FILED: NEW YORK COUNTY CLERK 10/20/2015 06:11 PM INDEX NO. 651881/2013 NYSCEF DOC. NO. 148 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 10/20/2015 SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK COUNTY OF NEW YORK -----------------------------------------------------------------------X KRISTINA M. ARMSTRONG, v. Plaintiff, Index No. 651881/2013 PLAINTIFF S REVISED PRIVILEGE LOG FOR SUCCESSOR COUNSEL S FILES BLANK ROME LLP, NORMAN S. HELLER, DYLAN S. MITCHELL, Defendants. ----------------------------------------------------------------------X Plaintiff Kristina Armstrong, respectfully attaches hereto, her Revised Privilege Log for Successor Counsel s files. 1. Initials on Privilege Log: Plaintiff KA=Kristina Armstrong The Firm of Kramer Kozek, LLP KK=Kramer Kozek, LLP and all attorneys and staff GK=Georgia D. Kramer, Esq. NK=Neil E. Kozek, Esq. DS=Deborah Sherman, Esq. CC=Cathy Credendino, Paralegal The Firm of Hennessey & Bienstock LLP HB=Hennessey & Bienstock LLP, and all attorneys and staff PH=Patricia Hennessey, Esq. PB=Peter Bienstock, Esq. The Consulting Firm of Eisner Amper, LLC, as experts MB=Martin Blaustien, CPA
2. Michael means R. Michael Armstrong, Plaintiff s former husband. 3. Family Court Matters The litigated matters arising near, on or after the Settlement Agreement was signed on May 11, 2011 and/or the Judgment of Divorce was entered on August 5, 2011, such as physical abuse, bugging of Plaintiff s cell phone or other acts by Michael Armstrong committed against Plaintiff, alleged Defaults or breaches of the Settlement Agreement or other Post- Judgment matters, purely personal issues, for example, children custody issues, parenting plans, holidays, health records, and/or alleged non-compliance with certain terms of the Settlement Agreement. 4. Matrimonial Case The underlying divorce action, known as Armstrong v. Armstrong, Supreme Court, Westchester County, Index No. 12972, up to the entry of the Judgment of Divorce, August 5, 2011. 5. Produced relates to documents that were initially marked or separated as privileged, but upon review, have been produced. 6. Relates to a different client, inadvertently in boxes refers to documents and attorneys notes relating to their other clients that were inadvertently mixed in the Armstrong boxes. Dated: New York, New York October 20, 2015 Respectfully submitted, SACK & SACK, LLP By: /s/_eric R. Stern Eric R. Stern, Esq. Attorneys for Plaintiff 110 East 59th Street, 19th Floor New York, New York 10022 Tel.: (212) 702-9000 Fax: (212) 702-9702 2
Revised Log of Attorney-Client, Attorney-Work Product and/or Family Court/Post Judgment Materials from Successor Counsel's Files Bates # Date From To Subject Doc type 1-10 7.7-8.25/2011 KA DS and GK Family Court Matters Emails, subpoena, cell phone tacking device put on phone by Michael, etc. 11-13 7/19/2011 KA DS Family Court Matters Questions re hearing re Michael's abuse 14 Produced 15-36 7/12/2011 GK and PH Family Court Matters emails and handwritten notes re abuse hearing/medical records 37-184 Produced 185-189 Produced 190-191 7/26/2011 KK KA Family Court Matters Re Subpoena served for abuse hearing 192 Produced 193-195 6/28/2011 TT KA Family Court Matters Alleged Default Notice re non-financial issues 196-200 Produced 201-203 Produced 204 5/24/2011 CC KC Attorney-client billing matters email 205-226 Produced 227 1/2/2011 GK, KA KA, GK withdrawals and Xmas holiday email 228-255 Produced 256-262 8/23/2011 DS KA Family Court matters email w/draft bill of particulars, police report 263-289 Produced 290-294 10/9/2009 KA GH Unrelated damage caused by neighbor to personal property 295-336 Produced 337-347 2.19-2.20.11 KA GK or PH Family/children issues cell phone statement with notes 348-353 Produced 354-357 8/25/2011 KA DS Family Court Matters Michael's abuse/police Report 358-383 Produced 384-385 10/7/2009 Unrelated damage caused by neighbor to personal property 386-415 Produced 416-435 5/4/2011 GK Medical Records Plaintiff's personal medical records 436-438 Produced 439 4/30/2011 GK Medical Records Plaintiff's personal medical records 440-455 4/29/2011 KA GK and PH trial/hearing prep P's Notes to Atty's on family dynamics 456-479 Produced 492-479 Produced 480-834 Produced 835-836 3/27/2011 KA GK and PH Children issues emails 837 Produced 838 6/15/2011 Family court matters Michael's Chart of world events 839-844 7/7/2011 GK or PH Interoffice/client billing matters emails w/ attachments 845-855 Produced 856-857 KA GK or PH Family Court matters Notes regarding Michael's physical abuse 858-861 6/23/2015 GK search terms for document search 862-933 Produced 934-941 12/20/2010 GK Children issues handwritten attorney notes re client meeting 942-947 Produced 948 1/2/2011 KA GK and PH Michael's sabatoge of X-mas email 949-959 Produced 960-961 3/17/2011 PH Children issues Client meeting notes with KA and GK 962-1044 Produced 1045-1094 PH or GK notes re family issues in dispute handwritten attorney notes 1095-1098 Produced 1099-1103 KA PH notes re family issues in dispute handwritten attonrney notes
1104-1112 Produced 1113-1136 Produced 1137-1145 PH Notes re Family matters handwritten attorney notes 1146 Produced 1147-1174 PH Notes re Family matters handwritten attorney notes 1175 Produced 1176 11/16/2010 HB PH Billing arrangement/opening file email 1177-1192 KA GK and PH Family Court Matters-testimony memorandum 1193-1213 Produced 1214-1246 KA GK and PH Notes & materials re family memorandum 1247-1267 7/6/2009 KA Repairs to House+neighor issues Invoices and letters 1268-1325 Produced 1326-1357 Produced 1358-1368 10/24/2010 KA GK and PH Personal issues re family matters emails 1369-1411 Produced 1412-1424 11/8/2010 KA, GK, PH KA, GK, PH Personal, Michael's Paramour emails 1425-1473 Produced 1474-1490 11/15/2010 PH, KA PH, KA parenting time emails 1491-1494 11/16/2011 PH, GK PH, GK Matrimonial Case emails 1495-1534 Produced 1499-1520 11/17/2010 PH, GK PH, GK Matrimonial Case emails with attachments 1521-1530 Produced 1531-1534 missing 1535-1543 11.18-11.24/2010 KA, GK, PH KA, GK,PH Thanksgiving Plans/children emails 1544-1571 Produced 1572-1581 12.12-12.21.2010 KA, GK, PH KA, GK,PH Weekends and Parenting Plans emails 1582-1596 1.2-1.20/2011 KA, GK, PH KA, GK,PH potential meeting & trial dates emails 1597-1600 Produced 1601-1610 2.19-2.27/2011 KA, GK, PH KA, GK,PH Chrildren Issues, Incidents emails 1611-1613 Produced 1614-1619 3.1-3.3/2011 KA, GK, PH KA, GK,PH Harrassment & Personal Issues emails 1620-1625 Produced 1626 3.7.2011 KA GK, PH Personal issues re family matters email 1627-1645 Produced 1646-1650 3.8.2011 KA, GK, PH KA, GK,PH Personal issues re family matters emails 1651-1679 Produced 1680-1681 3.17.2011 KA GK, PH Verbal Harrassment Email with memo 1682-1685 Produced 1686-1687 3.27.2011 KA GK, PH Saftey of Children email 1688-1706 4/1/2011 KA, GK,PH KA, GK,PH Children Schedules emails 1711-1732 Produced 1733 4/8/2011 KA PH Parenting Schedule email 1734-1790 Produced 1791-1799 4/15/2011 KA, GK GK, KA Personal note Rye art show emails 1800-1808 Produced 1809 4/19/2011 PH GK Michael's Paramour email 1810-1818 Produced 1819-1831 4/26/2011 KA GK, PH Personal Background materials email, with memorandum 1832-1834 Produced 1835-1851 4/26/2011 KA GK, PH Personal Background materials email, with memorandum 1852-1857 Produced 1858 5/2/2011 KA GK, PH Court appearance email 1859-1862 Produced 1863 5/4/2011 KA GK, PH Weekend and Saftey email
1864-1973 Produced 1974-1987 Produced 1988-1992 KA GK, PH Children Summer studies Materials 1993-1994 1/25/2013 KA GK, PH Family Court matters email 1995 7/27/2012 KA GK, PH Family Court matters/defaults email 1996-1998 Produced 1999-2000 7/11/2011 KA GK, PH Family Court matters/defaults email and Notice of Default 2001-2039 Produced 2040-2047 5/25/2011 GK KA Billing matters email with attachment 2048-2063 Produced 2064-2069 5/27/2011 KA, PH PH, KA Billing matters emails 2070-2075 Produced 2076-2077 5/25/2011 KA, PH PH, KA Billing matters emails 2078-2079 Produced 2080-2081 5/27/2011 KA, PH PH, KA Billing matters emails 2082-2083 Produced 2084 5/25/2011 KA, PH PH, KA Billing matters email 2085-2102 Produced 2103-2143 6.1-6.16/2011 KA, PH, GK PH, KA, GK Protect. Order/Michael at house Emails and memorandum 2144-2147 Produced 2148-2171 6.16.-6.17-2011 KA, PH, GK PH, KA, GK Post-Settl. Agreement Defaults emails 2172-2359 Produced 2360-2376 KA PH, GK Personal issues re family matters handwritten notes 2377-2406 Produced 2407-2419 11/15/2010 KA, PH, GK PH, KA, GK Custody and Parenting time emails and materials 2420-2487 Produced 2488-2490 12/6/2010 KA, PH, GK PH, KA, GK Custody and Parenting time emails 2491-2528 Produced 2429-2533 1/13/2011 KA GK and PH Children and related issues Notes 2354-2540 Produced 2541-2561 PH Relates to a different client,inadvertently in boxes 2562-2564 KA PH Children and related issues Notes 2565-2573 PH Relates to a different client,inadvertently in boxes 2574 4/8/2011 KA PH Parenting Schedule email 2575-2581 PH Relates to a different client,inadvertently in boxes 2852-2601 Produced 2602-2611 PH Relates to a different client,inadvertently in boxes 2612-2617 Produced 2618-2619 PH Relates to a different client,inadvertently in boxes 2620-2657 Produced 2658-2672 PH Relates to a different client,inadvertently in boxes 2673-2759 Produced 2760-2769 3/8/2010 KA GK Michael's Physical Abuse Police Report 2770--2921 Produced 2922-2929 5/16/2011 KK KA Billing matters Statement 2928-3926 Produced 3927-3931 5/10/2011 KK PH, GK Joint Decision Making children Email and notes 3932-3958 Produced 3959 12/23/2013 KA CC Escrow Account Email 3960-3966 1.28-3.4/2013 KA, CC KA, CC Status of physical files emails 3966-4102 12.6.11-4.23.12 GK, PH, KA GK, PH, KA Post-Judgment Defaults emails and materials 4103-4145 Produced 4146-4149 6.1-6.2/2011 KA, GK, PH KA, GK, PH Division of Per. Possessions emails 4150-4153 Produced