2015 International Conference on Education Research(ICER): Future Education Design: Theory, Practice, and Policy Diaspora Diplomacy and Capacity Building between the Caribbean Community (CARICOM) and Taiwan Presented by: Cleisha-Bernise Springer 克莉沙 International Masters in Asia-Pacific Studies (IMAS) National Chengchi University Class of Spring 2015
Presentation Outline 1. Introduction 2. Methodology 3. Findings and Discussion ( 5 core questions) 4. Recommendations 5. Final Conclusions 6. Limitations
Introduction Summation of Thesis The research sought to present diaspora diplomacy and diaspora engagement as important options worthy of consideration by the CARICOM member states for the continued strengthening of bilateral relations and the furtherance of their development goals. 1. Identify and present relevant national and regional diaspora-based strategies and schemes that may be employed collectively by CARICOM towards deepening bilateral relations with the Asia/Pacific region 2. Propose recommendations for diaspora engagement and active citizen mobilization of CARICOM nationals in Taiwan 3. Sought to highlight the potential of the youth demographic
Introduction Research Background -Diaspora communities (particularly first-generation migrants) accounted for 3% of the world s total population. (Economist 2011) -Diaspora communities aid in the social and economic development of their home countries through remittances and additional capital flows of foreign exchange. -Allowed local businesses to enter extra-regional niche markets. -Diversifies the socio-cultural fabric of their host countries, insodoing enhancing the global awareness and cultural sensitivity of their host countries.
Introduction Research Background Number of foreign residents in Taiwan at over 636,000. This figure accounts for nearly 3% of Taiwan s total population of 23.4 million people. CARICOM nationals represent 0.06% of Taiwan s total international community. Population of CARICOM Nationals in Taiwan Country No. of residents Barbados 4 Belize 118 Dominica 1 Grenada 1 Guyana 1 Haiti 86 Jamaica 3 Saint Kitts and Nevis 44 Saint Lucia 74 Saint Vincent and the Grenadines 53 Suriname 1 Total 386 *Source: 104.2 Foreign Residents by Nationality 2015/4/2 (National Immigration Agency)
Introduction Research Background Foreign Policy Context between CARICOM and East Asian states: -Japan, North and South Korea,China and Taiwan have diplomatic relations in the region. These relations span decades. -Foreign Policy of East Asian states towards the Caribbean concerns: sustainable development, infrastructure, ICT, environmental protection cultural and technical exchanges, infrastructure and fisheries.
Methodology Survey and Follow-up emailed interviews Conducted from May 20 th -June 13 th, 2015. Acquired 30 respondents from 5 CARICOM states (diplomatic allies to Taiwan) Questions were a combination of open-ended, closed and Likert scales Interviews (Face-to-face and Skype) Ambassadors of overseas missions of CARICOM states, Director-General of the Organization of Eastern Caribbean, representatives from FICHET (Foundation for International Cooperation in Higher Education) and Quanta Culture and Education Foundation Analysis of Supplementary case studies Saint Lucia and Jamaica were chosen as models for the CARICOM-Taiwan context.
Five Core Questions The study answered the following questions: 1. What tangible, mutual socio-economic benefits have such strategies produced in both the countries of origin and the host countries? 2. What specific aspects of regional diaspora-based diplomacy strategies can be applied to the CARICOM-Asia-Pacific context? 3. In what ways can the CARICOM diaspora in Taiwan enhance on the opportunities and environments presented to them by their host country? 4. What obstacles must be addressed if the projected benefits are to be achieved? 5. Could such strategies progress to noted significance that could warrant concern amidst tension brought on by the One China Policy?
Survey and Follow-up Interviews Conducted via Social Media (Facebook) May 20 th -June 13 th, 2015. Acquired 30 respondents from 5 CARICOM states (diplomatic allies to Taiwan) Combination of open-ended, closed, Likert scale Questions acquired, basic information such as county of residence and age and with more in depth questions that gauged familiarity with their culture, their connection back home, their eagerness to share their culture, and their interaction with their Taiwanese peers. 10 out of 30 participants consented to participate in follow-up interviews. Given 5 days to reply ( due to time constraints) 3 out of 10 respondents (all from Saint Lucia) replied to those follow-up interviews. Participants believed that Taiwan could benefit from the presence of CARICOM s diaspora, and that a united culture-based approach is important.
Findings & Discussion (5 Core Questions) The study answered the following questions: 1. What tangible, mutual socio-economic benefits have such strategies produced in both the countries of origin and the host countries? 2. What specific aspects of regional diaspora-based diplomacy strategies can be applied to the CARICOM-Asia-Pacific context? 3. In what ways can the CARICOM diaspora in Taiwan enhance on the opportunities and environments presented to them by their host country? 4. What obstacles must be addressed if the projected benefits are to be achieved? 5. Could such strategies progress to noted significance that could warrant concern amidst tension brought on by the One China Policy?
Recommendations Recommendation 1: Diaspora Data Repository 1. Diaspora mapping that extends to take account of scholarship students and young professionals in technical training workshops CARICOM Global Citizens Databank. 2. Keep a record of educational migrants and young labour migrants; information derived from regional, extra-regional institutions, national statistics bureaus, scholarship foundations, non-profit organizations as well as student organizations can be compiled. 3. Establishing IOM branches among the CARICOM member states or facilitating diaspora mapping, quantitative and qualitative data collection and analysis workshops with IOM Jamaica can help achieve this goal. 4. Function of the Council of Foreign and Community Relations
Recommendation 2: Formation of the CARICOM Global Youth and Professionals Network (CGYPC) Based on Pacific Youth Council Model 1. allowing youth of various disciplines an additional channel to be able to connect with their fellow youth abroad; 2. serve as an additional database for CARICOM to inquire about the demographics of CARICOM nationals in the Asia-Pacific; 3. serve as a culture and language resource by CARICOM nationals abroad for CARICOM nationals at home; 4. foster relations with prospective non-profit or quasi-governmental organizations that could be of assistance to grassroots schemes in the Caribbean region; 5. help expand CARICOM s outreach and develop rapporteur within Asia-Pacific host countries.
Recommendation 3: Opportunities for enhanced cultural-exchanges in Taiwan 1. Diaspora Panel Discussions 2. Partnering for Arts Workshops 3. SID Youth Conferences on Cultural Preservation and Promotion 4. Collaboration with Educational Foundations and Cultural Organizations 5. Collaboration with Taiwanese Overseas Ambassadors and ICDF volunteers 6. With newcomers come new ideas
Final Conclusions The need for a united approach has been acknowledged despite size and other limitations of the diaspora. There is undoubtedly potential present in the form of the diaspora abroad. The contributions they can make as part of a joint initiative supported by CARICOM are numerous but must be harnessed properly in order to produce the desired results. An initiative that emphasizes culture should not influence the Cross-strait status quo. However to avoid any impending problems, carefully tailored and mutually drafted objectives and schemes are needed. The status of the region as a low-risk zone is an advantage (Interview with Director-General of the OECS-23/5/2015). Intra-diaspora relations and individual motivation are additional factors that are of importance to the success of this initiative
Limitations Limited literature on Caribbean diaspora engagement with the Asia- Pacific Time Constraints Further comparison required Need for further qualitative and quantitative research Through limitations there are opportunities!
References The Economist,. (2011). The Magic of diasporas. Retrieved March 3, 2015, from http://www.economist.com/node/21538742 Interview with Director-General of the OECS (23/5/2015) Pacific Island Youth Council, http://pacificyouthcouncil.com/