IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF SOUTH AFRICA IN DIE HOOGSTE HOF VAN APPèL VAN SUID-AFRIKA NOVEMBER 2010 FINAL 13 October 2010
2 JUDGES - NOVEMBER 2010 1. Mpati P 2. Harms DP 3. Navsa JA 4. Nugent JA 5. Cloete JA 6. Lewis JA 7. Heher JA 8. Ponnan JA 9. Maya JA 10. Cachalia JA 11. Snyders JA 12. Mhlantla JA 13. Bosielo JA 14. Shongwe JA 15. Leach JA 16. Tshiqi JA 17. R Pillay AJA 18. Bertelsmann AJA 19. Ebrahim AJA 20. K Pillay AJA.
3 Monday : 1 November 2010 Sonwabiso Maxwell Ndimeni v Meeg Bank Limited (Bank of Transkei) 692/09 (LAC) 1 6 7 11 16 John Louis Carter Fourie NO & others v John Denis Newton & another 562/09 (WCC) (DAY ONE) 5 8 12 15 19 IUSTITIA Kashief Naude and another v The State 488/10 (WCC) 3 4 20 Tuesday : 2 November 2010 ABSA Bank Limited v Intensive Air (PTY) Limited and others 031/10 (GNP) (AFTER CONCLUSION OF CASE 031/10) 2 10 11 14 18 The Minister of Safety and Security v Tshei Jonas Sekhoto & another 131/10 (FB) 2 4 6 13 20 John Louis Carter Fourie NO & others v John Denis Newton & another 562/09 (WCC) - (DAY TWO) 5 8 12 15 19 Wednesday : 3 November 2010 The Minister of Trade and Industry and others v E L Enterprises and another 193/10 (GNP) 2 7 11 16 17 Puma AG Rudolf Dassler Sport v Rampar Trading (Pty) Ltd & others 59/10 (KZD)
John Louis Carter Fourie NO & others v John Denis Newton & another 562/09 (WCC) (DAY THREE) 4 2 7 11 16 17 5 8 12 15 19 Thursday : 4 November 2010 The Abraham Krok Trust v The Commissioner for the South African Revenue Service 58/10 (Tax Court) 3 4 9 10 18 Suid-Afrikaanse Roofdier Telersvereniging en andere v Minister van Omgewingsake en Toerisme (Pretoria) 72/10 (FB) 7 11 13 14 17 Friday : 5 November 2010 The Commissioner for the South African Revenue Service v Sprigg Investment 117 CC t/a Global Investment 036/10 (Tax Court)(Cape Town) 2 9 10 14 16 Stoffel v Jonker 535/10 6 13 17 18 20 Monday : 8 November 2010 South African Airways (Pty) Ltd v Aviation Union of South Africa & others 123/10 (LAC) 1 6 12 14 19 Galaxy Bingo East Rand (Pty) Ltd & others v Akani Egoli (Pty) Ltd & others
5 458/09 (GNP) OR 2 (AFTER CONCLUSION) Sandlundlu (Pty) Ltd v Shepstone & Wylie Inc 063/10 (KZD) 3 9 10 13 18 4 7 11 17 20 Tuesday : 9 November 2010 Moepi Platinum (Proprietary) Limited and others v Actis Africa Empowerment Fund LP 698/09 (GSJ) 2 9 11 13 16 Margaretha Aletta Ras N.O and Others v Nicolene Van Der Meulen and another 635/09 (GNP) 6 14 15 19 20 Wednesday : 10 November 2010 M. C. Manana v King Sabata Dalindyebo Municipality 345/2009 (ECM) 1 4 12 Desert Star Trading 145 (Edms) Bpk and others v No 11 Flamboyant Edleen BK and another 98/10 (GNP) 3 5 8 19 20 Thursday : 11 November 2010 The Commissioner for the South African Revenue Service v NWK Limited 027/10 (ITSC) 2 6 10 14 18 The Minister of Safety and Security & another v Hester Rita Fisher 592/09 (WCC) 4 9 11 13 17
6 Friday : 12 November 2010 Gauteng MEC for Health v 3P Consulting (Pty) Ltd 199/10 (KZP) 7 12 16 18 Van Heerden Oriental Products (Pty) Ltd v Pegma 178 Investments Trading CC & others 126/10 (KZP) 2 6 9 14 17 (AFTER CASE 126/10) Andre van De Venter v The State 342/10 (GNP) Edward Mogorosi v The State 410/10 (NWM) 8 10 15 8 10 15 Monday : 15 November 2010 Ethekwini Municipality and others v Combined Transport Services (Pty) Ltd and others 115/2010 (KZP) 1 7 9 11 17 Manong and Associates v City of Cape Town and another 457/09 (WCC) (Equality Court) 3 5 12 Van Heerden 19 Tuesday : 16 November 2010 The Chief Executive Officer of the South African Social Security Agency N. O. & others v Cash Paymaster Services (Pty) Ltd 90/10 (GNP) 2 8 11 16 18 Mvulazana Georgina Kuzwayo v The Representative of the Executor in the Estate of the Late Mbongeni Jonas Masilela 28/10 (GSJ) 6 9 Van Heerden 14 20
7 0R 2 (AFTER CONCLUSION) Exdev (Pty) Ltd v Rodney Wolmer 97/10 (GSJ) 7 10 15 17 19 Wednesday : 17 November 2010 The Commissioner for the South African Revenue Service v Saira Essa Productions CC & others 162/10 (GNP) 2 4 5 9 16 Thursday : 18 November 2010 J. C. Da Silva V Ribeiro & another v Slip Knot Investments 777 (Pty) Ltd 661/09 (GSJ) 1 10 16 17 20 Christiaan Jurie Els v Esmare Weideman and others 512/09 (WCC) (AFTER CONCLUSION OF CASE 661/09) Johannes Petrus Louw and others v Christiaan Hendrik Nel 045/2010 (GNP) 4 7 9 6 8 12 14 18 Friday : 19 November 2010 Scoin Trading (Pty) Ltd v Bernstein, Gillies Martin NO 29/10 (KZD) 2 11 20 Calibain BK h/a Swedo Tech Motor Centre v ABSA Bank Ltd 657/09 (FB) 7 Van Heerden 15 17 19
8 Monday : 22 November 2010 President of RSA v Mail & Guardian 570/10 (GNP) Thokozane Philane Sindane v The State 510/10 (KZP) Patrick Booysen v The State 268/10 (ECP) 4 9 10 Van Heerden 18 8 12 16 8 12 16 Tuesday : 23 November 2010 Winlite Aluminium Windows & Doors (Pty) Ltd v Pyramid Freight (Pty) Ltd t/a UTI 216/10 (WCC) 2 3 7 11 18 The Law Society of the Northern Provinces v Rochelle Mahon 86/10 (GNP) 6 10 15 16 19 Wednesday : 24 November 2010 The Law Society of the Northern Provinces and another v P J Viljoen 094/10 (GNP) 7 13 14 17 20 Thursday : 25 November 2010
9 Friday : 26 November 2010 Monday : 29 November 2010 Tuesday : 30 November 2010