Technical Report TROPICAL ECOSYSTEMS hub Drivers of change in the Torres Strait region: status and trends Butler, J.R.A., Bohensky, E., Skewes, T., Maru, Y., Busilacchi, S., Rochester, W., Katzfey, J. and Wise, R.M.
Drivers of change in the Torres Strait region: status and trends Project 11.1 Building Resilient Communities for Torres Strait Futures Butler, J.R.A., 1 Bohensky, E., 2 Skewes, T., 3 Maru, Y., 4 Busilacchi, S., 2 Rochester, W., 3 Katzfey, J., 5 Wise, R.M. 6 1 CSIRO Land and Water Flagship, Ecosciences Precinct, Brisbane 2 CSIRO Land and Water Flagship, ATSIP, James Cook University, Townsville 3 CSIRO Oceans and Atmosphere Flagship, Ecosciences Precinct, Brisbane 4 CSIRO Land and Water Flagship, Desert Knowledge Precinct, Alice Springs 5 CSIRO Oceans and Atmosphere Flagship, Aspendale, Victoria 6 CSIRO Land and Water Flagship, Blackmountain, Canberra December 2014 Supported by the Australian Government s National Environmental Research Program
ii
iv
Participatory scenario planning Cross-scale integration Community stakeholders Torres Strait stakeholders Government stakeholders Communities and livelihoods Well-being Resilience Drivers of change Population Economy Climate change Adaptation strategies Ecosystem goods and services Agriculture Fisheries Freshwater Biodiversity and ecosystems Terrestrial Freshwater Marine Adaptive co-management Outputs Outcomes Impacts
Driver of change Indicator Regional trend Torres Strait Islands trend Western Province PNG trend Climate change Annual surface temperature Annual rainfall Sea level rise Economic and social development Employment, education, health Human Development Index Oil, gas and mining NA Logging and infrastructure NA Shipping Population change Population Island population densities vi
1
2
Participatory scenario planning Cross-scale integration Community stakeholders Torres Strait stakeholders Government stakeholders Communities and livelihoods Well-being Resilience Drivers of change Population Economy Climate change Adaptation strategies Ecosystem goods and services Agriculture Fisheries Freshwater Biodiversity and ecosystems Terrestrial Freshwater Marine Adaptive co-management Outputs Outcomes Impacts 3
2011-12 2012-13 2013-14 2014-15 Climate projection downscaling 8 km projections Ecosystem services ADWIM modelling ADWIM ADWIM Drivers of change Regional scenario planning Case studies Adaptation strategies Drivers of change Community scenario planning Adaptation strategies Resilience assessment Resilience assessment Comparison and evaluation of adaptation strategies Drivers of change Resilience assessment Resilience assessment Adaptive co-management evaluation 4
5
- - - - - - 6
A2 scenario 2055 2090 Temperature ( C) +1.3 +2.5 Apparent temperature ( C) +2.2 +4.8 Rainfall (%) +3.4-2.9 Relative humidity (% humidity) +0.5 +0.6 Wind speed (%) -2.2-3.5 7
8
9
10 1990 2055 2090
11
12
13
14
Employment 2006 Living in the Torres Strait Indigenous Region Torres Strait Islander People Balance in Queensland Balance or all Australia Indigenous All Australia Non-Indigenous Australia % adults (15-64 years) employed 69 51 55 48 % adults (15-64 years) unemployed 8 9 % adults (15-64 years) not in labour force 37 43 % of employed in CDEP 52 Labour force participation rate 72 63 57 76 Unemployment rate 5 12 Income 2006 Gross weekly household income up to $515 (lowest 2 quintiles) Gross weekly household income at least $1,078 (highest quintile) Torres Strait Islander People Balance in Queensland Living in the Torres Strait Indigenous Region Balance in Australia Indigenous All in Australia 79% 65% 65% 70% 2% 6% 8% 15
Education indicators % adults (15 years and over) completed year 12 % adults (15 years and over) completed year 12 % adults (15 years and over) non-school qualification % adults (25-64) non-school qualification % adults (25-64) non-school qualification Cert III or higher % adults (25-64) non-school qualification % adults (25-64) non-school qualification Cert III or higher % adults (15 years and over) highest- Bachelor degree Year Torres Strait Islander People Living in the Torres Strait Indigenous Queensland Australia Region All Australia Indigenous All Australia 2006 38 35 25 22 2008 36 22 2006 18 15 15 23 2002 33 2002 19 2008 49 2008 36 2006 3 16
Education indicators Year 2001 2006 Torres Strait adults (15 years old and over) who completed year 12 or equivalent (%) 27.4 32.2 Torres Strait aged 25-64 with a non-school qualification (%) 21.8 28.5 Torres Strait aged 25-64 with a bachelor degree or higher (%) 3.6 4.7 Disability or long-term health condition Age group (years) Cases Proportion (%) 15 24 3,367 32.9 25 34 3,615 44.0 35 44 2,839 41.4 45 54 2,508 64.2 55 64 1,656 69.7 65 and over 1,833 92.3 Number Proportion (%) Excellent/ very Excellent/ very Age group (years) good Good Fair/poor good Good Fair/poor 15 34 years 10,375 6,206 1,856 56.3 33.7 10.1 35 years and over 4,327 5,790 5,008 28.6 38.3 33.1 Total 14,702 11,997 6,864 43.8 35.7 20.5 17
Proportion (%) Torres Strait Indigenous Region Balance of Australia Happy all/most of the time 84.2 70.2 Full of life all/most of the time 75.6 55.6 Calm or peaceful all/most of the time 75.1 54.9 Had a lot of energy all/most of the time 62.3 49.2 Indicator (unit) 1980 2000 2001 2005 Trend PNG (2005) Life expectancy (years) 46.2 (M) 49.5 (F) 54.0 (M) 54.7 (F) Fertility rate (births per female) 5.6 Infant mortality rate (deaths per 1000 live births) 92 (M) 73 (F) 68 (M) 64 (F) Childhood malnutrition (% children < 5 years) 1.3 3.9 1.8 Malaria (% population treated) 47 36 28 Pneumonia (% deaths of children < 5 years) 4.8 2.0 Outreach clinics (per 1,000 children < 5 years) 15.5 23.2 Triple Antigen Immunisation (% children < 1 year) 49 77 18
Percentage of households 100 80 Daru 100 80 Mabudauan Electricity Piped water Modern house 60 60 40 40 20 20 0 1995 2012/2013 0 1995 2012/2013 54 19 17 9 excellent good fair poor 19
20
HDI standard of living Education Index Australian non-indigenous Australia Indigenous TS region non Indigenous TS region Indigenous Life expectancy at birth (LE) 0 0.5 1 1.5. Indigenous Non- Indigenous Area HDI HDI Gap Australia 0.735 0.965 0.230 Torres Strait Indigenous Region 0.736 1.010 0.274 21
High HDI Norway (1) 0.943 Australia (2) 0.929 Torres Strait (73) 0.736 Afghanistan (172) 0.398 Western Province PNG (188) 0.260 Low HDI 22
Existing developments Province Development Start End Shareholders Infrastructure References Ok Tedi Western Copper, gold 1984 Porgera Gold 1991 Kutubu/Gobe Moran Oil 1992 - Planned developments LNG PNG Southern Highlands; Western 2013 to 2022 2015 to 2023 LNG 2014 2042 Gulf LNG Gulf LNG 2014 - LNG consortium Western LNG 2014 - Mt Kare Enga Gold, silver Frieda River Sepik Gold, copper Purari River Gulf Hydroelectricity Feasibility study started 2011 Feasibility study started in 2010 MoC signed recently - - - Ok Tedi Mining PNG Government Inmet Ltd. Barrick Gold Oil Search Ltd. ExxonMobile Merlin PNG Government BP, Chevron ExxonMobile Oil Search Ltd. PNG Government Santos Ltd. Nippon Oil Exploration Petromin Mineral Resources Development Company InterOil Petromin Horizon Oil Talisman Energy Eaglewood Energy Indochine Mining Ltd. Xstrata Highlands Pacific PNG Energy Development Ltd. OriginEnergy Ltd. Kumul export terminal Underground pipelines to Kumul Gas conditioning plants Underground pipelines to the coast LNG facility near Port Moresby Underground pipelines to the coast Floating LNG facility LNG refinery near Port Moresby Underground pipelines to the coast Gas facility in Daru Deep water port in Daru Commercial centre in Oriomo Infrastructure corridor from Kiunga to Nomad and Balimo to the coast in Oriomo Due to its position close to the Porgera mine it can replace it in the economic and ecological scenario of local populations once its operations will end Shareholders envisage replacing the Ok Tedi mine once its operation will end by providing economic benefits, infrastructures, and services to highland communities Undersea transmission cable to Daru and then to North Queensland. The project is planned to provide electricity to the area around Daru. Swales 2001; Smith 1990 Jackson and Banks 2002; Gilberthorpe and Banks 2011 Owen and Latimore 1998 Dixon et al. 2010; McIlraith 2011 Price 2012; InterOil Corporation 2010 Price 2012; PNGSDP 2009a, 2010 Indochine 2012 Xstrata 2010 OriginEnergy 2012 23
24
Province Forest area Concession size (ha) Western Wipim Tapila 244,000 Western Kiunga to Aimbak Not available Western Wawoi Guavi 448,300 Concession Permit holder Details References 1996 Forest Management Services Ltd. (PNG) No proper FMA; the project was originally based on a Timber Permit for road construction. In 2003 the project was halted by courts Timber Permit in 1992 with extension in 2002 Concord Pacific (Samling) Rimbunan Haijau (Malaysia) WWF is planning to assist in the establishment of a Forest Stewardship Council certified forestry project Logging road with substantial log export. A review found that the project was in breach of both the National Forest Policy and the Forestry Act A review found faults in the engagement process with landowners, in the application of legal requirements for sustainability, and in the application of a legal process WWF 2008; Forest Trends 2006 Rogers 2008; Forest Trends 2006 Rogers 2008; Forest Trends 2006 Western Makapa 301,500 Timber Permit in 1991 and extended in 2003 Innovision Forest Trends 2006 Western East Awin 184,000 Timber Permit in 2003 CS Bos Ltd (Malaysia) The permit was nullified by courts in 2004 but logging activities have continued Forest Trends 2006 Western Semabo 54,000 The project had not started by 2006 Forest Trends 2006 Gulf Vailala Blocks 2/3 268,000 Timber Permit in 1992 with extension in 2002 Rimbunan Haijau (Malaysia) Timber Permits were found to be unlawful but logging activities have continued Forest Trends 2006 Gulf Vailala Block 1 113,400 Timber Permit in 1991 with extension in 2003 Rimbunan Haijau (Malaysia) Forest Trends 2006 25
Province Forest area Concession size (ha) Western Kamula Doso 790,000 Southern Highlands Western Southern Highlands East Pangia 98,750 Kiunga to Nomad Hekiko 199,000 Gulf Hekiko 196,000 Concession Permit holder Details References 1998, declared invalid in 2010. The area is still to be given a concession. There is dispute between the aim for an agroforestry versus a conventional logging project. An earlier carbon trading scheme was ruled out. In 2001 a Timber Permit was ready to be signed by landowners In 2001 a project agreement was nearing completion. The concession has passed from proposed to active. In 2001 a project agreement was concluded but has not progressed. Rimbunan Haijau (Malaysia) - proposed Yeung Group Ltd. - proposed Logging road which would become part of the Trans Papua Road. This is being assessed by the PNG Department of Environment and Conservation Filer 2012; Filer et al. 2012; Forest Trends 2006 Rogers 2008 Rogers 2008 Rogers 2008; Forest Trends 2006 Rogers 2008; Forest Trends 2006 Gulf Vailala (Meporo) 79,000 In 2000 the project was in its very early stages. Rimbunan Haijau (Malaysia) Forest Trends 2006 26
27
3500 3000 No. of Voyages 2500 2000 1500 1000 500 0 1997/1998 1998/1999 1999/2000 2000/2001 2001/2002 2002/2003 2003/2004 2004/2005 2005/2006 2006/2007 2007/2008 2008/2009 Financial Years No. of Voyages No. of ships Trend in voyages Trend in ships 28
75 and over 70 74 65 69 60 64 55 59 50 54 45 49 40 44 35 39 30 34 25 29 20 24 15 19 10 14 5 9 0 4 Torres Strait Islander Non-Indigenous 15 10 5 0 5 10 15 29
Badu Island Boigu Island Erub (Darnley) Island Hammond Island Horn Island Iama (Yam) Island Mabuiag Island Mer (Murray) Island Saibai Island Warraber Island Yorke Island Ave, TS Outer Islands Persons 4000 3500 3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 500 0 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 Census Year 4% 3% 2% 1% 0% -1% -2% -3% 30
Population Persons 350 300 250 200 150 100 50 0 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 Census Year 14000 12000 10000 8000 7700 7490 10,667 6000 4000 2000 0 Year Low projection Medium projection High projection 31
600000 550000 500000 450000 Census data Low projection Medium projection High projection 400000 Population 350000 300000 250000 200000 150000 100000 50000 0 1980 1990 2000 2010 2020 2030 2040 2050 Year 32
70000 60000 50000 Census data Low projection Medium projection High projection Population 40000 30000 20000 10000 Daru 0 2000 2010 2020 2030 2040 2050 Year 33
Island Area (km 2 ) Population (2000) Density (people/km 2 ) Badu (Australia) 101.7 879 8.6 Boigu (Australia) 72.8 233 3.2 Dauan (Australia) 3.7 164 44.1 Erub (Australia) 6.0 422 70.3 Yam (Australia) 1.7 357 210.0 Kubin/St. Paul (Australia) 175.4 494 2.8 Mabuiag (Australia) 6.4 292 45.6 Masig (Australia) 1.6 265 165.6 Mer (Australia) 4.3 411 95.6 Poruma (Australia) 0.4 194 521.8 Saibai (Australia) 103.7 539 5.2 Ugar (Australia) 0.4 85 229.3 Warraber (Australia) 0.7 282 402.9 Parama (PNG) 8.0 1,100 137.5 Daru (PNG) 14.1 18,150 1,287.2 34
Driver of change Indicator Regional trend Torres Strait Islands trend Western Province PNG trend Climate change Annual surface temperature Annual rainfall Sea level rise Economic and social development Employment, education, health Human Development Index Oil, gas and mining NA Logging and infrastructure NA Shipping Population change Population Island population densities 35
36
37
38
39