Sustainable management of ASEAN Heritage Parks through valuing and improving eco-tourism Korea Environment Institute (KEI) ASEAN Centre for Biodiversity (ACB) Makiling Forest, Tarutao National Park
Contents 1 Introduction 2 Designing BBI pilot-project 3 Results of the project 4 Conclusion 2
1 Introduction 3
Background Eco-tourism is one of the most important ecosystem services, providing a powerful incentive for national and local economies which is also highlighted in SBSTTA20. ASEAN Member States declared ASEAN Heritage Parks(AHPs) to increase effectiveness of management, including eco-tourism, on certain protected areas with high conservation importance. Location of 37 AHPs 4
Background However, due to lack of data, it is a challenge to monitor ecotourism and set specific management plan for ecotourism in AHPs. ASEAN Centre for Biodiversity(ACB) asked for a science/technology-based approach that can be easily utilized in AHPs to assess status of eco-tourism. Dynamic population mapping using mobile phone data Deville et al. 2014 5
Objectives Korea Environment Institute (KEI), in collaboration with ASEAN Centre for Biodiversity (ACB), will apply an innovative modeling approach using social big-data to examine the current status of management, and support the development of related management strategies encouraging eco-tourism that enhances cultural services in AHPs. Measuring and mapping the value of nature-based tourism & recreation to a place Understanding what characteristics of the ecosystem attract tourists or deter them from visiting 6
2 Designing BBI pilot-project 7
Key Elements of BBI Reflecting needs of developing countries Partnership between institutions Support Implication of Aichi Targets Showcase for best practices Collaborative actions to transfer technic and knowledge Close coordination between experts 8
Key strategies to implicate BBI s objective A. Facilitate the linking of needs through effective partnerships between KEI and ACB B. Participation of regional experts C. Transferring techniques and knowledge 9
Key strategies to implicate BBI s objective Field-survey in AHPs (Mt. Makiling, Philippines) Exploring needs on management of AHPs with local institutions(acb) and local experts 10
Confirmed project sites The research project will be piloted in two sites, namely: 1) Mt. Makiling Natural Reserve, Laguna Province, Philippines 2) Tarutao National Marine Park, Satun Province, Thailand Mt. Makiling Tarutao Park 11
A Framework to evaluate eco-tourism in AHPs Field study (Survey with questionnaire) 2. Evaluate status and characteristic of eco-tourism in AHPs Characteristics of eco-tourism Spatial Preference 3. Support to develop strategies to facilitate ecotourism in AHPs 1. Estimate the spatial preference Big Data - FLICKER 12
Contents of the project Transfer technologies and knowledges to assess the current status on eco-tourism in AHPs Technical modeling on the status of eco-tourism using social big-data Field study(based on questionnaires) to evaluate status of eco-tourism A training workshop on modeling technique and best practices in eco-tourism management Support to develop strategies for sustainable management 13
Contents of the project (1) Transferring technologies and knowledges to assess the current status on eco-tourism in AHPs. - Technical modeling(invest Recreation Model) on the status of management using social big-data. - Field study(based on questionnaires) to evaluate status of eco-tourism. - A training workshop on technical/scientific approaches to encourage ecotourism at the 5th ASEAN Heritage Parks Conference. (2) Support to develop strategies for sustainable management of AHPs - Deter strong/weak elements, spatial visiting characteristic, and overall trends of eco-tourism in AHPs 14
3 Results of the project 15
Evaluating spatial preference using social big-data (1) Identifying ranking of AHPs with higher preference in FLICKER Ranking of PUD 35.000 Ranking of AHPs having higher social preference 35.000 30.000 30.000 25.000 25.000 PUD_ YR_ AVG 20.000 15.000 PUD_ YR_ AVG 20.000 15.000 10.000 10.000 5.000 5.000 0.000 0.000 ASEAN Heritage Parks ASEAN Heritage Parks PUD(Photo-User-Days): Mean uploaded number of geotagged photographs per day in Flicker from 2005 to 2014
Evaluating spatial preference using social big-data (1) Identifying ranking of AHPs with higher preference in FLICKER Top 12 AHPs with highest PUD per park area 0.700 0.600 0.500 PUD_YR_AVG/ park area 0.400 0.300 0.200 0.100 0.000 Inlay Lake Ao Mount Mount Kinabalu Ba Be Tarutao Hoang Lien Gunung Khao Yai Bai Tu Long Preah Phangnga - Makiling Timpoong - Son - Sa Pa Mulu Monivong Mu Koh Hibok-hibok (Bokor) Surin - Mu Koh Similan ASEAN Heritage Parks Support to analyze trend of eco-tourism after designating AHPs
Evaluating spatial preference using social big-data (2) Identifying specific visiting characteristics for two sites Makiling AHPs Tarutao AHPs Legend osm_points realtrail boundary pud_results <all other values PUD_YR_AVG 0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.6 1.7 6.7 9.8 17.7 19.7 26.5 33.2 Provide spatial characteristic identifying frequently visiting natural and artificial attraction, landscape and spot
Identifying specific characteristics of eco-tourism Through the discussion between KEI s experts and regional experts, three questionnaires were developed for visitor, regional community, and manager Regional AHPs managers supported field survey to collect questionnaires Total number of respondents: (1) Makiling - 100 (2) Tarutao - 142 (1) Effectiveness of AHPs to eco-tourism among two national parks Makiling AHPs Tarutao AHPs 100.0 80 80.0 70 60 60.0 50 40.0 20.0 visitor resident manager 40 30 20 10 visitor resident manager 0.0 It had major influence It had influence but not major Designation had no influence 0 It had major influence It had influence but not major Designation had no influence Among (1) biological, ecological value (2) social, cultural value and (3) facility, designation of AHPs had major influence to increase biological and ecological value
Identifying specific characteristics of eco-tourism (2) Visiting satisfactions of each attributes of eco-tourism Makiling AHPs Tarutao AHPs Satisfaction 4.3- High 4.2 4.1 4.0 3.9 3.8 3.7 3.6 3.5 3.4 3.3 Low High Biodiversity, 4.2 High Conservation Status, 4.0 Natural Ecosystems Services, 4.1 Infrastructure, 3.4 Educational Program, 3.9 Recreation/Lei sure Program, 3.8 Elements of eco-tourism Explanation of the Environment, 3.8 Number of Visitors, 4.0 Regional Product, 3.5 Regional Identities/Com munity Culture, 3.4 Satisfaction 3.8- High 3.8 3.7 3.7 3.6 3.6 3.5 3.5 3.4 3.4 Low 3.3 High Biodiversity, 3.8 Natural Ecosystems Services, 3.8 High Conservation Status, 3.6 Convenient Facilities, 3.6 Educational Program, 3.5 Recreation/L eisure Program, 3.8 Infrastructure, 3.3 Elements of eco-tourism Explanation of the Environment, 3.5 Number of Visitors, 3.6 Regional Identities/Co mmunity Culture, 3.4 Regional Product, 3.4
Identifying specific characteristics of eco-tourism (3) Suitability of management budget Makiling AHPs Tarutao AHPs After AHP designation, did management budg et increased? Managers: 55.6% said Yes After AHP designation, did management budg et increased? Managers: 88.9% said Yes Was it sufficient? Managers: 90.5 % said No Was it sufficient? Managers: 68.9 % said Yes How was the budget increased? increased external funding: 68.2 % increased government funding: 22.7 % How was the budget increased? increased government funding: 57.8% increased admission fee: 31.1%
Transferring technologies and knowledges Technical Workshop in Bukhan National Park, Republic of Korea Transferring techniques to use social big-data to assess spatial preference Identifying elements that need to be improved based on field study Introducing Korea s management strategies of national park
4 Conclusion 23
Conclusion The places people visit reveal their preferences about natural environments Use of social big-data made available to assess spatial preference, and AHPs managers were able to recognize where it needs to be well and newly managed Within spatial data, results of field-study provide insights to identify status of eco-tourism to identify strong and weak elements Transferred technique, knowledge, and result of the BBI pilot project can be further utilized in management of AHPs to effectively implement Aichi Target 1, 11, 14. 24
Thank You (kimyj@kei.re.kr)