AGENDA ITEM NO. 6 COMMITTEE/SUB Planning Committee DATE OF MEETING 12 NOVEMBER 2007 TITLE PUBLICITY CONTENTS DELEGATION Publication Items approved by the Group Leader, Development Management under the following Delegation references:- Building Regulations P150D and P160D, P570D P580D Planning Applications P020D, P200D to P250D, P270D to P320D, P350D to P370D, P390D, P420D to P440D Felling and Pruning of Trees P100D, P120D, P130D Agricultural and Telecommunications and P340D P330D RECOMMENDATIONS LIST OF BACKGROUND PAPERS Not applicable Relevant applications
INDEX TO GROUP LEADER, DEVELOPMENT MANAGEMENT S DELEGATED REPORT TO PLANNING COMMITTEE ON THE 22 ND OCTOBER 2007 Item 1 Item 2 Item 3 Building Regulations Planning Applications Application to Fell or Prune Trees These are reported to Planning Committee for information only. Anyone requiring further information on any of the matters contained in this report should contact:- Building Regulations Chris Robinson 345818 Planning Applications Paul Staniforth 345781 Applications to Fell or Prune Trees Steve Perry 345791
DELEGATED ITEM 1 BUILDING REGULATIONS AS AT 26 th OCTOBER 07 07/00562/DRO Room in Roof Space Conditional St Helens 4 Gloucester Road Chesterfield Derbyshire Approval Mr P Jaques 07/00437/DEX Two storey extension Conditional St Leonards 23 Owen Falls Avenue Chesterfield Derbyshire Approval S41 0FR Mr & Mrs Adams 07/00508/DEX Single storey rear extension Conditional Brimington South 19 Wayside Court Chesterfield Derbyshire Approval S43 1BS Mr J Wood 07/00492/MUL 2 Storey Extension to side of house Conditional Brockwell 2 West View Road Chesterfield Derbyshire Approval S41 7AH Mr Martin Baker 07/00535/OTH Remove chimney breast and dividing wall Conditional Hollingwood to ground floor Approval And 14 Lathkill Avenue Chesterfield Derbyshire Inkersall S43 3JA Mr & Mrs R Redfern 07/00539/DEX Proposed two storey dormer bungalow side Conditional Brockwell extension Approval 46 Bentham Road Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 4EZ Mr & Mrs Renner 07/00555/DEX 2 Storey Extension to Side Conditional West 295 Ashgate Road Chesterfield Derbyshire Approval S40 4DB Mr & Mrs Dodsworth 07/00567/MUL Two storey extension Conditional Old Whittington 156 Church Street North Chesterfield Approval Derbyshire S41 9QP Mr G Pryor
07/00572/MUL Single Storey Extension/Garage /Kitchen Conditional Brimington South and Toilet in Hall Approval 185 Lockoford Lane Tapton Chesterfield Derbyshire S41 0TG Mr & Mrs Cooper 07/00531/MUL Single storey rear extension, loft conversion Conditional West and internal alterations Approval 70 Heaton Street Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 3AF Mr & Mrs Dobson 07/00525/PART Proposed Childrens Centre and associated Decision Advice play areas and parking for Notice Derbyshire County Council Harpur Hill Primary School Trent Avenue Buxton Derbyshire SK17 8LP Frank Shaw Associates 07/00457/OTH Pitched Roof Over Garage Regularisation West 45 Somersall Park Road Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 3LD David Main 07/00614/OTH Removal of part of chimney breast to dining Regularisation Brockwell room and RSJ to kitchen 22 Newbold Avenue Chesterfield Derbyshire S41 7AR Mrs R Newman 07/00509/OTH Detached house and garage Rejected Hasland Land At Foxwood Close Chesterfield Derbyshire Mr M Ervine 07/00499/DEX Utility room and garden room extension Rejected Brockwell 31 Ashgate Road Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 4AG Mr & Mrs Wright
07/00521/DOM Two new dwellings (Plots 5 & 6) Rejected Hasland Land Adjacent To Manor House Farm 118 The Green Chesterfield Mr N Glover 07/00497/DRO Rooms in the roof Unconditional West 22 Queen Mary Road Chesterfield Derbyshire Approval S40 3LB Mr & Mrs M Boston 07/00378/DRO Loft Conversion Unconditional Brimington North 8 Fairfield Close Chesterfield Derbyshire Approval S43 1JX Mrs B Sharman 07/00575/DEX Single Storey Front Extension to Bungalow Unconditional Brimington South 8 Well Spring Close Chesterfield Derbyshire Approval S43 1QX Mr R Elshaw 07/00510/OTH Internal Offices Unconditional Old Whittington Unit 7 Carrwood Road Chesterfield Derbyshire Approval S41 9QB E May 07/00500/OTH Side and rear extensions and internal alterations Unconditional Lowgates And 1 Norbriggs Road Chesterfield Derbyshire Approval Woodthorpe S43 3BW Mr M Smart 07/00611/DEX Single storey extension Unconditional Linacre 5 Birstall Close Chesterfield Derbyshire Approval S41 8WA Mr & Mrs Ashby 07/00529/DEX Ground and first floor extensions Unconditional West 2 Deerlands Road Chesterfield Derbyshire Approval S40 4DF Mr & Mrs Gill
KEY FOR DECISION CODES CON - Granted with Conditions PAS - Granted REF - Refused DECAD - Decision Advice Notice REG - Regularisation WDN - Withdrawn KEY FOR APPLICATION CODES OTHFP - Other full plans applications DEXFP - Domestic extension full plans DOMFP - Domestic new dwelling full plans DROFP - Domestic room in the roof full plans RESUB - Resubmission PART - Partnership application MULFP - Multiple work full plans
Delegated List Planning Applications Code No Ward Proposal Decision Decision FileNo CHE/07/00513/FUL St Helens Redevelopment of existing site Conditional 12/10/2007 to include the demolition of all existing buildings and outbuildings and construction of 16 no. new dwellings (consisting 14 no. 2 bed house/apartments and 2 no. 3 bed house/apartments), revised plans received 1st October 2007 2353 At 103, 105 and 105a Newbold Road Chesterfield Derbyshire Messrs M And S Barlow CHE/07/00539/AD Moor Temporary vinyl banner sign refused 22/10/2007 (two years) 1209 At Unit 2 Chesterfield Trade Centre Sheffield Road Whittington Moor Chesterfield Derbyshire Floors 2 Go Limited CHE/07/00542/FUL West Demolition of existing property Conditional 29/10/2007 and construction of new two storey dwelling - amended plans received 9th October 143 At 72 Vincent Crescent Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 3NP Mr P Llewellyn 31 October 2007 Page 1 of 11
Code No Ward Proposal Decision Decision FileNo CHE/07/00563/RE West Spread of excavated soil and Retrospective 18/10/2007 new solar water heating tubes application 2083 At approved Ashgate Croft School Ashgate Road Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 4BN Ashgage Croft School CHE/07/00586/FUL Hasland Conservatory to side of Conditional 19/10/2007 dwelling and playroom/store extension to rear of garage 2811 At 6 Saxton Close Chesterfield Derbyshire S41 0SL Mr C Germany CHE/07/00587/FUL Brimington Loft conversion Conditional 19/10/2007 South 4232 At 286 Manor Road Brimington Chesterfield Derbyshire S43 1NX Mrs D Bird CHE/07/00589/FUL Middlecroft Replacement of existing Conditional 12/10/2007 And fencing with higher security Poolsbrook 6109 At Allotments Middlecroft Road Chesterfield Derbyshire Staveley Town Council CHE/07/00590/CO Hollingwoo Alterations to existing Middle Conditional 11/10/2007 d And Lodge to form 6 letting Inkersall bedrooms 2538 At Ringwood Hall Chesterfield Road Brimington Chesterfield Derbyshire S43 1DQ Mr David Seton 31 October 2007 Page 2 of 11
Code No Ward Proposal Decision Decision FileNo CHE/07/00591/AD Linacre Various illuminated pub Conditional 16/10/2007 signage, revised plans received 19th September 2007 5637 At Holme Hall Inn Linacre Road Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 4UX Punch Tavern Limited CHE/07/00594/LB Hollingwoo Listed Building consent for Conditional 11/10/2007 d And alterations to existing Middle Inkersall Lodge to form 6 letting bedrooms 2538 At Ringwood Hall Chesterfield Road Brimington Chesterfield Derbyshire S43 1DQ Mr David Seton CHE/07/00595/CO St Change of use from B8 to B1 - Conditional 12/10/2007 Leonards factory for manufacture and distribution of danceware 300 At mer Yeomans Ltd (warehouse) Markham Road Chesterfield Derbyshire Images Textiles Limited CHE/07/00603/RE St 3200 x 2100 first floor Retrospective 11/10/2007 Leonards conservatory - re-submission application approved 2419 At 7 Brambling Court Chesterfield Derbyshire S41 0ED Mr And Mrs Kellett 31 October 2007 Page 3 of 11
Code No Ward Proposal Decision Decision FileNo CHE/07/00612/FUL Moor Conversion of vacant second Conditional 24/10/2007 floor and 3 bedroom flat at first floor level into 4 one bedroom flats 1123 At 419 Sheffield Road Whittington Moor Chesterfield Derbyshire S41 8LT Mr And Mrs Litras CHE/07/00616/FUL Loundsley Erection of a conservatory Conditional 17/10/2007 Green 1873 At 12 Cheedale Close Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 Mr And Mrs Booth CHE/07/00621/FUL Walton Single storey extension with Conditional 17/10/2007 balcony over 5897 At 95A Foljambe Avenue Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 3EY Mr And Mrs A Hudson CHE/07/00622/FUL Moor Brick built garage Conditional 22/10/2007 1009 At 87 Peveril Road Chesterfield Derbyshire S41 8SG Mr J D Britland CHE/07/00627/FUL West Single storey side extension Conditional 10/10/2007 5057 At Tumbly 8 Clifford Close Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 3PP Mr G Thompson 31 October 2007 Page 4 of 11
Code No Ward Proposal Decision Decision FileNo CHE/07/00634/FUL St Helens Two storey extension Conditional 19/10/2007 Re-submission 3306 At 29 Tapton View Road Chesterfield Derbyshire S41 7JU Mr J Sargerson CHE/07/00635/FUL Barrow Hill Single storey side garage to Conditional 12/10/2007 And New dwelling Whittington 136 At 8 Cromdale Avenue Chesterfield Derbyshire S43 2DH Mr B Crook CHE/07/00636/FUL Walton Proposed single extension to Conditional 15/10/2007 rear of property, conversion of existing integral garage to form library and construction of single detached garage. New porch and porch roof. 5579 At 3 Badger Close Chesterfield Derbyshire S42 7NA Mr And Mrs Ottowell CHE/07/00637/FUL Moor 1. Add conservatory on rear Conditional 15/10/2007 2. Raise roof height of rear section of garage to allow kitchen extension into rear of garage 665 At 21 Ormsby Road Chesterfield Derbyshire S41 8SA Mark Buckley CHE/07/00638/FUL Hasland Conservatory to the rear of Conditional 12/10/2007 semi detached bungalow 1276 At 7 Mellor Way Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 2UA Mrs M Holmes 31 October 2007 Page 5 of 11
Code No Ward Proposal Decision Decision FileNo CHE/07/00639/FUL Brockwell New two storey extension to Conditional 10/10/2007 rear 3m projection externally 3110 At 24 Highfield Avenue Chesterfield Derbyshire S41 7AX Mr And Mrs Bailey CHE/07/00645/FUL Middlecroft Two storey side extension and Conditional 29/10/2007 And three dormers to the rear Poolsbrook elevation to create living accommodation in the existing roof space 2068 At Belmont Mill Green Chesterfield Derbyshire S43 Mr And Mrs Neale CHE/07/00646/FUL Brockwell Two storey extension to side refused 18/10/2007 of house and garden room at 3246 At 16 Heathfield Avenue Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 4AJ K Bancroft And J Sanderson CHE/07/00649/FUL Old Single storey side extension Conditional 31/10/2007 Whittington 1442 At 7 Mary Ann Street Chesterfield Derbyshire S41 9EP Mr And Mrs Wilson CHE/07/00650/FUL Moor Temporary siting (five years) Conditional 12/10/2007 of portacabin to be situated within company compound and used as office space 1467 At Ranger Equipment Ltd Workshop and Premises 52 Shaw Street Chesterfield Derbyshire S41 9AY Andrew Bray 31 October 2007 Page 6 of 11
Code No Ward Proposal Decision Decision FileNo CHE/07/00651/FUL Dunston Erection of smoking shelter Conditional 12/10/2007 1054 At Victoria Club and Institute 586 Sheffield Road Whittington Moor Chesterfield Derbyshire Victoria Club And Institute CHE/07/00653/FUL Hasland Single storey side extension Conditional 18/10/2007 including conservatory and loft conversion 6244 At 10 Hillcrest Road Chesterfield Derbyshire S41 0NR Mrs Lynne Atkin CHE/07/00657/FUL Brockwell Proposed single storey Conditional 16/10/2007 extension to form kitchen/dining and garden room to the rear of the existing 2304 At 66B Newbold Road Chesterfield Derbyshire S41 Mr And Mrs M Burton CHE/07/00658/FUL Walton Two storey and single storey Conditional 10/10/2007 extension to rear with dormer - amended plans received 1328 At 93 Whitecotes Lane Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 3HJ Mrs P Cawkwell CHE/07/00665/RE Walton Retention of detached garage Retrospective 17/10/2007 and conservatory to rear of application existing dwelling approved 1653 At 41 Ling Road Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 3HT Craig Hyre 31 October 2007 Page 7 of 11
Code No Ward Proposal Decision Decision FileNo CHE/07/00666/FUL Rother Single storey conservatory at Conditional 16/10/2007 rear of property 540 At 11 Lillymede Close Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 Trevor John Goldsmith CHE/07/00667/RE Barrow Hill Retention of fencing moved to Retrospective 19/10/2007 And New enclose and reclaim land that Application Whittington belongs to the applicant Refused 554 At 2 Lakeside Close Chesterfield Derbyshire S41 9TD Mr Chris Fearick CHE/07/00668/FUL Hollingwoo Dormer window to the front of Conditional 30/10/2007 d And the property and a first floor Inkersall extension to the rear. Both to increase headroom at first floor level and form balcony at first floor level above the conservatory. Received amended plans on the 15.10.07 1702 At 8 Westwood Drive Chesterfield Derbyshire S43 Mr P Thorneycroft CHE/07/00670/FUL Moor Conservatory to front elevation Conditional 17/10/2007 1644 At Ridgewood House Residential Home 13 Dukes Drive Chesterfield Derbyshire Mr Peter Walsh CHE/07/00671/FUL Brockwell Two storey side extension refused 16/10/2007 3113 At 46 Bentham Road Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 4EZ Mr And Mrs Renner 31 October 2007 Page 8 of 11
Code No Ward Proposal Decision Decision FileNo CHE/07/00684/FUL Brockwell Proposed single storey Conditional 15/10/2007 extension to create bedroom, ensuite and dressing room and extension to lounge 705 At 1 Barbon Close Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 4DP Mr And Mrs D Finneran CHE/07/00685/FUL Barrow Hill Two storey side extension Conditional 31/10/2007 And New (re-submission of Whittington CHE/07/00419/FUL) 613 At 18 Garden Close Chesterfield Derbyshire S43 2DR Mr And Miss G Hobson CHE/07/00690/FUL Walton Conservatory Conditional 24/10/2007 5903 At 5 St Andrews Rise Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 Mr And Mrs Wolstenholme CHE/07/00692/LB Linacre Various illuminated signs, Conditional 16/10/2007 revised plans received 19th September 2007 5637 At Holme Hall Inn Linacre Road Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 4UX Punch Taverns Ltd CHE/07/00699/FUL Brimington Single storey extension to Conditional 12/10/2007 South create kitchen/garage/canopy 21 At 185 Lockoford Lane Tapton Chesterfield Derbyshire S41 0TG Mr And Mrs M Cooper 31 October 2007 Page 9 of 11
Code No Ward Proposal Decision Decision FileNo CHE/07/00700/FUL West Replacing existing timber Conditional 24/10/2007 framed garage with sectional pre-cast concrete garage (Compton Apex Rockstone) 2525 At 1 Norton Avenue Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 3NG Mr D Norton CHE/07/00703/FUL Hasland Single storey extension to rear Conditional 30/10/2007 6397 At 83 The Green Chesterfield Derbyshire S41 0LW Mr M Horrorbin CHE/07/00704/FUL Hasland Proposed external porch Conditional 12/10/2007 122 At Portland House Britannia Road Chesterfield Derbyshire Concrete Repairs Ltd CHE/07/00706/FUL St Extension of existing second Conditional 22/10/2007 Leonards floor storage room over first floor to provide additional office space 1970 At Jones and Middleton 24 Glumangate Chesterfield Derbyshire Banner Jones Solicitors CHE/07/00710/FUL Brockwell Replace window to rear with a Conditional 31/10/2007 door 2373 At Industry Inn 49 Queen Street Chesterfield Derbyshire S40 4SF Stewart Lawson 31 October 2007 Page 10 of 11
Code No Ward Proposal Decision Decision FileNo CHE/07/00720/FUL Linacre Bay window extension to Conditional 29/10/2007 lounge, kitchen extension with bedroom and bathroom over and erection of garden rooms and conversion of garage (re-submission of approved application 5913 At 20 Spring House Close Chesterfield Derbyshire S42 7PD Mrs Daisy Hollis CHE/07/00723/FUL Lowgates External smoking area Conditional 29/10/2007 And Woodthorp 321 At Mastin Moor Miners Welfare Renishaw Road Chesterfield Derbyshire S43 3DW Mastin Moor Miners Welfare CHE/07/00737/FUL Old Conservatory Conditional 31/10/2007 Whittington 6186 At 5 Green Street Chesterfield Derbyshire S41 9JG Mr Patterson 31 October 2007 Page 11 of 11
SECTION 1 APPLICATION TO FELL OR PRUNE TREES 31 st OCTOBER 2007 CODE NO FILE NO WARD DESCRIPTION OF PROPOSAL TERMS OF DECISION 907/74TPO 4901.71 Lowgates and Woodthorpe The pruning and felling of trees reference T2-T5, T20, T23, T25, T27, T7, T12, T22, T26 and G1 on the Order Map situated at the Rectory, Staveley for Revd W Butt. Consent given to the pruning of trees T2-T5, T20, T23, T25 and T27. The trees are overhanging the public highway and driveway to Staveley Town Hall. The pruning will remove large limbs and deadwood that could fall into the highway. Consent given to the felling of four trees which are suffering from bleeding canker with the loss of bark and leaf coverage. Consent give with the condition to replant with more suitable species. Consent refused to the felling of one Lime tree which is of a sound condition and adds to the amenity of the area. DATE OF DECISION 29.10.07
907/75TPO 4901.10 West The re-pollarding of 1 Lime tree reference G2 on the Order Map for Paul Adamson on behalf of Derbyshire County Council. Consent given to the repollarding of one Lime tree due to subsidence issues and loss of light to flats opposite. 16.10.07 1007/79TPO 4901.27 Hasland The pruning of one Sycamore reference W1 on the Order Map for Churchway Homes Ltd. The tree is within a small woodland and is allegedly overhanging and shading plot 1 on a new development. Consent given to the limited pruning of one sycamore tree. The crown lifting of the tree to allow more light into the garden by the removal of selected branches. 31.10.07 1007/80TPO 4901.112 Dunston The pruning of one oak reference T2 on the Order Map for Chesterfield Borough Council Consent given to prune one Oak tree. General tree maintenance removal of deadwood, clear around telephone wires and street lamp and prune away from properties. 22.10.07
1007/81TPO 4901.268 Walton The pruning of one Lime tree reverence T18 on the Order Map for Mr R Blagdon and Julia Barnaby at 79 Moorland View Road Consent given to the crown reduction by 40% of one Lime tree. Trees have previously been felled adjacent to the tree. a reduction in height will alleviate concerns about any possible wind blow due to its sudden exposure to the natural elements. 23.10.07 1007/82A/ TPO 4901.230 West The felling of one Pine tree within G3 on the Order Map for Mr Wigfield at 174 Somersall Lane. The tree is allegedly in danger of falling onto the neighbouring property. Consent given to the felling of one Pine tree within G3. The tree is dangerously leaning towards the adjacent property with slight heave around the root plate. No condition to replant due to insufficient room and to allow existing trees to spread. 29.10.07
1007/82/TPO 4901.101 St Leonards The pruning of two trees reference G1 on the Order Map for Mr and Mrs Brown at 12 Piccadilly Road. Prune back branches near house and over highway and crown thin to allow more light into garden. Consent given to the pruning of two trees within group one. The trees require minor pruning works to clear pavement and highway and to clear buildings. Also a light crown thing to allow more light into property and garden. 23.10.07 1007/83/TPO 4901.149 Old Whittington The pruning of trees reference T90- T94, T96, T104-T106, T108 and T109 on the Order Map for C Watts at Green Farm 175 High Street. To clear footpath and street lighting. Consent given to prune numerous trees along High Street, Old Whittington at the request of Derbyshire County Council Highways. To clear street lighting and pavement of overhanging branches. 22.10.07
1007/85/TPO 4901.27 Hasland The pruning of various trees around a pond within a small woodland between Foxwood Close and Southfield Avenue reference W1 on the Order Map. Also the felling of one ash tree within W1 which is leaning towards the pond for Mr and Mrs Ervine of 8 Berwick Close, Walton. Consent given to the pruning of seven trees within a small woodland and around a pond in the wood. Consent also given to the felling of one Ash tree which is leaning over the pond with conditions to replant. The works will allow more light into the pond which has become neglected and create an environment which will be of benefit to wildlife. 30.10.07
SECTION 2 NOTIFICATION OF INTENT TO AFFECT TREES IN A CONSERVATION AREA 31 st OCTOBER 2007 CONTENTS OF NOTICE 1007/CA1. The felling of 4 trees and the pruning of 2 Ash trees at The Rectory, Staveley. The trees are allegedly to close to the boundary wall and fence. The trees are in the Staveley Town Centre Conservation Area. SUMMARY OF CONSIDERATIONS TERMS OF DECISION DATE OF DECISION The trees are growing in the grounds of The Rectory at Staveley. The trees which are to be felled are young trees which are adjacent the boundary wall and fence and will inevitably cause damage in future years. The pruning is general maintenance and is good arboricultural practice. Agreement to felling and pruning to B3 3998. 1989. 29.10.07