Mountain Goat Inventory North Peace July 2014

Similar documents
AURORA WILDLIFE RESEARCH

2000 SOUTHERN EAST KOOTENAY GOAT AERIAL SURVEY

Aerial Classified Mountain Goat and Bighorn Sheep Count, Penticton Creek to Vaseux Creek, South Okanagan, March 2009.

2009 Clearwater Area Sheep

Mountain goat survey in Management Unit 3-44, Thompson region, British Columbia, September 2006

Mountain goat survey in the East Kootenay, British Columbia, August 2005

APPENDIX 18-D 2010 AND 2011 MOUNTAIN GOAT AERIAL SURVEYS, BRUCEJACK PROJECT

Mountain goat survey in Canadian Mountain Holidays Bobbie Burns and Bugaboo summer operating areas, Kootenay region, British Columbia, September 2008

Population Assessment of Southern Mountain Caribou (Rangifer tarandus) in the Prince George Forest District

Role of the Protected Area

Biogeography of the Mountain Goat (Oreamnos americanus) Chidera Bisong

POPULATION CENSUSES OF CARIBOU IN THE NORTH COLUMBIA MOUNTAINS- COLUMBIA SOUTH SUBPOPULATION. April, Kelsey Furk, John Flaa

Mineral lick use by GPS radio collared mountain goats in southeastern British Columbia

Labrador - Island Transmission Link Target Rare Plant Survey Locations

Robson Valley Avalanche Tract Mapping Project

Kwadacha Wilderness Provincial Park and Kwadacha Addition (Kwadacha Recreation Area) Purpose Statement and Zoning Plan

STONE MOUNTAIN PROVINCIAL PARK Purpose Statement and Zoning Plan

Sawtooth National Forest Fairfield Ranger District

MILLIGAN HILLS PROVINCIAL PARK

ANAGEMENT P LAN. February, for Elk Lakes and Height of the Rockies Provincial Parks. Ministry of Environment, Lands and Parks BC Parks Division

APPENDIX C LIST OF OTHER PARK SYSTEMS WITHIN THE PRRD

2.0 PARK VISION AND ROLES

Restore and implement protected status that is equivalent, or better than what was lost during the mid-1990 s

Brown bear (Ursus arctos) fact sheet

SUGARBOWL-GRIZZLY DEN PROVINCIAL PARK AND SUGARBOWL-GRIZZLY DEN PROTECTED AREA Purpose Statement and Zoning Plan

Large Carnivore of the Ukrainian Carpathians

Fred Antoine Park. Management Plan. Final Public Review Draft

Planning Wildlife Crossings in Canada's Mountain Parks SESSION: Highway Mitigation: new insights for practitioners

WORKSHEET 1 Wilderness Qualities or Attributes Evaluating the Effects of Project Activities on Wilderness Attributes

OMINEACA PROVINCIAL PARK

The Canadian field-naturalist. Ottawa,Ottawa Field-Naturalists' Club.

Outdoor Recreation Opportunities Management

The Uphill Climb: Mountain Goat-Human Interactions on the Olympic National Forest. Kurt Aluzas Wildlife Biologist Enterprise Program

BIG ANIMALS and SMALL PARKS: Implications of Wildlife Distribution and Movements for Expansion of Nahanni National Park Reserve. John L.

DIVERSIFIED ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES BOX 6263, FORT ST. JOHN, B.C. V1J 4H7 PHONE/FAX (250)

What is an Marine Protected Area?

Keeping Wilderness Wild: Increasing Effectiveness With Limited Resources

DIVERSIFIED ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES BOX 6263, FORT ST. JOHN, B.C. V1J 4H7 PHONE/FAX (250)

Yard Creek Provincial Park. Management Plan

Lake Trout Population Assessment Wellesley Lake 1997, 2002, 2007

The Design of Nature Reserves

Evaluation of Woodland Caribou Winter Range in Mount Robson Provincial Park (Keystone Wildlife Research 1998)

April 10, Mark Stiles San Juan Public Lands Center Manager 15 Burnett Court Durango, CO Dear Mark,

Mountain Goats and Winter Recreation November 17, 2011

Draft Protocol for Monitoring the Effectiveness of Mountain Goat Winter Ranges

Wolverine-Forest Carnivore Research in the Northern Cascades of Oregon

2009 Muskoka Airport Economic Impact Study

DIVERSIFIED ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES BOX 6263, FORT ST. JOHN, B.C. V1J 4H7 PHONE/FAX (250)

A GIS Analysis of Probable High Recreation Use Areas in Three Sisters Wilderness Deschutes and Willamette National Forests

Underwater Acoustic Monitoring in US National Parks

Displacement of Mountain Caribou from Winter Habitat by. Snowmobiles

MOUNTAIN GOAT HERD UNIT MANAGEMENT PLAN Wildlife Management Unit #13 La Sal Mountains June 2013

Bridge River Delta Park. Management Plan. Final Public Review Draft

2012 In-Market Research Report. Kootenay Rockies

Appendix 1: Best Management Practices For Hang Gliding and Paragliding in Jasper National Parks

MANAGEMENT DIRECTION STATEMENT June, 1999

Mackinnon Esker Ecological Reserve Draft - Management Plan

HOTFIRE WILDLIFE MANAGEMENT MODEL A CASE STUDY

Crown of the Continent Ecosystem The Glacier-Great Bear Connectivity Conservation Area Briefing

KOOTENAY LAKE PROVINCIAL PARK (MIDGE CREEK SITE)

GOLDEN BACKCOUNTRY RECREATION ADVISORY COMMITTEE (GBRAC)

Mackinnon Esker Ecological Reserve. Management Plan

As outlined in the Tatshenshini-Alsek Park Management Agreement, park management will:

Risk Assessment in Winter Backcountry Travel

Victor Lake Park. Management Plan

Whitefish Range Partnership Tentatively Approved by WRP 11/18/2013!Rec. Wilderness Page 1

SeagrassNet Monitoring in Great Bay, New Hampshire, 2016

Kicking the Alpine Plants Out Mountain Goat Wallows In Mount Peale Research Natural Area (La Sal Mountains, Utah)

Kronotskii Biosphere Reserve, Ryabikov Street, Elizovo, Kamchatka, , Russia

A GUIDE TO MANITOBA PROTECTED AREAS & LANDS PROTECTION

Fraser River Provincial Park Purpose Statement and Zoning Plan

MANAGEMENT DIRECTION STATEMENT

Peace Region. MANAGEMENT Plan. January for Toad River Hot Springs Provincial Park. Ministry of Environment. Environmental Stewardship Division

The following criteria were used to identify Benchmark Areas:

Birch Point Provincial Park. Management Plan

FINGER-TATUK PROVINCIAL PARK

Road Ecology Center escholarship Repository John Muir Institute of the Environment University of California, Davis

MANAGEMENT DIRECTION STATEMENT June, 1999

MANAGEMENT DIRECTION STATEMENT June, 1999

Proposed Action. Payette National Forest Over-Snow Grooming in Valley, Adams and Idaho Counties. United States Department of Agriculture

2/7/2012. Mission Mountains Wilderness Contracting as a management alternative Climb the mountains and get their good tidings John Muir

The Rufford Foundation Final Report

BLANKET CREEK PROVINCIAL PARK

Rubber boas in Radium Hot Springs

APPENDIX H 2022 BASELINE NOISE EXPOSURE CONTOUR

Alternative 3 Prohibit Road Construction, Reconstruction, and Timber Harvest Except for Stewardship Purposes B Within Inventoried Roadless Areas

Dr. Ingrid Wiesel. Elizabeth Bay Optimisation Project

communication tower means a tower or structure built to support equipment used to transmit communication signals;

Preferred Recreation Recommendations Stemilt-Squilchuck Recreation Plan March 2018

Daisy Dean Trail 628/619 ATV Trail Construction

S h o r t - H a u l C o n s u m e r R e s e a r c h. S u m m a r y A p r i l

BIGHORN BACKCOUNTRY ACCESS MANAGEMENT PLAN

TOURISM SPENDING IN ALGONQUIN PROVINCIAL PARK

Sand Lakes Provincial Park. Draft Management Plan

Stuart River Provincial Park Purpose Statement and Zoning Plan

discover Genuine Montana The Last Best Place Great Falls Montana

5 Demography and Economy

Intact Habitat Landscapes and Woodland Caribou on the Island of Newfoundland

Muscovite Lakes Provincial Park Purpose Statement and Zoning Plan

Backgrounder Plains Bison Reintroduction to Banff National Park

Transcription:

P E A C E R E G I O N T E C H N I C A L R E P O R T Mountain Goat Inventory North Peace July 2014 by: Alicia D. Woods Wildlife Biologist Ministry of Forests, Lands and Natural Resource Operations #400-10003 110 th Avenue Fort St. John BC V1J 6M7 October 2014

Executive Summary Mountain goats are relatively abundant and found throughout the Peace Region. To better assess abundance and distribution of mountain goats across the Peace Region, a 5- year regional population assessment began in 2013. As part of this multi-year project, an aerial classified total count of mountain goats was conducted July 3-11, 2014 (Year 2 of 5) in Management Units 7-36, 7-43, and 7-57 of the Peace Region and Management Unit 7-37 of the Omineca Region of British Columbia. During the survey a total of 290 mountain goats were counted: 190 adults (males and females combined), 42 juveniles (yearlings and 2-year olds combined), 55 kids, and 3 unclassified individuals. A 65% sightability correction factor was applied to the total number of mountain goats counted, bringing the estimated number to 446. Information obtained from survey results will be used to manage sustainable harvest of mountain goats. 2

Table of Contents Executive Summary... 2 List of Figures... 4 List of Tables... 4 1.0 Introduction... 5 1.1 Background... 5 2.0 Methods... 6 2.1 Study Area... 6 2.2 Survey Methods... 7 2.3 Sightability... 8 3.0 Results... 9 4.0 Discussion... 15 5.0 Acknowledgements... 17 6.0 References... 17 7.0 Personal Communications... 19 8.0 Appendices... 20 3

List of Figures Figure 1. Summary of mountain goat harvest zones, general open season areas, and hunting closures in the Peace Region (7B), British Columbia.... 6 Figure 2. Management units surveyed during the July 2014 North Peace mountain goat inventory and during year one of the 5-year population assessment (July 2013), Peace Region (7B), British Columbia.... 7 Figure 3. Locations of observations of mountain goats from the 2014 North Peace mountain goat inventory, Peace Region (7B), British Columbia.... 10 Figure 4. Brewster Mountain-Nabesche River survey area (1991), showing mountain goat observations from 1991 and 2014 inventories, Peace Region (7B), British Columbia.... 12 Figure 5. Frequency of habitat types used by groups of mountain goats when first observed, North Peace mountain goat inventory, July 2014, Peace Region (7B), British Columbia.... 13 Figure 6. Activity of mountain goat groups when first observed, North Peace mountain goat inventory, July 2014, Peace Region (7B), British Columbia.... 13 Figure 7. Mountain goat population management units (PMUs) in the North Peace survey area of the Peace Region (7B), British Columbia.... 14 List of Tables Table 1. Sightability of mountain goat populations in areas comparable to habitats observed in the North Peace mountain goat inventory.... 9 Table 2. Total number of mountain goats observed in each population management unit (PMU) during the 2014 North Peace mountain goat inventory, Peace Region (7B), British Columbia.... 11 Table 3. Observed ratios of sex-age categories and density estimates by PMU for the North Peace 2014 mountain goat inventory, Peace Region (7B), British Columbia.... 11 Table 4. Comparison of mountain goat inventories conducted in the Peace Region (7B). Data shows observed numbers only, uncorrected for sightability.... 12 4

1.0 Introduction 1.1 Background Mountain goats (Oreamnos americanus) are fairly widespread across the Peace Region of northeastern British Columbia (BC) and are an important species to First Nations, resident and non-resident hunters, and wildlife enthusiasts. The population of mountain goats in the Peace Region in 2014 was estimated between 3,000 to 5,000 animals and population status was reported as stable (FLNRO unpub. 2014). However, the current status of mountain goat populations and distribution within the Peace Region is not well known due to a lack of recent, comprehensive inventories. Mountain goats are sensitive to over-harvest, as females and males can be difficult to distinguish in the field, resulting in the potential for a portion of harvest being females (Cote & Festa-Bianchet 2003). This is further compounded by the late age of reproduction for females (approximately 4-5 years of age; Festa-Bianchet & Cote 2008), which can result in population declines when a high female harvest is occurring. Within the Peace Region, mountain goat harvest is regulated through a General Open Season (GOS) north of the Peace River where mountain goat populations are remote and hunter access is more difficult, and through a Limited Entry Hunt (LEH) draw system in the South Peace (Management Units 7-19, 7-21, 7-22 and 7-31). Across the region, however, several mountain goat hunting closure areas have been established where high female harvest has occurred and where populations are more susceptible to over-harvest due to greater access (Figure 1). Until recently, inventories of mountain goat populations in the Peace Region have been done sporadically, were disjointed or not inclusive, and have been focussed on areas with industrial pressures, not population based. Due to a lack of comprehensive survey data, mountain goat populations have been managed conservatively to minimize risk of overharvest, especially in populations with greater access. To maintain sustainable populations, while still maintaining hunting harvest opportunities, a five-year (2013-2018) population assessment for mountain goats was proposed by regional Ministry of Forests, Lands, and Natural Resource Operations wildlife biologists to provide current biological data for their management. This population assessment has the following objectives: obtain current and accurate population estimates for mountain goats in the Peace Region; identify Population Management Units (PMUs) for mountain goat populations; obtain sex and age composition data (where possible) to provide a measure of survival, recruitment and population structure (e.g., ratios of age-sex categories). This report summarizes results from year two of the five year project. Year One of the project included four management units (7-19, 7-21, 7-22, and 7-31) in the South Peace area of the Peace Region (Figure 2; Goddard 2013). 5

Figure 1. Summary of mountain goat harvest zones, general open season areas, and hunting closures in the Peace Region (7B), British Columbia. 2.0 Methods 2.1 Study Area The 2014 North Peace mountain goat inventory included portions of four management units (7-36, 7-43, 7-57 and 7-37) and included approximately 5,500 km 2 of mountain goat range (Figure 2). The area surveyed included the high-elevation mountain goat habitat of the Rocky Mountains, but did not include the eastern foothills or canyon habitats in the four MUs. Biogeoclimatic zones surveyed included the Boreal Altai Fescue Alpine zone and the Engelmann Spruce-Subalpine Fir zone. 6

2.2 Survey Methods Areas inventoried were delineated as sample units prior to the survey based on previous inventories, historical occurrence data, and anecdotal knowledge. All sample units were surveyed to ensure a total count of all mountain goats. In addition, if areas appeared to have suitable goat habitat, but fell outside of pre-delineated areas, these were included in the inventory as time and budget allowed. Figure 2. Management units surveyed during the July 2014 North Peace mountain goat inventory and during year one of the 5-year population assessment (July 2013), Peace Region (7B), British Columbia. Aerial surveys were conducted from July 3-11, 2014, between 04:00 and 14:00 hours, or when daily temperatures were below 14 C. The survey period was selected to avoid daily periods of high temperatures and to increase chances of observing goats during peaks of activity (RISC 2002). A Bell 206 Jet Ranger was used to fly mountain complexes beginning at treeline and working upwards in elevation (Gonzalez-Voyer et al. 2001, 7

RISC 2002). The primary navigator sat next to the pilot and two observers were located in the back, with the recorder being located behind the pilot. Flight lines and locations of all animals were recorded on a Garmin GPSmap 60Cx hand held GPS unit. Topographic maps were viewed digitally on an ipad2 (IOS 6.1.3), using the application GIS Pro. Realtime tracking and flight lines were shown and recorded in GIS Pro during surveying as to reduce replication of survey areas. All observers scanned for mountain goats and classification of animals was conducted by experienced biologists (Ministry of FLNRO wildlife biologists Alicia Woods, Dan Lirette and Julie Kline). Locations of all animals were recorded as decimal degrees latitude and longitude. Mountain goats were classified as nanny, billy, kid, yearling, and 2-year old, following level 3 classification (RISC 2002). In the event that yearling and 2-year old animals could not be distinguished, they were classified as sub-adults. Classification of animals was based on moult patterns, body size, and horn morphology (RISC 2002). Mountain goats that could not be accurately identified were classified as either unclassified adult, unclassified sub-adult (either yearling or 2-year old), or simply unclassified. Population Management Units (PMUs) are defined as the geographic area that represents the year-round range of a big game population, while keeping interchange with other populations to a minimum, and are the spatial scale at which harvest management regimes are applied for mountain goats (MFLNRO 2013). This year, PMUs were delineated (post-survey), based on locations of mountain goat sightings from both current and historical surveys, topographical features that would limit movement between PMUs, and anecdotal knowledge. Incidental species were recorded while searching for mountain goats; however the helicopter did not vary from the search path to allow for their classification. The point locations recorded for incidentals did not necessarily fall above the actual location of the group; rather points were recorded from the helicopter s location when animals were spotted. 2.3 Sightability Recognizing that not all mountain goats would be seen during the survey (Cichowski et al. 1994, Gonzalez-Voyer et al. 2001, Poole 2007, Festa-Bianchet & Cote 2008), a sightability correction factor (SCF) was applied to the total number of mountain goats counted to obtain corrected population estimates at the Population Management Unit scale. Published literature was used to attain a SCF that would be acceptable for the survey area in the absence of a mark-recapture study, which was not within the scope of this project. For interior populations of mountain goats, the average SCF can range from 60-85% (Mountain Goat Management Team 2010; Table 1). Considering the mountainous, highelevation, rugged habitats occupied by mountain goats across the 2014 North Peace survey area and the best available science from comparative habitats, a sightability of 65% was assumed to be appropriate (Poole 2006). 8

Assuming 65% of mountain goats were observed during the inventory, a SCF of 1.54 was applied to the total count of mountain goats for each population management unit (Procter & Iredale 2012, G. Kuzyk, pers. comm.): SCF Calculation: SCF = 100 / percent sightability SCF Calculation for North Peace Mountain Goat PMUs: SCF = 100 / 65 SCF = 1.54 The sightability correction factor (SCF) is multiplied to the total observed count of mountain goats (Corrected estimate for 100 observed goats = 100 goats*1.54 = 254 goats). Table 1. Sightability of mountain goat populations in areas comparable to habitats observed in the North Peace mountain goat inventory. Study Area Sightability Reference North Thompson 60-70% Procter & Iredale 2012 Purcell Mountains Rocky Mountains 63% Poole 2007 West-central Alberta 69.5% Gonzalez-Voyer et al. 2001 Cascades & Olympic Ranges, Washington 79% Rice et al. 2009 Babine Mountains 68% Cichowski et al. 1994 East Kootenays 65% Poole 2013 3.0 Results The survey was flown between July 3-11, 2014 for a total cost of $71,278.06 including helicopter charter and fuel and accommodations while in the field. Weather conditions were favourable throughout the survey period. Survey conditions varied from clear skies and sunny, to overcast with 100% cloud cover. The maximum temperature recorded during surveying was 14 C, and the minimum temperature was 2 C. All high-elevation, rock and subalpine habitats that appeared to be suitable mountain goat habitat were surveyed. The search area, which included western portions of Management Units 7-36, 7-43 and 7-57, was expanded into MU 7-37, as it appeared mountain goats utilized habitats on both sides of the height of land. Eastern portions of MUs 7-43 and 7-57 were not surveyed during the 2014 survey due to a lack of funds, and because populations are believed to be separate from those occurring in the high-elevation habitats to the west. Mountain goats were observed in all management units flown during the survey (Figure 3). During the survey a total of 290 mountain goats were observed (77 males, 109 females, 4 unclassified adults, 55 kids, 21 yearlings, 21 two-year olds, and 3 unclassified goats; Table 2). The total corrected population estimate, assuming 65% of mountain 9

goats were observed, for the North Peace study area is 446 mountain goats (Table 2). High concentrations of mountain goats were observed in the Brewster Mountain area (MU 7-36), whereas areas to the north and west, mountain goat observations were more scattered and fewer goats were observed (Figure 3). Another significant concentration of mountain goats was observed in the Mt. McCusker-Sikanni Chief Mtn. area (MU 7-37 & MU 7-57). Areas between Brewster Mtn. and Mt. McCusker showed high mountain goat capability, but only scattered observations (Figure 3). Figure 3. Locations of observations of mountain goats from the 2014 North Peace mountain goat inventory, Peace Region (7B), British Columbia. 10

Table 2. Total number of mountain goats observed in each population management unit (PMU) during the 2014 North Peace mountain goat inventory, Peace Region (7B), British Columbia. Uncl. Subadult PMU MU Billies Nannies Adult Kids a Uncl. Total Brewster 7-36 7-37 33 61 3 35 27 1 160 246 Rockies 7-36 7-43 7-57 7-37 Total Corrected* 41 48 1 20 15 2 127 196 Foothills b 7-43 3 4 Total Observed 77 109 4 55 42 3 290 Total Corrected* 118 168 6 85 65 4 446 * Corrected number of mountain goats estimated based on the total observed mountain goats including a sightability correction factor, assuming 65% of the population was observed. a Sub-adults include both yearling and 2-year olds. b Only a small portion of the Foothills PMU was surveyed in 2014. An inventory planned for 2015 will provide more complete population information for this PMU. Ratios of sex-age categories for the entire survey area were 29 kids:100 adult goats and 22 sub-adults:100 adult goats. Table 3 shows the ratios for each PMU in the North Peace survey area. The mean group size of mountain goats was 3.2 goats (SE = 0.38, range = 1 to 25, n = 91 groups). Previous surveys have been conducted in the Brewster Mountain-Nabesche River area (Figure 4), allowing for comparison with the current year s count to determine a population trend. Direct comparison of the observed number of mountain goats, uncorrected for sightability, from 1991, 1998 and 2014 show the population has increased from 56 mountain goats in 1991, to 62 in 1998, and to 155 in 2014 (MoE 1991, Wood 2002). Densities of mountain goats in the 2014 North Peace population management units are generally lower compared to those in the South Peace area of the Peace Region (Table 4). Table 3. Observed ratios of sex-age categories and density estimates by PMU for the North Peace 2014 mountain goat inventory, Peace Region (7B), British Columbia. PMU Survey Area (km 2 ) Kids:100 Adults Subadults:100 Adults Kids:100 Non-kids Density Uncorrected (goats/100 km 2 ) Density Corrected* (goats/100 km 2 ) Brewster 2,063 36.1 27.8 54.7 8 goats:100 km 2 12 goats:100 km 2 Rockies 2,244 22.2 16.7 14.3 6 goats:100 km 2 8 goats:100 km 2 Total 4,307 29.4 22.5 32.5 7 goats:100 km 2 10 goats:100 km 2 *Estimated corrected for sightability. 11

Table 4. Comparison of mountain goat inventories conducted in the Peace Region (7B). Data shows observed numbers only, uncorrected for sightability. Total Goats Kids: 100 Adults Density (no./100 km 2 ) Survey Area/PMU Survey Year North Peace Brewster PMU July 2014 160 36.1 8 goats:100 km 2 Rockies PMU July 2014 127 22.2 6 goats:100 km 2 South Peace Clearwater-Carbon PMU July 2013 149 28.1 8 goats:100 km 2 Trapper Mountain PMU July 2013 78 50.0 30 goats:100 km 2 Sukunka PMU July 2013 240 22.9 13 goats:100 km 2 Quintette PMU July 2013 6 50.0 7 goats:100 km 2 Wapiti-Monkman PMU July 2013 176 22.3 28 goats:100 km 2 Belcout PMU July 2013 192 24.4 22 goats:100 km 2 Figure 4. Brewster Mountain-Nabesche River survey area (1991), showing mountain goat observations from 1991 and 2014 inventories, Peace Region (7B), British Columbia. 12

Number of Groups Number of Groups North Peace Mountain Goat Inventory 2014 Mountain goats were observed in a variety of habitat classes during the survey. The majority of mountain goat groups were in rock (62%), on grassy slopes (23%), or on scree slopes (11%; Figure 5). Over half of the groups/individuals were moving when first observed (36% running, 35% walking), whereas fewer groups were standing (27%; Figure 6). 60 56 50 40 30 20 10 0 10 3 21 1 Habitat Type Figure 5. Frequency of habitat types used by groups of mountain goats when first observed, North Peace mountain goat inventory, July 2014, Peace Region (7B), British Columbia. 35 32 33 30 25 25 20 15 10 5 0 Walking Standing Running no data Activity Type 1 Figure 6. Activity of mountain goat groups when first observed, North Peace mountain goat inventory, July 2014, Peace Region (7B), British Columbia. 13

Two Population Management Units (PMUs) were identified in the North Peace survey area: Brewster PMU and Rockies PMU (Figure 7). A third, Foothills PMU, will likely encompass mountain goat populations residing in the lower elevation foothill habitats to the east, which were not surveyed during the 2014 survey due to limited funds. Population management unit areas were designated based on the distribution of mountain goats observed during the 2014 survey, habitat availability, past survey data, anecdotal information from regional biologists, guide outfitters and hunters, and topographical features that are likely to influence distribution and barriers to dispersal (Figure 7). Figure 7. Mountain goat population management units (PMUs) in the North Peace survey area of the Peace Region (7B), British Columbia. Incidental species observed during the inventory included 217 caribou (Rangifer tarandus), 99 Stone s sheep (Ovis dalli stonei), 43 elk (Cervaus elaphus), 10 moose (Alces alces), 2 mule deer (Odocoileus hemionus), 52 grizzly bear (Ursus arctos), and 2 black bear (Ursus americanus). 14

4.0 Discussion The primary objective of the North Peace mountain goat inventory was to obtain a current and accurate estimate of population size, composition, and distribution across the study area and to define Population Management Units. A total count with appropriate sightability correction factor applied would inform harvest strategies for mountain goat populations in the North Peace. Relatively little population information was available for mountain goats in the North Peace area (MUs 7-36, 7-43, and 7-57). In the past, focussed inventories occurred for the sub-population on Brewster Mountain (MU 7-36; MoE 1991, Wood 2002), but no other inventories have been conducted for mountain goat populations north of the Peace Arm of the Williston Reservoir. To assess population trends, inventory data for the Brewster Mountain-Nabesche River area was compared for three inventory years (1991, 1998, and 2014). Since 1991, mountain goat populations appear to be increasing in the Brewster Mountain-Nabesche River area. Survey timing, area and effort were similar between the three surveys (MoE 1991, Wood 2002). Since 1991, mountain goat populations in the Brewster Mountain area have increased from approximately 56 mountain goats in 1991, to 155 mountain goats observed in 2014 (both uncorrected estimates). Population increases have also been observed in the South Peace study area, including the Clearwater-Carbon PMU and on Bullmoose Mountain, in the Sukunka PMU (Goddard 2013). In the Rockies PMU, population trends cannot be assessed as no previous inventories have been conducted. Mountain goat distribution throughout the PMU was scattered, and density of mountain goats in this PMU is much lower than other recently inventoried PMUs in the South Peace (Table 4; Goddard 2013). Habitat appeared to be highly suitable for mountain goats throughout the survey area, and areas that supported greater densities of mountain goats (e.g. Brewster Mountain, Mt. McCusker) appeared to have similar suitability than areas that had lower observations of mountain goats. It is unlikely that hunting pressure is the reason for low densities observed in the Rockies PMU. Even though the area is on a GOS harvest regime, there is low harvest reported from this PMU due to the inaccessibility to the area (MFLNRO unpub. data). Further, the South Peace PMUs are more accessible, have a higher level of habitat disturbance, and potential for increased predation due to these habitat changes, and yet densities in the South Peace PMU are still higher than those observed in the Brewster and Rockies PMU. The perceived absence of mineral licks in the Rockies PMU and western areas of the Brewster PMU may explain the lower densities of mountain goats in these areas (Wood 2002). Mountain goats can be dependent on mineral licks for an important supplement in their spring and summer diet (Hebert and McTaggart-Cowan 1971, Ayotte et al. 2008, Corbould et al. 2010, Mountain Goat Management Team 2010, Poole et al. 2010). A significant mineral lick exists at the south end of Brewster Mountain, which is heavily used by mountain goats in the area, and has been recognized for its importance as a Wildlife Habitat Area (Wood 2002, MoE 2014). However, the presence of other significant low- or high-elevation mineral licks throughout the Brewster and Rockies 15

PMU are unknown. Four mineral licks occur east of the Ospika River that are likely utilized by a small sub-population of mountain goats in the southern-most extent of the Rockies PMU (Corbould et al. 2010). Although only a few mountain goats were observed in this area during the survey, anecdotal reports suggest this portion of the PMU has supported a mountain goat population in the past; however, this has never been quantified (R. Woods, pers. comm.). In other areas across the Peace Region, mountain goats are known to frequent both dry and wet mineral licks within their range, when available, and that small groups or sub-populations of mountain goats can often be closely associated with mineral licks during the summer and fall months (Ayotte et al. 2008, D. Cary, pers. comm., M. Hammett, pers. comm.). What is still undetermined is whether the absence of mineral licks can be the reason for a lack of mountain goat populations or lower densities of mountain goats in otherwise suitable habitats. A sightability correction factor of 65% was used for the North Peace mountain goat PMUs based on the best available science in habitats comparable to the study area (Cichowski et al. 1994; Gonzalez-Voyer et al. 2001, Poole 2007, Rice et al. 2009, Mountain Goat Management Team 2010, Procter & Iredale 2012, Poole 2013). It is probable that sightability varies for different sex and age groups, habitat types (e.g. timbered habitats vs. alpine habitats), and for group size. However, given the objective of this survey to obtain a total population estimate (of the North Peace area), a sightability of 65% is appropriate for estimating a conservative total population size (Poole 2007, Rice et al. 2009). Population Management Units (PMUs) were delineated for two populations of mountain goats north of the Peace Arm of the Williston Reservoir, based on information from this survey, known mountain goat ecology, including home range size, habitats, movements and distribution of goats. Mountain goat populations residing along the height of land are known to cross over, using habitats on both the eastern and western sides of the height of land (R. Woods, pers. comm., M. Hammett, pers. comm.), and as such, PMU boundaries do not follow Management Unit lines. Further, radio telemetry studies on mineral lick use by mountain goats in the Ospika drainage, confirmed that monitored mountain goats did not cross the Ospika River for the duration of the six-year study (Corbould et al. 2010). The distinction between the Brewster PMU and the Rockies PMU was based on topography and habitat, and likelihood of dispersal of goats between these two areas. It is likely that both the Brewster and Rockies PMU have sub-populations within the larger PMU. Also, information from this survey enabled us to delineate a third PMU in the foothills habitats to the east (Foothills PMU). The Foothills PMU was not surveyed in entirety in 2014, but will be assessed in 2015, conditional upon available funding. Based on the current inventory, mountain goat populations in the North Peace area of the Peace Region appear to be stable and potentially increasing in both PMUs. Results from this inventory will provide scientific support for the management of sustainable mountain goat harvest by both resident and non-resident hunters in the North Peace area. Future work should be conducted in the proposed Foothills PMU, encompassing mountain goat habitats to the east of the Rockies and Brewster PMUs in Management Units 7-43, 7-57, and 7-58. In addition, northwestern portions of the Rockies PMU were not completed in 16

entirety in 2014 due to funding constraints. Several mountain complexes will need to be surveyed in 2015 to provide a complete population estimate for the Rockies PMU. 5.0 Acknowledgements Dan Lirette, Julie Kline and Lynn Avis were primary observers from the Fish and Wildlife division of the Ministry of Forests, Lands and Natural Resource Operations office in Fort St John. Russell Vickers from Qwest Helicopters provided safe and efficient flying for the duration of the survey. Funding for this inventory was provided by the Habitat Conservation Trust Foundation, Northern BC Guides Association, and the North Peace Rod and Gun Club. The Ministry of Forests, Lands and Natural Resource Operations recognizes the Habitat Conservation Trust Foundation and anglers, hunters, trappers and guides who contribute to the Trust, for making a significant financial contribution to support the 5-Year Mountain Goat Population Assessment. Without such support, this project would not have been possible. 6.0 References Ayotte, J.B., K.L. Parker, and M.P. Gillingham. 2008. Use of natural licks by four species of ungulates in northern British Columbia. Journal of Mammalogy 89: 1041-1050. Cichowski, D.B., D. Haas, & G. Schultze. 1994. A method for estimating mountain goat numbers in the Babine Mountains Recreation Area, British Columbia. Proceedings of the Biennial Symposium of the Northern Wild Sheep and Goat Council 6: 56-64. Corbould, F.B., J.B. Ayotte, M.D. Wood, and G.W. Blackburn. 2010. Experimental evaluation of logging impacts on mineral-lick use by mountain goats, north-central British Columbia. Peace/Williston Fish and Wildlife Compensation Program Report No. 343. 65 pp plus appendices. Cote, S.D. & M. Festa-Bianchet. 2003. Mountain goat. Pages 1061-1075 in G.A. Feldhamer, B.C. Thompson & J.A. Chapman, editors. Wild Mammals of North America: biology, management and conservation. John Hopkins University Press, Baltimore, Maryland, USA. Festa-Bianchet, M. & S.D. Cote. 2008. Mountain goats: ecology, behavior and conservation of an alpine ungulate. Island Press, Washington, DC, USA. Goddard, A.D. 2013. Mountain goat inventory South Peace 2013. Technical Report, Fish & Wildlife Section, Peace Region, Ministry of Forests, Lands, and Natural Resource Operations, Fort St. John, BC. 17

Gonzalez-Voyer, A., M. Festa-Bianchet, and K.G. Smith. 2001. Efficiency of aerial surveys of mountain goats. Wildlife Society Bulletin 29: 140-144. Hebert, D.M. and I. McTaggart-Cowan. 1971. Natural salt licks as a part of the ecology of the mountain goat. Canadian Journal of Zoology 49: 605-610. Ministry of Environment (MoE). 1991. Brewster Mtn.-Nabesche River mountain goat inventory. Unpublished data, Peace Region, Fort St. John, BC. Ministry of Environment (MoE). 2014. Approved Wildlife Habitat Areas Brewster mountain goat lick 9-001. <http://www.env.gov.bc.ca/wld/frpa/iwms/wha.html> Ministry of Forests, Lands and Natural Resource Operations (MFLNRO). 2013. Draft mountain goat harvest management procedure. Ministry of Forests, Lands and Natural Resource Operations, Victoria, BC. Mountain Goat Management Team. 2010. Management plan for the mountain goat (Oreamnos americanus) in British Columbia. Prepared for the BC Ministry of Environment, Victoria, BC. 87 pp. Poole, K.G. 2006. A population review of mountain goats in the Kootenay Region. Prepared by Aurora Wildlife Research, for the BC Ministry of Environment, Kootenay Region, Nelson, BC. Poole, K.G. 2007. Does survey effort influence sightability of mountain goats Oreamnos americanus during aerial surveys? Wildlife Biology 13:113-119. Poole, K.G. 2013. Mountain goat survey in the Flathead and Wigwam valleys, British Columbia, August 2013. Prepared by Aurora Wildlife Research, for the BC Ministry of Forests, Lands, and Natural Resource Operations, Cranbrook, BC. Poole, K.G., K.D. Bachmann, and I.E. Teske. 2010. Mineral lick use by GPS radiocollared mountain goats in southeastern British Columbia. Western North American Naturalist 70: 208-217. Procter, C. & F. Iredale. 2012. North Thompson River Mountain Goat Population Survey: Management Units 3-43A, B & C and 3-44C. Technical Report, Fish & Wildlife Division, Ministry of Forests, Lands and Natural Resource Operations, Kamloops, BC. 6 pp. Resources Inventory Committee (RISC). Aerial-based Inventory Methods for Selected Ungulates: Bison, Mountain Goat, Mountain Sheep, Moose, Elk, Deer, and Caribou. Version 2.0. 2002. Victoria, BC, British Columbia Ministry of Sustainable Resource Management: Terrestrial Information Branch. 18

Rice, C.G., K.J. Jenkins, and W.-Y. Chang. 2009. A sightability model for mountain goats. Journal of Wildlife Management 73:468-478. Wood, M.D. 2002. Summer inventory of mountain goats and Stone s sheep in the Nabesche River drainage, north-eastern British Columbia, 1998. Peace/Williston Fish and Wildlife Compensation Program Report No. 265. 14 pp plus appendices. 7.0 Personal Communications Gerry Kuzyk. Ungulate Specialist Biologist, Ministry of Forests, Lands and Natural Resource Operations, Victoria, BC. September 2013. Darwin Cary. Guide Outfitter, Kelowna, BC. May 2014. Mike Hammett. Guide Outfitter, Fort St. John, BC. September 2014. Rob Woods. Wildlife Biologist, Fort St. John, BC. July 2014. 19

8.0 Appendices Figure 7. Survey flight lines from North Peace mountain goat inventory, July 2014, Peace Region (7B), British Columbia. 20