Brussels Briefing No. 38: Fighting IUU FISHING IN THE CARIBBEAN Milton Haughton Executive Director
Presentation Overview IUU Fishing in the Caribbean Common Fisheries Policy Castries Declaration on IUU Regional Strategy on MCS Shared responsibility Next Steps
Local News Headlines Venezuelans could not outrun JDF coastguards December 31, 2012. SEVEN Venezuelan nationals who were busted for fishing illegally in Jamaican waters The foreigners, Antonio Lemos (captain),... (Observer, Jamaica) Honduran fisherman remanded in custody January 22, 2011. ONE of the injured Honduran fishermen involved in a recent shooting incident with the Jamaica Defence Force (JDF) Coast Guard was yesterday remanded in custody (Observer.) Greatest single threat' to Bahamas seafood resources January 26, 2011. A RECENT report by a leading University of Miami marine scientist has confirmed that poaching by commercial fishermen from the Dominican Republic is the greatest single threat to Bahamian seafood resources (The Tribune)
Local News Headlines Lobster poachers rob Ja of US$132m June 02, 2011. POACHERS have robbed Jamaica of more than US$130 m in lobster meat..agriculture Minister Guatemalan Fisherman Illegally Fishing In Blue Hole Aug,28, 2013. A Guatemalan fisherman pleaded guilty to Illegal Fishing (Channel5news Belize) French Fishing in Dominica s Waters a Major Problem says Environment Minister 26 May 2014. Minister for the Environment,..& Fisheries, Dr. Kenneth Darroux, has revealed that Dominica is facing a major challenge with illegal fishing activity from the French Islands (News.dm) ARMED AND DANGEROUS POACHERS FROM DOMINICAN REPUBLIC DEPLETING TURKS AND CAICOS ISLANDS FISH STOCK. By Vivian Tyson, Senior SUN Editor Thu, Jun 26, 2014. Armed and dangerous Poachers from the Dominican Republic are wreaking havoc on the Turks and Caicos Islands fishing industry,.(turks and Caicos Sun)
Target High value Species: Lobster, conch, shrimp, tunas, shark-fins, snappers, groupers etc
Regional Study (ACP Fish 2 ) Limited studies or published info on the nature, extent and magnitude of IUU Fishing Economic, social & environmental costs remain largely unquantified 100% 80% 60% 40% 20% 0% IUU fishing considered a threat to the sustainable management of fisheries resources Combatting IUU fishing is considered a top Government priority The economic loss incurred by IUU fishing has been estimated Formal compliance estimates for at least one national fishery have been established IUU fishing by nationals within national waters IUU fishing by foreign industrial, semi- industrial & small-scale vessels in national waters - Regional vessels - Distant Water Fishing Nations Not sure No Yes
Regional Study (ACP Fish 2) Key weaknesses include: Outdated legal / regulatory frameworks Inadequate sanctions / low penalties MCS not always recognised as an inherent part of fisheries governance Low level of MCS planning in national fisheries management structures Limited number of approved FMPs and inadequate data on catch, effort, IUUs incidents,
Regional Policy Framework 1. Revised Treaty of Charaguamas 2. CARICOM Strategic Plan (2015-2019) 3. CARICOM Common Fisheries Policy Prevent, deter and eliminate IUU fishing Strengthen, harmonise & modernises legislation Cooperation in MCS & information sharing Ecosystems approach Protect and conserve fish stocks & ecosystems Marketing and Trade 4. Castries Declaration on IUU Fishing 2010
Castries Declaration on IUU Fishing Main policy document Closer cooperation, commitment & consistency in fighting IUU Fishing Preamble + Body of the Declaration:- - 7 sections - sections 4-7 speaking to 28 specific actions Adopted by Ministerial Council in June 2010
RESOLVE & RENEW EFFORTS: Integrated approach (social, economic, environmental) & considering varying state responsibilities under international law Phased implementation via national & regional plans of action Adopt management actions for long term sustainable use of resources Revise legislation and regulations, with strong sanctions Identify & eliminate economic incentives of IUU, Adopt market measures in accordance with international standards Database of vessels in good standing Participatory approach Implement plans of action with transparency Seek to improve capacity at national and regional levels (CRFM)
Agree to: Monitor & regulate transshipment Regional network of information exchange meshing with International MCS Network Strengthen coastal and port state measures Further international actions against Flag of Convenience vessels & require genuine link between states and vessels Strengthen CRFM to more effective coordinate regional action Vessel marking requirements consistent with international & regional standards CRFM working group on IUU to deal with data collection Exchange info on IUU between States and with CRFM IUU fishing in the Bahamas, Aug 2014 Source : Ocean CREST Alliance
Regional MCS Strategy
Shared Responsibility: KEY Implementing partners REGIONAL IMPACS RSS CRFM National Systems Police Coast Guards Fisheries Dept - enforcement Unit (Belize) Fishers / Civil Society Organisations
Recent National Measures Suriname: - Investment in Patrol vessels - Integrated approach - VMS Bahamas: - US$200 million investment in MCS Jamaica - Fines / sanctions - Drones monitor & surveillance - Upgrading legislation
Regional: Next Steps Update legislation focusing on MCS content: Multi-lateral agreements among states for fisheries conservation, protection & MCS activities Harmonised management measures for high value species - conch & lobster Improving public awareness & involvement in MCS Cost-benefit analysis of MCS strategic options Establishment of Working Group on IUU fishing Improve cooperation with other Caribbean States - Central American States (MOU: CRFM/OSPESCA 2012) - French - département d'outre-mer in Caribbean
National Level Development of NPOA-IUUs and direct assistance for customised NPOA-IUU implementation Reinstitute/formalise a coastal/fisher watch program in support of combating IUU fishing Legislative reforms Next Steps
Protecting Caribbean Fisheries