However, the proposed wells are economically justified and should be drilled at this time. There will be no adverse effect upon the correlative rights of owners in offset units if the proposed wells are qiven a separate allowable in relation to the existina ~ BEFORE THE CORPORATION COMMISSION OF THE STATE OF OKLAHOMA APPLICANT : APACHE CORPORATIO N RELIEF SOUGHT: EXCEPTIO N TO RULE NOS. 165:10-13-9 AND 165 :10-17-11 OF THE OCC-OGR LAND COVERED: SECTION 16, TOWNSHIP 6 N ORTH, RANGE 9 WEST, CADDO COUNTY, OKLAHOMA. APP LICATION CAUSE CD NO. ) 200806612-T ) REF) AG6N9NT FOR FAX FILED ON TLED / Rg~ ~ SEP 1 8 2008 COURT C4ERK'S OFFICE - TULSA CORPORATION COMMISSIO N O F OKLAHOM A 1. PARTIES : Applicant is Apache Corporation. Its address is Two Warren Place, Suite 1500, 6120 South Yale, Tulsa, Oklahoma 74136-4224. It is the owner of oil and gas leasehold interests within Section 16, Township 6 No rt h, Range 9 West, Caddo County, Oklahoma. The parties being made respondents to this application are set out on the Exhibit "A" attached hereto. 2. ALLEGATION OF FACTS : (A) The Corporation Commission has heretofore, by Order No. 200366, established a 640 -acre drilling and spacing unit for the Sp ringer common source of supply underlying Section 16, Township 6 No rt h, Range 9 West, Caddo County, Oklahoma. (B) Well(s) in Section 16 currently produce(s) the Springer common source of supply. (C) Rule No. 165 :10-13-9 provides that increased density wells share one unit allowable with the initial unit well. The unit allowable is to be determined by the greater of a minimum allowable or a normal allowable based on wellhead absolute open flow of the best well in the unit. The normal allowable is derived from Rule No. 165 :10-17-11 which defines maximum permitted rates of production for unallocated gas wells. (D) The existing Springer wells in Section 16 are unallocated gas wells. The Applicant is proposing to drill two (2) additional wells into the Springer common source of supply underlying said Section 16. The Order to issue in a pending cause will authorize the drilling of such wells. Given the amount of gas capable of being produced by the existing Springer wells in said Section 16, and the expected wellhead absolute open flow potential for the proposed wells, the Applicant believes there will be insufficient allowable to justify the risk and expense of drilling such proposed wells.
SEPARATE ALLOWABLE - CAUSE CD NO. 20080 SECTION 16-6N-9W, CADDO COUNTY, OKLAHOMA APACHE CORP. 4. RELIEF SOUGHT : The relief requested is an Order granting an exception to the provisions of Rule Nos. 165:10-13-9 and 165:10-17-11 of the OCC-OGR, so as to provide a separate allowable to one (1) of the two (2) increased density wells authorized by the Order to issue in a pending cause for the Springer common source of supply underlying the 640-acre drilling and spacing unit consisting of Section 16, Township 6 North, Range 9 West, Caddo County, Oklahoma. The separate allowable to be calculated by the greater of the minimum allowable or the percentage of the wells' wellhead absolute open flow potential as determined under the provisions of the rules of the Commission. In the alternative, the Applicant would request an order increasing the unit allowable for the Springer common source of supply in Section 16 to a definite amount of gas per day, said amount to be determined by the evidence submitted at the hearing. APACHE CORPORATIO N ~ - RICHARD A. GRIMES, OBA #3627 609 S. Kelly Avenue, Suite K-4 Edmond, Oklahoma 7300 3 (405) 330-072 5 ATTORNEY FOR APPLICANT
SECTION 16-6N-9W, CADDO COUNTY, OKLAHOMA 1. A & S OPERATING IN C 233 S DETROIT STE 20 0 TULSA, OK 74120 2. A DANIEL WOSK A 2110 HUMMINGBIRD L N EDMOND, OK 73034-603 9 3. ABRAXAS OPERATING LL C 500 N LOOP 1604 E SUITE 100 SAN ANTONIO, TX 78232 4. ARBUCKLE ENTERPRISES INC PO BOX 525 0 EDMOND, OK 73083-5250 5. AXIS EXPLORATION LL C 15 W 6TH ST STE 235 0 TULSA, OK 74119-541 5 6. BARBER EXPLORATION COMPANY 8774 S RICHMOND AVE TULSA, OK 74137 7. BERT GOODPASTURE LIVING TRUST 11716 ROYAL COACH DR YUKON, OK 7309 9 8. BL MANAGEMENT LLC 3 1 00 CUMBERLAND D R EDMOND, OK 73034-8364 9. BLU LL C 1024 NW 71 S T 10. BOBWHITE MANAGEMENT CO INC 2250 E 49TH ST STE 1 TULSA, OK 74105 11. BRIAN P BURN S % BF ENTERPRISES INC 125 WORTH AVE STE 219 PALM BEACH, FL 33480 15. CAGO IN C 12300 HUNTERS CRK RD COLLEGE STATION, TX 77845-0295 16. CARDINAL RIVER ENERGY I LP 210 PARK AVE, STE 1130 OKLAHOMA CITY, OK 7310 2 17. CARL A NILSEN ESTAT E 3232 WEST BRITTON ROAD STE 140 OKLAHOMA CITY, OK 7312 0 18. CARL E GUNGOLL EXPLORATION LLC PO BOX 1846 6 OKLAHOMA CITY, OK 7315 4 19. CAROLE J DRAKE PO BOX 18466 OKLAHOMA CITY, OK 73154-046 6 20. CAROLYN L HUGHES REVOC INTER VIVO TRUST DTD 3/18/00 6500 N CLASSEN BLVD OKLAHOMA CITY, OK 7311 6 21. CAROLYN L. HUGHES TRUST C 6500 NORTH CLASSEN BLVD. OKLAHOMA CITY, OK 7311 6 22. CCI 1983-I TEXOMA LTD PO BOX 74108 7 DALLAS, TX 7524 3 23. CHESAPEAKE EXPLORATION LLC PO BOX 1849 6 OKLAHOMA CITY, OK 73154-049 6 24. CHESAPEAKE INVESTMENTS PO BOX 1875 6 OKLAHOMA CITY, OK 73 154-0756 25. CHESAPEAKE INVESTMENTS PO BOX 1875 6 OKLAHOMA CITY, OK 73154-0756
SECTION 16-6N-9W, CADDO COUNTY, OKLAHOMA 28. CHEVRON NORTH AMERICA EXPLORATION AND PROD CO PO BOX 3636 6 HOUSTON, TX 77236-636 6 29. CHEVRON USA INC PO BOX 36366 HOUSTON, TX 77236-6366 30. CLIFF CO X PO BOX 545 PIEDMONT, OK 7307 8 31. CLIFF WOODBURY 7405 S COLLEG E TULSA, OK 7413 6 32. CLIFF WOODBURY 7405 S COLLEG E TULSA, OK 7413 6 33. COLONEL A RICHARDSON JR 9249 S BROADWY BL UT 200 #429 HIGHLANDS RANCH, CO 80129 34. CONNER L HELM S 2500 FIRST NATIONAL CTR 120 N ROBINSON OKLAHOMA CITY, OK 7301 2 35. CONSUL PROPERTIES LLC 12316 - ANORTH MAY AVE #205 OKLAHOMA CITY, OK 7312 0 36. CROW CREEK ENERGY II LLC 2201 SOUTH UTICA PLACE TULSA, OK 7411 4 37. CURTIS S GREEN REV TR DTD 8/1/91C GREEN TTEE 2121 S COLUMBIA AVE STE 305 TULSA, OK 74114-350 5 38. DAVID TURNEY 2417 WEST BENT TRL ROAD EDMOND, OK 73003 41. EMERGE OIL & GAS COMPANY LLC 3103 KRISTIN COUR T GARLAND, TX 75044 42. EQUITABLE ROYALTY CORPORATION PO BOX 2356 OKLAHOMA CITY, OK 73101-2356 43. FELL OIL & GAS LL P PO BOX 9487 TULSA, OK 7415 7 44. FIELDPOINT PETROLEUM CORPORATION 1703 EDELWEISS DR CEDAR PARK, TX 7861 3 45. FULLER MINERAL TRUST, TERESA A FULLER SUCC TRUSTE E 606 BARRY P L ALTADENA, CA 91001-2329 46. G LYNDELL BUCK REVOCABLE, BUCK & CLEMA I BUCK SUCC CO TTEES PO BOX 1295 2 OKLAHOMA CITY, OK 73157-295 2 47. GAMBIT INVESTMENT CO. P O BOX 5239 7 TULSA, OK 74152-0397 48. GARY R UNDERWOO D 2500 FIRST NATIONAL CENTER 120 N ROBINSO N OKLAHOMA CITY, OK 7310 2 49. GARY W GOSS PO BOX 70026 8 TULSA, OK 74170-026 8 50. GORDON FAMILY INVESTMENT CO LLC 3000 UNITED FOUNDERS BLVD #G - 103G
SECTION 16-6N-9W, CADDO COUNTY, OKLAHOMA 53. HAROLD L HODGES P O BOX 270660 OKLAHOMA CITY, OK 73137 54. HENRY GUNGOLL ASSOCIATES LLC PO BOX 620 9 ENID, OK 73702-6209 55. HIGH ALPINE PRODUCTION LLC PO BOX 70092 7 TULSA, OK 74170-092 7 56. HOG PARTNERSHIP L P 5950 CEDAR SPRINGS RD STE 242 DALLAS, TX 75235-6803 57. J & D PETRO INC, VERLAN W HARRELAGENT 101 PARK AVE STE 310 OKLAHOMA CITY, OK 73102-720 1 58. JOHN R PARSONS 1993 REV TRUST, JOHN R PARSONS TRUSTEE 6507 LENOX AVE 59. JAMES D PAL M 1802 CANYON PARK CIR STE B EDMOND, OK 73013-6000 60. JMA RESOURCES IN C 1021 NW GRAND BLVD OKLAHOMA CITY, OK 7311 8 61. JOHN R. BUCKTHAL 700 S. FILLMORE, SUITE 345 AMARILLO, TX 7910 1 62. JOSECA INVESTMENTS LLC PO BOX 177 8 EDMOND, OK 73083-1778 63. JULIA BUCKTHAL PERSON 700 S FILLMORE ST. STE. 444 A 11 A A r111 1/1 T V l A A A I1 A A A 66. KLABZUBA BROTHERS LLC PO BOX 567 PRAGUE, OK 7486 4 67. KLABZUBA EXPLORATION LLC PO BOX 581 5 EDMOND, OK 7308 3 68. KLABZUBA ROYALTY COMPANY PO BOX 567 PRAGUE, OK 7486 4 69. LAIRMORE ENERGY CORPORATION PO BOX 1 BIXBY, OK 7400 8 70. LARRY FENITY 2301 BROOKSIDE AVENUE EDMOND, OK 73034 71. LAREDO PETROLEUM, INC. 15 WEST 6TH ST, STE 1800 TULSA, OK 7411 9 72. LOIN ENERGY CORPORATIO N PO BOX 309 LAGRANGE, TX 78945 73. LOIS J SCOTT TRUST 1517 SW 69TH S T LAWTON, OK 7350 5 74. MARY W ATHENS LIVING TRUST DTD 10/30/9 8 5 WEST SECOND STREET TULSA, OK 74114-2322 75. MCHAFFEY & GORE, P. C. C/O TRAVIS BROWN 300 NE 1 ST STREET OKLAHOMA CITY, OK 73104 76. MCHAFFEY & GORE, P.C. C/O TRAVIS BROWN 300 NE 1 ST STREET ~ 1- A I - A A -i ~i -.i.. i..
SEPARATE ALLOWABLE - CD NO. 200806612 - T SECTION 16-6N-9W, CADDO COUNTY, OKLAHOMA 79. NAPAH CORPORATION 700 S FILLMORE SUITE 444 AMARILLO, TX 79101-2443 80. NEAL MCLEM ORE 18257 S 132ND E AV E BIXBY, OK 7400 8 81. NORTHBROOK OIL & GAS CO PO BOX 1405 5 OKLAHOMA CITY, OK 7311 3 82. NORTHWESTERN MUTUAL LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY 720 E WISCONSIN AVE MILWAUKEE, WI 5320 2 83. PDIINC 105 N HUDSON 800 HIGHTOWER BLD OKLAHOMA CITY, OK 73102-4804 84. PAUL STAFFORD 11005 QUEENSWICK COURT OKLAHOMA CITY, OK 7316 2 85. PONTOTOC PRODUCTION COMPANY IN C 4965 PRESTON PARK BVD STE 800 PLANO, TX 75093 86. POSSE ENERGY LT D 1221 MCKINNEY STE 3700 HOUSTON, TX 77010-3676 87. PRIMEENERGY MANAGEMENT CORP C/O PRIME OPERATING COMPANY 5400 NW GRAND BLVD #450 JIB OKLAHOMA CITY, OK 73112-5652 88. PRIMEENERGY MANAGEMENT COR P C/O PRIME OPERATING COMPANY 5400 NW GRAND BLVD #450 JIB OKLAHOMA CITY, OK 73112-5652 91. R R ROBINSON TRUST PO BOX 172 1 LA QUINTA, CA 9224 7-172 1 92. R S BAKER J R PO BOX 3448 ENID, OK 73702 93. RAYMOND M TIMPANELL I 5729 LEBANON RD # 1 44 PMB 404 FRISCO, TX 75034 94. REBEL OIL COMPANY 6500 N CLASSEN BLVD 95. RICHARD L HAUSCHILD JR 6300 OAK FOREST RD EDMOND, OK 7302 5 96. ROBERT E LEE II I 4045 NW 64TH STE 201 97. ROBERT E LEE III TRUST C 4045 N W 64TH STE 201 98. ROBERT R KLABZUBA PO BOX 581 5 EDMOND, OK 73083-581 5 99. ROMAYNE S BAKER OIL AND GAS LIMITED PARTNERSHI P PO BOX 3607 ENID, OK 7370 2 100. RUPE OIL COMPANY IN C C/O CONTINENTAL OPERATING CO P 0 BOX 78301 0 WICHITA, KS 67278-301 0 101. S K WARREN RESOURCES L L C P 0 BOX 47037 2 TULSA, OK 74147-0372
SECTION 16-6N-9W, CADDO COUNTY, OKLAHOMA 105. SHIRLEY KLEIN COMPANY 6059 S NOME ST ENGLEWOOD, CO 80111 106. SIDWELL OIL & GAS INC P 0 BOX 9298 AMARILLO, TX 79105-929 8 107. STATE OF OKLAHOMA PO BOX 2691 0 OKLAHOMA CITY, OK 73126-091 0 108. STEPHEN C WILCOX & VICKI L WILCOX JT TEN 12909 CASTLEROCK CT OKLAHOMA CITY, OK 73142-5129 109. STEWART MARTIN BASIN 1981-1 PO BOX 1245 2 OKLAHOMA CITY, OK 7315 7 110. STROUBE ENERGY CORPORATION 17194 PRESTON RD #102 LB 249 DALLAS, TX 75248 111. SUNDOWN ENERGY INC 13455 NOEL RD STE 2000 DALLAS, TX 75240 112. T DAVID HASBROOK 3324 SHADOW VALLEY DR EDMOND, OK 73034 113. TCD EXPLORATION LL C 211 N ROBINSON STE 1300 S OKLAHOMA CITY, OK 73102-7149 114. TERRANE ASSOCIATES INC 20 COUNTRY WAY SCITUATE, MA 0206 6 115. THE HEFNER COMPANY INC PO BOX 2177 OKLAHOMA CITY, OK 73101-2177 116. TLW INVESTMENTS LLC 119. UNCOMPAHGRE ROYALTY LP PO BOX 2531 3 DALLAS, TX 75225 120. UNIT PETROLEUM COMPANY PO BOX 70250 0 TULSA, OK 741 70 121. UPSHER EXPLORATIONS LLC C/O SIDNEY P UPSHE R 2406 NORTHWEST GRAND CIRCLE OKLAHOMA CITY, OK 7311 6 122. UPSHER EXPLORATIONS LLC C/O SIDNEY P UPSHE R 2406 NORTHWEST GRAND CIRCLE 123. VIERSEN OIL & GAS C O PO BOX 70270 8 TULSA, OK 7417 0 124. W-4 CAPITAL LL C PO BOX 30598 EDMOND, OK 73003 125. WCT RESOURCES LLC PO BOX 5452 5 OKLAHOMA CITY, OK 7315 4 126. WHITE STAR ROYALTY CO LLC PO BOX 1869 3 OKLAHOMA CITY, OK 73154-069 3 127. WILLIAM H DAVI S 1334 TOWNSEND GLE N BLANCHARD, OK 7301 0 128. WILLIAM T STOKE S 7703 SOUTHWESTERN BLVD DALLAS, TX 75225 1 29. YOUNGBLOOD LTD, PENNY L YOUNGBLOOD G P 3826 N VERSAILLES AVE DALLAS, TX 75209