MEETING MINUTES WHATCOM COUNTY PARKS AND RECREATION COMMISSION January 17, 2013 Bellingham Senior Activity Center 315 Halleck St. Bellingham, WA 98225

Similar documents
Present: Commissioners: Gordon Rogers, Paul Woodcock, Jeffrey Margolis, Janet Boyhan and Kenn Kiesner

DRAFT MEETING MINUTES WHATCOM COUNTY PARKS & RECREATION COMMISSION Thursday, September 15, 2016

MEETING MINUTES WHATCOM COUNTY PARKS & RECREATION COMMISSION Thursday, April 16, Silver Lake Park 9006 Silver Lake Road Maple Falls, Washington

Committee Report. Community Development Committee For the Metropolitan Council meeting of August 12, Business Item No.

Business Item No XXX. Proposed Action That the Metropolitan Council approve the Coon Creek Regional Trail Master Plan.

Dakota County Planning Commission Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes Date: May 23, 2017 Time: 6:00 p.m. to 8:30 p.m.

AGENDA REGULAR PARKS COMMISSION MEETING May 26, :15 A.M Monticello Public Works Office

Whatcom County Parks & Recreation DRAFT 02/07/14

SUBJECT: Business Plan Update for Reid Hillview and San Martin Airports

Whatcom County Parks & Recreation Updated 01/11/16

National Scenic Byways Program US Department of Transportation

JUAN DE FUCA ELECTORAL AREA PARKS AND RECREATION ADVISORY COMMISSION. Notice of Meeting on Tuesday, June 26, 2018 at 3 p.m.

PURPOSE AND NEED. Introduction

TRUCKEE TAHOE AIRPORT DISTRICT BOARD OF DIRECTOR STAFF REPORT

AGENDA. 6:15 PM Monday, October 24, 2016 PenMet Parks Sehmel Homestead Park Volunteer Vern Pavilion th Avenue NW Gig Harbor, WA 98332

MINUTES ALTA TOWN COUNCIL MEETING JANUARY 8, 2015 ALTA COMMUNITY CENTER ALTA, UTAH

Understanding the caring capacity of the visitor experience Provide facilities to support a high level user experience Address visual quality through

OWOSSO. Parks & Recreation Commission. Regular Meeting 6:00pm Monday, June 22, 2015 City Council Chambers Owosso City Hall

CITY OF MERCED RECREATION AND PARKS COMMISSION MERCED CIVIC CENTER 678 West 18 th Street Merced, California. MINUTES Meeting of February 26, 2007

CONSERVATION COMMISSION MEETING Thursday, July 19, :00 PM City Hall, Council Chambers, Claremont, NH. MINUTES Approved 8/16/2018

FOREST PRESERVE COMMISSION AGENDA 10/16/18 at 5:30 PM* rd Avenue, Rock Island, IL County Building 3 rd Floor

MEETING OF THE METROPOLITAN PARKS AND OPEN SPACE COMMISSION Tuesday, April 4, 2017

COOS COUNTY AIRPORT DISTRICT REGULAR BOARD MEETING Thursday August 20, 2015

CITY OF NEW HOPE 4401 XYLON AVENUE NORTH NEW HOPE, MINNESOTA Chair Wills called the meeting to order at 7 p.m.

Proposal to Redevelop Lower Kananaskis River-Barrier Lake. Bow Valley Provincial Park. Frequently Asked Questions

Preferred Recreation Recommendations Stemilt-Squilchuck Recreation Plan March 2018

MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING Castle Rock Parks And Recreation Commission October 19, 2016

Final Design Approval of the Weather Shelters and Summit Stair for the Mount Umunhum Summit Project

BURLINGTON INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT BOARD OF AIRPORT COMMISSIONERS MINUTES OF MEETING September 12, 2016 APPROVED 10/14/16

WELCOME TO YOUR REGIONAL AIRPORT AUTHORITY MEETING OF THE CITY OF MERCED AGENDA

1.0 CALL TO ORDER Chair, Jeff Munger, called the meeting to order at 4:03 PM on November 15, 2017.

CHAPTER 5. Chapter 5 Recreation Element

Chapter 2: Summary of Existing Open Space System

350 COURT ST #8 FRIDAY HARBOR WA (360) fax (360) com. parks

Regular Meeting of the Parks and Recreation Commission. Proposed Minutes

WHATCOM COUNTY PLANNING & DEVELOPMENT SERVICES PERMITS RECEIVED. 12/1/2016 to 12/31/2016

EAST COCALICO TOWNSHIP BOARD OF SUPERVISORS MEETING AGENDA

Official Minutes of MARION COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS. May 8, 2018

455 N. Rexford Drive. Beverly Hills, CA Room 280-A. 2:00 p.m.

Crystal Lake Area Trails

MINUTES OF THE CITY OF WICHITA WICHITA AIRPORT ADVISORY BOARD. Monday, June 7, :00 p.m. Bill Calloway, Dorothy McKay, James Thompson

Social Services Transportation Advisory Council (SSTAC)

BOARD OF AIRPORT COMMISSIONERS

Schoolcraft Township is located in northeast Houghton County. A portion of the township borders Keweenaw County and Lake Superior.

AIRPORT COMMITTEE MEETING AGENDA September 06, :00 PM Moorhead Municipal Airport

BURLINGTON INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT BOARD OF AIRPORT COMMISSIONERS MINUTES OF MEETING May 22, 2017 APPROVED 6/28/17

PROPOSED MINUTES LAKETOWN TOWNSHIP PARKS & RECREATION COMMISSION AT TOWNSHIP HALL. October 20, 2010

THE BIG PICTURE. Week of March 4, Bring your dog. Bring your kids. Bring a picnic and spend the day with us! Free and open to the public.

BOARD OF SELECTPERSON S MEETING August 21, 2014, 6:30 p.m. Rumford Falls Auditorium

AGENDA PARKS AND RECREATION COMMISSION FESTIVAL PARK PAVILIONS WEDNESDAY, JULY 18, 2018

TOURISM & PUBLIC SERVICES RURAL SIGNAGE POLICY

PORT & HARBORS ADVISORY BOARD MEETING MINUTES DATE: 1/10/2017

Notice of Public Meeting of the DES MOINES AIRPORT AUTHORITY BOARD. Agenda

DISTRICT OF SQUAMISH

A moment of silence was taken for Trish Avery in appreciation for her service to the community.

THE BIG PICTURE. Week of March 11, City of Buda Accepting Applications For Boards and Commissions

AIRPORT COMMITTEE Thursday, May 11, :30 PM

Section II. Planning & Public Process Planning for the Baker/Carver Regional Trail began in 2010 as a City of Minnetrista initiative.

BURLINGTON INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT BOARD OF AIRPORT COMMISSIONERS MINUTES OF MEETING April 30, Bill Keogh Pat Nowak Alan Newman Jeff Schulman

EXHIBIT K TERMINAL PROJECT PROCEDURES PHASE I - DEVELOPMENT OF TERMINAL PROGRAM & ALTERNATIVES

PORT OF BELLINGHAM. Minutes MAC (MARINA ADVISORY COMMITTEE) MEETING TUESDAY, OCTOBER 9, 2012 SQUALICUM HARBOR OFFICE BELLINGHAM, WASHINGTON.

Feasibility Study Federal Inspection Service Facility at Long Beach Airport

CITY OF EAST GULL LAKE AGENDA PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION Tuesday, February 28, :30 PM

BURLINGTON INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT BOARD OF AIRPORT COMMISSIONERS MINUTES OF MEETING October 15, 2013 APPROVED 11/20/13

BURLINGTON INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT BOARD OF AIRPORT COMMISSIONERS MINUTES OF MEETING August 15, 2016 APPROVED 9/12/16. Bill Keogh Alan Newman Pat Nowak

TOWN OF WELLINGTON 3735 CLEVELAND AVENUE P.O. BOX 127 WELLINGTON, CO TOWN HALL (970) FAX (970)

MISSION TRAILS REGIONAL PARK CITIZENS ADVISORY COMMITTEE MINUTES OF THE MEETING OF MAY 3, 2016

Cabinet Member, Councillor Kerry had submitted a written report by which had been circulated to Parish Councillors.

10/25/2013. What is the SCORP?! 2013 Local Government Survey 2013 Statewide Public Survey Advisory Group Priority Areas Your Suggestions!

1.0 CALL TO ORDER Airport Commission Chair, Jeff Munger, called the meeting to order at 3:05 PM on August 21, 2017.

Canonsburg Borough Council Meeting Monday February 12, :30 PM

Location Waxhaw Community Meeting Room 209 W. S. Main Street 6:30 pm Wednesday, January 14,2105

Welcome to Seneca Lake Park & Marina Master Plan Update

Stony Creek Master Plan Public Meeting #2. May 21, 2016

January 14, Orange County Transportation Authority Attn: M2 NCCP/HCP 550 South Main Street P.O. Box Orange, CA

THE FAIRHAVEN OPTION

Welcome to Charles Mill Lake Park Master Plan Update

DISCUSSION - LOCAL LAW/GAS STATIONS/CONVENIENCE STORES. Supervisor Kelly said Town Attorney Terry Stewart was here for this discussion tonight.

Business Item No

Lena Beach Recreation Area Renovation. Dear National Forest User:

EAST PENNSBORO TOWNSHIP BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS REGULAR MEETING, APRIL 3, 2013

East Link Project Update. Maintenance of Traffic During Construction. April 21, 2015

BOONE COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION A G E N D A Tuesday, August 15, 2017 Boone County Board Room 1212 Logan Ave Belvidere IL :00 PM

Meeting Minutes SOUTHWEST FLORIDA REGION CFASPP STEERING COMMITTEE MEETING May 20, :00 PM Southwest Florida International Airport

Board Member Comments (items not on the Agenda)

Port of Friday Harbor

DALLAS PARK AND RECREATION BOARD AGENDA DALLAS CITY HALL 1500 MARILLA STREET, ROOM 6FN DALLAS, TEXAS THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 21, 2013 (9:30 A.M.

PUBLIC INPUT MEETING Heart of Navarre Tourism Corridor September 27, 2016

TOWN OF NEW LONDON, NEW HAMPSHIRE 375 MAIN STREET NEW LONDON, NH

Aviation Tax Report. June 30, 2016

Okanogan Borderlands Historical Society : ;:!

WEKIVA WILD AND SCENIC RIVER ACT OF 2000

River Ridge Campgrounds Cabin and RV sites

SHREWSBURY ABERYSTWYTH RAIL LIAISON COMMITTEE MINUTES. of a meeting held at The Town Hall Welshpool on

GREENVILLE-SPARTANBURG AIRPORT COMMISSION MINUTES January 17, 2012

BURLINGTON INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT BOARD OF AIRPORT COMMISSIONERS MINUTES OF MEETING February 19, 2013 APPROVED 03/18/13

BOARD OF TRUSTEES TOWN OF WESTCLIFFE TUESDAY, AUGUST 1 st, 2017 REGULAR MEETING -Page 1 -

CONSERVANCY COMMISSION THURSDAY, AUGUST 17, 2017

1. Approval of minutes of the March 4, 2010 Park and Recreation Board Meeting

Meeting of the Planning Commission June 6, 2017 Custer County Courthouse Westcliffe, Colorado

Transcription:

MEETING MINUTES WHATCOM COUNTY PARKS AND RECREATION COMMISSION January 17, 2013 Bellingham Senior Activity Center 315 Halleck St. Bellingham, WA 98225 Present: Commissioners: Walt Lockwood, Jr., Paul Woodcock, Kenn Kiesner, Jeffrey Margolis and Janet Boyhan Staff: Absent: Guests: Michael McFarlane, Erik Axelson, and Rod Lamb Gordon Rogers, David Wright and Theresa Sygitowicz Tom Mitchell CALL TO ORDER The meeting was called to order by Commission Vice Chair, Lockwood at 6:07 p.m. I. AGENDA A. January 17, 2013 Agenda Approval: A motion was made to approve the agenda by Commissioner Woodcock, seconded by Commissioner Kiesner and passed unanimously. II. III. IV. MINUTES A. December 20, 2012 Meeting Minutes Approval: A motion was made to approve the meeting minutes by Commissioner Woodcock, seconded by Commissioner Kiesner and passed unanimously. PUBLIC INPUT/COMMUNICATIONS A. Executive Louws presented the new Park Commission appointments to the Council at the January 15 th meeting. Janet Boyhan and Jeffrey Margolis were approved effective February 1, 2013. The Commission has one vacancy in District 3 which is in the Blaine- Ferndale area. DIRECTORS REPORT Michael McFarlane A. South Fork Projects: The County Parks has been approached by the Tulalip Tribe (Tribe) and Western Washington University (WWU) on projects that are of mutual concern and benefit to both. The Tulalip Tribe would like to get some hard data on the elk herd in South Fork by running live traps and collaring them at the Nessett Farm. The Tribe would then track their movements in the valley and make some management decisions based upon the data they receive. The Tribe is working to line up all their permits so that they can start up in March. The project will continue through 2013 and into next winter. Professor Wallen from WWU is interested in using drones with cameras to observe and track elk herds to see if it is practical. WWU will need to go through the Federal Aviation Administration to get clearance. The Tribe is also interested in working with Whatcom County to provide the elk with highquality forage on Park property. They want the elk to stay at South Fork Park. We have also offered Deming Eagle Park because the elk bed down in the area. The Tribe wants

to provide some alternative food plots that may hold the animals away from crop areas. The Tribe will need to coordinate with a number of parties on both issues. B. Dorothy Copp Property Encroachment at Glacier: The County has offered to sell Dorothy Copp the strip of land she built on for $12,487 ($2.50 sq. foot). She has tentatively agreed to the offer. C. Little Squalicum Park EPA Report: Michael McFarlane handed out a report from the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) on Little Squalicum Park. The City of Bellingham (City) also had a landfill at the site that was backed up to a very steep cliff. Some of that was removed but not all because of the potential to destabilize the bluff. The landfill is monitored to be sure nothing migrates out of that site. The City and Whatcom County both own portions of the property; however EPA had full jurisdiction over the project. The Commission proposed transferring the County property to the City. Michael McFarlane has been unable to contact the City Parks Director for the Mayor s response. V. OPERATIONS REPORT Erik Axelson A. Silver Lake Park Transition: New Lead Park Ranger Erika Miranda will start Sunday, January 20 th. She previously worked for 5 years as a Park Ranger at Snohomish County Parks and before that at Custer State Park in the Black Hills of South Dakota. Our maintenance crew is completing renovations at the Ranger residence at Silver Lake Park in time for Erika and her family to move in this weekend. B. Silver Lake Capital Projects: Silver Lake took in about $12,000 in camping revenue the first two days of 2013. This year, we will be upgrading some of the cabins and moving ahead with the playground replacement and in 2014, we have major infrastructure improvements scheduled. C. Dog Leash Signage: We showed a sign design focusing on canine rules (leash and clean-up) and water quality. These signs are ready to be produced and will be installed over the next several weeks. We expect to do outreach in February and March letting people know we are serious about the dog leash rules. A key part of that is to ramp up enforcement by having our Rangers re-trained and making sure that if citations are issued they will stand up in court. Our experience is that word gets around very quickly after initial enforcement, compliance goes way up and then it is a maintenance effort. D. Plantation Rifle Range: The Range had a big year in spite of losing two Border Patrol training contracts in 2012 (Border Patrol units are based in Blaine and moved their training to Custer because it is closer and cheaper). The Range exceeded the 2011 gross revenue by $14,000 in 2012, even without nine months of federal contracts and continues to attract increased patronage and revenue from the public. We are re-evaluating the rules and regulations at the Plantation Range and anticipate having the updates completed in the near future, with a goal of improved clarity and reducing liability. E. Youth Rifle Shooting Program: This 12-week program began January 12 th at the Plantation Rifle Range. The sponsors are: Yeager s Sporting Goods (Bellingham), Kesselring s Gun Shop (Burlington), Skagit Shooting Sports (Burlington) and Wholesale Sports and Outdoor Outfitters (Burlington). It is a popular program that covers its costs Whatcom County Parks & Recreation Commission Meeting Minutes Page 2 of 6

with the help of the sponsors. Erik Axelson will provide additional information about the program at the next meeting. F. Advertisements and Requests for Proposals: We are getting ready to advertise for Campground Hosts at Silver Lake and Lighthouse Marine Park. We will provide limited tenancy in exchange for about 20 hours per week of cleaning and maintenance. Many state and county park systems have campground host programs. In the next few weeks, we will be advertising Request for Proposal (RFP) for food and beverage service at selected parks such as Semiahmoo, Silver Lake, Hovander, Lighthouse Marine and Samish. This could be an opportunity to provide additional service to the community and to park visitors, and increase revenues. We will also put out an RFP for agricultural haying licenses at several locations including Hovander and Silver Lake. G. Signage for Park Properties: Erik Axelson showed a sign prototype promoting events at Roeder Home. The sign prepared by Rod Lamb uses an arts & crafts font in keeping the style of the house. It will be posted near the front door of the residence where it will be visible and elegant. We will do similar marketing for other County park properties that have rental possibilities. VI. DESIGN AND DEVELOPMENT REPORT Rod Lamb A. Lookout Mountain Forest Reserve: Lookout Mountain Forest Reserve was fully permitted in 2010, but the Council voted against entering into a contract with the low bidder so the project was put on hold. The permits have expired and will have to be renewed. The project will provide a new trailhead with a 29-car parking lot and restroom facility that will connect to the existing trails. The project will go out to bid in the next month or so. The project cannot start until the watershed window opens in June. B. Lily Point Signage: The trail marker signage is in. We still have a number of interpretive signs that need to be produced like the cannery and cultural history of the site. At the southern viewpoint there will be a sign on the geology of Point Roberts and Lily Point which will describe the view, identify the mountain peaks and the San Juan Islands. Rod Lamb noted that an eagle s nest that was located in a snag is gone. He thinks that it may have blown down in a recent storm and will inform the US Fish and Wildlife. C. Samish Docks: Our manufacturer continues to build the docks which we should get in the spring. They can then be staged and installed after June. D. Lighthouse Boat Dock: We are assembling the bid package for this project. We received all of the state, federal and local permits and will begin construction probably in July. The in-water work will happen towards the end of July when the permit allows. E. Hovander Trail: We put in a budget supplemental to the Council for approval on the segment of the trail from the boat launch south to the setback levy. The Council will vote on it at the Council meeting on January 29 th. If it is approved we will put together a bid package and have a contractor do the rough grading. Our crews will do the mitigation planting in conjunction with the Outside Worker crew. The contractor will do the rough grading and finish trail surfacing. Whatcom County Parks & Recreation Commission Meeting Minutes Page 3 of 6

F. Silver Lake Playground: We are in the initial stage of this project. It is going to be constructed spring or early summer. If Planning and Development Services (PDS) determines that the project qualifies for a shoreline exemption because of the current structure the permitting process will be much shorter. However, if the project does not qualify we may need a Substantial Shoreline Development Permit which requires going before the Hearing Examiner. G. Silver Lake Electrical and Road Upgrade: Project funding for the electrical and road upgrades were approved for the 2014 budget year. We will be completing some initial groundwork in 2013 to identify specific improvements and upgrades that are needed. H. South Fork Park: We have money approved for access improvements in the 2014 budget year. The access improvement will include a new vehicular access drive and a small parking lot. In 2013, we will get the project ready to submit for the next grant funding cycle, identify the required permitting, work on some of the existing trails at Nessett Farm, and locate a final crossing location over Hutchinson Creek. The conceptual design is located on the County Parks website at: www.co.whatcom.wa.us/parks/development/southfork. VII. UNFINISHED BUSINESS: A. None. VIII. NEW BUSINESS - Presented by Michael McFarlane A. Review of the Lake Whatcom Reconveyance Proposal for Recreational Use: Michael McFarlane made an abbreviated presentation to the Commission of the Tuesday, January 15 th Council presentation. This was the first of three presentations scheduled for the Council. The Lake Whatcom Reconveyance Proposal can be found on the County website at www.co.whatcom.wa.us/parks/development/reconveyance. B. 2012 Activity Reports: A preliminary revenue spreadsheet was passed out. Overall revenues did well this year, however the spreadsheet showed total revenue is a little short because we have not yet received reimbursement for labor from Conservation Futures and because Lake Whatcom Reconveyance was not approved we did not transfer funds from the Parks Improvement Fund into the Parks general budget. Group Picnic Shelter rental revenue is down from what it has been historically. We think this change has to do with the current economy and have adjusted the (2014 & 2015) budget. The Semiahmoo Cannery Day Lodge revenue has increased from previous years. A third of the Department budget is funded through revenues. C. Comprehensive Parks and Recreation Open Space Plan: $40,000 was approved in the 2013/2014 budget to update the Comprehensive Parks and Recreation Open Space Plan. The plan flags projects, acquisitions, outlines a 6-year Capital Improvement Plan and a 20-year outlook on Whatcom County Parks and Recreation. It is a planning document required to remain grant eligible and is used for a number of purposes by both private developers, as well as federal and state agencies. It must be approved by the County Council and certified by the Recreation Conservation Office (RCO) in Olympia. To remain eligible for the next grant cycle it needs to be completed by March 3, 2014. Whatcom County Parks & Recreation Commission Meeting Minutes Page 4 of 6

The process includes a community involvement survey, community meetings and updating inventory of existing lands and parks. We have better inventory data than we did in 2006 and that has not changed substantially. We will have to determine if we want to recalculate the Levels of Service or let them roll over into the new plan. We will have to do a SEPA (State Environmental Policy Act) review. The Planning Commission will review the plan when we are done and give their recommendations. The Park Commission will act as an advisory committee for the process. The Park Commission will need to decide if they want to work in a smaller workgroup to review all the information, the public input, surveys, goals and objectives. At each Park Commission meeting time will be set apart to review the information, giving input to staff. A consultant will be hired to do specific tasks like the survey or running the public meetings. Michael McFarlane would like to see the project completed by December 2013 for the Planning Commission and County Council approval in January 2014. The approved plan would then be certified in February 2014. At the next meeting we will bring the goals and objective and strategies to the next meeting to start the process. He will have them sent out early so the Commission has time to review them before the meeting. The plan can be found on the County website at: www.whatcomcounty.us/parks/development/comprehensive. D. General Discussion Items: 1. Boulevard Park: Commissioner Kiesner asked if the County still maintained Boulevard Park. Michael McFarlane explained that Boulevard Park was owned by both the City of Bellingham and Whatcom County. The lease between the City and the County expires this year and there is a 30-day period that either party can make changes to the lease or it automatically renews for another 30 years. 2. Fallen Trees at VanderYacht Park: Commissioner Margolis voiced concern about some fallen trees at the Josh VanderYacht Memorial Park. Trees were uprooted near a stream last fall. At the time, nothing was done because there was concern about the root wads damming the ditch. Erik Axelson commented that it was brought to the attention of senior management at Public Works recently. 3. Deming Eagle Park: Commissioner Margolis commented that he would like to see a portable ladder installed that will make it easier for visitors to get down onto the river bar. Erik Axelson mentioned that there is some liability and risk management that we would need to consider. Michael McFarlane added that the State has jurisdiction on the shore, but that we can look at other areas that are not as steep for access. 4. Sanican for Stimson Reserve: Commissioner Margolis asked why there was not a toilet at Stimpson Reserve. Michael McFarlane mentioned that it is on the agenda for the summer. The Land Trust is holding funds for a restroom building. We also have plans to build a restroom at the Lake Louise trailhead later this summer. 5. The Boy Scout Camp: Commissioner Kiesner brought up that the Boy Scouts of America are closing their camp that is located on the north side of Silver Lake and Whatcom County Parks & Recreation Commission Meeting Minutes Page 5 of 6

asked if the County would be interested in purchasing it. Michael McFarlane said they have not been approached about it, although it does fit the parameters for acquisition and it would keep the property from becoming residential. E. Commission Member Acknowledgment: Michael McFarlane acknowledged Commissioner Lockwood s service to the Commission. He was presented with a mug acknowledging his 7½ year of service. IX. ANNOUNCEMENTS A. Next Meeting: February 21, 2013 Location: Parks and Recreation Administrative Office 3373 Mt. Baker Highway Bellingham, WA 98226 Time: 6:00 p.m. X. ADJOURNMENT The meeting was adjourned at 9:01 p.m. by Commission Vice Chair, Lockwood. Transcribed by: Daisy C. Hansen, WC Clerk III Approved by: Michael McFarlane, WC Parks & Recreation Director Whatcom County Parks & Recreation Commission Meeting Minutes Page 6 of 6