Reimagining the Gorge Project

Transcription

1 Reimagining the Gorge Project A future vision for Cataract Gorge Reserve and Trevallyn Nature Reserve Green Paper April 2015 Definition of green paper: a tentative report and consultation document of proposals for debate and discussion, without any commitment to action. This green paper is informed by stakeholder workshops and community consultation results. Table of Contents Project background... 2 Group compositions... 3 Project reference group... 3 Whole system groups... 3 Design Team... 4 The case for change... 4 Vision objectives... 5 Engagement... 5 Project Reference Group - Planning to Plan Workshop... 5 Surveying young people... 5 Enquiry by Design (EbD) Process... 6 The visioning workshop... 6 Shaping the draft vision... 7 The presentation and feedback session... 7 The draft vision... 7 Draft Vision Guiding principles... 8 The Themes and Responses... 9 Themes and responses in detail... 9 Getting opinion Your Voice Your Launceston: Broader community Unedited comments from the online survey sorted by theme Survey of neighbouring properties Comparison of the online and neighbour surveys Unedited neighbour comments sorted by theme... 27

2 Reimagining the Gorge draft green paper March Additional comments from the owners of adjoining properties The findings and potential design responses Theme 1 Governance Theme 2 Environmental Management Theme 3: Access and Linkages Theme 4: Maintenance and amenities Theme 5: Interpretation, information and promotion Theme 6: Events Theme 7: Accommodation Theme 8: Other developments Next steps How to comment Project contact Project background Perhaps the most unique natural feature of Launceston Cataract Gorge is also the emotional centre of the city for many residents and an astounding discovery for visitors. The Tasmanian State Government committed funding to develop a renewed vision for the Gorge and an architectural approach in planning for developments. The project study area includes the Cataract Gorge Reserve managed by Council and the Trevallyn Nature Recreation Area (TNRA) managed by the Tasmanian Parks and Wildlife Service. The Cataract Gorge Reserve has an area of 192 hectares and the TNRA 440 hectares. Combined they provide 632 hectares of public parkland in close proximity to the Launceston city centre. The Cataract Gorge Reserve includes: Cliff Grounds, Cataract Walk, Fairy Dell and Gorge restaurant Duck Reach power station Caretaker s Cottage at Kings Bridge First Basin area including the pool and café Basin Cottage Lookouts Chair lift Suspension bridge The TNRA includes: Aquatic Point and Lake Trevallyn Hoo Hoo Hut BBQ area and Village Green Churinga Archery Club Mountain bike trails Orienteering courses Equestrian areas Paths and walking trails leading in, out and around. The project is about creating a vision for the study area. It is NOT a master plan Reimagining the Cataract Gorge aims to develop a vision, with associated concepts and potential projects to

3 Reimagining the Gorge draft green paper March realise the preferred community future for the study area. It will inform future planning for the study area. It is a joint project of the City of Launceston, Tasmanian Government and Tourism Northern Tasmania and is overseen by a Project Team with the following membership: Chair - Harry Galea Director Infrastructure Services City of Launceston Project Manager Andrew Smith Manager Parks and Recreation City of Launceston Chris Colley, Regional Manager North, Tasmania Parks and Wildlife Service Cindy Hanson, Regional Manager North, Department of State Growth Chris Griffin, CEO Tourism Northern Tasmania The Project Team appointed the following consultant team to help develop the vision Campbell and Jones experience in community engagement around design processes, (the nominated approach outlined in the project s expression of interest document). Cumulus Studio experience in the development of master plans and design concepts Lange Design experience in landscape architecture and recreational outcomes The tender documents outlined the following deliverables: 1. A communication plan for the overall project and consultancy 2. Community engagement to identify wider community views 3. Report on community expectations 4. A report to the Project Team on the draft vision & findings. 5. Creative design solutions to support & implement new vision 6. Final report including concepts and recommendations. Group compositions A number of groups have been involved in guiding the development of the vision. Project reference group Key stakeholder groups as outlined in the consultancy brief and including the Project Steering Group and representatives from the local Aboriginal Community, Cataract Gorge Advisory Committee, Tourism Northern Tasmania, Tasmanian Parks and Wildlife Service, Department of Sport and Recreation, Friends of Trevallyn Reserve, Heritage Protection Society, Department of State Growth, Hydro Tasmania, City Prom, Launceston Chamber of Commerce, Launceston Mountain Bike Club, Canoe Tasmania, Mountain Bike and Rock Climbing Tasmania and added to this Businesses in and adjacent to the study area. Whole system groups The whole system for the study area includes all those groups who will influence or be influenced by the vision. The whole system groupings were identified and agreed by participants during the Project Reference Group Workshop. Whole system groups for the study area The local Aboriginal Community Volunteers Businesses relevant to the area Cataract Gorge Protection Society Neighbours* Government agencies relevant to the Education area Friends of the Gorge and TNRA Heritage and Science Tourism industry Recreational users Please note: Neighbours in this list refers to neighbouring councils on the management of the study area. The Launceston City Council manages the Gorge and the Tasmania Government, the TNRA. The TNRA falls within three local government areas each with its own planning zones. The neighbours survey, which followed the EbD, referred to those people living around the study area. Following discussions with adjacent property owners the definition of neighbours has been expanded to include them.

4 Reimagining the Gorge draft green paper March Design Team Made up of consultants from Cumulus Studio and Lange Designs; the Project Steering Group members; Council personnel with expertise in recreational planning, natural resource management, traffic engineering, landscape architecture. The case for change The Cataract Gorge has a greater % of Tasmania s visitors than Freycinet or Cradle Mountain. So what is the case for change? Why develop a vision? The study area sits at the heart of the Launceston community. There is a strong connection to place from those who live here and those who visit. The events most held in the area are weddings. The Cataract Gorge has a greater % share of all Tasmania s visitors than Freycinet National Park and Cradle Mountain. Share of Tasmanian visitation July 2010 to June 2011 July 2011 to June 2012 July 2012 to June 2013 July 2013 to June 2014 Gorge % share of Tasmania 22% 18% 18% 21% Mona % share of Tasmania N/A 24% 24% 28% Freycinet % share of Tasmania 19% 17% 15% 18% Mount W % share of Tasmania 22% 20% 22% 22% Cradle % share of Tasmania 21% 19% 16% 17% Launceston % share of Tasmania 49% 44% 41% 41% Source Tasmanian Visitor survey So what is the case for change? Why develop a vision? These questions were put to the Project Reference Group at the initial October workshop,. Their response, and therefore the case for change in the development of a vision, was around four tensions. Tensions are not about but between. With the study area, the tensions are between wanting to Protect and preserve the natural and cultural values of the area AND maximising potential opportunities; Make the area a tourism driver, a core reason people come to the City, Region and State AND not compromising its integrity and character; Meaningfully acknowledge the local Aboriginal people and their connection to this place AND maintaining government management of the area; Maintain the areas to the standard needed and deserved as the City s key community and tourism place AND competing financial priorities; Amidst these tensions, what can a vision do? A vision can provide a description of the preferred future what the study area could and should be like as we move towards It can help facilitate agreement, certainty and confidence in decision-making. Without it, responses tend to be reactive. With a vision, they are more proactive.

5 Reimagining the Gorge draft green paper March A vision is long-term in its outlook and allows for the alignment of decisions and actions towards achieving it. Vision objectives At the Project Reference Group Workshop, the vision objectives were outlined and agreed: The vision for the Cataract Gorge Reserve and TNRA should: Unite and excite people regarding the future potential of the area; Help preserve and protect the natural and cultural values while accommodating increased visitation to the area; Maintain the integrity and character of this place for future generations; Remain relevant to an increasingly diverse society. These objectives were summarised in the following key message, which was used in all project communications. Strengthen our connection to this place: Make the most of our future. Engagement Around 341 people contributed to the development of the draft vision Project Reference Group - Planning to Plan Workshop It was held at Aurora Stadium on October 1 st 2014 and involved 34 people representative of the communities of interest for the study area The group examined the present situation for the study area and developed: Potential challenges and opportunities for the area The case for change and vision objectives Key communication message; The whole system groups to be represented at the Enquiry by Design (EbD) process Initial themes and issues to be further tested during this further engagement. Surveying young people A student survey was recommended and organised through the then Launceston City Council s Youth Development Officer. 244 young people between the age of 13 and 19 responded to the survey. Over half (50.8%) were 17 years old. Residential locations were widespread from both within and out of the City area. The Gorge is visited most frequently with 58% of respondents going weekly and monthly. By contrast 58% of respondents had never been to the TNRA. Walking, swimming, being with friends and picnicking are the most popular activities in both areas. There is a wider range of activities undertaken in the TNRA by those who know it is there.

6 Reimagining the Gorge draft green paper March Gorge Activities % TNRA Activities % Walk 27.7 Walk 17.9 Be with friends 26.9 Swim 14.2 Swim 25.8 Be with friends 12.7 Picnic BBQ 6.6 Picnic BBQ 12.3 Eat out 6.6 Boating / canoeing 10.8 Running jogging 2.1 Dog Walking 9.4 Rock climbing abseiling 1.7 Water ski 8.5 Cable Hang gliding 2.4 Mountain biking 2.4 Archery 1.9 Horse riding 1.4 Orienteering 1.4 The First Basin is the favourite place in the Gorge. This includes the pool, river, rocky shorelines and the Basin Café. The walking tracks and lookouts are popular with the Zig Zag track most frequently mentioned. The favourite place in the TNRA is the body of water referred to as the Trevallyn Dam and its associated facilities. The Hoo Hoo Hut picnic area, walking tracks and mountain bike trails are also popular. Free access, natural environment and the opportunities to socialise with family and friends were positively mentioned in relation to both areas. Not being able to play ball games, anti social behaviour by some groups and general upkeep in popular areas were listed as the greatest detraction to the Gorge experience. A general lack of knowledge about the TNRA is affecting visitation and usage. Occasionally water quality in the dam, South Esk River and First Basin is a problem for water-based activities. More recreational activities for young people were seen as desirable additions to both areas. Examples included chess playing, table tennis, slamball courts, bike hire, baseball hitting cages, down hill trails, water drinking stations and a flying fox. More undercover picnic areas with shade and associated seating were mentioned. Being allowed to play ball games was a constant theme as was a range of more affordable food options. For both areas, the Gorge in particular, there is a high level of positive ownership by young people. Enquiry by Design (EbD) Process The aim of the EbD was to: Test and explore the outputs from the Reference Group Workshop; Shape a draft vision response words and concepts; Get initial feedback from workshop participants and Adjust the written vision before release to the broader community. There were three parts to the EbD undertaken over three consecutive days: The visioning workshop This was a full day workshop held Tuesday, November 28 th, involving 63 people representative of the whole system around the study area and its activities. All whole system groups as previously described were represented. During this workshop, the following activities were undertaken: Exploration of the present situation internal and external perspectives Preferred future aspirations to be included in the vision Input into four specific aspects. Movement and Connection: How could and should we move in to, out of and around this place?

7 Reimagining the Gorge draft green paper March Experiences, Activities and Events: How could and should we accommodate and support the experiences activities and events people want to have now and in the future? Identity and Reputation: How could and should we express cultural identify, highlight uniqueness, raise awareness and build the reputation of this place? Possible Game Changers: Ideas you think will make a big difference to this place. Shaping the draft vision The Project Steering Group and Design Team (consultants and Council officers with expertise in recreation planning, natural resource management and interpretation) shaped the draft vision. The documents that guided the process included the outputs from the Project Reference Group and Visioning Workshops as well as the project s governing documents, namely: All relevant legislation All relevant planning schemes The Cataract Gorge Conservation Management Plan The Trevallyn Nature Recreation Area Management Plan 2008 Tasmanian Heritage Register Projects from the 2004 Business Plan already underway - Upgrade of the Basin Cottage - Redevelopment of the Stone Hut in the First Basin - BBQ development at First Basin The young persons survey results The presentation and feedback session This was the final part of the EbD process. The draft vision and associated concepts were presented to 30 people on the night of Thursday, November 30 th. The group included workshop participants and other whole system representatives who were unable to attend the EbD workshop. The draft vision The draft vision has been shaped using the outputs of both workshops and includes: A preferred future statement - a description of what the study area should be in Guiding principles - to help guide future choice and decision-making. Seven themes plus a catch-all-other theme, which included some development ideas raised at the workshop. 38 possible responses, within the eight themes, developed through the workshop participants. A number of design concepts to expand thinking about the workshop responses.

8 Reimagining the Gorge draft green paper March Draft Vision 2030 The Preferred Future for the Cataract Gorge Reserve and Trevallyn Nature Recreation Area (Note: The vision is written in the present tense as if it is 2030.) The Greater Cataract Gorge: An Aboriginal Place Illuminating our stories, both ancient and new Connecting YOU to OUR backyard The Greater Cataract Gorge: An Aboriginal Place There is a human history here over 40,000 years old. Today the Aboriginal Community bring to this place Knowledge and understanding of how it should be managed nurtured and enjoyed. The Greater Cataract Gorge, 632 hectares in the middle of our city, Is an opportunity to discover a sense of place, significant to us all. Illuminating our stories, both ancient and new From this place we can interpret our past and discover a deeper meaning of who we are. The stories of the powerful forces that shaped the landscape; The stories of the Aboriginals and their engagement with the land sky and water The newer, more recent stories of other peoples Who shaped, and were in turn shaped, by this place that became their home. Today s stories describe how the Gorge is part of everyday life, Influencing how we live and how we feel about living here. They are also of the experiences of those who visit our City and Island. We have all heard You have all this so close to your City Remarkable! Connecting YOU to OUR backyard The Greater Cataract Gorge is our backyard And wherever you are from, you re welcome to come and play. You can walk, hike, skate, swim, climb, glide or paddle At whatever level of adventure and excitement you want. You can celebrate with friends, learn our stories, Or just sit and Be. In the Greater Cataract Gorge you create your own memories and stories Each and every time you connect to this special place. Guiding principles To guide future behaviour and choices In the future we will: Be Respectful To the landscape and its significance By doing today, with both yesterday and tomorrow in mind. We will do as much as is necessary and as little as possible To secure the natural and cultural values of this place Collaborate and Work Together To realise our opportunities and tackle our challenges Be Open, have Confidence and Back Ourselves It s up to us, as a community, to make sure we Strengthen our connection to this place And make the most of our future.

9 Reimagining the Gorge draft green paper March The Themes and Responses To achieve the vision, responses will be developed within the following eight themes 1. Governance 2. Environmental Management 3. Access and Linkages 4. Maintenance and amenities 5. Interpretation, Information and Promotion 6. Events 7. Accommodation 8. Other developments Themes and responses in detail Each theme is described below with the suggested responses from the workshop process. Theme 1: Governance Key issues: Aboriginal Reconciliation: Prior to European arrival, Tasmanian Aboriginal people lived in the area. There have been several surveys of Aboriginal heritage in the Greater Cataract Gorge and at least eleven artifact sites and extensive scatters recorded on the Tasmanian Aboriginal Site Index. This is a story, which has not yet been told. Without it we are unable to fully understand and connect to the past and therefore cannot move into the future with confidence. Management: Launceston City Council manages the Gorge and the Tasmanian Government through the Department of Parks and Wildlife manages the TNRA. The TNRA falls within three local government areas, each with its own planning zones. Other organisations with interests in the area are TasWater, Hydro, MAST and Tas Fire Service. Governance is closely linked to management and maintenance of the combined area. The current situation works against whole of area planning. Models need to be explored that will facilitate aboriginal reconciliation, efficient use of resources, cooperation between all the stakeholder organisations and a whole of area view. Possible responses for consideration 1.1 Involve the Aboriginal Community in the management of the Gorge and TNRA 1.2 Create a Single Authority and Aboriginal ownership 1.3 One name for the combined area 1.4 Joint Aboriginal and English names for the entire area 1.5 Volunteers to work across both areas 1.6 Reference Group to meet annually, so a sound understanding of issues and needs is maintained 1.7 Key stakeholders to continue to work together around projects

10 Reimagining the Gorge draft green paper March Theme 2: Environmental management Key Issues: Water quality and flow: The major environmental issue in both the Gorge and TNRA is poor water quality caused by pollutants including bacteria, nutrients and sediments. Poor water quality, particularly from bacteria, can limit the use of the waterway for recreational activities. In summer, it is not uncommon to close the river for recreation due to public health risks. Visitation declines when water quality is poor. This is detrimental to businesses as well as the City s reputation. Improving water quality is a significant issue that will require cooperation and collaboration from all levels of government, their agencies and the area s neighbours. Natural Resource Management North and TasWater are presently developing plans, which will help guide and inform the response to improving water quality. Also many people would like to see increased water flow down the Gorge. Fire management: Living close to such a large expanse of bush land carries the risk of fire. Currently, consultants are revising the Bush Fire Management Strategy for all Council owned or managed bush land areas. In the next financial year the Cataract Gorge Fire Management Plan will be revised to address a range of issues including climate change impacts, bushfire risks, vegetation management and risk reduction strategies. Feral Animals: Feral cats, domestic ducks and other feral animals are occasionally sighted in the Reserve. These are considered a hazard to the natural wildlife and natural values of the area. Current interventions are aimed at removing these animals where possible. Control of Weeds: The Green Army has commenced working on a weed management program for the Gorge. In addition there is a range of other groups undertaking weed control programs. Other groups include volunteers, employees and contractors. It is ongoing and unending. Effects of Climate Change: The potential effects of climate change on the environment need monitoring. Dumped rubbish: Rubbish is presently being dumped in the area and this needs to stop. Possible responses for consideration 2.1 Improve river water quality 2.2 Achieve increased water flow through the First Basin. 2.3 Raise awareness of fire management plans and what people can do to minimise risk 2.4 Support the Green Army to eradicate weeds in the area 2.5 Continue to control the removal of feral animals 2.6 Stop people dumping rubbish in the area 2.7 Monitor the effects of climate change Theme 3: Access and Linkages Key issues: Access in to and around the area, as well as linkages to other precincts and developments around Kings Bridge is an issue. Presently the main car and visitor entrance to the Gorge is via the First Basin Car Park. There is limited car parking on the Cliff Grounds side. The main pedestrian access to the Gorge is via Kings Bridge, which has to accommodate cars and bikes as well, all within a very narrow space. Vehicle access to the TNRA is via Reatta Road, which meanders through suburban streets and without local knowledge, finding your way is challenging. Walking tracks provide the interface between the Gorge and TNRA. Again, a fair amount of local knowledge is needed to easily access the area. There are also calls for bike tracks to link the City and TNRA and also the two sides of the Gorge. Urban development round the area is influencing access and linkages. The growth in housing on the area s West Tamar side has seen an increase in vehicle traffic as residents travel into the City via the narrow Kings Bridge. A whole of city approach is needed to link precincts. People also need safe access points into the combined area. People with disabilities need fully accessible walking tracks and strategies are needed to reduce reliance on motor vehicles to access the area. Possible responses for consideration 3.1 Implement a way finding system for cars, cyclists and pedestrians 3.2 Make Kings Bridge the major pedestrian access point to the area. 3.3 Provide a hop on hop off bus for visitors 3.4 Build a stairway track for mountain bike riders to connect the City, Gorge and TNRA. 3.5 Explore potential across linkages for bike riders 3.6 Build a boardwalk from the Swinging Bridge to the First Basin to make the loop around the First Basin fully accessible

11 Reimagining the Gorge draft green paper March Theme 4: Maintenance and amenities Key Issues: This issue is linked to governance and a whole of area view. Maintaining the landscape and associated infrastructure makes and maintains the sense of place for both areas. Some infrastructure is wearing out and looking tired. There is budget pressure on maintenance and a need to generate income that can be used to help maintain standards. Built infrastructure is more extensive in the Gorge than in the TNRA. The Launceston City Council presently spends around $900,000 per annum on maintaining its areas of responsibility. Parks and Wildlife allocate around $19,000 per annum for the TNRA. New infrastructure is also needed to meet changing recreational trends and uses e.g. mountain bike tracks. Additional amenities could include, drinking fountains, shade, toilets, power outlets, way finding approaches and quiet spaces for reflection. Possible responses for consideration 4.1 Fund a maintenance program for the First Basin and Cliff Grounds that strengthens its role as a significant visitor experience for the State 4.2 Establish water stations throughout the area 4.3 Provide shade to the pool area during summer 4.4 Develop an amenities program for the TNRA (power, toilets etc.) that will support future activities and events. 4.5 Design and build thinking and reflective places throughout the area Theme 5: Interpretation, Information and Promotion Key Issues: Prior to European arrival, the Tasmanian Aboriginal people lived in the area. This essential story is yet to be told. Without it, we are only telling a part of the entire living story of the place. Visitors need information on the area so they know how to get to it and access all that it offers. They also want to make sense of the place through interpretation. Signage has been used in the past but is often vandalised and expensive to replace. Digital access to information for interpretation is now commonplace. Technology can create self-guided walks for visitors. However guided walks provide a richer connection to the place and its stories. This should be supported and delivered by the Aboriginal Community if possible along with other guiding professionals. Creating a nighttime interpretation event in the Gorge would not only add to a deeper connection to place and all its stories but provide visitors with a reason to stay overnight in the City. We need to tell all the stories about this place social, cultural, environmental and geological. It has many layers. Possible responses for consideration 5.1 Tell all the stories of the area using either built interpretation or technology. 5.2 Provide technology based self guided interpretation and information 5.3 Establish guided experiences for the area 5.4 Create a major night time, light interpretation experience that tells all the stories of the area Theme 6: Events Key Issues: Council records show that 185 events were held or are booked for the Gorge between 2011 and Most of the events are local and family orientated. It is a popular wedding venue with 104 weddings taking pace over a five-year period. Weddings make up 56% of all events in the Gorge and the most popular precinct is the Fairy Dell. Other events in order of popularity or demand are BBQs and parties; filming; school activities; busking; fitness and outdoor events e.g. the Cataract Challenge and the 2015 Oceania Orienteering Championships and World Cup; music e.g. the Basin Concert. A report on the capability of the Gorge to host major outdoor public events has raised concerns over the suitability and safety of holding events with attendance over Facilities at the TNRA exist for a potential range of outdoor recreational events e.g. equestrian, archery, orienteering, mountain biking and aquatic based activities. Events need to be compatible to the area and supported by infrastructure like toilets and power. Events across the area also need to be scheduled around an annual calendar. Possible responses for consideration 6.1 Develop, maintain and publish an annual calendar of events 6.2 Use the First Basin and Cliff Grounds for smaller local and family oriented events only. 6.3 Gain access to water for major events like kayaking, white water rafting, swimming and fishing and ensure these events bring a return to the city.

12 Reimagining the Gorge draft green paper March Theme 7: Accommodation Key Issues: There have been calls to establish accommodation close to the area to support the specific visitor interest groups presently being targeted e.g. the mountain biking fraternity, soft adventure seekers, older couples seeking a longer stay and touring based experiences and younger couples on a shorter stay who skew towards cultural interests. Being able to accommodate camping and RVs in the TNRA has also been raised. Possible responses for consideration 7.1 Establish a high quality eco development not in the area but on private land with views. 7.2 Develop camping and RV sites in the TNRA Theme (8) Other Developments Key Issues: A number of development ideas have also been raised and include: A Gondola Chairlift into the Cataract Gorge The idea of a gondola chairlift has been publicised in conjunction with the JAC Group s redevelopment of the Penny Royal Complex. The concept is for enclosed gondolas to run from a car park and entry point established on the Zig Zag Reserve above the Penny Royal cliff face that travels over the hill into the First Basin, finishing near the inclinator. The developers are very much aware that the establishment of such a visitor feature will only be achieved with community and government support. A Sculpture Park Spaces within the Gorge and Cliff Grounds lend themselves to the display of artworks, which also add to the interpretation of the place. The idea of a specific sculpture park has been raised. Similarly art could be used in the creation of other spaces, particularly for thinking and reflection. Zip Line A zip line consists of a pulley suspended on a cable, usually made of stainless steel and mounted on an incline. It s designed to enable a user, propelled by gravity, to travel from the top to the bottom of the inclined cable by holding on to the pulley. A zip line delivers an experience of adventure and entertainment. Possible responses for consideration 8.1 A gondola chairlift experience running from the Zig Zag Reserve over the hill and into the First Basin. 8.2 A sculpture park in the Fairy Dell and Maple Steps area 8.3 Art and design in thinking and reflective spaces 8.4 Establishing and operating a Zip Line experience Getting opinion The processes for getting community opinion on the draft vision and the thirty-eight possible responses are set out below. Please Note: The draft vision formed the basis for broader input and assessment processes. To maintain the integrity of the input from the previous workshops, the language used and how responses were expressed, was largely unchanged. The aim was to get initial feedback on a range of suggestions that had been generated so far. Your Voice Your Launceston: Broader community Broad community input was sought on the vision and specifically the 38 possible responses. This was completed on line through the Launceston City Council s digital engagement platform: Your Voice Your Launceston. People were asked to give their view on each of the possible responses using the following rating scale. The wording of the responses was not changed from the draft vision. Rating Don t like Low Priority Medium Priority High Priority Explanation I have reservations about this response and would not support its implementation I am ambivalent about this response. It may be worth considering down the track when other work has been done. A worthwhile response which should be addressed in the medium term when resources permit This is a great response, which fits my vision for the combined area. Work should start as soon as possible

13 Reimagining the Gorge draft green paper March Age Counts % Of count Launceston age profile percentage 0 to to Over Over There were 489 visits to the site 304 downloads of documents 118 people completed the survey The & age group returned the most surveys % of count compared to % of population % count 0 % pop 118 people completed the survey A weighted score for each response was calculated by assigning the following values to each rating. Don t like (1) Low priority (2) Medium priority (3) High priority (3) If all 118 respondents voted high priority for each response the highest possible score would be 472. (118 x 4) Scores close to 472 are the highest priority and most popular. If all 118 voted don t like for every response the lowest possible score would be 118. (118 x 1) Scores closest to 118 are the least popular. The mid point between 472 & 118 is 295 The following table ranks the survey responses from the highest to the lowest weighted score The highest weighted score is 456 which is 96.6% of the highest possible score. The lowest weighted score is 210 or 44.5% of the highest possible score which indicates some support. Response Weighted score % Of highest possible score 2.6 Stop people dumping rubbish in the area Improve river water quality Continue to support the removal of feral animals Achieve increased water flow through the First Basin Support the Green Army to eradicate weeds in the area Raise awareness of Fire Management plans and what people can do to minimise risk Key stakeholders to continue to work together around projects

14 Reimagining the Gorge draft green paper March Response 4.1Fund a maintenance program for the First Basin and Cliff Grounds that strengthens its role as a significant visitor experience for the State 1.6 Reference group to meet annually, so a sound understanding of issues and needs is maintained Weighted score % Of highest possible score Gain access to water for major events like kayaking, white water rafting, swimming and fishing and ensure these events bring a return to the city. 3.3 Provide a hop on hop off bus for visitors Volunteers to work across both areas Develop, maintain and publish an annual calendar of events Monitor the effects of climate change Develop an amenities program for the TNRA (power, toilets etc.) that will support future activities and events. 6.2 Use the First Basin and Cliff Grounds only for smaller local and family oriented events Implement a way finding system for cars, cyclists and pedestrians Establish water stations throughout the area Involve the Aboriginal Community in the management of the Gorge & TNRA Provide shade to the pool area during summer Establish guided experiences for the area Provide technology based self guided interpretation and information Explore potential "across" linkages for bike riders Tell all the stories of the area using either built interpretation or technology Joint Aboriginal and English names for the entire area Build a stairway track for mountain bike riders to connect the City, Gorge and TNRA Art and design in any development of thinking and reflective spaces Make Kings Bridge the major pedestrian access point to the area Build a boardwalk from the Swinging (suspension) Bridge to the First Basin to make the loop around the First Basin fully accessible 5.4 Create a major night time, light interpretation experience that tells all the stories of the area

15 Reimagining the Gorge draft green paper March Response Weighted score % Of highest possible score 1.3 One name for the combined area Design and build "thinking and reflective" places throughout the area Develop camping and RV sites in the TNRA Create a single authority and Aboriginal Ownership Establish a high quality eco development not in the area but on private land with views A sculpture park in the Fairy Dell and Maple Steps area Establishing and operating a Zip Line experience a gondola chair lift experience from the Zig Zag reserve over the hill and into the First Basin Unedited comments from the online survey sorted by theme The survey contained a section for respondents to add comments and other thoughts. The unedited comments have been sorted into themes and are listed below. Unedited comments from the online survey sorted by theme Theme (1) Governance As a near daily user of the Gorge for six or seven months of the year - as a swimmer, sitter, walker and runner - I am appalled by the restricted consultation process so far. I would like the Council to provide much more information about most of the topics of the survey before I develop an opinion on them. I will be requesting meetings with all councillors, and council staff, and anyone else engaged in the process as it stands. I would have liked to see the greater population involved in the process before this point, but realise now we will have to involve ourselves. See you at The Gorge. Tim Walker I appreciate the effort made by the Launceston City Council to survey its constituents however; I found that a few of these questions are too obscure to answer accurately. Worryingly, this is particularly the case with the important questions invoking the Tasmanian Aboriginal community - 'create a single authority and Aboriginal Ownership' used with such vagueness is particularly inappropriate and irresponsible. I applaud Council wanting to look at the community s assets and undertake a visioning project in consultation with stakeholders including ex residents like myself who have a deep attachment to the area and also have deep expertise since having left Launceston because of the lack of opportunity there. But I am a little alarmed at what Councils agenda is and question making "development of the gorge" a priority when there is so much else that could be done Leave the names alone. Aboriginal names are unpronounceable, and lead to confusion and distrust and lack the familiar. The first basin and Gorge are currently run by LCC in an excellent manner that meets the needs of local families, pleases visitors and tourists, and maintains a beautiful environment. It is crucial for the future of Launceston that this unique backdrop to the city is not wasted for private profits. Theme (2) Environmental management I am an earnest and passionate Gorge supporter who has valued the opportunity to input. I love the Gorge and it's natural values. It is a living classroom. It is a state tourism icon. It is lauded by visitors for what it is and it's spiritual connection being so much the heart of Launceston. We need to respect and defend these natural values. Off leash area for dogs in TNRA The welfare and habitat of native animals must be taken into account. The Gorge should be a place for quiet passive recreation except when national /international kayaking etc. events occur. It should be a refuge from the hustle and bustle of a busy day. The recreation areas should be separate, accessible and nominated, keeping sanctuary areas for native habitat and observation thereof. Its beauty is in its simplicity - lets not lose sight of the value of that. Leave the basin as it is! I feel that the mature European and North American Trees and plants in the area add to the look and a

16 Reimagining the Gorge draft green paper March Unedited comments from the online survey sorted by theme experience of the gorge itself... I feel that more of these trees need to be planted in the area to add to the beauty of the Cataract gorge and First Basin... less native trees and more exotic trees would make the gorge far more exiting and spectacular... and I think that the current exotic trees and plants should be protected as part of the gorge and not treated as pests. Allow dogs (on leads) into the gorge - fine people for not cleaning up after their dogs and for also not carrying poo bags. It's so hard to find a sealed track away from traffic where I can walk the dog, push the pram, and where my three year old can ride her scooter. Native plant interpretation, restoring & protecting native vegetation, removing exotic species - with exceptions made for heritage or botanical value. Water quality is a major issue and must be a priority as the image of Tasmania as a clean, natural state is tarnished by the water quality All aspects of 'Theme 2' are things I expect the LCC to be doing anyway: why is rubbish removal and the removal of introduced species listed as options? Halt the planting of introduced plant species, and facilitate the gradual removal of established introduced animal and plant species. Can you encourage Tasmanian's guardianship of the longest river in Tasmania by leading a process that demands the state government and its agencies adhere to a 'whole of river catchment' approach to its health and ongoing amenity for Launceston in perpetuity. Here's to hoping that's not too much to ask? Some of these ideas sound fine, but don't lose sight of the quality that makes this place special - simple nature! KEEP IT NATURAL The Gorge and TNRA are wonderful for what they are - a simple, natural space in the middle of the city. Don't turn them into a "visitor experience" or a gaudy lights show, a theme park, or a hotel, or an events venue. Just let people come, walk, sit, bike and swim. The natural values should always be first priority - flora, fauna and water are really special and must not be compromised If any development is allowed it must be minimalist. The best values of the gorge area are natural ones that can only be added to by taking away the negative impacts that people have had on the area (e.g. weeds, feral animals, etc.). It is like an oasis from the city, please keep it that way. Do not make it an extension of the city... It is vital that GREEN ARMY is not perceived as the only stakeholder responsible for weed management in the entire area. The Launceston City Council and the Parks and Wildlife Service are the key stakeholders responsible for establishing weed management/natural resource management plans. Green Army are a short term solution to a problem that Improving water quality and water flow are the highest priorities, not tourism attractions. requires a long term management plan. I personally take a garbage bag and clean rubbish around Hog's rock. Most of the rubbish comes form the take away cafe, but they don't take any responsibility for cleaning it up. That's development for you! Improve the water quality, remove weeds, feral animals, and clean it from rubbish and you have your self an asset for the future! The Trevallyn Nature Reserve needs sustained weed management and rehabilitation of some areas. Remember that less is more. People love the gorge/basin (both locals and visitors) for what it is and particularly for the natural parts. Don't mess with that. Remove the weeds but with volunteers, not by supporting the green army (if they are working for money them give them a real job with all of the benefits that should come with that). Improve the water quality and remove the weeds and feral animals. Just do that and it will remain the magical place it has been for so long. Please don't ruin it. No more building within view of gorge or basin areas. Leave the skyline alone. The gorge and the Trevallyn reserve are at their most useful and beautiful in their natural state with no human intervention whatsoever, beyond unintrusive access tracks. The current gorge buildings and infrastructure above the pool and lawn area are indescribably ugly and should be removed and native plants should replace them. Grow more Tasmanian native plants and trees, leave the exotics but don't plant any more Apart from there not being enough water flowing through the system, and the outbreaks of ecoli and algae in the first basin, the Gorge is fine as it is. Maintaining the ecological integrity of the area should be of greatest importance; it might be good to encourage native wildlife, such as wallabies and possums, in the fairy dell/restaurant area as a drawcard for tourists. Allow visitors as much of a natural experience as can still be had in this area. Ensure parks and wildlife are maintaining clearance around the reserve to reduce risk to walkers, hikers, bikers and residents and allow the residents that border the reserve to volunteer to assist in clearing fire breaks around their properties. Feral cats (I'm not sure how much of a problem these still are as I have not had a BBQ at the Gorge recently) Theme (3) Access & linkages For me, the best development in the gorge would be to build a track above the river water line on the opposite side to the one currently heavily trafficked so that visitors could walk up and back in a complete circuit rather than for most walkers returning the same way. Consideration needs to be given to runners and exercise groups in the area, not only mountain bikers

17 Reimagining the Gorge draft green paper March Unedited comments from the online survey sorted by theme Promote and establish better mountain bike trails, facilities and infrastructure in TNRA. Brilliant for tourism, given the boost in mountain bike trails around Launceston e.g. Hollybank and Derby. Increase links to city -better walking trial to city. Many people get lost walking/to from Town to via West Launceston access. Is a great walk but often asked for directions by visitors. Make it accessible for all - it's extremely difficult to push a pram over loose blue metal which seems to be on most walkways around Launceston, can only imagine how hard it would be to those confined to wheelchairs. Don't cater to mountain bike riders at the exclusion of the rest of the community - access for ALL needs to be the priority Continue the tradition of free access for adventure activities - e.g. kayaking, mountain biking & rock climbing Better access to the dam for launching kayaks. There is a perfect spot for this by the 'beach' with a level grassed area but no access road to it and it's hundreds of metres from the car parks. Boat owners are given vehicular access to the water for launching/retrieving and so should people with kayaks. They are not light to carry (except those tiny white water ones) nor easy to trundle. A simple access road/track into the lawn by the dam's edge for launching is all that is needed. Many tourists walk from town up York Street, provide small street signs for pedestrians directing them and rename that part of West Launceston "Cataract Hill" as it was called when the first houses were built there. Get rid of Tiger bus and replace with a Launceston tourist bus/ Gorge loop service at peak times. This will reduce car volumes to The Gorge and bus can also stop at other tourist spots in the city. There is no explanation here, or in the project updates, about the 'stairway track' for mountain bike riders, 'across' linkages for bike riders, or the 'boardwalk' from the Swinging (suspension) Bridge to the First Basin. This makes it difficult to have an opinion on these. Could you please return the West Launceston car park to a fee-free one, and reinstate the bluestone curbing and retainer walls. Could you please remove the boom gate that currently allows premium parking for a select few, and is visually polluting. Could you please stop the development of the new West Launceston access to the Gorge. It seems cynically designed to force people to use the travelator or stairs, and then to pass besides the existing business. Could you please stop putting in more ramps, stairs, rails, paths and tarmac? It is turning the place into a visually ugly landscape. Could you have a look at the West Launceston car park road where the sweeping bend and pedestrian path meet, it's only a matter of time until someone, most likely a child, gets run over. Can you discourage the increased use of vehicles in the Gorge grounds proper (on both sides of the river). Many senior citizens would like to access parts of the gorge and café facilities but if in a wheelchair, using a walker or a stick, access is, at this stage, impeded. Apart from the proposed board walk, is there anything that can be started on as a priority? Perhaps access from Gorge road to the café, Fairy Dell and rotunda area. It's also a great place to watch the peacocks as well as soak up the atmosphere, together with the proposed sculpture park, etc. It is impractical and unnecessary to provide urban standard access ways throughout the Reserves and is not the case in similar places overseas anyway. A bus service to the Basin Car park must be reinstated to reduce pressure on car parking capacity and drop offs/pickups. No further vehicle access. Further bike riding experiences and walking trails are a good use of public space. The fewer fences the better. It is a beautiful spot for pedestrians to walk. Cyclists have plenty of other space, let them ride elsewhere and keep the gorge for pedestrians. There are words in the survey I don t' understand; 'way finding', 'stairway' (for bikes?). There has already been significant investment in mountain bike tracks in the Trevallyn reserve to the detriment of walkers, and with an increase in bike tracks in the greater Launceston area, i believe we are already well serviced in this regard. Get rid of the Tramalator :) Feed back: It is not clear what is intended by some of the dot points. E.g.: Theme 3 No. 6 - there is already a path around the first basin. Why boardwalk? or is this about disability access to the swing bridge? Do we want wheelchairs blocking swing bridge?. Improve the road and parking from the Trevallyn side. Create easier access for wheelchairs, wheeled walkers and the frail, gondolas may assist with this The impact on mountain bike riders and zip lines on an area that is used so heavily by locals and tourists on foot seems to fly in the face of current use and would make the usage prohibitive. Mountain bike riders have had tracks developed in so many other areas, particularly recent with the blue tiers etc., perhaps leaving the gorge to be a peaceful and quiet area, allowing individuals to reflect not in set places, not in prescribed areas, is the best course of action. As far as access from Kings Bridge is concerned, no matter how careful I was checking the traffic coming downhill from Trevallyn or across the bridge from the city, I froze mid crossing as a car came hurtling along from the city side and screeched to a halt to allow me to continue crossing. Very scary. Not much room close to the tollbooth for parking. Can see congestion arising if that area is defined as the main entrance to the gorge. It is often difficult to

18 Reimagining the Gorge draft green paper March Unedited comments from the online survey sorted by theme park along the street leading to Kings Bridge - and a long walk in to the gorge precinct would detract for some people. I am wondering if this idea is to enhance the idea of the gondola from a private enterprise up and over the hill... I don't understand the concept of a boardwalk from the swinging bridge (Alexander Suspension Bridge?) to the First Basin. There are many tracks/paths around the First Basin that would benefit from sealing over the gravel and these appear adequate for the visitor to gain access to all parts of that section of the reserve. Sealing pathways may well be a plan in progress already. Launceston has a very active multi-sport community and it would be great if people could ride through the gorge and cross over to TNRA. In addition residents should be able to walk their dogs across the gorge to TNRA so that they didn't have to drive around. Designate a route by which dog walkers and mountain bikers can cross first basin to link West Launceston to the TNRA. Traffic management/safety should provide speed bumps on Basin Rd to protect families unloading from cars during the day and prevent illegal hoon drivers at night. Create an access from the top basin car park to the restaurant and cafe and install CCTV to increase security for night time visits... Desperately need a walking track from the Gorge Rd/Fulford St entrance to the Cliff Grounds so we don't have to walk on the road. And the track should be a reasonable distance from existing road so we don't have to breathe in the car fumes. More walking only tracks, as the shared mountain bike tracks are dangerous. Theme (4) Maintenance and amenities Maintaining walking and bike paths is high priority. Many are deteriorating The most important aspects of this area for my children and me are the bush, nature, peacefulness, quietness, walking tracks and the feeling of being far from town (i.e.: surrounded by wilderness/nature) without actually being far from town. It is where we go when we feel like "getting away from it all" but don't have time for a long drive or a camping trip. For example, with access to the TNRA we can enjoy campfire-baked potatoes, bushwalks and a play in the bush even on a school day. We have always felt so lucky to have an area like this only a few minutes from home. I hope that these qualities are not compromised by any future projects or developments Refreshing Cinderella's coach and horses in the Fairy Dell. It has been an icon for generations. Don't forget to keep the toilets up to date and well maintained. Good parking, access to drinking water and clean, modern, safe-looking toilets and the area will promote itself. I think the pool should be landscaped with bush rocks and low level native shrubbery to better fit in with the vista beyond it Need things to increase "fun factor" of the Gorge and/or close to site e.g. Luge Track. Have guided rock climbing or "jump" experiences -safe and organised. Nicer toilets - not unisex! Please don't develop this area!!! It is a beautiful reserve and does not need to be filled with "accessible" walkways etc. Please don't erect an ugly shade canopy over the pool!! It is difficult for me to express just how strongly I feel about leaving the Gorge as natural as possible. There has already been too much development (the escalator, terrible!). I have purchased a block of land on Basin View drive, purely due to its close proximity to the Gorge. Please don't spoil this amazing asset through pressure to develop, there's no going back. Maintain, keep wasps, cats and weeds under control, by all means, but no more shelters, information boards, walkways, under-cover areas. Not needed, not wanted. Can you please provide options in this survey for the remediation and partial decolonisation of the area, including removal of the concrete causeway, the prohibition of selling rubbish-producing takeaway food, the decommissioning of the little used and visually pollutive inclinator. Please let people play ball! Just stop them if they are annoying. I feel very strongly about there being a shade area over the pool. Especially from November to February. I also think the water stations around the area and better toilet amenities are a must! The Cataract Gorge is the biggest bargain in the council's asset folio: it does not need to be value added beyond the common sense maintenance schedule of weed, litter, amenities, interpretation management. It is valued because it is allowed to BE and SPEAK for itself as incredible natural site. Please direct Launceston ratepayer funds toward other, more urgent areas of its portfolio of management. There is much that is missing in this survey, and much that is included without justification. How can this information possibly be useful? How can I say I support, in any way, a cross-bridge or tracks without any details at all? Why are four types of experiences listed, but not others? Why are there no options for me to say no to further development? I have grave concerns about the outcome of this entire project if such a simple thing as a survey cannot be done well. In short, there are no options in this survey for keeping the Gorge area (to me that is distinct from the Trevallyn NRA) as it is, and even winding back some of the intrusions. How about these options. - Planting out the lawn area surrounding the pool with native trees to provide habitat, shade and regenerate a dead space. - Replacing the cheap, tacky food kiosk with something that sells Tasmanian food (which need not be expensive) and that produces no waste. - Be done with the travelator. It was a waste, and continues to be so. I was once stuck in it for ten minutes. It i hardly ever used, is only available for us at certain times and is just a complete eyesore. Cut

19 Reimagining the Gorge draft green paper March Unedited comments from the online survey sorted by theme the losses, have it gone. - Speaking of eyesores, the continued development of the cafeteria area on the West Launceston side has been poorly planned. There needs to be work done in the area to conceal the building with natural vegetation, and to ensure that no further built-development impacts upon our natural space. There is a real need to improve the facilities in the area, but not at the expense of havng 'wild' places. The fairy dell area desperately needs a make over, whether it is improved play equipment for children or art installations, it really needs a lift. Don't make it a playground for the "sporty types" only. Keep it low scale and visually undisturbed. Any and all buildings and infrastructure should be designed so as to blend in with the bush, IF they are to be built at all. Nothing should be built or added unless ABSOLUTELY necessary. As a regular user of the gorge, and having worked for many years in tourism, the area really only needs work done to improve tracks and accessibility - as with the trail of the tin dragon and the Tasmanian tiger exhibition that are sprinkled through the gorge - these idea appear to be excellent at the time, but are rarely used by locals or tourists and simply waste council money. Shade sounds great in the Basin area, but only trees, etc. They'd be a real asset but please keep away from man made structures, which would only detract from what makes the spot special. Thinking and reflective places are already provided in the form of the bushland and gorge area itself. More strategic seating would be a boon for those of us who are mobility impaired - and further to that, my experience has been that more courtesy needs to be shown by those of greater physical ability in the form of joggers as they appear to take precedence on the pathways when out doing their regular runs. And still in the last week of February mode, I noticed that the stone shelter at First Basin appears to be having its concrete slab roof removed (I hope the shelter is not going to disappear altogether). This task was being approached by loud, mechanical machinery creating lots of dust that was drifting in a thick cloud over the pathway people use as they come and go along there. My immediate thought was, what's in that dust. How old is the concrete. Does it contain asbestos Remove the unsightly fence from around the swimming pool. This was an over reaction and inappropriate, particularity when the open Basin is so close. Allow responsible consumption alcohol and small scale ball games for children. It is ridiculous that a family picnic cant include a ball game is it doesn't disrupt the enjoyment of others Create family interactive spaces with playgrounds that support all levels of children in the reserve and the basin. Develop more areas in the reserve for entertainment and family time eg better maintained BBQ's, outdoor activity areas and play equipment. To fund the ongoing maintenance of this area an entrance fee should be charged to non-launceston ratepayers. To maintain the historical structures, and even in their ruined states, as this is part of the aesthetic quality - not everything has to be 'new'. The toilets under the cafe...always dirty, smelly and generally yucky. I avoid them as much as possible. Healthier and local food in the café There is lots to be done to improve amenity. For instance why not have a cafe that actually looks over the First Basin (the current one has a structure that prevents patrons from being able to see the "Gorge" from their cafe tables) and that stays open beyond 3.45 in the afternoons. Trees, trees, trees! The pool area has been cleared out of those beautiful old oak trees we used to picnic under. Look at how people cram themselves under the small trees around the edge of the grassed area in the summer. No one eats their picnics in the blazing sun. Theme (5) Interpretation, information & promotion Promote it as an all year round safe place to walk for exercise or pleasure. It needs preservation and interpretation/guided experiences, and use occasional sporting events like Cataract Challenge to attract income. Provide walking tour brochures for walkers too taking them past some of the fine old houses in the area and offering option of entering down the Zig Zag track, etc. Evening light shows sound fantastic Just visiting and walking around the area allows individual interpretation: can people not just experience this without second hand 'interpretation'? Tourists I speak to on a daily basis are impressed by the lack of geo-sculpting that has been done to the area. A brochure or booklet should be enough to impart any required information; even a self-guiding app would be great. By all means continue the volunteer tours, especially if the Palawa community choose to be involved, but for the love of nature stop building things!!! The Basin Rd Car park area and entrance needs improvement and gimmicks like the inclinator need to be better concealed with dense landscaping. An interpretation building at the Basin Rd Car park (not the old cottage) should be constructed for the principle visitor entrance and where information on the flora, fauna and geology of the area can be explained. Signage within the Reserves must be minimised and reduced where possible and language alternatives addressed by modern phone technology. Do not ever have a sound and light show. They are awful cheesy things wherever they are found. Have information and interpretation available on apps and other technology as it appears but steer away from reflective, thinking spots as they sound far too forced and would ruin it for those who like it as it is. The place is full of them - every square metre in that place is a reflective, thinking spot!

20 Reimagining the Gorge draft green paper March Unedited comments from the online survey sorted by theme If interpretation panels are to be used for self-guided experiences, also build into these a range of discovery experiences for children. The major night time light interpretation? Where and what does this entail. How often would it occur? And would it be offered free to the general public or would it be to the main benefit of a commercial enterprise? The Gorge contains geological formations rarely found all in the one place in the world including 3 fault lines, which merge in the Gorge itself. Peter Manchester is a geologist with expert knowledge and these features should be advertised much more widely. Until I went on a guided walk with him I did not know of their existence. It could add to the visitors experience of the gorge with maybe small info plaques at each of the sites or, with new technology, apps that people could put on their phones etc. Theme (6) Events The Reserves are NOT suitable for major music events as they belong in purpose built stadiums. Events are a good use of public space and facilities need to be upgraded to accommodate such. Water events are a very good use of this public facility. Do not allow selfish Greens to stop public use of the First Basin for concerts and large public events! Continue with an increased program of public events for all the different ages and interests of the people of Tasmania As for the kayaking, white water rafting, swimming and fishing? What does 'bring a return to the city' mean? More events like new years day concert should be encouraged. Provide ways to enjoy the areas when it is raining Make the Basin Concert free or reasonably priced (way to expensive in 2015 and excluded many people from enjoying a loved public space on a public holiday). More Gorge Concerts! Theme (7) Accommodation The Reserves are fragile places that must not be over developed. Trevallyn Reserve should be the focus for the majority of eco tourism experiences, not Cataract Reserve. Camping in the Trevallyn Reserve should be limited and very carefully managed to be extremely Eco friendly. No to accommodation in the Trevallyn reserve - the amount of people sleeping in cars / campers on the side of the road up there (and in the basin car park on the Trevallyn side) and leaving their rubbish and using the surrounding bush as a public toilet is bad enough. Hotel/accommodation definitely not within view of the Gorge or Basin. An RV/camping ground in the Trevallyn reserve is a terrible idea which I oppose absolutely. Camping and RV sites: As the mobile home traveller can easily access car parks and gain entrance to places such as the Cataract Gorge Reserve and TNRA I can't see the benefit in taking up valuable land for a camping site. With these travellers able to set themselves up almost anywhere easily, would they be interested in grouping together in such a place for overnighting, when they can set themselves up by the water's edge along the Tamar just about anywhere. Paid and managed camping areas should be provided near TNRA for short stays (1-2 days). No camping laws should be enforced in First Basin car park, it is unsafe to lock camper s vehicles in this area overnight and campers create a nuisance for residents and visitors. Theme (8) Other developments I am fiercely opposed to ANY entrepreneur as Dean Cocker is in imposing their vision for accessing the Gorge through a Gondolier or a Zip line. Gaining financial reward from such a massive intrusion visually is not acceptable from the point of view of the general users of the Gorge. It is every resident's Gorge not there for the benefit of a few. While some developments may be generous in their investment for increasing visitor numbers and thus economic dividend to the state tourism industry such as The Penny Royal Development there is a growing disrespect for and lack of understanding of the natural and visual values of The Gorge. There are possibilities for non-intrusive investments that I have mentioned which can greatly enhance not curtail tourism and visitor attractiveness. The Gorge is Launceston's beach. What about a water playground, possibly incorporated in the sculpture park and that can be turned off and essentially disguised in the colder months? Any 'art and design' needs to be totally in tune with the nature of the area e.g. I would not support art for art's sake or abstract monstrosities that take away from the beauty and nature value. Needs to be very carefully considered e.g. in reflective spaces, should not take away from the peaceful, reflective experience, but add to it. Any sculptures should be imaginative not the usual dull offering similar to our hideous cushions in the mall. Look to the world for inspiration please! We don't want another Cradle Mountain type attraction. Why has a developer's desire to build a gondola style chairlift across the zig zag track been included in this 'vision'? Should not this vision be about the overall stewardship of this area in perpetuity, rather than piecemeal development and though bubbles? Otherwise, in another 15 years another council will come along and chip away again. This is public land, 'commons', if you like: not the playground for businesses to squeeze a dollar. Furthermore, I say no to 'interpretation' centres, no to permanent 'interruptive' art, and no to 'thinking and reflective' spaces! Why not propose these for areas in Launceston that otherwise do not have the

21 Reimagining the Gorge draft green paper March Unedited comments from the online survey sorted by theme spectacular attraction of the Cataract Gorge; a sculpture tail on a disused Tamar River bank, an interpretation centre in an historically significant location such as the CH Smith site, or a thinking and reflective space in each suburb. The Gorge and surrounds has evolved over 250 million years, the whole area is a thinking and reflective space! No new developments either within the Reserves or on private land should be visually intrusive from within the reserve and those that are ought to be screened out with new landscaping. The access from the Kings Bridge area is necessarily limited and cable cars etc. do not have a place here. Free access is important because this is the local recreation area and must remain accessible and "owned" by the public. No ski slopes dinosaur parks or chairlifts please as this will destroy the ambience and further destroy the aboriginal cultural significance and place. No private development in the reserve area. Public space is for public use. No selling off of any of the public space. The Gondola idea is OK provided it does not detract from the current "walking in the forest" experience. The Gorge is a natural wonder. It is important to our well-being. We don't need to develop it commercially; we need to learn to appreciate it more. We don't need to geo sculpt, reinterpret, add paths, concrete, trails, gondolas. All those things destruct us from us connecting to the place on a physical, emotional, neurological and spiritual level. Tourists and locals alike come here to unwind and reconnect. We are very lucky to have the gorge here. Do not let the developers to get their hands on people s commons. Expect hard opposition to commercial development. I cannot understand the imperative to develop the gorge. There are other areas in the region, which could do with investment. There is no mention at all in this survey of these key concepts. Sustainability - ecology - environmental restoration. Recognise that by not wanting to develop the Gorge, people are making a statement of love. I love the Gorge for what it was, what it was, and that it may still continue to be here for generations as it is. I am not anti-development or progress, far from it. The Gorge is the number one tourism attraction in Launceston as it is, there is no demand for change. It is such a sacred place to so many residents, year round. I enjoy the Gorge every single day. I walk through it, I climb in it, I ride in it. I live right by it. I swim in the Basin religiously from October to April. I've never met a single person say to me that they wish there was more development in the Gorge. Chairlifts, Gondolas, Cafes, Interpretation centres.. This is unwarranted. I'd implore each and every person involved in this project to contemplate the enormity of your decisions on the future of the Gorge and the wider community. Don't say yes to development just for the sake of it. Leave the Fairy Dell exactly as it is - that is why it is so beautiful. There are plenty of other spaces for great sculpture. No heavy infrastructure developments on public land. All developments should build upon the NATURAL beauty of the gorge, NOT detract from it. Focus on conservation, restoration and beautification. NO GONDOLA!!! I believe very strongly that a gondola should not be allowed to be built in the gorge - people come to see a natural phenomenon, not see infrastructure built on top of it - it would only detract from the area and offer little. If the argument is that it would increase accessibility, people can still access the gorge / basin from car parks at either end, and I thought that is why the council spent a considerable amount installing the travelator. A gondola would be inappropriate and support should not be provided to the proponent if they cannot facilitate it on their own. A sculpture park in the Fairy Dell? No way Any Gondola should not be visible to walkers on the Northern pathway from Kings Bridge to First Basin - yet another blot on the natural reserve/diminishment of amenity DO NOT even consider building a Gondola. It is totally unnecessary and would ruin the serenity and natural attraction of the Gorge. The very reason people visit and love the Gorge is because of its sense of place and natural beauty. DO NOT build silly things like sculpture parks or incorporate art into the Gorge. The Gorge is already suffering from over development and Art Pollution. So-called art works are degrading the gorge. Love the gondola chairlift idea. Great to see Josef Chromy involved. Create a chair lift as soon as possible, this is an excellent idea. A chair lift from Duck Reach to the basin and onto Kings Bridge area. The gondola is a terrible idea. The gondola should not go ahead. Do not build the gondola. No to the Chromy gondola, NO. Hands off The Gorge!! Leave it as the natural beauty that it is. We do not want it commercialised and ruined!! The Gorge attracts many tourists to Launceston which is a great thing. The Launceston community would benefit, directly and through increased visitor numbers, from additional 'experiences'. I would like to see the council looking to develop novel experiences (that may well have strong linkage to current

22 Reimagining the Gorge draft green paper March Unedited comments from the online survey sorted by theme facilities) that will attract visitors not already aware/interested in what Launceston has to offer. Experiences such as zip lining, bob luge, rafting / kayaking, and mountain biking, that will be appreciated by local youth, and will encourage families to visit and to stay for longer. I would rather see these activities developed and operated by council and the local community Future development should not focus on physical infrastructure such as gondolas or accommodation, but on access and experience developments such as guided and self-guided tours, increasing the water supply to allow for recreational activities such as kayaking, swimming, etc., and a free or low-cost frequent shuttle bus from the city to the entrance on basin road. Only allow commercial interests on an economic basis no freebies No rent free prime location e.g. gondola must pay and share profits what s the point of giving it away The main reason for my self-immigrating from the uk to Tas - is the Basin - not overly developed and not disneyfied - left in it natural state - A gondola is a poor way to experience this in any region of the world. Keep the gorge as it is keep it natural it's not Disney world a gondola system would be a total eyesore lets keep it in its natural beauty - stop chopping down trees as you have on the zigzag track stop putting up irrelevant signs we are not the Gold Coast people come to Tassie for nature the city has been spoilt by high rise development near the river ie seaport there are plenty of areas where public money (rates) which should be supported priority please Please don't Disneyfy the beautiful Cataract Gorge precinct. With upgrades and their costs, don't put a general charge on entry to recoup this, it would be a backward step. An Asian visitor enquired of my husband where to pay to come in to the First Basin. He and his companion were surprised and delighted when they realised it was free. Having visited regularly and overhearing snatched conversations of tourists to this site, and knowing many of them are from interstate or overseas, why offer them something of the type they can access where they come from in the form of chairlifts, gondolas etc. The Zip Line experience? Is it a flying fox style experience? There's obviously nothing to be done about the existing chairlift across the First Basin, and it appears to be well patronised, but to add more of this kind of structure in the form of a gondola needs deep consideration. As the device is to come up over the hill and land somewhere near the existing Inclinator, this will create a people-congestion in the entrance area to the First Basin. The Fairy Dell. My children and now my grandchildren love the Fairy Dell. What kinds of sculpture? How much space will these take up? Further to the above, I think it would be a boon to have a second Inclinator set up at the carpark on the Fairy Dell side of the reserve. This would give people like me another option for access, as during this last week of February, when entering the grounds and coming along to the existing Inclinator, I found it was shut down for maintenance. With bravado I descended the steps for a walk over to the Gorge Restaurant and lunch, but with the sun heating up and the distance back telling for me, I had a choice to make. Approaching the guard on duty, I asked if my husband could bring the car down to pick me up. With no being the answer, the only option left was a struggle up the steep roadway - or to return to the steps and climb them. The steps won due to the rail I could use as an aid. If there was a second Inclinator, I could have chosen to drive around to it and make the ascent into the reserve from there (so long as the maintenance schedule for separate Inclinators was at a different time!). The Gorge itself is a "thinking and reflective" space. Walk less than 2 minutes along the pathway from Kings Bridge and you leave the city and its noise behind. It is important that the Gorge remain a place of natural beauty and tranquility. Zip lines and more cable cars/gondolas will change the very essence of this natural wonder. Minimise increase in visually impacting infrastructure. Rule out public funding of development for private benefit. The gorge is a naturally very beautiful place. Development of the gorge will take away from what makes is beautiful. Any private development on public land should be subject to an independent business case including cost benefit analysis, public consultation, and finally other parties should have a right to bid for the proposal through an open tender to ensure the process is equitable and that the residents of Launceston get the best deal. The natural grandeur and environment of the Gorge must be kept at all costs. I have visitors who come regularly from the UK purely for the Gorge as it is. The Gorge, not including the TNRA, will struggle to cope with more visitors. Enhance opportunities for sport and recreation within the gorge/tnra, such as archery, mountain bike rides, kayaking, sailing, horse riding and water skiing. A gondola chair lift will change the natural state of the gorge and the LCC should not provide 1 cent of ratepayer's money to the private operator's proposal. If the smell along Margaret St, Paterson Street and the Royal Park is not corrected soon by way of a new sewage system there will be no tourists who will want to visit the Gorge. I think all Alderman should spend some time around this area to know the extent of the problem. Not to build any more structures such as the controversial house that was built about ten years ago that would obstruct the natural aspect of the place. I am against major development within the area and particularly dislike the idea of the Gondola. I don't care how many supposed jobs it is supposed to bring - I love the natural aspect of the Gorge and think it

23 Reimagining the Gorge draft green paper March Unedited comments from the online survey sorted by theme would be a shame to lose that and honestly we all need the exercise. The inclinator gives those with a disability the access they need into the Gorge. The gondola idea impacts on dwellings - not fair. Fairy Dell is a traditional play space and could be updated in a natural way, e.g. stepping stones, rocks to sit on and facilitate imaginative play in keeping with the plantings that are already there. Disagree with gondola it just seems like a money-making venture but isn't thoughtful, respectful or inspiring for the unique area. I think the less intrusion into the space the better in terms of the natural environment. The attraction of the Gorge is it being a piece of the natural world in the middle of an urban environment. Anything that compromises that will destroy its strength. Our Gorge manages to keep that feeling of wildness WHICH PEOPLE FROM ALL OVER THE WORLD ARE LOOKING FOR!!! It is magical, such a treasure. How fortunate we are! Please no chairlifts down the South Esk. People love the sound of the water, the echo of children s voices, not the sound of machinery and cash registers Installing works of art is unnecessary when you have nature to lift your spirits. If a chair lift brings in tens of thousands more people, the place will change radically and become like a circus. We can improve on the built environment, the pool and the playground by making them safer and shadier but please let the beauty of the place speak for itself. This is what people are seeking. Private tourism development ventures financed or partially financed by ratepayers should not be considered over the interests of Launceston's own residents and long-time users of the Cataract Gorge in its current comparatively unblemished state. Survey of neighbouring properties It was decided to seek the views of neighbours following a number of requests from residents and an article in The Examiner Newspaper for neighbours (neighbouring properties to the area) to offer their specific thoughts on the possible responses. One hundred and seventeen properties adjoining the study area were sent a paper version of draft vision document and the same survey of responses as YVYL. The same rating scale for each of the responses was used. Forty-five surveys (38.5%) were returned. Maximum sample size 45 participants Maximum potential high priority score is 45x4= 180 Maximum potential don t like score is 45x1= 45 Midpoint is = 225 / 2 = Scores close to 180 are the highest priority and most accepted. Scores close to 45 are the least popular The highest scoring response is 174, which is 96.7 % of the potential maximum high priority score. The lowest scoring response is 78, which is 43.3% of the potential maximum high priority score. No response is completely unpopular Response Weighted score % Total weighted score 2.6 Stop people dumping rubbish in the area Improve river water quality Continue to support the removal of feral animals Support the Green Army to eradicate weeds in the area Raise awareness of Fire Management plans and what people can do to minimise risk Achieve increased water flow through the First Basin Fund a maintenance program for the First Basin and Cliff Grounds that strengthens its role as a significant visitor experience for the State

24 Reimagining the Gorge draft green paper March Response Weighted score % Total weighted score 1.7 Key stakeholders to continue to work together around projects Reference group to meet annually, so a sound understanding of issues and needs is maintained Monitor the effects of climate change Develop an amenities program for the TNRA (power, toilets etc.) that will support future activities and events Implement a way finding system for cars, cyclists and pedestrians Gain access to water for major events like kayaking, white water rafting, swimming and fishing and ensure these events bring a return to the city Provide a hop on hop off bus for visitors Volunteers to work across both areas Tell all the stories of the area using either built interpretation or technology Establish water stations throughout the area Develop, maintain and publish an annual calendar of events Build a stairway track for mountain bike riders to connect the City, Gorge and TNRA Involve the Aboriginal Community in the management of the Gorge & TNRA Build a boardwalk from the Swinging (suspension) Bridge to the First Basin to make the loop around the First Basin fully accessible Provide shade to the pool area during summer Explore potential "across" linkages for bike riders Establish guided experiences for the area Make Kings Bridge the major pedestrian access point to the area Provide technology based self guided interpretation and information Use the First Basin and Cliff Grounds only for smaller local and family oriented events Create a major night time, light interpretation experience that tells all the stories of the area Joint Aboriginal and English names for the entire area Design and build "thinking and reflective" places throughout the area Art and design in any development of thinking and reflective spaces One name for the combined area Establish a high quality eco development not in the area but on private land with views

25 Reimagining the Gorge draft green paper March Response Weighted score % Total weighted score 8.3 A sculpture park in the Fairy Dell and Maple Steps area Develop camping and RV sites in the TNRA Establishing and operating a Zip Line experience A gondola chair lift experience from the Zig Zag reserve over the hill and into the First Basin Create a single authority and Aboriginal Ownership Comparison of the online and neighbour surveys The following table compares the ranking of responses from both surveys. There is a strong similarity of views between the two surveys. Rank YVYL online survey Neighbours survey Rank Stop people dumping rubbish in the area 2.6 Stop people dumping rubbish in the area Improve river water quality 2.1 Improve river water quality Continue to support the removal of feral animals 2.5 Continue to support the removal of feral animals Achieve increased water flow through the First Basin. 2.4 Support the Green Army to eradicate weeds in the area 2.3 Raise awareness of Fire Management plans and what people can do to minimise risk 1.7 Key stakeholders to continue to work together around projects 4.1Fund a maintenance program for the First Basin and Cliff Grounds that strengthens its role as a significant visitor experience for the State 1.6 Reference group to meet annually, so a sound understanding of issues and needs is maintained 6.3 Gain access to water for major events like kayaking, white water rafting, swimming and fishing and ensure these events bring a return to the city. 3.3 Provide a hop on hop off bus for visitors 1.5 Volunteers to work across both areas 2.4 Support the Green Army to eradicate weeds in the area 2.3 Raise awareness of Fire Management plans and what people can do to minimise risk 2.2 Achieve increased water flow through the First Basin. 4.1Fund a maintenance program for the First Basin and Cliff Grounds that strengthens its role as a significant visitor experience for the State 1.7 Key stakeholders to continue to work together around projects 1.6 Reference group to meet annually, so a sound understanding of issues and needs is maintained 2.7 Monitor the effects of climate change 4.4 Develop an amenities program for the TNRA (power, toilets etc.) that will support future activities and events. 3.1 Implement a way finding system for cars, cyclists and pedestrians

26 Reimagining the Gorge draft green paper March Rank YVYL online survey Neighbours survey Rank Develop, maintain and publish an annual calendar of events 2.7 Monitor the effects of climate change 4.4 Develop an amenities program for the TNRA (power, toilets etc.) that will support future activities and events. 6.2 Use the First Basin and Cliff Grounds only for smaller local and family oriented events. 3.1 Implement a way finding system for cars, cyclists and pedestrians 4.2 Establish water stations throughout the area 1.1 Involve the Aboriginal Community in the management of the Gorge & TNRA 4.3 Provide shade to the pool area during summer Establish guided experiences for the area Provide technology based self guided interpretation and information Explore potential "across" linkages for bike riders Tell all the stories of the area using either built interpretation or technology. 1.4 Joint Aboriginal and English names for the entire area 3.4 Build a stairway track for mountain bike riders to connect the City, Gorge and TNRA 8.4 Incorporate art and design into any development of thinking and reflective spaces 3.2 Make Kings Bridge the major pedestrian access point to the area. 3.6 Build a boardwalk from the Swinging (suspension) Bridge to the First Basin to make the loop around the First Basin fully accessible 5.4 Create a major night time, light interpretation experience that tells all the stories of the area One name for the combined area Design and build "thinking and reflective" places throughout the area 6.3 Gain access to water for major events like kayaking, white water rafting, swimming and fishing and ensure these events bring a return to the city. 3.3 Provide a hop on hop off bus for visitors 1.5 Volunteers to work across both areas 5.1Tell all the stories of the area using either built interpretation or technology. 4.2 Establish water stations throughout the area 6.1 Develop, maintain and publish an annual calendar of events 3.4 Build a stairway track for mountain bike riders to connect the City, Gorge and TNRA 1.1 Involve the Aboriginal Community in the management of the Gorge & TNRA 3.6 Build a boardwalk from the Swinging (suspension) Bridge to the First Basin to make the loop around the First Basin fully accessible 4.3 Provide shade to the pool area during summer 3.5 Explore potential "across" linkages for bike riders 5.3 Establish guided experiences for the area 3.2 Make Kings Bridge the major pedestrian access point to the area. 5.2 Provide technology based self guided interpretation and information 6.2 Use the First Basin and Cliff Grounds only for smaller local and family oriented events. 5.4 Create a major night time, light interpretation experience that tells all the stories of the area 1.4 Joint Aboriginal and English names for the entire area 4.5 Design and build "thinking and reflective" places throughout the area 8.4 Incorporate art and design into any development of thinking and reflective spaces 1.3 One name for the combined area

27 Reimagining the Gorge draft green paper March Rank YVYL online survey Neighbours survey Rank Develop camping and RV sites in the TNRA Create a single authority and Aboriginal Ownership Establish a high quality eco development not in the area but on private land with views. 8.3 Build a sculpture park in the Fairy Dell and Maple Steps area 8.1 Advertise for expressions of interest in establishing and operating a Zip Line experience 8.2 Facilitate a gondola chair lift experience from the Zig Zag reserve over the hill and into the First Basin 7.1 Establish a high quality eco development not in the area but on private land with views. 8.3 Build a sculpture park in the Fairy Dell and Maple Steps area 7.2 Develop camping and RV sites in the TNRA 8.1 Advertise for expressions of interest in establishing and operating a Zip Line experience 8.2 Facilitate a gondola chair lift experience from the Zig Zag reserve over the hill and into the First Basin 1.2 Create a single authority and Aboriginal Ownership Unedited neighbour comments sorted by theme The survey also provided opportunity for additional thoughts and comments. The unedited comments are set out below. Unedited comments from Neighbours survey sorted by theme Theme (1) Governance Any involvement with aboriginal groups MUST NOT lock out other groups. There are lots of traditional users who have a European Asian heritage. This heritage must also be recognised. The fact is no full blood aborigines have existed and descendants cannot agree who should be classified as a descendant. Administration and maintenance of area should be solely LCC responsibility. The VISION is clunky, ambiguous and possibly exclusive Careful of a football in Aboriginal politics. Theme (2) Environmental management All the council really needs to do is eradicate the feral cats. Dog control Provide residents adjacent to Gorge more details of the Fire Management Plan. If Gorge had fire it would be a catastrophe for Launceston and its tourists. Appropriate management of peacocks to prevent incursion to bushland and residential areas Manage enforce encroachment of gardens, backyards, chook pens etc. into reserve Don't ruin the natural ones already existing Use the area respectfully Be aware of the white goshawks in the area Offer incentives to others on the fringe to do community service as volunteers on weed eradication. Manage by rosters; say 4 days/year, minor rate remission or vouchers to council supported events. This rare and precious natural place in a city area. This is the uniqueness that attracts. Visitors don't want to see imported Indian peacocks, tell the story of the ecology, geology, flora and fauna. Clean water, no weeds. Get rid of feral cats that hang around the barbeques Preserve scenic views. No new objects should be allowed to intrude on natural settings. Wildlife survey of area to ensure manmade improvements do not impact on habitats. Theme (3) Access and Linkages Improve parking at Trevallyn entrance Buggy car to take people from Trevallyn car park to the kiosk People have enormous problems climbing the stairs Connect Duck Reach with Blackstone Heights Visitors should not stray off the Zig Zag track Linkage across the Gorge for dog walkers to pass through on lead Keep the lycra crowd out of the Gorge. Shared tracks do not work, no bikes. Improve the footpath along Basin Road it is not safe. Make Basin Road and Basin View Drive 2 Hour only so that people park in car park and don't clutter the road for residents. Bicycle access through the Basin would be fantastic so westies can get to Trevallyn and Trevallyn

28 Reimagining the Gorge draft green paper March Unedited comments from Neighbours survey sorted by theme can get to the City safely. Keep mountain bikes out of the Gorge and cliff grounds and Basin area. Kings Bridge entrance - Gorge is echo chamber. Traffic noise amplifies in the area. Utilising this entrance more fully would be difficult, as it will increase the level of noise pollution. Penny Royal parking area was originally negotiated between Mr Smith and LCC so that part of the car parking would be available for Gorge visitors. This point seems to have been lost. Car parking on the Trevallyn side of the Riverside Bridge near the Rowing Club and boat yard could be extended with a walkway under Kings Bridge to come out near the Caretakers Cottage. Theme (4) Maintenance and amenities Place more emphasis on the area between First Basin and Duck Reach Include picnic facilities tables, water, near Duck Reach Improve playground in Basin area. Incorporate art and sculpture. More shaded shelter areas particularly in the first basin area Ban abseiling on the south side between Kings Bridge and First Basin, use alternate areas Continue to support responsible rock climbing Improve existing infrastructure but don't add more. Toilet and amenities extremely important to keep cleaned and maintained. More up-keep on this. The Kiosk needs to be larger to cope with the influx of tourists and locals (next to Bush Café). Maintain what is there already, its perfect as it is, no wanky art installations Employ security staff to kick the foul mouthed people and Frisbees out of the pool Develop Duck Reach. Let kids have ball games on the lawn at the Basin. Theme (5) Interpretation Information and Promotion Have signs in Chinese characters for visitors Signage is convoluted at best Small aboriginal cultural centre Keep info factual and educational. Don't put childish signs/info a la Forestry Tas. This is an educated visitor market. Theme (6) Events Opposed to any event/function that restricts general free access to First Basin Bring back Basin Concern event, possibly with limited numbers Theme (7) Accommodation Fully self-contained RC camping in TNRA. Only short term. No pets. Allow RC's to use Basin car park with time limits. Maybe small fee for facility use. Theme (8) Other developments Leaving the Gorge as is ensures this area is not spoilt by people or groups with an inbuilt agenda that is not reflective of the residents who have loved the area what it offers now and has for the last 100 years. Unsure who has a vested interest in some of the ideas proposed but am wary that creating something in the area that is out of step with what the majority of residents want is going to occur because of the carefully worded SPIN that has been produced. NO invasive heavy infrastructure developments that will ruin natural settings NO Gondola Ensure the natural environment is preserved, resist development While facilitating and encouraging access, resist any tendency to turn Gorge Road into 'theme park' Totally opposed to the concept of Gondola chair lift or anything similar - it will further erode the natural beauty Utilise current infrastructure like underground pipes for unique experience Commercial activity should not affect residents freedom of access and use High-level suspension bridge linking West Launceston and Trevallyn. Would be a great shortcut for locals (bikes, pedestrians) and good attraction for tourists. Same for Blackstone Heights and TNRA. This is not a circus or a Wally world, visitors marvel at the realness, the unique Tasmanian experience. Leave it alone; keep it natural, no Wally world circuses! Noise - the area should be tranquil. No noisy intrusions should be allowed - boats, loud speakers, gondolas Gondola chairlift + Zip Line - we cannot make any judgement without more details about location, noise level, intrusion. Additional comments from the owners of adjoining properties A briefing session on this Green Paper was offered to the owners of neighbouring properties at 6pm on the 26 th of March Written invitations to attend were sent to the 117 properties and 35 people attended. The following opinions were expressed at the workshop and they add to the comments from the survey.

29 Reimagining the Gorge draft green paper March There was confusion about the whole system category Neighbours meaning neighbouring councils. Attendees felt strongly that owners of property backing onto the study area should be included in the neighbours category. There was a strong view that they should have been and therefore included in all the activities. What principles have been applied to the development of the vision and do they link, support or integrate to the principles of the documents of the givens Degradation is being caused by abseiling and there is a need to manage this. The affect of abseiling is detrimental to the natural beauty of the area. Put a traffic light on Kings Bridge to solve the safety problems associated with the mix of cars, bikes and pedestrians We don t need to make the area more accessible it already is. This is testified by the numbers who go there and one of the key reasons people go there is to walk all over it. They find ways in and out. No signs, move to technologies like phone apps. Any signage - should be multi-lingual If we foster the native animals in the place we will encourage people to stay overnight. Is the Penny Royal redevelopment encroaching into the Gorge? Are they going to get public land? Is it possible to build a road/landing spot on the Reserve? Where is it envisaged that the Gondola will start and where will it finish Has the Federal government committed funds for road works? Can land be rezoned? Why is the gondola idea in the official council survey? Continuous noise is intolerable. The Gorge is a sound box and amplifies all sound. One off events are ok but a continuous noise is a problem. The Tavern is now playing loud noise at night. Yes focus on the long-term vision but do not be blinded to the short-term issues of maintenance. The gum tree near the artist s cottage is on a lean and looks precarious. It has not been attended to. Preserving the beauty of the area needs constant maintenance. We must understand and be mindful of the impact non-native animals and activities have on the Gorge. We should not be considering dog walking in the Gorge, bikes being ridden in the Gorge, events and noise. People living near the Gorge see the effect on the fauna and flora from these kinds of activities. Shows a lack of understanding and different mentality if these things are being put forward to be part of the future.

30 Reimagining the Gorge draft green paper March The findings and potential design responses Theme 1 Governance There are a number of government agencies involved in the management of various parts of the study area. The various stakeholders need to cooperate and work more closely on projects and planning. Also volunteers should be able to work across the total area. There isthe potential to involve the Aboriginal Community in the management of the area. Changing the names or having joint Aboriginal or English names did not receive a lot of support. Similarly creating a single authority and Aboriginal ownership ranked low in both surveys. Theme 2 Environmental Management Environmental management was seen as a high priority in both surveys. Comments highlight affection and respect for the natural values of the area. Managing rubbish and improving water quality are the two most highly rated responses in both surveys. Improving water quality, also a high priority is an excellent example of where willing cooperation between stakeholders will be needed to resolve the issue. Many activities in the area centre on water so quality is a fundamental issue. Removing feral animals, eradicating weeds, raising awareness of fire management were all rated highly as was increasing water flow through the First Basin. Once again the water flow issue will require inter government cooperation. Allowing access for dogs on leads was mentioned in the comments.