Aquila Steel (S Africa) (Pty) Ltd Kopano ya baagi 04 Ngwanatsele 2014, Regorogile ura ya boraro & Rooiberg ura yabo thataro
LENANEO Kamogelo le matseno Mosola wa kopano Tsamaiso ya kopano Kitsiso ka Aquila le porojeke e tshitshingweng Thulaganyo (Process) ya tikologo e latelletsweng go fitlha jaanong Thulaganyo ya Scoping- le EIA (Tlhatlhobo ya ditlamorago tsa tikologo) Tshosobanyo ya ditlamorago tse botlhokwa Dithuto tsa di specialist Considered Alternatives Aspects tsa loago-ekonomi Thulaganyo tsa melawana tse tswelang pele Dipotso 2
KAMOGELO LE MATSENO Kitsiso tsa ditlhopha tse dirisanang mmogo mo porojekeng ya Meletse Iron Ore Aquila Steel (S Africa) (Proprietary) Limited Shangoni Management Services 3
MOSOLA WA KOPANO YA BAAGI Go tlhagisa seemo sa porojeke go baagi ba Regorogile, Rooiberg le batho ba dirang le go dula ko mashimong a leng fa gaufi, le go ka neelana ka monyetla wa go botsisa le go tshwaela. Kopano e ke karolo ya lenaneo lago tseisa sechaba karolo mo porojekeng. 4
TSAMAISO YA KOPANO Go nale toloki ya setswana mme ditshwaelo le ditshwenyego di tlile go tsentshiwa ko pogelong e maleba. Tlhagiso e tlile go tlhagiswa ka Setswana (Toloki ya sekgowa e teng) Kopa le sign attendance register e leng fa go tseniwang. 5
KITSISO KA AQUILA Aquila ne ele Australian listed company empa ya tseiwa ke Baosteel Resources le Aurizon ebe yaba delisted. Focus on significant projects in the key steel making raw materials of metallurgical coal and iron ore Setlhopha sa bona sa tsamaiso se nale dingwana dile dintsi se dira mme ebile se dira ka thata gore boleng ba di shareholder bo tlhatlhoge. Iron Ore - The West Pilbara Iron Ore Project in Australia and the Thabazimbi and Northern Cape iron ore projects in South Africa Coking Coal Eagle Downs Hard Coking Coal Project Manganese Gravenhage Manganese Project on the Avontuur Prospecting Right Aquila e tlhakanetse di porojeke tsa mo South Africa le Rakana Consolidated Mines (Pty) Ltd SOUTH AFRICA Avontuur (Manganese) 1-2Mtpa 1 Thabazimbi (Iron Ore) Up to 4Mtpa 1 AUSTRALIA Eagle Downs (Metallurgical Coal) ~5Mtpa 1 Washpool (Metallurgical Coal) West Pilbara (Iron Ore) >30Mtpa 1 6
BATSHWARI BA DI SHARES TSA AQUILA BA BANCHA Ka Phukwe 2014, consortium ya Baosteel Resources / Aurizon Ltd (85%/15%) e fitlhetse taolo ya Aquila Resources, the Australian registered parent company of ASSA Baosteel Resources Australia Pty Ltd is a wholly owned subsidiary of Baosteel Resources International Company Ltd, which is ultimately fully owned by Baosteel Group Corporation, a Chinese state-owned iron and steel company headquartered in Shanghai, China Baosteel Group Corporation is one of China s largest iron and steel producers with crude steel output of approximately 45 million tons in 2013 The third most profitable iron and steel company in the world with a total profit of ~RMB 10.1 billion (approx. R16 billion) and is ranked 211 th in the Fortune Global 500 in 2014 with revenue of ~RMB 303 billion (~R485 billion). Aurizon Operations Limited is a wholly-owned subsidiary of Aurizon Holdings Limited, a top-50 AS-listed company with a market cap of ~A$10bn (~R100bn) Aurizon is Australia's largest rail freight operator by volume and transports approximately 200 million tonnes of coal annually. Each year the Company transports more than 250 million tonnes of Australian commodities, connecting miners, primary producers, and industry with international and domestic markets. The company generates annual revenues in excess of ~A$3.5 billion (~R35 billion) and operates assets across Australia valued at more than ~A$10 billion (~R100 billion). Note: Exchange rate of R/RMB = 10:6.202, R/A$ = 10:1 7
8
9
THULAGANYO TSE LATETSWENG GO FITLHA JAANONG MPRDA EMPR (tokelo ya boepo) Mining right submission - July 2013 Scoping report submission October 2013 EMPR submitted 11 July 2014 Consultation with DMR ongoing NEMA EIA (tokelo tsa go dirisa tikologo) EIA application form submission - June 2014 Draft Scoping report submitted to LEDET 18 June 2014 Scoping Report currently being finalised Consultation with LEDET NWA WULA (Thulaganyo ya metsi) IWWMP in support an Integrated Water Use License Application in the process of being finalised Consultation with DWS NEMWA WL (Thulaganyo ya matlakala) Waste License application form submission - Nov 2013 (GN718). Now repealed. GN921 and GN926 promulgated in November 2013. Waste License Application considered withdrawn. New implications of the NEMWA: Amendment Act, (Act 26 of 2014) Exclusion of MRSRD removed from Section 4 of NEMWA, and the definition of hazardous waste in Schedule 3 now specially includes MRSRD. Consultation with NDEA GO TSEYA KAROLO GA SECHABA - Kitsiso tsa ntlha le di phasalatso - Kopano tsa dichaba di tshwarilwe ka di 01 February 2014 le 30 August 2014 - Karolo ya tshedimosetso ya dithuto tsa di Specialist ne e tshwerwe ka di 31 May 2014 - Di kopano tsa baagi ba Rooiberg le Regorogile ne di tshwerwe ka di 12 June 2014 - Dipoisano le dingaka di entswe ke Anthropologist - Draft Scoping Report ne e phasaladitswe gore sechaba se kgone go tshwaela. 10
THULAGANYO YA SCOPING LE EIA Tlhatlhobo e tseneletseng ya ditlamorago tse siameng le tse disa siamang (Go akaretsa le ditlamorago tsa loago-ekonomi) Statement sa ditlamorago Tlhaloso ya porojeke e tseneletseng Detailed comparative alternative assessment Ditlhokwa le ditakatso Dithuto tsa di specialist 11
TSHOSOBANYO YA DITLAMORAGO TSE BOTLHOKWA Setso le ngwao (Cultural heritage) Cave ya Madimatle le lefelo le leng gaufi le Madimatle Ecology Certain threatened / vulnerable species (Cheilanthes deltoidea subsp. Silicicola and protected tree species (Camel thorn, Leadwood and Marula). Go latlhegelwa ga madulo a diphologo Ditlamorago mo ditebegong Loago (Social) Sense of place (e tsamaisana le ditebego) le ditlamorago tse siameng goya ka leagoekonomi 12
DITHUTO TSA DI SPECIALIST TSE DIRILWENG Dithuto tsa di specialist Leina la Specialist / Company Thuto ka ditebego Thuto ka ecology Thuto ka go itshidisa ga di mamanthane Thuto ka ekonomi Thuto ka go thunya le go tshikinega ga lefatshe Thuto ka metsi a leng fa tlase ga lefatshe le dipatlisiso ka supply ya metsi afa tlase ga lefatshe Thuto ka setso Thuto ka pharakano Thuto ka modumo Thuto ka metsi le tse di dulang ko metsing Thuto ka boemo ba loapi Thuto ka dilo tsa kgale tse di fitlhelwang gantsi ka fa tlase ga mmu go tshwana le marapo a batho, diphologolo etc Dithuto ka mokgwa o goneng go tshidiwa ka teng mengwaga e fitileng Thuto ka loago Thuto ka manong Thuto ka mmu Thuto ka metsi ama fresh Jacques Volschenk Lukas Niemand Ernest Seamark Gerrie Muller Danie Zeeman Gerhard Steenkamp Sidney Miller Cobus Havenga Cor Meyer Francois Roux Rochelle Bornman Hanlie Liebenberg-Enslin John Almond Professor Chris van Vuuren San-Marie Aucamp Dr. Patrick Benson Zoneland Solutions Zoneland Solutions 13
DITHUTO TSA DI SPECIALIST TSE DIRIWANG/TLILENG GO DIRIWA Thuto ya specialist Consideration of possibility for Biodiversity off-set Baseline monitoring ya metsi Leina la specialist/company Lukas Niemand Ockie Scholtz 14
CONSIDERED ALTERNATIVES MO THULAGANYONG YA SCOPING LE EIA Alternatives tsa phitlhelelo ya metsi Site layout alternatives Alternatives tsa tsela (ya go tsena ko boepong) Alternatives tsa tsamaiso (transportation) ya ore le tloso ya matlapa a senang mosola (waste rock) Boepo ba mokoti vs Boepo ba fa tlase ga mmu 15
CRITERIA TSELA E DIRISITSWENG CATEGORY TIKOLOGO/MOLA SETEGENIKI EKONOMI LOAGO O /ENGINEERING BOEMO BA LOAPI METSI AKO DINOKENG, MATAMONG LE FA NTLE SETSO LE NGWAO DIPHOLOGOLO DIJALO GEOHYDROLOGY GEOLOGY MODUMO MMU PHARAKANO TSHIKINEGO LE AIR BLAST DITEBEGO DINYAKEGO TSA MOLAO TSE DINGWE TSA MOLAO (E.G. WATER USE ACTIVITIES, EIA REQUIREMENTS ETC.) SENSE OF PLACE SOCIAL LICENSE TO OPERATE LOAGO-EKONOMI MATHATA GO BAAGING, BOGODU, HEALTH RISKS, ETC. 16
TSELA E DIRISITSWENG CRITERIA CATEGORY TIKOLOGO/MOLAO SETEGENIKI EKONOMI LOAGO /ENGINEERING EASE OF INTEGRATION WITH PLANNED INFRASTRUCTURE GO TSENA KO BOEPONG CONSTRAINTS TO SITE LAYOUT SEBAKA SA GO AGA RISKS TSA GO AGA RISKS TSA GO DIRA BOLENG BA GO SIMOLOLA (GO AKARETSA GO TLHOMA LE GO LOKISA) BOLENG BA GO DIRA GO LOKISA (SITE REHABILITATION) 17
TSELA E DIRISITSWENG Under each of the four categories, by assessing the identified criteria, a score is assigned to each of the identified options (Between 1 and 3, with 3 being most favourable). The final score obtained for each of the options support decision on the most suitable for the proposed development. Category Weighting CATEGORY WATER SITE LAYOUT ROUTE ORE MINING SUPPLY TRANSPORT METHOD AND WASTE DISPOSAL ENVIRONMENTAL/LEGAL 0.3 0.3 0.3 0.3 0.15 SOCIAL 0.3 0.3 0.3 0.3 0.25 TECHNICAL/ENGINEERING 0.25 0.25 0.25 0.25 0.3 ECONOMICAL 0.15 0.15 0.15 0.15 0.3 18
TSELA E DIRISITSWENG The final score for each of the options is obtained by multiplying the % score for each category by the assigned weighting and adding the respective scores (as obtained for each category) to reach a final value for each option. The higher the % value, the more favourable the option. 19
Alternatives tsa go fitlhela metsi 20
Comparative review Alternatives tsa go fitlhela metsi 21
Site layout alternatives 22
Alternatives 1 3 23
Alternatives 4 6 24
Recommended Alternative 3 25
Comparative review Site layout alternatives 26
Alternatives tsa ditsela 27
Alternatives tsa ditsela (route) Go ditsela tse di malwa tse di ka dirisiwang go tsena ko boepong, tse pedi tsa ditsela tseo di supilwe ko simologong : Option 1: Southern Route / Northern Route Option 2: Alma Route 28
29
Comparative review Alternatives tsa ditsela Option 2: Tsela ya Alma e tlositswe jaaka option ebile ga ya akarediwa mo comparative assessment. Tiriso ya tsela ya Alma ekase kgonege ka gonne Transnet e kase kgone go nchafatsa seporo. 30
Alternatives Tsamaiso ya Ore le go latlhiwa ga matlapa a senang mosola. 31
Comparative review Tsamaiso ya Ore le go latlhiwa ga matlapa a senang mosola. 32
Alternatives tsa mofuta wa boepo 33
Alternatives tsa mofuta wa boepo Di option tse pedi di tlhatlhobilwe. Boepo ba mokoti (only feasible option from engineering and economical perspective) Boepo ba fa tlase ga mmu 34
Ekonomi: TSE SIAMENG (POSITIVE) TSA LOAGO- EKONOMI Meletse eka kgona go dirisana le mmaraka wa iron ore wa fa gae, go feta moo, Meletse ke modiri wa iron ore o botlhokwa mo mmarakeng wa ko mafatsheng a kwa ntle. Estimated Porojeke ya Meletse Iron Ore e tlile go contributor R3.3 billion go ekonomi ya Aforika Borwa ka corporate tax le R1.8 billion ka di royalty tax (Go ya ka MWP ya Meletse e isitsweng Ko DMR) Di benefit tsa ekonomi ya local le tsona ke tse dikgolo. R1.9 2.7 billion e tlile go investiwa fa go agiwa boepo go tlhakana le sustaining capital investment e tlo tswelang pele. 35
TSE SIAMENG TSA LOAGO-EKONOMI Di benefits tsa baagi SLP e isitsweng go DMR, kage ele karolo ya kopo ya ditokelo tsa Boepo. Porojeke ena e tshegetsa di primary goals tsa National Development Plan (NDP) ebile eka dirisiwa go fitlhelela di goal tsa mano a tlhabollogo (development plan) ya Lefelo la Waterberg: - Tlholego ya ditiro; - Tlhabologo ya Mafaratlhatlha; - Go investor go di porojekeng tsa baagi; - Tlhabollo ya kitso (Skills) le go tlhabolla thuto; - Internships le di bursaries ; le - Go gola ga ekonomi 36
THULAGANYO YA MELAWANA E TSWELANG PELE MPRDA EMPR NEMA EIA NWA WULA NEMWA WL Continued communication with DMR NEMA Final Scoping report submission to LEDET EIR compilation Finalisation and submission of IWULA / IWWMP to DWS Continued consultation with DWS Continued consultation with Departments on way forward (i.e. changes in legislation NEMWAA). Go tseisa sechaba karolo - Kopano ya baagi (04 Phukwe 2014) - Batho ba nang le kgatlhego kgotsa ba amenang ba tlilo neiwa monyetla wago ka lebella le go tshwaeia mo pegelong ya draft le final (go akarediwa le dithuto tsa di specialist) pele ga pegelo eo e fetsiwa kgotsa e isiwa ko go tshwanetseng. 37
DIPOTSO? 38