March 19, 2013 MINUTES Book 1 VALUE ADJUSTMENT BOARD Page 974

Transcription

1 VALUE ADJUSTMENT BOARD Page 974 SARASOTA COUNTY ADMINISTRATION CENTER 1660 RINGLING BOULEVARD THINK TANK, THIRD FLOOR SARASOTA, FLORIDA 8:00 a.m. Joseph A. Barbetta, County Commissioner, Chair Carolyn J. Mason, County Commissioner, Vice Chair Carol Todd, School Board Member James Piro, Citizen Member Leonard Smally, Citizen Member Also present were: Sheryl Edwards, Value Adjustment Board Attorney Pauline A. Shaw, Clerk of the Circuit Court Board Records Manager Debbie Shaffer, Deputy Clerk (08:02 a.m.) 1. MINUTES 8:03 a.m. Board Action: Approved the Minutes of the meeting dated February 25, Moved by Piro, seconded by Todd, carried by a 5-0 vote. (08:03 a.m.) 2. POLICIES AND PROCEDURES Value Adjustment Board Attorney Sheryl Edwards commented on her review of the Special Magistrates' Recommended Decisions, pursuant to Florida Department of Revenue Rule 12D (08:04 a.m.) 3. RECOMMENDATIONS OF SPECIAL MAGISTRATE RICHARD BASS A. GRANTED 8:04 a.m. Board Action: Adopted Special Magistrate Bass' Recommendation to grant the following Petitions. Moved by Mason, seconded by Todd, carried by a 5-0 vote. Petition No , Patricia Bealls, Trustee; Petition No , David Beachy; Petition No , David Beachy; Petition No , David Beachy. B. DENIED 8:04 a.m. Board Action: Adopted Special Magistrate Bass' Recommendation to deny the following Petitions. Moved by Mason, seconded by Todd, carried by a 5-0 vote. Petition No , Coastal QSR, LLC; Petition No , McDonald's Restaurant; Petition No , Jehohanan, Inc.; Petition No , Sayed Shaukat; Petition No , RRR Riverview, LLC; Petition No , 1825 Brentwood Road, Inc.;

2 VALUE ADJUSTMENT BOARD Page RECOMMENDATIONS OF SPECIAL MAGISTRATE BASS B. DENIED (Continued) Petition No , Randall Benderson, Trustee; Petition No , Walgreens Store No. 3332, LLC; Petition No , Walsota, LLC; Petition No , Despy Properties, LLC; Petition No , Walgreen Co.; Petition No , Olympia Development Group, Inc.; Petition No , Walgreen Co.; Petition No , Milman Family Ltd. Partnership; Petition No , Walgreen Co.; Petition No , Walgreen Co.; Petition No , Walgreen Co.; Petition No , Walgreen Co.; Petition No , Walgreen Co.; Petition No , Walgreen Co.; Petition No , Walgreen Co.; Petition No , Roberts Family Trust Florida Holdings, LLC; Petition No , Murphy Oil USA, Inc.; Petition No , Murphy Oil USA, Inc.; Petition No , Griffin Development, LLC; Petition No , Larry Schuster, Trustee; Petition No , Long Boat Land Company, LLC; Petition No , AN Luxury Imports of Sarasota, Inc.; Petition No , B F Ft. Myers, Inc.; Petition No , B F Ft. Myers, Inc.; Petition No , Eide Elling Charitable Foundation, Inc.; Petition No , B F Ft. Myers, Inc.; Petition No , KDL Associates; Petition No , La Linda Terrace Partnership; Petition No , B F Ft. Myers, Inc.; Petition No , Ronald Miller; Petition No , Florida Sunshine Property, Inc.; Petition No , Richard Goldberg; Petition No , Florida Sunshine Properties, Inc.; Petition No , Richard Best; Petition No , Florida Sunshine Properties, Inc.; Petition No , Florida Sunshine Property, Inc.; Petition No , BFM Enterprises, Inc.; Petition No , NP Pan Am Center, LLC; Petition No , Chad Williams; Petition No , Mahfouz El Shahawy; Petition No , Ringling Centre, LLC; Petition No , Douglas Moore, Trustee; Petition No , James McGonigle.

3 VALUE ADJUSTMENT BOARD Page 976 (08:05 a.m.) 4. RECOMMENDATIONS OF SPECIAL MAGISTRATE JOHN MCQUEEN A. GRANTED 8:05 a.m. Board Action: Adopted Special Magistrate McQueen's Recommendation to grant the following Petitions. Moved by Todd, seconded by Mason, carried by a 5-0 vote. Petition No , Bozena Walczak; Petition No , Karl Frisch; Petition No , Allan Lichtenstein; Petition No , RL 107, LLC; Petition No , Medallion Holdings, LLC; Petition No , Professional Parkway West, LLC; Petition No , Island Sun Inn, LLC; Petition No , Philip Graber; Petition No , Francis LaMotte; Petition No , Sarasota Health Care Partners, Ltd. B. DENIED 8:05 a.m. Board Action: Adopted Special Magistrate McQueen's Recommendation to deny the following Petitions. Moved by Todd, seconded by Mason, carried by a 5-0 vote. Petition No , Dan Cutzu; Petition No , Steven Murray; Petition No , Quality Self Storage Kenneth City, LLC; Petition No , Foundation Park Holdings, LLC; Petition No , Foundation Park Holdings, LLC; Petition No , Foundation Park Holdings, LLC; Petition No , Foundation Park Holdings, LLC; Petition No , Osprey Housing, LLC; Petition No , Medallion Holdings, LLC; Petition No , Stanley Ferro; Petition No , Richard Cialabrini; Petition No , Jens Albiez; Petition No , Saber-North Port, LLC; Petition No , Saber-North Port, LLC; Petition No , Saber-North Port, LLC; Petition No , Saber-North Port, LLC; Petition No , Saber-North Port, LLC; Petition No , Saber-North Port, LLC; Petition No , Saber-North Port, LLC; Petition No , Saber-North Port, LLC; Petition No , Saber-North Port, LLC; Petition No , Saber-North Port, LLC; Petition No , Jeffry Snauwaert; Petition No , Edward Ahlstrand; Petition No , Alan Redmon; Petition No , Joseph Rosen.

4 VALUE ADJUSTMENT BOARD Page 977 (08:06 a.m.) 5. RECOMMENDATIONS OF SPECIAL MAGISTRATE RICK RAPE A. GRANTED 8:06 a.m. Board Action: Adopted Special Magistrate Rape's Recommendation to grant the following Petitions. Moved by Piro, seconded by Smally, carried by a 5-0 vote. Petition No , W2007 Equity Inns Realty, LLC; Petition No , Fifth Third Bank; Petition No , City of Sarasota; Petition No , Marinemax East, Inc.; Petition No , MHC Bay Indies Vistas, Inc.; Petition No , MHC Lake Village, LLC; Petition No , Hafam FL 25, LLC; Petition No , Chili's Florida, Inc.; Petition No , Chili's Plaza of Sarasota, Ltd.; Petition No , Maxfield Property, Ltd.; Petition No , BKOP1, LLC; Petition No , SLAB LP Lease, LLC; Petition No , SLAB, LLC; Petition No , Health Care Reit, Inc. B. DENIED 8:06 a.m. Board Action: Adopted Special Magistrate Rape's Recommendation to deny the following Petitions. Moved by Piro, seconded by Smally, carried by a 5-0 vote. Petition No , Baer's Furniture Co., Inc.; Petition No , Fifth Third Bank; Petition No , GTE Federal Credit Union; Petition No , Wachovia Bank, NA; Petition No , Wachovia Bank, NA; Petition No , Wachovia Bank, NA; Petition No , First Union National Bank of Florida; Petition No , Linda Freeman, Trustee; Petition No , WCI Communities, LLC; Petition No , CA New Plan Sarasota, LP; Petition No , CA New Plan Sarasota, LP; Petition No , CA New Plan Sarasota, LP; Petition No , CA New Plan Sarasota, LP; Petition No , BRE Mariner Venice Plaza, LLC; Petition No , BRE Mariner Venice Plaza, LLC; Petition No , BRE Mariner Venice Plaza, LLC; Petition No , 430 HWY 41 Bypass N, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club II, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club II, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC;

5 VALUE ADJUSTMENT BOARD Page RECOMMENDATIONS OF SPECIAL MAGISTRATE RAPE B. DENIED (Continued) Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club II, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club II, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club II, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club II, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC;

6 VALUE ADJUSTMENT BOARD Page RECOMMENDATIONS OF SPECIAL MAGISTRATE RAPE B. DENIED (Continued) Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , LB Founders Club I, LLC; Petition No , BTS Investors, LLC; Petition No , MCH Lake Village, LLC; Petition No , Venice Plaza, Ltd.; Petition No , Sarasota Commons, Ltd.; Petition No , Hafam FL 582, LLC; Petition No , SLAB, LLC; Petition No , William Petit, Jr., Trustee. (8:06 a.m.) 6. RECOMMENDATION OF SPECIAL MAGISTRATE LORI RUTLAND 8:06 a.m. Board Action: Adopted Special Magistrate Rutland's Recommendation to deny Petition No , Norinda Yancy. Moved by Mason, seconded by Todd, carried by a 5-0 vote.

7 VALUE ADJUSTMENT BOARD Page 980 (8:07 a.m.) 7. RECOMMENDATIONS OF SPECIAL MAGISTRATE MICHAEL VALENTICH A. GRANTED 8:07 a.m. Board Action: Adopted Special Magistrate Valentich's Recommendation to grant the following Petitions. Moved by Todd, seconded by Mason, carried by a 5-0 vote , Haji Tehrani; , Dale Thomas. B. DENIED 8:07 a.m. Board Action: Adopted Special Magistrate Valentich's Recommendation to deny the following Petitions. Moved by Todd, seconded by Mason, carried by a 5-0 vote , Venice HMA, LLC; , Venice HMA, LLC; , Gateway A/B Fund VII, LP; , Sky King Unlimited, Inc , William Mehserle; , Melanie McMurray; , Edwin Fraser; , Sylvia Babineau; , Drew Gillett. (08:11 a.m.) 8. PRIVATE COUNSEL The Value Adjustment Board (VAB) considered the Ratification of Payment of Invoice for Private Counsel. 8:11 a.m. Board Action: Ratified payment to VAB Attorney Sheryl Edwards, in the amount of $3, Moved by Piro, seconded by Smally, carried by a 5-0 vote. (08:11 a.m.) 9. PAYMENT OF INVOICES 8:11 a.m. Board Action: Approved payments to the Special Magistrates as follows. Moved by Mason, seconded by Todd, carried by a 5-0 vote. A. Special Magistrate Richard Bass, in the amount of $1,125.00; B. Special Magistrate John McQueen, in the amount of $375.00; C. Special Magistrate Rick Rape, in the amount of $8,552.59; D. Special Magistrate Michael Valentich, in the amount of $ (08:12 a.m.) 10. AUTHORIZATION TO ADVERTISE FOR SPECIAL MAGISTRATES 8:12 a.m. Board Action: Authorized advertisement for Special Magistrates for the 2013 Value Adjustment Board season. Moved by Todd, seconded by Smally, carried by a 5-0 vote.

8 VALUE ADJUSTMENT BOARD Page 981 (08:12 a.m.) 11. MEETING SCHEDULE Upon inquiry, Clerk of the Circuit Court Board Records Manager Pauline Shaw noted that the Organizational Meeting for the 2013 Value Adjustment Board season will be scheduled for mid/late-september (08:13 a.m.) 12. OPEN TO THE PUBLIC Sylvia Babineau commented on her Petition. (08:07 a.m.) 13. OTHER BUSINESS 8:10 a.m. Board Action: Authorized the Chair's signature on Florida Department of Revenue Form DR-488, Certification of the Value Adjustment Board. Moved by Todd, seconded by Mason, carried by a 5-0 vote. MEETING RECESSED: 8:25 a.m. MINUTES APPROVED: Chair