SUSTAINABLE TOURISM DEVELOPMENT in SMALL ISLANDS: Case of Indonesian Small Island, Morotai Island (Lesson Learn from Malta Republic) THESIS A thesis submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the Master Degree from the University of Groningen and the Master Degree from the Institut Teknologi Bandung By: NUR LIENDA RUG: S 1702599 ITB: 25406023 Supervisors: Prof. Dr. Ir. Paul Ike (RuG) Arief Rosyidie, Drs.,MSP.,M.Arch.,Ph.D (ITB) DOUBLE MASTER DEGREE PROGRAMME ENVIRONMENTAL AND INFRASTRUCTURE PLANNING FACULTY OF SPATIAL SCIENCE UNIVERSITY OF GRONINGEN AND DEVELOPMENT PLANNING AND INFRASTRUCTURE MANAGEMENT SCHOOL OF ARCHITECTURE, PLANNING, AND POLICY DEVELOPMENT INSTITUT TEKNOLOGI BANDUNG 2008
ABSTRACT SUSTAINABLE TOURISM DEVELOPMENT in SMALL ISLANDS: Case of Indonesian Small Island, Morotai Island (Lesson Learn from Malta Republic) By: NUR LIENDA ITB: 25406023 RUG: S 1702599 Small islands with the unique ecosystem and specific natural environment tend to depend on tourism as the primary industry more than larger state do. Sustainable tourism became more important for small islands due to their characteristics and the issues that small islands face, such as small size, insularity and remoteness, proneness to natural disasters and environmental factors. Tourism as an activity has both positive and negative impact to economic, social and personal, and to environmental. Government roles are very crucial in order to promote the successful of sustainable tourism development. In produce the policy related to the sustainable tourism development for small islands, government have to consider the island s carrying capacity and put into account the indicators of sustainable tourism. The indicator for sustainable tourism development and some roles of government in supporting the tourism development is used in order to do the comparative analysis between Malta Republic and Indonesia (with case of Morotai Island). In Malta Republic, tourism sector already give significant contribution to its economic. Malta experienced the negative impact of tourism and realized the importance of practicing the sustainable tourism and in the other hand Morotai Island is one of small islands in Indonesia that has potential to be developed as tourism destination but still faced with some limitation. In this thesis, author wants to explored what Malta Republic already done in develops and manages the sustainable tourism. And from Malta experience in tourism, it can take some learning point that can be applied and developed to promote the sustainable tourism in Indonesian small islands. Key words: Sustainable tourism, indicators of sustainable tourism, small islands, government roles, policy, Malta Republic, and Morotai Island. i
PREFACE Working at Local Development Planning Board of Maluku Utara Province, makes me realize that government s roles to support the development of the region is very important. As a relative new province which consists of more than hundred small islands with all the potential that can be develop for tourism became one of the reasons for me to write this thesis. Small islands are interest to explore due to their specific condition. Studying Environmental and Infrastructure Planning in University of Groningen give me chance to studying the development in other countries. My thesis is to compare and learning about sustainable tourism development in small islands with Malta Republic as the focus of lesson learn. It hopes that from Malta Republic I can take some lesson that can be applied to develop sustainable tourism in Indonesia. In prepare this master thesis; there are some parties that help me through all this process. It difficult to mention it one by one, but I want to deliver my special thanks to my supervisors, Prof. Dr. Ir. Paul Ike from RuG and Arief Rosyidie, Drs.,MSP.,M.Arch.,Ph.D from ITB for giving comments, critics, input and support during this process. Next, I want to express my thanks to National Development Planning Board (BAPPENAS) and Netherlands Education Support Office NESO to give chance for me to studying in ITB Indonesia and RuG Netherland and Also my office, BAPPEDA of Maluku Utara Province. I would like also to thanks to all my lectures in RuG, SAPPK and UPT Bahasa ITB, all my colleagues, my friends in Indonesia and Groningen, my floor mates in Plutolaan, thanks for all great time together. My special thanks for my Mum (Sarbanun Fabanyo) and Dad (Drs. Mahmud Adrias), Agung Sri Sadono, Maulana my beloved son, thanks for being patient for all the time that we are not together, my sisters Yani and Ara, and Tasya for all support and spirit. And for Allah SWT, for make all possible July 2008, Plutolaan, Groningen, The Netherlands ii
TABLE OF CONTENTS Abstract. Preface... Table of Content.... Table of Table and Figure.. Chapter I Introduction 1.1 Background.. 1.2 Research Problems and Objectives... 1.3 Research Question... 1.4 Scope of Study. 1.5 Methodology 1.6 Report Structure... Chapter II The Concept of Sustainable Tourism in Small Islands 2.1 The Concept of Sustainable Development. 2.2 Sustainable Tourism. 2.2.1 Tourism. 2.2.2 Sustainable Tourism.. 2.3 Sustainable Tourism in Small Islands. 2.3.1 Small Islands. 2.3.2 Sustainable Tourism in Small Island... 2.4 Roles of Government in Tourism Development.. Chapter III Sustainable Tourism Development in Small Islands (Malta Republic) 3.1 General Description 3.2 Tourism in Malta. 3.2.1 Infrastructures.. 3.2.2 The Impact of Tourism on Economic.. 3.2.3 The Impact of Tourism on Environment. 3.3 Motivation for Sustainable Tourism.. 3.4 The Roles of Government... Chapter IV Sustainable Tourism Development in Small Islands (Indonesia Small Islands, Morotai Island) 4.1 General Description.. i ii iii v 1 2 3 3 3 4 6 9 9 14 22 22 25 27 30 32 33 34 35 37 38 43 iii
4.2 Tourism in Morotai 4.2.1 General Condition.. 4.2.2 Tourism Potential.. 4.2.3 Infrastructures. 4.2.4 The Impact of Tourism.. 4.3 The Roles of Government. 4.3.1 Central Government. 4.3.2 Local Governments.. Chapter V Comparative Analysis 5.1 The Impact of Tourism 5.1.1 The Impact of Tourism to the Economic. 5.1.2 The Impact of Tourism to the Environment. 5.2 The Motivations for Sustainable Tourism 5.3 The Roles of Government 45 45 46 47 48 49 49 51 55 56 57 57 58 Chapter VI Conclusion and Recommendations 6.1 Conclusion.. 6.2 Recommendations.. References 62 64 66 iv
LIST OF TABLES Table II.1 Table II.2 Table II.3 Table III.1 Table III.2 Table IV.1 Table IV.2 Table V.I The Pillars of Sustainable Development.. Economic Benefits of Travel and Tourism.. Core Indicators of Sustainable Tourism.. International Arrival in Malta: 1959 2006... Visitations to Malta by Country, 2000 2006. The Gross Regional Domestic Product of Halmahera Utara Regency (In Thousand Rupiah).. The Identification of Tourism Potential in Morotai Island Compatibility and Level of Policy... Comparative Analysis Table. 8 11 18 32 22 48 53 61 Figure II.1 Figure II.2 Figure II.3 Figure II.4 Figure II.5 Figure II.6 Figure II.7 Figure III.1 Figure IV.1 LIST OF FIGURES Scheme of Sustainable Development Definitions of Sustainable Tourism Destinations. Process of Holistic and long-term planning Diagram... Position 1: polar opposites... Position 2: continuum.. Position 3: movement.. Position 4: convergence Map of Malta... Morotai Location. 7 15 16 19 19 20 20 31 44 v