Making A Living In The Music Industry: Space & Place Seminar 3 rd March 20 Colin Mason; Mark Sheridan, Julie McFarlane
2 Overview. Introduction Another Side to the Story. Making a Living in the Music Industry: Working & Living in the City The Study: Research Aims, Objectives and Methods Age Instruments Genre Secondary Education Making a Living in the Music Industry: Working & Living in the City Current Place of Residence: The Good & The Bad Income and Employment Patterns Collaborations and Networks: Relationships Matter Barriers and Benefits Summary
3 Introduction. Talking up the creative economy Major sector of the economy Growing Job creation Wealth creation Graduate-rich Knowledge-based Innovation Regeneration potential Work Foundation The creative industries are a national asset an important source of jobs and wealth creation one of the more dynamic components of the knowledge economy Leading an economic shift to a new creative economy driven by innovations in technology, business and culture
But there is another side to the story. 4 The creative economy is built around new forms of organisation The project rather than the firm Independent free agents rather than employees Communities of practice Contingent labour dominates the creative economy Temporary jobs, part-time jobs, self-employment Multiple job holding, sporadic work Need for geographic mobility Me & Co Having to sell themselves in the market place Risk of self-exploitation Emphasis on non-monetary rewards: art for art s sake Individuals have to manage their careers Importance of collaboration Emphasis on inter-personal networks Reputation, trust, reciprocity are critical Place matters where you hang out Outcomes Greater freedom, greater flexibility, more choice and variety More insecure lives
5 Making A Living in The Music Industry: The Study...
6 The Study. Research Aim: Gather information about the employment pattern of BA Applied Music Graduates since completing the degree at Strathclyde in 997. Research Objective: Gain insights into the experiences and successes of graduate musicians and illustrate the priorities and future aspirations of these and other musicians. Research Method: A survey was created and distributed to a list of over 50 graduates of the BA Applied Music course in 997 and of those 04 respondents completed at least some of the survey (66 completed it). The main method of distribution was diverse and surveys were accessed via, email, post and social network sites as well as four face-to-face interviews being conducted.
At what age did you start taking music lessons?... 7 No of Participants Age 6 8 8 3 6 2 9 0 8 6 5 6 7 8 9 0 2 3 4 5 7 25 27
Which instruments do you play? (Tick all that apply) 8 2.80% 3.60% 7.20% 0.80% Bass Guitar Clarsach, Harp 9.60% 5.20% Computer Drumkit 4.40% Fiddle 8.80% 2.80% Flute, Oboe, Clarinet, Bassoon Guitar, electric, acoustic 6.80% Percussion Piano/keyboards 7.60% Pipes, Highland, Small Border 0.80% Saxophone: Soprano, Alto, Tenor Baritone 4.80% Trumpet, Horn, Trombone, Euphonium, Tuba Violin, Viola, Cello, Bass 0.80% 5.60% Voice 8.40% Whistles Other (Please specify)
9 Which genre(s) of music do you play? (Tick all that apply) Celtic Classical DJ Folk Funk Fusion Jazz Pop R & B Rock Traditional Other (Please specify)
0 Which is the Main Genre? Total No of Participants: 75 Traditional/Scottish Rock/Pop Pop and Jazz Klezmer Improvised Music Folk rock Experimental Classical Celtic/Classical Too Hard to Classify (?) 2 2 3 3 3 5 6 7 8 27 0 0 20 30
In which town/city did you undertake your secondary school education? 3 3 2 20 2 2 2 3 2 3 Aberdeen Ayr Cambridge Campbeltown Canning, Nova Scotia, Canada Clydebank, West Dunbartonshire Cumnock, East Ayrshire Dingwall dundee East Kilbride Edinburgh East Kilbride Glasgow Hamilton Kilbarchan, Renfrewshire Kilmarnock Lochwinnoch, Renfrewshire London Moodiesburn, Glasgow Newport, Fife Perceton, Irvine Perth Perth, Australia Port Glasgow Rothienorman, Aberdeenshire Stevenston sweden Tullibody Total No of Participants: 79
Making A Living in The Music Industry: Working & Living in the City. 2
3 Current City or Place of Residence?... 3 3 2 33 2 2 2 2 3 2 Aberdeen Ayr Cambridge Campbeltown Canning, Nova Scotia, Canada Clydebank, West Dunbartonshire Cumnock, East Ayrshire Dingwall Dundee Dingwall East Kilbride Edinburgh Glasgow Hamilton Inverness Kilbarchan, Renfrewshire Kilmarnock Lochwinnoch, Renfrewshire London Newport, Fife Perceton, Irvine Perth Perth, Australia Stevenston sweden Tullibody Total No of Participants: 69
4 If you are still living in Glasgow, in what ways is Glasgow a good/bad place to make a living from music? Good Teaching Opportunities Education and Training Opportunities Good Venues and Music Community Performing Arts Scene Classical Sector Bad No Money (Funding) Competition for Work (Saturated Market) No Airplay Costs Involved (Creating, Producing, Performance etc...) Non- Applicable Don t Live Here 64 Responses
5 Have you generated any income as a musician in the past 2 months? 2.68% Yes - 62 No - 9 87.32% Total No of Participants: 7
6 What form has this income taken? 23.8% 55.56% Self-employed - 5 Employed - 3 Both - 35 20.63% Total No of Participants: 63
What have been the sources of your music income in the past 2 months? (Tick all that apply) 7 3.69% 3.36% 3.69% 4.03% Teaching (Tutoring Privately, Teaching at Private or Local Authority Schools) - 82 Individual Performing (Public or Private Events) - 52 7.05% 27.5% Group Performing (Public or Private Events) - 66 Festival Work - 20 4.36% 6.7% 7.45% Composing - 3 Recording (Private Sales) - 2 Recording (Record Company Sales) - Production/Technical/Studio Work - 0 22.5% PRS/MCPS - Other (Please specify) - 2
8 Have you received income from work unrelated to music in the past 2 months? 44.29% Yes - 3 55.7% No - 39 Total No of Participants: 70
9 If yes please provide information on the type of job. 2.94% 20.58% Employee - 26 Self-employed - 7 Other - 76.47% Total No of Participants: 34
20 Has your total income in the past 2 months been sufficient to live on? 4.08% Yes - 6 No - 0 85.92% Total No of Participants: 7
2 If no how have you made ends meet? 2.43% 35.7% 0.00% Financial support from parents/family? Unemployment benefit (job seekers allowance? Shared expenses with live-in partner? Other (Please specify) 42.86% Total No of Participants: 4
22 Approximately what has been your income in the past 2 months? Question Responses As a musician As a music teacher Non music work Other music related work All Sources. Less than 5,000 38 52.63% 5.79% 7.89% 0.53% 3.6% 2. 5,000-9,999 22 45.45% 3.64% 3.64% 8.8% 9.09% 3. 0,000-4,999 2 25.00% 25.00% 4.67% 00.00% 8.33% 4. 5,000-9,999 3 30.77% 23.08% 7.89% 0.53% 3.6% 5. 20,000-24,999 2 00.00% 33.33% 33.33% 8.33% 25.00% 6. 25,000-29,999 9.% 66.67% 22.22% 00.00% 00.00% 7. 30,000 and above 24 8.33% 50.00% 6.67% 00.00% 25.00% Total Average 30
23 How do you obtain music related work (Tick all that apply)? Advertising.08% 8.30% Promotion packs 6.6% 2.53%.08% 4.69% Cold calling/emailing Responding to adverts 4.33%.9% 6.4%.55% Own web site Social networking sites (e.g. Facebook, Bebo, My Space, You Tube, etc)festivals Fellow ex-students Other musicians Strathclyde staff 4.69% 7.69% 0.% Other friends and relatives Agency Word of mouth Other (Please specify)
24 How do you obtain paid non-music work? (Tick all that apply) Employment agency 5.06% 6.33% 6.33% Advertising Promotion packs 20.25%.27% 2.53% Cold calling/emailing Responding to adverts Own web site 5.06% 5.9% Social networking sites (e.g. Facebook, Bebo, My Space, You Tube, etc)responding to adverts Fellow ex-students Other musicians.39% 5.06% Strathclyde staff Other friends and relatives 0.00% 7.59% 5.06% 8.86% Employment agencies Word of mouth Other (Please specify)
What are the key skills needed to make a living in the music industry? 25
26 What are the top three barriers to making a living in the Music Industry? Political Lack of Funding Lack of Support Lack of Training Economical /Environmental No Money (Funding) Economic Instability Competition for Work (Saturated Market) Costs Involved (Creating, Producing, Performance etc...) Social Technology Family Commitments Finances Personal Barriers (Age, Ability etc..) Competition Piracy No Financial Stability Total Responses: 54
27 Summary.
28 Questions???