Amphibian Ark Conservation Needs Assessment - Cuba, March 2011 Page 1

Similar documents
Special animals of the caves of the Kinabatangan need protection!

BIDOUP NUI BA NATIONAL PARK Foggy Forests & Legendary Mountains

The South Gippsland Koala. For over 60 years, the plantation industry has shared a unique relationship with the Strzelecki Koala. protection.

The Design of Nature Reserves

Establishment of Maquenque National Park to Achieve Connectivity within the San Juan-La Selva Biological Corridor

State of Nature 2016

NCC SUBMISSION ON EXPLANATION OF INTENDED EFFECT: STATE ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING POLICY NO 44 KOALA HABITAT PROTECTION

Draft Resolution on wetlands in polar and subpolar regions

Exchange of Experiences: Natural World Heritage sites. Sri Lanka. S.I Rajapakse, Assistant Director Ministry of Mahaweli Development and Environment

Bumble Bee Bat. Anna, Ava, Canaan

KOALA BEACH ESTATE TWEED SHIRE. 20 Years On

Monitoring the Environmental Status of the Heart of Borneo

WORKSHEET 1 Wilderness Qualities or Attributes Evaluating the Effects of Project Activities on Wilderness Attributes

The criteria for selecting this species as a candidate were the following:

Saving the Monarch Butterfly

Biosphere Reserves of India : Complete Study Notes

The Conservation Contributions of Ecotourism Cassandra Wardle

Designated Sites. Headlines

MANAGEMENT DIRECTION STATEMENT

ALBERTA S GRASSLANDS IN CONTEXT

Spatial Distribution and Characteristics of At-Risk Species in the Southeast U.S.

Biodiversity is life Biodiversity is our life

MAIN LAKE PROVINCIAL PARK

Natural Wonders. Great Rift Valley, a dormant volcano, a vital water tower, and a Critically Endangered forest antelope

REGIONAL AGREEMENT AND FRAMEWORK FOR MARINE MAMMALS CONSERVATION IN THE WCR: THE SPAW PROTOCOL AND THE MARINE MAMMAL ACTION PLAN

June 29 th 2015 SOS LEMURS SPECIAL INITIATIVE

National Park Service Wilderness Action Plan

Alternative 3 Prohibit Road Construction, Reconstruction, and Timber Harvest Except for Stewardship Purposes B Within Inventoried Roadless Areas

Arachnophobes look away now: Stunning BLUE tarantula is one of 30 new species discovered in Guyana's Kaieteur National Park

Code of conduct on international travel and invasive alien species

Draft Resolution on wetlands in polar and subpolar regions

Biosphere Reserve of IRAN. Mehrasa Mehrdadi Department of Environment of IRAN

Land Use. Grasslands and Rangelands National Parks and Reserves. Thursday, October 9, 14

News Highlights News Highlights News Highlights News Highlights News Highlights News Highlights

Western Australia The State of Islands

BOWAL TANKON AND BOWAL TOUPPE MAMA, DALABA

Twelve Apostles Marine National Park Australia

Appendix 1: Best Management Practices For Hang Gliding and Paragliding in Jasper National Parks

Zhulieta Harasani, MBA PhD. Petrit Harasani The shared Transboundary Natural and Cultural Heritage of the Lake Ohrid Region

The Impact of Human Activities on Plant diversity in Nanda Devi Biosphere Reserve, West Himalaya, India

Ecotourism in protected areas chances and threats. Aleksandra Machnik Chair of Human Ecology, Faculty of Tourism and Recreation AWF Poznań

SANTA-BOCA PROVINCIAL PARK

Protection of Ulcinj Saline

Mount Revelstoke and Glacier National Parks of Canada State of the Park Assessment (2018)

Decision Memo Broken Wheel Ranch Equestrian Outfitter Special-Use Permit Proposed Action

Lake Ohrid. our shared responsibilities and benefits. Protecting

photos Department of Environment and Conservation Biodiversity Conservation

RESEARCH REPORT. Globalization: Creating a Common Language. Sustainability Committee. Promoting ecotourism as a tool for sustainable environment

Daisy Dean Trail 628/619 ATV Trail Construction

Minimal Impact Caving Guidelines

On the Edge with Mangroves

Visual and Sensory Aspect

Conservation Services of

Project 3.3. The importance of peripheral areas of the Wet Tropics for conservation of biodiversity

Submission to the Draft Tasmanian Wilderness World Heritage Area Management Plan 2014 Tasmanian Government

3.10 BIOLOGICAL RESOURCES

PROMOTING NATIONAL PUBLIC AWARENESS IN BIODIVERSITY CONSERVATION AT LAKE TSIMANAMPESOTSA NATIONAL PARK, MADAGASCAR

CUBA HERPETOLOGY and NATURAL HISTORY PROGRAM

A GUIDE TO MANITOBA PROTECTED AREAS & LANDS PROTECTION

B10. Agate Beach State Recreation Site

Overview. Wilderness Act of Statement of Need. What is Wilderness Character. Monitoring Wilderness Character

Terrestrial Protected Area Nomination: Central Mangrove Wetland South-West, Grand Cayman

LEAFLET FEBRUARY. WWF-Greater Mekong DAWNA TENASSERIM LANDSCAPE. Wayuphong Jitvijak / WWF-Thailand

Wilderness Worksheets

INTERNATIONAL UNION FOR THE PROTECTION OF NEW VARIETIES OF PLANTS

112th CONGRESS. 1st Session H. R. 113 IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES

OPG, Nuclear 2

Madagascar. Biology, Rainforest & PADI. 16 Days. t: e: w:

Clearwater Lake Provincial Park. Draft Management Plan

13.1 REGIONAL TOURISM ISSUES AND SUMMARY OF FINDINGS

Why Guyana's rainforests are a scientist's dream

Little Limestone Lake Provincial Park. Draft Management Plan

Order of the Minister of Environment #39, August 22, 2011 Tbilisi

LAKE OHRID. Our Lake, Our Future. World Heritage Supplement

Pinellas County Environmental Lands

2.0 PARK VISION AND ROLES

State of Conservation Report Sagarmatha National Park, Nepal

Sabourin lake biodiversity reserve

The Rufford Foundation Final Report

Global Sustainable Tourism Destinations Criteria

UNIT 5 AFRICA PHYSICAL GEOGRAPHY SG 1 - PART II

Caring for our Lake our Future

The Values of the Tasmanian Wilderness World Heritage

Rainforest Frogs of the Wet Tropics,

Abbey Chesterton bridge Questions & Answers

[FWS HQ ES 2013 N191; FXES111309F FF09E22000] Endangered and Threatened Wildlife and Plants; Initiation of a 5-Year Review of

Wetlands Reservoirs of Biodiversity. Billy McCord, SCDNR

IMPORTANCE OF MANGROVES

Decision Memo for Desolation Trail: Mill D to Desolation Lake Trail Relocation

Labrador - Island Transmission Link Target Rare Plant Survey Locations

DATE: January 19, WCA Governing Board. Johnathan Perisho, Project Manager. Mark Stanley, Executive Officer

BULUSAN VOLCANO NATURAL PARK (BVNP) AS LOCAL CONSERVATION AREA

MINIMUM REQUIREMENTS DECISION GUIDE WORKSHEETS

Home to mangroves- trees that can grow in saltwater Mangroves provide housing for fish Greater Sundas home to endangered birds and other animals

Brown bear (Ursus arctos) fact sheet

Plant Conservation Efforts in Peninsular Malaysia

A GIS Analysis of Probable High Recreation Use Areas in Three Sisters Wilderness Deschutes and Willamette National Forests

Chambers of Commerce and Lake Groups advertised this NCWRPC created online survey that was : Opened: August 22, 2012; and Closed: October 4, 2012.

! Steps Methods Analyse

SUSTAINABLE ECOTOURISM DEVELOPMENT IN THE EMBERÁ INDIGENOUS COMMUNITIES, CHAGRES NATIONAL PARK, PANAMA

Transcription:

Amphibian Ark Conservation Needs Assessment - Cuba, March 2011 Page 1 Species in the In Situ Conservation Role 45 species Species for which mitigation of threats in the wild may still bring about their successful conservation. Species Eleutherodactylus blairhedgesi Threat Mitigation Threats cannot/will not be reversed in time Protected Habitat Comments Species occurs in an area where oil mining and tourism development is increasing (A. Rodríguez pers. comm. March 2011). There is a high risk of damage to the coast from oil mining (L. Díaz, pers. comm. March 2011). This is the only frog species in Cuba that lives close to the sea, and can tolerate high levels of salt (L. Díaz, pers. comm. March 2011). Huge potential for conservation education programs, especially about habitat restoration, unique habitat etc. Eleutherodactylus emiliae Threats cannot/will not be reversed in time Reassessed as Vulnerable during the 2010 Cuban Red List assessment. During recent surveys (2009) many fewer animals were found than during previous surveys, 18 years ago, This is in a protected area (L. Díaz. A. Estrada, pers. comm. March 2011). Could be used for education purposes as a good example of how species can disappear very quickly (L. Díaz, pers. comm. March 2011). Eleutherodactylus iberia Eleutherodactylus orientalis Reassessed as Vulnerable during 2010 Cuban Red List assessment. Is the smallest frog in the world. Habitat degradation could increase in the future from mining activities for nickel and chrome, even though the distribution of the species is within a national park. This activities could affect the watershed for many rivers in the area, so there is a high likelihood of widespread pollution (L. Díaz, A. Rodríguez pers. comm. March 2011). The species limits are also currently under review and additional studies are required (A. Rodríguez pers. comm. March 2011). Good for conservation education programs due to the clutch size and the size of the frog. Used as a flagship species in tourism, in brochures etc. (A. Rodríguez pers. comm. March 2011). Reassessed as Vulnerable during the 2010 Cuban Red List assessment. The entire distribution of the species is in a protected area. There is occasional habitat alteration in the area, mostly associated with the management of cacao and coffe plantations (A. Rodríguez pers. comm. March 2011). This is a very small frog that lays a single egg. The species is used for educational purposes by eco-tourism guides to talk about small frog species in Cuba (A. Rodríguez pers. comm. March 2011). Eleutherodactylus bresslerae

Amphibian Ark Conservation Needs Assessment - Cuba, March 2011 Page 2 Species Eleutherodactylus acmonis Threat Mitigation Protected Habitat Comments Reassessed as Vulnerable during the 2010 Cuban Red List assessment. Occurs in an effectively protected area (A. Rodríguez pers. comm. March 2011). Logging and farming still continue to be a threat to the species (L. Díaz, A. Rodríguez, pers. comm. March 2011). Economically significant because the local people take tourists to the area to show them this species (A. Rodríguez pers. comm. March 2011). Is fairly abundant and widespread (A. R. Estrada, pers. comm. March 2011). Distribution is very restricted but perhaps due to poor taxonomic resolution (A. Estrada, pers comm.). Would be a good analog for E. casparii and other ground-dwelling Eleutherodactylus species. Useful species for conservation education purposes. Eleutherodactylus cubanus Eleutherodactylus jaumei Reassessed as Vulnerable during the 2010 Cuban Red List assessment. This is one of the smallest frogs in the world and it has a clutch size of 1. Is a good candidate for conservation education programs. Reassessed as Vulnerable during the 2010 Cuban Red List assessment. Is one of the few species that lays only one egg (L. Díaz, pers. comm. March 2011). Eleutherodactylus leberi Reassessed as Vulnerable during the the 2010 Cuban Red List assessment. Lives in partly disturbed habitat, but it is unsure if this species is affected by disturbance (L. Díaz, A. Rodríguez pers. comm. March 2011). This species is recognised as a frog (rather than an insect) by the local farmers, and they show some empathy towards it, therefore there is a possibility for conservation education programs (A. Rodríguez pers. comm. March 2011). Eleutherodactylus melacara Reassessed as Vulnerable during the 2010 Cuban Red List assessment. Is used for education purposes by local eco-tourism guides (A. Rodríguez pers. comm. March 2011). Peltophryne cataulaciceps The population on the main island is relatively unknown compared to the population on Isla de la Juventud. Good educational potential due to very fast development of tadpoles (L. Díaz, pers. comm. March 2011). Phylogenetic studies are ongoing but not yet published (Alonso, R., A. J. Crawford & E. Bermingham (submitted). Molecular phylogeny of an endemic radiation of Cuban toads (Bufonidae: Peltophryne) based on mitochondrial and nuclear genes. Journal of Biogeography).

Amphibian Ark Conservation Needs Assessment - Cuba, March 2011 Page 3 Species Eleutherodactylus principalis Threat Mitigation Protected Habitat Comments Recent findings shows that this might be a synonym of the widespread E. auriculatus although the resolution of its taxonomic status is pending (Rodríguez, A., M. Vences, B. Nevado, A. Machordom y E. Verheyen. 2010. Biogeographic origin and radiation of Cuban Eleutherodactylus of the auriculatus species group, inferred from mitochondrial and nuclear gene sequences. Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution 54: 179 186). Eleutherodactylus symingtoni Eleutherodactylus limbatus Reassessed as Endangered during the 2010 Cuban Red List assessment. Most of the known locations for this species are in protected areas, however, the possible distribution of the species includes a great deal of unprotected area (L. Díaz, A. Rodríguez pers. comm. March 2011). Reassessed as Least Concern during the 2010 Cuban Red List assessment. Occurs in forests and has a wide distribution. Is mentioned in eco-tourism activities as the smallest frog in the world, even though this is not correct (A. Rodríguez pers. comm. March 2011). This species could be used as a husbandry analog for many other Eleutherodactylus species of the limbatus group. Eleutherodactylus zeus Is the largest Eleutherodactylus species. The distress call of this species sounds like a baby crying and the advertisement call is is a low-pitched, harmonic structured single signal. Reassessed as Near Threatened during the 2010 Cuban Red List assessment. Tourist activity is the main threat to this species, but it also occurs in areas that tourists do not visit (A. Rodríguez pers. comm. March 2011). Is important for use by eco-tourism guides to talk about cave-dwelling animals (A. Rodríguez pers. comm. March 2011). Could be a good husbandry analog for E. symingtoni. Eleutherodactylus adelus Reassessed as Vulnerable during the 2010 Cuban Red List assessment. The species is only known from pine forests and these are under increasing threat from fires (natural events that can become more frequent due to human effects) and selective logging (L. Díaz, pers. comm. March 2011). Although the species occurs close to protected areas, the pine forests themselves are not effectively protected but it is unknown if logging of the pine forests actually affects the species (A. Rodríguez pers. comm. March 2011).

Amphibian Ark Conservation Needs Assessment - Cuba, March 2011 Page 4 Species Eleutherodactylus albipes Threat Mitigation Protected Habitat Comments Reassessed as Vulnerable during the 2010 Cuban Red List assessment. Occurs in a very specific habitat at high altitude (L. Díaz, pers. comm. March 2011). The species occurs in protected areas and these are effectively managed (A. Rodríguez, L. Díaz, pers. comm. March 2011). The trail on Turquino Peak is used a lot by tourists and this is leading to increasing amounts of rubbish being left behind. There are no resources to remove the rubbish (L. Díaz, pers. comm.). At this stage, we do not know if this affects the species (A. R. Estrada, pers. comm. March 2011). Is also one of the highest altitude living frogs in Cuba. Eleutherodactylus bartonsmithi Reassessed as Vulnerable during the 2010 Cuban Red List assessment. Habitat has probably not changed over the last 50 years. The biggest impact on this species is a paved road that was put through the area (A. R. Estrada, pers. comm. March 2011). Eleutherodactylus etheridgei Reassessed as Vulnerable during 2010 Cuban Red List assessment. This is a coastaldwelling species, and future development may impact this species, even though it can exist with human settlement (L. Díaz, A. Rodríguez pers. comm. March 2011). It occurs in very dry and hot areas and it spends the day in rocks and limestone. Eleutherodactylus glamyrus Reassessed as Vulnerable during the 2010 Cuban Red List assessment. Educational potential exists due to the use of the area as an eco-tourism area - information could be included in local information available for tourists (A. Rodríguez pers. comm. March 2011). Eleutherodactylus maestrensis Eleutherodactylus michaelschmidi Reassessed as Vulnerable during the 2010 Cuban Red List assessment. Is known from 4 or 5 localities in a mountain range. Area of occupation estimated to be 24 sq km (A. Rodríguez pers. comm. March 2011). evidence of decrease in habitat. Phylogeny still requires further research. Reassessed as Vulnerable during the 2010 Cuban Red List assessment. The species occurs close to a protected area (L. Díaz pers. comm. March 2011), and has recently been found inside the protected area (A. Rodríguez pers. comm. March 2011). Eleutherodactylus pezopetrus Reassessed as Vulnerable during the 2010 Cuban Red List assessment. Recent surveys in the original location failed to find the species, but it has subsequently been found in other areas (L. Díaz, pers. comm. March 2011). Two of the three localities where this species occurs are in protected areas (A. Rodríguez and L. Díaz, pers. comm. March 2011). Eleutherodactylus rivularis Reassessed as Vulnerable during the 2010 Cuban Red List assessment.

Amphibian Ark Conservation Needs Assessment - Cuba, March 2011 Page 5 Species Eleutherodactylus tetajulia Threat Mitigation Protected Habitat Comments Reassessed as Vulnerable during the 2010 Cuban Red List assessment. Although the species mostly occurs in protected areas, mining activities could threaten this region in the near future (A. Rodríguez pers. comm. March 2011). Eleutherodactylus tonyi Unknown Reassessed as Vulnerable during the 2010 Cuban Red List assessment. Four of the nine know localities occurs in a significant national park that also covers extensive areas of suitable habitat (A. Rodríguez and L. Díaz, pers. comm. March 2011). Recent findings have identiffied new localities for this taxon outside of protected areas (Heinicke, M. P., L. M. Díaz y S. B. Hedges. 2011. Origin of invasive Florida frogs traced to Cuba. Biology Letters 7: published online 26 January 2011) and additional research is required to determine the extent of distribution (A. Rodríguez pers. comm. March 2011). Eleutherodactylus turquinensis The name of this species is likely to change during 2011 (L. Díaz, pers. comm. March 2011). Reassessed as Vulnerable during the 2010 Cuban Red List assessment. The main threat to this species is from tourists contaminating the water. There is potential to educate tourists in the area about protecting amphibians and not polluting the streams (L. Díaz, pers. comm. March 2011). Due to its aquatic habits this is one of the potential species to be affected by chytrid fungus (L. Díaz, pers. comm. March 2011). Eleutherodactylus eileenae Reassessed as Least Concern during the 2010 Cuban Red List assessment. It is one of the few species in Cuba that has a common name, which refers to its call. Husbandry analog for E. leberi. Populations on Guanahacabibes Peninsula and Sierra de los Organos seem to be distinct from the others on the rest of the island. (A. Rodríguez pers. comm. March 2011). Eleutherodactylus klinikowskii Reassessed as Least Concern during the 2010 Cuban Red List assessment although this is currently under review. This is a cave-dwelling frog, that occurs in a high tourist area but the species does not seem to be declining and the habitat is not being degraded. Tourists go on a trail through the caves where this species exists, and there are good opportunities for conservation education here (A. Rodríguez pers. comm. March 2011).

Amphibian Ark Conservation Needs Assessment - Cuba, March 2011 Page 6 Species Eleutherodactylus guanahacabibes Threat Mitigation Protected Habitat Comments Reassessed as Near Threatened during the 2010 Cuban Red List assessment. Is now a more common species than was previously thought (L. Díaz, pers. comm. March 2011). There are plans to increase roads and tourism access in some of the areas where this species occurs. Possibly has some economic value for eco-tourism (A. Rodríguez pers. comm. March 2011). Eleutherodactylus casparii Reassessed as Least Concern during the 2010 Cuban Red List assessment. Unsure of the impact of increased tourism in the forest on this species. It is a ground-dwelling species (A. R. Estrada, pers. comm. March 2011). Eleutherodactylus dimidiatus Reassessed as Least Concern during 2010 Cuban Red List assessment. Is an attractive species. Could be a husbandry analog for E. emiliae or E. maestrensis. Eleutherodactylus goini Reassessed as Least Concern during 2010 Cuban Red List assessment. Eleutherodactylus greyi Reassessed as Least Concern during the 2010 Cuban Red List assessment. Unsure if this species is dependant on forest (L. Díaz, pers. comm. March 2011). Eleutherodactylus guantanamera Reassessed as Least Concern during the 2010 Cuban Red List assessment. Could be a husbandry analog for E. melacara. Species limits between this species and E. ionthus remain elusive (A. Rodríguez pers. comm. March 2011). Eleutherodactylus gundlachi Eleutherodactylus intermedius Reassessed as Least Concern during the 2010 Cuban Red List assessment. Reassessed as Least Concern during the 2010 Cuban Red List assessment. Could be used as a husbandry analog for E. maestrensis. Commonly heard in forests, and population size is considered to be quite high. There is no evidence of decrease in population numbers (L. Díaz, pers. comm. March 2011). Occurs in a number of large protected areas. It is a forest-restricted species, and there are risks from logging (L. Díaz, pers. comm. March 2011). Could be used as a husbandry ananalog for E. albipes and E. tetajulia. Eleutherodactylus ionthus Reassessed as Least Concern during the 2010 Cuban Red List assessment. The species inhabits uplands and lowlands and is not overly affected by habitat disturbance (L. Díaz, pers. comm. March 2011).

Amphibian Ark Conservation Needs Assessment - Cuba, March 2011 Page 7 Species Eleutherodactylus pinarensis Threat Mitigation Protected Habitat Comments Reassessed as Least Concern during the 2010 Cuban Red List assessment. The species is relatively common in suitable habitats (L. Díaz, pers. comm. March 2011). Some of the caves that are used by this species have become degraded, and the local forest is also under minor threat from charcoaling (L. Díaz, pers. comm. March 2011). Eleutherodactylus ricordii Reassessed as Least Concern during the 2010 Cuban Red List assessment. This species is a forest specialist and there are still good populations of the species (L. Díaz, A. R. Estrada, A. Rodríguez pers. comm. March 2011). Could be used as a husbandry analog for other ground-dwelling species e.g. E. acmonis. Eleutherodactylus thomasi Reassessed as Least Concern during the 2010 Cuban Red List assessment. The species occurs mostly in protected areas (L. Díaz, A. Rodríguez pers. comm. March 2011). Localy there is mining in the area of distribution, and the species exists in caves that are also being degraded (A. Rodríguez, L. Díaz pers. comm. March 2011). Could be a husbandry analog for E. pinarensis and E. pezopetrus. Eleutherodactylus toa Eleutherodactylus varians Unknown Reassessed as Least Concernduring the 2010 Cuban Red List assessment. Reassessed as Least Concern during the 2010 Cuban Red List assessment. Is a bromeliad dweller and is sensitive to habitat destruction and requires bromeliads. Is known to re-populate areas where bromeliads have been re-established (L. Díaz, pers. comm. March 2011). Could be used as a husbandry analog for E. guantanamera and E. melacara. Could be used for education programs due to its very loud and distinctive call. Eleutherodactylus zugi Reassessed as Least Concern during the 2010 Cuban Red List assessment. According to some authors, one of the two subspecies currently recognized should be assigned a specific status (E. erythroproctus) (Hedges, S. B., W. E. Duellman y M. P. Heinicke. 2008. New World direct-developing frogs (Anura: Terrarana): Molecular phylogeny, classification, biogeography, and conservation. Zootaxa 1737: 1 182). But given that proper data were not provided, still is not recognized as such by Cuban herpetologists (Díaz, L. M. y A. Cádiz. 2008. Guía taxonómica de los anfibios de Cuba. ABC Taxa 4: 1-294; A. Rodríguez and L. Díaz, pers. comm. March 2011).

Amphibian Ark Conservation Needs Assessment - Cuba, March 2011 Page 8 Species Eleutherodactylus mariposa Threat Mitigation Protected Habitat Comments Reassessed as Vulnerable during the 2010 Cuban Red List assessment. Some of the population occurs in a non-legally protected area, but this area is not effectively managed and other areas where the species exists are not protected (L. Díaz, A. Rodríguez pers. comm. March 2011). Has a very charismatic call (A. Rodríguez pers. comm. March 2011).

Amphibian Ark Conservation Needs Assessment - Cuba, March 2011 Page 9

Amphibian Ark Conservation Needs Assessment - Cuba, March 2011 Page 10

Amphibian Ark Conservation Needs Assessment - Cuba, March 2011 Page 11

Amphibian Ark Conservation Needs Assessment - Cuba, March 2011 Page 12

Amphibian Ark Conservation Needs Assessment - Cuba, March 2011 Page 13

Amphibian Ark Conservation Needs Assessment - Cuba, March 2011 Page 14

Amphibian Ark Conservation Needs Assessment - Cuba, March 2011 Page 15

Amphibian Ark Conservation Needs Assessment - Cuba, March 2011 Page 16