IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF SOUTH AFRICA IN DIE HOOGSTE HOF VAN APPèL VAN SUID-AFRIKA AUGUST/SEPTEMBER 2011 FINAL ROLL (30 May 2011)
2 JUDGES - AUG/SEPT 2011 1. Harms AP 2. Navsa JA 3. Mthiyane JA 4. Brand JA 5. Cloete JA 6. Lewis JA 7. Heher JA 8. Van Heerden JA 9. Ponnan JA 10. Maya JA 11. Cachalia JA 12. Snyders JA 13. Mhlantla JA 14. Malan JA 15. Bosielo JA 16. Shongwe JA 17. Leach JA 18. Theron JA 19. Majiedt JA 20. Seriti JA 21. Wallis JA 22. Meer AJA 23. Plasket AJA 24. Petse AJA
3 Monday : 15 August 2011 DAY 1 H W Louw NO & others v Swartland Municipality 650/10 (WCC) 1 5 16 21 23 Maccsand (Pty) Ltd & another v The City of Cape Town & others 709/10 & 746/10 (WCC) 1 5 16 21 23 Law Society of the Northern Provinces v Kashan Ramakoka Mabando & another 736/10 (NWM) 2 7 8 19 24 Ndoyisiwe Paulos Notito v The State 123/11 (FB) Mcebisi Magadla v The State 80/11 (ECM) 3 13 15 20 22 3 13 15 20 22 Tuesday : 16 August 2011 DAY TWO H W Louw NO & others v Swartland Municipality 650/10 (WCC) 1 5 16 21 23 Maccsand (Pty) Ltd & another v The City of Cape Town & others 709/10 & 746/10 (WCC) 1 5 16 21 23 Venfin Investments (Pty) Ltd v KZN Resins (Pty) Ltd t/a KZN Resins 642/10 (KZD) 4 9 12 14 18
4 Shane Gilbert v The State 065/11 (KZP) 7 10 11 17 24 Wednesday : 17 August 2011 Lynette Mary Roux v Health Professions Council of South Africa and another 786/10 (GNP) 2 6 9 13 14 South African Rail Commuter Corporation Limited v Thwala Philisiwe Allmma 661/10 (GSJ) 3 7 10 19 21 Mark Julian Atkin v Petrus Jacobus Botes 566/10 (GNP) Matthys Johannes van As v The Road Accident Fund 346/10 (WCC) 5 8 15 20 22 5 8 15 20 22 Thursday : 18 August 2011 Ausplow (Pty) Ltd v Northpark Trading 3 (Pty) Ltd & others 742/10 (Court of the Commissioner of Patents) 1 9 12 14 23 Imperial Marine Company v The Motor Vessel Pasquale Della Gatta and another and Imperial Marine Company v The Motor Vessel Filippo Lembo and another 638/10 (WCC) 2 4 6 17 21
5 Mususumeli Samuel Maemu v The State 147/2011 (LT) Simphiwe Raymond Shusha v The State 609/10 (KZP) 7 11 16 18 19 7 11 16 18 19 Friday : 19 August 2011 JUDGES MEETING Monday : 22 August 2011 Value Group Limited & another v Value Port Transport CC & others 259/10 (GSJ) 1 6 12 19 21 SWD Rugbyvoetbalunie & another v Hennie Baartman & another 668/10 (WCC) 2 5 14 17 18 Phodiclinics (Pty) Ltd v Pinehaven Private Hospital (Pty) Ltd and others 594/10 (GSJ) 3 10 11 15 20 Tuesday : 23 August 2011 Registrar of Medical Schemes & another v Suremed Medical Scheme 201/11 (GNP) 1 6 14 15 18 Harry Mathew Charlton v Parliament of the Republic of South Africa 680/10 (LAC) 4 8 10 13 22
Casino Enterprises (Pty) Ltd (Swaziland) v The Gauteng Gambling Board and others 653/10 (GNP) 7 9 20 23 24 Jacobus Bogaards v The State 864/10 (GNP) Wednesday : 24 August 2011 6 3 10 13 17 20 ABSA Bank Limited v The South African Commercial Catering and Allied Workers Union National Provident Fund (under curatorship) 697/10 (GSJ) 6 9 11 15 16 Thursday : 25 August 2011 The Attorneys Fidelity Fund Board of Control v Mettle Property Finance (Pty) Ltd 499/10 (GNP) 1 8 10 18 21 F Booysen & others v The State 035/11 (WCC) 2 7 12 16 19 Burger & Wallace Construction (Pty) Ltd v Ballprop Ten (Pty) Ltd 406/10 (WCC) 5 14 22 23 24
7 Friday : 26 August 2011 Minister of Safety and Security & others v M Mohamed & another 598/10 (WCC) 2 7 11 12 23 Roshan Morar N.O v Mahomed Aslam Osman Akoo & another 498/10 (KZP) 4 13 19 21 22 Sibongakonke Lorraine Mbuyisa v The State 183/2001 (GSJ) 5 9 17 Marawaan Muller and another v The State 855/10 (WCC) 5 9 17 Monday : 29 August 2011 Moruleng and District Taxi Association & another v North West Provincial Department of Transport & 26 others 254/10 (NWM) 1 10 15 16 23 Selwyn Winston de Vries & others v The State 130/11 (WCC) Transnet Limited v Owner of the MV Alina II 898/10 (WCC) 2 13 17 4 9 14 18 21
8 Tuesday : 30 August 2011 Myeleti Minerals (Pty) Ltd v The Minister of Minerals and Energy & others 660/10 (GNP) 4 7 12 14 24 Shereen Cassim & another v Voyager Property Management (Pty) Ltd & others 574/10 (KZD) 5 9 16 17 20 Munier Effendi v The State 66/11 (WCC) 6 8 22 Wednesday : 31 August 2011 Emfuleni Resorts (Pty) Ltd & another v Mazizini Community & others 655/10 (LCC) 1 3 12 15 24 Hans Gunter Ponelat v Erica Schrepfer 802/10 (WCC) 7 10 14 19 22 Thursday : 1 September 2011 Transnet Limited v Erf 152927 Cape Town (Pty) Ltd & others 798/10 (WCC) Ashcor Secunda (Pty) Ltd v Sasol Synthetics Fuels (Pty) Ltd 624/10 (GSJ) 2 8 13 18 21 4 9 11 16 23
9 Mark William Lynn N. O. v Colin Henry Coreejes & anther 687/10 (GNP) 6 12 14 19 20 Friday : 2 September 2011 The State v Arthur Tshepo Meje & another 248/2011 (GNP) 3 10 16 20 23 Laeveld Trust 2001 (Pty) Ltd & others v Blue Fire Properties 115 (Pty) Ltd 795/10 (GNP) 5 7 14 15 18 Clear Enterprises (Pty) Ltd v The Commissioner for the South African Revenue Services & others 757/10 (GNP) 9 11 17 21 24 Monday : 5 September 2011 G J van der Watt & another v C J Jonker & others 837/10 (FB) 1 6 9 11 19 South African Transport and Allied Workers Union v J Garvis & others 007/11 (WCC) 2 4 8 13 23 Daniël William Mokela v The State 135/11 (GNP) 3 10 15
10 Joseph Mathebula and another v The State 045/11 (GNP) 3 10 15 Tuesday : 6 September 2011 Khulu Nkosi & others v Cornelius Lourens Greyling & others 110/2011 (LCC) 2 7 12 18 24 Director of Public Prosecutions v Thulani Sibusiso Thusi & others 769/10 (GSJ) 3 8 16 Mduduzi Nelson Mthimkhulu v The State 210/11 (GNP) 3 8 16 Pick n Pay Retailers (Pty) Ltd & others v M B Eayrs NO, C M De Villiers NO, H Hughes obo The Daku Trust & others 809/10 (ECP) 4 14 17 20 21 Wednesday : 7 September 2011 International Trade Administration Commission & another v South African Tyre Manufacturers Conference (Pty) Ltd & others 738/2010 (GNP) 1 3 5 11 16 Mogale Winston Standford Modiri v The Minister of Safety and Security & others 581/2010 (FB) 4 10 13 19 22
11 Thursday : 8 September 2011 Stiphen Mkhize v Umvoti Municipality & others 628/2010 (KZP) Body Corporate Croftdene Mall v The Ethekwini Municipality 603/2010 (KZD) Fanie Masenye Moswathupa v The State 168/11 (GNP) Langa Fakude & another v The State 852/10 (KZP) 2 6 12 14 22 5 7 10 11 23 9 18 20 9 18 20 Friday : 9 September 2011 Emergency Care Trading Association v The Health Professions Council of South Africa & others 664/2010 (GNP) 5 12 16 20 21 Compass Insurance Company Limited v Hospitality Hotel Developments (Pty) Ltd 756/2010 (GSJ) 6 8 11 14 17 Siobhan Lee O Shea N. O. v Christopher Peter van Zyl NO & others 791/10 (WCC) 7 13 15 18 22
12 Monday : 12 September 2011 Wakefields Real Estate (Pty) Limited v Gavin Wayne Attree & others 666/2010 (KZD) 2 6 9 13 21 Thabo Mofutsanyana District Municipality v Steyn-Enslin & Vennote & others 639/2010 (FB) 3 7 10 15 19 Eldacc (Pty) Ltd v Bidvest Properties (Pty) Ltd 682/2010 (GSJ) 5 8 11 20 23 Tuesday : 13 September 2011 Exploitatie-en-Beleggingsmaatschappij Argonauten II B.V. & another v George Nicolaas Honig & another 649/2010 (WCC) 3 8 15 17 22 David Wallace Zietsman v Electronic Media Network Ltd & another 771/10 (Court of the Commissioner of Patents (Pretoria)) 3 8 15 17 22 Grey Global Group Inc v Khumalo Bongani Aug & another 725/2010 (GSJ) 6 10 14 18 24 The Municipality of Stellenbosch v Shelf-Line 104 (Pty) Ltd 615/2010 (WCC) 7 12 16 19 23
13 Wednesday : 14 September 2011 Thursday: 15 September 2011 Gavin Cecil Gainsford NO and others v Tiffski Property Investments (Proprietary) Ltd and others 874/2010 (GSJ) 1 5 13 17 24 The State v Paulos Kam Thabethe 619/10 (GNP) Brian Fredericks v The State 208/11 (WCC) 3 15 16 3 15 16 Matolwandile Bonga Mda v The Law Society of the Cape of Good Hope 534/10 (ECM) 4 11 14 19 20 Friday : 16 September 2011 Commissioner for the South African Revenue Service v Labat Africa Limited 669/10 (GNP) 1 6 10 19 23
14 National Lotteries Board & others v South Environment Project & another 788/10 (WCC) Simange Wiseman Mthembu v The State 206/11 (KZP) African Education 4 8 11 16 20 9 15 24 Director of Public Prosecutions v Larry Burt Phillips 271/11 (GNP) 9 15 24 Monday : 19 September 2011 Judd Harvey Smith v The City of Cape Town & others 913/10 (WCC) 6 7 12 14 18 Tuesday : 20 September 2011 J W Potgieter & another v A M J Potgieter N.O & others 629/10 (GNP) 2 4 8 17 19 Wednesday : 21 September 2011 Thursday : 22 September 2011
15 Friday : 23 September 2011 Monday : 26 September 2011 Tuesday : 27 September 2011 Wednesday : 28 September 2011 Thursday : 29 September 2011 Friday : 30 September 2011