An Assessment of the Economic Impacts of Cultural Heritage Projects in Georgia and Macedonia
|
|
- Lauren Short
- 6 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 An Assessment of the Economic Impacts of Cultural Heritage Projects in Georgia and Macedonia Presentation by Dr. David Throsby and Dr. Benoit Laplante World Bank, Washington D.C. May 4, 2011 Outline 1. Introduction 2. The economics of cultural heritage 3. The economic impacts of CH project: Georgia 4. The economic impacts of CH project: Macedonia 5. Conclusions / Lessons 1
2 Outline 1. Introduction 2. The economics of cultural heritage 3. The economic impacts of CH project: Georgia 4. The economic impacts of CH project: Macedonia 5. Conclusions / Lessons Introduction The World Bank has financed a variety of investment projects aimed generally at supporting the conservation, restoration, and maintenance of physical heritage around the world, including in ECA countries. A review of the project portfolio implemented during the period FY1997 through 2010 revealed that the size of the investments ranged from US$150,000 to US$240 million, with Learning and Innovation Loans (LILs) averaging approximately US$5 million. The overall objective of these investments is to promote employment, poverty reduction and more generally economic development using cultural heritage resources as an asset. 2
3 Introduction Although Bank projects in the cultural heritage field are subject to the usual assessments that are applied to any project implementation, little is known about the subsequent performance of these projects in the years post-completion. Accordingly this study was undertaken to provide some empirical evidence for the economic impacts of cultural heritage investment. Two case studies were chosen for this purpose, in the historic town centres of Tbilisi, Georgia and Skopje, Macedonia respectively. Outline 1. Introduction 2. The economics of cultural heritage 3. The economic impacts of CH project: Georgia 4. The economic impacts of CH project: Macedonia 5. Conclusions / Lessons 3
4 The economics of cultural heritage Field of increasing interest. Various types of CH assets have been subjected to analysis: Built (e.g. churches, museums, whole areas) and natural (e.g. national parks, Lake Sevan, etc.) With various purposes: Assessing economic impacts; Assessing economic benefits. Various groups of people: Local residents; Tourists (national and/or international). And various approaches: Panel datasets, control groups, etc. Contingent valuation, travel cost, hedonic pricing, etc. The economics of cultural heritage In this study: The projects we are looking are investment projects to restore whole area of the respective cities. Methodology A full ex post cost-benefit analysis using actual data would be ideal But data limitations are likely to make this very difficult to implement pe e A simpler procedure is to gather relevant indicators 4
5 The economics of cultural heritage In this study: After discussion with local teams in both Skopje and Tbilisi, it was determined that a reasonable objective would be: Assess the economic impacts of the investment projects. The economics of cultural heritage Economic indicators Output of goods and services Business profitability Tourism impacts Labor market effects: employment and wages Real estate rentals and prices Further investments stimulated Cultural indicators Immediate use and non-use cultural benefits to residents and visitors Longer term cultural l impacts: sustainability issues 5
6 The economics of cultural heritage Key question of interest: What would have happened in those areas with project if there had been no project (counterfactual scenario)? And that a reasonable approach would be: Select a similar area as control group; Collect general secondary data as well as and primary data in each area; Target national stakeholders. The economics of cultural heritage Limitations of the study in both sites: (1) These projects have been initiated more than 10 years ago in a region of the world which was experiencing important political and economic turmoils. This creates difficulties in terms of data availability. (2) Time to develop survey template, pre-test, and implement was very limited. 6
7 Outline 1. Introduction 2. The economics of cultural heritage 3. The economic impacts of CH project: Georgia 4. The economic impacts of CH project: Macedonia 5. Conclusions / Lessons The economic impacts of CH project: Georgia 7
8 The economic impacts of CH project: Georgia Number of licenses issued for new businesses: Business licenses issued throughout Georgia according to legal status and not according to sectors; Business licenses issued in Tbilisi according to legal status and according to tax authority offices. Employment rates, sectors, average salaries Employment countrywide by economic sectors years; Employment and average salary in Tbilisi years; Average monthly salary countrywide by economic sectors years; Average salary according to economic sectors countrywide years; Employment & average salary in restaurants/hotels in Tbilisi for Real estate values Retail sales Tourists and visitors The economic impacts of CH project: Georgia For the purpose of the study, the following areas were targeted: Zemo Kala District of Old Town Tbilisi a selected project area (referred to as target area ) subject to intervention within the World Bank Cultural l Heritage Project context; t and Metekhi Plateau of Old Town Tbilisi located across the target area and not subject to intervention (control group). 8
9 The economic impacts of CH project: Georgia 0 Sololaki 7 Zemo Kala (Erekles Moedani) 1 Metekhi (Darejani) 8 Zemo Kala (Vercxlis Qucha) 2 Metekhi (Plateau) 9 Kvemo Kala (Gudiashvilis Moedani) 3 Abanotubani 1 Kldis Ubani 0 4 Kvemo Kala (Tsikhis ubani) 1 Sololaki (kvemo) 1 5 Zemo Kala (Sanapiro) 1 Sololaki (Zemo) 2 6 Kvemo Kala (Centraluri) The economic impacts of CH project: Georgia Survey respondents by area and types Zemo Kala # of interviews Metekhi Plateau # of interviews Population 80 Population 38 Pedestrians 36 Pedestrians 0 Museums 4 Museums 0 Hotels 6 Hotels 6 Restaurants 18 Restaurants 1 Shops 24 Shops 6 Business Center 1 Business Center 0 Total 169 Total 51 I t f b i th t t d In terms of businesses, the survey targeted: All hotels/guesthouses located in Zemo Kala and Metekhi Plateau; All restaurants and practically all shops in Metekhi Plateau; All museums located in Zemo Kala. 9
10 The economic impacts of CH project: Georgia Changes in real estate value Per sq.m. Price in Zemo Kala and Metekhi Metekhi Kala Over the period 2005 and 2010, real estate values increased by 12.2% in Metekhi Plateau, and by 21.8% in Zemo Kala. The economic impacts of CH project: Georgia Perception of changes in housing conditions Recent Housing Conditions Compared to Before % 42% 42% 30% 30% 16% Improved Worsened Stayed the same Metekhi Kala 10
11 The economic impacts of CH project: Georgia Since 2002, 18 new restaurants, cafes and pubs were established in Zemo Kala since None were established in Metekhi Plateau. 6 Factors of Starting Business in Kala Tourists' concentration Historical location Convenient location Prestigious location Attractive location Old district Crowded place The economic impacts of CH project: Georgia 700 Number of visitors (thousands) Rest of Georgia Tbilisi Kala
12 The economic impacts of CH project: Georgia Perception of Kala and the impact of the project Agree Neutral/ No opinion/ Can t say Disagree Kala is an important part of Georgian culture Restoring Kala improves Tbilisi as a place to visit or live in Investing in improvements in Kala is a waste of money Kala is a place that helps people come together The renovated buildings of Kala are beautiful Kala gives me a sense of Georgian cultural identity Kala should be demolished and replaced with modern buildings The economic impacts of CH project: Georgia Beyond the Bank project: In 2005, the Rehabilitation of Old Tbilisi Program, which was cofinanced by the Municipality of Tbilisi and the private sector. An additional US$ 10 million was leveraged through direct funds from the President s cabinet dedicated Old Town Tbilisi s infrastructure rehabilitation. In 2010 the Mayor of Tbilisi launched the New Life for Old Tbilisi Program. 12
13 Outline 1. Introduction 2. The economics of cultural heritage 3. The economic impacts of CH project: Georgia 4. The economic impacts of CH project: Macedonia 5. Conclusions / Lessons Map of the Old Bazaar in Skopje Skopje Old Bazaar Contact zone Dukandzik Contact zone Mavrovka Contact zone Skopska tvrdina (Skopje Fortress) Contact zone Most (Bridge) 13
14 Map of the Old Bazaar in Prilep Prilep Old Bazaar Contact zone south (W) Contact zone north (N) Contact zone Mala Carsija (Small bazaar) (I) Contact zone Kej (I down) Contact zone Pazar (Bazaar) (S) Skopje, a street in the Old Bazaar in
15 Skopje, a street in the Old Bazaar in 2010 Stakeholders Commercial businesses such as shops, restaurants, cafes, hotels etc. in the Old Bazaar area; Cultural organisations such as museums, mosques, churches, etc. Residents in the Old Bazaar area and in Skopje more generally; Tourists and visitors from elsewhere in Macedonia and from other countries; Public and semi-public authorities, NGOs etc. 15
16 Surveys undertaken Restaurants, café shops, souvenir shops, handcrafts, and jewellery makers; Hotels, guest-houses, hostels; Museums, galleries, exhibition halls; and Domestic and foreign visitors. Findings from economic indicators Initial Bank investment helped stimulate additional funding of $2½ million in Daily tourist numbers have almost doubled Mean daily tourist expenditure up by 30% Increase of 52% in daily numbers of locals + tourists visiting restaurants, cafes, shops. Employment numbers and have grown more than three times faster than in control site. Particular impacts on attendances in museums and galleries among both foreigners and locals. Positive climate created for further business expansion in the Old Bazaar area. 16
17 Perception of cultural benefits: Visitors to Old Bazaar The Old Bazaar is an important part of Macedonian culture Restoring the Old Bazaar improves Skopje as a place to visit or live in Investing in improvements in the Old Bazaar is a waste of money The Old Bazaar is a place that helps people come together The renovated buildings of the Old Bazaar are beautiful The Old Bazaar gives me a sense of Macedonian cultural identity The Old Bazaar should be demolished and replaced with modern buildings I have learnt something about my cultural heritage from being here Strongly agree (%) Agree (%) Neutral (%) Disagree (%) Strongly disagree (%) Total (%) Statements about value of cultural heritage Skopje Old Bazaar Prilep Old Bazaar Total proportion agreeing (%) Total proportion agreeing (%) Positive statements Part of Macedonian culture Improvement in liveability Visual/aesthetic value (a) 70.5 Social value Identity/symbolic value Educational value Negative statements Heritage investment a waste of money Should be demolished 21.5 Note: (a) This statement not included in Prilep survey 17
18 A contingent valuation or choice modeling study should pay attention to: defining the population of beneficiaries; using appropriate procedures to ensure a valid random sample is drawn, if necessary stratified according to variables of interest; designing a questionnaire that provides necessary information and realistic scenarios to respondents; including questions that yield objective data on respondents perceptions of the strength of the external or public-good effects under consideration; controlling for biases in soliciting respondents willingness to pay; and specifying a feasible payment vehicle comprehensible to respondents. Willingness to contribute Visitors willingness to make a one-off contribution to heritage restoration in the Old Bazaars in Skopje and Prilep (per cent) Amount willing to contribute Proportion of respondents (%) Skopje Prilep Zero Up to 500 MKD MKD MKD More than 1500 MKD Total
19 The economic impacts of CH project: Macedonia Beyond the Bank Project: Funds have been leveraged from various donors as well as the private and public sectors s totaling nearly US$ 2.5 million since 2006; Investments planned for 2011 alone (restoration of a caravanserai, a Hamam, Skender Beg square and four shops) are predicted to be in excess of US$ 2 million. Outline 1. Introduction 2. The economics of cultural heritage 3. The economic impacts of CH project: Georgia 4. The economic impacts of CH project: Macedonia 5. Conclusions / Lessons 19
20 Conclusions and lessons In comparison with the control sites in each case, tourist numbers and expenditures have increased, businesses have expanded, new start-ups have been initiated, and employment and skill levels have been enhanced. The study has also provided some quantitative evidence on the cultural benefits perceived by stakeholders and their willingness to pay through voluntary contributions to a fund to continue the rehabilitation work. Conclusions and lessons However, as noted in the Completion Report for the Georgia project dated 18 March 2004 monitoring and evaluation systems must be carefully designed to ensure that monitoring efforts produce data that are useful in assessing project outcomes and impact. Without such data, it is difficult to assess what has changed and to assess how much of these changes can be attributed to the CH investment project, especially many years after the project has been completed. 20
21 Conclusions and lessons A further issue of interest, beyond attribution, is of additionality in a broader geographical scope than the project area. At the city level, or at the national level, how much more economic activities were generated as a result of the project? Conclusions and lessons In principle, it would have been possible to implement a travel cost approach or an hedonic pricing approach to assess the economic benefits of the project. These are well suited for ex-post assessment. However, these methodologies take considerable amount of time and resources to implement. 21
22 An Assessment of the Economic Impacts of Cultural Heritage Projects in Georgia and Macedonia Presentation by Dr. David Throsby and Dr. Benoit Laplante World Bank, Washington D.C. May 4,
Tourism Satellite Account Calendar Year 2010
The Economic Impact of Tourism in Georgia Tourism Satellite Account Calendar Year 2010 Highlights The Georgia visitor economy rebounded in 2010, recovering 98% of the losses experienced during the recession
More informationThe Economic Impact of Tourism in North Carolina. Tourism Satellite Account Calendar Year 2015
The Economic Impact of Tourism in North Carolina Tourism Satellite Account Calendar Year 2015 Key results 2 Total tourism demand tallied $28.3 billion in 2015, expanding 3.6%. This marks another new high
More informationThe Economic Impact of Tourism in North Carolina. Tourism Satellite Account Calendar Year 2013
The Economic Impact of Tourism in North Carolina Tourism Satellite Account Calendar Year 2013 Key results 2 Total tourism demand tallied $26 billion in 2013, expanding 3.9%. This marks another new high
More informationEconomic Impact Analysis. Tourism on Tasmania s King Island
Economic Impact Analysis Tourism on Tasmania s King Island i Economic Impact Analysis Tourism on Tasmania s King Island This project has been conducted by REMPLAN Project Team Matthew Nichol Principal
More informationTourism Industry Council Tasmania Community Survey 2018 Research Report. May 2018
Tourism Industry Council Tasmania Community Survey 2018 Research Report May 2018 This report has been prepared by Enterprise Marketing and Research Services 60 Main Road, Moonah TAS 7009 All enquiries
More informationThe Economic Impact of Tourism in Buncombe County, North Carolina
The Economic Impact of Tourism in Buncombe County, North Carolina 2017 Analysis September 2018 Introduction and definitions This study measures the economic impact of tourism in Buncombe County, North
More informationForegone Economic Benefits from Airport Capacity Constraints in EU 28 in 2035
Foregone Economic Benefits from Airport Capacity Constraints in EU 28 in 2035 Foregone Economic Benefits from Airport Capacity Constraints in EU 28 in 2035 George Anjaparidze IATA, February 2015 Version1.1
More informationIntroduction. Significance of domestic travel. How many domestic trips do Georgians take? 2,933 2,951
Introduction Figure 1: Domestic visits 2017-2018 (in thousands) This report presents the basic trends in domestic travel by Georgian residents for the period of first quarter of 2018. Figures include the
More informationAppendix 3 REMPLAN Economic Impact Modelling: New Energy Port Hedland Waste to Energy Project
Public Environmental Review Boodarie Waste to Energy and Materials Recovery, Port Hedland Appendix 3 REMPLAN Economic Impact Modelling: New Energy Port Hedland Waste to Energy Project NEW ENERGY PORT HEDLAND
More informationANGLIAN WATER GREEN BOND
ANGLIAN WATER GREEN BOND DNV GL ELIGIBILITY ASSESSMENT Scope and Objectives Anglian Water Services Financing Plc is the financing subsidiary of Anglian Water Services Limited. References in this eligibility
More informationMackay. Social Indicators te.queensland.com/research
Mackay Social Indicators 2013 This study examines the social impacts of tourism on the local communities, as perceived by its residents. The research is intended to inform the decision making of state
More informationLiving on the edge: The impact of travel costs on low paid workers living in outer London executive summary. living on the edge 1
Living on the edge: The impact travel costs on low paid workers living in outer London executive summary living on the edge 1 introduction key findings London has a world-class public transport system
More informationPerformance Criteria for Assessing Airport Expansion Alternatives for the London Region
Performance Criteria for Assessing Airport Expansion Alternatives for the London Region Jagoda Egeland International Transport Forum at the OECD TRB Annual Meeting 836 - Measuring Aviation System Performance:
More informationTropical North Queensland
Tropical North Queensland Social Indicators 2013 This study examines the social impacts of tourism on the local communities, as perceived by its residents. The research is intended to inform the decision
More informationBrisbane. Social Indicators te.queensland.com/research
Brisbane Social Indicators 2013 This study examines the social impacts of tourism on the local communities, as perceived by its residents. The research is intended to inform the decision making of state
More informationThe Strategic Commercial and Procurement Manager
Item 3 To: Procurement Sub Committee On: 8 June 2016 Report by: The Strategic Commercial and Procurement Manager Heading: Renfrewshire Council s Community Benefit Strategy 2016 1. Summary 1.1. The purpose
More informationThe Economic Impact of Tourism in Walworth County, Wisconsin. July 2013
The Economic Impact of Tourism in Walworth County, Wisconsin July 2013 Key themes for 2012 The Walworth County, Wisconsin visitor economy continued its brisk growth in 2012. Visitor spending rose 11% after
More informationActivity Concept Note:
Activity Concept Note: Summary Provide a short summary of the proposed Activity including indicative New Zealand funding level and note whether this is a New Zealandled or partner-led process. Why: Rationale
More informationCOMMUNITY BASED TOURISM DEVELOPMENT (A Case Study of Sikkim)
COMMUNITY BASED TOURISM DEVELOPMENT (A Case Study of Sikkim) SUMMARY BY RINZING LAMA UNDER THE SUPERVISION OF PROFESSOR MANJULA CHAUDHARY DEPARTMENT OF TOURISM AND HOTEL MANAGEMENT KURUKSHETRA UNIVERSITY,
More informationStudy on Hotel Management Graduates Perceptions and Preferences of Jobs in Hotel Industry in Chennai City
Study on Hotel Management Graduates Perceptions and Preferences of Jobs in Hotel Industry in Chennai City T.S. Natarajan, Research scholar, Department of Management studies, SCSVMV University, India. E-mail:
More informationThe Economic Impact of Tourism in Jacksonville, FL. June 2016
The Economic Impact of Tourism in Jacksonville, FL June 2016 Highlights Visitor spending surpassed $2.0 billion in 2015, growing 4.4%. As this money flowed through Duval County, the $2.0 billion in visitor
More informationAGENDA. MENA Region Economic Context/Challenges. Importance of Cultural Heritage. Responding to Countries Needs and Demands
Leveraging Cultural Heritage for Sustainable Development MIDDLE EAST & NORTH AFRICA Hedi Larbi Sector Manager April 16, 2007 AGENDA MENA Region Economic Context/Challenges Importance of Cultural Heritage
More informationStakeholder Perspectives on the Potential for Community-based Ecotourism Development and Support for the Kgalagadi Transfrontier Park in Botswana
Stakeholder Perspectives on the Potential for Community-based Ecotourism Development and Support for the Kgalagadi Transfrontier Park in Botswana Naomi Moswete, University of Botswana Brijesh Thapa, University
More informationNAPA VALLEY VISITOR INDUSTRY 2012 Economic Impact Report
Join Visit Napa Valley NAPA VALLEY VISITOR INDUSTRY 2012 Economic Impact Report Research prepared for Visit Napa Valley by Destination Analysts, Inc. Table of Contents SECTION 1 Introduction 2 SECTION
More informationPOVERTY REDUCTION THROUGH COMMUNITY-BASED TOURISM IN VIET NAM: A CASE STUDY
POVERTY REDUCTION THROUGH COMMUNITY-BASED TOURISM IN VIET NAM: A CASE STUDY A paper contributed by the ITC Export-led Poverty Reduction Programme Team (EPRP) POVERTY REDUCTION THROUGH COMMUNITY-BASED TOURISM
More informationTerms of Reference: Introduction
Terms of Reference: Assessment of airport-airline engagement on the appropriate scope, design and cost of new runway capacity; and Support in analysing technical responses to the Government s draft NPS
More informationContext Briefing 3 Changes over time in the provision of amenities and facilities
Context Briefing 3 Changes over time in the provision of amenities and facilities Anne Ellaway Scott Macdonald Laura Macdonald Natalie Nicholls March 2014 GoWell is a collaborative partnership between
More informationIntroduction. Significance of domestic travel. How many domestic trips do Georgians take? 3,230 3,145
Introduction This report presents the basic trends in domestic travel by Georgian residents for the period of second quarter of 2017. Figures include the results of a household survey conducted by the
More informationCaribbean Regional Sustainable Tourism Development Programme
Caribbean Regional Sustainable Tourism Development Programme Project No. 8 ACP RCA 035 Report of Survey of Residents' Involvement and Attitudes towards Tourism: Barbados, St.Lucia and Trinidad & Tobago
More informationIntroduction 3. Accommodation 4. Ireland Market 5. Activity Providers, Attractions, Retail and Transport 6. Overseas Market Performance 7.
Contents Page No: Introduction 3 Accommodation 4 Ireland Market 5 Activity Providers, Attractions, Retail and Transport 6 Overseas Market Performance 7 Prospects 8 Factors Impacting on Performance 9 Operational
More informationSummary Report. Economic Impact Assessment for Beef Australia 2015
Summary Report Economic Impact Assessment for Beef Australia 2015 September 2015 The Department of State Development The Department of State Development exists to drive the economic development of Queensland.
More informationNAPA VALLEY VISITOR INDUSTRY 2014 Economic Impact Report
NAPA VALLEY VISITOR INDUSTRY 2014 Economic Impact Report Research prepared for Visit Napa Valley by Destination Analysts, Inc. Table of Contents SECTION 1 Introduction 2 SECTION 2 Executive Summary 5 SECTION
More informationAccountability Report
2017-2018 Accountability Report Tourism Nova Scotia Contents Accountability Statement... 3 Message from the Chair & CEO... 4 Financial Results... 6 Measuring Our Performance... 7 Accountability Statement
More informationBenefit Sharing in Protected Area Management: the Case of Tarangire National Park, Tanzania
Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Findings reports on ongoing operational, economic and sector work carried out by the
More informationTourism Inhambane Baseline Survey
Tourism Inhambane Baseline Survey Presented to Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internattionale Zusammenarbeit GmbH Inhambane, February 2014 Contents ACRONYMS AND ABBREVIATIONS 5 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 6 1 INTRODUCTION
More informationTHE 2006 ECONOMIC IMPACT OF TRAVEL & TOURISM IN INDIANA
THE 2006 ECONOMIC IMPACT OF TRAVEL & TOURISM IN INDIANA A Comprehensive Analysis Prepared by: In Partnership with: PREPARED FOR: Carrie Lambert Marketing Director Indiana Office of Tourism Development
More informationNAPA VALLEY VISITOR INDUSTRY 2016 Economic Impact Report
NAPA VALLEY VISITOR INDUSTRY 2016 Economic Impact Report Research prepared for Visit Napa Valley by Destination Analysts, Inc. Table of Contents S E C T I O N 1 Introduction 2 S E C T I O N 2 Executive
More informationNew Ideas Form. LEADER Arwain Sir Benfro FORM 2. Discussed with PLANED staff member: Yes, Cris Tomos
New Ideas Form LEADER Arwain Sir Benfro FORM 2 Discussed with PLANED staff member: Yes, Cris Tomos Thank you for your interest in bringing forward an idea for developing with the LEADER funding in Pembrokeshire.
More informationCHILDRENS WELFARE FOUNDATION SUSTAINABLE CHILD AND YOUTH TOURISM YOUTH TRAVEL AND ADVENTURE AND NATURE TOURISM
CHILDRENS WELFARE FOUNDATION SUSTAINABLE CHILD AND YOUTH TOURISM YOUTH TRAVEL AND ADVENTURE AND NATURE TOURISM Paper presented by Cleto Chibale, Director, Inc To : The 3 rd IIPT, Conference in Lusaka,Zambia
More informationEconomic Impact of Tourism in Hillsborough County September 2016
Economic Impact of Tourism in Hillsborough County - 2015 September 2016 Key findings for 2015 Almost 22 million people visited Hillsborough County in 2015. Visits to Hillsborough County increased 4.5%
More informationComparing Domestic and Foreign Tourists Economic Impact in Desert Triangle of Rajasthan
Dynamic Research Journals (DRJ) Journal of Economics and Finance (DRJ-JEF) Volume ~ Issue (January, 7) pp: 7- Comparing Domestic and Foreign Tourists Economic Impact in Desert Triangle of Rajasthan Mala
More informationImpact Evaluation of a Cluster Program: An Application of Synthetic Control Methods. Diego Aboal*, Gustavo Crespi** and Marcelo Perera* *CINVE **IDB
Impact Evaluation of a Cluster Program: An Application of Synthetic Control Methods Diego Aboal*, Gustavo Crespi** and Marcelo Perera* *CINVE **IDB Impact Evaluation of a Cluster Program Roadmap 1. Motivation
More informationFormer Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia (FYROM)
Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia (FYROM) Tourism in the economy Tourism directly contributed MKD 6.4 billion or 1.3% of GDP in 2013, and accounted for 3.3% of total employment. Estimates for 2014
More informationThe Economic Impact of Tourism in: Dane County & Madison, Wisconsin. April 2017
The Economic Impact of Tourism in: Dane County & Madison, Wisconsin April 2017 Key themes for 2016 Visitor spending continued growing in Dane County, Wisconsin in 2016, growing 5.2% to surpass $1.2 billion.
More informationThe Economic Impact of Tourism Brighton & Hove Prepared by: Tourism South East Research Unit 40 Chamberlayne Road Eastleigh Hampshire SO50 5JH
The Economic Impact of Tourism Brighton & Hove 2014 Prepared by: Tourism South East Research Unit 40 Chamberlayne Road Eastleigh Hampshire SO50 5JH CONTENTS 1. Summary of Results 1 1.1 Introduction 1 1.2
More informationEvolution of Cultural Heritage Portfolio in MNA A Multi Faceted Approach
URBAN DEVELOPMENT Evolution of Cultural Heritage Portfolio in MNA A Multi Faceted Approach Urban Week,January 31, 2011 Chantal Reliquet, Sr. Urban Specialist 1 World Bank Lending in Historic City Regeneration
More informationThe Economic Impact of Tourism in Maryland. Tourism Satellite Account Calendar Year 2015
The Economic Impact of Tourism in Maryland Tourism Satellite Account Calendar Year 2015 MD tourism economy reaches new peaks The Maryland visitor economy continued to grow in 2015; tourism industry sales
More informationSustainable Pro-poor Community-based Tourism in Thailand
Chapter 6 Sustainable Pro-poor Community-based Tourism in Thailand Komsan Suriya Faculty of Economics, Chiang Mai University E-mail: suriyakomsan@yahoo.co.th This study investigates tourism income distribution
More informationInformation concerning the change in the cockpit access regulation
Information concerning the change in the cockpit access regulation German airlines will once again put the original access control regulation into effect and this will be supplemented by additional safety
More informationPRIMA Open Online Public Consultation
PRIMA Open Online Public Consultation Short Summary Report Published on 1 June 2016 Research and Introduction Objective of the consultation: to collect views and opinions on the scope, objectives, and
More informationThe Economic Impact of Tourism New Forest Prepared by: Tourism South East Research Unit 40 Chamberlayne Road Eastleigh Hampshire SO50 5JH
The Economic Impact of Tourism New Forest 2008 Prepared by: Tourism South East Research Unit 40 Chamberlayne Road Eastleigh Hampshire SO50 5JH CONTENTS Glossary of terms 1 1. Summary of Results 4 2. Table
More informationEconomic Impacts of Campgrounds in New York State
Economic Impacts of Campgrounds in New York State June 2017 Report Submitted to: Executive Summary Executive Summary New York State is home to approximately 350 privately owned campgrounds with 30,000
More informationTUI Travel Sustainability Survey 2010
TUI Travel Sustainability Survey 2010 Group Marketing TUI Travel International Consumer Research TUI Travel PLC International Consumer Research 15/03/2010 Page 1 Objectives Create international factbase
More informationThe results of the National Tourism Development Strategy Assessments
The results of the National Tourism Development Strategy Assessments - 2012 (I) The assessment tool In 2012 the Sustainable Tourism Working Group of the CEEweb for Biodiversity prepared a guidance for
More informationThe Economic Impact of Tourism in Maryland. Tourism Satellite Account Calendar Year 2016
The Economic Impact of Tourism in Maryland Tourism Satellite Account Calendar Year 2016 County Results Washington County, Visitors Washington County Visitors (thousands) Year Overnight Day Total Growth
More informationCRUISE ACTIVITY IN BARCELONA. Impact on the Catalan economy and socioeconomic profile of cruise passengers (2014)
CRUISE ACTIVITY IN BARCELONA Impact on the Catalan economy and socioeconomic profile of cruise passengers (2014) 2 CRUISE ACTIVITY IN BARCELONA 2014 Impact on the Catalan economy and socioeconomic profile
More informationYUKON TOURISM DEVELOPMENT STRATEGY GROWING TOURISM. OUR FUTURE. OUR PATH.
YUKON TOURISM DEVELOPMENT STRATEGY GROWING TOURISM. OUR FUTURE. OUR PATH. Tourism in Yukon WHAT DOES TOURISM CONTRIBUTE TO THE YUKON ECONOMY? Tourism is a major contributor to the local economy, responsible
More informationREAUTHORISATION OF THE ALLIANCE BETWEEN AIR NEW ZEALAND AND CATHAY PACIFIC
Chair Cabinet Economic Growth and Infrastructure Committee Office of the Minister of Transport REAUTHORISATION OF THE ALLIANCE BETWEEN AIR NEW ZEALAND AND CATHAY PACIFIC Proposal 1. I propose that the
More informationTHE FESTIVALS AS A TOOL ON OHRID TOURISM DESTINATION BRANDING
Review (accepted July 13, 2013) THE FESTIVALS AS A TOOL ON OHRID TOURISM DESTINATION BRANDING Zoran Strezovski 1 Sasko Gramatnikovski Abstract: The main aim of the paper is about festivals in the southern
More informationBalearic Islands Good Practices
Balearic Islands Good Practices Marga Picornell Balearic Islands Tourism Board (ATB) 24th October, 2017 Palma de Mallorca (ES) Balearic Islands Good Practices BETTER IN WINTER promotional strategy Sustainable
More informationThe Economic Impact of Tourism in The Appalachian Region of Ohio. June 2014
The Economic Impact of Tourism in The Appalachian Region of Ohio June 2014 Appalachia Region Tourism Summary Total Tourism Impact Appalachian Region Sales Wages Taxes Employment $4.9 billion $1.2 billion
More informationMEETING CONCLUSIONS. Andean South America Regional Meeting Lima, Peru 5-7 March ECOTOURISM PLANNING
MEETING CONCLUSIONS Andean South America Regional Meeting Lima, Peru 5-7 March 2002 1.0 ECOTOURISM PLANNING 1.1 Protected Areas Ecotourism in Protected Areas is part of an integrated vision of tourism
More informationWhale Watching Tourism in the Kingdom of Tonga
Whale Watching Tourism in the Kingdom of Tonga Preliminary Report for the Pacific Islands Forum October 2007 A report for the International Fund for Animal Welfare and Opérations Cétacés Prepared by: Introduction:
More informationTHEORY OF CHANGE. Kigali, Rwanda 10 March 2014
THEORY OF CHANGE Kigali, Rwanda 10 March 2014 Outline 1. Introduction to theory of change 2. Building a theory of change in 7 steps Outline 1. Introduction to theory of change 2. Building a theory of change
More informationThe Economic Impact of Tourism in The Appalachian Region of Ohio. June 2016
The Economic Impact of Tourism in The Appalachian Region of Ohio June 2016 Appalachian Region tourism summary Total Tourism Impact Appalachian Region, Ohio Sales Wages Taxes Employment $5.3 billion $1.3
More informationPUHOI TO PAKIRI VISITOR SURVEY UPDATE. ( Simon Milne New Zealand Tourism Research Institute
PUHOI TO PAKIRI VISITOR SURVEY UPDATE (www.regionalsurveys.co.nz) Simon Milne New Zealand Tourism Research Institute 1 There are three partners in this research - all contributing time, money, energy and
More informationHaworth Tr T avel Plan r 10th February 2006
Haworth Travel Plan 10th February 2006 Haworth Travel Plan has been prepared for: Contents 1 Why have Haworth Travel Plan?... 3 2 Who will benefit from Haworth Travel Plan?... 4 3 What actions will be
More informationThe Economic Contributions of Agritourism in New Jersey
The Economic Contributions of Agritourism in New Jersey Bulletin E333 Cooperative Extension Brian J. Schilling, Extension Specialist in Agricultural Policy Kevin P. Sullivan, Institutional Research Analyst
More informationACTION PLAN FOR THE PERIOD concerning the STRATEGY ON IMPLEMENTATION OF THE FRAMEWORK AGREEMENT ON THE SAVA RIVER BASIN
Doc. 1S-26-O-11-5/1-2 ACTION PLAN FOR THE PERIOD 2011-2015 concerning the STRATEGY ON IMPLEMENTATION OF THE FRAMEWORK AGREEMENT ON THE SAVA RIVER BASIN April 2011 Table of Contents INTRODUCTION... 5 1.
More informationState Aid to Airlines and Airports. Niamh McCarthy Kings College 8 October 2013
State Aid to Airlines and Airports Niamh McCarthy Kings College 8 October 2013 Timely Questions Why is there so much aid to National carriers? Where is the demand for airport infrastructure? The Davies
More informationCase of SMEs in the tourism sector of Fogo, Cape Verde
Case of SMEs in the tourism sector of Fogo, Cape Verde Amdework Dilnessaw State University of Bergamo 1 Table of Content Back ground Objective of the research Scope & Limitation Data & Methodology Value
More informationRegional Tourism Satellite Accounts (RTSA) in Austria
Peter Laimer Directorate Spatial Statistics CIS countries and Georgia Workshop III (Session 1) 10-12 June 2013 Baku/Azerbaijan Regional Tourism Satellite Accounts (RTSA) in Austria Methods, data sources,
More informationSlum Situation Analysis
Slum Situation Analysis Components of a slum upgrading programme 1. SLUM SITUATION ANALYSIS 2. REVIEW OF POLICIES AFFECTING SLUM AREAS 3. SLUM UPGRADING AND PREVENTION STRATEGY 4. RESOURCE MOBILISATION
More informationThe Economic Impact of Travel in Kansas. Tourism Satellite Account Calendar Year 2013
The Economic Impact of Travel in Kansas Tourism Satellite Account Calendar Year 2013 Who we are Tourism Economics Union of industry expertise and economic disciplines Real world insights based on quantitative
More informationRESIDENTS PERCEPTION OF TOURISM DEVELOPMENT: A CASE STUDY WITH REFERENCE TO COORG DISTRICT IN KARNATAKA
RESIDENTS PERCEPTION OF TOURISM DEVELOPMENT: A CASE STUDY WITH REFERENCE TO COORG DISTRICT IN KARNATAKA Mr. Sukhesh P H.O.D., Department of Commerce Govt., First Grade College, Karnataka State, India.
More informationThe Economic Impact of Tourism on Galveston Island, Texas Analysis
The Economic Impact of Tourism on Galveston Island, Texas 2012 Analysis Headline Results Headline results Tourism is a significant contributor to business sales, employment, and taxes on Galveston Island.
More informationIndicators of Sustainable Development for Tourism Destinations
Indicators of Sustainable Development for Tourism Destinations Dr. Ted Manning Lead Expert WTO Indicators Program President, Tourisk Inc. Ottawa Canada Washington DC 2004 Dolomites Italy Tourism is at
More informationGambling Tourism in PNG- A Grace or a Curse?: Implications of the Proposed Casino Gambling as Perceived by the Community
Gambling Tourism in PNG- A Grace or a Curse?: Implications of the Proposed Casino Gambling as Perceived by the Community Dr. Joyce Rayel Mr. Ponnusamy Manohar Ms. Imelda Atu Mr. Ronal Raka PRESENTATION
More informationAn Analysis of Communication, Navigation and Surveillance Equipment Safety Performance
An Analysis of Communication, Navigation and Surveillance Equipment Safety Performance Phulele Nomtshongwana and Krige Visser Graduate School of Technology Management, University of Pretoria www.saama.org.za
More informationGold Coast: Modelled Future PIA Queensland Awards for Planning Excellence 2014 Nomination under Cutting Edge Research category
Gold Coast: Modelled Future PIA Queensland Awards for Planning Excellence 2014 Nomination under Cutting Edge Research category Jointly nominated by SGS Economics and Planning and City of Gold Coast August
More informationTourism Impacts and Second Home Development in Pender County: A Sustainable Approach
Tourism Impacts and Second Home Development in Pender County: A Sustainable Approach (Funded by North Carolina Sea Grant) Center for Sustainable Tourism Division of Research and Graduate Studies East Carolina
More informationPutting Museums on the Tourist Itinerary: Museums and Tour Operators in Partnership making the most out of Tourism
1 of 5 ICME papers 2002 Putting Museums on the Tourist Itinerary: Museums and Tour Operators in Partnership making the most out of Tourism By Clare Mateke Livingstone Museum, P O Box 60498, Livingstone,
More informationCruise tourism in Akaroa: Visitor experiences, business stakeholder perceptions, and community attitudes Michael Shone & Jude Wilson 31 July 2013
Cruise tourism in Akaroa: Visitor experiences, business stakeholder perceptions, and community attitudes Michael Shone & Jude Wilson 31 July 2013 Part A: Cruise ship visitor experiences and expenditure,
More informationAmerican Hotel Investors for Cuban Economic Growth SAMPLE. eased certain restrictions. In 2009, President Obama eased the travel ban by allowing
Disclaimer: This document and the content on it has nothing to do with the brand. The content is the opinion of the author and was created as part of a class assignment American Hotel Investors for Cuban
More informationObjectives of the study:
Introduction: Tourism is a fast growing industry in Kerala. It has come to occupy a prominent place in the economy of this costal state that its future prosperity is inextricably bound with this tantalizing
More informationThe Economic Impact of Tourism on Guam. Tourism Satellite Account Calendar Year 2016
The Economic Impact of Tourism on Guam Tourism Satellite Account Calendar Year 2016 Highlights! 2016 was a banner year for tourism on Guam, with visitation to Guam surpassing 1.5 million and visitor spending
More informationHEALTH SECTOR ECONOMIC INDICATORS REPORT
HEALTH SECTOR ECONOMIC INDICATORS REPORT For: Mid North Coast Local Health District Report prepared by: April 2013 Table of Contents Introduction 3 Executive Summary 4 Output 5 Value-Added 7 Workforce
More informationESTIMATION OF ECONOMIC IMPACTS FOR AIRPORTS IN HAWTHORNE, EUREKA, AND ELY, NEVADA
TECHNICAL REPORT UCED 97/98-14 ESTIMATION OF ECONOMIC IMPACTS FOR AIRPORTS IN HAWTHORNE, EUREKA, AND ELY, NEVADA UNIVERSITY OF NEVADA, RENO ESTIMATION OF ECONOMIC IMPACTS FOR AIRPORTS IN HAWTHORNE, EUREKA
More informationAIR Citizen s Summary
w w w.ip a- cb c- 00 7. eu C om pe tit i ve ne ss To u ris m En vi ro nm en t Programme co-funded by the EUROPEAN UNION Ms. Corina Crețu, Commissioner for Regional Policy said: "I am pleased to adopt this
More informationVietnam Marine Protected Area Management Effectiveness Evaluation
Vietnam Marine Protected Area Management Effectiveness Evaluation 5 th EAS Congress (16-21 November, 2015) Bui Thi Thu Hien IUCN Viet Nam Marine Protected Areas: Global Status There are over 161,000 protected
More informationThe Economic Impact of Travel in Minnesota Analysis
The Economic Impact of Travel in Minnesota 2013 Analysis Overview 2013 Highlights Traveler Spending Traveler spending of $10.3 billion generated $17.6 billion in total business sales in 2013 as travel
More informationConcept Note. And Call for Papers
Concept Note And Call for Papers SWAZILAND ECONOMIC CONFERENCE 2017 Economic Recovery and Sustainable Growth in Swaziland Mbabane, Swaziland, October 25 27, 2017 The Swaziland Economic Policy Analysis
More informationPublic Disclosure Copy
Public Disclosure Authorized AFRICA Ethiopia Trade & Competitiveness Global Practice IBRD/IDA Specific Investment Loan FY 2009 Seq No: 14 ARCHIVED on 21-Dec-2015 ISR20896 Implementing Agencies: Public
More information(Also known as the Den-Ice Agreements Program) Evaluation & Advisory Services. Transport Canada
Evaluation of Transport Canada s Program of Payments to Other Government or International Agencies for the Operation and Maintenance of Airports, Air Navigation, and Airways Facilities (Also known as the
More informationEconomic Valuation of Heritage- Related Investments: A Case Study from China
Economic Valuation of Heritage- Related Investments: A Case Study from China By Jian Xie The World Bank jxie@worldbank.org Requirements for Economic Analysis in Investment Projects At the World Bank, there
More informationJAL Group Announces its FY Medium-Term Business Plan
JAL Group Announces its FY2006-2010 Medium-Term Business Plan -Mobilize the Group s Strengths to Regain Trust - Tokyo, Thursday March 2, 2006: The JAL Group today announced its medium-term business plan
More informationCoffs Coast Visitor Profile and Satisfaction Report: Summary and Discussion of Results
Coffs Coast Visitor Profile and Satisfaction Report: Summary and Discussion of Results Introduction The Coffs Coast Visitor Profile and Satisfaction (VPS) project was completed as part of the Destination
More informationTOURISM AS AN ECONOMIC ENGINE FOR GREATER PHILADELPHIA
TOURISM AS AN ECONOMIC ENGINE FOR GREATER PHILADELPHIA 2015 Visitation and Economic Impact Report FINAL REPORT SUBMITTED TO: VISIT PHILADELPHIA 30 S. 17 th St, Suite 2010 Philadelphia, PA 19103 FINAL REPORT
More information3.0 LEARNING FROM CHATHAM-KENT S CITIZENS
3.0 LEARNING FROM CHATHAM-KENT S CITIZENS An important aspect in developing the Chatham-Kent Trails Master Plan was to obtain input from stakeholders and the general public. Throughout the course of the
More informationThe Challenges for the European Tourism Sustainable
The Challenges for the European Tourism Sustainable Denada Olli Lecturer at Fan S. Noli University, Faculty of Economy, Department of Marketing, Branch Korça, Albania. Doi:10.5901/mjss.2013.v4n9p464 Abstract
More information