BIOM5010/BMG5112: Fall 2016

Transcription

1 Quiz: 1A Consider the story of the drug marketed as Vioxx by Merck and Co, and considered in the 2011 exam. Consider one issue of scientific misconduct in this case. What type is it (Fabrication, Falsification, Plagiarism, etc)? Briefly ( 50 words) describe what happened and its consequences for the investigators and other people.

2 Quiz: 1B What is the difference between single and a double blind review? Briefly (50 words) explain one reason that peer review is blinded.

3 Quiz: 1C What is the value of a journal rating system such as the impact factor? criticism of such a journal rating system. Briefly explain one

4 Quiz: 1D Does the example below (from 1 ) constitute plagiarism? Briefly explain why or why not. Indicate section of the text that are suspicious. Original paragraph: Knossos is one of the major archaeological sites in Greece in terms of its importance and interest to the visitor. This is because the mighty city of Minos and Ariadne, of Pasiphae, the Minotaur and Idomeneus, was one of the first cities on European soil, a centre which radiated the light of one of the most brilliant civilizations of Greek and European prehistory Minoan civilization, named after the great god-kind Minos. The Knossos Labyrinth is both the key and the stumbling-block to our understanding of Minoan civilization. Submitted work: The city of Knossos is one of the major archaeological sites in Greece and attracts a great number of visitors each year, mostly because of the famous stories of King Minos, Theseus, the Minotaur and Ariadne. It was one of the first cities on European soil and was the center of one of the most brilliant Greek civilizations the Minoans. From what remains of this city, the foundation, a few walls, fragments of frescoes, pithoi, fallen stones from columns we can learn much about the splendour of this great ancient civilization. 1 plagiarism eg.html

5 Quiz: 1D Does the example below (from 1 ) constitute plagiarism? Briefly explain why or why not. Indicate section of the text that are suspicious. Original paragraph: Knossos is one of the major archaeological sites in Greece in terms of its importance and interest to the visitor. This is because the mighty city of Minos and Ariadne, of Pasiphae, the Minotaur and Idomeneus, was one of the first cities on European soil, a centre which radiated the light of one of the most brilliant civilizations of Greek and European prehistory Minoan civilization, named after the great god-kind Minos. The Knossos Labyrinth is both the key and the stumbling-block to our understanding of Minoan civilization. Submitted work: The city of Knossos is one of the major archaeological sites in Greece and attracts a great number of visitors each year, mostly because of the famous stories of King Minos, Theseus, the Minotaur and Ariadne. It was one of the first cities on European soil and was the center of one of the most brilliant Greek civilizations the Minoans. From what remains of this city, the foundation, a few walls, fragments of frescoes, pithoi, fallen stones from columns we can learn much about the splendour of this great ancient civilization. 1 plagiarism eg.html

6 Quiz: 1E Currently E-cigarettes are sold as leisure products and as such are covered by safety and quality standards 1 ; however, many countries consider e-cigarettes to be a medical device, like other smoking cessation products. In Canada, they are currently banned 2. Assume Health Canada chose to regulate e-cigarettes as a medical device. List at least two considerations that would be made to choose a medical device class, and what device class would e-cigarettes be? 1 The Economist, Sep 28th 2013, E-cigarettes: Kodak moment, Online: 2 Financial Post, Nov 16th 2013, Online: business.financialpost.com/2013/11/16/how-e-cigarettes-have-become-a-verywild-west-industry-in-canada/