Nova Scotia Political Donations 2010

First off, let s be clear that in Nova Scotia you can claim a tax credit equal to 75% of the contributions you made to recognized Nova Scotia political parties or to candidates seeking election in the Nova Scotia House of Assembly. The maximum credit is $750. Essentially, this means that the government reimburses you for 75% of any contribution up to $1000. So you can give the Greens $1000 and it only costs you $250 as long as your tax bill is more than $750. Imagine if that was the case in the US.. The eligibility rules for making political contributions changed in Nova Scotia effective January 21, 2010. As of that date, contributions to recognized parties, electoral district associations and candidates by corporations, partnerships and trade-unions are prohibited, leaving only individuals resident in Nova Scotia eligible to make political contributions. The annual contribution limit of $5000.00 remains unchanged. How s this all going? Today we learn that a single donor has given nearly $35 million to Political Action Committees in the US. That sum would fund the next 40 years of political contributions in Nova Scotia, and on that basis alone we can be reasonably pleased that money plays such a small role in Nova Scotia politics. Our majority government received less than half of all donations at the last election. Although the Liberals are a distant third in fundraising, it s clear that fundraising among Conservatives is robust. The Basics Donations Party Donors Percent of donors Total Percent of dollars Average NDP 1534 49.6% $400,697.00 49.1% $ 261.21 Liberal 350 11.3% $99,778.00 12.2% $ 285.08 Conservative 1199 38.8% $314,273.54 38.5% $ 262.11 Atlantica 3 0.1% $1,205.71 0.1% $ 401.90 Green 4 0.1% $720.00 0.1% $ 180.00 ALL 3090 $816,674.25 $ 264.30 Page 1

Public Funding Nova Scotia Political Donations 2010 Registered parties receive public funding under Section 191 of the Elections Act. The amount of funding each party receives is determined by a formula involving an amount for each vote received by candidates representing the particular party in the most recent general election. And as of this year, public funding looks like this: Recognized Party Name Fiscal Year2006-2011* Fiscal Year2012/2013* Funding to Date Green Party of Nova Scotia $343,894.62 $7,577.94 $351,472.56 Nova Scotia Liberal Party $975,959.27 $88,204.87 $1,064,164.14 Nova Scotia New Democratic Party $1,395,272.20 $146,711.37 $1,541,983.57 The Progressive Conservative Association of Nova Scotia $1,152,618.17 $79,588.06 $1,232,206.23 Totals $3,867,744.26 $322,082.24 $4,189,826.50 Third Party Advertising Expenses The new Act (May 19, 2011) requires that any third party that has spent $500 in election advertising must register with the Chief Electoral Officer. They cannot register before an election has been called. They also must not spend more than $10,000 during a general election. All registered third parties must file a report with the Chief Electoral Officer with details of election advertising expenses. The Chief Electoral Officer must publish this report along with the names and addresses of registered third parties. Only the Cape Breton by-election of June 21, 2011 has fallen under this rule, and no third party involvement is reported The Atlantica party was de-certified in June, 2012. For purposes of the following analysis of donations in 2010, it and the Green Party are ignored because the number of donors is so tiny. Page 2

Cumulative Nova Scotia Political Donations 2010 Stratification of Donations Here is the best evidence that support for the three major parties is well distributed among the populace. Regardless of the total raised, the profile of donors is very almost eerily similar. 100% Cumulative Donor %s by size of donation 90% 80% 70% 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 19 21 23 24 25 29 41 50 Donation in Hundreds NDP Liberal Conservative Page 3

As you can see small donations are the largest source of funds for each party. All parties receive the benefit of the 75% deduction of gifts up to $1000 the best return on investment for generous donors. $80,000 Dollars raised by size of donation $70,000 $60,000 $50,000 $40,000 $30,000 NDP Liberal Conservative $20,000 $10,000 $0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 19 21 23 24 25 29 41 50 Donation in hundreds Page 4

Geography Nova Scotia Political Donations 2010 There is some evidence of regional difference you will need to draw your own conclusions. It is interesting to note that only 4 individuals account for Hammonds Plains high ranking among Liberal sources. Top Ten Sources of Donations NDP $ 234,913.92 59% Halifax 461 $ 124,554.54 Dartmouth 187 $ 45,145.77 Wolfville 53 $ 13,238.27 Antigonish 30 $ 10,925.81 Sydney 46 $ 9,151.25 Lower Sackville 41 $ 8,153.80 Truro 33 $ 7,571.50 Glace Bay 18 $ 5,950.74 New Glasgow 12 $ 5,148.10 Lunenburg 17 $ 5,074.14 Liberals $ 65,535.00 66% Halifax 88 $ 31,716.00 Dartmouth 47 $ 11,832.00 Hammonds Plains 4 $ 6,050.00 Bedford 11 $ 3,904.00 Pictou 20 $ 3,879.00 Arichat 8 $ 2,450.00 Yarmouth 7 $ 2,050.00 West Arichat 3 $ 1,450.00 Sydney 3 $ 1,104.00 Annapolis Royal 2 $ 1,100.00 Conservative $ 198,876.54 63% Halifax 242 $ 99,185.27 Dartmouth 109 $ 29,210.60 Truro 81 $ 26,172.87 Bedford 30 $ 10,274.00 Sydney 26 $ 7,786.80 Kentville 34 $ 6,390.00 Amherst 33 $ 5,590.00 North Sydney 15 $ 4,905.00 Page 5

Antigonish 18 $ 4,752.00 Hammonds Plains 10 $ 4,610.00 Donors of $1000 or more A few more generous Conservatives raise the total a bit, but this only reinforces the impression that the NDP is a popular party. 81 Conservatives contributed $ 86,670.00 Last First Street City Code Amount 510-2677 Gladstone Street Halifax B3K 0A3 $ 2,304.00 Henderson David L. Machum, D. Q.C. Geoffrey 900-1959 Upper Water St Halifax B3J 2X2 $ 1,850.00 Creelman Doug 24 Wilson Drive Fall River B2T 1V8 $ 1,500.00 Merchant Robert 6033 Fernwood Lane Halifax B3H 0A5 $ 1,400.00 Postill David 162Cresthaven Dr Halifax B3M 4B9 $ 1,400.00 Chipman J.L. 29 Andrew Cobb Court Bedford B4A 4J9 $ 1,300.00 George T.H. 202-1540 Summer St Halifax B3H 4R9 $ 1,300.00 Cooper Galbraith Anne 10 Shamrock Dr Dartmouth B3A 2Y7 $ 1,300.00 Cuthbertson Brian 6464 Waegwoltic Ave Halifax B3H 2B4 $ 1,250.00 Chisholm Robert J. 47 Victoria Street Antigonish B2G 1X2 $ 1,200.00 d'entremont Chris Box 92, RR 3 Tusket BOW 3M0 $ 1,200.00 Guinan John 18 Tulip Place Truro B2N 5Y6 $ 1,150.00 Bain Keith L. 1551 Old Route 5 Big Bras d'or B1X1B5 $ 1,120.00 MacLeod Alfie 780 Fourchu Rd Gabarus Lake B1K2C6 $ 1,120.00 Muir Jamie 65 Smith Ave Truro B2N 1C5 $ 1,100.00 Haynes Kathryn 1560 Larch Street Halifax B3H 3W8 $ 1,056.00 Haynes Ross H. 1560 Larch Street Halifax B3H 3W8 $ 1,056.00 Marjorie A. 602-2717 Gladstone St. Halifax B3K 0A4 $ 1,054.00 Hodgson Hunt Jeffrey 31 Edgehill Dr Truro B6L 3K4 $ 1,010.00 Andrews Harriet 312 Seaview Drive North Sydney B2A 3P1 $ 1,000.00 Batherson Robert K. 3188 Mayfield Ave Halifax B3L 4V2 $ 1,000.00 Boyd Peter 41 Forest Road Dartmouth B3A 2M4 $ 1,000.00 Chernin Martin I. 16 Whitney Ave Sydney B1P4Z7 $ 1,000.00 Page 6

Clarke Doug 114 Greenside Lane Hammonds Plains B4B 2A1 $ 1,000.00 Curwin Gregg 54 Doull Avenue Halifax B3N 1Y7 $ 1,000.00 Curwin Tracy 54 Doull Avenue Halifax B3N 1Y7 $ 1,000.00 Demone Henry 70TupperSt, PO Box 148 Lunenburg B0J 2C0 $ 1,000.00 Densmore Bruce 18 Devonport Ave Fall River B2T 1A4 $ 1,000.00 Dexter Robert 202-2000 Barrington St. Halifax B3J 3K1 $ 1,000.00 Donahoe Arthur R. 13-6770 Jubilee Rd. Halifax B3H 2H8 $ 1,000.00 Fares Wadih 18 Broadholme Lane Halifax B3N 3B7 $ 1,000.00 Foran Michael 510 Young Ave Halifax B3H 2V3 $ 1,000.00 Forbes Jeff 450 Thompson Run Hammonds Plains B4B 1W8 $ 1,000.00 Galbraith Grant 10 Shamrock Dr Dartmouth B3A 2Y7 $ 1,000.00 Garson Craig 785 Young Ave Halifax B3H 2V8 $ 1,000.00 Himsl Mary 5575 Stoneham Court Halifax B3K 4A7 $ 1,000.00 Hughes Paul 351 Prospect Ave Kentville B4N 5R5 $ 1,000.00 Kelderman Dianne 10 East Mount Court, RR#2 Truro B2N 5B1 $ 1,000.00 Kontak Michael A. 6146 Pepperell Street Halifax B3H 2N9 $ 1,000.00 LaFlamme Jean 28 Diana Grace Avenue Dartmouth B2W 6A2 $ 1,000.00 Lamey Christina 1541 LeMerchant Street Halifax B3H 3R2 $ 1,000.00 MacGregor Cathy 16Stockleigh PI Halifax B3M 4K4 $ 1,000.00 Machum Grant 1959 Upperwater Street Halifax B3J 2X2 $ 1,000.00 Machum Kimberley 885 Marlborough Woods Halifax B3H 1H9 $ 1,000.00 MacKenzie Jacquelin e 6162 Oakland Road Halifax B3H 1P2 $ 1,000.00 MacQuarrie Charles 10 Hampton Way Truro B2N 6P5 $ 1,000.00 MacQuarrie Malcolm 79 Exhibition St Truro B2N 4C8 $ 1,000.00 Mattocks Kathy 23 Hillcrest Street Truro B2N 3M4 $ 1,000.00 McCrea Joanne 955 Bellevue Avenue Halifax B3H 3L8 $ 1,000.00 McCrea Kimberly 1039 Marlborough Avenue Halifax B3H 3H2 $ 1,000.00 McCrea Scott 1039 Marlborough Avenue Halifax B3H 3H2 $ 1,000.00 Melvin James 28 Ravine Park Crescent Halifax B3M4N1 $ 1,000.00 Mills James 204-1479 Lower Water St Halifax B3J 3Z3 $ 1,000.00 Moffatt Douglas 36 Whitman Court Truro B2N 3G3 $ 1,000.00 Moffatt Garfield 116 Park St Truro B2N 3J3 $ 1,000.00 Moore Joseph 1101-1470 Summer Street Halifax B3H 3A3 $ 1,000.00 Mussett Robert 7 Rockwood Ave Halifax B3N 1X4 $ 1,000.00 Page 7

O'Connor Diane 62 Wedgewood Ave Halifax B3M 2B5 $ 1,000.00 O'Connor Sean 62 Wedgewood Ave Halifax B3M 2B5 $ 1,000.00 Otto Phil 589 Westpoint Drive Lucasville B4B 1X8 $ 1,000.00 Phinney Bruce 25 Wedgewood Ave Halifax B3M 2B2 $ 1,000.00 Power Michael K. 9 Olympiad Ave Bridgewater B4V 3S5 $ 1,000.00 Reid Debbie 72 Braemar Drive Sydney B1R1V9 $ 1,000.00 Reid Douglas W. 951 Ivanhoe Street Halifax B3H 2X2 $ 1,000.00 Ritchie J. William 926 Marlborough Avenue Halifax B3H 3G8 $ 1,000.00 Ritchie James 35 Shore Road Herring Cove B3V1G7 $ 1,000.00 Ritchie Jenipher General Delivery Sandy Cove B0V 1E0 $ 1,000.00 Ritchie Lorna 926 Marlborough Ave. Halifax B3H 3G8 $ 1,000.00 Rovers Leo A. RR2 Stewiacke BON 2J0 $ 1,000.00 Shupe Gordon 26 Centre Street Bedford B4A 2B2 $ 1,000.00 Smith Peter R. PO Box 114 Lunenburg B0J 2C0 $ 1,000.00 Sobey Rob 11 Birchill Drive Stellarton B0K1S0 $ 1,000.00 Spatz Josef 346-1475 Lower Water Street Halifax B3J 3Z2 $ 1,000.00 Stanish William 311-5595 Fenwick Street Halifax B3H 4M2 $ 1,000.00 Steele H. R. 745 Windmill Road Dartmouth B3B 1C2 $ 1,000.00 Stegemann Barb 6 Carriageway Court Bedford B4A 3V4 $ 1,000.00 Stoddart Kevin 186SkyeCres Hammonds Plains B4B 1W8 $ 1,000.00 Stonehouse Grant 2 Blue Heron Lane Tantallon B3Z 2K5 $ 1,000.00 Surrette Mark 200 Parklea Drive Head of St. Margarets Bay B3Z 2G5 $ 1,000.00 Wilson Ian 6129 Jubilee Road Halifax B3H 2E8 $ 1,000.00 Zed Robert 6151 Oakland Road Halifax B3H 1P3 $ 1,000.00 12 Liberals contributed $ 16,847.00 Last First Street City Code Amount Covert Peter 5 Lakshore Dr. Hammonds Plains B4B 1S6 $ 5,000.00 Gillis John 2025 North Park Street Halifax B3K4B2 $ 1,450.00 Boudrot Jason 1448 Highway 206 West Arichat B0E 3J0 $ 1,250.00 709-5959 Spring Garden Rd. Halifax B3H 1Y5 $ 1,147.00 Clancy Mary Dares Gil 12 Vancouver St. Yarmouth B5A 2N8 $ 1,000.00 Delva Nicholas 1170 Rockcliffe Street Halifax B3H 3Y6 $ 1,000.00 Fiske Jock 3141 Ashburn Ave. Halifax B3L 4B8 $ 1,000.00 Page 8

Fiske John 7062 Royal Pine Ave. Halifax B3L2G1 $ 1,000.00 Gillis Jennifer 2025 North Park St. Halifax B3K4B2 $ 1,000.00 Halyk Russell 3 Palisade Place Halifax B3M 2Y7 $ 1,000.00 Smithers Fred P.O. Box 884 Dartmouth B2Y 3Z5 $ 1,000.00 VanZoost Jan 22 Alden Hubley Drive, RR1 Annapolis Royal BOS 1A0 $ 1,000.00 61 NDP contributed $ 78,745.84 Last First Street City Code Amount Steele Graham 16 Kelvin Grove Halifax B3M 3Y9 $ 4,112.00 More Marilyn 202-162 Ochterloney St Dartmouth B2Y 4X3 $ 2,932.00 Chisholm John c/o Nova Construction Co Ltd Antigonish B2G 2L7 $ 2,500.00 Parker Charlie 1360 Lochbroom Rd Westville B0K 2A0 $ 2,408.50 Cartmill Charles 6634 South St Halifax B3H 1V2 $ 2,137.00 MacDonell John 729 Renfrew Rd Enfield B2T 1H9 $ 2,117.00 McDonough Alexa 402V-1544 Summer St Halifax B3H 4S1 $ 1,908.75 Mahon Peggy 2208 Sherbrooke Rd New Glasgow B2H 5C8 $ 1,674.10 Whynott Mathew 6 Tenth St Hammonds Plains B4B 1R6 $ 1,618.58 Birdsall Pamela 590 Main St Mahone Bay B0J 2E0 $ 1,540.33 Jennex Ramona 2687 Poplar Dr Coldbrook B4R 1A9 $ 1,518.58 Martin Shauna 1346 Birmingham St Halifax B3J 2J2 $ 1,390.25 MacDonald Maureen 5525 Cabot PI Halifax B3K 2J6 $ 1,345.34 Dexter Darrell 43 Stuart Harris Dr Dartmouth B2W 3Z4 $ 1,325.00 O'Connor Dan 6298 Duncan St Halifax B3L 1K3 $ 1,305.00 Ramey Gary 67 Catidian PI Hebbville B4V 7A7 $ 1,243.50 Corbett Frank 2351 Lingan Rd Lingan B1H5H5 $ 1,221.83 Jessome Joan 60 Piggot Ave Fall River B2T 1S6 $ 1,221.75 Prest Sidney 4005 Mooseland Rd Mooseland B0J 2J0 $ 1,218.58 Wright David 510-53 Bedros Lane Halifax B3M 4X4 $ 1,200.00 Sutcliffe Janet 30 Tall Trees Crt Mineville B2Z 1K2 $ 1,180.00 Conrad Vicki 339 East Rd Mill Village B0J 2H0 $ 1,176.75 Lamey Joanne 35 Birchwood Terr Dartmouth B3A 3W4 $ 1,158.50 MacKenzie David 60 Theakston Ave Halifax B3P 2S8 $ 1,153.50 Boudreau Jim 62 Williams Point Rd Antigonish B2G 2L4 $ 1,151.90 Landry Barbara 11 Fairway Dr New Glasgow B2H 0A5 $ 1,140.00 Leslie Megan 2658 Belle Aire Terr Halifax B3K 3W8 $ 1,125.08 Newcombe Cheryl 38 Community Centre Windsor B2T1W6 $ 1,125.00 Page 9

Lane Junction Campbell Myrtle 1354 Main St Glace Bay B1A5A7 $ 1,106.75 Black Paul 16 Murray Hill Dr Dartmouth B2Y 3A7 $ 1,101.84 Milburn Douglas 141 ShandwickSt Sydney B1P4V7 $ 1,100.00 Kent Rebecca 50 Wentworth Cir Eastern Passage B3G 1G1 $ 1,093.50 Wallbridge David 2460 Harvard St Halifax B3L 2T1 $ 1,070.27 MacKinnon Clarrie 2326 Cowan St Westville B0K 2A0 $ 1,040.25 Landry Dianne 36 Oceanglen Lane Pictou B0K1HO $ 1,025.00 Brodie Judy 316 Kennedys Rd Boutiliers Point B3Z 1V7 $ 1,022.50 Skabar Brian 8 Regent St Amherst B4H 1P9 $ 1,021.83 Gay Ruth 8 Elizabeth St Glace Bay B1A6J9 $ 1,010.00 Dickinson Bruce 227 Forest Dr New Germany B0R1E0 $ 1,005.00 Christie Marion 45 George St Lower Sackville B4C 2M7 $ 1,000.08 Conrad C Scott 339 East Rd Mill Village B0J 2H0 $ 1,000.00 Dutton Lucia 201-35 Evans Ave Halifax B3M 1C3 $ 1,000.00 Freeman H. Charles 290 Laurie Wamboldt Rd Greenfield B0T 1E0 $ 1,000.00 Haase Florence 2812 Hwy 3 Chester B0J 1J0 $ 1,000.00 Hartigan Carl PO Box 1191 Stn Main Antigonish B2G 2L6 $ 1,000.00 Joyce Freda 17 Diamond St Trenton B0K 1X2 $ 1,000.00 Joyce Andrew 17 Diamond St Trenton B0K 1X2 $ 1,000.00 Landry P. Ross 36 Oceanglen Lane Pictou B0K1HO $ 1,000.00 Lee Nanci 5516FaklandSt Halifax B3K 1A3 $ 1,000.00 MacDonald Colin 1414 Thornvale Ave Halifax B3H 4C2 $ 1,000.00 Miller Russell 227 Forest Dr New Germany B0R1E0 $ 1,000.00 Milne Judi 41 Hillside Dr Conquerall Bank B4V0H1 $ 1,000.00 Newcombe Roy 38 Community Centre Lane Windsor Junction B2T1W6 $ 1,000.00 Pratt Mary 41 Hillside Dr Conquerall Bank B4V0H1 $ 1,000.00 Roblee Elta 409 Main St Milton B0T 1P0 $ 1,000.00 Savege A C Bryan 2-209 Water St Shelburne B0T1W0 $ 1,000.00 Smith Linda 2024 Elm St Halifax B3L 2Y3 $ 1,000.00 Smith James 2024 Elm St Halifax B3L 2Y3 $ 1,000.00 Sutcliffe Gregory 30 Tall Trees Crt Mineville B2Z 1K2 $ 1,000.00 Van Zoost Donald 158-3 Queen St Bridgewater B4V 1P6 $ 1,000.00 Young Donna 212 Green St Lunenburg B0J 2C0 $ 1,000.00 Page 10

Map You can look at this map interactively. There is an icon for each donation, and clicking on the icon gives information about the donor. Large icons represent donations of $1000 and over. Icons are color-coded to their parties. Some icons are slightly misplaced Google doesn t understand PO Boxes or RR #s. On the whole. locations are pretty accurate. Even as a static document, the map shows political donation to be a phenomenon of towns and cities. Page 11

Finally, here are snapshots of the map for each of the major parties alone. These are for first impressions only. Most of the icons are hidden and the scale is very small. NDP Page 12

Liberal Conservative Page 13