SCOTTISH ADVISORY COMMITTEE ON DISTINCTION AWARDS

SG/2018/101 SCOTTISH ADVISORY COMMITTEE ON DISTINCTION AWARDS 2017 Annual Report Published December 2018

Contents Foreword 1 Page Report on the 2017 Awards Round 2 Appendices A. List of award holders in Scotland as at 30 September 2017 5 B. Analysis by age group and category of award holders who retired in the 2017 awards round 11 Analysis of award holders as at 30 September 2017 C. Age group 12 D. Nature of contract 13 E. NHS Board 14 F. 15 G. Gender 18 H. Ethnic Origin 19 Membership of SACDA I. For the 2018 awards round 20

Foreword This is the nineteenth Annual Report of the Scottish Advisory Committee on Distinction Awards (SACDA). This report is freely available to consultants, NHS Boards, and all others who have an interest in the awards scheme. The Cabinet Secretary for Health and Sport, Shona Robison, took the decision to continue to freeze the awards budget in 2017, meaning that no new distinction awards were granted. The committee was required only to review existing awards in line with the normal five-yearly and supplementary review procedures. Accordingly, there is no analysis of awards granted, or of the Scoring System used by SACDA in granting awards. Instead, the report includes a list of Distinction Award holders in Scotland as at 30 September 2017, together with supporting statistical analysis of the award holding and general consultant population. All statistics in the report are based on consultant data extracted from the SWISS database, which is maintained by NHS Boards. SACDA is aware that this data is not robust, due to difficulties in data collection. This is particularly in relation to contract type and honorary contract holders and this should be taken into account when viewing the tables. SACDA has continued to work with NHS Boards to improve the quality of the data. Ken Thomson Chair 1

Report on the 2017 Awards Round (1 October 2016 30 September 2017) Introduction The Scottish Advisory Committee on Distinction Awards (SACDA) was set up in November 1998 to replace the Scottish Sub-Committee of the Advisory Committee on Distinction Awards (ACDA). SACDA, a non-departmental public body, acts on behalf of the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Sport in deciding which medical and dental consultants in the NHS in Scotland should receive distinction awards for outstanding professional work. As stated in the foreword to the report, no new awards were granted in the 2017 awards round. However, SACDA remained responsible for the operation of the Distinction Awards scheme in Scotland. The Advisory Committee on Clinical Excellence Awards (ACCEA) is responsible for its operation in England and Wales. Although the two committees are completely independent, close contact between the Chairs and Medical Directors of SACDA and ACCEA has been maintained. We attach weight to ensuring general consistency of approach. Membership of SACDA during the year ended 30 September 2017 Mr Ken Thomson Chair Professor Charles Swainson Medical Director / Vice-Chair Dr Catherine Calderwood (Chief Medical Officer) ex-officio SGHSCD Professor Alan Cameron Dr Frances Dow Professor Brenda Gibson Mr Paul Gray (Chief Executive NHS Scotland) ex-officio SGHSCD Professor Gordon McInnes Ms Gillian Mawdsley Details of SACDA committee members for next year s (2018) awards round are set out in Appendix I. Award holders As at 30 September 2017 there were 253 holders of awards in Scotland, which is 4.5% of the total number of consultants (5584) in Scotland, as set out below: 2

Award Award Holders all Consultants A+ 16 0.3 A 51 0.9 B 186 3.3 Total 253 4.5 A list of all award holders in Scotland as at 30 September 2017 is at Appendix A and related statistical analysis is set out in Appendices B to H. 2017 saw a steady number of retirements amongst consultants, both award holding and non-award holding. Five-Yearly and Supplementary Reviews of Awards During the 2017 awards round, 56 awards (43 B, 11 A, and 2 A+) were reviewed by SACDA. The Committee recommended continuation of all 56 awards. Scoring System SACDA again scored all of the five-yearly review and supplementary review paperwork using the standard scoring system and criteria for awards that would have been applied to new applicants. As with the assessment of applicants for new awards, the scoring results formed the basis for the committee s evaluation of award holders under review but the final decisions reflected SACDA s overall judgement and were not based purely on scores. The vast majority of award holders obtained scores at or above their original scores at initial award. Although the scores for a few award holders had fallen slightly, these were still within the range for that award level. Consequently, all award holders for 2016-17 continue to hold the same level of award. Full details of the SACDA scoring system may be found on the SACDA website at: http://www.shsc.scot/media/22378/2013-02-sacda-scoring-guidelines.pdf Equality and Diversity An analysis of Awards by age (Appendix C), gender (Appendix G) and ethnic origin (Appendix H) has been made. However, it should be noted that as the Awards are closed, inequalities cannot be addressed and can only be analysed retrospectively with regards to the diversity of Awards Holders as at 2011. In addition, it should be noted that 125 (49%) Award holders did not declare ethnicity. Guide for 2018 The SACDA Online system was used again in the 2017 five-yearly review round for the submission of all documentation. At the time of writing, no new Guide to the Scheme 3

has been published and therefore the same system was used again for the 2018 fiveyearly review round. Forward Planning As advised in the 2012 report, an independent, UK-wide review of the Clinical Excellence and Distinction Awards schemes, was carried out by the Doctors and Dentists Review Body in 2011. The report was published on 17 December 2012 and the former Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing stated that consideration of the report s recommendations would be taken forward on a UK basis by the four Health Departments. SACDA supports the recommendations and is keen to see some progress in implementing the report in Scotland but understands that this will form part of future discussions around consultant contracts which will form part of wider work on a whole-system approach to achieving a sustainable healthcare service for 2020 and beyond and improving doctors working lives. 4

Appendix A Distinction Award Holders in Scotland As at 30 September 2017 The nominal roll listing all consultants in NHS Scotland can be found on the SACDA website at: http://www.shsc.scot/meetings/scottish-advisory-committee-on-distinction-awards/current-awardsround-1/ Award Name Initials Speciality Employing Authority Level Date Abu-Arafeh IA Paediatrics NHS Forth Valley B 2008 Ahmed S Public Health Medicine NHS National Services Scotland B 2008 Aitman T General Medicine NHS Lothian B 2010 Akyol A General Surgery NHS Lothian B 2005 Anderson J General Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2009 Andrews P Anaesthetics NHS Lothian A 2009 Arends M General Medicine NHS Lothian B 2008 Ayoub A Dentistry NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2007 Bagg J Dentistry NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A 2006 Bain M Public Health Medicine NHS National Services Scotland B 2009 Baldacchino A General Psychiatry NHS Fife B 2009 Baxter G Diagnostic Radiology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2005 Belch J General Medicine NHS Tayside A+ 2008 Bhattacharya S Obstetrics and Gynaecology NHS Grampian B 2008 Bhopal R General Medicine NHS Lothian A 2004 Binning A Anaesthetics NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2009 Booth M Anaesthetics NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2007 Brady A General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2009 Brenkel I Orthopaedic Surgery NHS Fife B 2007 Breusch S Orthopaedic Surgery NHS Lothian B 2010 Bridges A General Medicine NHS Forth Valley B 2006 Brittenden J General Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2009 Brodie M General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A 2002 Burns H Public Health Medicine NHS Health Scotland A+ 2006 Byrne D General Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2010 Cameron A Obstetrics and Gynaecology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A 2008 Cameron D General Medicine NHS Lothian B 2008 Campbell H General Medicine NHS Lothian A 2006 Cantwell R General Psychiatry NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2008 Carey F Histopathology NHS Tayside B 2007 Carter C General Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2005 Carton A Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery NHS Lanarkshire B 2009 Chambers W Anaesthetics NHS Grampian A 2001 Clarkson J Dentistry NHS Tayside B 2009 Clift B Orthopaedic Surgery NHS Tayside B 2009 Medical Microbiology & Coia J Virology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2008 Colvin J Anaesthetics NHS Tayside B 2008 Conn I Urology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A 2010 Connacher A General Medicine NHS Tayside B 2008 5

Appendix A Connell JMC General Medicine NHS Tayside A+ 2005 Connolly M General Psychiatry NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2009 Cook B Anaesthetics NHS Lothian B 2010 Cook A General Psychiatry NHS Lanarkshire B 2010 Cooper S Psychiatry of Learning NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde Disability A 2009 Critchley H General Medicine NHS Lothian A+ 2009 Crossman D General Medicine NHS Fife A 2013 Cruickshank M Obstetrics and Gynaecology NHS Grampian B 2009 Culligan D Haematology NHS Grampian B 2009 Daniel M Anaesthetics NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2010 Davis C Paediatric Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2007 De Caestecker L Public Health Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2004 Dean J Clinical Genetics NHS Grampian B 2006 Dempster J ENT Surgery NHS Ayrshire and Arran B 2009 Dennis M General Medicine NHS Lothian A 2007 Dhillon B Ophthalmology NHS Lothian B 2005 Diament R General Surgery NHS Ayrshire and Arran B 2009 Dillon J General Medicine NHS Tayside B 2010 Dixon J General Surgery NHS Lothian A 2010 Docherty J General Medicine NHS Highland B 2010 Dominiczak A General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A+ 2007 Dominiczak M Chemical Pathology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2000 Dow E Chemical Pathology NHS Tayside B 2006 Doyle E Anaesthetics NHS Lothian B 2009 Dreyer J General Surgery NHS Dumfries and Galloway B 2010 Dunlop M General Medicine NHS Lothian A+ 2010 Dunlop D General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2007 Dunn L Neurosurgery NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2009 Elder A Geriatric Medicine NHS Lothian B 2010 El-Shafei H Cardiothoracic Surgery NHS Grampian B 2009 Eteiba H General Medicine National Waiting Times Centre B 2008 Evans A Histopathology NHS Tayside B 2009 Evans T General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2008 Evans AJ Diagnostic Radiology NHS Tayside B 2005 Fearon K General Medicine NHS Lothian B 2006 Felix D Dentistry NES A 2009 Ferguson J Emergency Medicine NHS Grampian B 2005 Findlay I General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A 2006 Fitzsimons E Haematology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2002 Flapan A General Medicine NHS Lothian B 2008 Fleming S Histopathology NHS Tayside A 2009 Forsythe J General Surgery NHS Lothian A 2005 Fox R Communicable Diseases NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2008 Fox J General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2007 Fraser A Public Health Medicine NHS Health Scotland B 2006 Gallacher S General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2007 Garden O General Medicine NHS Lothian A+ 2004 6

Appendix A Gibson B Haematology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A+ 2009 Gillespie S Histopathology NHS Fife A 2005 Going J Histopathology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2001 Goldberg D Public Health Medicine NHS National Services Scotland A 2005 Grant R Neurology NHS Lothian B 2006 Gray A Emergency Medicine NHS Lothian B 2008 Grosset D Neurology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2005 Haddock G Paediatric Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2006 Hannaford P General Medicine NHS Grampian B 2006 Harrison D Chemical Pathology NHS Lothian A+ 2009 Haslett C General Medicine NHS Lothian A+ 2001 Hay A Forensic Psychiatry NHS Highland B 2008 Hayes P General Medicine NHS Lothian B 2003 Hendry A Geriatric Medicine NHS Lanarkshire B 2005 Herriot R Haematology NHS Grampian A 2009 Heys SD General Surgery NHS Grampian A 2008 Hislop W Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery NHS Ayrshire and Arran B 2005 Holyoake T Haematology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2006 Hood J Medical Microbiology & NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde Virology B 2005 Horgan P General Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2007 Houston J Diagnostic Radiology NHS Tayside B 2010 Hughes R Obstetrics and Gynaecology NHS Lothian B 2007 Hunter J General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2009 Hussain S ENT Surgery NHS Tayside B 2008 Ibbotson S Dermatology NHS Tayside B 2010 Jardine A General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2006 Johnston P Histopathology NHS Grampian B 2009 Jones B Medical Microbiology & NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde Virology B 2009 Keating J Orthopaedic Surgery NHS Lothian B 2008 Keel A Haematology NHS Lothian B 2007 Kennedy N General Medicine NHS Lanarkshire B 2009 Ker J General Practice NHS Tayside B 2008 Kerr K Histopathology NHS Grampian A 2005 Kidd B General Psychiatry NHS Tayside B 2002 Kinsella J Anaesthetics NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A 2008 Kirk A Cardiothoracic Surgery National Waiting Times Centre B 2009 Kirkpatrick M Paediatrics NHS Tayside B 2009 Knight R General Medicine NHS Lothian B 2004 Lang C General Medicine NHS Tayside B 2007 Langhorne P Geriatric Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A 2006 Large D Orthopaedic Surgery NHS Ayrshire and Arran B 2009 Lawrie S General Psychiatry NHS Lothian B 2008 Lean M General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2002 Lees KR General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A 2005 Leese G General Medicine NHS Tayside B 2005 Leung H Urology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2009 Lipworth B General Medicine NHS Tayside A 2008 7

Appendix A Lumsden M Obstetrics and Gynaecology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A 2007 Macarthur K Cardiothoracic Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A 2009 Macdonald T General Medicine NHS Tayside A+ 2009 Macfadyen UM Paediatrics NHS Forth Valley A 2001 Macfie A Anaesthetics National Waiting Times Centre B 2008 Macgilchrist A General Medicine NHS Lothian B 2010 Mackay T Respiratory Medicine NHS Lothian B 2005 Mackinlay GA Paediatric Surgery NHS Lothian B 2004 Macpherson L Dentistry NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2008 Macrury S General Medicine NHS Highland B 2006 Madhok R General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2003 Mahmood T Obstetrics and Gynaecology NHS Fife A 2006 Mallon E Histopathology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2006 Mathers A Obstetrics and Gynaecology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A 2008 Matthews K General Psychiatry NHS Tayside B 2005 Maxwell S General Medicine NHS Lothian B 2008 Mcalpine L General Medicine NHS Lanarkshire B 2004 Mcalpine C Geriatric Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2008 Mcgarry GW ENT Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A 2010 Mcgrady E Anaesthetics NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2008 Mcgregor J General Surgery NHS Ayrshire and Arran A 2009 Mcinnes I General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A 2009 Mckay P Haematology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2009 Mckay C General Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2008 Mckee R General Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2005 Mckillop G Diagnostic Radiology NHS Lothian B 2009 Mckinlay A General Medicine NHS Grampian B 2010 Mcknight J Endocrinology and Diabetes NHS Lothian B 2008 Mclellan A General Medicine NES A 2009 Mclintock T Anaesthetics NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2010 Mcmurray J General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A+ 2010 Mcritchie H Diagnostic Radiology NHS Borders B 2009 Meddings R Urology NHS Ayrshire and Arran B 2008 Mehta A Paediatrics NHS Tayside B 2008 Mires G Obstetrics and Gynaecology NHS Tayside B 2004 Molloy R General Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2008 Morris A General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2008 Morrison J General Practice NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2007 Morrison R Forensic Psychiatry NHS Forth Valley B 2009 Morton C Dermatology NHS Forth Valley B 2010 Mossey P Dentistry NHS Tayside B 2007 Mountain R ENT Surgery NHS Tayside B 2005 Muir K Neurology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2010 Mumford C Neurology NHS Lothian B 2009 Murchison J Diagnostic Radiology NHS Lothian B 2008 Murray GI Histopathology NHS Grampian B 2005 Murray S General Medicine NHS Lothian B 2008 Murray A Diagnostic Radiology NHS Grampian B 2007 8

Appendix A Nandwani R Genito-Urinary Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2005 Nathwani D Communicable Diseases NHS Tayside A 2009 N'Dow J Urology NHS Grampian B 2009 Neilly J Respiratory Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2009 Newby D General Medicine NHS Lothian B 2007 Nicolson M General Medicine NHS Grampian B 2005 Norman J General Medicine NHS Lothian B 2004 O'dwyer P General Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A 2002 Ogden G Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery NHS Tayside A 2008 O'Kelly T General Surgery NHS Grampian B 2005 Oldroyd K General Medicine National Waiting Times Centre B 2006 Owen P Obstetrics and Gynaecology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2008 Owens D General Psychiatry NHS Lothian A 2002 Pace N Anaesthetics NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2006 Parks R General Medicine NHS Lothian A 2010 Paterson-Brown S General Surgery NHS Lothian A 2009 Patey R Anaesthetics NHS Grampian B 2009 Paton J Paediatrics NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A 2008 Pell J Public Health Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A 2010 Penman I General Surgery NHS Lothian B 2008 Petrie J General Medicine NHS Tayside B 2009 Porteous M Clinical Genetics NHS Lothian A 2009 Ralston S General Medicine NHS Lothian A+ 2009 Ray D Anaesthetics NHS Lothian B 2009 Rees J General Medicine NHS Lothian A 2005 Reid W Geriatric Medicine NES B 2008 Ritchie L Public Health Medicine NHS Grampian A 2007 Robertson I Diagnostic Radiology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2007 Roditi G Diagnostic Radiology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2009 Salter D General Medicine NHS Lothian B 2009 Satsangi J General Medicine NHS Lothian B 2006 Sattar N Chemical Pahtology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2008 Savill J General Medicine NHS Lothian A+ 2005 Seaton R Communicable Diseases NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2009 Seckl J General Medicine NHS Lothian A+ 2009 Serpell M Anaesthetics NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2004 Shearer A Dentistry NES B 2009 Sheikh A General Practice NHS Lothian B 2009 Shimi S General Surgery NHS Tayside B 2005 Siddiqui N Obstetrics and Gynaecology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2006 Simpson A Orthopaedic Surgery NHS Lothian A 2009 Singh J Ophthalmology NHS Lothian B 2008 Small M General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2003 Smith I General Psychiatry NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2003 Smith D General Surgery NHS Tayside B 2008 Stark C Public Health Medicine NHS Highland B 2010 Starr J Geriatric Medicine NHS Lothian B 2006 Steele R General Surgery NHS Tayside A+ 2008 9

Appendix A Stenson B Paediatrics NHS Lothian B 2009 Stonebridge P General Surgery NHS Tayside B 2006 Stott D Geriatric Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2007 Strachan M General Medicine NHS Lothian B 2010 Struthers A General Medicine NHS Tayside A+ 2007 Sullivan F General Practice NHS Fife B 2007 Taha A General Medicine NHS Ayrshire and Arran B 2007 Tait R Haematology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2006 Taylor J Geriatric Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2009 Taylor J General Psychiatry NHS Ayrshire and Arran B 2010 Thomas J Chemical Pathology NHS Lothian B 2009 Thomson L Forensic Psychiatry State Hospital B 2008 Turner ML Blood Transfusion NHS National Services Scotland B 2006 Turner AN General Medicine NHS Lothian B 2008 Uren N General Medicine NHS Lothian B 2009 Walker B General Medicine NHS Lothian A 2010 Walker A Public Health Medicine NHS Tayside B 2009 Walker W Cardiothoracic Surgery NHS Lothian B 2008 Wallace W Paediatrics NHS Lothian A 2008 Walls AWG Dentistry NHS Lothian A 2011 Walsh T General Medicine NHS Lothian B 2007 Walters M General Medicine NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2009 Ward H Public Health Medicine NHS National Services Scotland B 2009 Wardlaw J General Medicine NHS Lothian A 2008 Watson H Haematology NHS Grampian B 2008 Watson S Plastic Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2009 Watt G General Practice NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A 2007 Webb D General Medicine NHS Lothian A+ 2008 Weiler-Mithoff E Plastic Surgery NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2008 Welbury RRR Dentistry NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A 2006 Weller D General Medicine NHS Lothian B 2007 White P ENT Surgery NHS Tayside B 2007 Whyte M General Medicine NHS Lothian A 2013 Wigmore S General Medicine NHS Lothian B 2009 Williams A Chemical Pathology NHS Lothian B 2010 Williams C General Psychiatry NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde B 2006 Willison H Neurology NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde A 2008 Zajicek J Neurology NHS Fife B 2008 10

Appendix B ANALYSIS BY AGE GROUP AND CATEGORY OF AWARD HOLDERS WHO RETIRED Scotland 2017 Awards Round Distinction Award Holders Age Group A+ A B Total Total number of 16 51 186 253 awards Under 65 Number 2 7 18 27 % 12.5% 13.8% 9.7% 10.7% 65 and over Number 2 4 0 6 % 12.5% 7.8% 0 2.4% Total Number 4 11 18 33 % 25% 21.6% 9.7% 13.1% 11

Appendix C ANALYSIS BY AGE GROUP (All Consultants) Scotland as at 30 September 2017 Age Group Award Holders A+ A B Total Non- Award Holders All Consultants Under 35 0 0 0 0 168 168 35-39 0 0 0 0 907 907 40-44 0 0 0 0 1184 1184 45-49 0 1 5 6 1152 1158 50-54 0 5 35 40 997 1037 55-59 3 14 100 117 634 751 60-64 9 25 39 73 1162 235 65+ 4 6 7 17 127 145 Total 16 51 186 253 5314 5584 12

Appendix D ANALYSIS BY NATURE OF CONTRACT Scotland as at 30 September 2017 Nature of Contract A+ A B NON-AWARD HOLDERS Honorary 15 31 54 62 Permanent 1 20 132 5522 Total 16 51 186 5584 13

Appendix E ANALYSIS BY NHS BOARD NHS Board % Per Area Scotland as at 30 September 2017 Award Holders A+ A B Total Non-Award Holders % Per % Per % Per Area Area Area % Per Area All Consultants Ayrshire and Arran 0 0 1 0.4 6 2.2 7 2.5 271 97.5 278 Borders 0 0 0 0 1 0.9 1 0.9 116 99.1 117 Dumfries and Galloway 0 0 0 0 1 1.0 1 1.0 102 99.0 103 Fife 0 0 3 1.2 3 1.2 6 2.3 252 97.7 258 Forth Valley 0 0 1 0.5 4 1.8 5 2.3 212 97.7 217 Grampian 0 0 4 0.7 16 2.8 20 3.5 522 96.5 541 Greater Glasgow & Clyde 3 0.2 18 1.1 64 3.8 85 5.0 1609 95.0 1694 Highland 0 0 0 0 5 2.0 5 2.0 251 98.0 256 Lanarkshire 0 0 0 0 5 1.0 5 2.0 479 99.0 484 Lothian 9 1.0 17 1.8 44 4.7 70 7.4 875 92.6 945 National (1) 1 0.8 3 2.1 11 7.6 15 10.4 129 89.6 144 Orkney 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 9 100.0 9 Shetland 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 12 100.0 12 Tayside 3 0.6 4 0.8 27 5.2 34 6.6 481 93.4 515 Western Isles 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 11 100.0 11 Total 16 0.3 51 0.9 186 3.3 253 4.5 5331 95.5 5584 Note: (1) Includes consultants w orking in National Organisations; NHS National Services Scotland (operating name for the Common Services Agency), NHS Education for Scotland, Healthcare Improvement Scotland, NHS Health Scotland, the Scottish Ambulance Service, the State Hospitals Board for Scotland, the Mental Welfare Commission for Scotland, the National Waiting Times Centre and NHS 24. 14

ANALYSIS BY SPECIALTY Scotland as at 30 September 2017 Appendix F Total of Consultants All Consultants Aw ard Holders Non-Aw ard Holders in A+ A B Total 0 Anaesthetics 768 13.8 0 0 2 0.3% 12 1.6% 14 1.8% 754 98.2% Public Health Medicine 111 2.0 1 0.9% 3 2.7% 7 6.3% 11 9.9% 100 90.1% General Practice 25 0.4 0 0 0 0 3 12.0% 3 12.0% 22 88.0% Occupational Medicine 12 0.2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 12 100.0% Dentistry (1) 111 2.0 0 0 5 4.5% 5 4.5% 10 9.0% 101 91.0% Blood Transfusion 2 0.0 0 0 0 0 1 50.0% 1 50.0% 1 50.0% Chemical Pathology (2) 63 1.1 0 0 0 0 3 4.7% 3 4.7% 60 95.3% Haematology 97 1.7 1 1.0% 6 6.2% 7 7.2% 14 14.5% 83 85.5% Clinical Genetics 21 0.4 0 0 1 4.8% 1 4.8% 2 9.5% 19 90.5% Medical Microbiology & Virology 66 1.2 0 0 0 0 1 1.5% 1 1.5% 65 98.5% Histopathology 115 2.1 1 0.9% 3 2.6% 8 7.0% 12 10.4% 103 89.6% Communicable Diseases 34 0.6 0 0 1 2.9% 2 5.8% 3 8.8% 31 91.2% Dermatology 73 1.3 0 0 1 1.4% 2 7.7% 3 4.1% 70 95.9% General Medicine (3) 672 12.0 13 1.9% 12 1.8% 46 6.9% 71 10.6% 601 89.4% Geriatric Medicine 187 3.3 0 0 1 0.5% 7 3.7% 8 4.3% 179 95.7% Paediatrics (4) 329 5.9 0 0 3 0.9% 3 0.9% 6 1.8% 323 98.2% Palliativ e Medicine 39 0.7 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 39 100.0% Neurology 86 1.5 0 0 1 1.2% 4 4.7% 5 5.8% 81 94.2% Rehabilitation Medicine 22 0.4 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 22 100.0% 15

Total of Consultants All Consultants Aw ard Holders Appendix F Non-Aw ard Holders in A+ A B Total 0 Respiratory Medicine 115 2.1 0 0 0 0 3 2.6% 3 2.6% 112 97.4% Genito Urinary Medicine 30 0.5 0 0 0 0 1 3.3% 1 3.3% 29 96.7% Obstetrics & Gynaecology 265 4.7 0 0 3 1.1% 7 2.7% 10 3.8% 255 96.2% General Psychiatry 362 6.5 0 0 0 0 10 2.8% 10 2.8% 352 97.2% Psychotherapy 15 0.3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 15 100.0% Child & Adolescent Psychiatry 65 1.2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 65 100.0% Forensic Psychiatry 48 0.9 0 0 0 0 2 4.2% 2 4.2% 46 95.8% Psychiatry of Learning Disability 52 0.9 0 0 1 1.9% 0 0 1 1.9% 51 98.1% Old Age Psychiatry 62 1.1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 62 100.0% Diagnostic Radiology (5) 345 6.2 0 0 1 0.3% 9 2.6% 10 2.9% 335 97.1% Radiotherapy (Clinical Oncology) 94 1.7 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 94 100.0% Emergency Medicine (6) 264 4.7 0 0 0 0 2 0.8% 2 0.8% 262 99.2% ENT Surgery (Otolaryngology) 92 1.6 0 0 1 1.1% 4 4.4% 5 5.4% 87 94.6% General Surgery 294 5.3 0 0 4 1.4% 12 4.1% 16 5.4% 278 94.6% Neurosurgery 35 0.6 0 0 0 0 1 2.9% 1 2.9% 34 97.1% Ophthalmology 136 2.4 0 0 0 0 2 1.5% 2 1.5% 134 98.5% Oral & Maxillofacial Surgery 31 0.6 0 0 0 0 2 6.5% 2 6.5% 29 93.5% Trauma & Orthopaedic Surgery 266 4.8 0 0 1 0.4% 6 2.3% 7 2.6% 259 97.4% Plastic Surgery 45 0.8 0 0 0 0 2 4.4% 2 4.4% 43 95.6% Paediatric Surgery 24 0.4 0 0 0 0 3 12.5% 3 12.5% 21 87.5% Cardiothoracic Surgery 33 0.6 0 0 0 0 5 15.2% 5 15.2% 28 84.8% Urology 78 1.4 0 0 1 1.3% 3 3.9% 4 5.1% 74 94.9% 16

Total of Consultants All Consultants Aw ard Holders Appendix F Non-Aw ard Holders in A+ A B Total 0 Total of all consultants 5584 100.0 16 0.50% 51 1.20% 186 3.3% 253 4.5% 5331 95.5% NOTES: (1) Includes: oral medicine, orthodontics, paediatric dentistry, restorative dentistry, community dentistry, oral pathology, dental public health, dental and maxillofacial radiology, surgical dentistry and oral surgery (2) Includes: immunology (3) Includes: cardiology, clinical pharmacology and therapeutics, endocrinology and diabetes, gastroenterology, general (acu te) medicine, homeopathy, medical oncology, rheumatology, audiological medicine, medical ophthalmology, clinical neurophysiology and renal medicine (4) Includes: paediatric cardiology (5) Includes: clinical radiology and nuclear medicine (6) Includes: intensive care 17

Appendix G ANALYSIS BY GENDER (Of All Current Award Holders) Scotland as at 30 September 2017 Male Female All % % % All Consultants 3359 60.1 2225 39.9 5584 100 Award Award Level (1) Level (1) Awards (2) A+ 12 75 4 25 16 6.3 A 44 86.3 7 13.7 51 20.2 B 158 84.2 28 15.8 186 73.5 Total Awards 214 84.6 39 15.4 253 100 NOTES: (1) of Male or Female Aw ard Holders as a the number of Aw ards at same Aw ard Level (2) of Male or Female Aw ard Holders as a the Total Number of Aw ards 18

ANALYSIS BY ETHNIC ORIGIN Scotland as at 30 September 2017 APPENDIX H ETHNIC GROUP AWARD HOLDERS A+ A B NON-AWARD HOLDERS ALL CONSULTANTS White Other British 1 8 25 763 797 White Irish 1 0 1 126 128 White Scottish 1 12 41 1624 1678 White Other 1 5 16 442 464 African 0 0 0 19 19 Mixed or Multiple 0 0 2 24 26 Ethnic Group Asian - Bangladeshi 0 0 1 13 14 Asian - Chinese 0 0 1 36 37 Asian Indian 0 1 3 339 343 Asian Other 0 0 0 12 12 Asian Pakistani 0 1 2 35 38 Caribbean or Black - 0 0 0 2 2 Black Caribbean or Black - 0 0 0 3 3 Caribbean Caribbean or Black - 0 0 0 2 2 Other Other Ethnic Group - 0 0 1 2 3 Arab Other Ethnic Group - 0 0 4 42 46 Other Declined 8 11 31 1006 1055 Unknown 4 13 58 841 917 Totals 16 51 186 5331 5584 19

Appendix I MEMBERSHIP OF SACDA FOR THE 2018 AWARDS ROUND Chair Mr Ken Thomson (until 28 February 2018 only) worked for 32 years in NHS management, latterly as Chief Executive of Yorkhill NHS Trust. Since taking early retiral he worked for five years as Project Director of An Lòchran - a Gaelic language cultural promotion organisation in Glasgow. In addition he is a lay member of Employment Tribunals (Scotland) and of the Conduct Sub-Committee of the Scottish Social Services Council. Mr Thomson formerly held a non-executive member position with the National Waiting Times Centre Board, between August 2003 and July 2009. He has also been conductor of the prestigious Gaelic choir - The Glasgow Gaelic Musical Association - and is a prolific arranger of songs for Gaelic choirs, having published a book of twenty of his arrangements. Medical Director and Vice-Chair Vacant Committee Members Professor Alan Cameron (to serve until 31 March 2020) became an A Award holder in 2008. He has been a consultant obstetrician in Glasgow for 25 years and is based at the Queen Elizabeth University Hospital in Glasgow where he leads the Ian Donald Fetal Medicine Centre. He has a long association with the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists (RCOG) as Scottish Members representative, Scottish Fellows Representative, Chair of the Scottish Committee and Vice-President for Clinical Quality. He is the co-principal investigator of the flagship RCOG project Each baby Counts and senior clinical advisor to the Lindsay Stewart Centre, the research and audit office of the RCOG. He is also a member of the National Screening Committee. Dr Frances Dow CBE (to serve a second term until 28 February 2019) is a former Vice Principal of the University of Edinburgh. Since then she has held a number of appointments in the public and voluntary sectors, mainly in education, immigration, education and healthcare. Currently Frances is the Chair of the Court of Queen Margaret University and a member of the General Teaching Council for Scotland s Appointments Committee. She has served on the Scottish Government s Medical Revalidation Programme Board, on the Nursing and Midwifery Revalidation Programme Board and on the Transition of Supervision of Midwives Task Force. She was a lay member on the Council for Healthcare Regulatory Excellence (now the Professional Standards Authority) and has chaired two Scottish Government Health Directorates steering groups: on the Regulation of Healthcare Support Workers and on Professionalism with particular reference to the Nursing and Allied Health Profession 20

Appendix I Professor Brenda Gibson (to serve a second term until 28 February 2019) became an A+ award holder in 2009. She is a Paediatric Haematologist with an interest in stem cell transplantation and is based at the Royal Hospital for Sick Children, Glasgow, Scotland. She is past President of the British Society for Haematology and was the Chair of the Childhood Leukaemia Working Party from 2002-2014. She has extensive knowledge of clinical trials and has been a Chief Investigator on a number of national paediatric leukaemia trials. She is an active member of a number of international groups including EBMT Paediatric Diseases Working Party, I-BFM AML Steering Committee and EMA Paediatric Committee on Medicines for Children. Professor Gordon McInnes (to serve a third term until 31 December 2018) became an A award holder in 2007. He is a retired physician previously based at the Western Infirmary, Glasgow and Professor Emeritus in Clinical Pharmacology at the University of Glasgow. He is past president of the British Hypertension Society and the Scottish Society of Physicians, past Chair of the Committee of Heads and Professors of Clinical Pharmacology at the British Pharmacological Society and past member of the Specialist Advisory Committee in Clinical Pharmacology and Therapeutics and the Council of the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Glasgow. Gillian Mawdsley (to serve until 31 March 2020) has been appointed as a Lay Member. She is a Scottish qualified solicitor who has held a wide range of legal positions mainly in the public sector, with a long standing interest in medical-legal issues as demonstrated by her academic qualifications in Forensic Medicine and Medical Law. In her role at the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service, she worked closely with the medical profession in conducting a number of medical Fatal Accident Inquiries. That background continues with her current lay appointments at NHS Education for Scotland and the Royal College of Physicians of Edinburgh. She is a tutor in various legal subjects at Edinburgh, Glasgow and Strathclyde Universities. As a legal member of the Scottish Solicitors Discipline Tribunal, she is aware of the need for upholding standards and understanding the challenges that can be faced professionally. 1 x Medical member /Academy of Royal Colleges and Faculties vacancy 1 x NHS Employer vacancy Ex-officio Members Dr Catherine Calderwood Chief Medical Officer for Scotland Mr Paul Gray Director General for Health and Social Care and Chief Executive of the NHS in Scotland 21