Genotyping of extant and ancient populations has been used

 Douglas Peters
 3 months ago
 Views:
Transcription
1 Maritime route of colonization of Europe Peristera Paschou a,1, Petros Drineas b,1, Evangelia Yannaki c, Anna Razou d, Katerina Kanaki d, Fotis Tsetsos a, Shanmukha Sampath Padmanabhuni a, Manolis Michalodimitrakis d, Maria C. Renda e, Sonja Pavlovic f, Achilles Anagnostopoulos c, John A. Stamatoyannopoulos g, Kenneth K. Kidd h, and George Stamatoyannopoulos g,2 a Department of Molecular Biology and Genetics, Democritus University of Thrace, Alexandroupolis, Greece; b Department of Computer Science, Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, Troy, NY 12180; c Department of Hematology, George Papanicolaou Hospital, Thessaloniki, Greece; d Department of Forensic Medicine, University of Crete, Heraklion, Crete, Greece; e Unità di Ricerca P. Cutino, Ospedali Riuniti Villa SofiaCervello, Palermo, Italy; f Institute of Molecular Genetics and Genetic Engineering, University of Belgrade, Belgrade, Serbia; g Departments of Medicine and Genome Sciences, University of Washington, Seattle, WA 98195; and h Department of Genetics, Yale University School of Medicine, New Haven, CT Edited* by Yuet Wai Kan, University of California, San Francisco School of Medicine, San Francisco, CA, and approved May 9, 2014 (received for review November 7, 2013) The Neolithic populations, which colonized Europe approximately 9,000 y ago, presumably migrated from Near East to Anatolia and from there to Central Europe through Thrace and the Balkans. An alternative route would have been island hopping across the Southern European coast. To test this hypothesis, we analyzed genomewide DNA polymorphisms on populations bordering the Mediterranean coast and from Anatolia and mainland Europe. We observe a striking structure correlating genes with geography around the Mediterranean Sea with characteristic east to west clines of gene flow. Using population network analysis, we also find that the gene flow from Anatolia to Europe was through Dodecanese, Crete, and the Southern European coast, compatible with the hypothesis that a maritime coastal route was mainly used for the migration of Neolithic farmers to Europe. Genotyping of extant and ancient populations has been used to address the question of the origins of the people of Europe. The genome of the presentday Europeans reflects merging of the Paleolithic settlers who colonized Europe 35,000 40,000 y before the present era (BPE) and the Neolithic people who started colonizing Europe approximately 9,000 y BPE. The Neolithic contribution to the gene pool of modern Europeans has been estimated with studies of extant European populations by using mitochondrial DNA, Ychromosomal DNA, or nuclear DNA polymorphisms. Mitochondrial DNA studies estimate the Neolithic contribution to the maternal lineages of the modern Europeans to range between 10 and 20% (1). A contribution of approximately 22% was suggested by a study of Ychromosome polymorphisms, which also found that the Neolithic contribution was more pronounced along the Mediterranean coast (2). Neolithic contributions of 50 70% were estimated with other methodologies (3 5), including highly polymorphic DNA markers (6). Clinal patterns of genetic diversity of autosomal (7 9) or Ychromosomal (10) polymorphisms across Europe suggest that the Neolithic migrants originated from the Near East (7 9). It has been proposed that these Near Eastern migrants brought to Europe their new agricultural technologies (7 9, 11) and, perhaps, the IndoEuropean language (12). How did these Neolithic people reach Europe from the Near East? The geographic focus of the transition from foraging to the Neolithic way of life was the Levantine corridor, which extended from the Fertile Crescent to the southeastern sections of the central Anatolian basin (13). The Neolithic farmers could have taken three migration routes to Europe. One was by land to NorthEastern Anatolia and from there, through Bosporus and the Dardanelles, to Thrace and the Balkans (14, 15). A second route was a maritime route from the Aegean Anatolian coast to the Mediterranean islands and the coast of Southern Europe (12, 14 18). The third was from the Levantine coast to the Aegean islands and Greece (19). Navigation across the Mediterranean was active during the Early Neolithic and Upper Paleolithic (16 18) as illustrated by the finding of obsidian from the island of Milos in Paleolithic sites of the Greek mainland (19, 20) and the early colonization of Sardinia, Corsica, and Cyprus (18, 21 23). If a maritime route was used by the Neolithic farmers who settled Europe, their first stepping stones into Europe were the islands of Dodecanese and Crete. The Dodecanese is very close to the Aegean coast of Anatolia, whereas the westmost Dodecanesean islands are very close to Crete. Crete hosts one of the oldest Neolithic settlements of Europe in the site of Knossos, established 8,500 9,000 y BPE (24, 25), and the inhabitants of the island established the first advanced European civilization starting approximately 5,000 BPE. To obtain insights on the question of migrations to Europe, we analyzed genomewide autosomal single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) from a dataset of 32 populations. This dataset includes population samples from the islands of Crete and Dodecanese, one from Cappadocia in Central Anatolia, three subpopulations from different regions of mainland Greece, 14 other populations from Southern and Northern Europe, five populations from the Near East, and seven from North Africa. In addition to established methods for genetics analysis, we use a population genetics network approach that can define pathways of gene flow between populations. Our data are compatible with the hypothesis that a maritime route connecting Anatolia and Southern Europe through Dodecanese and Crete was the main route used by the Neolithic migrants to reach Europe. Results Genes Mirror Geography Across the Mediterranean Basin. We first used principal components analysis (PCA) to visualize the genotypic distances between studied populations (Fig. 1; also see SI Appendix, Significance The question of colonization of Europe by Neolithic people of the Near East and their contribution to the farming economy of Europe has been addressed with extensive archaeological studies and many genetic investigations of extant European and Near Eastern populations. Here, we use DNA polymorphisms of extant populations to investigate the patterns of gene flow from the Near East to Europe. Our data support the hypothesis that Near Eastern migrants reached Europe from Anatolia. A maritime route and island hopping was mainly used by these Near Eastern migrants to reach Southern Europe. Author contributions: G.S. designed research; P.P., P.D., E.Y., A.R., K.K., M.M., M.C.R., S.P., A.A., and K.K.K. performed research; E.Y., A.R., K.K., M.M., M.C.R., S.P., and A.A. performed population studies; K.K.K. contributed data; P.P., P.D., F.T., and S.S.P. analyzed data; and P.P., P.D., J.A.S., and G.S. wrote the paper. The authors declare no conflict of interest. *This Direct Submission article had a prearranged editor. Freely available online through the PNAS open access option. 1 P.P. and P.D. contributed equally to this work. 2 To whom correspondence should be addressed. This article contains supporting information online at 1073/pnas //DCSupplemental. GENETICS PNAS June 24, 2014 vol. 111 no
2 Figs. S1 and S2 and Tables S1 and S2). Populations on the southern and northern coasts of the Mediterranean, appear to be separated by the geographic barrier of the Mediterranean Sea. The role of the Mediterranean Sea as a barrier for gene flow among populations was also supported by our analysis using the BARRIER software (26), which implements Monmonier s maximum difference algorithm (SI Appendix, SI Methods and Results and Fig. S3). In accordance with this finding, notice, in Fig. 1B, that the PCA distribution of the populations closely resembles the geographic map of the countries circling the Mediterranean Sea. On this PCA map of populations, the east coast of the Mediterranean Sea is appropriately occupied by the Palestinians and the Lebanese Druze. Yemenites and Bedouins branch out from the Mediterranean populations and are closer to the populations of the Near East. Fig. 2 further illustrates the considerable resemblance of the PCA projection of the genotypes on the 2D space to the geographic map of the European Mediterranean coast. The east to west cline from Near East and Anatolia across the southern Mediterranean coast fits with the hypothesis of early population movements from the Near East to Europe (7 9). The populations of the European Mediterranean Coast connect with the Near East although Anatolia (Cappadocia). In fact, the closest populations to Anatolia are those of Crete and Dodecanese rather than the populations of the Balkans or Northern Greece. When considering Europe, Anatolia, and the Near East using PCA (Fig. 1C), a clear gradient is again observed, with populations from Northern and Central Europe connecting to Anatolia and the Near East via Southern Europe and through the bridge of the islands of Dodecanese and Crete. Three population tests (f3 statistics) as described in ref. 27 did not provide any evidence of bidirectional admixture or population splits along this line of stepping stones connecting Anatolia to Southeastern Europe (SI Appendix, SI Methods and Results). The correlation of geographic coordinates of the Mediterranean populations to the top two principal components (as shown in SI Appendix, Fig.S2D) is very high; the Pearson correlation coefficient is 0.66 between latitude (north to south axis) and the first principal component, and 0.81 between longitude (east to west axis) and the second A B Yemenites Bedouin Druze EigenSNP 2 Cappadocia Crete Southern Europe Sardina Palestinians Egypt Libya Northern Africa * * Basque * C Northern Europe Southern Europe Crete Cappadocia Central Europe Libya Egypt Palestinians Druze Northern Africa Algeria Basque Bedouin Chuvash Crete Denmark Dodecanese Druze East Rumelia Egypt Finland France Hungary Ireland Italy Cappadocia Libya Macedonia North Morocco South Morocco Mozabite SE Laconia Palestine Peloponnese Russia Sahara OCC Sardinia Serbia Sicily Tunisia Tuscany Yemenite EigenSNP 1 Fig. 1. Genes mirror geography around the Mediterranean coast. (A) Geographic distribution of the populations included in this study. (B) Projection on top two principal components of samples from 25 populations genotyped on 75,000 genomewide autosomal SNPs. A clear cline is observed with Anatolia (Cappadocia) connected to Southern Europe through the bridge of the islands of the Dodecanese and Crete. Bedouins and Yemenites drift toward Central South Asia. No apparent gene flow between Northern Africa and the Southern coast of Europe is observed. (C) Projection on top two principal components of samples from 30 populations genotyped on the same set of SNPs presented in B. Northern European populations have now been added; Bedouins and Yemenites were removed. The cline now continues through Central and Northern Europe Paschou et al.
3 Fig. 2. Genetic structure of populations along the Southern European Coast in relation to Anatolia. (A) PCA plot of 10 populations from the Southern European coast and Cappadocia. The first principal component reveals the East to West cline in genetic variation along the Southern Coast of Europe and Mediterranean islands. Basques and Sardinians appear isolated relatively to the remaining studied populations. (B) Structure of the Southern European populations and Cappadocia excluding the more remote Basques and Sardinians. principal component (P < 10 5 as defined by Mantel test, see SI Appendix, Table S3 for geographic coordinates of the populations; this analysis does not even rotate or rescale the data, as was done in ref. 28). Thus, the PCA analysis supports a migration pathway from Anatolia to Europe through island hopping in the Aegean Sea. To further analyze the relationships between the populations of the Mediterranean basin through an independent methodology, we used ADMIXTURE, an unsupervised ancestryinference algorithm (Fig. 3; also see SI Appendix,Fig.S4andS5). ADMIXTURE analysis on an LDpruned dataset of 72,951 SNPs leads to essentially the same conclusions as PCA. The Near East and Anatolia are connected to Southern Europe through Crete and Dodecanese supporting the hypothesis of a pathway to Europe through the coastal Mediterranean route. ADMIXTURE analysis also illustrated the distinction between the populations of the North African coast and those of the European Mediterranean coast, and their connection through the populations of the Near East (Fig. 3). Thus, both the results of the PCA and the ADMIXTURE analysis are compatible with a maritime route of migrations from Anatolia/Near East to Southern Europe, in which Crete and the Dodecanese were used as the stepping stones by the migrating populations. Network Analysis to Identify Pathways of Gene Flow Between Populations. To further test hypotheses on the routes of colonization of Southern Europe, we developed an approach for networkbased population analysis. In doing so, we essentially attempted to reconstruct the pathways of gene flow between Near East, Anatolia, Mediterranean populations, and Northern/Central European populations as captured by PCA or ADMIXTURE. The goal was the creation of networks connecting the populations under study. To form a network of related populations, we leveraged the fact that both PCA and ADMIXTURE essentially reduce the dimensionality of the original dataset by expressing each sample as either (i) a linear combination of the top few eigenvectors (in the case of PCA) or (ii) as percentages of ancestry from a small number of typically unknown ancestral populations (in the case of ADMIXTURE). To be more precise, in our study, each individual sample is originally described with respect to 75,194 SNPs; mathematically, this observation is equivalent to saying that the sample lies in a 75,194dimensional subspace. After applying PCA or ADMIXTURE to the dataset, all samples are described with respect to K coefficients. K ranges between one and eight in all our results. Thus, the output of PCA or ADMIXTURE lies in a Kdimensional subspace, with K << 75,194. In the case of PCA, these coefficients correspond to the projections of each sample in the top K principal components (SI Appendix, Fig. S6), whereas in the case of ADMIXTURE, the coefficients correspond to the percentages for ancestry of each sample with respect to the K ancestral, but unknown, populations. It is worth indicating that PCA and ADMIXTURE are very different statistical techniques: PCA assumes the existence of a small number of pairwise orthogonal components that explain the variance in the data, whereas ADMIXTURE is a modelbased ancestry inference technique. (See SI Appendix for more details and a discussion of appropriate measures of distance for the lowdimensional PCA and ADMIXTURE subspaces.) To form the networks, we first identified the top 10 nearest neighbors of each individual in the PCA or ADMIXTURE Kdimensional subspace, with the additional constraint that these nearest neighbors must not lie in the population of origin of the target individual. More specifically, we start by computing the l 2 (Euclidean) distance (in the case of PCA) or the l 1 (total variation) distance (in the case of ADMIXTURE) between the target individual and every other individual in our dataset. (See SI Appendix for a precise definition of the distance metric.) This procedure is repeated for all individuals in the dataset. Intuitively, our measure of distance dist(x,y) between population X and population Y is the number of nearest neighbors that individuals in population X have in population Y. (A minor fine tuning can be used to mitigate the effect of different population sizes in our sample; see SI Appendix for details). The network formation algorithm can be described as follows: For each pair of populations X and Y, we compute both distances, dist(x,y) and dist(y,x). We create an edge between X and Y (thus claiming that the two populations are neighbors of each other) if min {dist(x,y),dist(y,x)} > 0, and we assign as a weight of the respective edge the value min{dist(x,y),dist(y,x)}. It is worth noting that our choice is quite conservative, because we assume that populations X and Y are related if, and only if, both X and Y have nearest neighbors in each other. Population Network Analysis Supports a Maritime Path for the Colonization of Europe. Results of the network formation algorithm based on PCA are visualized with the Cytoscape software (Fig. 4A). In this figure, an edge between two populations shows that the two populations share genetically related individuals, with thicker edges indicating a larger number of genetically close individuals. The resulting networks (Fig. 4A; also see SI Appendix, Figs. S6 and S7) clearly indicate a path from the Near East populations (Palestinian, Druze) to Anatolia (Cappadocia), and from there to the islands of Dodecanese, and Crete. The connections between Crete and the rest of Greece (South East Laconia Peloponnese Macedonia) as well as the populations of Sicily and Italy are evident. Analyses were performed by using the top three to seven PCs (SI Appendix, Figs. S6 and S7) and results were robust regardless of the number of principal components used. The geographic proximity and partial overlap in the PCA of Crete and Sicily is also compatible with gene flow from Crete to Italy and to Southern Europe through population movements along the Southern Mediterranean coast. Results of our network analysis remain robust even when the independent methodology of ADMIXTURE is used to infer population distances. The resulting networks based on ADMIXTURE GENETICS Paschou et al. PNAS June 24, 2014 vol. 111 no
4 Centrality Statistics Support the Role of Islands in Connecting Anatolia to Europe. As part of our network analysis using Cytoscape, we also computed centrality statistics of the nodes in our network. The color of the network nodes in Fig. 4 denotes the socalled closeness centrality with warmer colors representing more important nodes. Crete and Dodecanese are among the most central nodes in the network. More specifically, the closeness centrality is a classical network metric indicating the total distance from a node in a network to all other nodes. It is often regarded as a measure of how long it will take to spread information (in this case, genetic material) to other nodes in the network in a sequential manner. Crete is always the highest or the second highest ranking node in all networks that we formed with respect to this statistic, and Cappadokia is always among the top five nodes. Similarly, if we consider the socalled betweenness centrality, which quantifies the number of times a node in the network acts as a bridge along the shortest path between two other nodes, Crete and Cappadocia share the number one and two spots in almost all networks that we formed. East Rumelia, the Peloponnese, and the Dodecanese also rank among the top 12 nodes in most of the networks that we formed, indicating the pivotal role of the populations that were collected and included in our analysis in the migration from Near East and Anatolia to Europe. Fig. 3. Population structure around the Mediterranean basin. A modelbased, unsupervised ancestry analysis approach (ADMIXTURE) was used to analyze populations on 72,951 (LDpruned) genomewide autosomal SNPs (K = 2 8). Two separate East to West clines are observed along the Northern African and Southern European Mediterranean coasts. outputs are shown in Fig. 4B (also see SI Appendix, Fig. S8). Both the PCA and the ADMIXTUREbased networks tell a consistent story and the pathway of gene flow from Anatolia to Southern Europe through the islands of Crete and Dodecanese is apparent. Results are robust, both with respect to the fact that two different approaches have been used (PCA and ADMIXTURE) and with respect to the dimensionality reduction parameter K, which varies between 3 and 8 for ADMIXTURE, and 3 and 7 for PCA. Network analysis using the Fst distance metric (SI Appendix,Fig.S9)does not provide very high resolution, but is similar in patterns to the networks obtained based on ADMIXTURE and PCA distances. Simulations of a stepping stone model of migrations around the Mediterranean using IBDSim (29) (SI Appendix, SI Methods and Results) and investigation of simulated genotypes through PCA and our population network analysis (SI Appendix, Figs. S10 and S11 and Table S4), provide additional support to our hypothesis and leads to patterns that are strikingly similar to the actual observed patterns and relationships among populations, with Crete acting as a hub that connects Anatolia to Southeastern Europe. Phylogenetic Analysis. We constructed a rooted neighborjoining tree for our sample of 32 populations from North Africa, the Near East, Anatolia, and Southern and Northern Europe. The phylogenetic tree (SI Appendix, Fig. S12) was calculated from a matrix of Fst distances among populations, using the algorithms implemented in PHYLIP and SmartPCA. Results are compatible with the clusters identified through PCA and ADMIXTURE analysis, and the identified lineages are largely concordant with the findings from our population network analysis. The populations from North Africa form a separate cluster branching out from SouthWest Asia. The closest European branches to the population of Cappadocia from Anatolia are those representing the islands of the Dodecanese and Crete. In turn, Crete connects to the most southern tip of mainland Greece (Southeast Laconia) as well as Sicily and the remaining populations from Northern and Central Europe that form a separate cluster. Thus, phylogenetic analysis also points to the central role of Crete and the Dodecanese in connecting Anatolia to Southern Europe. Similar results are obtained through analysis of our dataset with TreeMix (30) and NeighborNet (31). Both algorithms aim to construct a phylogenetic graph, improving the fit of a simple tree by allowing more than one path between populations. TreeMix and NeighborNet graphs underline gene flow from Anatolia to Southern Europe through the islands of the Dodecanese and Crete, without evidence for additional migrations from Anatolia through the Balkans (SI Appendix, Figs. S13 and S14 and Table S5). Discussion In historical times, there have been three major invasions of South Eastern Europe from the direction of the Near East but no evidence of major migratory events and gene flow. The Persians dominated South Western Asia in the fifth century BC: They established satrapies in Asia Minor and invaded Europe, but they were stopped by the Greeks (32). The Arabs attempted multiple invasions during the seventh and eighth centuries AD, but they were stopped by the Byzantines (33). An Arab tribe originating from Andalusia established in Crete a pirate state in the ninth century, but they were exterminated by the Byzantines 140 y later, and they left no traces of settlement in the island other than the name of their seat of power in the town of Chandax (33). The Turks invaded Asia Minor starting the 11th century and occupied the Balkans in the subsequent three centuries, but any Turks and converts to Islam left from Greek territories with the population exchanges that took place in the 20th century (34); the origin of the Turkish tribes was the central Asia. Seljuk Turks settled in Anatolia in the 12th century AD; Paschou et al.
5 A Mozabite North_Morocco Algeria Egypt South_Morocco Libya Sahara_OCC B Palestinian Druze Tunisia Mozabite N_Morocco Algeria Palestinian S_Morocco Libya Sahara_OCC Egypt Druze Italy Chuvash Dodecanese Sicily East Serbia Tuscany Rumelia Hungary Crete Russia Finland Cappadocia SE_Laconia Macedonia France Denmark Peloponnese Ireland Cappadocia Basque Sardinia Dodecanese Italy Russia Finland Sicily Tuscany Crete East Hungary Chuvash Rumelia SE_Laconia Serbia Denmark Peloponnese Macedonia France Ireland Basque Sardinia Fig. 4. A coastal route of colonization of Europe. (A) A network analysis and visualization of the connections among 30 populations as revealed by the top five principal components. The network was formed by identifying nearest neighbors of each individual outside its populations of origin. Thicker edges represent stronger genetic relationships between pairs of populations, whereas warmer colors indicate high centrality of the respective nodes. The route connecting North Africa, Middle East, and Anatolia via the islands of the Dodecanese, and Crete to the rest of Europe, is apparent. (B) A network analysis and visualization of connections among 30 populations as revealed by ADMIXTURE with K = 5. Results are very similar to those in Fig. 4A, despite the fact that Admixture is a very different technique to extract ancestry information. Our networks are robust to the use of additional principal components or larger values of the ADMIXTURE parameter K for their formation (SI Appendix, Figs.S7andS8). however, the Anatolian Cappadocians we included in this study belong to the population that have kept the religion and the language of the preseljuk Cappadocians and, therefore, most likely carry the genetic makeup of the ancient Anatolians. The only important gene flows from Near East to Europe must have occurred in prehistoric times and, as genetic evidence suggests, the most prominent migrations should have occurred during the Neolithic. The idea that the Neolithic was introduced to Europe through coastal routes of colonization has been proposed by several archaeologists (12, 16, 17, 19, 22, 35). The earliest Neolithic sites with developed agricultural economies in Europe dated BPE are found in Greece (19, 36, 37). The general features of material culture of the Greek Neolithic (14, 19, 36) and the genetic features of the preserved crops and associated weeds of the earliest Greek Neolithic sites point to Near Eastern origins (38). How these Near Eastern migrants reached Greece is a matter of speculation. One route of migration was by land from Central to Northeast Anatolia and from there to Southern Balkans through Bosporus, the Dardanelles, and Thrace (14, 15, 39). This migration route is less likely because archaeological evidence (19, 36, 40, 41) including 14 C dating (19, 40, 41) suggests that the Neolithic sites in Thrace and Macedonia are younger than those of mainland Greece, an unexpected finding if the Neolithic migrants who colonized Greece arrived there from the north. Other models suggest that waves of the NearEastern migrants reached Greece by sailing either from the Aegean Anatolian coast (12, 14, 16, 17, 22, 35) or from the Levantine coast (19, 36). Our data support the Anatolian rather than the Levantine route because they consistently show the Aegean islands to be connected to the Near East through Anatolia. Archaeological evidence from Greek and Near Eastern and Anatolian Neolithic sites suggests that multiple waves of Neolithic migrants reached Greece and Southern Europe. Most likely multiple routes were used in these migrations but, as our data show, the maritime route and island hopping was prominent. Our findings also suggest that to the west of Greece, the Neolithic reached Sicily and Italy by sea, as it has been suggested by archaeologists (12, 42). Studies of extant European and Near Eastern populations using multiple autosomal genetic polymorphisms have established the presence of clinal distributions of allelic frequencies (4 10, 43, 44). These clines in gene frequencies have been attributed to the geographically gradual merging of the gene pools of the Neolithic Near East migrants with the gene pools of the existing Paleolithic population of Europe. The correlation of clinal gene frequencies with the archaeological record of the spread of agriculture in Europe lead to the suggestion that it was the migration of Neolithic populations from the Near East that led to the spread of agriculture in Europe (7). The underlying hypothesis is that the development of agriculture triggered marked population growth and produced demographic pressures that resulted in dispersion of the Neolithic populations to new regions (7 9, 11). The rate of dispersion from the Near East to Western Europe has been estimated to approximately km/y (44). A faster rate of dispersion is expected if maritime routes were used for the colonization of Southern Europe. Indeed, archaeological evidence suggests that farming spread faster in Southern Europe (12, 42, 45) and radiocarbon measurements in Neolithic sites are compatible with very rapid colonization of the west Mediterranean by Neolithic migrants (46, 47). Although the Southeastern Mediterranean islands seem to have acted as a bridge from Anatolia to Southern Europe, the relatively small degree of gene flow between the African and the European coasts shows that the Mediterranean Sea also had a barrier function as also suggested with studies of mtdna polymorphisms (48). Thus, the Mediterranean seems to have facilitated the migrations of Neolithic farmers along its Southern European coast but it mostly acted as an isolating factor between its European and African coasts. Materials and Methods Samples. We collected a total of 202 samples from nine populations that were genotyped on two different platforms (SI Appendix, Table S1). In our sample collection process from the Greek subpopulations, we extracted DNA from blood samples of individuals that were at least 70 y old and selfreported that all four grandparents originated from the target population. We expect that because of our sample selection process, our data reflect the genetic structure of the Greek subpopulations four generations before present. We combined our data with four additional datasets to study population structure around the Mediterranean basin as well as Northern Europe. Thus, we produced a dataset of 964 samples from 32 populations, genotyped on 75,194 SNPs. More specifically, we used additional data from (i) the Human Genome Diversity Panel (49), (ii) the HapMap Phase III Project (50), (iii) publicly available data on Northern African populations that were first GENETICS Paschou et al. PNAS June 24, 2014 vol. 111 no
6 released by Henn and coworkers (51), and (iv) data from the Kidd Laboratory at Yale University (allele frequencies for these data are available via the ALFRED database) (SI Appendix, Table S2). PCA and ADMIXTURE. We used our own MatLab implementation of PCA (52, 53) (see SI Appendix for details). Before running ADMIXTURE, we pruned the SNPs to remove SNPs in high LD by using a windowed approach and a value of r 2 equal to 0.8. Correlation Between PCA and Geographic Coordinates. We estimated the correlation between geographic coordinates (SI Appendix, Table S3) and the top two eigenvectors emerging from PCA. For each population in our sample, we approximated its location of origin either using information provided to us by the individuals that collected the respective sample, or by using a capital city that is relatively close to the population under study. The correlation between geographic coordinates and the eigenvectors was computed by converting both the geographic coordinates vector and the eigenvectors to z scores, and then computing the Pearson correlation coefficient. A Mantel test was run to estimate statistical significance. Network Analysis. To better understand the connection between the populations included in our study, we performed a network analysis on the results of PCA and ADMIXTURE. To form the networks, we identified the top few nearest neighbors of each sample by representing each sample with respect to the top K coefficients returned by PCA or ADMIXTURE, and then computing the distance of each sample to all other samples, under the additional constraint that these neighbors should not belong to the same population of origin as the sample itself. Once a network whose nodes correspond to populations and whose edges correspond to connections between populations, as described above, is formed, we visualize it by using the Cytoscape software package (see SI Appendix for details). ACKNOWLEDGMENTS. We thank F. Sakellaridi, E. Papadaki, I.Adamopoulos, K. Farmaki, M. Tsironis, A. Mariolis, and P. Kaloyannidis for their assistance during the field study; A. Papadopoulou, N. Psatha, and N. Zogas for technical assistance; and N. Patterson and I. Lazaridis for helpful discussions. This work partially was supported by National Institutes of Health grants (to G.S. and K.K.) and National Science Foundation grants (to P.D.) and cofunded by the European Union (European Social Fund) and National Resources under the Operational Programme Education and Lifelong Learning Action GENOMAP.GR, ARISTEIA II Programme, NSRF (to P.P.). 1. Richards M, et al. (2000) Tracing European founder lineages in the Near Eastern mtdna pool. Am J Hum Genet 67(5): Semino O, et al. (2000) The genetic legacy of Paleolithic Homo sapiens sapiens in extant Europeans: A Y chromosome perspective. Science 290(5494): Barbujani G, Bertorelle G (2001) Genetics and the population history of Europe. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 98(1): CavalliSforza LL, Minch E (1997) Paleolithic and Neolithic lineages in the European mitochondrial gene pool. Am J Hum Genet 61(1): Chikhi L, Nichols RA, Barbujani G, Beaumont MA (2002) Y genetic data support the Neolithic demic diffusion model. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 99(17): Belle EMS, Landry PA, Barbujani G (2006) Origins and evolution of the Europeans genome: Evidence from multiple microsatellite loci. Proc Biol Sci 273(1594): Menozzi P, Piazza A, CavalliSforza L (1978) Synthetic maps of human gene frequencies in Europeans. Science 201(4358): Ammerman AJ, CavalliSforza LL (1984) The Neolithic Transition and the Genetics of Populations in Europe (Princeton Univ Press, Princeton, NJ), pp Sokal RR, Oden NL, Wilson C (1991) Genetic evidence for the spread of agriculture in Europe by demic diffusion. Nature 351(6322): Rosser ZH, et al. (2000) Ychromosomal diversity in Europe is clinal and influenced primarily by geography, rather than by language. Am J Hum Genet 67(6): Childe VG (1950) The Dawn of European Civilization (Routledge and Kegan Paul, London), pp Renfrew C (1987) Archaeology and Language (Jonathan Cape, London), pp Harris DR (1996) The Origins and Spread of Agriculture and Pastoralism in Eurasia (UCL Press, London), pp Hammond N (1976) Migrations and Invasions in Greece and Adjacent Areas (Noyes Press, Park Ridge, NJ), pp Özdogan M (2011) Archaeological evidence on the westward expansion of farming communities from eastern Anatolia to the Aegean and the Balkans. Curr Anthropol 52(S4):S415 S Broodbank C (2006) The origins and early development of Mediterranean maritime activity. J Mediterr Archaeol 19(2): Davison K, Dolukhanov P, Sarson GR, Shukurov A (2006) The role of waterways in the spread of the Neolithic. J Archaeol Sci 33(5): Cherry JF (1981) Pattern and process in the earliest colonization of the Mediterranean Islands. Proc Prehist Soc 47: Perlès C (2001) The Early Neolithic in Greece (Cambridge Univ Press, Cambridge, UK), pp Runnels CN (1995) Review of Aegean prehistory IV: The stone age of Greece from the Palaeolithic to the advent of the Neolithic. Am J Archaeol 99(4): Vigne JD, et al. (2012) First wave of cultivators spread to Cyprus at least 10,600 y ago. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 109(22): Cherry JF (1990) The first colonization of the Mediterranean islands: A review of recent research. J Mediterr Archaeol 3(2): Knapp AB (2013) The Archaeology of Cyprus (Cambridge World Archaeology, New York), pp Efstratiou N, Karestsou A, Banou ES, Margomenou D (2004) Knossos: Palace, City, State, eds Cadogan G, Hatzaki E, Vasilakis A (British School at Athens, London), pp Evans JD (1994) Knossos: Labyrinth of History, eds Evely D, HughesBrock H, Momigliano N (British School at Athens, London), pp Manni F, Guérard E, Heyer E (2004) Geographic patterns of (genetic, morphologic, linguistic) variation: How barriers can be detected by using Monmonier s algorithm. Hum Biol 76(2): Patterson N, et al. (2012) Ancient admixture in human history. Genetics 192(3): Novembre J, et al. (2008) Genes mirror geography within Europe. Nature 456(7218): Leblois R, Estoup A, Rousset F (2009) IBDSim: A computer program to simulate genotypic data under isolation by distance. Mol Ecol Resour 9(1): Pickrell JK, Pritchard JK (2012) Inference of population splits and mixtures from genomewide allele frequency data. PLoS Genet 8(11):e Bryant D, Moulton V (2004) Neighbornet: An agglomerative method for the construction of phylogenetic networks. Mol Biol Evol 21(2): Herodotus (1925) (Harvard Univ Press, Cambridge, MA). 33. Vasiliev AA (1952) History of the Byzantine Empire (Univ Wisconsin Press, Madison, Madison, WI), Vol 1, pp , (1925) Greece and Turkey  Convention concerning the exchange of Greek and Turkish populations and protocol. League of Nations Treaty Series 32: Broodbank C, Strasser TF (1991) Migrant farmers and the Neolithic colonization of Crete. Antiquity 65(247): Demoule JP, Perlès C (1993) The Greek Neolithic: A new review. J World Prehist 7(4): Van Andel TH, Runnels CN (1995) The earliest farmers in Europe. Antiquity 69(264): Colledge S, Conolly J, Shennan S (2004) Archaeobotanical evidence for the spread of farming in the eastern Mediterranean. Curr Anthropol 45(Supp):S35 S Özdogan M (1997) The beginning of Neolithic economies in southeastern Europe: An Anatolian perspective. J Eur Archaeol 5(2): Cauwe N, Dolukhanov P, Kozlowski J, Van Berg PL (2007) Le Néolithique en Europe (Armand Collin, Paris), pp Andreou S, Fotiadis M, Kotsakis K (1996) Review of Aegean Prehistory V: The Neolithic and Bronze Age of Northern Greece. Am J Archaeol 100(3): Phillips P (1975) Early Farmers of West Mediterranean Europe (Hutchinson Univ Library, London), pp Sokal R, Menozzi P (1982) Spatial autocorrelations of HLA frequencies in Europe support demic diffusion of early farmers. Am Nat 119(1): Pinhasi R, Fort J, Ammerman AJ (2005) Tracing the origin and spread of agriculture in Europe. PLoS Biol 3(12):e Whittle A (1994) The first farmers. The Oxford Illustrated Prehistory of Europe, ed Cunliffe B (Oxford Univ Press, Oxford), pp Zilhão J (2001) Radiocarbon evidence for maritime pioneer colonization at the origins of farming in west Mediterranean Europe. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 98(24): Zilhao Z (2000) From the Mesolithic to the Neolithic in the Iberian Peninsula. Europe s First Farmers, ed Price TD (Cambridge Univ Press, Cambridge, UK), pp Simoni L, Gueresi P, Pettener D, Barbujani G (1999) Patterns of gene flow inferred from genetic distances in the Mediterranean region. Hum Biol 71(3): Li JZ, et al. (2008) Worldwide human relationships inferred from genomewide patterns of variation. Science 319(5866): The International HapMap 3 Consortium (2010) Integrating common and rare genetic variation in diverse human populations. Nature 467(7311): Henn BM, et al. (2012) Genomic Ancestry of North Africans Supports BacktoAfrica Migrations. PLoS Genetics 8(1):e Paschou P, et al. (2007) PCAcorrelated SNPs for structure identification in worldwide human populations. PLoS Genet 3(9): Paschou P, et al. (2007) Intra and interpopulation genotype reconstruction from tagging SNPs. Genome Res 17(1): Paschou et al.
7 Supplementary Material: Data New samples: We collected a total of 202 samples from nine populations that were genotyped on two different platforms (see Supplementary Table 1 below for details). In our sample collection process, we extracted DNA from blood samples of individuals that were at least 70 years old and selfreported that all four grandparents originated from the target population. We also took care to avoid relatives in our sampling. We expect that due to our sample selection process our data reflect the genetic structure of the target populations four generations before present. Supplementary Table 1: New samples collected and genotyped in our work. Sample size indicates the number of individuals in our study. Population Region Sample Size (N) Genotyping Platform Cappadocia Anatolia 10 Illumina OMNI 2.5 (2,379,855 SNPs) Crete South Europe 90 Illumina OMNI1QUAD (1,134,514 SNPs) Dodecanese South Europe 10 Illumina OMNI 2.5 (2,379,855 SNPs) East Rumelia South Europe 12 Illumina OMNI 2.5 (2,379,855 SNPs) Macedonia South Europe 16 Illumina OMNI 2.5 (2,379,855 SNPs) Peloponnese South Europe 19 Illumina OMNI 2.5 (2,379,855 SNPs) Serbia South Europe 20 Illumina OMNI 2.5 (2,379,855 SNPs) Sicily South Europe 20 Illumina OMNI 2.5 (2,379,855 SNPs) South East Laconia South Europe 5 Illumina OMNI 2.5 (2,379,855 SNPs) 1
8 Additional Datasets: We combined our data with four additional datasets in order to study population structure around the Mediterranean basin as well as Northern Europe. More specifically, we used data from (i) the Human Genome Diversity Panel (HGDP) [45], (ii) the HapMap Phase III Project [46], (iii) publicly available data on Northern African populations that were first released by Henn et al [47], and (iv) data from the Kidd Lab at Yale University (allele frequencies for data from the Kidd Lab are available via the ALFRED database at Supplementary Table 2 presents a detailed list of the 762 additional samples from 23 populations that were used in our main analyses. Supplementary Table 2: An additional 762 samples from four other datasets were included in our main analyses. The genotyping platforms for each of the four additional datasets are described in the respective references. Sample size indicates the number of individuals in our study. Population Region Sample Size Reference (country of origin) (N) Algeria North Africa 19 Henn et al 2012 Egypt North Africa 19 Henn et al.2012 Libya North Africa 17 Henn et al.2012 North Morocco North Africa 18 Henn et al.2012 Sahara Occidental North Africa 18 Henn et al.2012 South Morocco North Africa 16 Henn et al.2012 Tunisia North Africa 18 Henn et al.2012 Bedouin South West Asia 47 HGDP Druze South West Asia 46 HGDP Mozabite South West Asia 28 HGDP Palestinian South West Asia 51 HGDP Yemen South West Asia 37 Kidd Lab Basque South Europe 44 Henn et al.2012, HGDP Italy South Europe 13 HGDP Sardinia South Europe 28 HGDP Tuscany South Europe 96 HAPMAP, HGDP Hungary Central Europe 41 Kidd Lab Chuvash East Europe 41 Kidd Lab Russia East Europe 46 HGDP, Kidd Lab France West Europe 29 HGDP Danes North Europe 43 Kidd Lab Finns North Europe 25 Kidd Lab Ireland North Europe 22 Kidd Lab 2
9 Supplementary Figure 1: Geographic map showing the locations of the populations in Supplementary Tables 1 and 2 (see also Figure 1A in the main text). 3
10 Combined Datasets: The main dataset that was used in all our analyses emerged after combining the populations in Supplementary Tables 1 and 2. After extracting common SNPs, merging and aligning genotypes, and applying basic quality control filters (see Supplementary Methods for details), this dataset consisted of 964 samples from 32 populations, genotyped on 75,194 SNPs. Supplementary Table 3: Approximate location of origin and geographic coordinates (longitude/latitude) for populations in our sample that surround the Mediterranean basin. Population Capital Latitude (NorthSouth) Longitude (EastWest) Sahara Occidental Laayoune South Morocco Agadir North Morocco Rabat Tunisia Tunis Mozabite Ghardaia Algeria Algiers Libya Benghazi Egypt Cairo Druze Damascus Palestine Gaza Cappadocia Kayseri East Rumelia Plovdiv Serbia Belgrade Macedonia Thessaloniki Peloponnese Tripoli SE Laconia Neapoli Laconias Dodecanese Rhodes Crete Heraclion Sicily Catania Italy Rome Tuscany Florence Sardinia Olbia Basque Bilbao
11 Supplementary Material: Methods and Results Merging genotypes from different sources: In order to merge datasets from the five different sources described in Supplementary Tables 1, 2, and 3, we had to pay particular attention to strand information and properly align common SNPs. Since such information was not always available, we chose to omit SNPs with reference alleles CG and AT in order to avoid ambiguity. Quality control: Despite the fact that the missing genotype rates in any of the five datasets that we analyzed in our work were quite low (invariably below 1%), we chose to perform an additional quality control check and remove any SNP that had a missing rate exceeding 20% in any of the populations under study. Our objective was to remove SNPs that might cause spurious artifacts in our analyses simply because they had many missing genotypes in one of the studied populations. Computing Fst: We computed Fst between all available populations using the SmartPCA tool from the Eigenstrat software package, as well as our own MatLab script that implements the Fst formula of the International HapMap Project. PCA: We used our own MatLab implementation of PCA, which meancenters the data while ignoring missing entries. We first transformed the genotypic data to numeric values, without any loss of information, in order to apply linear algebraic analyses. Consider a dataset for a group of populations consisting of m subjects and assume that for each subject n biallelic SNPs have been assayed. Thus, we are given a table T, consisting of m rows and n columns. Each entry in the table is a genotype (pair of bases), ordered alphabetically. We transform this initial data table to an integer matrix A, which consists of m rows (one for each subject) and n columns (one for each SNP). Each entry of A will be set to +1, 0, 1; an entry could be empty in the case of missing genotypes. Let B 1 and B 2 be the bases that appear in the jth SNP (in alphabetical order). If the genotypic information for the jth SNP of the ith individual is B 1 B 1 the (i,j)th entry of A is set to +1; else if it is B 1 B 2 the (i,j)th entry of A X is set to 0; else if it is B 2 B 2 the (i,j)th entry of A is set to 1; see Paschou et al. 2007a [48], Paschou et al. 2007b [49] for more details. After forming the matrix A, we transform it to a meancentered matrix M, by meancentering each column (SNP) of A. It is worth noting that we ignore missing entries when forming M. Finally, in order to compute the principal components, it suffices to compute the Singular Value Decomposition of the matrix product MM T, which is an mbym matrix. Supplementary Figure 2 (five panels) shows PCA plots (in two or three dimensions) for subsets of the populations of Supplementary Tables 1 and 2. Panels (a) and (B) are PCA plots of all populations in Supplementary Tables 1 and 2, projected on the top two and three principal components. Panel (c) is the threedimensional analog of main text Figure 1b. Panels (d) and (e) are PCA plots of populations around the Mediterranean basin, with Bedouin and Yemenites excluded. There is an obvious resemblance between the geography of the region and the twodimensional PCA plots. Different sample sizes and their effect on Principal Component Analysis: To test the effect of different sample sizes on PCA, we computed centroids of our input populations in Supplementary Tables 1 and 2 first using all available samples, then using only 20 samples per population (chosen uniformly at random), and finally using only 30 samples per population (chosen uniformly at random). We then correlated the centroids of the populations using all available samples with the centroids that were computed using 20 and 30 samples only. The 5
12 Pearson correlation coefficient for the first principal component between the centroids that were computed using all available samples and the centroids that were computed using 30 (respectively 20) samples per population exceeded (respectively 0.955) with a standard deviation (over 100 repetitions) of less than (resp ). The correlation for the second principal component was only slightly worse in the case of 20 samples per population: the Pearson correlation coefficient for the second principal component between the centroids that were computed using all available samples and the centroids that were computed using 30 (respectively 20) samples per population exceeded 0.93 (respectively 0.85) with a standard deviation (over 100 repetitions) of less than (respectively 0.02). Given these statistics, we opted to keep all available samples in our populations in order to capture as much of the population variance as possible. Correlation between PCA and geographic coordinates: In order to estimate the correlation between geographic coordinates and the top two eigenvectors emerging from PCA, we used the data in Supplementary Table 3. For each population in our sample, we approximated its location of origin either using information provided to us by the individuals that collected the respective sample, or by using a capital city that is relatively close to the population under study. The correlation between geographic coordinates and the eigenvectors was computed by converting both the geographic coordinate vector and the eigenvectors to zscores, and then computing the Pearson correlation coefficient. We also ran a Mantel test in order to estimate the statistical significance of the result by permuting the geographic distance matrix between all pairs of populations (we note that we used the Haversine formula to accurately compute distance between populations using longitude and latitude information). After 10,000 permutations we did not get a single permutation whose Pearson correlation coefficient exceeded the observed ones, thus concluding that our observation is significant with a pvalue at least Identification of genetic barriers: We used the BARRIER v2.2 software [26] to explore the genetic barriers in our dataset. BARRIER implements Monmonier s maximum difference algorithm in order to identify such barriers. First, using the geographic coordinates of the 23 populations surrounding the Mediterranean sea (see Supplementary Figure 2d for the PCA plot of these populations), we used BARRIER to plot the studied populations on the two dimensional plane (see Supplementary Figure 3a). Supplementary Figure 3a also shows the Delaunay triangulation and the Voronoi tessellation for the 23 populations. Recall that the Voronoi tessellation (blue lines) can be thought of as defining polygons that include all points on the plane that are closer to the centroid of the polygon under investigation than to the centroid of any other polygon. Since the centroids of the polygons in BARRIER correspond to the studied populations, we can consider the respective polygons as the areas in the plane that correspond to the respective population. If two polygons (and their respective populations) share an edge, then one might conclude that, based on the geographic distances, the respective populations are connected and thus some gene flow between the two populations could be expected. Indeed, the green edges in Supplementary Figure 3a (corresponding to the Delaunay triangulation) indicate connections between various pairs on populations based on geography; clearly, many connections exist that cross the Mediterranean sea: note that populations 1, 10, 12, 13, 14, 18, 22 all correspond to North African populations, yet, based solely on geography, they have multiple connections with South European populations. This picture changes drastically once genetic information from Principal Components Analysis is incorporated. In order to get statistical significance, we used a standard bootstrap procedure to 6
13 compute 100 distance matrices by resampling individuals from our populations. To be precise, we used a tenfold crossvalidation procedure in order to construct these 100 distance matrices, where each matrix contains all pairwise distances between the centroids of the 23 studied populations, as computed via Principal Components Analysis on the sampled individuals. The BARRIER software accepts the bootstrap distance matrices as input in order to run Monmonier s algorithm in order to compute genetic barriers between the studied populations. Supplementary Figure 3b clearly shows (observe the thick red lines) strong genetic barriers separating the North African populations from the South European populations, as expected by the presence of the Mediterranean sea. Estimating population admixture: We used the ADMIXTURE v1.22 software for all our admixture analyses. The parameter K (number of ancestral populations) ranged between two and eight in all our analyses. Prior to running ADMIXTURE, we pruned the SNPs in order to remove SNPs in high LD. Towards that end, we used the PLINK software and pruned SNPs using a windowed approach and a value of r 2 equal to 0.8. We used DISTRUCT v.1.1 and CLUMPP v to visualize the output of ADMIXTURE. Supplementary Figure 4 shows an ADMIXTURE plot of all populations in Supplementary Tables 1 and 2, for all values of K between two and eight. Supplementary Figure 5 shows an ADMIXTURE plot of all populations in Supplementary Tables 1 and 2, excluding the Bedouins and the Yemenites, for all values of K between two and eight. The data in Supplementary Figure 5, namely the percentages of origin of each individual with respect to the K (unknown) ancestral populations, were used in our ADMIXTURE based network formation algorithms (see Supplementary Figure 8). In order to account for potential variance in multiple runs of ADMIXTURE, we performed 20 runs of ADMIXTURE for each value of K between two and eight. We focus our discussion on the dataset used in main text Figure 3; the conclusions for the datasets used in Supplementary Figures 4 and 5 are identical. Each of the 20 runs (for a fixed value of K) was performed with a different random seed using the s time parameter of ADMIXTURE in order to initialize the random seed generator using the current time of the machine; this is often considered to be a good approximation to true randomness. We observed that for all values of K the results were very highly correlated. More specifically, recall that ADMIXTURE returns, for each sample in the dataset, K coefficients indicating percentage of ancestry in each of the K (assumed) ancestral populations. First of all, for a particular value of K, the average Pearson correlation coefficient among the reported ADMIXTURE coordinates and the coordinates returned in the 20 replicates ranged from 0.94 for K=2 to 0.86 for K=8. This already indicates that the correlation between the various replicates of ADMIXTURE is very high (a similar observation was made by [Henn et al. (2011) Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 108(13): ], who reported that multiple runs of ADMIXTURE only resulted in minor changes and simply chose to report one run; in a subsequent paper, [47] only performed a single run of ADMIXTURE). The situation is actually even more favorable, once we look closer at the data: more specifically, for each of the 20 runs (say run j, for some j between one and 20), we computed the Pearson correlation coefficient between the reported coefficients for each of the K ancestral populations (as shown in main text Figure 3) and their best fit in the jth run (we implemented a matching algorithm to perform the alignment between the K ancestral populations in the reported run and the jth replicate). We noticed that, for all values of K between two and six, over 70% of the replicates were essentially identical to the reported one (average Pearson correlation coefficient exceeded 0.98), while for K equal to seven or eight approximately 50% of the replicates were essentially identical to the reported one (average Pearson correlation coefficient approximately 0.95). Checking the 7
14 reported values of loglikelihood and delta (as reported by ADMIXTURE), we observed that for the cluster of identical repetitions convergence was better than for the other repetitions, thus indicating a better approximation to the true optimal value. Therefore, we chose to report one of the essentially identical runs. A similar analysis was performed in [Behar et al. (2010) Nature (8) 466 (7303):23842], who used a similar method to account for the slight variation in the ADMIXTURE output (and then chose to report one of the identical ADMIXTURE outputs). f3 statistics: In order to test for bidirectional admixture and population splits along the populations that stand at the gateway to Europe, we ran three population tests as described by Patterson et al [27] and implemented in TreeMix [30]. Seven populations bridging Anatolia to Southern Europe were included in the analysis (Cappadocia, Dodecanese, Crete, SE Laconia, Peloponnese, Macedonia, East Rumelia), and f3 statistics were calculated for all possible triplets of populations. After removal of SNPs in LD (at r 2 >0.5) from our initial dataset of over 650,000 SNPs, we were left with approximately 278,000 SNPs. When studying a triplet of populations (e.g., C; A,B) f3 statistics and the corresponding Zscore of significance can only be negative if population C has ancestry from populations related to both A and B. It is only in this case that paths exist between C and A as well as C and B that also take opposite drift directions. The observation of a significantly negative value of f3(c; A, B) is thus evidence of complex phylogeny in C. All triplets of populations are shown in our online supplementary material (http://www.cs.rpi.edu//~drinep/maritime_route/f3.xls). We only get marginally negative results for the Peloponnese population in Greece, indicating that this population might have resulted from some admixture from both North and South. All other tested triplets tested positive, indicating that there are simple paths connecting populations to each other along the course of migration from Anatolia into Europe. This is in concordance with our network analysis. Network analysis: To better understand the connection between the populations included in our study we performed a network analysis on the results of PCA and ADMIXTURE. We start by noting that both PCA and ADMIXTURE are essentially reducing the dimensionality of the original dataset by expressing each sample as either (a) a linear combination of the top few eigenvectors (in the case of PCA) or (b) as percentages of ancestry from a small number of typically unknown ancestral populations (in the case of ADMIXTURE). To be more precise, each individual sample is originally described with respect to 75,194 SNPs; mathematically, this is equivalent to saying that the sample lies in a 75,194dimensional subspace. After applying PCA or ADMIXTURE to the dataset, all samples are described with respect to K coefficients; K ranges between one and eight in all our analyses. Mathematically, this is equivalent to saying that the output of PCA or ADMIXTURE lies in a Kdimensional subspace, with K <<< 75,194. It is worth highlighting that PCA and ADMIXTURE are unrelated dimensionality reduction techniques that make different assumptions regarding the underlying structure of the dataset. PCA is a very general algorithmic technique that recovers the latent structure of highdimensional data that lie in an approximately linear manifold, by leveraging the existence of a small number of pairwise orthogonal principal components that capture the linear structure of the dataset. ADMIXTURE, on the other hand, is a much more specialized modelbased statistical analysis technique whose underlying model, to the best of our understanding, is only applicable to population genetics datasets. Its end goal is a (maximum likelihood based) estimation of individual ancestries from largescale SNP datasets. An important difference regarding the output of the two techniques is that the output of PCA lies in a lowdimensional normed subspace as described above, where the metric of distance between two samples is the Euclidean distance, since PCA minimizes an objective function that is based on the Euclidean or l 2 norm. (Recall that the Euclidean or l 2 distance between a pair of points in a Kdimensional space is the square root of the sum of the squares of the coordinatewise distances between the 8
15 two points.) However, while the output of ADMIXTURE also lies in a lowdimensional subspace, the relevant norm is not necessarily the Euclidean norm. As a matter of fact, the output of ADMIXTURE is essentially a probability distribution for each sample, indicating the percentage of origin of the sample with respect to the ancestral populations. Indeed, the coefficients returned by ADMIXTURE for each sample are positive and sum up to one, a fact that does not hold for PCA. Thus, a more appropriate choice of norm for ADMIXTURE s output is the l 1 norm, which better captures the distance between two probability distributions. (Recall that the l 1 distance between a pair of points in a Kdimensional space is sum of the absolute values of the coordinatewise distances between the two points.) In order to form a network of related populations using the output of PCA or ADMIXTURE, we first identify the top ten nearest neighbors of each individual in the PCA or ADMIXTURE dimensionally reduced subspace, with the additional constraint that these nearest neighbors must not lie in the population of origin of the target individual. To be more precise, consider an individual in population X; this individual is represented with respect to K coefficients, which are the output of PCA or ADMIXTURE. We start by computing the l 2 (Euclidean) distance in the case of PCA (or l 1 distance in the case of ADMIXTURE) between the target individual and every other individual in our dataset. Then, we identify the top ten nearest neighbors to the individual under study, with the constraint that these nearest neighbors do not belong to population X. (We note that the distances are only used in order to select the top ten nearest neighbors from the target individual; the numeric values of the distances of those neighbors and the target individual are ignored in the remainder of our network analysis.) This procedure is repeated for all individuals in the dataset. Assuming that we have n samples from p populations in our dataset, this procedure eventually returns an nbyp table with rows corresponding to samples and columns corresponding to the populations under study. The (i,j)th entry in the table denotes how many neighbors individual i has in population j. Clearly, by the construction of our nearestneighbor identification algorithm, the (i,j)th entry of the matrix is equal to zero if the jth column of the table corresponds to the population of origin of the ith sample. Given the above nbyp table A, we are now ready to create a network of populations with edges connecting related populations. In order to describe our procedure to infer whether populations X and Y are connected, as well as the weight of the respective connection, we first need to introduce some notation. Let t be the cardinality of population X and let s be the cardinality of population Y. Let i 1,i 2,,i t be the row indices corresponding to samples in X. Let j Y be the column of A that corresponds to population Y and compute t 1 dist( Y, X ) Ai a jy s Similarly, if we use i 1,i 2,,i s to denote the row indices of the table A that correspond to samples in Y (recall that the cardinality of Y is s) and j X to denote the column of A that corresponds to population X, we can compute s 1 dist( Y, X ) Ai a jx t It should be obvious that, up to scaling, our distance metric simply counts the number of nearest neighbors that individuals of population X have in population Y. This is a simple and intuitive a 1 a 1 9
16 idea; a minor fine tuning is necessary in order to mitigate the effect of different population sizes in our sample. A number of comments will help the reader to better understand the above two metrics of distance between populations X and Y. First of all, our distance metric is not symmetric: mathematically, dist(x,y) is not necessarily equal to dist(y,x). Second, in order to mitigate the effect of different population sizes, we normalize the aforementioned count by dividing it by the square root of the population size. The goal of this normalization is to assign larger weights when nearest neighbors in smaller populations are identified. For example, identifying a nearest neighbor in a population Y that has only 10 samples should be weighted more than identifying a nearest neighbor in a population Y that has 100 samples. The choice of normalizing by the square root (more generally, a power less than one) of the sample size is a common tradeoff in order to mitigate the effects of different population sizes, while not overcompensating for such effects. Third, using the dimensionally reduced space (for various values of K) derived by PCA or ADMIXTURE in order to compute the nearest neighbors of each individual (instead of using all available genotypes and the allelic distance) has two advantages: first and foremost, it denoises the data by keeping only the most prominent and meaningful axes of variance and thus avoiding the statistical artifacts of the curseofdimensionality; second, it speeds up computations since the data now lie in a lowdimensional space. We are now ready to describe our network formation algorithm. For each pair of populations X and Y, we compute both distances: dist(x,y) and dist(y,x). We create an edge between X and Y (thus claiming that the two populations are neighbors of each other) if min{dist(x,y),dist(y,x)} > 0, and we assign as a weight of the respective edge the value min{dist(x,y),dist(y,x)}. It is worth noting that our choice is quite conservative, since we will assume that populations X and Y are related if and only if both X and Y have nearest neighbors in each other. This notion of edge weights handles situations where a population Y is far away from all other populations and thus dist(x,y)=0 for all populations X, but, by construction, there will exist some populations X so that dist(y,x)>0 (since each sample in Y will have some nearest neighbors in populations outside Y, even if Y is isolated). Finally, once a network whose nodes correspond to populations and whose edges correspond to connections between populations, as described above, is formed, we visualize it using the Cytoscape software package. We briefly discuss the number of nearest neighbors to be retained using our approach. It should be clear that our network formation algorithm has one free parameter, namely the number of nearest neighbors to retain in the first step of the process. We chose to set that value to ten, which is equal to 1/3 of the average number of samples per population in our dataset. (Supplementary Tables 1 and 2 show the number of samples per population; the average number of samples/population is equal to 30.1) We also experimented with the number of nearest neighbors set to eight, nine, eleven, and twelve, without observing noticeable differences in the resulting networks. Our network analysis using PCA is based on Supplementary Figures 2d and 2e, as well as their higher dimensional analogs, which of course cannot be plotted. Note that we included all 10
17 populations in Supplementary Tables 1 and 2, except for the Bedouins and the Yemenites, which form a separate cline towards CentralSouth Asia. Similarly, our network analyses using ADMIXTURE were based on Supplementary Figure 5, which again excludes the Bedouins and the Yemenites. First, in the case of PCA, we had to determine how many principal components are significant. Towards that end, we examined the distribution of singular values in Supplementary Figure 6 (both panels). Panel (a), which corresponds to the plots in Supplementary Figures 2d and 2e, shows that the singular values drop fast: the top three are clearly significant; then the fourth and the fifth one, as well as the sixth and the seventh one, form small clusters. A simple metric of significance (see the legend of Supplementary Figure 6) indicates that the top seven singular values are indeed significant. Adding the Bedouins and the Yemenites to our dataset results in a slight increase in the number of significant singular values, which is now equal to ten. Supplementary Figures 7 and 8 show the various networks that were formed using all values of K and either PCA or ADMIXTURE as the basis for computing nearest neighbors. In the case of PCA, we examined values between three and seven (the number of significant principal components). In the case of ADMIXTURE, we examined values of K between three and eight. Interestingly, all networks are highly similar, showing a distinct path from North Africa to Near East and Southern Europe via Cappadocia, Dodecanese, and Crete. The resulting networks, as visualized by Cytoscape, are also available online as.cys files and include numerous network statistics, as computed by Cytoscape (see Supplementary Online Material). Network analysis via Fst: We also performed a network analysis using the Fst metric as follows: we formed an edge between two populations if the respective Fst was below 0.08 (we chose this threshold value since it resulted in keeping the top 25% most significant Fst pairs while maintaining a connected network larger threshold values resulted in similar yet denser networks, while smaller values disconnected the network). The resulting network is shown in Supplementary Figure 9 and is similar in spirit to the networks formed via our metric that is based on PCA and ADMIXTURE. We believe that PCA and ADMIXTURE based networks capture in a much finer sense the connections between the analyzed populations; Fst is a much coarser statistic. Simulating a steppingstone model: To further test the steppingstone hypothesis regarding the migration of populations around the Mediterranean basin, we used IBDSim to generate simulated data. IBDSim [29] is a package for the simulation of genotypic data under isolation by distance. It is based on a backward generation by generation coalescent algorithm allowing the consideration of various isolationbydistance models. We used IBDSim in order to generate 10,000 independent SNPs for ten populations that were placed on a onedimensional lattice on coordinates that are representations of a subset of ten populations from our data. We set the effective population size to 30, the mutation rate to 0.5e6, and the migration rate to 0.5. (See Supplementary Table 4, where ten consecutive  from a geographic perspective  populations around the Mediterranean basin were chosen; the table also indicates their geographic coordinates, the distance from one population to the next one, the normalized distance from one population to the next one, and the respective lattice points where the populations were placed. 11
18 More specifically, we treated the minimum distance between any two consecutive populations in our list as a single unit; this was the distance between Crete and the Dodecanese. Then, we divided each distance by the minimum distance, thus getting the sixth column of the table. Finally, we placed populations in the xaxis of a onedimensional lattice by rounding the distances in the sixth column to the nearest integer in order to approximately respect the distances between two consecutive populations.) We used default values for the migration rate and the mutation rate and generated data using the stepping stone model, as implemented by IBDSim. Recall that in the stepping stone model, an individual can only move to an adjacent population. The resulting PCA plots and the corresponding network are shown in Supplementary Figures 10 and 11 and they are clearly reminiscent of patterns presented in Supplementary Figures 2 and 7 (PCA and network analysis of real data). Thus our simulations provide further support for our conclusions regarding the stepping stone hypothesis of population migrations around the Mediterranean with Crete acting as a hub that connects Anatolia to Southeastern Europe. Inferring phylogenetic trees: We used PHYLIP to infer phylogenetic trees using the output of SmartPCA (Fst distances between all pairs of available populations). Phylogenetic trees were constructed using the neighborjoining method (NEIGHBOR tool in PHYLIP). DRAWGRAM and DRAWTREE were used in order to plot the resulting phylogenetic trees. In order to further verify our findings, we constructed a phylogenetic tree based on the Fst distance matrix. The resulting tree (see Supplementary Figure 12 that includes the SubSaharan African San population as an outgroup this is a South African population that has been made available by the HGDP consortium) clearly support the findings of PCA, ADMIXTURE, as well as our network analyses. TreeMix: To further verify the migration pathways and signals of admixture among the studied populations from Northern Africa, Middle East, Anatolia, and Europe, we additionally used TreeMix [30] to find a population graph that best describes the relationship between populations in the dataset by testing for gene flow between them. Genomewide allele frequency data is used to first find the maximumlikelihood tree of populations and then infer possible additional migration events by identifying populations that poorly fit this tree. The maximum likelihood tree of all populations included in this analysis is shown in Supplementary Figure 13a, with the respective residuals shown in Supplementary Figure 13b. (It is worth noting that this tree explains 96.3% of the variation of the data, as computed by TreeMix.) In concordance with all other analysis that we present, gene flow from Anatolia to Southern Europe appears to have occurred through the islands of the Dodecanese and Crete. Residuals were subsequently analyzed in order to identify pairs of populations that are more related to each other than is captured by this graph and corresponding migration events were inferred. We then sequentially added 10 migration events to reach a tree that captures approximately 98.5% of the data. Migration events are shown in Supplementary Table 5. TreeMix analysis supports some additional gene flow among populations from Northern Africa (e.g., from South Morocco to Egypt and Algeria), as well as a connection between South Morocco and Middle East. Furthermore, an indication of the complex genetic history of Sardinia is uncovered with connections to Northern Africa, Italy, and the Basques. 12
19 NeighborNet analysis: As a final verification of the migration pathways and signals of admixture among the studied populations, we performed a phylogenetic network analysis using the NeighborNet method [31] implemented in SplitsTree v4.13. NeighborNet is a distance based method for the construction of phylogenetic networks that is based on the neighborjoining algorithm. Recall that a fundamental property of a tree is that between every pair of populations there is a unique path connecting them, while a network or graph allows for multiple paths. The NeighborNet algorithm relaxes the neighborjoining algorithm to construct a phylogenetic graph that aims to improve the fit to the data by allowing (if necessary) additional paths between pairs of populations. Comparing to our own network formation algorithms, it is worth noting that our approach is not based on neighborjoining and does not attempt to fit any particular structure to the data. It simply picks the most informative connections in order to produce a graph of gene flow among populations. In order to run NeighborNet, we first computed the Fst matrix between all populations using EIGENSOFT on our dataset and used this matrix as the input for the NeighborNet algorithm. The NeighborNet method was used to produce an unrooted network, which was subsequently visualized using the EqualAngle method (Supplementary Figure 14). In concordance with all of our previous analysis, it is again clear that the Dodecanese and Crete play a pivotal role as a hub in gene flow connecting Anatolia to Southern Europe, and the rest of Europe. 13
20 Supplementary Material: Figures Supplementary Figure 2: PCA plots of (subsets of) the populations in Supplementary Tables 1 and 2. (a) PCA plot of all populations in Supplementary Tables 1 and 2; projection on top two Principal Components. The cline from Northern Africa to Northern Europe via Near East, Cappadocia, Dodecanese, and Crete is apparent. (b) PCA plot of all populations in Supplementary Tables 1 and 2; projection on top three Principal Components. (c) PCA plot of populations around the Mediterranean basin; projection on top three principal components. This plot is the threedimensional version of main text Figure 1b. Bedouins and Yemenites are separated from the Mediterranean basin populations. (d) PCA plot of populations around the Mediterranean basin; projection on top two principal components. (Bedouin and Yemenites haven been excluded from this plot.) (e) PCA plot of populations around the Mediterranean basin; projection on top three principal components. (Bedouin and Yemenites have been excluded from this plot.) The Tunisian population is separated from the other populations in the third principal component. 14
21 Figure S2a 15
22 Figure S2b 16
23 Figure S2c 17
24 Figure S2d 18
25 Figure S2e 19
26 Supplementary Figure 3: Results from running the BARRIER v2.2 software. (a) Delaunay triangulation (green lines) and Voronoi tessellation (blue lines) of populations around the Mediterranean basin. (b) Genetic barriers were computed using 100 bootstrap distance matrices (computed via Principal Components Analysis and tenfold crossvalidation) and are indicated by red lines; thickness of the lines increases with the statistical significance of the respective barriers. Notice that strong genetic barriers separate the North African populations from the South European populations, as expected by the presence of the Mediterranean. Figure S3a Palestine Egypt Druze Figure S3b Cappadocia Libya Dodecanese Crete SE Laconia Peloponnese Tunisia Algeria Sicily Italy Sardinia North Morocco South Morocco Sahara OCC Basque 20
27 Supplementary Figure 4: ADMIXTURE plot of all populations in Supplementary Tables 1 and 2, for all values of K between two and eight. A clear gradient can be observed, from North Africa to Near East, South Europe (with a subgradient forming from Cappadocia, Dodecanese, Crete, and Peloponnesos), and, eventually, North Europe. K=2 K=3 K=4 21
28 K=5 K=6 K=7 K=8 22
29 Supplementary Figure 5: ADMIXTURE plot of all populations in Supplementary Tables 1 and 2, excluding the Bedouins and the Yemenites, for all values of K between two and eight. We again observe a clear gradient from North Africa to Near East, South Europe (with a subgradient forming from Cappadocia, Dodecanese, Crete, and Peloponnesos), and, eventually, North Europe. The percentages of origin of each individual with respect to the K (unknown) ancestral populations were used in our network formation algorithms (see Supplementary Figure 8). K=2 K=3 K=4 23
30 K=5 K=6 K=7 K=8 24
31 Supplementary Figure 6: (a) Plot of top 50 singular values of the covariance matrix formed using all samples, excluding the Bedouins and the Yemenites, in Supplementary Tables 1 and 2. The top principal components of this covariance matrix will be used in our PCAbased network formation algorithms (Supplementary Figure 7). Applying a simple metric of singular value significance (i.e., extracting principal components corresponding to singular values that exceed the average singular value by at least three standard deviations) identifies the top seven singular values as significant. (b) Plot of top 50 singular values of the covariance matrix formed using all samples, including the Bedouins and the Yemenites, in Supplementary Tables 1 and 2. Applying a simple metric of singular value significance (i.e., extracting principal components corresponding to singular values that exceed the average singular value by at least three standard deviations) identifies the top ten singular values as significant. Figure S6a 25
32 Figure S6b 26
33 Supplementary Figure 7: Networks formed using PCA and the top K (for all values of K between three and seven) principal components in order to identify nearest neighbors for each individual (see Supplementary Methods for details and Supplementary Figure 6a for the number of significant Principal Components). Warmer colors indicate nodes of high centrality for the whole network (as computed by Cytoscape), while thicker edges indicate strong connections (high genetic similarity between the respective populations). Different values of K result in highly similar networks, highlighting the robustness of our results. The path from Northern Africa to Southern Europe via Near East, Cappadocia, the Dodecanese, and, of course, Crete is obvious. Note that the panel corresponding to K=5 is identical to Figure 4a in the main text; we include it here as well to facilitate comparisons. PCAbased network, K=3 27
34 PCAbased network, K=4 PCAbased network, K=5 28
35 PCAbased network, K=6 PCAbased network, K=7 29
36 Supplementary Figure 8: Networks formed using ADMIXTURE with the parameter K (the number of ancestral populations) set between four and eight in order to identify nearest neighbors for each individual (see Supplementary Methods for details). Warmer colors indicate nodes of high centrality for the whole network (as computed and visualized by Cytoscape), while thicker edges indicate strong connections (high genetic similarity between the respective populations). Different values of K result in highly similar networks, highlighting the robustness of our results. Even more interestingly, the networks of Supplementary Figures 7 and 8 are again very similar, even though PCA is a modelfree dimensionality reduction technique, while ADXMIXTURE is a modelbased approach (see Supplementary Methods for a more detailed discussion of the two approaches). Once more, the path from Northern Africa to Southern Europe via Near East, Cappadocia, the Dodecanese, and, of course, Crete is obvious. Note that the panel corresponding to K=5 is identical to Figure 4b in the main text; we include it here as well to facilitate comparisons. ADMIXTUREbased network, K=4 30
37 ADMIXTUREbased network, K=5 ADMIXTUREbased network, K=6 31
38 ADMIXTUREbased network, K=7 ADMIXTUREbased network, K=8 32
39 Supplementary Figure 9: Network formed using Fst values between pairs of populations (see Supplementary Methods for details). Warmer colors indicate nodes of high centrality for the whole network (as computed by Cytoscape), while thicker edges indicate strong connections (high genetic similarity between the respective populations). 33
40 Supplementary Table 4: Geographic coordinates of the ten populations around the Mediterranean basin that were used as a basis for our simulations in Supplementary Figures 10 and 11. The table also indicates the distance from one population to the next one, the normalized distance from one population to the next one, and the respective lattice points where the populations were placed. We denoted the ten populations as pop1 through pop10 in Supplementary Figures 10 and 11. Population Latitude Longitude Distance (in kms) from previous population Normalized distance (divided by minimum distance) Coordinates in xaxis (rounded) Algeria (pop1) Tunisia (pop2) Libya (pop3) Egypt (pop4) Druze (pop5) Palestine (pop6) Cappadocia (pop7) Dodecanese (pop8) Crete (pop9) Peloponnese (pop10) 34
41 Supplementary Figure 10. PCA plot of ten simulated populations; see Supplementary Table 4 for a list of the corresponding populations around the Mediterannean basin that were used as a basis for our simulation. Note that the figure is reminiscent of our PCA plots of populations around the Mediterranean basin. 35
42 Supplementary Figure 11. Network formed by our algorithm using the PCA plot of data simulated under a stepping stone model (Supplementary Figure S10). In order to simulate the stepping stone model of migrations, distances between real populations around the Mediterranean were used (see Supplementary Table 4). Note that the network of the simulated data is in complete concordance with the network formed using real data for the respective populations. 36
43 Supplementary Figure 12. Phylogenetic tree formed using Fst distances between all populations studied. The results are concordant with a closer genetic relationship of Anatolia to the islands of Crete and the Dodecanese rather than to the Balkans. 37
44 Supplementary Figure 13a. The maximumlikelihood tree generated by TreeMix, capturing 96.27% of the data. In concordance with all other analysis that we present, gene flow from Anatolia to Southern Europe appears to have occurred through the islands of the Dodecanese and Crete. Drift parameter 38
45 Supplementary Figure 13b. Residuals of the maximumlikelihood phylogenetic tree generated by TreeMix and shown in Supplementary Figure 13a. Population pairs that show high residuals (i.e., are not perfectly captured by the graph in Supplementary Figure S13a), were subsequently analyzed in order to identify pairs of populations that are more related to each other and corresponding migration events were inferred. Supplementary Table 5 shows the top ten inferred migration events based on this residual plot. As implemented in TreeMix, the residual covariance between each pair of populations i and j is divided by the average standard error across all pairs. This scaled residual in then plotted in each cell (i,j). Colors are described in the palette on the right. Residuals above zero represent populations that are more closely related to each other in the data than in the bestfit tree and thus are candidates for admixture events. 39
Mediterranean Europe
Chapter 17, Section World Geography Chapter 17 Mediterranean Europe Copyright 2003 by Pearson Education, Inc., publishing as Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River, NJ. All rights reserved. Chapter 17, Section
More informationDr. Dimitris P. Drakoulis THE REGIONAL ORGANIZATION OF THE EASTERN ROMAN EMPIRE IN THE EARLY BYZANTINE PERIOD (4TH6TH CENTURY A.D.
Dr. Dimitris P. Drakoulis THE REGIONAL ORGANIZATION OF THE EASTERN ROMAN EMPIRE IN THE EARLY BYZANTINE PERIOD (4TH6TH CENTURY A.D.) ENGLISH SUMMARY The purpose of this doctoral dissertation is to contribute
More informationKernel Principal Component Analysis and its Applications in Face Recognition and Active Shape Models
Kernel Principal Component Analysis and its Applications in Face Recognition and Active Shape Models Quan Wang ECSE, Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute May 13, 2011 Main Work Studied the theories of kernel
More informationAncient Greece GREECE UNIT 5 GEOGRAPHY CHALLENGE. 1 Unit 5 Geography Challenge miles. Lambert Azimuthal EqualArea Projection
W N S E UNIT 5 GEOGRAPHY CHALLENGE Ancient Greece 0 250 500 miles 0 250 500 kilometers Lambert Azimuthal EqualArea Projection GREECE 1 Unit 5 Geography Challenge UNIT 5 GEOGRAPHY CHALLENGE Geography Skills
More informationPredicting Flight Delays Using Data Mining Techniques
Todd Keech CSC 600 Project Report Background Predicting Flight Delays Using Data Mining Techniques According to the FAA, air carriers operating in the US in 2012 carried 837.2 million passengers and the
More informationLesson 1
Lesson 1 Objectives Evaluate how geography affected people of the Aegean Cultures. Study the effects of trade on he growth of the Minoan customs and ideas to their way of life. Observe how the Mycenaeans
More informationThe Minoans, DNA and all.
Mathilda s Anthropology Blog. Just another WordPress.com weblog The Minoans, DNA and all. Posted on April 14, 2008 26 Comments Starting with the breaking DNA news, and this rather sinks the Black Athena
More informationMinoan Greeks Mycenaean Hellenic Hellenistic King Minos Thalossocracy
20/04/2015 3:22 PM The Greeks were the second Mediterranean society to undertake widespread colonization, after the Phoenicians. Relative latecomers to the Aegean World; a high culture existed in the
More informationAncient Greece. Teachers Curriculum Institute Geography and the Settlement of Greece 1
G e o g r a p h y C h a l l e n g e Ancient Greece G R E E C E N W E S 0 250 500 miles 0 250 500 kilometers Lambert Azimuthal EqualArea Projection Teachers Curriculum Institute Geography and the Settlement
More informationA response to Ilse Schoep: some critical notes on interpreting the palace of Knossos as a temple
41 Abstract A response to Ilse Schoep: some critical notes on interpreting the palace of Knossos as a temple Alexander Akulov independent scholar; St.Petersburg, Russia; email: aynu@inbox.ru Schoep supposes
More informationNorth Africa. Chapter 25. Chapter 25, Section
Chapter 25, Section World Geography Chapter 25 North Africa Copyright 2003 by Pearson Education, Inc., publishing as Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River, NJ. All rights reserved. Chapter 25, Section World
More informationTHE PREHISTORIC AEGEAN AP ART HISTORY CHAPTER 4
THE PREHISTORIC AEGEAN AP ART HISTORY CHAPTER 4 INSTRUCTIONAL OBJECTIVES: Students will be able to understand the environmental, technological, political, and cultural factors that led societies in the
More informationαρχαία Ελλάδα (Ancient Greece)
αρχαία Ελλάδα (Ancient Greece) The Birthplace of Western Civilization Marshall High School Mr. Cline Western Civilization I: Ancient Foundations Unit Three AA Neolithic Europe Europe s earliest farming
More informationWho goes where? How long do they stay? How much do they spend?
Who goes where? How long do they stay? How much do they spend? Analysis of inbound tourism by Region and Market Summary Evangelia Lamprou Researcher  Statistician Dr. Aris Ikkos, ISHC Research Director
More informationProject Concept Note
NorthEast Asian Subregional Programme for Environmental Cooperation (NEASPEC) 1. Overview 1. Project Title 2. Goals Project Concept Note Study on Transborder Movement of Amur Tigers and Leopards using
More informationBrown bear (Ursus arctos) fact sheet
Brown bear (Ursus arctos) fact sheet Biology Status Distribution Management Conservation Biology Size: Reproduction: Diet: Social organisation: Home ranges: Males 140 320 kg/females 100 200 kg Mating:
More informationTarget. List and describe the government, religion, economy, and contributions of the Minoan civilization
The Minoans Target List and describe the government, religion, economy, and contributions of the Minoan civilization The Aegean Civilization Illiad and the Odyssey Homer Did the people and places really
More information= Coordination with Direct Communication
Particle Swarm Optimization Mohamed A. ElSharkawi Computational Intelligence Applications (CIA) Lab. Department of EE, Box 352500 University of Washington Seattle, WA 981952500 elsharkawi@ee.washington.edu
More informationHEATHROW COMMUNITY NOISE FORUM
HEATHROW COMMUNITY NOISE FORUM 3Villages flight path analysis report January 216 1 Contents 1. Executive summary 2. Introduction 3. Evolution of traffic from 25 to 215 4. Easterly departures 5. Westerly
More informationWHI SOL 5. Ancient Greeks
WHI SOL 5 Ancient Greeks The physical geography of the Aegean Basin shaped the economic, social, and political development of Greek civilization. The expansion of Greek civilization through trade and colonization
More informationTOEFL ibt Quick Prep. Volume 1. Go anywhere from here.
TOEFL ibt Quick Prep Volume 1 Go anywhere from here. INTRODUCTION Introduction ABOUT THE TOEFL ibt TEST The TOEFL ibt test measures your ability to use and understand the English language as it is read,
More informationAirspace Complexity Measurement: An Air Traffic Control Simulation Analysis
Airspace Complexity Measurement: An Air Traffic Control Simulation Analysis Parimal Kopardekar NASA Ames Research Center Albert Schwartz, Sherri Magyarits, and Jessica Rhodes FAA William J. Hughes Technical
More informationAncient Greece: The Greek Mainland and Greek Colonies
Name: Ancient Greece: The Greek Mainland and Greek Colonies Directions 1. Using page 117 in your textbook, complete the following task: Cities Continents, Islands, Regions Bodies of Water Carthage Athens
More informationSettlement Patterns West of Ma ax Na, Belize
SETTLEMENT PATTERNS WEST OF MA AX NA, BELIZE 1 Settlement Patterns West of Ma ax Na, Belize Minda J. Hernke Faculty Sponsor: Kathryn ReeseTaylor, Department of Sociology/Archaeology ABSTRACT The focus
More informationToday you need: Pencil If you have your notebookput it in bin. Thank you
SS Terrific Tuesday 1/23/18 Today you need: Pencil If you have your notebookput it in bin. Thank you Bell work: Put your name on your paper!!!! Look at the map of Ancient Greece. 1. State twothree observations
More informationPaper presented to the 40 th European Congress of the Regional Science Association International, Barcelona, Spain, 30 August 2 September, 2000.
Airline Strategies for Aircraft Size and Airline Frequency with changing Demand and Competition: A TwoStage Least Squares Analysis for long haul traffic on the North Atlantic. D.E.Pitfield and R.E.Caves
More informationPerformance and Efficiency Evaluation of Airports. The Balance Between DEA and MCDA Tools. J.Braz, E.Baltazar, J.Jardim, J.Silva, M.
Performance and Efficiency Evaluation of Airports. The Balance Between DEA and MCDA Tools. J.Braz, E.Baltazar, J.Jardim, J.Silva, M.Vaz Airdev 2012 Conference Lisbon, 19th20th April 2012 1 Introduction
More informationAnalysing the performance of New Zealand universities in the 2010 Academic Ranking of World Universities. Tertiary education occasional paper 2010/07
Analysing the performance of New Zealand universities in the 2010 Academic Ranking of World Universities Tertiary education occasional paper 2010/07 The Tertiary Education Occasional Papers provide short
More informationCoverage of Mangrove Ecosystem along Three Coastal Zones of Puerto Rico using IKONOS Sensor
Coverage of Mangrove Ecosystem along Three Coastal Zones of Puerto Rico using IKONOS Sensor Jennifer Toledo Rivera Geology Department, University of Puerto Rico, Mayagüez Campus P.O. Box 9017 Mayagüez,
More informationRecapturing the Spatial Dynamics of the Venetian Occupation Period
Recapturing the Spatial Dynamics of the Venetian Occupation Period of Merabello in Eastern Crete through a GIS Approach MARIANNA KATIFORI'^ ' University of Crete, Dept. of History & Archaeology and Dept.
More informationCase No IV/M KUONI / FIRST CHOICE. REGULATION (EEC) No 4064/89 MERGER PROCEDURE. Article 6(1)(b) NONOPPOSITION Date: 06/05/1999
EN Case No IV/M.1502  KUONI / FIRST CHOICE Only the English text is available and authentic. REGULATION (EEC) No 4064/89 MERGER PROCEDURE Article 6(1)(b) NONOPPOSITION Date: 06/05/1999 Also available
More informationWhat we have in 2009?
Academic Ranking of World Universities 2009 Dr. Ying CHENG & Prof. Nian Cai LIU Center for World Class Universities Graduate Schoolofof Education Shanghai Jiao Tong University Third International Conference
More informationPHY 133 Lab 6  Conservation of Momentum
Stony Brook Physics Laboratory Manuals PHY 133 Lab 6  Conservation of Momentum The purpose of this lab is to demonstrate conservation of linear momentum in onedimensional collisions of objects, and to
More informationToday: using MATLAB to model LTI systems
Today: using MATLAB to model LTI systems 2 nd order system example: DC motor with inductance derivation of the transfer function transient responses using MATLAB open loop closed loop (with feedback) Effect
More information1.4: Premium Air Travel: An Important Market Segment
CHAPTER 1.4 Premium Air Travel: An Important Market Segment SELIM ACH BRIAN PEARCE International Air Transport Association (IATA) The premium (first and business class) travel segment is an important market,
More informationLarval fish dispersal in a coralreef seascape
VOLUME: 1 ARTICLE NUMBER: 0148 In the format provided by the authors and unedited. Larval fish dispersal in a coralreef seascape Glenn R. Almany 1, Serge Planes 1, Simon R. Thorrold 2 *, Michael L. Berumen
More informationTOURISM MACROECONOMICS Definitions and Key Concepts
Tourism as a complex phenomenon TOURISM MACROECONOMICS Definitions and Key Concepts Need to adopt a multidisciplinary approach TOURISM AS A SYSTEM LEIPER MODEL Tourist  Space Travel and Tourism Industry
More information1. Sea: heavy influence on physical environment of Greece (Aegean Sea, Ionian Sea)
1. Sea: heavy influence on physical environment of Greece (Aegean Sea, Ionian Sea) 2. Mountains (with narrow valleys): cover more than ¾ of Greece s surface area 3. Islands: more than 2000 islands (Crete
More informationText 1: Minoans Prosper From Trade. Topic 5: Ancient Greece Lesson 1: Early Greece
Text 1: Minoans Prosper From Trade Topic 5: Ancient Greece Lesson 1: Early Greece VOCABULARY Crete Aegean Sea fresco Mycenanean Arthur Evans Minoans Knossos shrine Minoans Prosper From Trade The island
More informationReading Informational Medford 549C Work Sample Effective February 2010 Informational Text Title:
Reading Informational Medford 549C Work Sample Effective February 2010 Informational Text Title: Geography and the Settlement of Greece Reading Work Sample Assessment Middle School Geography and the Settlement
More informationDue: Wednesday, September 16, 2015
Chapter 10: Mediterranean Society The Greek Phase Due: Wednesday, September 16, 2015 Chapter Overview Although the Greeks did not build a centralized state until the short reign of Alexander of Macedon,
More informationAuthors. Courtney Slavin Graduate Research Assistant Civil and Environmental Engineering Portland State University
An Evaluation of the Impacts of an Adaptive Coordinated Traffic Signal System on Transit Performance: a case study on Powell Boulevard (Portland, Oregon) Authors Courtney Slavin Graduate Research Assistant
More informationGeography of the Greek Homeland. Geography of the Greek Homeland
We live around the sea like frogs around a pond, noted the Greek thinker Plato. Indeed, the Mediterranean and Aegean seas were as central to the development of Greek civilization as the Nile was to the
More informationThe Seychelles National Meteorological Services. Mahé Seychelles
Report for the fishermen Finding the best days to process seacucumber in the Seychelles during the months of March, April and May. The Seychelles National Meteorological Services Mahé Seychelles By: Hyacinth
More informationThe Destination Management Company of Greece
The Destination Management Company of Greece The Company John Casulli (to the right) President Since 1972 various management positions in the tourism sector: VP, Eastern Mediterranean for TWA Travelers
More informationGeographic Background 7/9/2009. Western Civ. Mr. Cegielski
Essential Question: How did the Minoans and Myceneans establish the basic foundations of Classical Greek Civilization? Western Civ. Mr. Cegielski Geographic Background In ancient times, Greece was not
More informationReconstruction of some Minoan words through signs of Phaistos disc
21 Reconstruction of some Minoan words through signs of Phaistos disc Alexander Akulov independent scholar; St.Petersburg, Russia; email: aynu@inbox.ru Abstract Some signs of Phaistos disc look like pictures
More informationStructured UNiversity mobility between the Balkans and Europe for the Adriaticionian Macroregion
Structured UNiversity mobility between the Balkans and Europe for the Adriaticionian Macroregion Silvia Mangialardo Università Politecnica delle Marche st Joint Forum of the AdriaticIonian Macroregion
More informationCRITICAL FACTORS FOR THE DEVELOPMENT OF AIRPORT CITIES. Mauro Peneda, Prof. Rosário Macário AIRDEV Seminar IST, 20 October 2011
CRITICAL FACTORS FOR THE DEVELOPMENT OF AIRPORT CITIES Mauro Peneda, Prof. Rosário Macário AIRDEV Seminar IST, 20 October 2011 Introduction Airports are becoming new dynamic centres of economic activity.
More informationCHAPTER NINE: PERCEPTIONS OF THE DEVELOPMENT AND PLANNING PROCESS
CHAPTER NINE: PERCEPTIONS OF THE DEVELOPMENT AND PLANNING PROCESS 9.0 INTRODUCTION Few industries have such a pervasive impact on the local community as tourism. Therefore, it is considered essential to
More informationANTH 489. Romans, Arabs and Vikings. Seafaring in the Mediterranean during the Early Christian Era.
ANTH 489 Romans, Arabs and Vikings. Seafaring in the Mediterranean during the Early Christian Era. Class 12: The Late Roman Shipwrecks at Skerki Bank. Between 1988 and 2003 Dr. Robert D. Ballard and the
More informationNetworks for the Minoan Aegean
CAAUK Southampton 25 th 26 th January 2007 Tim Evans Theoretical Physics Networks for the Minoan Aegean 27 26 29 14 33 20 18 34 Tim Evans (Imperial), Carl Knappett (Exeter), Ray Rivers (Imperial) 28
More informationSection 1. The Index
Section 1. The Index Measuring where Africa stands on regional gives an assessment of what is happening across the continent and is an important way of highlighting where the gaps are. It is a dynamic,
More informationNubia s Proximity to Egypt Equals a Lifetime of Egyptian Rule. Ancient Nubia is known for being Egypt s overlooked neighbor. Nubia is also known for
Walker, Aleta CENG 105 WS Professor Peterson Cultural Analysis Final Draft November 13, 2012 Nubia s Proximity to Egypt Equals a Lifetime of Egyptian Rule Ancient Nubia is known for being Egypt s overlooked
More informationModeling Visitor Movement in Theme Parks
Modeling Visitor Movement in Theme Parks A scenariospecific human mobility model Gürkan Solmaz, Mustafa İlhan Akbaş and Damla Turgut Department of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science University
More informationAn Analysis Of Characteristics Of U.S. Hotels Based On Upper And Lower Quartile Net Operating Income
An Analysis Of Characteristics Of U.S. Hotels Based On Upper And Lower Quartile Net Operating Income 2009 Thomson Reuters/West. Originally appeared in the Summer 2009 issue of Real Estate Finance Journal.
More informationProduced by: Destination Research Sergi Jarques, Director
Produced by: Destination Research Sergi Jarques, Director Economic Impact of Tourism Oxfordshire  2015 Economic Impact of Tourism Headline Figures Oxfordshire  2015 Total number of trips (day & staying)
More informationPeculiarities in the demand forecast for an HSRL connecting two countries. Case of Kuala Lumpur Singapore HSRL
València, Universitat Politècnica de València, 2016 DOI: http://dxdoiorg/104995/cit201620163458 Peculiarities in the demand forecast for an HSRL connecting two countries Case of Kuala Lumpur Singapore
More informationThe genetic basis of adaptive evolution has long escaped the grasp of evolutionary
65 CHAPTER 6 Detecting Hitchhiking from Patterns of DNA Polymorphism Justin C. Fay and ChungI Wu The genetic basis of adaptive evolution has long escaped the grasp of evolutionary geneticists due to the
More informationThe explanations of other terms used throughout the tables are contained in the section on Definitions immediately following the tables.
FOREWORD 1 CONTENT 1.1 UK Airports  Annual Statements of Movements, Passengers and Cargo is prepared by the Civil Aviation Authority with the cooperation of the United Kingdom airport operators. The
More informationATTEND Analytical Tools To Evaluate Negotiation Difficulty
ATTEND Analytical Tools To Evaluate Negotiation Difficulty Alejandro Bugacov Robert Neches University of Southern California Information Sciences Institute ANTs PI Meeting, November, 2000 Outline 1. Goals
More informationTOURISM SPENDING IN ALGONQUIN PROVINCIAL PARK
TOURISM SPENDING IN ALGONQUIN PROVINCIAL PARK Margaret E. Bowman 1, Paul F.G. Eagles 2 1 Ontario Parks Central Zone, 451 Arrowhead Park Road, RR3, Huntsville, ON P1H 2J4, 2 Department of Recreation and
More informationThe Greek World: Classical, Byzantine, And Modern
The Greek World: Classical, Byzantine, And Modern If you are searched for the book The Greek World: Classical, Byzantine, and Modern in pdf form, in that case you come on to the right site. We furnish
More informationGreece: A History By Alexander Eliot
Greece: A History By Alexander Eliot  A History Of Greece  medulla.store  Browse and Read A History Of Greece A History Of Greece Will reading habit influence your life? Many say yes. Reading a history
More informationARHA 221 THE ARTS OF MEDITERRANEAN AND EUROPEAN CIVILIZATIONS: ANCIENT TO PREMODERN Spring 2011
ARHA 221 THE ARTS OF MEDITERRANEAN AND EUROPEAN CIVILIZATIONS: ANCIENT TO PREMODERN Spring 2011 SYLLABUS Winter fishing in the Mediterranean (Island of Corfu, November 2010, photo A. Ricci) Schedule:
More informationGood morning! You need: both sheets from yesterday! Write HW in agenda: BRING IN CANS. College day tomorrow: Wear college shirts and hats!
Good morning! You need: both sheets from yesterday! Write HW in agenda: BRING IN CANS College day tomorrow: Wear college shirts and hats! Ancient Greece BIG IDEA: Greece s geography and closeness to seas
More informationCourse Catalog  Spring 2015
Course Catalog  Spring 2015 Classical Civilization Classics Department Head: Ariana Trail Department Office: 4080 Foreign Languages Building, 707 South Mathews, Urbana Phone: 3331008 www.classics.illinois.edu
More informationTHE HABITAT OF THE ENDANGERED MEDITERRANEAN MONK SEAL (MONACHUS MONACHUS) IN THE ARCHIPELAGO OF MADEIRA
Vol. 5 (2): November 2002 Download this article THE HABITAT OF THE ENDANGERED MEDITERRANEAN MONK SEAL (MONACHUS MONACHUS) IN THE ARCHIPELAGO OF MADEIRA Alexandros A. Karamanlidis 1, Rosa Pires 1, 2, Nádia
More informationRecreation Opportunity Spectrum for River Management v
Recreation Opportunity Spectrum for Management v. 120803 Introduction The following Recreation Opportunity Spectrum (ROS) characterizations and matrices mirror the presentation in the ROS Primer and Field
More informationControlling the False Discovery Rate in Bayesian Network Structure Learning
False Discovery Rate in Bayesian Network Structure Learning Ioannis Tsamardinos Asnt Prof., CSD, Univ. of Crete ICS, FORTH Laura E. Brown DBMI, Vanderbilt Univ. Sofia Triantafylloy CSD, Univ. of Crete
More informationSingle and mass avalanching. Similarity of avalanching in space.
Single and mass avalanching. Similarity of avalanching in space. Pavel Chernous* Center for Avalanche Safety, "Apatit" JSC, Kirovsk, Russia ABSTRACT: Sometimes it is possible to observe only single avalanche
More informationGATWICK RNAV1 SIDS CAA PIR ROUTE ANALYSIS REPORT
GATWICK RNAV1 SIDS GATWICK RNAV1 SIDS CAA PIR ROUTE ANALYSIS REPORT ROUTE ANALYSIS REPORT FOR GATWICK This section explains the track distribution of conventional SIDs and the RNAV SID replications using
More informationWorld History I. Workbook
World History I Workbook WALCH PUBLISHING Table of Contents To the Student............................ vii Unit 1: The Earliest People Activity 1 Understanding Archaeology................ 1 Activity 2
More informationPRAJWAL KHADGI Department of Industrial and Systems Engineering Northern Illinois University DeKalb, Illinois, USA
SIMULATION ANALYSIS OF PASSENGER CHECK IN AND BAGGAGE SCREENING AREA AT CHICAGOROCKFORD INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT PRAJWAL KHADGI Department of Industrial and Systems Engineering Northern Illinois University
More informationExample report: numbers are for illustration purposes only
www.iata.org/paxforecast Example report: numbers are for illustration purposes only Country Report  United States Page Table of Contents 1 Market Overview 2 Top Country Pairs 3 Annual Market Regional
More informationHow the Nile River Led to Civilization in Ancient Egypt
How the Nile River Led to Civilization in Ancient Egypt By USHistory.org, adapted by Newsela staff on 03.07.17 Word Count 786 Level 950L TOP: This photo, taken around 1915, shows the flooding of the Nile
More informationHotel Location Analysis using ArcGIS
Hotel Location Analysis using ArcGIS Yang Yang Department of Geography University of Florida Outline Introduction Background Data Source Research Methodology Preliminary Result Introduction Location! Location!
More informationOutlook for air travel markets
Outlook for air travel markets June 2016 Brian Pearce Chief Economist International Air Transport Association Extended period of strong air travel market growth 30% 25% 20% 15% 10% 5% 0% 5% 10% 15%
More informationTHE GREAT POWERS and the EASTERN MEDITERRANEAN
Boston University THE GREAT POWERS and the EASTERN MEDITERRANEAN CAS IR 325 / HI 229 Fall Semester 2017 Tuesday and Thursday 9.30 10.45 Prof. Erik Goldstein Office Hours: Tues./ Thurs. 23 Office: 152
More informationQUALITY OF SERVICE INDEX
QUALITY OF SERVICE INDEX Advanced Presented by: David Dague SH&E, Prinicpal Airports Council International 2010 Air Service & Data Planning Seminar January 26, 2010 Workshop Agenda Introduction QSI/CSI
More informationEgyptian Civilization (3100 B.C332 B.C.)
Egyptian Civilization (3100 B.C332 B.C.) Ancient Egypt a land of mysteries. No other civilization has so captured the imagination of scholars and public in general. Mystery surrounds its origins, its
More informationNew Approach to Search for Gliders in Cellular Automata
New Approach to Search for Gliders in Cellular Automata E. Sapin Faculty of Computing, Engineering and Mathematical Sciences, University of the West of England, Bristol BS16 1QY, UK emmanuelsapin@hotmail.com
More informationTH E FIRST SEASON of investigations at the
QUSEIR ALQADIM Janet H. Johnson & Donald Whitcomb TH E FIRST SEASON of investigations at the ancient port of Quseir alqadim on the Red Sea in Egypt took place in winter, 1978; the investigations were
More informationTourist Traffic in the City of Rijeka For the Period Between 2004 and 2014
Tourist Traffic in the City of Rijeka For the Period Between 2004 and 2014 Rijeka, February 2015. Table of Contents Pg No. 1. Introduction 3 2. Physical indicators on an annual level 4 2.1. Structure and
More informationInterstate 90 and Mercer Island Mobility Study APRIL Commissioned by. Prepared by
Interstate 90 and Mercer Island Mobility Study APRIL 2017 Commissioned by Prepared by Interstate 90 and Mercer Island Mobility Study Commissioned by: Sound Transit Prepared by: April 2017 Contents Section
More informationAncient Greece. Chapter 6 Section 1 Page 166 to 173
Ancient Greece Chapter 6 Section 1 Page 166 to 173 Famous Things About Greece The Parthenon Mt. Olympia Famous Things About Greece Plato Aristotle Alexander The Great Athens Sparta Trojan War Greek Gods
More informationNotes: The Greek World (Chapter 9)
Notes: The Greek World (Chapter 9) I. Persia Becomes an Empire under Cyrus the Great A. Cyrus the Great led a Persian revolt against the in 580 BCE 1. the Great won independence for Persia from the Medes,
More informationAppendix B Ultimate Airport Capacity and Delay Simulation Modeling Analysis
Appendix B ULTIMATE AIRPORT CAPACITY & DELAY SIMULATION MODELING ANALYSIS B TABLE OF CONTENTS EXHIBITS TABLES B.1 Introduction... 1 B.2 Simulation Modeling Assumption and Methodology... 4 B.2.1 Runway
More informationFigure 1.1 St. John s Location. 2.0 Overview/Structure
St. John s Region 1.0 Introduction Newfoundland and Labrador s most dominant service centre, St. John s (population = 100,645) is also the province s capital and largest community (Government of Newfoundland
More informationHISTORY AND REVIEW OF RAILWAYHIGHWAY GRADE CROSSING WARNING SYSTEMS AND THE GENESIS OF STANDARD SPECIFICATION
HISTORY AND REVIEW OF RAILWAYHIGHWAY GRADE CROSSING WARNING SYSTEMS AND THE GENESIS OF STANDARD SPECIFICATION H ugh Kendall General Railway Signal Company IN T R O D U C T IO N Warning systems at railroad/highway
More informationGulf Carrier Profitability on U.S. Routes
GRA, Incorporated Economic Counsel to the Transportation Industry Gulf Carrier Profitability on U.S. Routes November 11, 2015 Prepared for: Wilmer Hale Prepared by: GRA, Incorporated 115 West Avenue Suite
More information2004 SOUTH DAKOTA MOTEL AND CAMPGROUND OCCUPANCY REPORT and INTERNATIONAL VISITOR SURVEY
2004 SOUTH DAKOTA MOTEL AND CAMPGROUND OCCUPANCY REPORT and INTERNATIONAL VISITOR SURVEY Prepared By: Center for Tourism Research Black Hills State University Spearfish, South Dakota Commissioned by: South
More informationA TYPOLOGY OF CULTURAL HERITAGE ATTRACTION VISITORS
University of Massachusetts Amherst ScholarWorks@UMass Amherst Tourism Travel and Research Association: Advancing Tourism Research Globally 2007 ttra International Conference A TYPOLOGY OF CULTURAL HERITAGE
More informationHEATHROW COMMUNITY NOISE FORUM. Sunninghill flight path analysis report February 2016
HEATHROW COMMUNITY NOISE FORUM Sunninghill flight path analysis report February 2016 1 Contents 1. Executive summary 2. Introduction 3. Evolution of traffic from 2005 to 2015 4. Easterly departures 5.
More informationThe Effectiveness of JetBlue if Allowed to Manage More of its Resources
McNair Scholars Research Journal Volume 2 Article 4 2015 The Effectiveness of JetBlue if Allowed to Manage More of its Resources Jerre F. Johnson Embry Riddle Aeronautical University, johnsff9@my.erau.edu
More informationGlobal travel patterns: an overview
Journal of Travel Medicine, 2017, 1 5 doi: 10.1093/jtm/tax007 Perspective Perspective Global travel patterns: an overview Dirk Glaesser*, John Kester, Hanna Paulose, Abbas Alizadeh, and Birka Valentin
More informationChapter 25 Section One: Istanbul: A Primate City throughout History urban primate city
Chapter 25 Section One: Istanbul: A Primate City throughout History Meryem lives in Istanbul, the largest city in Turkey. It is early morning. She is riding a ferryboat to get to work. The ferry carries
More informationIdentifying and Utilizing Precursors
Flight Safety Foundation European Aviation Safety Seminar Lisbon March 1517 / 2010 Presented by Michel TREMAUD ( retired, Airbus / Aerotour / Air Martinique, Bureau Veritas ) Identifying and Utilizing
More informationAircraft Noise. Why Aircraft Noise Calculations? Aircraft Noise. SoundPLAN s Aircraft Noise Module
Aircraft Noise Why Aircraft Noise Calculations? Aircraft Noise Aircraft noise can be measured and simulated with specialized software like SoundPLAN. Noise monitoring and measurement can only measure the
More information