North York Moors National Park Authority Planning Committee

North York Moors National Park Authority Planning Committee Item 5 15 January 2015 Miscellaneous Items (a) Appeals (i) Set out below is information on dates/venues of inquiries/hearings:- Appellants Name and Location NYM0003/2014 Mr Lee White Lockerice Hole, Swainby NYM0024/2009 Mr Robert David Page Spring House, Hobbin Head Lane, Sleights Method of Determination Date of Local Inquiry/Informal Hearing Venue Hearing TBA TBA Inquiry 14 April 2015 The Old Vicarage, Bondgate, Helmsley (b) Planning Applications Determined by the Director of Planning A list of planning applications determined by the Director of Planning in accordance with the Scheme of Delegation is attached at Appendix A. [NB: Members wishing to enquire further into particular applications referred to in the Appendix are asked to raise the matter with the Director of Planning in advance of the meeting to enable a detailed response to be given]. (c) List of Enforcement Matters Determined by the Director of Planning A list of enforcement matters determined by the Director of Planning in accordance with the Scheme of Delegation is attached at Appendix B. Andy Wilson Chief Executive (National Park Officer) Chris France Director of Planning

List of Planning Applications Determined by the Director of Planning for the Period from 24/11/2014 to 23/12/2014 in the Following Order and then by District: Delegated Planning Applications; Post Committee Applications; on Expiration of Advertisement; on Receipt of Amended Plans and Further Observations; Approval of Conditions; Applications Adjacent to the Park (3024); Notifications Under Schedule 2, Part 6/7, of The Town & Country Planning (General Permitted Development) Order 1995 Appendix A NYM/2014/0595/FL Approved 22/12/2014 installation of 16 no. solar photovoltaic panels (retrospective) at Forge Cottage/Blacksmiths, Carlton in Cleveland for Mr Robert Ward NYM/2014/0677/LB Granted 26/11/2014 Listed Building consent for internal alterations including wall and roof insulation works at Holly Tree Cottage, Over Silton for Mr & Mrs John & Joanne Aston NYM/2014/0703/FL Approved 03/12/2014 alterations to dwelling including raising of roof height together with construction of 3 no. dormer windows and balcony to front elevation and dormer windows to rear elevation (revised scheme to NYM/2014/0067/FL) at Fir-Brook, Great Ayton for Mr Shaun Grainger NYM/2014/0705/CU Approved 28/11/2014 change of use of part of dwelling to office (Use Class B1) (no external alterations and to remain part of main dwelling) at Old Stores, Coxwold for Mrs Jane Coope NYM/2014/0722/FL Approved 28/11/2014 erection of general purpose agricultural building at The Laurels, Kilburn Road, Coxwold for Mr Tim Glover NYM/2014/0732/FL Refused 22/12/2014 construction of 1 no. (eco) dwelling with associated access and landscaping works at land off Quarry Lane, Osmotherley for Mr Stephen Kelly NYM/2014/0733/FL Approved 22/12/2014 conversion of attached garage/store and subdivision of existing dwelling to form 1 no. unrestricted dwelling and 1 no. Estate workers dwelling/holiday letting cottage at Estate Cottage, Home Farm, Thimbleby for Mr Andrew Shelley NYM/2014/0734/FL Approved 05/12/2014 use of land for the temporary siting of a residential static caravan for two years at Hall Farm, Carlton in Cleveland for Mr David Marwood

NYM/2014/0735/LB Granted 19/12/2014 Listed Building consent for internal and external alterations at Estate Cottage, Home Farm, Thimbleby for Mr Andrew Shelley NYM/2014/0751/LB Granted 22/12/2014 Listed Building consent for internal and external alterations and construction of two storey rear extension following demolition of existing lean to at 78 North End, Osmotherley for Mr & Mrs John & Sarah Irwin NYM/2014/0785/NM Approved 22/12/2014 non material amendment to planning approval NYM/2013/0667/FL to allow the extension to be roofed in slate rather than zinc at Bramble Byre, 3 Black Horse Court, Black Horse Lane, Swainby for Mr Anthony Sutcliffe NYM/2014/0565/FL Approved 18/12/2014 replacement of front timber windows with upvc at The Rectory, High Street, Thornton Dale for Mr Russell Pickering NYM/2014/0614/FL Approved 28/11/2014 creation of vehicular access at Scugdale Cottage, Hartoft for Mr & Mrs Stevenson NYM/2014/0639/CU Approved 26/11/2014 change of use of land from agricultural to a mixed use to include use of land for events open to the general public at Park Plain, Duncombe Park, Helmsley for The Helmsley Estate NYM/2014/0672/LB Granted 05/12/2014 Listed Building consent for internal and external alterations and extension to outbuilding to form 1 no. dwelling at Bleach Mill Farm, Maltongate, Thornton le Dale for Mr & Mrs P Mills NYM/2014/0682/NM Approved 23/12/2014 non material amendment to planning approval NYM/2011/0762/FL to allow revised layout of rear external first floor escape stairs and roof arrangements at The Crown Hotel, 21 Market Place, Helmsley for The Crown Hotel (Buildings) Ltd NYM/2014/0691/FL Approved 25/11/2014 erection of a livestock agricultural building at Dicky Barn Buildings, Hawnby for Mr Peter Smith NYM/2014/0699/FL Approved 09/12/2014 variation of condition 2 (material amendment) to planning approval NYM/2014/0290/FL for the erection of plant room extension at The Horseshoe Inn, Levisham for Messrs C & T Wood NYM/2014/0708/FL Approved 22/12/2014 removal of section of boundary wall and gates together with rebuilding of pillar to create parking area at The Bungalow, South Lane, Thornton le Dale for Mr Alan Riby

NYM/2014/0718/FL Approved 10/12/2014 construction of replacement conservatory to rear together with re-roofing works at 3 High Street, Helmsley for Mr Howard Topham NYM/2014/0757/FL Approved with Conditions 22/12/2014 construction of general purpose agricultural building (shed B) at Holly Bower, Sproxton for D Russell Ltd NYM/2014/0812/NM Approved 22/12/2014 non material amendment to planning approval NYM/2013/0649/FL to allow alterations to window arrangements to house types B (plot 4), F2 (plot 12) and H (plot 1) at land to the north of Linkfoot Lane, Helmsley for Wharfedale Homes NYM/2014/0817/NM Approved 22/12/2014 non material amendment to planning approval NYM/2013/0480/FL to allow for alterations to approved windows and doors to west, north and east elevations, increase in ridge height to north elevation and omission of rooflights at Grange Farm, Levisham for The Ginger Pig Ltd NYM/2014/0531/FL Refused 22/12/2014 conversion of store to form holiday letting unit at Fisherman's Store, Beckside, Staithes for Mr Christopher Bateson NYM/2014/0561/FL Approved 16/12/2014 re-roofing of agricultural building and re-building of central section, creation of earth bund together with formation of hardstanding at land & Buildings at Church Lane, Fylingthorpe for Mr Nigel Sutterby NYM/2014/0618/FL Approved 10/12/2014 siting of shed for domestic and general agricultural storage together with creation of vehicular access track to shed (part retrospective) at Feathers Nest, Thorpe Lane, Robin Hoods Bay for Ms Gail Perry NYM/2014/0633/FL Approved 05/12/2014 alterations to main house and attached store to form additional living accommodation at Low Quebec, Moor Lane, Littlebeck for Mr & Mrs A & C Best NYM/2014/0663/FL Refused 26/11/2014 conversion and extension of shop/studio to form Tea Room, construction of garage incorporating holiday apartment above, extension to dwelling together with associated access and parking area at Nestling House, Littlebeck for Mr & Mrs Trevor Allen & Nicola Willis NYM/2014/0668/FL Approved 04/12/2014 conversion of barn to form 2 no. holiday cottages at barn at Swang Farm, Egton Bridge for Mr and Mrs M Welford NYM/2014/0670/FL Approved 24/11/2014 erection of conservatory to rear at 18 Seaton Close, Staithes for Mr & Mrs P Theaker

NYM/2014/0673/FL Approved 11/12/2014 alterations to include the repositioning of window on south east elevation and door to south west elevation, raising of apex roof to existing extension and installation of 1 no. rooflight at Seaview, Runswick Bay for Mr & Mrs P Blenkinsop NYM/2014/0675/LB Granted 02/12/2014 Listed Building consent for replacement slate roof tiles to front extension at St Hedda's RC Primary School, Egton Bridge for St Hedda's RC Primary NYM/2014/0680/FL Approved 11/12/2014 construction of single storey garden room extension, replacement rooflights, windows and doors together with formation of new window openings and installation of additional rooflights at The Green, Egton for Mr & Mrs E Mangles NYM/2014/0692/FL Approved 15/12/2014 erection of garden shed/log store at Kadelands House, Easton Lane, Ainthorpe for Mr David Ellwood NYM/2014/0696/FL Approved 15/12/2014 erection of timber clad plant room with flue to house biomass boiler on land south of Community Centre, Botton Village, Danby for Camphill Village Trust Ltd NYM/2014/0704/FL Approved 16/12/2014 variation of condition 1 of planning approval NYM/2012/0621/FL to allow the agricultural workers dwelling to be used as a short term holiday let or for local occupancy letting until October 2017 at Hollybush Farm, Littlebeck for Mr T R Lawn NYM/2014/0709/FL Approved 08/12/2014 erection of conservatory to form holiday park reception/office at Highgate Howe Holiday Home Park, Hawsker for Highgate Howe Holiday Home Park NYM/2014/0719/LB Refused 15/12/2014 Listed Building consent for removal of 2 no. internal walls at 23 Briar Hill, Danby for Mr Christopher Butters NYM/2014/0723/FL Approved 19/12/2014 alterations and construction of single storey side extension, conversion of attached barn to form additional living accommodation together with change of use of agricultural land to form extension to domestic curtilage at Brook Farm, Raw for Mr Chris Hadley NYM/2014/0727/LB Granted 19/12/2014 Listed Building consent for internal and external alterations, construction of single storey side extension and conversion of attached barn to form additional living accommodation at Brook Farm, Raw for Mr Chris Hadley NYM/2014/0728/FL Approved 22/12/2014 variation of condition 4 of planning approval NYM4/016/0107/PA to allow the annexe and extension to be used by members of family or let out as Bed & Breakfast accommodation at Foxholme, Main Street, Sawdon for Foxholme B & B

NYM/2014/0729/FL Approved 19/12/2014 conversion of existing barns and outbuilding to form 3 no. holiday cottages with associated amenity space together with formation of bin store, creation of new access and parking areas and widening of existing access at East Ridge Farm, Ridge Lane, Staithes for Mr & Mrs P & D Stubbs NYM/2014/0737/FL Approved 22/12/2014 installation of 2 no. replacement Yorkshire sash timber windows and timber door at 5 Castle Rise, West Ayton for Mrs Angela Dowkes NYM/2014/0741/FL Approved 23/12/2014 construction of replacement community hub/sports pavilion and creation of new access and car parking area together with change of use from agricultural land to recreational at Goathland Cricket Club, off Old Railway Line, Goathland for Mr Keith Thompson NYM/2014/0742/FL Approved 22/12/2014 installation of replacement windows to front elevation at 21 Church Street, Castleton for Mr & Mrs Paul Kevan NYM/2014/0743/NM Approved 28/11/2014 non material amendment to planning approval NYM/2014/0381/FL to allow the extension to have a rendered finish at 54 High Street, Castleton for Mr & Mrs David Chapman NYM/2014/0745/FL Approved 22/12/2014 variation of condition 2 (material amendment) to planning approval NYM/2006/0768/FL to allow omission of extension, alterations to windows, doors, rooflights and internal layout, reduction in ridge height of section of building and replacement of roof tiles with slate at 4 Main Road, Aislaby for Mr Frank Hall NYM/2014/0772/NM Approved 15/12/2014 non material amendment to planning approval NYM/2014/0499/FL to allow for raising of garage roof and door height by 800mm at Outends, Church Lane, Fylingthorpe for Mr T Barber NYM/2014/0604/FL Approved 25/11/2014 removal of condition 4 of planning approval NYM/2005/0624/FL to allow annexe to be a separate independent dwelling at Dam Farm, Scaling, Easington for Mr A Yeoman NYM/2014/0746/FL Approved 15/12/2014 variation of conditions 2 (material amendment) and 3 of planning approval NYM/2014/0238/FL to allow an increase in footprint and change to internal layout of the hobbit pods and extension of the holiday season from six months to 11 months at Golden Hill Farm, Liverton for North Shire

Notifications NYM/2014/0678/AGRP Approved 09/12/2014 construction of a new road and turning area for forestry purposes at Taylor Hill, Stape for Forestry Commission NYM/2014/0686/AGRP Refused 02/12/2014 erection of general purpose agricultural building at High Broomflatt Farm, Raisdale, Chop Gate for Mr Richard Turner NYM/2014/0725/AGRP Refused 15/12/2014 erection of general purpose agricultural building at land near Demesne Farm, Fylingthorpe for L E & G Hodgson NYM/2014/0747/AGRP Approved 22/12/2014 erection of agricultural storage building at Hobbrush Farm, Over Silton for Mr David Henry NYM/2014/0756/AGRP Approved 22/12/2014 erection of general purpose agricultural building (shed A) at Holly Bower, Sproxton for D Russell Ltd Applications Determined by the Director of Planning on Expiry of Advertisement, Receipt of Further Amended Plans and Observations NYM/2014/0736/FL construction of 1 no. local occupancy dwelling with associated garden area, access and parking at land between No s 21 and 23 Rosedale Lane, Port Mulgrave for Mr Dale Cush The application has been refused for the following reason: 1. The proposed development by virtue of its scale, design and form has a detrimental impact on the character of the street scene and will detract from the landscape character of this part of the North York Moors National Park. As such the proposed development is considered to fail to accord with the requirements of Development Policy 3 which seeks to maintain and enhance the distinctive character of the National Park. NYM/2014/0749/FL alterations and construction of two storey rear extension following demolition of existing lean-to at 78 North End, Osmotherley for Mr & Mrs John & Sarah Irwin The application has been approved with the following informatives added: 1. MISCINF03 The applicant is advised that this permission cannot be implemented until the associated Listed Building consent NYM/2014/0751/LB has been approved by the Local Planning Authority. 2. MISCINF01 All bats and their roosts are fully protected under the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981 (as amended by the Countryside and Rights of Way Act 2000) and are further protected under Regulation 39(1) of the Conservation (Natural Habitats etc) Regulations 1994. Should any bats or evidence of bats be found prior to or during development, work must stop immediately and Natural England contacted on 0300 060 3900 for further advice. This is a legal requirement under the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981 (as amended) and applies to whoever carries out the work. All contractors on site should be made aware of this requirement and given information to contact Natural England or the Bat Conservation Trust national helpline on 0845 1300 228.

Applications Adjacent to the National Park (3024) None Background Documents to this report File Ref: 1. Signed reports- dates as given 2. Signed letter - dates as given 3022/1 3024/1 Location North York Moors National Park Authority

Appendix B LIST OF ENFORCEMENT MATTERS DETERMINED BY THE DIRECTOR OF PLANNING FOR THE PERIOD 22 November 2014 5 January 2015 File No. Development & Address Decision Taken Enf. Enq. 10147 Enf. Enq. 10763 Enf. Enq. 8753 Hollins Cottage, Hutton le Hole Creation of Steps within Highway Verge/Common Land Chester Farm, Lockton Erection of kennel building and dog breeding land to rear 52 Staithes Lane, Staithes Erection of Rear Wall and siting of Oil Tank NYM/2012/0664/AG Meeks Farm, Carlton in Cleveland Variation to approved plans for agricultural building differing door/window positions Enf. Enq. 10175 Peat House, Egton Bridge Replacement stone and pantile outbuilding larger footprint