Presenters. Researcher, Institute for Urban Strategies, The Mori Memorial Foundation

Similar documents
Rethinking Global City Competitiveness. Jeremy Kelly, Global Research, JLL 7 th June 2018

Contents Introduction...3 Main Headlines...4 The Overall Rankings...7 Most Significant Centres Areas of Competitiveness

Travelling to Liverpool

Exploring Digital Geographies Cityscape Global. Jeremy Kelly, Head of Global Research Craig Plumb, Head of Research, MENA

Thank you and acknowledgements. Community of Metros. CoMET

25 th March 2013 Hyatt Hotel Reinforcing Montreal s competitiveness as a financial centre. GFCI 13 Published This Morning!

What this meant to British travellers

WHY INVEST IN 25HOURS. AccorHotels Global Development August 2018

Cargo Market & Turkish Cargo. Network & Fleet. Products Development and Future Plans

Guangzhou, Seoul and Sydney in top 10 of PIRI 100. Australasia remains top performing region for third consecutive year

4 th Dimension Focus. Global Hotel Trends Q3 2017

Prime Property Prices in Vancouver Rise by 25%

MasterCard. Global Destination Cities Index

Cathay Pacific Vantage Pass 2019

Global Research I Q The JLL Global Premium Office Rent Tracker

Mobility in Cities Database

TURKISH CARGO NETWORK: YOUR KEY HUB TO GLOBAL SUPPLY CHAIN November 2017

2011 Global Supply Benchmarking Research and Analysis

Front cover picture: European Parliament, Brussels

ACI 2008 WORLDWIDE AIRPORT TRAFFIC STATISTICS

Europe s New Financial Centre(s)

Finding Rationality in an Irrational World: The Economics of Successful Hotel Negotiations

10 Facts about Emerging-market Cities 46%

Airline Marketing Brussels Airport Léon Verhallen, Head of Airline Business Development

Cargo Market & Turkish Cargo. Network & Fleet. Fleet. Africa Routes. America Routes. Asia Pacific Routes. Central & Southern Europe Routes

Bengaluru, Delhi and Mumbai CBDs top prime office yields earners in the world: Knight Frank Global Cities - The 2018 Report

GCSE 4762/01 LEISURE AND TOURISM UNIT 2: Leisure and Tourism Destinations

2016 HALF YEAR RESULTS. Mandarin Oriental Hotel Group

A UNIQUE, GLOBAL, DIGITAL BRAND FOCUSING ON SMART SPACES THAT DELIVER OUTSTANDING VALUE RELAX, WORK AND PLAY...

Zones metropolitaines: sources de croissance. Montreal, 7 Mai 2009

Business Climate in Sapporo. Economic & Tourism Affairs Bureau, City of Sapporo

ISSUE 1, 2017 Global Travel Insights

Exploring City Pathways

Analyst Presentation. 9 th June 2006

2016 ANNUAL RESULTS. Mandarin Oriental Hotel Group

Mark Yeandle MBA FCIM

The Global Financial Centres Index 24

Version number Effective date Person in charge Changes

Global Financial Centres Index

ANDREW WATTERSON Vice President Planning and Revenue Management

Mitchel Allen, VP, Business Development March 16, 2017

Fukuoka Growth. 06 Quality of Life. (Version 1.0) Growth Potential of Fukuoka City

Think Asia, Think Hong Kong. Winchell Cheung Director, Midwest

5 REASONS WHY OUR CORPORATE TRAVEL PROGRAMME IS PERFECT FOR YOU

The European Hotel Market

PRIDE OF OWNERSHIP.

Defining & Understanding M.I.C.E. Meetings

ICCA & the International Association Meetings ICCA-JNTO-JTA Bid Workshop 2013

LEISURE AND TOURISM. Unit 2: Leisure and Tourism Destinations. Section A. Section B

Agenda. Introducing the Speaker. Welcome. Speaker. Sandra Chipchase THE EIGHTH RA LAYTON LECTURE WITH SANDRA CHIPCHASE DR NINA MISTILIS

Massport. Airline Route Development at Boston Logan

global duty free & travel retail sales 2011

PART 1: EXISTING AND EVOLVING GLOBAL FARE COLLECTION INDUSTRY Introduction Transit ticketing industry 6

Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Philippe A. Bonnefoy. Massachusetts Institute of Technology Planning & Design of Airport Systems

European city tourism Study Analysis and findings

Transport Performance and the Data Clubs Approach. Richard Anderson ESRC International Public Service Rankings 13 th December 2005

TFO Canada Seminar. Exchanging Experience: Lessons Learned in Promoting Trade to Canada. Ms Zalela Jaafar MATRADE Toronto July 17, 2010

Market trends and outlook

2017 ANNUAL RESULTS. Mandarin Oriental Hotel Group

ANNUAL BUSINESS TRAVEL INDEX MARCH 2018

2012 Global Corporate Travel Forecast and Hotel Negotiability Index

National MICE Development A Global Perspective

Sydney: a story for the world?

Airport Characteristics: Part 2 Prof. Amedeo Odoni

An Economic Snapshot of Honduras

Sustainable Transport Toolbox

Facts and figures about Munich Airport

Front cover picture: London, United Kingdom

Past Events

Global Canberra? Conference on Centenary Canberra Past, Present and Future August, 2013, University of Canberra

Submission: Darling Harbour South

Airport Lounges. Relax and get fresh before your onward flight found under Sightseeing. Middle East, Africa LOUNGE

International Visitors to New England. DNE Summit 2016 Newport, RI

Passenger Flows Zurich Airport. July to November 2011

UNPACKING BLEISURE TRAVELER TRENDS

MasterCard 2015 Global Destination Cities Index

Athens International Airport. The 2007 market performance

WORLD REPORT ON METRO AUTOMATION

Fastest rental growth in four years. Global Office Index Q2 2016

Growing Size and Complexity Prof. Amedeo Odoni

12.3million. passengers and 851,000 tonnes of cargo carried by Cathay Pacific in 2002.

EUROPEAN CITIES MONITOR

The Need and Urgency for a Three-Runway System (3RS) August 7, 2014

turnaround tables Arriving and Departing OTP Variances for the World s Largest Airports Based on full year data 2017

Changing role of place in international student support

Unit Standard Level: 2 Credit: 4 Version: 2

EUROPEAN CITIES MONITOR

The Financial Agenda: Investment Climate in South America

Europe 2020 Project Bond Initiative Deal structure credit support and decision making

Agenda. Binswanger. Food Industry Trends. Food Industry Changes. Suggestions for the Economic Development Community. Conclusion

Forecasting Forum 2017: what will happen to travel pricing in the year ahead?

SUMMER & FALL 2018 SCHEDULE SUMMER 2018 FALL 2018 SPRING 2019

Invitation to Tokyo, Japan

The Odds Look Good for Integrated Resorts in Japan

Global Airline Capacity Winter 2013/14 Boeing Commercial Airplanes

Key Stats. Of 11 peer cities assessed, Calgary has the second highest level of economic power comparing GDP per capita

YOUR SPACE AWAITS th Street SW Calgary, AB

Hong Kong: Helping Manage Opportunities and Challenges in China. Christopher Jackson Assistant Executive Director 3 March 2009

CORPORATE STEVE BOOKING SMITH CHANNELS

Prices and earnings 2015

Transcription:

Presenters Chiharu Hirota (Moderator) Researcher, Institute for Urban Strategies, The Mori Memorial Foundation Hiroo Ichikawa Dean, Professional Graduate School of Governance Studies, Meiji University Executive Director, the Mori Memorial Foundation Hiroo Mori Senior Managing Director, Mori Building Co., Ltd

Global Power City Index Rating the Global 40 Cities since 2008 Hiroo Ichikawa

Organization Committee Supervision of Creating Rankings Member Saskia Sassen Professor, Columbia University Chairman Heizo Takenaka Professor, Keio University The Director of the Global Security Research Institute Chairman, Institute for Urban Strategies, The Mori Memorial Foundation Member Hiroo Ichikawa Professor and Dean, Graduate School of Governance Studies, Meiji University Director of the Mori Memorial Foundation Principal Advisor Sir Peter Hall Professor, Bartlett School of Planning, University College London Member Richard Bender Professor and Dean Emeritus, University of California, Berkeley Expertise Partners Advise in Qualitative Survey Intellectuals and Professionals with International Experiences as Global Actors Peer Reviewer Review and Comment on the Ranking Allen J. Scott Distinguished Professor, University of California, Los Angeles Peter Nijkamp Professor, VU University Amsterdam Fellow, Tinbergen Institute Working Group -Fundamental Research of Cities -Analysis of Data -Creation of Draft Rankings Principal Hiroo Ichikawa Staff Institute for Urban Strategies, The Mori Memorial Foundation Mitsubishi Research Institute, Inc.

Global Power City Index 2012 Hiroo Ichikawa

Selected 40 Cities 17Cities in Europe/Africa 13 Cities in Asia 10 Cities in America 5 Cities added from GPCI-2011

Criteria for Selection 1 Cities found in the top ten of existing, influential city rankings ( The Global Financial Centres Index, Worldwide Centers of Commerce Index and Cities of Opportunity ) 2 Major cities of countries which are in the top ten in terms of competition according to influential international competiveness rankings (created by ( World Economic Forum, and IMD ) 3 Cities which do not meet the above criteria but which are deemed appropriate for inclusion by the GPCI committee or its working members.

Ranking Creation Method - Creation Flow for Function-based Ranking

5 Ranking Actors Creation in this study Method - Flow of Creation for Actor-specific Ranking Manager Researcher Artist Tourist Resident Important Factors Demanded by Each Actor Economy 13 2 2-5 Function Research & Development Cultural Interaction Livability 2 7 - - 2 7 7 7 12 7 12 9 8 6 12 Environment 6 5 5-8 Accessibility 9 4 2 8 5 49 indicators 34 indicators 24 indicators 26 indicators 39 indicators Manager Score Researcher Score Artist Score Visitor Score Resident Score

MANAGER Demands to the City 1. Accumulation of enterprises & business deals 2. Potential of business growth 3. Ease of business (including regulations) 4. Business surroundings 5. Pool of human resources 6. Accumulation of business support industry 7. Favorable environment for business and for employees' families 8. Politics, economy, and disaster risk

RESEARCHER Demands to the City 1. Qualities of research institutions, researchers and directors 2. Accumulation of research institutes & researchers 3. Existence of opportunities that stimulate researchers in conducting academic activities 4. Readiness to accept researchers 5. Opportunities after graduation (job finding, etc.) 6. Living environment

ARTIST Demands to the City 1. Cultural stimulus 2. Pool of artists 3. Art markets 4. Environment for creative activities 5. Living environment

VISITOR 1. Atmosphere of cities Demands to the City 2. Public safety 3. Destinations for tourists 4. Accommodations 5. Restaurants 6. Shopping 7. Mobility

RESIDENT 1. Economic environment Demands to the City 2. Living environment 3. Work environment 4. Educational environment 5. Leisure activities 6. Safety and security 7. Medical environment

Total score and rank by Functions

0.0 200.0 400.0 600.0 800.0 1,000.0 1,200.0 1,400.0 1,600.0 1,800.0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 London(1452.5)[2 (320.6)] New York(1376.6)[1 (320.9)] Paris(1349.6)[3 (308.7)] TOKYO(1324.9)[4 (304.3)] Singapore(1118.6)[5 (255.3)] Seoul(1081.1)[7 (233.4)] Amsterdam(1068.3)[9 (226.6)] Berlin(1047.3)[6 (234.8)] Hong Kong(1027.2)[8 (231.1)] Vienna(1016.7)[12 (215.3)] Beijing(978.3)[18 (204.2)] Frankfurt(966.7)[10 (225.1)] Barcelona(964.6) Shanghai(964.5)[23 (199.3)] Sydney(962.8)[11 (215.8)] Stockholm(961.2) Osaka(942.1)[15 (205.8)] Zurich(937.9)[14 (211.4)] Brussels(931.3)[24 (199.2)] Copenhagen(929.7)[19 (203.2)] Toronto(925.6)[25 (194.6)] Madrid(908.6)[20 (202.8)] Los Angeles(890.7)[13 (212.2)] Vancouver(890.1)[22 (201.3)] Istanbul(875.4) Geneva(867.8)[17 (205.2)] Boston(858.4)[16 (205.7)] Chicago(854.1)[26 (189.4)] Milan(850.5)[27 (183.6)] 経済 Washington D.C.(836.5) 研究 開発 San Francisco(833.3)[21 (201.5)] Taipei(807.9)[29 (175.2)] 文化 交流 Fukuoka(790.3)[28 (177)] 居住 Kuala Lumpur(788.1)[31 (167.2)] 環境 Bangkok(781.4)[30 (171.8)] 交通 アクセス Mexico City(781) Moscow(760.2)[33 (160.8)] Sao Paulo(667.7)[32 (161.5)] Mumbai(608.1)[34 (142.4)] Cairo(601)[35 (139.1)]

Ranking Changes from GPCI-2008 to GPCI-2012

Function-specific Ranking Top 4 Cities Rank Total Score Economy R&D Cultural Interaction Livability Environment Accessibility 1 London 1452.5 Tokyo 338.9 New York 217.3 London 353.5 Paris 298.7 Tokyo 208.4 Paris 251.3 2 New York 1376.6 New York 327.5 Tokyo 162.1 Paris 264.4 Osaka 294.5 Stockholm 205.2 London 250.6 3 Paris 1349.6 Beijing 297.0 Paris 133.8 New York 263.7 Fukuoka 292.4 Geneva 203.2 Amsterdam 216.5 4 Tokyo 1324.9 London 282.0 London 130.8 Berlin 169.7 Vancouver 291.5 Zurich 202.7 Seoul 206.3 5 Singapore 1118.6 Hong Kong 262.9 Boston 117.8 Singapore 167.4 Vienna 289.5 Sao Paulo 199.8 Hong Kong 205.2 6 Seoul 1081.1 Singapore 259.4 Los Angeles 116.4 Barcelona 159.5 Amsterdam 280.0 Madrid 196.1 Frankfurt 204.3 7 Amsterdam 1068.3 Shanghai 253.6 Seoul 109.1 Tokyo 157.0 Stockholm 277.5 Vienna 195.9 New York 197.5 8 Berlin 1047.3 Zurich 236.4 Singapore 108.6 Los Angeles 150.4 Barcelona 277.3 Berlin 193.7 Tokyo 187.5 9 Hong Kong 1027.2 Paris 234.1 Chicago 96.6 Beijing 150.2 Berlin 275.8 Copenhagen 191.7 Singapore 182.8 10 Vienna 1016.7 Washington, D.C. 231.8 San Francisco 80.4 Vienna 150.1 Taipei 275.7 Frankfurt 191.0 Istanbul 182.0 11 Beijing 978.3 Geneva 229.6 Hong Kong 77.7 Istanbul 149.0 Tokyo 271.0 Barcelona 190.4 Shanghai 162.4 12 Frankfurt 966.7 Sydney 226.4 Osaka 71.2 Brussels 145.3 Copenhagen 270.4 London 182.2 Brussels 161.8 13 Barcelona 964.6 Seoul 222.6 Shanghai 70.3 Sydney 145.3 Milan 270.2 Seoul 179.5 Milan 157.2 14 Shanghai 964.5 Copenhagen 214.7 Washington, D.C. 70.1 Milan 128.6 Geneva 267.0 Sydney 174.9 Moscow 154.8 15 Sydney 962.8 Toronto 212.6 Beijing 66.6 Seoul 126.6 Brussels 265.5 Singapore 174.0 Barcelona 152.4 16 Stockholm 961.2 Amsterdam 211.4 Berlin 64.9 Madrid 126.3 Zurich 264.1 Amsterdam 173.6 Madrid 149.3 17 Osaka 942.1 Stockholm 209.3 Amsterdam 61.8 Hong Kong 125.2 Toronto 263.9 Osaka 168.4 Toronto 146.9 18 Zurich 937.9 Frankfurt 207.4 Zurich 59.9 Amsterdam 124.9 Kuala Lumpur 262.2 Paris 167.3 Bangkok 146.8 19 Brussels 931.3 Berlin 205.9 Sydney 57.7 Moscow 119.8 Frankfurt 262.0 Washington, D.C. 161.9 Copenhagen 141.2 20 Copenhagen 929.7 Vancouver 196.2 Toronto 54.3 Chicago 114.7 London 253.4 Los Angeles 160.2 Osaka 140.7 21 Toronto 925.6 Vienna 194.6 Stockholm 51.9 Bangkok 113.7 Madrid 253.0 Vancouver 157.1 Vienna 139.1 22 Madrid 908.6 Osaka 191.1 Vancouver 51.5 Shanghai 109.7 Shanghai 245.4 New York 155.6 Boston 138.3 23 Los Angeles 890.7 San Francisco 189.1 Taipei 50.5 Mexico City 105.9 Mexico City 239.3 Brussels 155.4 Kuala Lumpur 138.2 24 Vancouver 890.1 Taipei 189.1 Barcelona 49.8 Toronto 97.6 Seoul 237.0 Fukuoka 153.5 Berlin 137.4 25 Istanbul 875.4 Boston 182.8 Vienna 47.4 Stockholm 93.5 Sydney 226.7 San Francisco 152.7 Taipei 135.4 26 Geneva 867.8 Chicago 178.5 Moscow 46.7 San Francisco 92.5 Singapore 226.4 Toronto 150.4 Chicago 133.8 27 Boston 858.4 Los Angeles 175.6 Geneva 45.6 Washington, D.C. 79.9 Beijing 226.3 Milan 148.6 Sydney 131.8 28 Chicago 854.1 Moscow 172.7 Fukuoka 44.6 Osaka 76.2 Mumbai 222.7 Boston 143.5 Beijing 130.3 29 Milan 850.5 Brussels 167.4 Madrid 43.8 Vancouver 74.3 Istanbul 221.9 Mexico City 142.0 Zurich 127.0 30 Washington, D.C. 836.5 Istanbul 162.3 Copenhagen 39.9 Copenhagen 71.8 Hong Kong 218.3 Hong Kong 137.9 Stockholm 123.7 31 San Francisco 833.3 Kuala Lumpur 159.3 Istanbul 39.8 Kuala Lumpur 71.3 Bangkok 215.9 Bangkok 135.6 Mexico City 119.9 32 Taipei 807.9 Mexico City 154.2 Brussels 35.8 Boston 70.4 New York 215.0 Mumbai 134.4 Vancouver 119.5 33 Fukuoka 790.3 Fukuoka 153.4 Bangkok 35.6 Frankfurt 67.3 Cairo 211.7 Kuala Lumpur 133.6 Fukuoka 113.0 34 Kuala Lumpur 788.1 Sao Paulo 146.9 Frankfurt 34.7 Cairo 55.8 San Francisco 208.0 Chicago 125.1 San Francisco 110.6 35 Bangkok 781.4 Madrid 140.1 Milan 29.3 Zurich 47.8 Boston 205.7 Shanghai 123.0 Cairo 106.8 36 Mexico City 781.0 Barcelona 135.3 Kuala Lumpur 23.5 Sao Paulo 43.9 Chicago 205.4 Istanbul 120.4 Washington, D.C. 104.2 37 Moscow 760.2 Bangkok 133.7 Mexico City 19.7 Mumbai 41.6 Sao Paulo 196.8 Taipei 115.7 Los Angeles 103.5 38 Sao Paulo 667.7 Mumbai 126.5 Sao Paulo 8.4 Taipei 41.4 Moscow 195.3 Cairo 109.9 Geneva 91.4 39 Mumbai 608.1 Milan 116.6 Mumbai 4.1 Fukuoka 33.4 Washington, D.C. 188.7 Beijing 107.9 Mumbai 78.8 40 Cairo 601.0 Cairo 113.6 Cairo 3.3 Geneva 31.0 Los Angeles 184.7 Moscow 70.8 Sao Paulo 72.0

Indicator Group Deviation Top 4 Cities

Tokyo s Strengths 25 指標 15 指標 13 指標 12 指標 2 指標 1 指標 1 指標 London 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 20 未満 20~30 30~40 40~50 50~60 60~70 70~80 80~90 90 以上経済研究 開発文化 交流居住環境 London 30 25 指標 25 20 15 指標 15 13 指標 12 指標 10 5 2 指標 1 指標 1 指標 0 20 未満 20~30 30~40 40~50 50~60 60~70 70~80 80~90 90 以上経済研究 開発文化 交流居住環境 Number of Indicators by Deviation Score 30 London 28 30 New York 25 20 15 10 5 0 0 0 2 14 Under 20 20~30 30~40 40~50 50~60 60~70 70~80 80~90 Over 90 13 13 indicators over 70 8 2 3 25 20 15 10 5 0 1 0 1 22 19 11 15 indicators over 70 6 6 Under 20 20~30 30~40 40~50 50~60 60~70 70~80 80~90 Over 90 3 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 Paris 0 0 1 20 22 10 17 indicators over 70 15 1 1 Under 20 20~30 30~40 40~50 50~60 60~70 70~80 80~90 Over 90 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 Tokyo 0 0 3 16 30 Under 20 20~30 30~40 40~50 50~60 60~70 70~80 80~90 Over 90 10 11 indicators over 70 4 6 1

Function-specific Ranking North American Cities Rank Total Score Economy R&D Cultural Interaction Livability Environment Accessibility 1 London 1452.5 Tokyo 338.9 New York 217.3 London 353.5 Paris 298.7 Tokyo 208.4 Paris 251.3 2 New York 1376.6 New York 327.5 Tokyo 162.1 Paris 264.4 Osaka 294.5 Stockholm 205.2 London 250.6 3 Paris 1349.6 Beijing 297.0 Paris 133.8 New York 263.7 Fukuoka 292.4 Geneva 203.2 Amsterdam 216.5 4 Tokyo 1324.9 London 282.0 London 130.8 Berlin 169.7 Vancouver 291.5 Zurich 202.7 Seoul 206.3 5 Singapore 1118.6 Hong Kong 262.9 Boston 117.8 Singapore 167.4 Vienna 289.5 Sao Paulo 199.8 Hong Kong 205.2 6 Seoul 1081.1 Singapore 259.4 Los Angeles 116.4 Barcelona 159.5 Amsterdam 280.0 Madrid 196.1 Frankfurt 204.3 7 Amsterdam 1068.3 Shanghai 253.6 Seoul 109.1 Tokyo 157.0 Stockholm 277.5 Vienna 195.9 New York 197.5 8 Berlin 1047.3 Zurich 236.4 Singapore 108.6 Los Angeles 150.4 Barcelona 277.3 Berlin 193.7 Tokyo 187.5 9 Hong Kong 1027.2 Paris 234.1 Chicago 96.6 Beijing 150.2 Berlin 275.8 Copenhagen 191.7 Singapore 182.8 10 Vienna 1016.7 Washington, D.C. 231.8 San Francisco 80.4 Vienna 150.1 Taipei 275.7 Frankfurt 191.0 Istanbul 182.0 11 Beijing 978.3 Geneva 229.6 Hong Kong 77.7 Istanbul 149.0 Tokyo 271.0 Barcelona 190.4 Shanghai 162.4 12 Frankfurt 966.7 Sydney 226.4 Osaka 71.2 Brussels 145.3 Copenhagen 270.4 London 182.2 Brussels 161.8 13 Barcelona 964.6 Seoul 222.6 Shanghai 70.3 Sydney 145.3 Milan 270.2 Seoul 179.5 Milan 157.2 14 Shanghai 964.5 Copenhagen 214.7 Washington, D.C. 70.1 Milan 128.6 Geneva 267.0 Sydney 174.9 Moscow 154.8 15 Sydney 962.8 Toronto 212.6 Beijing 66.6 Seoul 126.6 Brussels 265.5 Singapore 174.0 Barcelona 152.4 16 Stockholm 961.2 Amsterdam 211.4 Berlin 64.9 Madrid 126.3 Zurich 264.1 Amsterdam 173.6 Madrid 149.3 17 Osaka 942.1 Stockholm 209.3 Amsterdam 61.8 Hong Kong 125.2 Toronto 263.9 Osaka 168.4 Toronto 146.9 18 Zurich 937.9 Frankfurt 207.4 Zurich 59.9 Amsterdam 124.9 Kuala Lumpur 262.2 Paris 167.3 Bangkok 146.8 19 Brussels 931.3 Berlin 205.9 Sydney 57.7 Moscow 119.8 Frankfurt 262.0 Washington, D.C. 161.9 Copenhagen 141.2 20 Copenhagen 929.7 Vancouver 196.2 Toronto 54.3 Chicago 114.7 London 253.4 Los Angeles 160.2 Osaka 140.7 21 Toronto 925.6 Vienna 194.6 Stockholm 51.9 Bangkok 113.7 Madrid 253.0 Vancouver 157.1 Vienna 139.1 22 Madrid 908.6 Osaka 191.1 Vancouver 51.5 Shanghai 109.7 Shanghai 245.4 New York 155.6 Boston 138.3 23 Los Angeles 890.7 San Francisco 189.1 Taipei 50.5 Mexico City 105.9 Mexico City 239.3 Brussels 155.4 Kuala Lumpur 138.2 24 Vancouver 890.1 Taipei 189.1 Barcelona 49.8 Toronto 97.6 Seoul 237.0 Fukuoka 153.5 Berlin 137.4 25 Istanbul 875.4 Boston 182.8 Vienna 47.4 Stockholm 93.5 Sydney 226.7 San Francisco 152.7 Taipei 135.4 26 Geneva 867.8 Chicago 178.5 Moscow 46.7 San Francisco 92.5 Singapore 226.4 Toronto 150.4 Chicago 133.8 27 Boston 858.4 Los Angeles 175.6 Geneva 45.6 Washington, D.C. 79.9 Beijing 226.3 Milan 148.6 Sydney 131.8 28 Chicago 854.1 Moscow 172.7 Fukuoka 44.6 Osaka 76.2 Mumbai 222.7 Boston 143.5 Beijing 130.3 29 Milan 850.5 Brussels 167.4 Madrid 43.8 Vancouver 74.3 Istanbul 221.9 Mexico City 142.0 Zurich 127.0 30 Washington, D.C. 836.5 Istanbul 162.3 Copenhagen 39.9 Copenhagen 71.8 Hong Kong 218.3 Hong Kong 137.9 Stockholm 123.7 31 San Francisco 833.3 Kuala Lumpur 159.3 Istanbul 39.8 Kuala Lumpur 71.3 Bangkok 215.9 Bangkok 135.6 Mexico City 119.9 32 Taipei 807.9 Mexico City 154.2 Brussels 35.8 Boston 70.4 New York 215.0 Mumbai 134.4 Vancouver 119.5 33 Fukuoka 790.3 Fukuoka 153.4 Bangkok 35.6 Frankfurt 67.3 Cairo 211.7 Kuala Lumpur 133.6 Fukuoka 113.0 34 Kuala Lumpur 788.1 Sao Paulo 146.9 Frankfurt 34.7 Cairo 55.8 San Francisco 208.0 Chicago 125.1 San Francisco 110.6 35 Bangkok 781.4 Madrid 140.1 Milan 29.3 Zurich 47.8 Boston 205.7 Shanghai 123.0 Cairo 106.8 36 Mexico City 781.0 Barcelona 135.3 Kuala Lumpur 23.5 Sao Paulo 43.9 Chicago 205.4 Istanbul 120.4 Washington, D.C. 104.2 37 Moscow 760.2 Bangkok 133.7 Mexico City 19.7 Mumbai 41.6 Sao Paulo 196.8 Taipei 115.7 Los Angeles 103.5 38 Sao Paulo 667.7 Mumbai 126.5 Sao Paulo 8.4 Taipei 41.4 Moscow 195.3 Cairo 109.9 Geneva 91.4 39 Mumbai 608.1 Milan 116.6 Mumbai 4.1 Fukuoka 33.4 Washington, D.C. 188.7 Beijing 107.9 Mumbai 78.8 40 Cairo 601.0 Cairo 113.6 Cairo 3.3 Geneva 31.0 Los Angeles 184.7 Moscow 70.8 Sao Paulo 72.0

Function-specific Ranking Asian Cities ランク 総合スコア経済研究 開発文化 交流居住 1 London 1452.5 Tokyo 338.9 New York 217.3 London 353.5 Paris 298.7 Tokyo 208.4 Paris 251.3 2 New York 1376.6 New York 327.5 Tokyo 162.1 Paris 264.4 Osaka 294.5 Stockholm 205.2 London 250.6 3 Paris 1349.6 Beijing 297.0 Paris 133.8 New York 263.7 Fukuoka 292.4 Geneva 203.2 Amsterdam 216.5 4 Tokyo 1324.9 London 282.0 London 130.8 Berlin 169.7 Vancouver 291.5 Zurich 202.7 Seoul 206.3 5 Singapore 1118.6 Hong Kong 262.9 Boston 117.8 Singapore 167.4 Vienna 289.5 Sao Paulo 199.8 Hong Kong 205.2 6 Seoul 1081.1 Singapore 259.4 Los Angeles 116.4 Barcelona 159.5 Amsterdam 280.0 Madrid 196.1 Frankfurt 204.3 7 Amsterdam 1068.3 Shanghai 253.6 Seoul 109.1 Tokyo 157.0 Stockholm 277.5 Vienna 195.9 New York 197.5 8 Berlin 1047.3 Zurich 236.4 Singapore 108.6 Los Angeles 150.4 Barcelona 277.3 Berlin 193.7 Tokyo 187.5 9 Hong Kong 1027.2 Paris 234.1 Chicago 96.6 Beijing 150.2 Berlin 275.8 Copenhagen 191.7 Singapore 182.8 10 Vienna 1016.7 Washington, D.C. 231.8 San Francisco 80.4 Vienna 150.1 Taipei 275.7 Frankfurt 191.0 Istanbul 182.0 11 Beijing 978.3 Geneva 229.6 Hong Kong 77.7 Istanbul 149.0 Tokyo 271.0 Barcelona 190.4 Shanghai 162.4 12 Frankfurt 966.7 Sydney 226.4 Osaka 71.2 Brussels 145.3 Copenhagen 270.4 London 182.2 Brussels 161.8 13 Barcelona 964.6 Seoul 222.6 Shanghai 70.3 Sydney 145.3 Milan 270.2 Seoul 179.5 Milan 157.2 14 Shanghai 964.5 Copenhagen 214.7 Washington, D.C. 70.1 Milan 128.6 Geneva 267.0 Sydney 174.9 Moscow 154.8 15 Sydney 962.8 Toronto 212.6 Beijing 66.6 Seoul 126.6 Brussels 265.5 Singapore 174.0 Barcelona 152.4 16 Stockholm 961.2 Amsterdam 211.4 Berlin 64.9 Madrid 126.3 Zurich 264.1 Amsterdam 173.6 Madrid 149.3 17 Osaka 942.1 Stockholm 209.3 Amsterdam 61.8 Hong Kong 125.2 Toronto 263.9 Osaka 168.4 Toronto 146.9 18 Zurich 937.9 Frankfurt 207.4 Zurich 59.9 Amsterdam 124.9 Kuala Lumpur 262.2 Paris 167.3 Bangkok 146.8 19 Brussels 931.3 Berlin 205.9 Sydney 57.7 Moscow 119.8 Frankfurt 262.0 Washington, D.C. 161.9 Copenhagen 141.2 20 Copenhagen 929.7 Vancouver 196.2 Toronto 54.3 Chicago 114.7 London 253.4 Los Angeles 160.2 Osaka 140.7 21 Toronto 925.6 Vienna 194.6 Stockholm 51.9 Bangkok 113.7 Madrid 253.0 Vancouver 157.1 Vienna 139.1 22 Madrid 908.6 Osaka 191.1 Vancouver 51.5 Shanghai 109.7 Shanghai 245.4 New York 155.6 Boston 138.3 23 Los Angeles 890.7 San Francisco 189.1 Taipei 50.5 Mexico City 105.9 Mexico City 239.3 Brussels 155.4 Kuala Lumpur 138.2 24 Vancouver 890.1 Taipei 189.1 Barcelona 49.8 Toronto 97.6 Seoul 237.0 Fukuoka 153.5 Berlin 137.4 25 Istanbul 875.4 Boston 182.8 Vienna 47.4 Stockholm 93.5 Sydney 226.7 San Francisco 152.7 Taipei 135.4 26 Geneva 867.8 Chicago 178.5 Moscow 46.7 San Francisco 92.5 Singapore 226.4 Toronto 150.4 Chicago 133.8 27 Boston 858.4 Los Angeles 175.6 Geneva 45.6 Washington, D.C. 79.9 Beijing 226.3 Milan 148.6 Sydney 131.8 28 Chicago 854.1 Moscow 172.7 Fukuoka 44.6 Osaka 76.2 Mumbai 222.7 Boston 143.5 Beijing 130.3 29 Milan 850.5 Brussels 167.4 Madrid 43.8 Vancouver 74.3 Istanbul 221.9 Mexico City 142.0 Zurich 127.0 30 Washington, D.C. 836.5 Istanbul 162.3 Copenhagen 39.9 Copenhagen 71.8 Hong Kong 218.3 Hong Kong 137.9 Stockholm 123.7 31 San Francisco 833.3 Kuala Lumpur 159.3 Istanbul 39.8 Kuala Lumpur 71.3 Bangkok 215.9 Bangkok 135.6 Mexico City 119.9 32 Taipei 807.9 Mexico City 154.2 Brussels 35.8 Boston 70.4 New York 215.0 Mumbai 134.4 Vancouver 119.5 33 Fukuoka 790.3 Fukuoka 153.4 Bangkok 35.6 Frankfurt 67.3 Cairo 211.7 Kuala Lumpur 133.6 Fukuoka 113.0 34 Kuala Lumpur 788.1 Sao Paulo 146.9 Frankfurt 34.7 Cairo 55.8 San Francisco 208.0 Chicago 125.1 San Francisco 110.6 35 Bangkok 781.4 Madrid 140.1 Milan 29.3 Zurich 47.8 Boston 205.7 Shanghai 123.0 Cairo 106.8 36 Mexico City 781.0 Barcelona 135.3 Kuala Lumpur 23.5 Sao Paulo 43.9 Chicago 205.4 Istanbul 120.4 Washington, D.C. 104.2 37 Moscow 760.2 Bangkok 133.7 Mexico City 19.7 Mumbai 41.6 Sao Paulo 196.8 Taipei 115.7 Los Angeles 103.5 38 Sao Paulo 667.7 Mumbai 126.5 Sao Paulo 8.4 Taipei 41.4 Moscow 195.3 Cairo 109.9 Geneva 91.4 39 Mumbai 608.1 Milan 116.6 Mumbai 4.1 Fukuoka 33.4 Washington, D.C. 188.7 Beijing 107.9 Mumbai 78.8 40 Cairo 601.0 Cairo 113.6 Cairo 3.3 Geneva 31.0 Los Angeles 184.7 Moscow 70.8 Sao Paulo 72.0 環境 交通 アクセス

Actor-specific Ranking Top 4 Cities Rank Manager Researcher Artist Visitor Resident 1 London 55.8 New York 63.5 Paris 58.0 London 58.5 Paris 60.3 2 Singapore 54.1 Tokyo 52.5 London 57.1 New York 54.6 London 55.3 3 Hong Kong 50.1 London 49.4 Tokyo 52.5 Paris 53.4 Tokyo 54.1 4 New York 49.4 Paris 47.9 Berlin 50.0 Istanbul 46.1 New York 53.7 5 Shanghai 47.8 Boston 36.1 New York 49.5 Hong Kong 45.4 Frankfurt 51.1 6 Beijing 47.7 Seoul 34.1 Barcelona 46.6 Tokyo 45.0 Berlin 50.0 7 Tokyo 45.0 Los Angeles 33.6 Vienna 46.5 Beijing 43.6 Zurich 49.7 8 Paris 44.9 Singapore 32.1 Los Angeles 44.7 Barcelona 42.9 Vienna 49.2 9 Seoul 44.4 San Francisco 31.4 Milan 43.0 Singapore 42.3 Washington, D.C. 48.1 10 Zurich 41.8 Chicago 29.0 Amsterdam 42.8 Shanghai 41.3 Vancouver 48.1 11 Berlin 41.7 Sydney 28.9 Mexico City 40.9 Berlin 40.7 Boston 46.6 12 Amsterdam 41.4 Washington, D.C. 28.4 Madrid 40.9 Seoul 40.0 Amsterdam 46.4 13 Geneva 40.2 Beijing 28.3 Toronto 40.1 Bangkok 38.9 Osaka 46.3 14 Vienna 40.0 Berlin 27.4 Stockholm 39.7 Vienna 37.3 Milan 46.1 15 Stockholm 39.6 Amsterdam 26.5 Beijing 39.6 Milan 37.1 Stockholm 46.1 16 Vancouver 39.2 Osaka 26.5 Sydney 38.1 Brussels 35.9 Copenhagen 46.0 17 Taipei 39.2 Zurich 25.9 Osaka 37.8 Amsterdam 35.1 Geneva 45.1 18 Sydney 38.7 Vienna 25.9 Brussels 37.7 Madrid 34.7 San Francisco 45.0 19 Toronto 38.7 Vancouver 25.0 Vancouver 37.3 Taipei 33.9 Barcelona 44.7 20 Copenhagen 38.4 Hong Kong 24.8 Copenhagen 37.2 Toronto 33.4 Brussels 44.7 21 Istanbul 38.2 Stockholm 24.4 San Francisco 36.9 Osaka 33.0 Madrid 43.9 22 Frankfurt 37.8 Copenhagen 24.3 Chicago 36.6 Sydney 32.9 Fukuoka 43.6 23 Kuala Lumpur 37.4 Toronto 23.7 Istanbul 35.8 Kuala Lumpur 32.8 Toronto 43.6 24 Boston 36.2 Geneva 23.7 Fukuoka 35.5 Cairo 32.1 Sydney 43.0 25 Washington, D.C. 34.8 Brussels 22.7 Frankfurt 35.2 Frankfurt 31.8 Seoul 42.6 26 Osaka 34.6 Moscow 22.0 Bangkok 35.2 Chicago 31.7 Hong Kong 42.5 27 Chicago 33.8 Barcelona 21.1 Shanghai 35.0 Vancouver 31.4 Shanghai 41.6 28 Barcelona 33.5 Mexico City 20.8 Moscow 33.6 Mexico City 31.4 Taipei 40.8 29 Brussels 33.3 Madrid 20.0 Kuala Lumpur 33.6 Boston 30.1 Beijing 40.3 30 Madrid 32.7 Shanghai 19.9 Taipei 32.5 Fukuoka 29.6 Singapore 39.8 31 Bangkok 32.6 Taipei 19.2 Seoul 32.3 Moscow 29.6 Los Angeles 38.9 32 Los Angeles 31.7 Milan 19.1 Cairo 31.9 Stockholm 29.6 Mexico City 38.7 33 Fukuoka 31.2 Fukuoka 19.0 Mumbai 30.9 San Francisco 28.5 Chicago 38.3 34 San Francisco 30.3 Frankfurt 19.0 Washington, D.C. 30.6 Copenhagen 27.6 Moscow 36.8 35 Mumbai 29.5 Istanbul 17.8 Sao Paulo 30.0 Los Angeles 27.1 Istanbul 32.0 36 Moscow 28.2 Bangkok 17.5 Zurich 29.3 Zurich 25.5 Kuala Lumpur 29.9 37 Cairo 28.0 Kuala Lumpur 15.5 Geneva 28.7 Mumbai 24.4 Bangkok 29.8 38 Milan 27.4 Sao Paulo 14.9 Singapore 28.0 Washington, D.C. 23.7 Cairo 27.7 39 Sao Paulo 25.2 Mumbai 10.3 Boston 25.1 Geneva 21.6 Mumbai 27.4 40 Mexico City 24.4 Cairo 9.0 Hong Kong 24.1 Sao Paulo 16.0 Sao Paulo 27.3

Actor-specific Ranking North American Cities Rank Manager Researcher Artist Visitor Resident 1 London 55.8 New York 63.5 Paris 58.0 London 58.5 Paris 60.3 2 Singapore 54.1 Tokyo 52.5 London 57.1 New York 54.6 London 55.3 3 Hong Kong 50.1 London 49.4 Tokyo 52.5 Paris 53.4 Tokyo 54.1 4 New York 49.4 Paris 47.9 Berlin 50.0 Istanbul 46.1 New York 53.7 5 Shanghai 47.8 Boston 36.1 New York 49.5 Hong Kong 45.4 Frankfurt 51.1 6 Beijing 47.7 Seoul 34.1 Barcelona 46.6 Tokyo 45.0 Berlin 50.0 7 Tokyo 45.0 Los Angeles 33.6 Vienna 46.5 Beijing 43.6 Zurich 49.7 8 Paris 44.9 Singapore 32.1 Los Angeles 44.7 Barcelona 42.9 Vienna 49.2 9 Seoul 44.4 San Francisco 31.4 Milan 43.0 Singapore 42.3 Washington, D.C. 48.1 10 Zurich 41.8 Chicago 29.0 Amsterdam 42.8 Shanghai 41.3 Vancouver 48.1 11 Berlin 41.7 Sydney 28.9 Mexico City 40.9 Berlin 40.7 Boston 46.6 12 Amsterdam 41.4 Washington, D.C. 28.4 Madrid 40.9 Seoul 40.0 Amsterdam 46.4 13 Geneva 40.2 Beijing 28.3 Toronto 40.1 Bangkok 38.9 Osaka 46.3 14 Vienna 40.0 Berlin 27.4 Stockholm 39.7 Vienna 37.3 Milan 46.1 15 Stockholm 39.6 Amsterdam 26.5 Beijing 39.6 Milan 37.1 Stockholm 46.1 16 Vancouver 39.2 Osaka 26.5 Sydney 38.1 Brussels 35.9 Copenhagen 46.0 17 Taipei 39.2 Zurich 25.9 Osaka 37.8 Amsterdam 35.1 Geneva 45.1 18 Sydney 38.7 Vienna 25.9 Brussels 37.7 Madrid 34.7 San Francisco 45.0 19 Toronto 38.7 Vancouver 25.0 Vancouver 37.3 Taipei 33.9 Barcelona 44.7 20 Copenhagen 38.4 Hong Kong 24.8 Copenhagen 37.2 Toronto 33.4 Brussels 44.7 21 Istanbul 38.2 Stockholm 24.4 San Francisco 36.9 Osaka 33.0 Madrid 43.9 22 Frankfurt 37.8 Copenhagen 24.3 Chicago 36.6 Sydney 32.9 Fukuoka 43.6 23 Kuala Lumpur 37.4 Toronto 23.7 Istanbul 35.8 Kuala Lumpur 32.8 Toronto 43.6 24 Boston 36.2 Geneva 23.7 Fukuoka 35.5 Cairo 32.1 Sydney 43.0 25 Washington, D.C. 34.8 Brussels 22.7 Frankfurt 35.2 Frankfurt 31.8 Seoul 42.6 26 Osaka 34.6 Moscow 22.0 Bangkok 35.2 Chicago 31.7 Hong Kong 42.5 27 Chicago 33.8 Barcelona 21.1 Shanghai 35.0 Vancouver 31.4 Shanghai 41.6 28 Barcelona 33.5 Mexico City 20.8 Moscow 33.6 Mexico City 31.4 Taipei 40.8 29 Brussels 33.3 Madrid 20.0 Kuala Lumpur 33.6 Boston 30.1 Beijing 40.3 30 Madrid 32.7 Shanghai 19.9 Taipei 32.5 Fukuoka 29.6 Singapore 39.8 31 Bangkok 32.6 Taipei 19.2 Seoul 32.3 Moscow 29.6 Los Angeles 38.9 32 Los Angeles 31.7 Milan 19.1 Cairo 31.9 Stockholm 29.6 Mexico City 38.7 33 Fukuoka 31.2 Fukuoka 19.0 Mumbai 30.9 San Francisco 28.5 Chicago 38.3 34 San Francisco 30.3 Frankfurt 19.0 Washington, D.C. 30.6 Copenhagen 27.6 Moscow 36.8 35 Mumbai 29.5 Istanbul 17.8 Sao Paulo 30.0 Los Angeles 27.1 Istanbul 32.0 36 Moscow 28.2 Bangkok 17.5 Zurich 29.3 Zurich 25.5 Kuala Lumpur 29.9 37 Cairo 28.0 Kuala Lumpur 15.5 Geneva 28.7 Mumbai 24.4 Bangkok 29.8 38 Milan 27.4 Sao Paulo 14.9 Singapore 28.0 Washington, D.C. 23.7 Cairo 27.7 39 Sao Paulo 25.2 Mumbai 10.3 Boston 25.1 Geneva 21.6 Mumbai 27.4 40 Mexico City 24.4 Cairo 9.0 Hong Kong 24.1 Sao Paulo 16.0 Sao Paulo 27.3

Actor-specific Ranking Asian Cities Rank Manager Researcher Artist Visitor Resident 1 London 55.8 New York 63.5 Paris 58.0 London 58.5 Paris 60.3 2 Singapore 54.1 Tokyo 52.5 London 57.1 New York 54.6 London 55.3 3 Hong Kong 50.1 London 49.4 Tokyo 52.5 Paris 53.4 Tokyo 54.1 4 New York 49.4 Paris 47.9 Berlin 50.0 Istanbul 46.1 New York 53.7 5 Shanghai 47.8 Boston 36.1 New York 49.5 Hong Kong 45.4 Frankfurt 51.1 6 Beijing 47.7 Seoul 34.1 Barcelona 46.6 Tokyo 45.0 Berlin 50.0 7 Tokyo 45.0 Los Angeles 33.6 Vienna 46.5 Beijing 43.6 Zurich 49.7 8 Paris 44.9 Singapore 32.1 Los Angeles 44.7 Barcelona 42.9 Vienna 49.2 9 Seoul 44.4 San Francisco 31.4 Milan 43.0 Singapore 42.3 Washington, D.C. 48.1 10 Zurich 41.8 Chicago 29.0 Amsterdam 42.8 Shanghai 41.3 Vancouver 48.1 11 Berlin 41.7 Sydney 28.9 Mexico City 40.9 Berlin 40.7 Boston 46.6 12 Amsterdam 41.4 Washington, D.C. 28.4 Madrid 40.9 Seoul 40.0 Amsterdam 46.4 13 Geneva 40.2 Beijing 28.3 Toronto 40.1 Bangkok 38.9 Osaka 46.3 14 Vienna 40.0 Berlin 27.4 Stockholm 39.7 Vienna 37.3 Milan 46.1 15 Stockholm 39.6 Amsterdam 26.5 Beijing 39.6 Milan 37.1 Stockholm 46.1 16 Vancouver 39.2 Osaka 26.5 Sydney 38.1 Brussels 35.9 Copenhagen 46.0 17 Taipei 39.2 Zurich 25.9 Osaka 37.8 Amsterdam 35.1 Geneva 45.1 18 Sydney 38.7 Vienna 25.9 Brussels 37.7 Madrid 34.7 San Francisco 45.0 19 Toronto 38.7 Vancouver 25.0 Vancouver 37.3 Taipei 33.9 Barcelona 44.7 20 Copenhagen 38.4 Hong Kong 24.8 Copenhagen 37.2 Toronto 33.4 Brussels 44.7 21 Istanbul 38.2 Stockholm 24.4 San Francisco 36.9 Osaka 33.0 Madrid 43.9 22 Frankfurt 37.8 Copenhagen 24.3 Chicago 36.6 Sydney 32.9 Fukuoka 43.6 23 Kuala Lumpur 37.4 Toronto 23.7 Istanbul 35.8 Kuala Lumpur 32.8 Toronto 43.6 24 Boston 36.2 Geneva 23.7 Fukuoka 35.5 Cairo 32.1 Sydney 43.0 25 Washington, D.C. 34.8 Brussels 22.7 Frankfurt 35.2 Frankfurt 31.8 Seoul 42.6 26 Osaka 34.6 Moscow 22.0 Bangkok 35.2 Chicago 31.7 Hong Kong 42.5 27 Chicago 33.8 Barcelona 21.1 Shanghai 35.0 Vancouver 31.4 Shanghai 41.6 28 Barcelona 33.5 Mexico City 20.8 Moscow 33.6 Mexico City 31.4 Taipei 40.8 29 Brussels 33.3 Madrid 20.0 Kuala Lumpur 33.6 Boston 30.1 Beijing 40.3 30 Madrid 32.7 Shanghai 19.9 Taipei 32.5 Fukuoka 29.6 Singapore 39.8 31 Bangkok 32.6 Taipei 19.2 Seoul 32.3 Moscow 29.6 Los Angeles 38.9 32 Los Angeles 31.7 Milan 19.1 Cairo 31.9 Stockholm 29.6 Mexico City 38.7 33 Fukuoka 31.2 Fukuoka 19.0 Mumbai 30.9 San Francisco 28.5 Chicago 38.3 34 San Francisco 30.3 Frankfurt 19.0 Washington, D.C. 30.6 Copenhagen 27.6 Moscow 36.8 35 Mumbai 29.5 Istanbul 17.8 Sao Paulo 30.0 Los Angeles 27.1 Istanbul 32.0 36 Moscow 28.2 Bangkok 17.5 Zurich 29.3 Zurich 25.5 Kuala Lumpur 29.9 37 Cairo 28.0 Kuala Lumpur 15.5 Geneva 28.7 Mumbai 24.4 Bangkok 29.8 38 Milan 27.4 Sao Paulo 14.9 Singapore 28.0 Washington, D.C. 23.7 Cairo 27.7 39 Sao Paulo 25.2 Mumbai 10.3 Boston 25.1 Geneva 21.6 Mumbai 27.4 40 Mexico City 24.4 Cairo 9.0 Hong Kong 24.1 Sao Paulo 16.0 Sao Paulo 27.3

Findings of the GPCI-2012 1. London now ranks top overall, having overtaken New York. 2. Tokyo remains at No. 4, despite the effects of the Great Eastern Earthquake on some of the indicators. 3. Among the second tier group of cities, Asian cities such as Beijing and Shanghai show continuing progress and are closing the gap between themselves and the top four cities. We also see that North American cities seem to be suffering from a downward trend and are slipping down the rankings.

1. London now ranks top overall Olympic Bidding and the Comprehensive Power of Cities <Source> http://www.london2012.com

1. London now ranks top overall The Effects of Securing Global Events on the Comprehensive Power of Cities 2012 2011

Comparison between London and NY 7.0% GDP Growth Rate 6.0% 5.0% 4.0% 3.0% 2.0% 1.0% 0.0% -1.0% -2.0% 百万ドル 800,000 700,000 600,000 London New York Paris Tokyo GDP( トップ 4 都市 ) GPCI-2009 GPCI-2010 GPCI-2011 GPCI-2012 500,000

London VISITOR Visitor London(1st) 0 50 100 New York(2nd) 0 50 100 Paris(3rd) 0 50 100 Tokyo(4th) 0 50 100 1. Atmosphere of cities 69.3 61.6 77.7 54.5 2. Public safety 52.5 53.5 55.3 57.3 3. Destinations for tourists 83.9 71.5 73.4 55.6 4. Accommodations 65.4 64.9 47.2 50.2 5. Restaurants 53.0 66.6 68.4 75.3 6. Shopping 59.1 61.3 63.8 60.0 7. Mobility 77.4 64.8 78.1 59.8 Visitor 76.3 71.8 70.6 61.0

Key Message (Finding 1) 1. London now ranks top overall, having overtaken New York. <Analysis from the data> Result of Olympic Effect The indicators with score increased from GPCI-2011 to GPCI-2012 Number of Large World- Class Cultural Events Held Number of Guest Rooms of Luxury Hotels GPCI-2011 GPCI-2012 7 8 15,400 16,100 Number of Hotels 760 900 Number of Stadiums 37 46 London vs New York Comparison of the number of Increase and decrease of scores in each indicator from GPCI-2011 to GPCI-2012 London New York Over 10 point increase 7 indicators 5 indicators Over 10 point decrease 4 indicators 4 indicators

2. Tokyo remains at No. 4 Despite the effects of the Great Eastern Earthquake on 3.11

Great Eastern Earthquake Simulation estimated in 2011 Nominal GDP GDP per Capita GDP Growth Rate Number of Passengers on International Flights Accessibility Score - 1.0 Rank Score ± 0 Rank Environment Economy Score - 0.5 Rank Total Score - 2.9 Rank Score ± 0 Rank Livability R&D Score ± 0 Rank Score -1.3 Rank Cultural Interaction Legend Number of International Conferences Held Number of Foreign Residents Number of Visitors from Abroad Number of International Students No Changes Rank Drops Affected Indicator by 3.11(Estimated) We estimated that the Tokyo s major influence was International interaction in comparison to the Top 3 cities.

Estimated Change 6 Months after Mar 11

Changes from the Great Eastern Earthquake Simulation in 2011 Accessibility Score + 2.1 Rank Score + 9.7 Rank Environment Economy Score -2.9 Rank Total Score +9.7 Rank Score + 4.1 Rank Livability R&D Score - 12.3 Rank Score +9.0 Rank Cultural Interaction Legend No Changes Rank Drops Rank Rises

Key Message (Finding 2) 2. Tokyo remains at No. 4, despite the effects of the Great Eastern Earthquake on some of the indicators. 6 month after the disaster, we estimated 12 indicators will be declined. However, the following indicator increased its score in fact. Economy Cultural Interaction Accessibility Nominal GDP Number of International Number of Passengers on Conferences Held International Flights GDP per Capita Total Unemployment Rate

3. Asia Cities Upwards, North American Cities Downwards

Comprehensive Ranking 2012: Changes since 2008 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 GPCI-2008 GPCI-2009 GPCI-2010 GPCI-2011 GPCI-2012 North American Cities New York Toronto Los Angeles Vancouver Boston Chicago Washington,D.C. 40 San Francisco

Comprehensive Ranking 2012: Changes since 2008 0 5 10 15 GPCI-2008 GPCI-2009 GPCI-2010 GPCI-2011 GPCI-2012 North American Cities New York Toronto Los Angeles Vancouver 20 Boston 25 Chicago 30 Washington,D.C. 35 San Francisco 40

Comprehensive Ranking 2012: Changes since 2008 0 GPCI-2008 GPCI-2009 GPCI-2010 GPCI-2011 GPCI-2012 Asian Cities Tokyo 5 10 15 20 25 Singapore Seoul Hong Kong Beijing Shanghai Osaka Taipei 30 35 40 Fukuoka Kuala Lumpur Bangkok

GDP Forecast of Major Asian Cities 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030 2031 2032 ( 年 ) ( 千億 US ドル ) ( USD million) 1,200,000 12 1,000,000 10 800,000 8 Tokyo 東京 Shanghai 上海 北京 Beijing シンガポール Singapore 600,000 6 Hong Kong 香港 400,000 4 200,000 2 0 台北 Taipei ソウル Seoul

Key Message (Finding 3) 3. Among the second tier group of cities, Asian cities such as Beijing and Shanghai show continuing progress and are closing the gap between themselves and the top four cities. We also see that North American cities seem to be suffering from a downward trend and are slipping down the rankings. Beijing Rapid growing indicator Shanghai Rapid growing indicator GPCI-2011 GPCI-2012 GPCI-2011 GPCI-2012 World s Top 300 Companies (Score) 2842 3370 Number of Hotels 330 460 Number of Visitors from Abroad 3.43mil 4.22mil World s Top 300 Companies (Score) 103 239 Number of Hotels 450 530 Number of Visitors from Abroad 4.90mil 6.66mil

Revitalization of Tokyo Hiroo Mori Senior Managing Director, Mori Building Co., Ltd. 18 October 2012

1. City of Tokyo Among the World s Leading Cities 2. Revitalization of Tokyo 3. Actions by Public Sector 4. Actions by Private Sector

1. City of Tokyo Among the World s Leading Cities 2. Revitalization of Tokyo 3. Actions by Public Sectors 4. Actions by Private Sectors

Summary of Tokyo s Status Strengths Weaknesses - Safety, Cleanliness - Diversity - High Efficiency, Accuracy - Hospitality - Lack of Urban Policies - Earthquakes Risks - Less Proximity to the Rest of the World

Compact City Model Super High-Rise Buildings Create Open Space 3ha 800 m2 50F 75% = 30,000 m2 = 3ha 3ha 100 m2 300 units = 30,000 m2 = 3ha

Vertical Garden City Vertical Garden City - Compact city including spaces for working, living and enjoying Creation of open space throughout the site by intelligent integrated land use Application of Vertical thinking to space over roads Greening of rooftops, walls, etc. Integrated complex space with diverse uses realized by multidimensional development Underground plaza shrinks the sense of distance from the openness of the above ground environment

1. City of Tokyo Among the World s Leading Cities 2. Revitalization of Tokyo 3. Actions by Public Sectors 4. Actions by Private Sectors

For Revitalization of Tokyo The Future of Central Tokyo Key Words International and Innovative Highly skilled people, intelligence and cultural diversity Source: the Association for Tokyo Urban-Core Rejuvenation. Creation of international, innovative, leading city of Asia.

For Revitalization of Tokyo To Achieve the Vision 6 Key Items: Internationalization Earthquake-resistance, Energy-sufficiency Greenery, Watersides, and Promenades Interaction with Talent Accumulation and Mixture of Functions Updating while Preserving History Source: the Association for Tokyo Urban-Core Rejuvenation. Creation of international, innovative, leading city of Asia.

Image of Urban Space and Activities in 2025 Vertically-integrated podiums for mixed-use with ground level differences

Image of Urban Space and Activities in 2025 Harvesting in rice paddy Observation of natural environment Open space for education connected to neighborhood Interactive classroom in collaboration with foreign schools

Image of Urban Space and Activities in 2025 Fresh market with locally-harvested foods Performances and music on bustling street LRT together with pedestrians Bike lanes running throughout neighborhoods

Image of Urban Space and Activities in 2025 Landscape incorporating natural ground Visitors enjoying a play after international convention World-famous theater with large space underground

1. City of Tokyo Among the World s Leading Cities 2. Revitalization of Tokyo 3. Actions by Public Sector 4. Actions by Private Sectors

Developing International Competitiveness as a National Strategy Special Priority Development Areas for Urban Renaissance (Jan. 2012) Support for Hardware Comprehensive Special Zones for International Competitiveness Development (Dec. 2011) Support for Software

Special Priority Development Areas for Urban Renaissance 11 areas across the country

Special Priority Development Areas for Urban Renaissance 4 areas in Tokyo

Special Priority Development Areas for Urban Renaissance Planning with Public-Private Partnerships Regulations regarding Air Rights over Roads Permit Process for Development Projects Tax Benefits for Development Projects

Comprehensive Special Zones for International Competitiveness Development 7 areas across the country Special Zone for Asian Headquarters in Tokyo Special Zone for Food Complex in Hokkaido Special Zone of Life Innovation in Kanagawa Special Zone promoting Life and Green Innovation in Tsukuba Special Zone to Create Asia s No.1 Aerospace Industry in Aichi and Gifu Special Zone for Innovation in Kansai Special Zone for Green Asia in Kyushu

Tokyo s Special Zone for Asian Headquarters

Tokyo s Special Zone for Asian Headquarters 1. Approaches / Business Exchange 2. Business Support 3. Living Environment Development 4. Business Environment to Secure BCP By 2016, an additional 50 Asian regional headquarters and 500 operations of foreign companies

1. City of Tokyo Among the World s Leading Cities 2. Revitalization of Tokyo 3. Actions by Public Sectors 4. Actions by Private Sector

Grand Design of Akasaka, Roppongi, Toranomon and Shinbashi Areas Tokyo Station Center of life and culture Center of work and culture Center of international culture

Actual Projects in Akasaka, Roppongi, Toranomon and Shinbashi Areas

Marunouchi and Nihonbashi Marunouchi Nihonbashi Source: Tokyo Metropolitan Government Your Base for New Innovation

Ginza, Shimbashi, Toranomon Shimbashi Toranomon Source: Tokyo Metropolitan Government Your Base for New Innovation

Shibuya, Roppongi, Shinagawa Roppongi Shibuya Shinagawa Source: Tokyo Metropolitan Government Your Base for New Innovation

We look forward to welcoming you to Tokyo soon

Thank you