane Type in Aircraft Rating (In Flight Cruise Relief Only) of a Pilot s Licence (Aeroplanes)
ISO 9001: 2015 CERTIFIED Civil Aviation Authority of Fiji Application for the inclusion of the A330 Aeroplane Type in Aircraft Rating (In Flight Cruise Relief Only) of a Pilot s Licence (Aeroplanes) Form
More informationDoprava a spoje elektronický časopis Fakulty prevádzky a ekonomiky dopravy a spojov Žilinskej univerzity v Žiline, ISSN
THE PROBLEM OF UPSET RECOVERY TRAINING IN SCOPE OF AIR FRANCE AF447 ACCIDENT Ján Pitor 1, Karel Havel 2 Introduction Several recent fatal accidents of airliners show deficiencies in pilot manual flying
More informationAIRCRAFT INCIDENT REPORT
AIRCRAFT INCIDENT REPORT (cf. Aircraft Accident Investigation Act, No. 35/2004) M-04303/AIG-26 OY-RCA / N46PW BAe-146 / Piper PA46T 63 N, 028 W 1 August 2003 This investigation was carried out in accordance
More informationASAGA STUDY Guillaume ADAM & Johan CONDETTE
Bureau d Enquêtes et D Analyses pour la sécurité de l aviation civile ASAGA STUDY Guillaume ADAM & Johan CONDETTE guillaume.adam@bea-fr.org johan.condette@bea-fr.org 1. CONTEXT 2. INCIDENTS AND ACCIDENTS
More informationLessons learned at Alaska Airlines:
Royal Aeronautical Society Flight Simulation Group Implementing Enhanced UPRT Lessons learned at Alaska Airlines: High Level Seminar and Course on Loss of Control in-flight (LOC-I) and Upset Prevention
More informationMcDonnell Douglas MD-81 registered OY-KHP Date and time 6 February 2010 at 18h25 (1) Operator
Tail strike on runway during night landing (1) Except where otherwise stated, the times shown in this report are expressed in Universal Time Coordinated (UTC). One hour should be added to obtain the legal
More informationReport. Serious Incident on 11 January 2010 At Lagos Aerodrome (Nigeria) To the Boeing ER Registered F-GSQI Operated by Air France
Report Serious Incident on 11 January 2010 At Lagos Aerodrome (Nigeria) To the Boeing 777-300ER Registered F-GSQI Operated by Air France Bureau d Enquêtes et d Analyses pour la sécurité de l aviation civile
More informationREPORT SERIOUS INCIDENT
www.bea.aero REPORT SERIOUS INCIDENT Momentary Loss of Control of the Flight Path during a Go-around (1) Unless otherwise specified, the times in this report are expressed in Universal Time Coordinated
More informationInvestigation Report. Bundesstelle für Flugunfalluntersuchung. Identification. Factual Information
Bundesstelle für Flugunfalluntersuchung German Federal Bureau of Aircraft Accident Investigation Investigation Report 5X002-0/07 May 2010 Identification Type of Occurrence: Serious Incident Date: 24. January
More informationMisinterpreted Engine Situation
Misinterpreted Engine Situation Morrisville, NC December 13, 1994 Engine self-recovery light misinterpreted. Control lost on attempted goaround. Fatal crash. The aircraft crashed while executing an ILS
More informationAircraft Accident Investigation Bureau of Myanmar
1 Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau of Myanmar The aircraft accident investigation bureau (AAIB) is the air investigation authority in Myanmar responsible to the Ministry of Transport and Communications.
More informationPilot intended crashes: What can be done?
Pilot intended crashes: What can be done? Previous intentional crashes Preliminary report, Accident G-AIPX, Airbus A320-211,Prads-Haute-Bléone, France http://www.bea.aero/docspa/2015/d-px150324.en/pdf/d-px150324.en.pdf
More informationAVIATION INVESTIGATION REPORT A02P0290 GEAR-UP LANDING
Transportation Safety Board of Canada Bureau de la sécurité des transports du Canada AVIATION INVESTIGATION REPORT A02P0290 GEAR-UP LANDING CANADA JET CHARTERS LIMITED CESSNA CITATION 550 C-GYCJ SANDSPIT
More informationERRONEOUS SAFETY 28 AERO DAVID CARBAUGH CHIEF PILOT FLIGHT OPERATIONS SAFETY BOEING COMMERCIAL AIRPLANES. Third-Quarter 2003 July
ERRONEOUS Erroneous flight instrument indications still contribute to airplane accidents and incidents despite technological advances in airplane systems. To overcome potential problems, flight crews should
More informationKhartoum. Close Call in. causalfactors. Confusion reigned when an A321 was flown below minimums in a sandstorm.
A navigation fix that was not where the flight crew thought it was, omission of standard callouts and a mix-up in communication about sighting the approach lights were among the factors involved in an
More informationAI AIRCRAFT SERIOUS INCIDENT INVESTIGATION REPORT THAI AIRASIA X CO., LTD. H S X T C CHINA AIRLINES B
AI2018-2 AIRCRAFT SERIOUS INCIDENT INVESTIGATION REPORT THAI AIRASIA X CO., LTD. H S X T C CHINA AIRLINES B 1 8 3 6 1 March 27, 2018 The objective of the investigation conducted by the Japan Transport
More informationAutomation Dependency. Ensuring Robust Performance in Unexpected Situations Sunjoo Advani, IDT
Automation Dependency Ensuring Robust Performance in Unexpected Situations Sunjoo Advani, IDT Automation Dependency Challenges Crews are trained to rely on automation and envelope protection - HOWEVER
More informationThe role of Flight Data Analysis in the aircraft manufacturer s SMS.
WELCOME 09/06/2015 The role of Flight Data Analysis in the aircraft manufacturer s SMS. Monica Fiumana Martin Falcón monica.falcon@embraer.com.br Air Safety Department Embraer The role of Flight Data Analysis
More informationINVESTIGATION REPORT. Incident to ATR registered F-GVZG on 11 September 2011 at Marseille
INVESTIGATION REPORT www.bea.aero (1) Except where otherwise indicated, the times in this report are in Universal Time Coordinated (UTC). (2) Pilot Flying (3) Pilot Monitoring (4) MultiFunction Computer
More informationGUERNSEY ADVISORY CIRCULARS. (GACs) UPSET PREVENTION AND RECOVERY TRAINING GAC 121/135-2
GUERNSEY ADVISORY CIRCULARS (GACs) GAC 121/135-2 UPSET PREVENTION AND RECOVERY TRAINING Published by the Director of Civil Aviation, Guernsey First Issue August 2018 Guernsey Advisory Circulars (GACs)
More informationMID-Region. Standard Operating Procedures Effectiveness and Adherence
RASG-MID SAFETY ADVISORY 07 (RSA-07) May 2016 MID-Region Standard Operating Procedures Effectiveness and Adherence Date of Issue: May 2016 Revision No: Document Ref. No.: First Edition RASG-MID/MIDRAST/LOC-I/2
More informationChina Airlines Airbus A R (Flight 140) Misses Landing and Goes up in Flame at Nagoya Airport
China Airlines Airbus A300-600R (Flight 140) Misses Landing and Goes up in Flame at Nagoya Airport April 26, 1994 at Nagoya Airport Masayuki Nakao (Institute of Engineering Innovation, School of Engineering,
More information154 km west of Learmonth, WA 7 October 2008, VH-QPA Airbus A
AO-2008-070, In-flight upset 154 km west of Learmonth, WA 7 October 2008, VH-QPA Airbus A330-303 3 3 mike.walker@atsb.gov.au Overview Occurrence sequence of events On-site phase Cabin safety Systems Investigation
More informationLOFT A/B-90 SIM PRE/POST
INITIAL FOR KING AIR SERIES AIRCRAFT SimCheck Initial KING AIR SERIES AIRCRAFT OBJECTIVE: To introduce and review normal, emergency, and instrument flight operations in King Air aircraft through the use
More informationNational Transportation Safety Board Aviation Accident Final Report
National Transportation Safety Board Aviation Accident Final Report Location: Clarence Center, NY Accident Number: Date & Time: 02/12/2009, 2017 EST Registration: N200WQ Aircraft: BOMBARDIER INC DHC-8-402
More informationAIRBUS FlyByWire How it really works
AIRBUS FlyByWire How it really works Comparison between APOLLO s and Phoenix PSS Airbus FlyByWire implementation for FS2002 Copyright by APOLLO Software Publishing The FlyByWire control implemented on
More informationLoss of Control and Airplane State Awareness. Capt. Brit Etzold The Boeing Company COSCAP-NA/15 Xiamen, China 15 May 2015
Loss of Control and Airplane State Awareness Capt. Brit Etzold The Boeing Company COSCAP-NA/15 Xiamen, China 15 May 2015 Accident Categories Change over time Comparison of Fatalities 1993-2002, 1998-2007
More informationICAO LOC-I SYMPOSIUM STALL & UPRT IMPLEMENTATION. Itash Samani Global Head of FSTD Regulations, Regulatory Affairs June 2015 Nairobi Kenya
1 ICAO LOC-I SYMPOSIUM STALL & UPRT IMPLEMENTATION Itash Samani Global Head of FSTD Regulations, Regulatory Affairs 22-24 June 2015 Nairobi Kenya STALL & UPRT IMPLEMENTATION Regulatory Requirements ICAO,
More informationInterim Statement Ref. AAIU
SYNOPSYS Interim Statement Ref. Air Accident Investigation Unit (Belgium) City Atrium Rue du Progrès 56 1210 Brussels SYNOPSIS Date and time: Aircraft: Sunday 01 January 2017 at 11:47 UTC a. Airbus A320-214.
More informationOffice of Research and Engineering Safety Study Report: Introduction of Glass Cockpit Avionics into Light Aircraft Study Overview Joseph Kolly
Office of Research and Engineering Safety Study Report: Introduction of Glass Cockpit Avionics into Light Aircraft Study Overview Joseph Kolly NTSB Research Mandate Title 49 United States Code, Chapter
More informationOPERATIONS CIRCULAR 1 of 2010
GOVERNMENT OF INDIA CIVIL AVIATION DEPARTMENT OFFICE OF THE DIRECTOR GENERAL OF CIVIL AVIATION OPP. SAFDARJUNG AIRPORT, NEW DELHI 110 003 TELEPHONE: 091-011-24635261 24644768 FAX: 091-011-24644764 TELEX:
More informationFlight Operations Briefing Notes
Flight Operations Briefing Notes I Introduction The term optimum use of automation refers to the integrated and coordinated use of the following systems: Autopilot / flight director (AP / FD); Autothrottle
More informationNATIONAL TRANSPORTATION SAFETY BOARD
Docket No. SA-531 Exhibit No. 14-Q NATIONAL TRANSPORTATION SAFETY BOARD Washington, D.C. Colgan Air Safety Initiatives (4 Pages) Colgan Air Safety Initiatives After February 12, 2009 The following initiatives
More informationImplementing UPRT in an airline
Yann RENIER, IATA Presented by Henry Defalque, ICAO Module 3 Day 1 Implementing UPRT in an airline Flight Plan Safety Data Regulatory matters Training content Instructor qualification FSTD requirements
More informationBULLETIN Serious incident involving Tecnam P2002 JF OY-EJM
BULLETIN Serious incident 4-12-2018 involving Tecnam P2002 JF OY-EJM Side 1 af 11 FOREWORD This bulletin reflects the opinion of the Danish Accident Investigation Board regarding the circumstances of the
More informationFINAL REPORT SERIOUS INCIDENT TO AIRBUS A , REGISTRATION 9M-AQA, RUNWAY EXCURSION 7 JULY 2014
FINAL REPORT SERIOUS INCIDENT TO AIRBUS A320-216, REGISTRATION 9M-AQA, RUNWAY EXCURSION 7 JULY 2014 [AAIB BRUNEI 001/2014] Air Accident Investigation Team Brunei Darussalam Ministry of Communication 21
More informationRunway Safety Programme Global Runway Safety Action Plan
Runway Safety Programme Global Runway Safety Action Plan Brian DeCouto ICAO Air Navigation Bureau Implementation Support Officer - Safety 2 nd Global Runway Safety Symposium Lima, Peru, 20-22 November
More informationNewcastle Airport. 36 years
ACCIDENT Aircraft Type and Registration: No & Type of Engines: Embraer EMB-145MP, G-CGWV 2 Allison AE 3007A1 turbofan engines Year of Manufacture: 2000 (Serial no: 145362) Date & Time (UTC): Location:
More informationPilot RVSM Training Guidance Material
Pilot RVSM Training Guidance Material Captain Souhaiel DALLEL IFALPA RVP AFI WEST RVSM Pilot Procedures ICAO requires states to establish for flight crews specific: Initial training programs and Recurrent
More informationSAFE WINGS. This issue SOMATOGRAVIC ILLUSION GULF AIR FLIGHT 072 TATARSTAN AIRLINES FLIGHT 363 OTHER SUSPECTED SOMATOGRAVIC ILLUSION
SAFE WINGS Issue 49, JUNE 2016 This issue SOMATOGRAVIC ILLUSION GULF AIR FLIGHT 072 TATARSTAN AIRLINES FLIGHT 363 OTHER SUSPECTED SOMATOGRAVIC ILLUSION SAFE WINGS June Edition 49 EDITORIAL We have arrived
More informationBY MARK LACAGNINA. Stefan Sonnenberg/Airliners.net
BY MARK LACAGNINA Check Flight Stefan Sonnenberg/Airliners.net 22 flight safety foundation AeroSafetyWorld November 2010 Goes Bad The crew was unaware that the A320 s angle-of-attack sensors were frozen.
More informationR9 Slides - Systems & Limitations Validation Questions
A330 Recurrent Training Questions 6/5/2015 Updated : 08/07/2015 Send corrections / comments to: Bob Sanford, E-mail: busdriver@hky.com R9 Slides - Systems & Limitations Validation Questions What are the
More informationREPORT SERIOUS INCIDENT
www.bea.aero REPORT SERIOUS INCIDENT Unstabilised approach, triggering of GPWS and MSAW warnings, dual input, missed approach, at night under instruction (1) Unless otherwise specified, the times in this
More informationAA AIRCRAFT ACCIDENT INVESTIGATION REPORT UNITED AIRLINES N U A
AA2013-3 AIRCRAFT ACCIDENT INVESTIGATION REPORT UNITED AIRLINES N 2 2 4 U A March 29, 2013 The objective of the investigation conducted by the Japan Transport Safety Board in accordance with the Act for
More informationAir Accident Investigation Unit Ireland FACTUAL REPORT
Air Accident Investigation Unit Ireland FACTUAL REPORT SERIOUS INCIDENT Boeing 747-430, D-ABVH North Atlantic 19 November 2012 Boeing 747-430 D-ABVH North Atlantic 19 November 2012 FINAL REPORT AAIU Report
More informationTurboprop Propulsion System Malfunction Recog i n titi ion on an d R d Response
Turboprop Propulsion System Malfunction Recognition and Response Propulsion System Malfunction Recognition and Response The rate of occurrence per airplane departure for Propulsion System Malfunction Plus
More informationReal Stories of Loss of Control: When Upset Training Saved Lives. Tuesday, Oct. 16 2:30-3:30
Real Stories of Loss of Control: When Upset Training Saved Lives Tuesday, Oct. 16 2:30-3:30 Real Stories of Loss of Control: When Upset Training Saved Lives Bill Oefelein Naval Aviator and Test Pilot US
More informationCirrus SR22 registered F-HTAV Date and time 11 May 2013 at about 16 h 20 (1) Operator Place Type of flight Persons on board
www.bea.aero REPORT ACCIDENT Bounce on landing in strong wind, go-around and collision with terrain (1) Unless otherwise mentioned, the times given in this report are local. Aircraft Cirrus SR22 registered
More informationAir Accident Investigation Unit Ireland. FACTUAL REPORT INCIDENT TO BOMBARDIER DHC-8-402, G-JEDR Waterford Airport (EIWT), Ireland 05 June 2012
Air Accident Investigation Unit Ireland FACTUAL REPORT INCIDENT TO BOMBARDIER DHC-8-402, G-JEDR Waterford Airport (EIWT), Ireland 05 June 2012 Bombardier DHC-8-402, G-JEDR Waterford Airport (EIWT) 05 June
More informationAI AIRCRAFT SERIOUS INCIDENT INVESTIGATION REPORT J-AIR CORPORATION J A J
AI2015-3 AIRCRAFT SERIOUS INCIDENT INVESTIGATION REPORT J-AIR CORPORATION J A 2 0 2 J April 23, 2015 The objective of the investigation conducted by the Japan Transport Safety Board in accordance with
More informationAdvisory Circular to Air Operators. Mode Awareness and Energy State Management Aspects of Flight Deck Automation
Tel: 95 1 533004 Fax: 95 1 533016 AFTN: VYYYYAYX email: dfc@dca.gov.mm Ministry of Transport Department of Civil Aviation DCA H.Q Building Yangon International Airport Mingaladon, Yangon 11021 MYANMAR
More informationOPERATIONS CIRCULAR 01/2012. Subject: HEAD-UP DISPLAYS (HUD) AND ENHANCED VISION SYSTEMS (EVS)
GOVERNMENT OF INDIA CIVIL AVIATION DEPARTMENT OFFICE OF THE DIRECTOR GENERAL OF CIVIL AVIATION OPP. SAFDARJUNG AIRPORT, NEW DELHI 110 003 TELEPHONE: 091-011-4635261 4644768 FAX: 091-011-4644764 TELEX:
More informationIATA Air Carrier Self Audit Checklist Analysis Questionnaire
IATA Air Carrier Self Audit Checklist Analysis Questionnaire Purpose Runway Excursion Prevention Air Carrier Self Audit Checklist The Flight Safety Foundation (FSF) Reducing the Risk of Runway Excursions
More informationRASG-MID SAFETY ADVISORY 09 (RSA-09) May MID-Region. Airplane States Awareness (ASA) Low Speed Alerting
RASG-MID SAFETY ADVISORY 09 (RSA-09) May 2016 MID-Region Airplane States Awareness (ASA) Low Speed Alerting Date of Issue: May 2016 Revision No: Document Ref. No.: First Edition RASG-MID/MIDRAST/LOC-I/1
More informationAVIATION OCCURRENCE REPORT A98W0216 LOSS OF SEPARATION
AVIATION OCCURRENCE REPORT A98W0216 LOSS OF SEPARATION BETWEEN AIR CANADA BOEING 747-238 C-GAGC AND AIR CANADA BOEING 747-400 C-GAGM 55 NORTH LATITUDE AND 10 WEST LONGITUDE 27 SEPTEMBER 1998 The Transportation
More informationLoss of Control Due to Flight Crew Loss of Airplane State Awareness: Analysis and Safety Enhancements
Loss of Control Due to Flight Crew Loss of Airplane State Awareness: Analysis and Safety Enhancements Presented at RASG-AFI LOC-I symposium, Nairobi 22 June 2015 by Chamsou Andjorin The Boeing Company
More informationAVIATION INVESTIGATION REPORT A04Q0041 CONTROL DIFFICULTY
Transportation Safety Board of Canada Bureau de la sécurité des transports du Canada AVIATION INVESTIGATION REPORT A04Q0041 CONTROL DIFFICULTY AIR CANADA JAZZ DHC-8-300 C-GABP QUÉBEC/JEAN LESAGE INTERNATIONAL
More informationAirworthiness Directive
Airworthiness Directive AD No.: 2017-0257R1 Issued: 09 January 2018 EASA AD No.: 2017-0257R1 Note: This Airworthiness Directive (AD) is issued by EASA, acting in accordance with Regulation (EC) 216/2008
More informationPart I. Executive Summary. Introduction
Part I Comments by the Ethiopian Civil Aviation Authority on the Accident Investigation of Ethiopian Flight 409, Boeing 737-800, ET-ANB, January 25, 2010 Executive Summary Introduction 1. The Ethiopian
More informationAirplane State Awareness Joint Safety Analysis Team
Airplane State Awareness Joint Safety Analysis Team Final Report Analysis and Results June 17, 2014 ii Airplane State Awareness Joint Safety Analysis Team Interim Report Provided to the Commercial Aviation
More informationAVIATION INVESTIGATION REPORT A09O0117 ERRONEOUS INSTRUMENT INDICATIONS RESULTING IN AIRSPEED AND ALTITUDE DEVIATIONS
AVIATION INVESTIGATION REPORT A09O0117 ERRONEOUS INSTRUMENT INDICATIONS RESULTING IN AIRSPEED AND ALTITUDE DEVIATIONS LOT POLISH AIRLINES SA BOEING 767-300 SP-LPA NORTH BAY, ONTARIO 19 JUNE 2009 The Transportation
More informationAIRCRAFT INCIDENT REPORT
AIRCRAFT INCIDENT REPORT Report by the US National Transportation Safety Board into the incident to Boeing 757-200, TF-FII near Baltimore, USA on October 20, 2002 M-08602/AIG-34 The aim of aircraft accident
More informationFINAL REPORT BOEING , REGISTRATION 9V-SYH TURBULENCE ENCOUNTER 17 OCTOBER 2011
FINAL REPORT BOEING 777-300, REGISTRATION 9V-SYH TURBULENCE ENCOUNTER 17 OCTOBER 2011 AIB/AAI/CAS.078 Air Accident Investigation Bureau of Singapore Ministry of Transport Singapore 14 May 2013 2013 Government
More information20 November th European Flight Safety Workshop
20 November 2012 22.12.12 1 6 th European Flight Safety Workshop 'Automation Addiction': Is Technology Weakening Pilots' Skills? Acknowledgements: Capt Dennis Landry By Frances (USA) Romero Time.com Wed,
More informationLESSON PLAN Introduction (3 minutes)
LESSON PLAN Introduction (3 minutes) ATTENTION: MOTIVATION: OVERVIEW: Relate aircraft accident in which a multi-engine airplane ran off the end of the runway. This could have been avoided by correctly
More informationROYAL JORDANIAN AIRLINES FLIGHT OPERATIONS DEPARTMENT / FLIGHT SAFETY FLIGHT SAFETY NEWSLETTER ( AUGUST 2011 )
ROYAL JORDANIAN AIRLINES FLIGHT OPERATIONS DEPARTMENT / FLIGHT SAFETY FLIGHT SAFETY NEWSLETTER ( AUGUST 2011 ) Prepared by: F/O. Marwan Al-Dayaflah Manager Flight Safety 1 Table of content SUBJECT Hard
More informationRSA RASG-PA SAFETY ADVISORY
RSA RASG-PA SAFETY ADVISORY Regional Aviation Safety Group-Pan America Subject: Mode Awareness and Energy State Management Aspects of Flight Deck Automation Date: 1 September 2012 RSA No. RSA 2011-001-R0
More informationAir Accident Investigation Unit Ireland. FACTUAL REPORT ACCIDENT Colibri MB-2, EI-EWZ ILAS Airfield, Taghmon, Co. Wexford
Air Accident Investigation Unit Ireland FACTUAL REPORT ACCIDENT Colibri MB-2, EI-EWZ ILAS Airfield, Taghmon, Co. Wexford 9 June 2017 Colibri MB2, EI-EWZ ILAS Airfield, Co. Wexford 9 June 2017 FINAL REPORT
More informationTCAS Pilot training issues
November 2011 TCAS Pilot training issues This Briefing Leaflet is based in the main on the ACAS bulletin issued by Eurocontrol in February of 2011. This Bulletin focuses on pilot training, featuring a
More informationPROCEDURES Control your Speed During Descent, Approach and Landing
PROCEDURES Control your Speed During Descent, Approach and Landing Control your Speed During Descent, Approach and Landing This article is the conclusion of our theme of speed management during a flight,
More informationLesson Plan Introduction
Lesson Plan Introduction The following flight training program has been designed with consideration for the student's comfort level. The advancement is dependent upon the student's ability. The following
More informationThe pilot and airline operator s perspective on runway excursion hazards and mitigation options. Session 2 Presentation 1
The pilot and airline operator s perspective on runway excursion hazards and mitigation options Session 2 Presentation 1 Communications Communication hazards and mitigation The failure to provide timely,
More informationGlass Cockpits in General Aviation Aircraft. Consequences for training and simulators. Fred Abbink
Glass Cockpits in General Aviation Aircraft. Consequences for training and simulators Fred Abbink Content Development of Air transport cockpits, avionics, automation and safety Pre World War 2 Post World
More informationNational Transportation Safety Board Washington, D.C
National Transportation Safety Board Washington, D.C. 20594 Safety Recommendation Report Emergency Training for Air Traffic Controllers Accident Numbers: ERA15FA099, ERA14FA192, ERA13FA105, ERA13FA088,
More informationImplementation of Terrain Awareness and Warning System (TAWS) Final Report to CAST. Hop Potter, AFS-210,
Implementation of Terrain Awareness and Warning System (TAWS) Final Report to CAST Hop Potter, AFS-210, 5-24-06 What is TAWS? TAWS is a stunning success in preventing one of the most persistent causes
More informationFlight Operations Briefing Notes
Flight Operations Briefing Notes FSF ALAR Task Force Conclusions and Recommendations I Introduction This summary presents the conclusions and recommendations of the international Approach-and-Landing Accident
More informationInternational Aviation Safety Program
February 8, 2000 National Transportation Safety Board International Aviation Safety Program Aircraft Accident Investigations involving: International events with a U.S. registered aircraft, a U.S. operator
More informationTeaching UPRT BY SUNJOO ADVANI
Among the keys to global success will be accentuating the positive and Photos courtesy S. Advani, IDT eliminating the negative. Teaching UPRT BY SUNJOO ADVANI U pset prevention and recovery training (UPRT)
More information2017 WATS Conference FAA National Simulator Program
2017 WATS Conference FAA Presented by: Harvey Gay and Richard Budd Date: May 3, 2017 SL-1-NSP SUMMARY OUTLINE (NSP), AFS 205 FSTDs Classes of Airports Missing, Malfunctioning, or Inoperative Items FSTD
More information