YORKSHIRE DALES NATIONAL PARK AUTHORITY ITEM 7 Committee: PLANNING Date: 9 December 2014 Report: HEAD OF DEVELOPMENT MANAGEMENT 1. APPEALS A schedule of appeals under consideration is attached as Annex A to this report. 2. DELEGATED DECISIONS Matters within the remit of the Committee, determined in accordance with the Authority s Scheme of Delegation, are listed in the schedule attached as Annex B. Richard Graham Head of Development Management NB: If any Member wishes to enquire about a specific case, would they please contact the Head of Development Management prior to the meeting. The files relating to delegated matters are not normally brought to meetings. Background documents:- Section 1 Correspondence from Planning Inspectorate on appropriate files. Section 2 Delegation forms signed by or on behalf of the Chief Executive.
1. SCHEDULE OF APPEALS ANNEX A Application No Details of appeal and Date of Appeal Method of location decision/ start date determination notice R/85/34D full planning permission 17-02-14 21-05-14 Written for erection of single storey timber framed conservatory Culverham Farm House, West Scrafton R/85/34E/LB listed building consent for 17-02-14 21-05-14 Written erection of single storey timber framed conservatory Culverham Farm House, West Scrafton C/70/7B full planning permission 09-05-14 15-07-14 Written for erection of porch Nibor Barn, Thorpe EC/01/8C unathorised works to a 01-08-14 Written listed building Manor House, Airton The following appeals have been determined: Details of appeal Date of Date of Method of Date of Decision and location decision/ notification of determination inquiry notice appeal to NPA /informal hearing R/49/34D/LDC - certificate of 29-10-13 22-01-14 10/11/2014 lawfulness for sub-division Dismissed of Ingleby Lodge to form a separate dwelling at Ingleby Laithe, Ingleby Lodge, Askrigg EC/64/28A - unauthorised 16-06-14 Written 13/11/2014 siting of marquee and Dismissed removal of trees at Taitlands, Stainforth ER/03/31 - unauthorised 14-07-14 Written 13/11/2014 conversion of barn including Dismissed new openings, new roof, stove and installation of septic tank at Barn in OS Field 5637 & 4236, Swale Hall Lane, Grinton
ANNEX B 2. SCHEDULE OF DELEGATED DECISIONS (i) The following applications have been determined in accordance with the Authority's Scheme of Delegation - dates indicate date of receipt followed by date of decision, the total number of weeks taken is shown in brackets (all those listed have been approved unless specifically indicated otherwise): Application Location Development No C/01/82 C/01/82A/LB The Barn, Airton full planning permission for alterations to existing garage and boundaries, relocation of greenhouse, replacement of oil tanks and resurfacing of driveway 05/09/2014 : 29/10/2014 (8) The Barn, Airton listed building consent for alterations to existing garage and boundaries, relocation of greenhouse, replacement of oil tanks and resurfacing of driveway 05/09/2014 : 29/10/2014 (8) C/04/98N The Austwick full planning permission for erection of 2 and 3 storey rear Traddock, extension and reconfiguration of internal space to Graystonber increase number of letting rooms from 12 to 17, formation Lane, Austwick of enlarged dining room, new kitchen and back of house facilities 06/06/2014 : 18/11/2014 (24) C/04/98P/LB The Austwick listed building consent for erection of 2 and 3 storey rear Traddock, extension and reconfiguration of internal space to Graystonber increase number of letting rooms from 12 to 17, formation Lane, Austwick of enlarged dining room, new kitchen and back of house facilities 06/06/2014 : 18/11/2014 (24) C/07/82A The Cottage, REFUSED - full planning permission for erection of Beamsley storage building 17/09/2014 : 12/11/2014 (8) C/14/63C The Old Police full planning permission for construction of extensions House, Burnsall and widening of driveway, demolition of garage and northern extension and installation of 14kW Air Source Heat Pump 17/07/2014 : 17/11/2014 (18) C/14/9E Oatcroft, full planning permission for erection of extension to Burnsall existing agricultural building and installation of 4kW solar panels 10/09/2014 : 30/10/2014 (7) C/20/6L Throstles Nest full planning permission for erection of sunroom to west Farm, elevation Conistone with Kilnsey C/20/76P/LB Renshaw 30/09/2014 : 29/10/2014 (4) listed building consent for internal alterations Farmhouse, Conistone-with- Kilnsey 16/09/2014 : 06/11/2014 (7) C/23/19E Coxons Farm, full planning permission for erection of agricultural building Cracoe 26/09/2014 : 10/11/2014 (7)
C/26/746A 42 Dales minor material amendment to planning permission Avenue, Embsay C/26/746 relating to enlargement of extension 08/10/2014 : 14/11/2014 (5) C/26/98B Annexe to full planning permission for conversion of existing Greenside, Kirk outbuildings into residential annexe Lane, Embsay 18/09/2014 : 13/11/2014 (8) C/31/620B 2 Meadow full planning permission for installation of 16 (3.8kW) Rise, black Solar Panels on the roof Giggleswick 13/10/2014 : 10/11/2014 (4) C/33/10L Spring Croft, full planning permission for conversion of two Moor Lane, dwellinghouses to bunkhouse accommodation Grassington 31/07/2013 : 10/11/2014 (67) C/33/141J Old Hall, 10 full planning permission for restoration and internal re- Wood Lane, ordering of existing dwelling and replacement of existing Grassington single storey rear extension 10/09/2014 : 05/11/2014 (8) C/33/141K/LB Old Hall, 10 listed building consent for restoration and internal re- Wood Lane, ordering of existing dwelling and replacement of existing Grassington single storey rear extension 10/09/2014 : 05/11/2014 (8) C/37/23A The Barn, full planning permission for change of use of existing barn Windy Pike, to offices with store and laundry room Hanlith 04/09/2014 : 30/10/2014 (8) C/41/23M C/44/151H C/44/151J/LB The Old Lodge, full planning permission for erection of single dwelling Mill Lane, and retention of existing stable block Hebden 25/10/2013 : 14/11/2014 (55) Foxwood Farm, minor material amendment to planning permission Newhouses, C/44/151F regarding omission of two-storey extension Horton in and creation of new window opening and french door in Ribblesdale existing extension 08/09/2014 : 28/10/2014 (7) Foxwood Farm, Listed building consent application for the omission of Newhouses, two-storey extension (granted consent under application Horton in C/44/151G/LB) and creation of new window opening and Ribblesdale french door in existing extension 08/09/2014 : 28/10/2014 (7) C/45/639C Beezley Farm, full planning permission for the subdivision of Beezley Ingleton Farmhouse (as approved on 27 April 2005, Ref C/45/639, and subsequently implemented) revised to include erection of a front porch and rear extension to Unit 2, take down and rebuild the west gable wall of Unit 2, and change the use of land to the rear of Unit 1 to form part of the residential curtilage of the properties 25/09/2014 : 14/11/2014 (7) R/03/119A Greystones, full planning permission for erection of garden room Grinton extension 09/10/2014 : 17/11/2014 (6) R/05/183C Chapel Garth, full planning permission for erection of side extension and Gunnerside formation of a self contained annexe 12/08/2014 : 30/10/2014 (11) R/06/68C Crake Holme, full planning permission for installation of 16 solar panels Muker to roof (4kW) 29/09/2014 : 03/11/2014 (5)
R/51/22H Stowe House, full planning permission for attic conversion to existing Aysgarth Guest House to create 3 no. suite rooms, including installation of roof glazing and conservation roof lights to the rear elevation and external window and door alterations 04/09/2014 : 30/10/2014 (8) R/52/152E Friends full planning permission for extension of existing car park Meeting House, Bainbridge 22/09/2014 : 17/11/2014 (8) R/54/142A R/54/152/GPDO Moody Farm, Morpeth Gate, West Burton East Routengill full planning permission for erection of two storey Farm, Walden extension to east gable, demolish tin roof car port and replace, and construct new access track 15/09/2014 : 10/11/2014 (8) REFUSED - notification under part 6 of the Town & Country Planning (General Permitted Development Order) 1995 for erection of agricultural building extensions to existing field barns 14/10/2014 : 10/11/2014 (4) R/58/52E/LB Thoralby Village listed building consent for siting of defibrillator box on rear Hall, Westfield elevation Lane, Thoralby 09/10/2014 : 05/11/2014 (4) R/58/67C/LB Grange REFUSED - listed building consent for replacement of Cottage, three windows to front Thoralby 08/09/2014 : 03/11/2014 (8) R/60/30D The Forbidden full planning permission for change of use of flat racing Corner, Tupgill stables to restaurant, change of use of land for inclusion Park Estate, within visitor attraction to create car park and extend Coverham gardens, erection of single storey porch extension and two storey gable extension, and erection of roof for visitor centre (retrospective) 09/09/2014 : 04/11/2014 (8) S/01/183A Greenwell full planning permission to roof over sheep pens and Farm, Dent collecting yard 22/09/2014 : 10/11/2014 (8) S/03/110J Thorns Hall, full planning permission for siting of timber bicycle Cautley Road, storage shed Sedbergh 15/10/2014 : 18/11/2014 (5) S/03/555A/LB Nether listed building consent to replace upvc guttering with cast Bainbridge, iron guttering and down pipes Howgill Lane, Sedbergh 13/10/2014 : 14/11/2014 (4) S/03/570 Akay Lodge, full planning permission for erection of extensions to Loftus Hill, existing dwelling Sedbergh 29/09/2014 : 17/11/2014 (7)
(ii) Tree Preservation Matters This is a list of delegated decisions which Members are asked to note: Location Land adjacent to Usha Top Farm, Low Row, Swaledale - Swaledale & Arkengarthdale Conservation Area Parsonage, Crackpot - Swaledale & Arkengarthdale Conservation Area Bainside East and Friends House East, Bainbridge - Bainbridge Greets, Askrigg - Askrigg Whitefield View, Askrigg - Askrigg St Mary s Church, Arkengarthdale - Swaledale & Arkengarthdale Stockdale, Thwaite - Swaledale & Arkengarthdale Conservation Area Darley Croft, Sedbergh - Sedbergh Fell Foot, Kettlewell - Kettlewell Croft Cottage, Linton - Linton Park Bottom, Litton - Littondale The Vicarage, Dent - Dent The Old Chapel, Albert Hill, Settle - Settle Wensleydale Cottage, West Burton - West Burton Greystones, West Burton - West Burton Details No objection be raised to the removal of one sycamore tree No objection be raised to removal of one flowering cherry No objection be raised to the removal of branches from one rowan tree and one larch tree that are interfering with BT cables and roofs No objection be raised to the removal of one variegated poplar No objection be raised to the removal of one 3- stemmed sycamore, one cherry tree and the crown lift of one sycamore tree No objection be raised to removal of one ash No objection be raised to removal of one ash No objection be raised to the removal of one cypress tree No objection be raised to the removal of one leylandii No objection be raised to the removal of one silver birch tree No objection be raised to removal of one lime, one scots pine, crown raise one beech, reshape one damson tree, fell six small trees (two oak, two rowan, one beech and one unidentified tree) No objection be raised to crown clean and re shape one sycamore with a maximum crown reduction of up to 15% No objection be raised to the removal of one sycamore and two cypress trees No objection be raised to the crown reduction of one walnut tree No objection be raised to the felling of one grey cedar and one maple, crown thinning of two maples and the veteran tree management of three ash trees