IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF SOUTH AFRICA IN DIE HOOGSTE HOF VAN APPèL VAN SUID-AFRIKA FINAL ROLL November 2014 27 October 2014 The number of the Judge to whom in each case the judgment has been allocated is designated by dark shading
2 JUDGES - NOVEMBER 2014 1. Mpati P 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26.
3 Monday : 3 November 2014 09. National African Federated Chamber of Commerce and Industry & others v Veronica Pinky Nomaswazi Mkhize and others 805/2013 (GJ) 1 12 15 18 20 Mpati P 02. Société des Produits Nestlé S.A. & another v International Foodstuffs & others 100/2014 (GP) 2 11 17 19 22 01. Regent Insurance Company Ltd v King s Property Development (Pty) Ltd 005/2014 (GP) 4 13 14 21 25 Tuesday : 4 November 2014 07. Tyco International (Pty) Ltd & another v Golden Mile Trading 547 CC 949/2013 (WCC) 3 7 8 15 24 11. Passenger Rail Agency of South Africa v Irvine Van Sam Mashongwa
4 966/2013 (GP) 5 12 14 19 22 10. Basil A. Holford v Carleo Enterprises (Pty) Ltd & others 977/2013 (GP) 6 9 16 23 26 Wednesday : 5 November 2014 51. South African Sport Confederation and Olympic Committee v Laraine Lane 1016/2013 (GJ) 1 4 6 8 21 30. State v Joseph Arthur Walter Brown 681/2013 (WCC) Mpati P 2 3 5 11 19 19. M K NKomo v State 979/2013 (FB) 7 18 26 Thursday : 6 November 2014
39. Company Secretary of Arcelormittal & others v Vaal Environmental Justice Alliance 069/2014 5 2 12 16 23 24 29. The Commissioner of the South African Revenue Service v Mariana Bosch & another 485/2013 (WCC) 3 9 13 14 22 15. Alfred Levin & others v Paul Joseph Khourie 624/2013 (GJ) 7 8 18 20 25 Friday : 7 November 2014 13. Sithembile Valencia Mkhize In re: Zwelibhekile Sibusiso Mbuyazi v The Premier of the Province of Kwazulu-Natal 822/2013 (KZP) 1 6 17 20 21 Mpati P 12. Mogale City Municipality v Fidelity Security Services (Pty) Ltd and others 823/2013 (GJ) 2 13 16 18 19
14. PMG Motors Kyalami (Pty) Ltd (in liquidation) and another v Firstrand Bank Ltd, Wesbank Division 866/2013 (GJ) 4 5 15 23 26 6 Monday : 10 November 2014 05. Roodezant Ko-Operatiewe Wynmakery Bpk v Robertson Winery (Pty) Ltd & another 503/2013 (GP) 3 6 9 11 25 06. Spring Forest Trading 599 CC v Wilberry (Pty) Ltd t/a Ecowash & another 725/2013 (KZD) 4 7 8 17 24 16. MEC for Health: Gauteng Provincial Government v Lungile Ntsele o.b.o. Ayanda 675/2013 (GJ) 5 10 16 18 23 And 3. Cecilia Goliath v The Member of the Executive council for Health in the Province of the Eastern Cape 085/2014 (ECG) 5 10 16 18 23
7 Tuesday : 11 November 2014 08. Meadowglen Homeowners Association & others v City of Tshwane Metropolitan Municipality & another 767/2013 7 13 19 20 22 20. Denvor Paul Fielies v State 851/2013 (WCC) 27. Raphael Machongo v The State 20344/2014 (NWM) 8 12 15 9 23 26 Govern AJA Wednesday : 12 November 2014 04. Elizabeth Coetzee v Financial Planning Institute of South Africa & others 1079/2013 2 10 16 17 24 35. The Competition Commission v Computicket 853/2013 (CAC) 3 5 11 19 21
8 55. Bakgatla-Ba-Kgafela Tribal Authority & another v Bakgatla-Ba-Kgafela Communal Property Association 939/2013 (LCC) 4 12 13 14 22 Thursday : 13 November 2014 46. Charter Developments (Pty) Ltd v Waterkloof Marina Estates (Pty) Ltd & another 1025/2013 (GP) 2 11 13 18 22 38. Belet Industries CC t/a Belet Cellular v MTN Service Provider (Pty) Ltd 936/2013 (GJ) 4 7 8 16 25 17. Helen Nokubonga Jili v Firstrand Bank Limited t/a Wesbank and The National Credit Regulator (as Amicus Curiae) 763/2013 (KZD) 6 9 10 15 24 Friday : 14 November 2014 28. Ansafon (Pty) Ltd & another v master of the Northern Cape Division of the High Court, South Africa and others
9 513/2013 (NCK) 1 6 12 14 26 Mpati P 47. The Minister of Safety and Security N.O. and another v Leonard Charles Schubach 437/2013 (GP) 2 9 19 20 25 Rustenburg Local Municipality v Mwenzi Service Station CC Cross-appeal: Mwenzi Service Station CC v Rustenburg Local Municipality 20146/2014 3 5 10 16 23 Monday : 17 November 2014 31. World Hope Ministries & another v Die Volle Evangelie Kerk van God in Suidelike Afrika 758/2013 (WCC) 1 7 17 21 26 Mpati P 43. Minister of Education for the Western Cape & another v Beauvallon Secondary School & others 865/2013 (WCC) 3 6 10 15 23 Brand Ja
48. Sakhiwo Health Solutions (Limpopo) (Pty) Ltd v MEC of Health, Limpopo Provincial Government 908/2013 (GP) 4 8 13 20 22 10 Tuesday : 18 November 2014 34. MEC Local Government & Traditional Affairs v Joachim Hendrik Botha N.O. and others 887/2013 (KZP) 2 9 11 17 21 32. The Owners of the MV Silver Star v Hilane Limited 082/2014 (ECP) 33. X-Procure Software SA (Pty) Ltd v Sutherland TL 882/2013 (GJ) 5 13 14 19 26 6 10 15 16 24 Wednesday : 19 November 2014 49. Maghandheran Pillay v The Hollard Insurance Company Limited 749/2013 (GJ) 1 7 8 12 18 Mpati P
11 50. Bayer Pharma AG (formerly Byaer Schering Pharma AG) v Pharma Dynamics (Pty) Ltd 1066/2013 (PAT) 3 4 11 20 22 52. B Braun Medical (Pty) Ltd v Ambasaam CC 757/2013 (GP) 5 9 17 23 25 Mathopo JA Thursday : 20 November 2014 57. South African Local Authorities Pension Fund v Msunduzi Municipality 994/2013 (KZP) 6 8 13 16 25 53. Ruth Christine Visser v 1Life Direct Insurance Limited 1005/2013 (GJ) 7 15 17 21 23 Friday : 21 November 2014
37. Director of Public Prosecutions, Western Cape v Mohamed Shakiel Parker 103/2014 (WCC) 12 3 9 10 14 15 42. Laeveld Agrochem (Pty) Ltd v City of Tshwane 941/2013 (GP) 4 5 19 21 25 Monday : 24 November 2014 56. National Minister of Social Development & another v Marta Driver & others 1026/2013 (WCC) 1 7 10 20 25 45. State Bank of India & another v Denel Soc Ltd and others 947/2013 (GJ) Mpati P 3 8 11 18 21 44. Yair Shimansky & another v Browns the Diamond Store Proprietary Limited 009/2014 (WCC) 4 12 13 22 24
13 Tuesday : 25 November 2014 59. New Port Finance Company (Pty) Ltd & another v Nedbank 030/2014(WCC) 2 12 13 16 19 60. Marine 3 Technologies Holdings (Pty) Ltd v Afrigroup Investments (Pty) Ltd & another 0018/2014 (PAT) 5 17 23 24 26 21. Bradly Syster & another v State 126/2014 (WCC) 8 20 21 Schoeman JA Wednesday : 26 November 2014 40. Henry Emomotimi Okah v State 019/2014 (GJ) 22. Schalk Willem Du Plooy v State 940/2013 (GP) 2 5 14 22 26 Dambuza JA 3 15 25 And
14 25. Lukas Vusi Mahlamuza & another v State 20288/2014 (GP) 24. Hendrik Frederick Deloport & other v State 861/2013 (GP) 3 15 25 7 10 11 12 20 And 26. Thabang Sidwell Zono v State 20182/14 (LT) 7 10 11 Thursday : 27 November 2014 23. Thembani Bamba v State 20089/2014 (WCC) 9 17 24 18. State v Mudau Muvhulawa Erick & others 631/2013 (LT) 6 13 22 Friday : 28 November 2014 KLVC v SDI & The Office of the Family Advocate 20334/2014 (KZD) 6 10 11 18 20
15