IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF SOUTH AFRICA IN DIE HOOGSTE HOF VAN APPèL VAN SUID-AFRIKA FEBRUARY / MARCH 2013 FINAL ROLL (30 November 2012)
JUDGES February / March 2013 2 1. Mpati P 2. Mthiyane DP 3. Brand JA 4. Nugent JA 5. Lewis JA 6. Ponnan JA 7. Maya JA 8. Cachalia JA 9. Malan JA 10. Shongwe JA 11. Leach JA 12. Tshiqi JA 13. Theron JA 14. Majiedt JA 15. Pillay JA 16. Petse JA 17. Southwood AJA 18. Schoeman AJA 19. Erasmus AJA 20. Plasket AJA 21. Van der Merwe AJA 22. Swain AJA 23. Saldulker AJA 24. Mbha AJA
Friday 15 February 2013 3 Simon Peter Mugridge v The State 657/12 (ECP) 2 7 10 19 22 AllPay Consolidated Investment Holdings (Pty) Ltd & others v The Chief Executive Officer of the South African Social Security Agency & others 678/12 (GNP) 4 6 13 16 17 Burlyn Roux Vos & others v The State 512/12 (WCC) 9 18 21 Monday 18 February 2013 King Sabata Dalindyebo Municipality v Landmark Mthatha (Pty) Ltd & another (Two Third Parties intervening) 136/11 (ECM) 1 7 14 15 19 General Council of the Bar & another v Urmilla Roshnee Devi Mansingh & others 417/12 (GNP) 3 10 11 17 23 Picbel Groep Voorsorgfonds (In Liquidation) v William Vass Graham Somerville & Three Similar Cases 405/12 (TRIAL) 6 8 16 20 24
4 Tuesday 19 February 2013 Independent Outdoor Media (Pty) Ltd & others v The City of Cape Town 222/12 (WCC) 2 11 13 19 23 Minister of Mineral Resources of the Republic of South Africa & others v Sishen Iron Ore Company (Pty) Ltd & another 394/12 (GNP) 3 5 8 17 22 The Department of Correctional Services & another v Police and Prisons Civil Rights Union & others 107/12 (LAC) 4 7 15 20 24 Wednesday 20 February 2013 Toya-Lee van Wyk & others v The State 575/11 (WCC) 1 15 24 Robert Cheng-Litsung & another v Industrial Development Corporation of South Africa Limited & another 173/12 (WCC) Dulce Vita CC V Adv Chris van Coller & others 192/12 (GNP) 5 8 13 18 21 9 12 14 16 17
Thursday 21 February 2013 5 The Law Society of the Cape of Good Hope v Michael Wharton Randell 341/12 (ECG) 2 14 21 22 24 Dirk Johannes Crafford v The South African National Road Agency Limited 215/12 (GNP) 3 11 18 20 23 Dengetenge Holdings (Pty) Ltd v Southern Sphere Mining and Development Company Limited & others 619/12 (GNP) 4 6 10 13 19 Friday 22 February 2013 Imperial Bank Limited v Norman Klein NO & others 349/12 (GSJ) 1 8 15 18 23 Tshirangwana Masotsha Tshilidzi v The State 650/12 (LT) 5 10 14 21 22 Jacob Mashike and Wilhelm Christian Ross NNO & another v Senwesbel Limited & another 253/12 (GNP) 6 7 9 16 20
Monday 25 February 2013 6 Lykes Lines Limited, LCC v Vereeniging Meat Packers (Pty) Ltd 279/12 (KZP) 2 3 16 18 19 Lagoonbay Lifestyle Estate (Pty) Ltd v The Minister for Local Government, Environmental Affairs and Development Planning of the Western Cape & others 320/12 (WCC) 4 6 12 14 23 Trapel Farms CC & others v Rodel Financial Services (Pty) Ltd 352/12 (KZP) Tuesday 26 February 2013 7 11 13 17 24 Absa Technology Finance (Pty) Ltd v Michael s Bid a House CC & another 212/12 (GSJ) 5 13 16 20 22 Irwing 514 CC v Mngani Property 4 (Pty) Ltd; Mngani Property 4 (Pty) Ltd v Irwing 514 CC 428/11; 297/11 (GSJ) 8 11 12 14 15 The Steve Tshwete Local Municipality v Fedbond Participation Mortgage Bond Managers (Pty) Ltd & another 409/12 (GNP) 9 10 21 23 24
Wednesday 27 February 2013 Sadhasivan Nolan Chetty v The State 742/12 (KZP) 7 1 2 20 Thursday 28 February 2013 Pierre Andrè Nel v Oudtshoorn Municipality 247/12 (WCC) 1 4 15 18 24 Charles Robert Roger Macleod v Babalwa Kweyiya 365/12 (WCC) 2 12 14 20 23 Cape Empowerment Trust Limited v Fisher Hoffman Sithole 200/11 (WCC) 3 7 8 10 22 Friday 1 March 2013 The Trustees of the Insolvent Estate of Grahame Ernest John Whitehead v Leon Jean Alexandre Dumas & another 323/12 (GNP) 5 6 8 13 16 Kadoma Trading 15 (Pty) Ltd v Noble Crest CC 452/12 (WCC) 7 10 15 19 22 Master Currency (Pty) Ltd v The Commissioner for the South African Revenue Service 155/12 (TAX COURT) 9 11 17 18 21
Monday 4 March 2013 8 Telkom SA Ltd v ZTE Mzanzi (Pty) Ltd &others 383/12 (GNP) 4 11 16 18 23 First Rand Bank Ltd v Brera Investments CC 385/12 (GSJ) 5 6 9 13 20 The Baphiring Community & others v Tshwaranani Projects & others 806/12 (TRIAL) Tuesday 5 March 2013 8 10 14 21 24 Alfred Mbalakwa Mnisi v The State 531/12 (GNP) Mudau Samson Mawela v The State 764/12 (LT) Leon Smith v The State 595/12 (GNP) 1 12 15 17 24 2 8 14 19 23 4 10 18 Wednesday 6 March 2013
Thursday 7 March 2013 9 The Minister of Police v Frederik Barnard van der Vyver 861/11 (WCC) 3 11 13 14 15 Raymond Banda & another v Frank Johannes van der Spuy & another 781/11 (GSJ) 5 7 8 19 22 28. Food & Allied Workers Union v L Ngcobo (M Ndlela) & another 353/12 (KZD) Friday 8 March 2013 Vuyani Maselani & another v The State 511/12 (WCC) 6 9 12 17 20 1 12 15 17 22 The Chairperson, Medical and Dental Professions Board & others v L Vambe 075/12 (GNP) Muziwenhlanhla Smanga Mthimkhulu v The State 547/11 (WCC) 2 5 19 20 21 7 10 11 16 24 Monday 11 March 2013 Jacob Humphreys v The State 424/12 (WCC) 3 8 11 19 21
10 Leadtrain Assessments (Pty) Ltd & others v Leadtrain & others 427/12 (GSJ) Nelson Sepuru Makgatho v The State 732/12 (GNP) 4 6 12 22 23 7 9 10 14 24 Tuesday 12 March 2013 Michael Mafoho v The State 149/12 (GNP) 2 10 18 22 24 Sandile Patrick Radebe & another v The State 726/12 (GNP) Given Mabunda v The State 765/12 (LT) 5 11 19 Mornè Barnard v The State 891/12 (FB) 9 13 15 16 17 Wednesday 13 March 2013 Thursday 14 March 2013 David Sithole v The State 604/12 (GNP) 1 14 20 17 23
Sibongumusa Henry Zondo v The State 627/11 (GNP) 11 7 10 11 22 24 Mbekezeli Mafu v The State 644/12 (GNP) 8 19 21 Friday 15 March 2013 Eugene Bernhard de Klerk & another v Steven-Lee Properties (Pty) Ltd & another 297/12 (GSJ) Justice Khakhathi Nevhutalu v The State 692/12 (GNP) 2 3 5 21 23 6 12 14 15 16 Themba Aaron Nkosi v The State 470/12 (TRIAL) 8 9 13 18 20 Monday 18 March 2013 Tuesday 19 March 2013
Wednesday 20 March 2013 12 Thursday 21 March 2013 Friday 22 March 2013 Monday 25 March 2013 Tuesday 26 March 2013 Wednesday 27 March 2013
13 Thursday 28 March 2013 Friday 29 March 2013